- Pension plans face a major mystery in accurately valuing their assets and liabilities given uncertainties around future market returns, inflation, and other economic factors.
- They estimate future returns, called the expected rate of return, to smooth out market volatility but these estimates are often unrealistic and do not reflect the global bond bubble.
- With most pension plans already running deficits, an accurate expected rate of return that incorporates the risks of the bond bubble popping could show significantly larger deficits than currently reported and require greater employer contributions.
Robert Feinholz: Planning for a 30 year retirementForman Bay LLC
Robert Feinholz: Planning for a 30 year retirement.
Funding a 30-year retirement will take financial planning prowess as you juggle the effects of inflation, distributions, taxes, asset allocation, and expenditures. Are you up to the task?
Robert Feinholz: The art of managing retirement assumptionsForman Bay LLC
Robert Feinholz: The art of managing retirement assumptions
A retirement plan is built on a set of assumptions that can’t be validated until it’s too late. One key to successful retirement planning is carefully setting assumptions and revising them often.
In this presentation we will deal with the “Concept of Investment” and further discuss the purpose, speculation and strategies to be followed while investing.
To know more about Welingkar School’s Distance Learning Program and courses offered, visit:
http://www.welingkaronline.org/distance-learning/online-mba.html
Robert Feinholz: Planning for a 30 year retirementForman Bay LLC
Robert Feinholz: Planning for a 30 year retirement.
Funding a 30-year retirement will take financial planning prowess as you juggle the effects of inflation, distributions, taxes, asset allocation, and expenditures. Are you up to the task?
Robert Feinholz: The art of managing retirement assumptionsForman Bay LLC
Robert Feinholz: The art of managing retirement assumptions
A retirement plan is built on a set of assumptions that can’t be validated until it’s too late. One key to successful retirement planning is carefully setting assumptions and revising them often.
In this presentation we will deal with the “Concept of Investment” and further discuss the purpose, speculation and strategies to be followed while investing.
To know more about Welingkar School’s Distance Learning Program and courses offered, visit:
http://www.welingkaronline.org/distance-learning/online-mba.html
Why Saving on a Regular Basis Might Be WiseOpen Knowledge
A small step today can make a big difference in retirement. “People who save regularly for retirement tend to be happier with their retirement planning than those who do not,” says Kathrin Nies, author of 'Why Saving on a Regular Basis May be Wise', a study conducted by the Munich Center for the Economics of Aging and Allianz Global Investors.
Principal protection with upside potential. 20% rollover bonus. 401k,IRA rollover eligible. For more information call (888) 235-8060 or visit us at www.AdvisorRick.com.
What's it like to work with The Independent Financial Group? Founding Principal Jim Lorenzen talks about how IFG may be different from other wealth management advisory firms.
Federica Teppa, Maarten van Rooij. Are Retirement Decisions Vulnerable to Fra...Eesti Pank
Federica Teppa
(De Nederlandsche Bank & Netspar)
Maarten van Rooij
(De Nederlandsche Bank & Netspar)
Open Seminar at Eesti Pank
Tallinn - September, 2013
Principal Retirement Advisors offers a first-of-its-kind one-stop solution to help you achieve your key financial goals and attain a financially independent and secured retirement. We offer advisory services on a wide range of products including Mutual funds, Fixed-income products, Gold ETFs and insurance for individual investors across all life stages.
Public pensions are on the verge of exploding municipal and the state budget in coming years.
Generational theft is a strong language, but Richard Dreyfus, Senior Fellow at the Commonwealth Foundation beleives that this looming timebomb" has the potential to bankrupt our cities and our state. He made complelling arguments and marshalled the facts to present a simple, compelling and thought provoking presentation.
Berlin (1990): Inspiration from the German reunification was not inspiring. In fact – nothing was going as planned. Ideas were not flowing, lyrics were not working, and the music certainly wasn’t playing.
The days were so dire, that Bono pleaded that their music would have to move people in mysterious ways, and be even better than the real thing. Never to give up, the rock band dug themselves in and declared they would keep trying to become one, until the end of the world.
Berlin (2013): Inspiration from becoming the World’s exporting super power had long vanished. Throwing their hard earned money at the Irish and Portuguese, staring down the Greeks while Athens burned, and forcing the Italians, Spanish and Cypriots to accept their way or the highway was reason for celebration. Everything was going as planned - until now.
When it comes to sleepless nights, Toimi Soini of Finland originally set the record by using the “toothpicks under the eyelids” method for 11 straight days. In hindsight, Toimi was an amateur.
You wouldn’t know it, but the nice people running the Bank of Canada have gone sleepless since 2003 – that’s 3,564 days without sweet dreams.
Yet, that’s nothing compared to the very private folks at the Swiss National Bank. These super-secretive bankers have surpassed over 4,660 sleepless nights – despite living in Zzzzzzurich.
This, of course brings us to the World record for sleepless nights. At 5,025 nights and counting, the always polite and well dressed chaps over at the Bank of England are reigning champions.
Toimi Soini was not a banker and this was his downfall. As for the Canadians, Swiss and British – yes they are all bankers, but not just any bankers. This terrific trio have the displeasure of forever being known as the bankers who sold their gold.
The irony of course, is the action of the World’s central bankers themselves is the reason why gold is destined to remain golden for sometime to come. And with gold sitting near $1700/oz, and with no end to the money printing games, the sleepless nights are destined to continue.
Why Saving on a Regular Basis Might Be WiseOpen Knowledge
A small step today can make a big difference in retirement. “People who save regularly for retirement tend to be happier with their retirement planning than those who do not,” says Kathrin Nies, author of 'Why Saving on a Regular Basis May be Wise', a study conducted by the Munich Center for the Economics of Aging and Allianz Global Investors.
Principal protection with upside potential. 20% rollover bonus. 401k,IRA rollover eligible. For more information call (888) 235-8060 or visit us at www.AdvisorRick.com.
What's it like to work with The Independent Financial Group? Founding Principal Jim Lorenzen talks about how IFG may be different from other wealth management advisory firms.
Federica Teppa, Maarten van Rooij. Are Retirement Decisions Vulnerable to Fra...Eesti Pank
Federica Teppa
(De Nederlandsche Bank & Netspar)
Maarten van Rooij
(De Nederlandsche Bank & Netspar)
Open Seminar at Eesti Pank
Tallinn - September, 2013
Principal Retirement Advisors offers a first-of-its-kind one-stop solution to help you achieve your key financial goals and attain a financially independent and secured retirement. We offer advisory services on a wide range of products including Mutual funds, Fixed-income products, Gold ETFs and insurance for individual investors across all life stages.
Public pensions are on the verge of exploding municipal and the state budget in coming years.
Generational theft is a strong language, but Richard Dreyfus, Senior Fellow at the Commonwealth Foundation beleives that this looming timebomb" has the potential to bankrupt our cities and our state. He made complelling arguments and marshalled the facts to present a simple, compelling and thought provoking presentation.
Berlin (1990): Inspiration from the German reunification was not inspiring. In fact – nothing was going as planned. Ideas were not flowing, lyrics were not working, and the music certainly wasn’t playing.
The days were so dire, that Bono pleaded that their music would have to move people in mysterious ways, and be even better than the real thing. Never to give up, the rock band dug themselves in and declared they would keep trying to become one, until the end of the world.
Berlin (2013): Inspiration from becoming the World’s exporting super power had long vanished. Throwing their hard earned money at the Irish and Portuguese, staring down the Greeks while Athens burned, and forcing the Italians, Spanish and Cypriots to accept their way or the highway was reason for celebration. Everything was going as planned - until now.
When it comes to sleepless nights, Toimi Soini of Finland originally set the record by using the “toothpicks under the eyelids” method for 11 straight days. In hindsight, Toimi was an amateur.
You wouldn’t know it, but the nice people running the Bank of Canada have gone sleepless since 2003 – that’s 3,564 days without sweet dreams.
Yet, that’s nothing compared to the very private folks at the Swiss National Bank. These super-secretive bankers have surpassed over 4,660 sleepless nights – despite living in Zzzzzzurich.
This, of course brings us to the World record for sleepless nights. At 5,025 nights and counting, the always polite and well dressed chaps over at the Bank of England are reigning champions.
Toimi Soini was not a banker and this was his downfall. As for the Canadians, Swiss and British – yes they are all bankers, but not just any bankers. This terrific trio have the displeasure of forever being known as the bankers who sold their gold.
The irony of course, is the action of the World’s central bankers themselves is the reason why gold is destined to remain golden for sometime to come. And with gold sitting near $1700/oz, and with no end to the money printing games, the sleepless nights are destined to continue.
She adores hats. She is always very polite and respectful of others. She waves to everyone, and consistently avoids conflict. She is a lady; she is The Queen.
Without a doubt, Queen Elizabeth lives a life quite unlike everyone else in the World – after all, royalty does have its privileges. Yet, when it comes to investing, the Queen is swimming in the same pool of stock market sharks as us common people.
Like everyone else, she pours through her quarterly statements to see how she’s fared. And like everyone else, she loves to make money and simply deplores negative returns. It was rumored that the 2008 crisis hit her particularly hard – over USD 40 million in stock market losses.
This experience must have jilted something, as when The Queen was visiting the esteemed London School of Economics she asked the professor a rather “un-queen” like question – why did economists fail to predict the biggest global recession since the Great Depression?
The reason the world's economic slump continues is quite clear - people are spending less money than before.
The solution used by the world's central banks is to reduce the amount of money available to people to spend.
Irony or confusion? Take a pick. One thing is clear - investors are doing unusual things with their money, and unfortunately they are paying the price.
Years ago, the seeds were sown.
Governments began an untenable trend of consistently spending more money than they collected in taxes. The difference of course, was made up by borrowing. As the years and deficits rolled along, so too did the amount of money owing. Governments responded by borrowing even more.
Meanwhile, global economies inevitably experienced varying crises. Governments and central banks always responded the same way - even more spending (and borrowing), and lower interest rates to stimulate growth.
Today, we've reached a dead-end.
Governments continue to borrow, but only because interest rates have been reduced to 0% AND because they are borrowing from themselves by printing money.
This dead-end is also compounded by a slowing global economy caused by the reluctance of private investors to spend.
In this issue of the IceCap Global Outlook, we prepare investors for a collision between:
a slowing economy,
0% and negative% interest rates,
an unsustainable debt binge.
What happens next hasn't occurred before in our lifetime - and this is why many investors will be blindsided.
With Halloween right around the corner, it's the time of year to analyse what is safe and what is scary in investment markets.
And, the scariest investments in the world will become a complete surprise to many.
In this IceCap Global Outlook we detail what to be afraid of and why, and better yet - where you should hide.
Emerging economic trends are going to make the future very difficult for millenials who hope to buy a house or have savings for retirement. Learn the basics of financial literacy; how to avoid debt, build a nestegg and acquire advice on personal portfolio management.
For Those Who Want to Prosper & Thrive in Retirementfreddysaamy
http://ekinsurance.com/financial/retirement/
Our core capital should be designed to outlive us. In fact, it’s important for you to start thinking about your money in terms of it outliving you, not the other way around. You don’t want to outlive your money.
Welcome to the fifth edition of Outline, Redington’s quarterly collection of thought-pieces designed to help institutional investors make smarter and more informed decisions.
This edition features short articles on the future of pensions policy, the complexities of running a pension scheme and how technology can help overcome them, risks inherent from gilt and swap rate differences, an outcome-driven approach to fund management, a review of asset classes in 2013, plus an overview of the global macro environment.
We hope you find the articles interesting and helpful as you consider how best to manage the risk-adjusted return of your portfolios
Everyone enjoys a nice surprise - especially the ones that cause you to grin ear to ear, smile non-stop and wish the moment will never end.
There can also be bad surprises - and these are not the least bit enjoyable.
In this issue of the IceCap Global Outlook, we explain how governments are about to experience a bad surprise. And their reaction to these surprises will be significantly higher taxes for everyone.
There will also be a good surprise - adjusting your portfolios in anticipation of the bad surprise will allow you to not only preserve your capital, but also have you grinning ear to ear.
We invite you to read more.
For many, the investment world can be a confusing place. Banks, mutual finds, stocks, bonds, currencies, insurance, inflation, taxes, economies - it's no wonder the majority have glossed eyes.
And sitting on top of this confusion pie are central banks.
Each country has its own central bank which is responsible for setting overnight interest rates and the amount of money in that country's financial system.
Yet, there is one central bank that is the most important, sits on top of the world, and all of its actions impact not only their local country, but also every other country in the world.
This central bank is the US Federal Reserve.
In this latest IceCap Global Outlook we share how actions by the US Federal Reserve are always reactive to a crisis which, ironically, it helped create in the first place.
Today's central banks are once again, trying to thread the financial needle, and rescue us from the crisis that was born from the depths of the 2008-09 Great Financial Crisis.
The crisis is happening, yet there is good news - the crisis is creating opportunities to not only preserve your hard earned savings, but to capitalize too.
For the past 10 years, global central banks have created policies to artificially suppress interest rates to the lowest levels ever recorded.
Included in this strategy has been a deliberate strategy to create negative interest rates which have subsequently created an enormous financial bubble in global bond markets.
While this bubble and associated risks are known to a small section of global investors, Canada remains highly complacent to the risks involved and have demonstrated a lack of appreciation of how risks outside of Canada, can actually create financial stress within Canada.
This issue of the IceCap Global Outlook shares our view on Canadian Provincial Debt markets and why we believe it has a high probability of evolving into a significant liquidity event for Canadian investors.
The current economic expansion has achieved 2 significant milestones. And what makes these milestones special is that when combined together, they create an economic paradox.
For starters, the current economic expansion has set the record as the longest period of continuous economic growth in US history.
While at the same time, it has also set the record as being the weakest period of continuous economic growth in US history.
This should raise questions as well as concerns.
The answer to the primary question is as follows: this economic expansion has been completely supported and enabled by unorthodox interest policies by global central banks. Zero % and negative % interest rates around the world has allowed economies to maintain positive, yet muted growth.
The concern with this economic experience is that the majority of this growth has been artificially created.
In this IceCap Global Outlook, we examine the invisible hand and why it is the key to understanding why economic growth is so weak, and better still - what happens next.
The European Union (EU) is a political and economic union of 28 member countries.
Its stated goals are to promote peace, freedom, and justice. It will also enhance economic, social and territorial cohesion, while also respecting everyone's rich culture and diversity.
Reality is a different story.
The EU is a bully.
Its short history is littered with continuous, venomous, and contradicting actions against many of its 28 member countries - and all to the benefit of those in Brussels.
It has been documented, that bullies only respond to strength. And today across the EU - the victims of the bullies in Brussels are fighting back.
The political establishments are quickly losing power.
The tide has turned, and it will have a profound effect on the EU, the Eurozone and global financial markets.
Every major shift in economics, politics and social environments creates significant investment opportunities.
This time will be no different.
South of San Francisco lies a small stretch of the famous California Highway 1 notoriously known by locals as The Devil's Slide.
The stunning view along this road is supported by a weak and steep foundation of loose rock, and porous soil that has been increasingly eroding away over the years sweeping cars, pavement and lives into the sea below.
Naturally, rock slides from the erosion reached a point where the road has been deemed unsafe and closed. In the end, the Devil in the details was a weak foundation supported by illogical engineering.
Today, the Financial Devil has watched patiently, as the world’s central banks and political leaders built a financial debt and interest rate structure on a foundation consisting of theories, acronyms and worst of all – hope.
Since 1982, the financial world has enjoyed a thrilling ride – one zoomed around the world by 36 years of bailouts and declining long-term interest rates.
In this issue of the IceCap Global Outlook we help you see how a pattern of minor financial stresses will culminate into a major financial stress.
And more importantly, how to identify the opportunities that will be created as the majority of the industry continues to ignore the Financial Devil.
In this issue, IceCap shows how the Toronto housing bubble has been created and what will make it break - the answer may surprise you.
In addition, we detail how the European Central Bank has applied all sorts of financial make-up to convince the world that Italy, Spain, Portugal and others are in solid, financial shape.
Of course, the problem with make-up is that eventually it wears off, and then what is left exposed is not pretty.
The recent American election continues to have the world on edge. Seemingly every media outlet and investment manager around the world continues to hammer away at the bad or good that will be created by the actions of the new President.
This is a mistake.
While the entire world continues to be focused on President Trump and American Politics, it has become completely distracted as to what is happening in Europe.
Europe remains a pile of timber and in this issue of the IceCap Global Outlook, we describe how dramatic swings in politics and interest rates will be the spark that reignites the crisis in the old world.
With Halloween right around the corner, it's the time of year to analyse what is safe and what is scary in investment markets.
And, the scariest investments in the world will become a complete surprise to many.
In this IceCap Global Outlook we detail what to be afraid of and why, and better yet - where you should hide.
1. Our view on global investment markets:
July 2015 – Elementary my Dear Watson
Keith Dicker, CFA
Chief Investment Officer
keithdicker@IceCapAssetManagement.com
www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
1-902-492-8495
2. 1
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
If you’re into mysteries, there’s certainly no shortage of them around
the world. Enjoying them is one thing, solving them is quite another.
In the mystery solving world, Sherlock Holmes was clearly heads,
hands and feet above everyone else. His unorthodox thinking was the
key to solving the mystery behind the Hounds of Baskerville, while
shrewd decision making always proved valuable when up against the
maniacal Moriarty.
Lieutenant Columbo meanwhile, was also a sharp cookie. Whereas
Sherlock dove straight into a mystery and aggressively confronted his
foes, the affable Columbo excelled at bumbling around the problem
which caused his foes to underestimate him. Which of course, always
helped everyone’s favourite detective gather more clues and crack
the case.
Mysterious hounds and mysterious criminals certainly help keep our
minds razor sharp as well as entertained. Yet, perhaps the biggest
mystery in the world today involves - pension plans.
Many people have them, and most people fully know what their
eventual pension payout will be. Unfortunately, the average person
doesn’t know how their pension plan is actually taped together, and
fewer still, appreciate that the “promise” of their “eventual pension
payout” is not as guaranteed as they may believe.
One more thing…
Let’s leave no doubt - considering the mysterious complexity of these
plans, to understand them one must certainly be a sharp cookie –
that’s the easy part.
However, to fully understand them, one must use unorthodox
thinking and make shrewd analytical decisions. Last but not least,
never underestimate how today’s financial environment is about to
leave many pension plans scratching their heads with confusion and
despair.
Our previous Global Market Outlook “Right on Target” discussed
Defined Contribution Pension plans and why they will be significantly
affected by the upcoming crisis in the bond market.
For this Global Market Outlook, we are writing about Defined Benefit
Pension Plans. They too will be affected by the bond crisis. But
whereas individuals will be affected in Defined Contribution Pension
Plans, both individuals and their employers will be affected in Defined
Benefit Pension Plans.
The big difference of course, is whether your employer is a company
or a government entity.
DBP vs DCP – the big difference
The main difference between Defined Benefit Plans (DBP) and
Defined Contribution Plans (DCP) all boils down to who ultimately
bares the risk.
3. 2www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
For DBP, the ultimate risk is with the employer. After all, if the
investments do not grow to what is needed to make pension
payments – the employer must make up the difference.
On the other hand, DCP are set-up so that the employee bares all the
risk. On retirement day, if there isn’t enough money in the
investment pot – tough luck. Don’t go running to your employer –
you, and only you are responsible for ensuring you have enough set
aside.
If you don’t have enough, you’ll have to either scrape and scrounge to
make ends meet, continue working, or maybe move in with your kids
(provided they are not already living with you).
Recognising this key fact will help you understand why practically all
employers today have moved towards DCP. After all, if you had a
choice whether to accept or reject any risk that carried no return –
you would choose to reject the risk, every single time.
This is exactly what employers have done by moving towards DCP.
The Defined Benefit (DBP) Pension Plan
Few people today know why, when or how pension plans were
created. They’re just there, and if you are a member of a pension
plan, the financial burden of retirement has been greatly relieved.
If only that were true.
It’s complicated In fact, today pension plans have become so large and systemically
important - not only from a financial perspective, but also from a
social and political perspective, that they are fully entwined and
exposed to the perils created by today’s bizarre investment
environment.
The key to understanding pension plans is knowing that they are one
gigantic pool of money - meaning there are a lot of individuals,
agencies, consultants, investment managers, accountants, actuaries,
lawyers, record keepers, administrators, corporate trustees,
performance measurement analysts and other service providers lined
up to offer their help; all for a fee of course.
Weeding through this convoluted scheme, there is only one thing
you need to know to solve the pension mystery:
- pension funds rely upon an estimated rate of return for valuing the
financial health of the fund, and
- it has become virtually impossible for them to achieve this return
The First Step
The first step in de-mystifying the DBP, is simply understanding that it
has 2 dimensions: 1) Assets 2) Liabilities
Assets Liabilities
All contributions and
investments
All current &
estimated future
pension payments
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
4. 3www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
The Assets for all DBP’s are a consolidation of the contributions from
the employer and the employee and the resulting investments.
Investments can include many things but commonly include stocks,
bonds, and real estate.
The Liabilities represent all the money that needs to be paid out of
the fund and is called the PBO (pension benefit obligation). The most
prominent obligations are the current and future pension payments,
as well as healthcare premiums.
This however, is where things get a bit tricky due to a fair bit of
educated guessing taking place. The very best actuaries sharpen their
spreadsheets and guess:
1. when most employees will die
2. what their future salary will look like
3. how long she will work for her employer
4. the rate of inflation
5. an appropriate discount rate
There are a few other moving parts, making it even easier to see how
slight changes in one component can really change the liability
picture for a pension plan.
Now, the next step is where the pension mystery really turns
interesting. The difference between what the pension fund owns and
what it owes is called either a surplus or a deficit.
Things get tricky
If the actuaries determine that the pension fund has more than
enough money to make all present and future payments, then the
pension plan is said to be in a SURPLUS position.
On the other hand – if the pension plan does not have enough money
available, then it is in a DEFICIT position.
Around the world today, the vast majority of DBP are running a
deficit. Many plans are running close to a 20% deficit. – incredibly,
this is considered to be healthy. Other plans such as the Illinois Public
Pension Plan is running a 50% deficit – clearly this isn’t healthy.
If your plan is in a surplus position today, we suggest your pension
plan is in a very rare and favourable financial position.
Assets Liabilities
All contributions and
investments
All current and
estimated future
pension payments
Deficit
June 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
5. 4www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
Where things become especially mysterious, is how the Assets are
valued. This is where the pension plan uses an estimated or expected
rate of return to value their assets over the long-term.
What makes this such a high alert/danger zone warning is that very
few of the consultants and actuaries involved with pension plans
understand and appreciate the bubble that has developed in the
global bond market.
No one alive today, has ever experienced a global bond bubble, and
because it has never happened in the recent past, practically
everyone in the investment and pension industry does not believe in
the bubble, or what will happen once it pops.
And when the bond bubble pops, it will have significant long-term
effects on pension plan assets and their financial health.
Pension Plan Assets
Everyone knows their pension plan owns stocks and bonds. What few
know is how they are actually valued.
Because stock and bond markets can be very volatile in the short-
term, and pension plans provide benefits over the long-term, many
argue that it is unfair to determine the financial health of a pension
plan based upon short-term, recent market performance.
Unless of course, the short-term market performance is exceptionally
It has never happened before…
good – then the above doesn’t apply.
However, if markets whipsaw around like they did in 2012, 2009,
2008, 2002, 2001, 1998, 1994 (we could go on but...), then pension
plan consultants prefer to smooth out these return fluctuations when
reporting their financial check-up.
The main tool used for smoothing returns is called the Expected Rate
of Return. It isn’t the actual rate of return, but rather, it is an estimate
of what the pension plan will earn over the long-term.
Now, here’s the trick – the higher the expected rate of return, the
higher the expected value of plan assets.
The higher the expected plan assets, the lower the expected deficit.
And, the lower the expected deficit, the lower the expected
contributions that is required by the employer.
Note: these expected returns are theoretical - not actual.
In a nutshell – high expected rates of return are good. But only good
if they retain a semblance of reality. And since most people live in
reality, the expected rate of return used by pension plans should also
resemble reality.
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
6. 5www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
Don’t live in the past
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
And this brings us to the very big problem for pension plans today.
Theoretical or expected returns used by pension funds today are no
where close to what may be earned in reality.
60% Stocks + 40% Bonds
In order to better appreciate reality, one must first understand that
most pension funds typically hold about 60% in stocks and 40% in
bonds.
The popularity of DBP pension funds really surged in the 1980s only
to plateau in the 1990s. And during that time, a diversified portfolio
with a roughly 60-40 split almost always produced a really nice return
experience, which made everyone really happy.
And since all of today’s consultants cut their teeth during this period,
or learned from people who worked during this period – then a
balanced 60-40 split will do just fine for everyone today. After all, the
80s and 90s happened over 25 years ago. For any investment strategy
to endure over that amount of time, it must be good.
Unfortunately, due to high expected rates of return, many pension
funds are actually living in a fantasy world.
Case in point, consider the Expected Rate of Returns for:
- Ohio Police & Fire Pension Fund = +8.25%
- California Public Employees Retirement System = +7.50%
60%
40%
Bonds
Stocks
Structure of typical pension plan
More conservative Expected Rates of Return can be found with:
- Nova Scotia Public Service Superannuation Plan = +6.50%
- Healthcare of Ontario Pension Plan = +6.34%
To the naked eye, these return expectations may appear quite
reasonable – after all, we’ve always been told that over 100 years,
the stock market always averages 10% annual returns or higher.
However, our regular readers know that it isn’t the stock market that
worries us. Instead, it’s the bond market that should be keeping
people awake at night.
Yet, even long-term stock market returns have a major flaws. For
starters, the 10% number comes from the well-known
Ibbotson/Morningstar studies which show that since 1926, the US
stock market returned 10% annually.
7. 6www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
The average return never happens
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
With almost 90 years of history, this must be pretty darn accurate.
However, if the Ibbotson study started 20 years earlier, the annual
return declines to about 7% a year (source: Crestmont Research).
Think about this; a 90 year study shows a 10% annual return, but a
110 year study shows a 7% annual return. That’s a pretty big
difference, and certainly throws doubt on what exactly is the long-
term average.
Better still, Chart 1 (this page) shows the 10% average return is
actually rarely achieved. Since 1900, 44% of the time the average 10-
year return was < 8%.
Think about that one – whether you exceed an 8% return has
effectively become a flip of the coin.
While that describes the challenges of using long-term returns from
the stock market, our real concern is actually with the bond market.
We’ve written, presented, interviewed and even web-casted many
times before about the bubble in the bond market. It’s a very big
deal, and when it bursts it will have cascading effects in every market,
all over the world.
And considering that the average pension plan has 40% of its
investments in the bond market – this is a BIGdeal.
To fully appreciate how big of a deal this is, one needs to appreciate
the complete picture of:
- expected rates of return
- stock market returns
- bond market returns
Chart 1: Frequency of average returns
8. 7www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
Theory vs Reality
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
Since most pension plans hold about 60% in stocks and 40% in bonds,
the pension plan’s total return is simply:
60% * Stock Market Return + 40%*Bond Market Return
As an example, if Stocks increased 10% and Bonds increased 5%, the
pension plan’s total return = 60%*10% + 40%*5% = 8% Total Return.
Simple enough and in theory, that’s how it works. However, it’s reality
that has us concerned.
To demonstrate exactly why pension funds are in trouble, note the
above calculation. Due to the way the bond market works, it is fairly
easy today to accurately predict the maximum return achievable –
we’ll get to the minimum return in a moment.
Today, the yield or interest received on a 10 year US Government
Treasury Bond is about 2%. This means if you buy the bond today, the
best return possible is 2% a year for the next 10 years.
This is where our technical readers point out that bond investors also
hold corporate bonds, junk bonds and emerging market bonds which
will increase the yield further. As a result, even using the Barclay’s US
Aggregate Bond Index as a different return proxy still only increases
the yield to 2.2%. For this example, we’ll simply round down to 2%.
6%
? %
2%
Expected Rate of Return
Current Bond Market Return
Future Stock Market Return
Putting it all together: below we show using a 6.5% Expected Rate of
Return and a 2% Bond Market return, the pension plan would need a
9.50% return from the stock market to meet it’s return objective.
Most people would agree that over the long-run stocks will produce a
9.50% return.
This is true for a 6.50% Expected Rate of Return. Watch happens to
the poor folks at the Ohio Police & Fire Pension Fund who has elected
to use a 8.25% Expected Rate of Return
% Allocation Strategy Strategy Return Proportion Return
60% Stocks 9.50% 5.70%
40% Bonds 2.00% 0.80%
Expected Rate of Return 6.50%
9. 8www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
They’re just numbers
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
Whoa - this pension plan needs a +12.45% return from the stock
market to meet it’s return objective. And considering everyone swims
in the same stock market, the probability of the Ohio Police & Fire
Pension Fund meetings its return objectives are next to 0%.
And that’s assuming a +2% return from the Bond Market.
Next, and this is the most critical aspect of the pension mystery and
why we are writing about it – what happens to pension funds when
(not if), the bond bubble breaks?
Let’s return to the more conservative +6.5% Expected Rate of Return,
and assume the bond bubble breaks with a -20% permanent loss.
Whereas the pension plan previously needed a +9.5% return, now it
needs a +24.17% annual return to meet its objective. That’s a pretty
big swing in the required return from the stock market.
% Allocation Strategy Strategy Return Proportion Return
60% Stocks 12.42% 7.45%
40% Bonds 2.00% 0.80%
Expected Rate of Return 8.25%
% Allocation Strategy Strategy Return Proportion Return
60% Stocks 24.17% 14.50%
40% Bonds -20.00% -8.00%
Expected Rate of Return 6.50%
Using the same -20% loss in the bond market for the Ohio Police &
Fire Pension Fund and their +8.25% Expected Rate of Return shows
the following:
As you can see, losses from the bond market has the potential to
make life really uncomfortable for pension plans.
Unfortunately, the probability of even more extreme losses exist.
Consider what happens if bond markets suffer a -50% loss:
Yes, at this point it’s very likely nothing is working anyway. Losses will
have become too great to be covered by stock market returns, and
the employer is likely struggling as well.
And this is our point - our research shows that the bond market is
clearly in bubble territory. The reason it should be greatly feared is
% Allocation Strategy Strategy Return Proportion Return
60% Stocks 27.08% 16.25%
40% Bonds -20.00% -8.00%
Expected Rate of Return 8.25%
% Allocation Strategy Strategy Return Proportion Return
60% Stocks 44.17% 26.50%
40% Bonds -50.00% -20.00%
Expected Rate of Return 6.50%
10. 9www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
Hope of a better day
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
that the majority of investors, managers, and consultants do not
believe anything bad can happen to the bond market.
We’ve been taught that only the stock market can produce
spectacular crashes and upheaval. Bond markets are dull, boring,
anonymous creatures that never go beep in the night.
Some may consider a 5-10% loss will occur but it will be recovered.
Others truly believe government finances will slowly recover, creating
a gradual return to financial market normalcy.
We hope (there’s that word again) both are right. However, the
continuing deterioration in government finances, increasing debt
loads, and the use of money printing and negative interest rates to
spark a recovery leaves little doubt – the bond market is going to
produce many nasty surprises for all investors, and most notably
pension funds.
The Solution
For starters pension plans must recognise the risk – without
admitting to the problem, nothing will be done. Unfortunately, very,
very few see the risk. We’ve spoken with many pension funds and the
majority hide behind the consensus view that there is no problem
with the bond market.
Consultants play a pivotal role. And unfortunately, they too do not
see the risk, or worse still even want to look at the risk. We’ve seen
many studies produced by the big consultants, and they’ll commonly
use 20, 30 and even 50 year data to support their recommendations.
Again, the problem with this approach is that a sovereign bond
bubble hasn’t occurred during any of these periods.
Another problem that has been created over the years is the
complete transition away from using investment managers to make
the asset allocation decision and towards this decision being made by
the consultants.
In the 70s and 80s, a pension plan would hire an investment manager
with a balanced mandate – meaning it was up to the manager to
make tactical moves between stocks and bonds.
As the years rolled on, the investment industry enjoyed the biggest
bull market known to mankind. This experience showed consultants
that instead of letting managers decide between stocks and bonds,
they would simply select managers who focussed exclusively on
either stock or bonds.
Balanced fund managers were terminated and replaced with small
cap managers, value managers, growth managers etc.
In other words, the consultants took full control over the asset
allocation decision. And considering the world was experiencing a
bull market – it worked out very well.
11. 10www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
Chicago is nice, but we prefer the Bay area
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
Like all good things, eventually they come to an end. And in our
opinion, the current global financial landscape has once again tilted
the focus back towards balanced mandates. Well, at least that’s
where it should be.
Hence, the broad solution is for pension funds and their consultants
to move away from niche managers, and back towards asset
allocation focussed managers. The sooner they understand the world
has moved away from a stock picking game, and towards an
allocating game the better.
A more specific solution involves re-allocating plan assets away from
the danger areas of the world (Euro-zone, government debt, banks
and insurance companies) and towards the markets big enough to
absorb the capital flows – USD and US equities.
We fully expect this to occur, but only after the bond bubble breaks.
Chicago
It’s an amazing city. The architecture is great. The food is great. The
football team is, well just okay. We do love Chicago. Yet, it’s also a
text book example of how unrealistic pension fund benefits and
return expectations can put a city on the verge of bankruptcy.
Without going into great detail, Chicago has accumulated enormous,
Greek-like debts. Based upon current economic activity and tax
revenues, the City will never be able to repay the debts.
One of the biggest debts is money owed to the pension fund. The
problem is that if the City declares bankruptcy (same as Detroit),
courts have ruled that pension benefits cannot be touched.
In other words as the crisis continues, Chicago’s budget deficit
increases further and since it cannot reduce benefits to the pension
plan, the only other way to improve its debt owing is to raise taxes.
There are two challenges to this simple solution:
1) raising tax rates actually reduces economic activity and therefore
reduces the total tax revenue collected (see Greece);
2) it creates a social problem in that everyone in Chicago will be
forced to pay higher taxes, so that the City can continue to offer a
very generous pension plan to a select few.
This same problem in Chicago, is also happening elsewhere in the
United States, as well as Germany and other countries. It’s yet
another example of how the debt bubble is seeping around the
world.
We suggest you do your own research. You may be be surprised as to
how quickly the conflict between pension benefits and city/state
fiscal balances has grown.
We expect it will become even more contentious.
12. 11www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
Just a little outside
Not Now
Throughout the ages, folk songs and camp fire stories have spread
around the world about ways to get under the skin of the big bank
economist.
There are several strategies – yet few of them have been successful.
The first one is really only understood inside the investment industry.
In case you haven’t noticed, the big banks and investment dealers
make a tonne of money – a tonne of money.
Within this bucket of money, traders contribute significantly. After all,
they scrape pennies, nickels, dimes and in the case of foreign
exchange – thousands of dollars from each trade. Great work if you
can get it.
Meanwhile, investment bankers have reached near rock star status as
they typically earn millions simply for recommending how a company
should issue shares and debt.
Of course, once shares and debt have been issued, and fees have
been paid, the newly minted stock and bonds are then passed along
to the traders to extract even more fees. Talk about double-dipping.
And then, we have the economists.
They have no clients. They do not recommend trades. Nor do they
scheme any new equity or debt issuance for companies seeking
capital. In fact, in many ways they are a drain on a bank’s resources.
Yes, most dress nicely, many are terrific public speakers, some even
look good on TV, and best of all, practically all of them can dazzle you
with charts, spreadsheets and economic theory only proven in the
academic world.
Make no mistake, the global economy is extremely complicated.
There are many moving parts, making it a multi-dimensional puzzle
that perhaps can only be solved by a select few and unsurprisingly,
none of them are big bank economists. And, there is plenty of data
and evidence to show why.
We’ve previously shown Chart 2 on the next page detailing the
success of professional economists over time.
There are 2 key messages from this study:
1) When it comes to estimating the economic growth rate of the
USA, over the past 45 years, economists have only been correct
15% of the time.
2) Since 1970, there have been 7 recessions in the USA and
professional economists as a group have predicted none of them.
No one is perfect, and no one on earth can claim to never having
made a mistake. But for professional economists to predict none of
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
13. Since 1970, sell-side economists have
predicted 0 of the 7 recessions
And, only have been correct 15.1% of the time
Chart 2: Economists estimates of US GDP
12www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
Source: Ned Davis Research
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
14. 13www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
Now, not later
the recessions is startling to say the least.
Worse still, and despite not contributing directly to the bottom line,
the big bank economist continues to dominate the overall message
sent to the investor masses.
They continue to soak up air time on the telly. Practically every city
and town gushes with excitement whenever a big bank economist
graces them with their presence at any annual dinner or meeting.
And, despite no contribution to bank profit centers, and an
embarrassing track record of never projecting a recession – their
confidence remains high, very high.
Well, until now.
A few months ago, the Federal Reserve Board of Atlanta did the
unthinkable – they created a quantitative model that accurately
predicts America's economic growth.
The “GDP Now” model has taken the investment and economic
industry by storm. Since its release, there have been 2 very clear,
identifying trends:
1) The model’s estimates have differed substantially to that of the
big bank economists
2) The model has been extremely accurate
This is really good news of course. There are numerous ways a better
economic forecast can help everyone. Well, everyone that is except
for the big banks economists. In fact, they are not only displeased
with GDP Now, they are outright angry.
Apparently, GDP Now is the straw that broke the economists back.
During the first quarter of this year, big bank economists forecast the
US to grow at about +1.4%. GDP Now forecast was +0.1%.
Actual growth? +0.2%
Chart 2 (next page) shows estimates from both the big bank
economists and GDP Now for the second quarter of 2015. Once
again, there’s a substantial difference between the two sides with
economists predicting a +3.0% growth rate compared to a +0.8%
estimate from the GDP Now model.
Of course, instead of trying to improve their game by digging into the
details of the GDP Now model, economists are suddenly doing the
very human thing – they are attacking the government entity that is
in charge of calculating the GDP data.
Yes, that’s right. Instead of trying to become better, the economic
community is fighting back by claiming that their estimates are
actually closer to being right. And once GDP is calculated accurately ,
they will be proven correct.
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
15. 14
Chart 2: GDP Now Forecasting Model
www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
16. 15www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
Keep the good, throw out the bad
This is where the story floats off into academic Neverland.
Economists claim the US Bureau of Economic Analysis should start
applying a double seasonal adjustment.
For those who haven’t succumbed to the enthralling world of
economic computations, seasonal adjustments are used to effectively
smooth out fluctuations in data that regularly occurs during certain
times of year.
For example, since it sometimes snows during winter – construction
work is often delayed which has a negative effect on economic
activity during the winter, while a boost during the summer months.
Seasonal adjustments attempts to smooth out the volatility from one
period to another. Note, the singular tense in “seasonal”.
As far as we can tell, double seasonal adjustments will involve
ignoring any bad economic data, and calculating GDP with only good
economic data.
Since the big bank economists never predict recessions, the net effect
will be to bring the reported GDP number up closer to their estimate,
and further away from the number estimated by the computer-
generated GDP Now Model.
We say this tongue in cheek – yet, if all the bad data was removed, it
should in theory create the perfect socialist dream – a complete
erasure of all past and future recessions.
And more importantly – big bank economists may finally begin to
earn their keep.
Oh Canada
With all of the Canadian-based hockey teams eliminated from the
Stanley Cup Playoffs, Canadians have now resorted to watching the
American-based teams battle for their prestigious Cup. Considering
Canadian-born players make up over 70% of the league, the Canadian
flag continues to fly high.
Unfortunately, during the first 3 months of the year, the Canadian
economic flag has been flying at half mast - maybe too many
Canadians were watching hockey instead of spending their loonies.
0.3%
-0.6%
-0.7%
-0.5%
-0.3%
-0.1%
0.2%
0.4%
Estimate by Big Bank Economists Actual GDP
Canada Q1 2015 GDP
+
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
17. 16www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
The first rule of Boy Scouts
During the quarter, Canada’s economy declined -0.6%. And, since we
are talking about economics, it’s only fair to once again highlight the
performance of the Canadian big bank economists.
Although Canadian hockey players dominate their American
counterparts (European & Russian too for that matter), Canadian
economists were equally ineffective as American economists.
Prior to the big announcement of Canada’s GDP, Canada’s big
economists confidently predicted a +0.3% expansion of the great
northern economy.
Once again, the big bank economists were not only significantly off
with their guess, but clearly no one expected a declining economy
either.
Be Prepared
Here at IceCap we are invited to speak at many events – both big and
small. Investors everywhere are very interested in our global market
outlook and how we see the world developing over the near term.
Contact us directly if you’d like to have us speak at an event or
directly to your team.
We often begin by saying our research shows there is a very high
probability of the world seeing a major global recession AND a
surging stock market.
Since the 2 events are widely considered to be mutually exclusive –
we often see pained, and confused looks across the room. And since
the majority of investors’ expectations have been shaped and molded
by our big banks, their economists, and of course recent market
experience – this confusion and skepticism is perfectly logical.
Once you’ve cleansed your mind, and are able to see and think freely,
it’s quite obvious that the entire world is experiencing an economic
slowdown. China and Brazil are slowing. Canada and the USA are
slowing. As too are countries in the European Union.
Analysts can slice and dice the data seven ways to Sunday, yet the
objective conclusion remains the same – negative growth and
slowing growth but no accelerating growth. Despite the hope (there’s
that word again) that things will work their way out, evidence clearly
says otherwise.
Over the last 80 years, every time there’s been trouble in the world
and the economy, it was eventually and inevitably reflected in the
stock market. And in all cases it was justifiably so for one reason and
one reason only – during this period the safe haven investment was
always government bonds.
Think about that last statement – this is the key to understanding
where markets are heading today.
Today, the reason why we expect both a global recession and a
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson
18. 17www.IceCapAssetManagement.com
USD remains our favourite
surging stock market is due to the eventual recognition that the
trouble in the world today is in the government bond market
meaning it will NOT be the traditional safe haven investment.
Once you recognise this unique feature of today’s financial world,
then it becomes easy to understand that as soon as the troubles in
the bond market make the front page headlines – Billions and Billions
of Dollars, Loonies, Pounds, Euros and Yen will be tripping over
themselves to leave the bond market.
And since all money needs a home – the stock market, and the USD
will be the home of choice.
Our Strategy
Over the last few months, practically all markets have nudged down.
Whereas the first couple of months of 2015 gave investors nice
returns, markets have largely come back to where many investors are
now close to flat for the year.
Currencies: The US Dollar weakened somewhat last month and for
non-USD clients, we used this as an opportunity to add further to our
currency strategy by increasing our allocation to US Dollars. This
strategy now equals approximately 25% of all portfolios.
Equities: Emerging market strategies have been carried by the
surge-like strength of China. This move is not sustainable, and we
therefore realized profits and sold our emerging markets position.
Fixed Income: As you know, we fully expect bond markets to really
shake around later this year, and are now preparing for strategic
moves within these strategies.
Commodities: We remain out of gold and commodity markets.
Neither is appealing at this time. We expect one more leg down in
gold and would likely use this as an opportunity to enter that market.
These days we remain on high alert within both stock and bond
markets. The volatility within each is enormous and the possibility of
significant moves in either direction remains high. We continue to
use our momentum-based models for signals in these areas.
As always, we’d be pleased to speak with anyone about our
investment views. We also encourage our readers to share our global
market outlook with those who they think may find it of interest.
Please feel to contact:
Keith Dicker at keithdicker@IceCapAssetManagement.com
John Corney at johncorney@IceCapAssetManagement.com or
Ariz David at arizdavid@IceCapAssetManagement.com
Thank you for sharing your time with us.
July 2015 Elementary my Dear Watson