Quality in Social Services
            From the Perspective of Services
               Working with Homeless People
            European Conference, Luxembourg City, 21 st October 2011


                                        Workshop 8:
             The role of skills and qualifications in
              ensuring quality of service delivery

                                         Paolo Brusa




Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
Working with people experiencing homelessness

                                        is an intervention of care

        Let's handle it with care

                                                 &

                                             make some distinctions between
                                                   its 3 structural elements




                                    setting              offer                tools

Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
the place or type of surroundings where something is
      setting           positioned or where an event takes place as its unique tool

                                              everywhere an intervention takes place
                                                     there is an own setting
                                                  (a shelter, a park, a social service...)



       offer            the expression of readiness to do or give something if desired

                                             it comprehends everything that we do or give
                                                 but only if it matches with desires,
                                                  aspirations & will of the receiver

                                                                                Hard to handle
                                                                                  with care
                                                                               the donor's debt


     tools              a device or implement used to carry out a particular function


                                             as our particular function is care-giving,
                                             the relation is the sole available tool

Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
Working with people experiencing homelessness
                               is an intervention of care
     where a care-worker meets a person experiencing homelessness


                 The care-work is structured around this relation
                 between these 2 persons with all their dynamics


        the relation is not peer-to-peer -> significant role played by

             user
                        A person entitled to
                        have needs that require
                        to be satisfied                                              ............
                                                       emotions          power
             prof.
                        a person supposed to have something to offer
                        concerning the specific needs which are
                        expressed by the user in that specific setting
Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
most urgent qualification is the capacity to read what is going
 on within this relation
                            a work of art that requires to:



    - be aware of personnel relational given position, role, power


    - take full responsibility for what it is happening since its
    position is structurally higher


    - capacity to read within the lines of what it is going on with the
    user in a specific setting & change position if required by
    relational dynamics

Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
most urgent qualification is the capacity to read what is going
 on within this relation
                            a work of art that requires to:


    - handle with particular care all power-trip, which are often implicit, &
    might appear in forms of seduction, manipulation, aggressiveness,
    recklessness, fixation to the rules, total and silent compliance …

    - always doubt on his/her personal prejudices, in order to have them as
    a positive allied to deepen the significant of the relational dynamics and
    not as a predefined discrimination

    - learn to read the movements of all the actors as part of a dynamic
    process, where failure is not a value-driven meaning, but a peculiar stage
    that requires extra-care


Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
the relation of care can be represented by the Borromean Rings

                                     -> in mathematics, quantum physic, various symbolism,
                                     logic and psychoanalysis, 3 topological circles are linked to
                                     form a Brunnian link

                                     -> meaning that every time one ring is removed, the other
                                     two remains unlinked.

                                     -> no one of the 3 rings, by the fact of being wrapped by
                                     another ring, is not itself wrapping another

                                     -> within the relationship, each dynamic which is not
                                     bound is binding, everything that is not brought to
                                     awareness and consciousness becomes an action

        -> this is applicable to all representations at every level of our work :
            - setting, offer, tools
            - personnel, user, institution
            - wellness, hardship, symptom
            - biography before homelessness, today needs, process of reinsertion
            - inclusion, exclusion, shelter
            - logical path in social policy, SSGIs offer, people biography
            - physical domain, legal domain, social domain
            - experience, skill, reality
                 …
Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
older personnel with long experience is not necessarily skilled
   younger personnel with high-level education is lacking experience


   all persons face a variety of considerations, meanings, prejudices,
   points of view, emotions, indications, needs & recommendations

         each user is an individual
             each situation is dissimilar
                  each day we all are a bit different
   the challenge is to consider not solely a training programme, but
   an on-going supervision.

   The combination of these 3 levels can support personnel, users,
   institutions to regain the inner sense of the work of taking and
   giving care to people experiencing homelessness.
Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
means learning through experience while
                                                  the experience comes from playing

                                                   is a role-play game specifically created to
                                                       help the workshop conduction for
                                                    professionals working in the social field

                                                  consists on a human-sized game board
                                                  that’s posed on the ground

                                                  participants are asked to take part at the
                                                  game as personification of various
                                                  institutions, of case studies, or of
                                                  general situations that might happen to
                                                  the topics at stake

                                                  The rules are very simple

                                                  It allows participants to develop paths to
   MULTI                POLIS                     awareness-raising concerning social, prof
                                                  and personal dynamics, in logical
                                                  framework focused on methodological
                                                  skills in giving/taking care

Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
The game-board will                                                 Participants receive a
     lay on the floor.                                                case study card and are
                                                                       asked to link and enter
                                                                         their specific role




                                                           The participants start the role play
                                                           by throwing the foam-rubber dices

            Following the dices sum,
            the participant defines its
            objectives and its path to
                     reach it
Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
When the participant takes the situational
 card, one of the observer is invited to
 reach the red center of the board-game
                                                                         While other
                                                                         participants observe
                                                                         with attention, the
                                                                         role-play take place




  The conductor always follows
    the role-play to support,
 control, address and guaranty its
       correct development




                              The gaming-time is variable

Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
When the role-play and the game ends, a
    collective discussion and confrontation
    take place in order to share individual
    observations and reflections…
                                        …that have been used to collectively
                                        build up the contents that represents
                                        the workshop outputs




Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
To favour a collective free shareware, use and
      evolution, Multi-Polis is registered under Creative
      Commons BY-NC-ND 3.0                                                         ND



              This means that you are free to copy, distribute, display, and perform the work
              under the following condition:

              BY ) Attribution -> you must give the original author credit


              NC ) Non Commercial -> you may not use this work for commercial purposes

              ND ) No Derivative Works -> you may not alter, transform, or build upon this
              work

               You may share your output results with the community by sending the .pdf
              form to MultiPolis mail address



       Any of these conditions can be waived if you get permission from the copyright holder.
                 Your fair use and other rights are in no way affected by the above.

Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
Comments from participants

    … the session was like an experience of free-diving and breathing: free-diving, as when one remains
 firm, still and silent as facing something new and unexpected like a new vision; and breathing, as when
                         one savours its beauty and potential ... psychologist 2010

 … it is curious to see the relational traps in which we fall daily, to become reality in front of you …
                                            social worker 2010

   … for the first time ever, I've seen something that pushes the social workers to experience what
                          does really mean to be homeless … service user 2010

 … I felt many things, I received many input, I perceived the fresh breeze of a way to work different
                       from all I have been told so far...    social worker 2010

    … we thought that your MultiPolis game would be worth looking more precisely... trainer 2008

   … it gives opportunities to go beyond the traditional professional roles and challenges to explore
                            situations in an open way ... social worker 2007


                             Contact:         Paolo Brusa
                             via Musinè 12-10143 Torino
                             tel.     +39.011.1971 9353
                             mobile   +39.333.222 32 89
                             mail    info@multipolis.eu
                             web      www.multipolis.eu
Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011            Workshop 8
       Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery

The Role of Skills and Qualifications in Ensuring Quality of Service Delivery

  • 1.
    Quality in SocialServices From the Perspective of Services Working with Homeless People European Conference, Luxembourg City, 21 st October 2011 Workshop 8: The role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery Paolo Brusa Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 2.
    Working with peopleexperiencing homelessness is an intervention of care Let's handle it with care & make some distinctions between its 3 structural elements setting offer tools Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 3.
    the place ortype of surroundings where something is setting positioned or where an event takes place as its unique tool everywhere an intervention takes place there is an own setting (a shelter, a park, a social service...) offer the expression of readiness to do or give something if desired it comprehends everything that we do or give but only if it matches with desires, aspirations & will of the receiver Hard to handle with care the donor's debt tools a device or implement used to carry out a particular function as our particular function is care-giving, the relation is the sole available tool Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 4.
    Working with peopleexperiencing homelessness is an intervention of care where a care-worker meets a person experiencing homelessness The care-work is structured around this relation between these 2 persons with all their dynamics the relation is not peer-to-peer -> significant role played by user A person entitled to have needs that require to be satisfied ............ emotions power prof. a person supposed to have something to offer concerning the specific needs which are expressed by the user in that specific setting Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 5.
    most urgent qualificationis the capacity to read what is going on within this relation a work of art that requires to: - be aware of personnel relational given position, role, power - take full responsibility for what it is happening since its position is structurally higher - capacity to read within the lines of what it is going on with the user in a specific setting & change position if required by relational dynamics Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 6.
    most urgent qualificationis the capacity to read what is going on within this relation a work of art that requires to: - handle with particular care all power-trip, which are often implicit, & might appear in forms of seduction, manipulation, aggressiveness, recklessness, fixation to the rules, total and silent compliance … - always doubt on his/her personal prejudices, in order to have them as a positive allied to deepen the significant of the relational dynamics and not as a predefined discrimination - learn to read the movements of all the actors as part of a dynamic process, where failure is not a value-driven meaning, but a peculiar stage that requires extra-care Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 7.
    the relation ofcare can be represented by the Borromean Rings -> in mathematics, quantum physic, various symbolism, logic and psychoanalysis, 3 topological circles are linked to form a Brunnian link -> meaning that every time one ring is removed, the other two remains unlinked. -> no one of the 3 rings, by the fact of being wrapped by another ring, is not itself wrapping another -> within the relationship, each dynamic which is not bound is binding, everything that is not brought to awareness and consciousness becomes an action -> this is applicable to all representations at every level of our work : - setting, offer, tools - personnel, user, institution - wellness, hardship, symptom - biography before homelessness, today needs, process of reinsertion - inclusion, exclusion, shelter - logical path in social policy, SSGIs offer, people biography - physical domain, legal domain, social domain - experience, skill, reality … Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 8.
    older personnel withlong experience is not necessarily skilled younger personnel with high-level education is lacking experience all persons face a variety of considerations, meanings, prejudices, points of view, emotions, indications, needs & recommendations each user is an individual each situation is dissimilar each day we all are a bit different the challenge is to consider not solely a training programme, but an on-going supervision. The combination of these 3 levels can support personnel, users, institutions to regain the inner sense of the work of taking and giving care to people experiencing homelessness. Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 9.
    means learning throughexperience while the experience comes from playing is a role-play game specifically created to help the workshop conduction for professionals working in the social field consists on a human-sized game board that’s posed on the ground participants are asked to take part at the game as personification of various institutions, of case studies, or of general situations that might happen to the topics at stake The rules are very simple It allows participants to develop paths to MULTI POLIS awareness-raising concerning social, prof and personal dynamics, in logical framework focused on methodological skills in giving/taking care Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 10.
    The game-board will Participants receive a lay on the floor. case study card and are asked to link and enter their specific role The participants start the role play by throwing the foam-rubber dices Following the dices sum, the participant defines its objectives and its path to reach it Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 11.
    When the participanttakes the situational card, one of the observer is invited to reach the red center of the board-game While other participants observe with attention, the role-play take place The conductor always follows the role-play to support, control, address and guaranty its correct development The gaming-time is variable Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 12.
    When the role-playand the game ends, a collective discussion and confrontation take place in order to share individual observations and reflections… …that have been used to collectively build up the contents that represents the workshop outputs Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 13.
    To favour acollective free shareware, use and evolution, Multi-Polis is registered under Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 3.0 ND This means that you are free to copy, distribute, display, and perform the work under the following condition: BY ) Attribution -> you must give the original author credit NC ) Non Commercial -> you may not use this work for commercial purposes ND ) No Derivative Works -> you may not alter, transform, or build upon this work You may share your output results with the community by sending the .pdf form to MultiPolis mail address Any of these conditions can be waived if you get permission from the copyright holder. Your fair use and other rights are in no way affected by the above. Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery
  • 14.
    Comments from participants … the session was like an experience of free-diving and breathing: free-diving, as when one remains firm, still and silent as facing something new and unexpected like a new vision; and breathing, as when one savours its beauty and potential ... psychologist 2010 … it is curious to see the relational traps in which we fall daily, to become reality in front of you … social worker 2010 … for the first time ever, I've seen something that pushes the social workers to experience what does really mean to be homeless … service user 2010 … I felt many things, I received many input, I perceived the fresh breeze of a way to work different from all I have been told so far... social worker 2010 … we thought that your MultiPolis game would be worth looking more precisely... trainer 2008 … it gives opportunities to go beyond the traditional professional roles and challenges to explore situations in an open way ... social worker 2007 Contact: Paolo Brusa via Musinè 12-10143 Torino tel. +39.011.1971 9353 mobile +39.333.222 32 89 mail info@multipolis.eu web www.multipolis.eu Quality in Social Services – Luxembourg City, 21st October 2011 Workshop 8 Paolo Brusa – the Role of skills and qualifications in ensuring quality of service delivery