Concertation event on
    Accessibility

            Maria Gemou
             CERTH/HIT



 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Focus-Objectives of this concertation
• To verify the presented identified synergies.
• To discuss issues raised (identified or not) in the
  context of these synergies (i.e. restrictions, problems,
  resources, …).
• To define specific actions that will fulfill a minimum
  level of synergies between all projects represented.
• To identify synergies that could but cannot be fulfilled
  and justify (technical, economic, other reasons, …).
• To come up, finally, with a specific roadmap to follow
  and present to the EC…



             AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                            From, To and With AEGIS

With which      In which aspect?              Issues to be discussed       Roadmap
 project?


ACCESSIBLE   •Personas: ACCESSIBLE           •How personas and end         TBD (most
             and AEGIS Personas have         user categories                already
             been exchanged                  (beneficiaries) can be used     done)
             •Ontologies: AEGIS              in the accessibility
             ontology encompasses            evaluation and assessment
             parts of ACCESSIBLE             of applications?
             ontologies                      • How a large scale
             •Development:                   assessment infrastructure
             Developer tools:                could be defined?
             ACCESSIBLE assessment           • How an internationally
             simulation and assessment       harmonized methodology
             tools complement the            for evaluating the
             AEGIS OAF with a further        conformance of applications
             step (evaluation).              to Standards should be
             Specifically for the            adopted?
             demonstration purposes, a
             Netbeans plug-ins of DIAS
             and WAAT were
             implemented and
             integrated in the context of
             AEGIS SP3 IDE.


                 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                              From, To and With AEGIS

With which     In which aspect?                Issues to be discussed          Roadmap
 project?


 Haptimap    •Development                      •Does it really make sense to   TBD (some
               • Setting up a fast Open        combine functionalities?
                 Street Map (OSM)
                                                                                already
                                               •How many resources would         done)
                 server: to be used by
                 both projects and in order
                                               that require (on behalf of
                 to solve some issues with     both projects)?
                 the license agreement of
                 the OSM and also provide
                 a faster alternative for
                 supporting the
                 applications of both
                 projects (done).
               • Source code: Exchange
                 of the source code of the
                 two applications (done).
             •Pilots: Exchange
             applications for pilots (done).
             •Integration: Perhaps
             functionalities could be
             combined…




                  AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                            From, To and With AEGIS

With which   In which aspect?              Issues to be discussed          Roadmap
 project?


 ETNA &      Portals                   •Different focus: OAEG covers         TBD
 ATIS4All    Specifically,             only open source and wishes to
             integration of AEGIS      stay as such.
             OAEG (online portal       •Also, AEGIS provides more than
             and blog aggregator       repository of solutions and
             focusing on open          services (i.e. blog aggregator,
             source,                   standards, OAF implementation
             www.oaeg.eu) and          linked to ontologies, mobility
             “EASTIN 2.0”              schemes, ….)
             portal (online portal          • Could all resources of
             providing a seamless              EASTIN 2.0 and OAEG be
             access to ETNA and                combined in 2 levels?
             ATIS4All repositories               • Open Source
             on ICT-based AT                     • Proprietory
             products, accessibility   •Level of detail: EASTIN 2.0
             solutions and related     gives more advanced search and
             services.                 level of info in comparison to
                                       OAEG. Also most probably
                                       different classification is being
                                       followed. OAEG already
                                       encompasses Oatsoft…


                 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                           From, To and With AEGIS

With which   In which aspect?              Issues to be discussed           Roadmap
 project?


  VICON      •Personas,                •What type of user models in           TBD
             Ontologies and            each case? How to combine?
             User Models (but               • VICON uses Datatype
             note that VICON                   Properties, AEGIS uses
             focuses on h/w and                Object Properties
             AEGIS on s/w)                  • VICON reasoning contains
             •Development:                     information about user
             Developer tools:                  model classification etc.,
             Integration of VICON              AEGIS has no reasoning
             simulation                •Different focus...(AEGIS on ICT
             models/tools into         products and VICON on consumer
             developer tools of        products and interfaces for e-
             AEGIS in 2 respects:      services)
               • In
                 recommendations
                 phase, before
                 design
                 (Accessibility
                 Advisor Tool in
                 AEGIS).
               • In assessment
                 phase, after
                 development.
                 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                           From, To and With AEGIS

With which   In which aspect?              Issues to be discussed           Roadmap
 project?


 VERITAS     •Personas,                •How can Personas be described         TBD
             Ontologies and            in a common way?
             Interaction Models             • Large Persona population
             (but note the                    of AEGIS
             different focus;               • VERITAS can provide
             common field the ICT             quantifiable personas with
             based apps and                   specific characteristics
             services)                 •Discussion on the properties of
             •Developer tools:         the developer tools in AEGIS:
             Integration of                 • Check whether simulated
             VERITAS simulation               accessibility evaluation is
             models/tools into                possible
             developer tools of             • Under which assumptions
             AEGIS in assessment
             phase, after
             development (only in
             common fields).




                 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                           From, To and With AEGIS

With which   In which aspect?              Issues to be discussed              Roadmap
 project?


 Cloud4All   •UCD: AEGIS public        •Different focus in user clustering.      TBD
             UCD approach as a         Cloud4All will apply the “one-
             paradigm for              size-fits-one”, approach. AEGIS
             Cloud4All                 follows typical disability clustering
             •Interaction models       (though not really ICF).
             and Ontologies:                • Thus, Personas and user
             Cloud4All virtual                  models use should be very
             models will be fed                 careful.
             from AEGIS user           •AEGIS is slightly demonstrating
             models and Personas       Cloud extension, whenever
             among other sources.      possible. Could be a good start.
             •Development: To          •Other?
             select AEGIS apps to
             apply auto-
             configuration in
             AEGIS (from desktop,
             mobile, web)
             •Portals: OAEG into
             Cloud4All GPII
             Marketplace?



                 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                          From, To and With AEGIS

With which   In which aspect?             Issues to be discussed            Roadmap
 project?


  Cardiac    •Roadmaps: AEGIS         •Perhaps AEGIS roadmap to be            TBD
             and CARDIAC should       formatted as part of one of the
             exchange roadmaps.       CARDIAC roadmaps (needs also
                                      to be standalone however)?
                                          • At first sight, it seems that
                                              AEGIS could be
                                              contributing to all more or
                                              less CARDIAC Structured
                                              Dialogic Design Process
                                              maps.




                AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                            From, To and With AEGIS

With which   In which aspect?              Issues to be discussed        Roadmap
 project?


 AsTeRICS    •Pilots:                  •AsTeRICS focuses on                TBD
             AsTeRICS could serve      unconventional peripherals (out
             as a demonstrator         of scope of AEGIS)…
             how people with           •What type of AEGIS apps could
             severe motor              serve as a case study for
             disabilities can          AsTeRICS and in which sense?
             interact with AEGIS-
             based GUIs.
             •Standards: To
             combine and
             synchronize (verified)
             know-how for
             contribution to
             standards (especially
             on interoperability).




                 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                           From, To and With AEGIS

With which   In which aspect?              Issues to be discussed             Roadmap
 project?


 eAccess+    •Portals: The             •eAccess encompasses a lot that          TBD
             semantically enriched     are out of scope of AEGIS (i.e.
             guide and link to         digital TV, self-service terminals);
             eAccess-ibility           however, web a11y is common…
             resources could be        •Other?
             integrated with OAEG
             (?)




                 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                           From, To and With AEGIS

With which   In which aspect?              Issues to be discussed        Roadmap
 project?


  GUIDE      •User models:             •GUIDE seems to be more related     TBD
             Exchange                  to Cloud4All?
             •Development:                  • Connected TV out of
               • Interfaces:                  AEGIS scope
                 AEGIS widgets              • User profiles are to be
                 could be of use in           worked out in Cloud4All
                 GUIDE (?)
               • Developer tools:
                 To integrate
                 GUIDE simulation
                 tools in
                 assessment phase
                 (?)
             •Portals (integration)
             •Pilots: Exchange
             selected projects
             apps and test them.
             •Roadmaps:Synchro
             nisation
             •Standards: On user
             models?


                 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                           From, To and With AEGIS

With which   In which aspect?              Issues to be discussed        Roadmap
 project?


 WAI-ACT     •Development: Work        •Synchronisation and in depth       TBD
             on WAI-ARIA from          review of recommendation to
             AEGIS and                 standards and roadmaps.
             ACCESSIBLE could be       • Which items of AEGIS and
             useful to WAI-ACT         ACCESSIBLE would be useful to
             •Standards: Review        WAI-ACT?
             of relevant AEGIS
             contributions to
             standards
             •Roadmaps:
             Exchange of research
             agendas (on web
             accessibility)




                 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Identified Synergies
                            From, To and With AEGIS

With which   In which aspect?              Issues to be discussed          Roadmap
 project?


  MyUI       •Support for              •Adaptive user interfaces for         TBD
             designers and             interactive TV is out of scope of
             developers of             AEGIS…
             accessible                •Other?
             applications and
             services
             •Development:
             Integration of the
             tools into AEGIS
             developers tools in
             recommendations
             phase before design
             (Accessibility advisor
             tool in AEGIS)




                 AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
Grouping Synergies
Identified synergies on:
• UCD: Cloud4All (1)
• Personas, Ontologies, User Models: ACCESSIBLE, VICON,
  VERITAS, Cloud4All, GUIDE (5)
• Portals: ETNA, ATIS4All, Cloud4All, AsTeRICS, eAccess+,
  GUIDE (6)
• Pilots: GUIDE, Haptimap, AsTeRICS (3)
• Development: ACCESSIBLE, Haptimap, VICON, VERITAS,
  Cloud4All, GUIDE, WAI-ACT (7)
• Integration: Haptimap (1)
• Roadmaps: Cardiac, GUIDE, WAI-ACT (3)
• Standards: AsTeRICS, GUIDE, WAI-ACT (3)

              AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels

Aegis concertation certh

  • 1.
    Concertation event on Accessibility Maria Gemou CERTH/HIT AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 2.
    Focus-Objectives of thisconcertation • To verify the presented identified synergies. • To discuss issues raised (identified or not) in the context of these synergies (i.e. restrictions, problems, resources, …). • To define specific actions that will fulfill a minimum level of synergies between all projects represented. • To identify synergies that could but cannot be fulfilled and justify (technical, economic, other reasons, …). • To come up, finally, with a specific roadmap to follow and present to the EC… AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 3.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? ACCESSIBLE •Personas: ACCESSIBLE •How personas and end TBD (most and AEGIS Personas have user categories already been exchanged (beneficiaries) can be used done) •Ontologies: AEGIS in the accessibility ontology encompasses evaluation and assessment parts of ACCESSIBLE of applications? ontologies • How a large scale •Development: assessment infrastructure Developer tools: could be defined? ACCESSIBLE assessment • How an internationally simulation and assessment harmonized methodology tools complement the for evaluating the AEGIS OAF with a further conformance of applications step (evaluation). to Standards should be Specifically for the adopted? demonstration purposes, a Netbeans plug-ins of DIAS and WAAT were implemented and integrated in the context of AEGIS SP3 IDE. AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 4.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? Haptimap •Development •Does it really make sense to TBD (some • Setting up a fast Open combine functionalities? Street Map (OSM) already •How many resources would done) server: to be used by both projects and in order that require (on behalf of to solve some issues with both projects)? the license agreement of the OSM and also provide a faster alternative for supporting the applications of both projects (done). • Source code: Exchange of the source code of the two applications (done). •Pilots: Exchange applications for pilots (done). •Integration: Perhaps functionalities could be combined… AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 5.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? ETNA & Portals •Different focus: OAEG covers TBD ATIS4All Specifically, only open source and wishes to integration of AEGIS stay as such. OAEG (online portal •Also, AEGIS provides more than and blog aggregator repository of solutions and focusing on open services (i.e. blog aggregator, source, standards, OAF implementation www.oaeg.eu) and linked to ontologies, mobility “EASTIN 2.0” schemes, ….) portal (online portal • Could all resources of providing a seamless EASTIN 2.0 and OAEG be access to ETNA and combined in 2 levels? ATIS4All repositories • Open Source on ICT-based AT • Proprietory products, accessibility •Level of detail: EASTIN 2.0 solutions and related gives more advanced search and services. level of info in comparison to OAEG. Also most probably different classification is being followed. OAEG already encompasses Oatsoft… AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 6.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? VICON •Personas, •What type of user models in TBD Ontologies and each case? How to combine? User Models (but • VICON uses Datatype note that VICON Properties, AEGIS uses focuses on h/w and Object Properties AEGIS on s/w) • VICON reasoning contains •Development: information about user Developer tools: model classification etc., Integration of VICON AEGIS has no reasoning simulation •Different focus...(AEGIS on ICT models/tools into products and VICON on consumer developer tools of products and interfaces for e- AEGIS in 2 respects: services) • In recommendations phase, before design (Accessibility Advisor Tool in AEGIS). • In assessment phase, after development. AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 7.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? VERITAS •Personas, •How can Personas be described TBD Ontologies and in a common way? Interaction Models • Large Persona population (but note the of AEGIS different focus; • VERITAS can provide common field the ICT quantifiable personas with based apps and specific characteristics services) •Discussion on the properties of •Developer tools: the developer tools in AEGIS: Integration of • Check whether simulated VERITAS simulation accessibility evaluation is models/tools into possible developer tools of • Under which assumptions AEGIS in assessment phase, after development (only in common fields). AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 8.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? Cloud4All •UCD: AEGIS public •Different focus in user clustering. TBD UCD approach as a Cloud4All will apply the “one- paradigm for size-fits-one”, approach. AEGIS Cloud4All follows typical disability clustering •Interaction models (though not really ICF). and Ontologies: • Thus, Personas and user Cloud4All virtual models use should be very models will be fed careful. from AEGIS user •AEGIS is slightly demonstrating models and Personas Cloud extension, whenever among other sources. possible. Could be a good start. •Development: To •Other? select AEGIS apps to apply auto- configuration in AEGIS (from desktop, mobile, web) •Portals: OAEG into Cloud4All GPII Marketplace? AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 9.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? Cardiac •Roadmaps: AEGIS •Perhaps AEGIS roadmap to be TBD and CARDIAC should formatted as part of one of the exchange roadmaps. CARDIAC roadmaps (needs also to be standalone however)? • At first sight, it seems that AEGIS could be contributing to all more or less CARDIAC Structured Dialogic Design Process maps. AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 10.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? AsTeRICS •Pilots: •AsTeRICS focuses on TBD AsTeRICS could serve unconventional peripherals (out as a demonstrator of scope of AEGIS)… how people with •What type of AEGIS apps could severe motor serve as a case study for disabilities can AsTeRICS and in which sense? interact with AEGIS- based GUIs. •Standards: To combine and synchronize (verified) know-how for contribution to standards (especially on interoperability). AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 11.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? eAccess+ •Portals: The •eAccess encompasses a lot that TBD semantically enriched are out of scope of AEGIS (i.e. guide and link to digital TV, self-service terminals); eAccess-ibility however, web a11y is common… resources could be •Other? integrated with OAEG (?) AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 12.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? GUIDE •User models: •GUIDE seems to be more related TBD Exchange to Cloud4All? •Development: • Connected TV out of • Interfaces: AEGIS scope AEGIS widgets • User profiles are to be could be of use in worked out in Cloud4All GUIDE (?) • Developer tools: To integrate GUIDE simulation tools in assessment phase (?) •Portals (integration) •Pilots: Exchange selected projects apps and test them. •Roadmaps:Synchro nisation •Standards: On user models? AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 13.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? WAI-ACT •Development: Work •Synchronisation and in depth TBD on WAI-ARIA from review of recommendation to AEGIS and standards and roadmaps. ACCESSIBLE could be • Which items of AEGIS and useful to WAI-ACT ACCESSIBLE would be useful to •Standards: Review WAI-ACT? of relevant AEGIS contributions to standards •Roadmaps: Exchange of research agendas (on web accessibility) AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 14.
    Identified Synergies From, To and With AEGIS With which In which aspect? Issues to be discussed Roadmap project? MyUI •Support for •Adaptive user interfaces for TBD designers and interactive TV is out of scope of developers of AEGIS… accessible •Other? applications and services •Development: Integration of the tools into AEGIS developers tools in recommendations phase before design (Accessibility advisor tool in AEGIS) AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels
  • 15.
    Grouping Synergies Identified synergieson: • UCD: Cloud4All (1) • Personas, Ontologies, User Models: ACCESSIBLE, VICON, VERITAS, Cloud4All, GUIDE (5) • Portals: ETNA, ATIS4All, Cloud4All, AsTeRICS, eAccess+, GUIDE (6) • Pilots: GUIDE, Haptimap, AsTeRICS (3) • Development: ACCESSIBLE, Haptimap, VICON, VERITAS, Cloud4All, GUIDE, WAI-ACT (7) • Integration: Haptimap (1) • Roadmaps: Cardiac, GUIDE, WAI-ACT (3) • Standards: AsTeRICS, GUIDE, WAI-ACT (3) AEGIS Workshop and International Conference, Brussels