SlideShare a Scribd company logo
WIKIPEDIA IS NOT (ONLY) AN ENCYCLOPEDIA
PROF. RICHARD ROGERS
WIKIPEDIA IS NOT AN
ENCYCLOPEDIA?
R. Margritte, 1928-29
It is a representation of an encyclopedia
M. Foucault, 1983
It cannot be reduced to an encyclopedia
WIKIPEDIA STUDIES
Wikipedia is compared to Encyclopedia Brittanica. Quality; bias.
Publicity management tool.
As an abnormally vigilant community of free-labourers.
As a bureaucracy and as stigmergy.
As having a relationship with Google.
Wikipedia as object of study
As as 'cultural reference' representing 'national points of view'
WIKIPEDIA STUDIES
>Wikipedia is compared to Encyclopedia Brittanica. Quality; bias.
Publicity management tool.
As an abnormally vigilant community of free-labourers.
As a bureaucracy and as stigmergy.
As having a relationship with Google.
Wikipedia as object of study
As as 'cultural reference' representing 'national points of view'
WIKIPEDIA / BRITANNICA
COMPARISON
Nature conducted a peer review of 42 entries from Wikipedia and the
Encyclopedia Britannica. The results:
Only eight serious errors, such as misinterpretations of important
concepts, were detected in the pairs of articles reviewed, four from
each encyclopaedia. But reviewers also found many factual errors,
omissions or misleading statements: 162 and 123 in Wikipedia and
Britannica, respectively.
Jim Giles, "Internet encyclopedias go head to head," Nature 438, 900-901, 2005.
WIKIPEDIA STUDIES
Wikipedia is compared to Encyclopedia Brittanica. Quality; bias.
>Publicity management tool.
As an abnormally vigilant community of free-labourers.
As a bureaucracy and as stigmergy.
As having a relationship with Google.
Wikipedia as object of study
As 'networked content' co-authored by bots and
as 'cultural reference'
WIKISCANNER - THE
CULTURE OF 'OUTING'
Griffith's WikiScanner FAQ:
_The tool's database contains "34,417,493 anonymous [Wikipedia] edits
dating from February 7th, 2002 to August 4th, 2007."
_Database is constructed "by extracting all anonymous edits from the
publicly available Wikipedia database dump (monthly release)."
_WikiScanner uses ip2location database that has "2,668,095 different
organizations."
WikiScanner - De-anonymizing edits to Wikipedia with database mash-up
WIKIPEDIA STUDIES
Wikipedia is compared to Encyclopedia Brittanica. Quality; bias.
Publicity management tool.
>As an abnormally vigilant community of free-labourers.
>As a bureaucracy and as stigmergy.
As having a relationship with Google.
Wikipedia as object of study
As 'networked content' co-authored by bots and
as 'cultural reference'
WIKIPEDIANS AS VIGILANT,
FREE LABORERS
The editors of Wikipedia are highly vigilant, and able to make
revert, maintain and clean up at great speed.
"I went, I changed, they conquered." - Alex Halavais describing
error insertion experiment (2004)
Jon Udell's Heavy Metal Umlaut movie, when he is amazed that
vandalism was reverted sometimes only seconds after vandal edit
How is it often studied? As abnormally vigilant workers
WIKIPEDIA AS RELATED
TO GOOGLE
The editors of Wikipedia ground the name and existence of subject in
Google results.
95% of Wikipedia articles in top ten results in Google.
(English-language Wikipedia)
Google's knowledge graph makes sue of Wikipedia content, and
supposedly depresses traffic to the onine encyclopedia.
How to characterise Wikipedia's relationship with Google?
WIKIPEDIA AS NETWORKED
CONTENT
The top editors of Wikipedia are bots, followed by humans (with
software that sends alerts).
Capture Wikipedia data, and enquire into the technicity of content.
How dependent is Wikipedia on non-humans?
How else may it be studied? As networked content
WIKIPEDIA AS
CULTURAL REFERENCE
As articles mature, they may express a national as opposed to
neutral point of view. Neutral to whom?
How to have language Wikipedia versions show cultural reference?
Wikipedia as research tool? Studying the politics of memory
WIKIPEDIA AS
CULTURAL REFERENCE
Compare article elements and determine their distinctiveness:
- title
- authors (or editors plus location)
- table of contents
- references
- images
Also features native to Wikipedia:
- location of the anonymous editors (based on IP address)
- templates, revision history and talkpages
Method for the study of Wikipedia as cultural reference
Referenced hosts in the Srebrencia articles per Wikipedia language version, colored
by frequency, and ordered by frequency and by alphabet, 20 December 2010
1 2 3 4 5 6
Serbian Bosnian Dutch Croatian Serbo-Croatian English
un.org un.org un.org un.org un.org un.org
srebrenica.ba srebrenica.ba icty.org srebrenica.ba srebrenica.ba srebrenica.ba
icty.org ic-mp.org groene.nl icty.org
srebrenica-
zepa.ba
icty.org
bosnia.org.uk idc.org.ba vandiepen.com bosnia.org.uk srebrenica.nl bosnia.org.uk
guardian.co.uk srebrenica-zepa.ba books.google.nl guardian.co.uk vladars.net guardian.co.uk
ic-mp.org helsinki.org.yu
dutchbat.luchtmobiel.
nl
icj-cij.org ic-mp.org
icj-cij.org hlc.org.yu dutchbat1.com idc.org.ba icj-cij.org
iwpr.net ogrish.com
emperors-
clothes.com
iwpr.net idc.org.ba
news.bbc.co.uk sense-agency.com nu.nl news.bbc.co.uk iwpr.net
nytimes.com vladars.net ochtenden.nl nytimes.com news.bbc.co.uk
ohr.int dzemat-oberhausen.de volkskrant.nl ohr.int nytimes.com
srebrenica-zepa.ba inzl.unsa.ba vreme.com ohr.int
vreme.com preventgenocide.org balkaninsight.com vreme.com
128.121.186.47
srebrenica-
genocide.blogspot.com
bim.ba 128.121.186.47
b92.net zeneucrnom.org domovina.net b92.net
helsinki.org.yu edition.cnn.com balkaninsight.com
hlc.org.yu europarl.europa.eu bim.ba
news.independent.co.u
k
independent.co.uk domovina.net
ogrish.com newsweek.com edition.cnn.com
reuters.com pbs.org europarl.europa.eu
slobodan-milosevic.org potocarimc.ba groene.nl
Burial of 465 identified Bosniaks,
Potočari, 2007.
Map of the Srebrenica military
operations, made by the U.S. Central
Intelligence Agency, with green
arrow showing the route of the
Bosnian forces.
Map of the location of Srebrenica,
the Republika Srpska,
Bosnia-Herzegovina.
Srebrenica-Potočari Memorial and
Cemetery, Bosnia-Herzegovina.
Grave of a 13-year old Bosniak boy.
Ratko Mladic.
An exhumed body with blindfold
and hands tied behind his back. As of
September 2012, the photo has been
removed from Wikipedia article.
Exhumed grave of victims, 2007.
Podrinje Identification Project's
facility for storing, processing, and
handling exhumed remains..
"UN left 8,000 to die in Bosnia."
Headline in The Independent,
30 October 1995.
Satellite photo of Nova Kasaba
mass grave.
International Criminal Tribunal for
the Former Yugoslavia, Den Haag,
the Netherlands.
Srebrenica Genocide Memorial
Stone at Potočari, with the victim
count of 8,372.
Skull exhumed outside
of Potočari, July 2007.
Wall of names at the Srebrenica
Genocide Memorial.
War-damaged buildings
in Srebrenica.
The Bosniak enclaves of Srebrenica
and Zepa, declared safe areas by the
U.N. in 1993.
DUTCH ENGLISH BOSNIAN CROATIAN SERBIAN
SERBO-
CROATIAN
WIKIPEDIA STUDIES
Wikipedia is compared to Encyclopedia Brittanica. Quality; bias.
Publicity management tool.
As an abnormally vigilant community of free-labourers.
As a bureaucracy and as stigmergy.
As having a relationship with Google.
Wikipedia as object of study
As 'cultural reference' representing 'national points of view'
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Richard Rogers
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Richard Rogers

More Related Content

What's hot

Documenting Ferguson: Building a community digital repository
Documenting Ferguson: Building a community digital repositoryDocumenting Ferguson: Building a community digital repository
Documenting Ferguson: Building a community digital repository
Chris Freeland
 
Curation North Carolina
Curation North CarolinaCuration North Carolina
Curation North Carolina
Joyce Kasman Valenza
 
The Embedded Librarian | las imágenes
The Embedded Librarian | las imágenesThe Embedded Librarian | las imágenes
The Embedded Librarian | las imágenes
biblioteca.etsit
 
The DPLA and NY Heritage for Tech Camp 2014
The DPLA and NY Heritage for Tech Camp 2014The DPLA and NY Heritage for Tech Camp 2014
The DPLA and NY Heritage for Tech Camp 2014
Larry Naukam
 
All Together Now
All Together NowAll Together Now
All Together Nowkburhanna
 
The Digital Public Library of America: An Overview and Working with the Natio...
The Digital Public Library of America: An Overview and Working with the Natio...The Digital Public Library of America: An Overview and Working with the Natio...
The Digital Public Library of America: An Overview and Working with the Natio...
Martin Kalfatovic
 
Helping Genealogists Climb Family Trees June 2008
Helping Genealogists Climb Family Trees June 2008Helping Genealogists Climb Family Trees June 2008
Helping Genealogists Climb Family Trees June 2008
Elise C. Cole
 
Pratt sils knowledge organization spring 2014
Pratt sils knowledge organization spring 2014Pratt sils knowledge organization spring 2014
Pratt sils knowledge organization spring 2014PrattSILS
 
Online Genealogy Intro for Mendon NY Public Library and Historical Society
Online Genealogy Intro for Mendon NY Public Library and Historical SocietyOnline Genealogy Intro for Mendon NY Public Library and Historical Society
Online Genealogy Intro for Mendon NY Public Library and Historical Society
Larry Naukam
 
Readers' advisory 2.0 / Suggestions de lecture 2.0
Readers' advisory 2.0 / Suggestions de lecture 2.0Readers' advisory 2.0 / Suggestions de lecture 2.0
Readers' advisory 2.0 / Suggestions de lecture 2.0
Alexandra Yarrow
 
Pilots & Partnerships: University Academic Computing and University Libraries...
Pilots & Partnerships: University Academic Computing and University Libraries...Pilots & Partnerships: University Academic Computing and University Libraries...
Pilots & Partnerships: University Academic Computing and University Libraries...Chris Freeland
 
Li 804 alphild dick
Li 804 alphild dickLi 804 alphild dick
Li 804 alphild dickAlphild Dick
 
Local Library Presentation @ Computers in Libraries 2008
Local Library Presentation @ Computers in Libraries 2008Local Library Presentation @ Computers in Libraries 2008
Local Library Presentation @ Computers in Libraries 2008Charles Lyons
 
DPLA - an introduction for historians
DPLA  - an introduction for historiansDPLA  - an introduction for historians
DPLA - an introduction for historians
Larry Naukam
 
The Past's Present Future: Emerging Trends in Online Cultural Heritage
The Past's Present Future:  Emerging Trends in Online Cultural HeritageThe Past's Present Future:  Emerging Trends in Online Cultural Heritage
The Past's Present Future: Emerging Trends in Online Cultural Heritage
Richard Urban
 
Knowledge Organization Lis 653 Spring 2017 Class Posters
Knowledge Organization Lis 653 Spring 2017 Class PostersKnowledge Organization Lis 653 Spring 2017 Class Posters
Knowledge Organization Lis 653 Spring 2017 Class Posters
PrattSILS
 
IMLS DCC Progress Update to the Chief Officers of State Library Agencies (COSLA)
IMLS DCC Progress Update to the Chief Officers of State Library Agencies (COSLA)IMLS DCC Progress Update to the Chief Officers of State Library Agencies (COSLA)
IMLS DCC Progress Update to the Chief Officers of State Library Agencies (COSLA)
Richard Urban
 
Digital Public Library of America
Digital Public Library of AmericaDigital Public Library of America
Digital Public Library of America
Larry Naukam
 
Cultural Heritage Information Dashboards
Cultural Heritage Information DashboardsCultural Heritage Information Dashboards
Cultural Heritage Information Dashboards
Richard Urban
 

What's hot (20)

Res
ResRes
Res
 
Documenting Ferguson: Building a community digital repository
Documenting Ferguson: Building a community digital repositoryDocumenting Ferguson: Building a community digital repository
Documenting Ferguson: Building a community digital repository
 
Curation North Carolina
Curation North CarolinaCuration North Carolina
Curation North Carolina
 
The Embedded Librarian | las imágenes
The Embedded Librarian | las imágenesThe Embedded Librarian | las imágenes
The Embedded Librarian | las imágenes
 
The DPLA and NY Heritage for Tech Camp 2014
The DPLA and NY Heritage for Tech Camp 2014The DPLA and NY Heritage for Tech Camp 2014
The DPLA and NY Heritage for Tech Camp 2014
 
All Together Now
All Together NowAll Together Now
All Together Now
 
The Digital Public Library of America: An Overview and Working with the Natio...
The Digital Public Library of America: An Overview and Working with the Natio...The Digital Public Library of America: An Overview and Working with the Natio...
The Digital Public Library of America: An Overview and Working with the Natio...
 
Helping Genealogists Climb Family Trees June 2008
Helping Genealogists Climb Family Trees June 2008Helping Genealogists Climb Family Trees June 2008
Helping Genealogists Climb Family Trees June 2008
 
Pratt sils knowledge organization spring 2014
Pratt sils knowledge organization spring 2014Pratt sils knowledge organization spring 2014
Pratt sils knowledge organization spring 2014
 
Online Genealogy Intro for Mendon NY Public Library and Historical Society
Online Genealogy Intro for Mendon NY Public Library and Historical SocietyOnline Genealogy Intro for Mendon NY Public Library and Historical Society
Online Genealogy Intro for Mendon NY Public Library and Historical Society
 
Readers' advisory 2.0 / Suggestions de lecture 2.0
Readers' advisory 2.0 / Suggestions de lecture 2.0Readers' advisory 2.0 / Suggestions de lecture 2.0
Readers' advisory 2.0 / Suggestions de lecture 2.0
 
Pilots & Partnerships: University Academic Computing and University Libraries...
Pilots & Partnerships: University Academic Computing and University Libraries...Pilots & Partnerships: University Academic Computing and University Libraries...
Pilots & Partnerships: University Academic Computing and University Libraries...
 
Li 804 alphild dick
Li 804 alphild dickLi 804 alphild dick
Li 804 alphild dick
 
Local Library Presentation @ Computers in Libraries 2008
Local Library Presentation @ Computers in Libraries 2008Local Library Presentation @ Computers in Libraries 2008
Local Library Presentation @ Computers in Libraries 2008
 
DPLA - an introduction for historians
DPLA  - an introduction for historiansDPLA  - an introduction for historians
DPLA - an introduction for historians
 
The Past's Present Future: Emerging Trends in Online Cultural Heritage
The Past's Present Future:  Emerging Trends in Online Cultural HeritageThe Past's Present Future:  Emerging Trends in Online Cultural Heritage
The Past's Present Future: Emerging Trends in Online Cultural Heritage
 
Knowledge Organization Lis 653 Spring 2017 Class Posters
Knowledge Organization Lis 653 Spring 2017 Class PostersKnowledge Organization Lis 653 Spring 2017 Class Posters
Knowledge Organization Lis 653 Spring 2017 Class Posters
 
IMLS DCC Progress Update to the Chief Officers of State Library Agencies (COSLA)
IMLS DCC Progress Update to the Chief Officers of State Library Agencies (COSLA)IMLS DCC Progress Update to the Chief Officers of State Library Agencies (COSLA)
IMLS DCC Progress Update to the Chief Officers of State Library Agencies (COSLA)
 
Digital Public Library of America
Digital Public Library of AmericaDigital Public Library of America
Digital Public Library of America
 
Cultural Heritage Information Dashboards
Cultural Heritage Information DashboardsCultural Heritage Information Dashboards
Cultural Heritage Information Dashboards
 

Similar to KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Richard Rogers

Wikipedia and Libraries
Wikipedia and LibrariesWikipedia and Libraries
Wikipedia and Libraries
Bob Kosovsky
 
Working with Wikipedia: Leveraging the Online Encyclopedia to Serve Your Patr...
Working with Wikipedia: Leveraging the Online Encyclopedia to Serve Your Patr...Working with Wikipedia: Leveraging the Online Encyclopedia to Serve Your Patr...
Working with Wikipedia: Leveraging the Online Encyclopedia to Serve Your Patr...
Don Boozer
 
Repurposing Wikipedia: Wikipedia as data set and analytical device
Repurposing Wikipedia: Wikipedia as data set and analytical deviceRepurposing Wikipedia: Wikipedia as data set and analytical device
Repurposing Wikipedia: Wikipedia as data set and analytical device
Digital Methods Initiative
 
INVENiT II project presentation
INVENiT II project presentationINVENiT II project presentation
INVENiT II project presentation
bucurcristina
 
Leveraging Wikipedia and Libraries as Agents of Inclusion and Visibility for ...
Leveraging Wikipedia and Libraries as Agents of Inclusion and Visibility for ...Leveraging Wikipedia and Libraries as Agents of Inclusion and Visibility for ...
Leveraging Wikipedia and Libraries as Agents of Inclusion and Visibility for ...
Michael David MILLER
 
We are not in a post facts world
We are not in a post facts worldWe are not in a post facts world
We are not in a post facts world
Lorna Campbell
 
Blogging Archaeology: creating an Open Access source for knowledge
Blogging Archaeology: creating an Open Access source for knowledgeBlogging Archaeology: creating an Open Access source for knowledge
Blogging Archaeology: creating an Open Access source for knowledge
Vasilka Dimitrovska
 
BadgerLink
BadgerLinkBadgerLink
BadgerLink
crbooth
 
Closing the Gender Gap on Wikimedia
Closing the Gender Gap on WikimediaClosing the Gender Gap on Wikimedia
Closing the Gender Gap on Wikimedia
John Lubbock
 
Free for All: Wikipedia, Wikimedia, and the Future of History
Free for All: Wikipedia, Wikimedia, and the Future of HistoryFree for All: Wikipedia, Wikimedia, and the Future of History
Free for All: Wikipedia, Wikimedia, and the Future of History
Andrew Lih
 
The Power Of The User
The Power Of The UserThe Power Of The User
The Power Of The User
Patrick Danowski
 
Marking territory: Exerting Control over the Shape of Scientific Knowledge i...
Marking territory: Exerting Control over the Shape of Scientific  Knowledge i...Marking territory: Exerting Control over the Shape of Scientific  Knowledge i...
Marking territory: Exerting Control over the Shape of Scientific Knowledge i...
Stephanie Steinhardt
 
Encyclopedias--Powerpoint 2003
Encyclopedias--Powerpoint 2003Encyclopedias--Powerpoint 2003
Encyclopedias--Powerpoint 2003Johan Koren
 
Accessibility of the American Archive of Public Broadcasting in Academic Libr...
Accessibility of the American Archive of Public Broadcasting in Academic Libr...Accessibility of the American Archive of Public Broadcasting in Academic Libr...
Accessibility of the American Archive of Public Broadcasting in Academic Libr...
WGBH Media Library and Archives
 
Biodiversity Heritage Library: Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
Biodiversity Heritage Library: Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of LifeBiodiversity Heritage Library: Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
Biodiversity Heritage Library: Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
Martin Kalfatovic
 
The Biodiversity Heritage Library: A Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
The Biodiversity Heritage Library: A Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of LifeThe Biodiversity Heritage Library: A Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
The Biodiversity Heritage Library: A Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
Martin Kalfatovic
 
SFScon19 - Cristian Cenci Catrin Vimercati - Territorial development through ...
SFScon19 - Cristian Cenci Catrin Vimercati - Territorial development through ...SFScon19 - Cristian Cenci Catrin Vimercati - Territorial development through ...
SFScon19 - Cristian Cenci Catrin Vimercati - Territorial development through ...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
Judaica europeana dovwinerjudaicalibrarians
Judaica europeana dovwinerjudaicalibrariansJudaica europeana dovwinerjudaicalibrarians
Judaica europeana dovwinerjudaicalibrariansDov Winer
 
Boston Library Consortium Webinar Part 1, Accessibility of AAPB for Academic ...
Boston Library Consortium Webinar Part 1, Accessibility of AAPB for Academic ...Boston Library Consortium Webinar Part 1, Accessibility of AAPB for Academic ...
Boston Library Consortium Webinar Part 1, Accessibility of AAPB for Academic ...
Ryn Marchese
 

Similar to KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Richard Rogers (20)

Wikipedia and Libraries
Wikipedia and LibrariesWikipedia and Libraries
Wikipedia and Libraries
 
Working with Wikipedia: Leveraging the Online Encyclopedia to Serve Your Patr...
Working with Wikipedia: Leveraging the Online Encyclopedia to Serve Your Patr...Working with Wikipedia: Leveraging the Online Encyclopedia to Serve Your Patr...
Working with Wikipedia: Leveraging the Online Encyclopedia to Serve Your Patr...
 
Repurposing Wikipedia: Wikipedia as data set and analytical device
Repurposing Wikipedia: Wikipedia as data set and analytical deviceRepurposing Wikipedia: Wikipedia as data set and analytical device
Repurposing Wikipedia: Wikipedia as data set and analytical device
 
INVENiT II project presentation
INVENiT II project presentationINVENiT II project presentation
INVENiT II project presentation
 
Leveraging Wikipedia and Libraries as Agents of Inclusion and Visibility for ...
Leveraging Wikipedia and Libraries as Agents of Inclusion and Visibility for ...Leveraging Wikipedia and Libraries as Agents of Inclusion and Visibility for ...
Leveraging Wikipedia and Libraries as Agents of Inclusion and Visibility for ...
 
We are not in a post facts world
We are not in a post facts worldWe are not in a post facts world
We are not in a post facts world
 
Blogging Archaeology: creating an Open Access source for knowledge
Blogging Archaeology: creating an Open Access source for knowledgeBlogging Archaeology: creating an Open Access source for knowledge
Blogging Archaeology: creating an Open Access source for knowledge
 
BadgerLink
BadgerLinkBadgerLink
BadgerLink
 
Closing the Gender Gap on Wikimedia
Closing the Gender Gap on WikimediaClosing the Gender Gap on Wikimedia
Closing the Gender Gap on Wikimedia
 
Wikipedia
WikipediaWikipedia
Wikipedia
 
Free for All: Wikipedia, Wikimedia, and the Future of History
Free for All: Wikipedia, Wikimedia, and the Future of HistoryFree for All: Wikipedia, Wikimedia, and the Future of History
Free for All: Wikipedia, Wikimedia, and the Future of History
 
The Power Of The User
The Power Of The UserThe Power Of The User
The Power Of The User
 
Marking territory: Exerting Control over the Shape of Scientific Knowledge i...
Marking territory: Exerting Control over the Shape of Scientific  Knowledge i...Marking territory: Exerting Control over the Shape of Scientific  Knowledge i...
Marking territory: Exerting Control over the Shape of Scientific Knowledge i...
 
Encyclopedias--Powerpoint 2003
Encyclopedias--Powerpoint 2003Encyclopedias--Powerpoint 2003
Encyclopedias--Powerpoint 2003
 
Accessibility of the American Archive of Public Broadcasting in Academic Libr...
Accessibility of the American Archive of Public Broadcasting in Academic Libr...Accessibility of the American Archive of Public Broadcasting in Academic Libr...
Accessibility of the American Archive of Public Broadcasting in Academic Libr...
 
Biodiversity Heritage Library: Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
Biodiversity Heritage Library: Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of LifeBiodiversity Heritage Library: Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
Biodiversity Heritage Library: Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
 
The Biodiversity Heritage Library: A Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
The Biodiversity Heritage Library: A Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of LifeThe Biodiversity Heritage Library: A Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
The Biodiversity Heritage Library: A Cornerstone of the Encyclopedia of Life
 
SFScon19 - Cristian Cenci Catrin Vimercati - Territorial development through ...
SFScon19 - Cristian Cenci Catrin Vimercati - Territorial development through ...SFScon19 - Cristian Cenci Catrin Vimercati - Territorial development through ...
SFScon19 - Cristian Cenci Catrin Vimercati - Territorial development through ...
 
Judaica europeana dovwinerjudaicalibrarians
Judaica europeana dovwinerjudaicalibrariansJudaica europeana dovwinerjudaicalibrarians
Judaica europeana dovwinerjudaicalibrarians
 
Boston Library Consortium Webinar Part 1, Accessibility of AAPB for Academic ...
Boston Library Consortium Webinar Part 1, Accessibility of AAPB for Academic ...Boston Library Consortium Webinar Part 1, Accessibility of AAPB for Academic ...
Boston Library Consortium Webinar Part 1, Accessibility of AAPB for Academic ...
 

More from marjobakker

KNVI O&O middag 2017 presentatie Lisa Kuitert
KNVI O&O middag 2017 presentatie Lisa KuitertKNVI O&O middag 2017 presentatie Lisa Kuitert
KNVI O&O middag 2017 presentatie Lisa Kuitert
marjobakker
 
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Wilma Goossen
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Wilma GoossenKNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Wilma Goossen
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Wilma Goossen
marjobakker
 
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Jan-Maarten Pauw
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Jan-Maarten PauwKNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Jan-Maarten Pauw
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Jan-Maarten Pauw
marjobakker
 
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - stellingen
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - stellingenKNVI O&O middag 2017 - stellingen
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - stellingen
marjobakker
 
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Coen Wilders
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Coen WildersKNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Coen Wilders
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Coen Wilders
marjobakker
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - Programma
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - Programma KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - Programma
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - Programma
marjobakker
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Sandra Rientjes
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Sandra RientjesKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Sandra Rientjes
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Sandra Rientjes
marjobakker
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Tim de Haan
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Tim de HaanKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Tim de Haan
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Tim de Haan
marjobakker
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Olaf Janssen
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Olaf JanssenKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Olaf Janssen
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Olaf Janssen
marjobakker
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Maarten Brinkerink
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Maarten BrinkerinkKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Maarten Brinkerink
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Maarten Brinkerink
marjobakker
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Jos Damen
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Jos DamenKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Jos Damen
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Jos Damen
marjobakker
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Esther Doornbusch
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Esther DoornbuschKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Esther Doornbusch
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Esther Doornbusch
marjobakker
 

More from marjobakker (12)

KNVI O&O middag 2017 presentatie Lisa Kuitert
KNVI O&O middag 2017 presentatie Lisa KuitertKNVI O&O middag 2017 presentatie Lisa Kuitert
KNVI O&O middag 2017 presentatie Lisa Kuitert
 
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Wilma Goossen
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Wilma GoossenKNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Wilma Goossen
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Wilma Goossen
 
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Jan-Maarten Pauw
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Jan-Maarten PauwKNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Jan-Maarten Pauw
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Jan-Maarten Pauw
 
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - stellingen
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - stellingenKNVI O&O middag 2017 - stellingen
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - stellingen
 
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Coen Wilders
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Coen WildersKNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Coen Wilders
KNVI O&O middag 2017 - presentatie Coen Wilders
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - Programma
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - Programma KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - Programma
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - Programma
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Sandra Rientjes
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Sandra RientjesKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Sandra Rientjes
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Sandra Rientjes
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Tim de Haan
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Tim de HaanKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Tim de Haan
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Tim de Haan
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Olaf Janssen
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Olaf JanssenKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Olaf Janssen
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Olaf Janssen
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Maarten Brinkerink
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Maarten BrinkerinkKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Maarten Brinkerink
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Maarten Brinkerink
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Jos Damen
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Jos DamenKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Jos Damen
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Jos Damen
 
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Esther Doornbusch
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Esther DoornbuschKNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Esther Doornbusch
KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Esther Doornbusch
 

Recently uploaded

Acorn Recovery: Restore IT infra within minutes
Acorn Recovery: Restore IT infra within minutesAcorn Recovery: Restore IT infra within minutes
Acorn Recovery: Restore IT infra within minutes
IP ServerOne
 
Announcement of 18th IEEE International Conference on Software Testing, Verif...
Announcement of 18th IEEE International Conference on Software Testing, Verif...Announcement of 18th IEEE International Conference on Software Testing, Verif...
Announcement of 18th IEEE International Conference on Software Testing, Verif...
Sebastiano Panichella
 
Competition and Regulation in Professional Services – KLEINER – June 2024 OEC...
Competition and Regulation in Professional Services – KLEINER – June 2024 OEC...Competition and Regulation in Professional Services – KLEINER – June 2024 OEC...
Competition and Regulation in Professional Services – KLEINER – June 2024 OEC...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
0x01 - Newton's Third Law: Static vs. Dynamic Abusers
0x01 - Newton's Third Law:  Static vs. Dynamic Abusers0x01 - Newton's Third Law:  Static vs. Dynamic Abusers
0x01 - Newton's Third Law: Static vs. Dynamic Abusers
OWASP Beja
 
Obesity causes and management and associated medical conditions
Obesity causes and management and associated medical conditionsObesity causes and management and associated medical conditions
Obesity causes and management and associated medical conditions
Faculty of Medicine And Health Sciences
 
Getting started with Amazon Bedrock Studio and Control Tower
Getting started with Amazon Bedrock Studio and Control TowerGetting started with Amazon Bedrock Studio and Control Tower
Getting started with Amazon Bedrock Studio and Control Tower
Vladimir Samoylov
 
Eureka, I found it! - Special Libraries Association 2021 Presentation
Eureka, I found it! - Special Libraries Association 2021 PresentationEureka, I found it! - Special Libraries Association 2021 Presentation
Eureka, I found it! - Special Libraries Association 2021 Presentation
Access Innovations, Inc.
 
Sharpen existing tools or get a new toolbox? Contemporary cluster initiatives...
Sharpen existing tools or get a new toolbox? Contemporary cluster initiatives...Sharpen existing tools or get a new toolbox? Contemporary cluster initiatives...
Sharpen existing tools or get a new toolbox? Contemporary cluster initiatives...
Orkestra
 
Bonzo subscription_hjjjjjjjj5hhhhhhh_2024.pdf
Bonzo subscription_hjjjjjjjj5hhhhhhh_2024.pdfBonzo subscription_hjjjjjjjj5hhhhhhh_2024.pdf
Bonzo subscription_hjjjjjjjj5hhhhhhh_2024.pdf
khadija278284
 
Bitcoin Lightning wallet and tic-tac-toe game XOXO
Bitcoin Lightning wallet and tic-tac-toe game XOXOBitcoin Lightning wallet and tic-tac-toe game XOXO
Bitcoin Lightning wallet and tic-tac-toe game XOXO
Matjaž Lipuš
 
Doctoral Symposium at the 17th IEEE International Conference on Software Test...
Doctoral Symposium at the 17th IEEE International Conference on Software Test...Doctoral Symposium at the 17th IEEE International Conference on Software Test...
Doctoral Symposium at the 17th IEEE International Conference on Software Test...
Sebastiano Panichella
 
International Workshop on Artificial Intelligence in Software Testing
International Workshop on Artificial Intelligence in Software TestingInternational Workshop on Artificial Intelligence in Software Testing
International Workshop on Artificial Intelligence in Software Testing
Sebastiano Panichella
 
somanykidsbutsofewfathers-140705000023-phpapp02.pptx
somanykidsbutsofewfathers-140705000023-phpapp02.pptxsomanykidsbutsofewfathers-140705000023-phpapp02.pptx
somanykidsbutsofewfathers-140705000023-phpapp02.pptx
Howard Spence
 

Recently uploaded (13)

Acorn Recovery: Restore IT infra within minutes
Acorn Recovery: Restore IT infra within minutesAcorn Recovery: Restore IT infra within minutes
Acorn Recovery: Restore IT infra within minutes
 
Announcement of 18th IEEE International Conference on Software Testing, Verif...
Announcement of 18th IEEE International Conference on Software Testing, Verif...Announcement of 18th IEEE International Conference on Software Testing, Verif...
Announcement of 18th IEEE International Conference on Software Testing, Verif...
 
Competition and Regulation in Professional Services – KLEINER – June 2024 OEC...
Competition and Regulation in Professional Services – KLEINER – June 2024 OEC...Competition and Regulation in Professional Services – KLEINER – June 2024 OEC...
Competition and Regulation in Professional Services – KLEINER – June 2024 OEC...
 
0x01 - Newton's Third Law: Static vs. Dynamic Abusers
0x01 - Newton's Third Law:  Static vs. Dynamic Abusers0x01 - Newton's Third Law:  Static vs. Dynamic Abusers
0x01 - Newton's Third Law: Static vs. Dynamic Abusers
 
Obesity causes and management and associated medical conditions
Obesity causes and management and associated medical conditionsObesity causes and management and associated medical conditions
Obesity causes and management and associated medical conditions
 
Getting started with Amazon Bedrock Studio and Control Tower
Getting started with Amazon Bedrock Studio and Control TowerGetting started with Amazon Bedrock Studio and Control Tower
Getting started with Amazon Bedrock Studio and Control Tower
 
Eureka, I found it! - Special Libraries Association 2021 Presentation
Eureka, I found it! - Special Libraries Association 2021 PresentationEureka, I found it! - Special Libraries Association 2021 Presentation
Eureka, I found it! - Special Libraries Association 2021 Presentation
 
Sharpen existing tools or get a new toolbox? Contemporary cluster initiatives...
Sharpen existing tools or get a new toolbox? Contemporary cluster initiatives...Sharpen existing tools or get a new toolbox? Contemporary cluster initiatives...
Sharpen existing tools or get a new toolbox? Contemporary cluster initiatives...
 
Bonzo subscription_hjjjjjjjj5hhhhhhh_2024.pdf
Bonzo subscription_hjjjjjjjj5hhhhhhh_2024.pdfBonzo subscription_hjjjjjjjj5hhhhhhh_2024.pdf
Bonzo subscription_hjjjjjjjj5hhhhhhh_2024.pdf
 
Bitcoin Lightning wallet and tic-tac-toe game XOXO
Bitcoin Lightning wallet and tic-tac-toe game XOXOBitcoin Lightning wallet and tic-tac-toe game XOXO
Bitcoin Lightning wallet and tic-tac-toe game XOXO
 
Doctoral Symposium at the 17th IEEE International Conference on Software Test...
Doctoral Symposium at the 17th IEEE International Conference on Software Test...Doctoral Symposium at the 17th IEEE International Conference on Software Test...
Doctoral Symposium at the 17th IEEE International Conference on Software Test...
 
International Workshop on Artificial Intelligence in Software Testing
International Workshop on Artificial Intelligence in Software TestingInternational Workshop on Artificial Intelligence in Software Testing
International Workshop on Artificial Intelligence in Software Testing
 
somanykidsbutsofewfathers-140705000023-phpapp02.pptx
somanykidsbutsofewfathers-140705000023-phpapp02.pptxsomanykidsbutsofewfathers-140705000023-phpapp02.pptx
somanykidsbutsofewfathers-140705000023-phpapp02.pptx
 

KNVI-IP inspiratiemiddag over Wikipedia - presentatie Richard Rogers

  • 1. WIKIPEDIA IS NOT (ONLY) AN ENCYCLOPEDIA PROF. RICHARD ROGERS
  • 2. WIKIPEDIA IS NOT AN ENCYCLOPEDIA? R. Margritte, 1928-29 It is a representation of an encyclopedia M. Foucault, 1983 It cannot be reduced to an encyclopedia
  • 3. WIKIPEDIA STUDIES Wikipedia is compared to Encyclopedia Brittanica. Quality; bias. Publicity management tool. As an abnormally vigilant community of free-labourers. As a bureaucracy and as stigmergy. As having a relationship with Google. Wikipedia as object of study As as 'cultural reference' representing 'national points of view'
  • 4. WIKIPEDIA STUDIES >Wikipedia is compared to Encyclopedia Brittanica. Quality; bias. Publicity management tool. As an abnormally vigilant community of free-labourers. As a bureaucracy and as stigmergy. As having a relationship with Google. Wikipedia as object of study As as 'cultural reference' representing 'national points of view'
  • 5. WIKIPEDIA / BRITANNICA COMPARISON Nature conducted a peer review of 42 entries from Wikipedia and the Encyclopedia Britannica. The results: Only eight serious errors, such as misinterpretations of important concepts, were detected in the pairs of articles reviewed, four from each encyclopaedia. But reviewers also found many factual errors, omissions or misleading statements: 162 and 123 in Wikipedia and Britannica, respectively. Jim Giles, "Internet encyclopedias go head to head," Nature 438, 900-901, 2005.
  • 6.
  • 7. WIKIPEDIA STUDIES Wikipedia is compared to Encyclopedia Brittanica. Quality; bias. >Publicity management tool. As an abnormally vigilant community of free-labourers. As a bureaucracy and as stigmergy. As having a relationship with Google. Wikipedia as object of study As 'networked content' co-authored by bots and as 'cultural reference'
  • 8. WIKISCANNER - THE CULTURE OF 'OUTING' Griffith's WikiScanner FAQ: _The tool's database contains "34,417,493 anonymous [Wikipedia] edits dating from February 7th, 2002 to August 4th, 2007." _Database is constructed "by extracting all anonymous edits from the publicly available Wikipedia database dump (monthly release)." _WikiScanner uses ip2location database that has "2,668,095 different organizations." WikiScanner - De-anonymizing edits to Wikipedia with database mash-up
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11. WIKIPEDIA STUDIES Wikipedia is compared to Encyclopedia Brittanica. Quality; bias. Publicity management tool. >As an abnormally vigilant community of free-labourers. >As a bureaucracy and as stigmergy. As having a relationship with Google. Wikipedia as object of study As 'networked content' co-authored by bots and as 'cultural reference'
  • 12. WIKIPEDIANS AS VIGILANT, FREE LABORERS The editors of Wikipedia are highly vigilant, and able to make revert, maintain and clean up at great speed. "I went, I changed, they conquered." - Alex Halavais describing error insertion experiment (2004) Jon Udell's Heavy Metal Umlaut movie, when he is amazed that vandalism was reverted sometimes only seconds after vandal edit How is it often studied? As abnormally vigilant workers
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17. WIKIPEDIA AS RELATED TO GOOGLE The editors of Wikipedia ground the name and existence of subject in Google results. 95% of Wikipedia articles in top ten results in Google. (English-language Wikipedia) Google's knowledge graph makes sue of Wikipedia content, and supposedly depresses traffic to the onine encyclopedia. How to characterise Wikipedia's relationship with Google?
  • 18.
  • 19. WIKIPEDIA AS NETWORKED CONTENT The top editors of Wikipedia are bots, followed by humans (with software that sends alerts). Capture Wikipedia data, and enquire into the technicity of content. How dependent is Wikipedia on non-humans? How else may it be studied? As networked content
  • 20.
  • 21. WIKIPEDIA AS CULTURAL REFERENCE As articles mature, they may express a national as opposed to neutral point of view. Neutral to whom? How to have language Wikipedia versions show cultural reference? Wikipedia as research tool? Studying the politics of memory
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26. WIKIPEDIA AS CULTURAL REFERENCE Compare article elements and determine their distinctiveness: - title - authors (or editors plus location) - table of contents - references - images Also features native to Wikipedia: - location of the anonymous editors (based on IP address) - templates, revision history and talkpages Method for the study of Wikipedia as cultural reference
  • 27.
  • 28. Referenced hosts in the Srebrencia articles per Wikipedia language version, colored by frequency, and ordered by frequency and by alphabet, 20 December 2010 1 2 3 4 5 6 Serbian Bosnian Dutch Croatian Serbo-Croatian English un.org un.org un.org un.org un.org un.org srebrenica.ba srebrenica.ba icty.org srebrenica.ba srebrenica.ba srebrenica.ba icty.org ic-mp.org groene.nl icty.org srebrenica- zepa.ba icty.org bosnia.org.uk idc.org.ba vandiepen.com bosnia.org.uk srebrenica.nl bosnia.org.uk guardian.co.uk srebrenica-zepa.ba books.google.nl guardian.co.uk vladars.net guardian.co.uk ic-mp.org helsinki.org.yu dutchbat.luchtmobiel. nl icj-cij.org ic-mp.org icj-cij.org hlc.org.yu dutchbat1.com idc.org.ba icj-cij.org iwpr.net ogrish.com emperors- clothes.com iwpr.net idc.org.ba news.bbc.co.uk sense-agency.com nu.nl news.bbc.co.uk iwpr.net nytimes.com vladars.net ochtenden.nl nytimes.com news.bbc.co.uk ohr.int dzemat-oberhausen.de volkskrant.nl ohr.int nytimes.com srebrenica-zepa.ba inzl.unsa.ba vreme.com ohr.int vreme.com preventgenocide.org balkaninsight.com vreme.com 128.121.186.47 srebrenica- genocide.blogspot.com bim.ba 128.121.186.47 b92.net zeneucrnom.org domovina.net b92.net helsinki.org.yu edition.cnn.com balkaninsight.com hlc.org.yu europarl.europa.eu bim.ba news.independent.co.u k independent.co.uk domovina.net ogrish.com newsweek.com edition.cnn.com reuters.com pbs.org europarl.europa.eu slobodan-milosevic.org potocarimc.ba groene.nl
  • 29. Burial of 465 identified Bosniaks, Potočari, 2007. Map of the Srebrenica military operations, made by the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency, with green arrow showing the route of the Bosnian forces. Map of the location of Srebrenica, the Republika Srpska, Bosnia-Herzegovina. Srebrenica-Potočari Memorial and Cemetery, Bosnia-Herzegovina. Grave of a 13-year old Bosniak boy. Ratko Mladic. An exhumed body with blindfold and hands tied behind his back. As of September 2012, the photo has been removed from Wikipedia article. Exhumed grave of victims, 2007. Podrinje Identification Project's facility for storing, processing, and handling exhumed remains.. "UN left 8,000 to die in Bosnia." Headline in The Independent, 30 October 1995. Satellite photo of Nova Kasaba mass grave. International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, Den Haag, the Netherlands. Srebrenica Genocide Memorial Stone at Potočari, with the victim count of 8,372. Skull exhumed outside of Potočari, July 2007. Wall of names at the Srebrenica Genocide Memorial. War-damaged buildings in Srebrenica. The Bosniak enclaves of Srebrenica and Zepa, declared safe areas by the U.N. in 1993. DUTCH ENGLISH BOSNIAN CROATIAN SERBIAN SERBO- CROATIAN
  • 30.
  • 31. WIKIPEDIA STUDIES Wikipedia is compared to Encyclopedia Brittanica. Quality; bias. Publicity management tool. As an abnormally vigilant community of free-labourers. As a bureaucracy and as stigmergy. As having a relationship with Google. Wikipedia as object of study As 'cultural reference' representing 'national points of view'