This study examined how to modify the Teaching Proficiency through Reading and Storytelling (TPRS) method to better engage middle school Spanish students and maintain classroom structure. The researcher conducted an action research project comparing a baseline TPRS lesson to a modified lesson. In the baseline lesson, students became disruptive and the classroom structure broke down. In the modified lesson, the researcher added clear expectations, a visual element, and opportunities for choral response. Analysis found that students were more positively engaged during the modified lesson, suggesting these modifications can help support TPRS in secondary language classrooms.