Nicki L Davis, PhD nickinmr@gmail.com 
STC Berkeley 
9 July 2014
“Nobody should have to go through this to get their work done!”
“Nobody should have to go through this to get their work done!”
• 
Project initiation 
• 
Content analysis 
• 
Writer training and pilot 
• 
Content conversion 
• 
Lessons learned 
• 
Q&A
Device proliferation 
Content silos 
• 
Duplication of effort 
• 
Content lacked standardization and consistency 
• 
Individual stakeholders had only a limited grasp of the big picture
• 
Beth Fryer, Timothy Martin, Dan Claessens 
• 
Faith Weber, Doug O’Neill
• 
Evaluate tools (CMS and authoring tools) 
• 
Choose vendors for tools and other services 
• 
Determine where we needed outside help 
• 
Calculate costs 
• 
Negotiate with vendors 
• 
Submit proposal and get management approval 
• 
Manage training and rollout to writing team
Partner Report Card 
Partner 
Activity 
Mark 
Analyze content 
Train writers in DITA 
Train writers in XML and CMS tools 
Assist with information model (pilot) 
Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) 
Create publication scripts 
Create conversion scripts 
Clean up migrated content
Problem 
Design Goals 
People want Google, we delivered books 
• 
Put all user documentation in one place 
• 
Provide navigational context 
• 
Provide versioning 
Internal users created overlapping content; volume not maintainable 
• 
Technical documentation deliverables must be fully searchable with Technical Support external website. 
• 
Establish clarity of ownership (governance) 
SMEs frustrated by overlapping content and glacial pace of review/correction cycle 
• 
Allow SMEs to comment on topics, and have that feedback delivered directly to the writer in charge 
No information on which pages (out of 40,000) are viewed most often 
• 
Provide analytics to prioritize work on content
Partner Report Card 
Partner 
Activity 
Mark 
1 
Analyze content 
A+ 
Train writers in DITA 
Train writers in XML and CMS tools 
Assist with information model (pilot) 
Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) 
Create publication scripts 
Create conversion scripts 
Clean up migrated content
Our existing CMS did not meet our requirements. 
Core team found two CMS vendors whose systems did meet our requirements. 
Both systems required Darwin Information Typing Architecture (DITA). 
Writing team evaluated each system for one week in mid-2010.
Books on DITA 
1-week training class in DITA 
3-day training class on the CMS 
6-month pilot to develop information model and implement CMS
One partner (#2) helped trained writers in DITA and helped with the information model 
Individual writers conducted research projects in areas of interest (context-sensitive help, reuse strategy, cross-references, and so on.) 
CMS vendor (#3) helped with training and implementation of the CMS 
Writers devoted about 20% of their time to the pilot 
Writing team met weekly in conference call with partners
Partner Report Card 
Partner 
Activity 
Mark 
1 
Analyze content 
A+ 
2 
Train writers in DITA 
A+ 
3 
Train writers in XML and CMS tools 
A- 
2 
Assist with information model (pilot) 
A- 
3 
Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) 
A+ 
Create publication scripts 
Create conversion scripts 
Clean up migrated content
Mark topics with DITA information type (task, concept, reference) in original CMS 
Inventory shared topics in original CMS 
Inventory shared graphics in original CMS 
Inventory instances of “conrefs” in original CMS
Old CMS 
Export 
Import to new CMS 
DITA 
Convert 
XML 
Staging 
Server 
Production Server 
Output 
Publish 
Transfer 
Clean up
Some cleanup is always necessary 
The less “intelligent” the original content, the more manual cleanup will be necessary
PDF 
Smartphone 
1. 
Click the Alert button. 
The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 
2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. 
The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box. 
Click the Alert button. 
On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. 
The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.
Non-semantic (unintelligent) 
Semantic (intelligent) 
1. 
Click the Alert button. 
The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 
2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. 
The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box. 
1. 
Click the Alert button. 
The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 
2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. 
The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.
Non-semantic (unintelligent) 
Semantic (intelligent) 
<steps> 
<step><cmd>Click the Alert button </cmd> 
<stepresult>The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. </stepresult> 
</step> 
<step><cmd>On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. </cmd> 
<info>The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.</info> 
</step> 
</steps>
Non-semantic (unintelligent) 
Semantic (intelligent) 
<ol> 
<li>Click the Alert button. 
<p>The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 
<p> 
</li> 
<li>On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. 
<p>The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box</p> 
</li> 
</ol> 
<steps> 
<step><cmd>Click the Alert button </cmd> 
<stepresult>The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. </stepresult> 
</step> 
<step><cmd>On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. </cmd> 
<info>The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.</info> 
</step> 
</steps>
Non-semantic (unintelligent) 
Semantic (intelligent) 
<p> to ?? 
<ol> 
<li>Click the Alert button. 
<p>The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 
<p> 
</li> 
<li>On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. 
<p>The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box</p> 
</li> 
</ol> 
<steps> 
<step><cmd>Click the Alert button </cmd> 
<stepresult>The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. </stepresult> 
</step> 
<step><cmd>On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. </cmd> 
<info>The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.</info> 
</step> 
</steps> 
<p> to ??
Non-semantic (unintelligent) 
Semantic (intelligent) 
1. 
Click the Alert button. 
The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 
2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. 
The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box. 
1. 
Click the Alert button. 
The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 
2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. 
The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.
Partner Report Card 
Partner 
Activity 
Mark 
1 
Analyze content 
A+ 
2 
Train writers in DITA 
A+ 
3 
Train writers in XML and CMS tools 
A- 
2 
Assist with information model (pilot) 
A- 
3 
Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) 
A+ 
Create publication scripts 
Create conversion scripts 
4 
Clean up migrated content 
A+
Original 
As migrated 
1. 
Click the Alert button. 
The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 
2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. 
The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box. 
1. 
Click the Alert button. The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 
2. 
The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 
3. 
On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box. 
4. 
The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.
Partner Report Card 
Partner 
Activity 
Mark 
1 
Analyze content 
A+ 
2 
Train writers in DITA 
A+ 
3 
Train writers in XML and CMS tools 
A- 
2 
Assist with information model (pilot) 
A- 
3 
Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) 
A+ 
Create publication scripts 
D 
Create conversion scripts 
F 
4 
Clean up migrated content 
A+
Partner Report Card 
Partner 
Activity 
Mark 
1 
Analyze content 
A+ 
2 
Train writers in DITA 
A+ 
3 
Train writers in XML and CMS tools 
A- 
2 
Assist with information model (pilot) 
A- 
3 
Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) 
A+ 
2 
Create publication scripts 
D 
2 
Create conversion scripts 
F 
4 
Clean up migrated content 
A+
Partner #2 Report Card 
Partner 
Activity 
Mark 
2 
Train writers in DITA 
A+ 
2 
Assist with information model (pilot) 
A- 
2 
Create publication scripts 
D 
2 
Create conversion scripts 
F
You won’t really understand intelligent content and semantic markup until you’ve done it on your own content. 
Professional DITA training and assistance with information model during pilot worked well. 
CMS vendor support during pilot kept things running smoothly. 
Mechanics of moving from unintelligent to intelligent content are challenging. 
Manual cleanup is no fun. 
Intelligent content rocks!
When a partnership works, it saves time and prevents frustration. 
Go for a partner with experience in the areas where you need help. Hiring an inexperienced partner is a false economy. 
Even with the inexperienced partner, it was still worth it to get outside help.
• 
Beth Fryer, Timothy Martin, Dan Claessens 
• 
Faith Weber, Doug O’Neill 
http://www.dclab.com/webinars/case-study-the-value- of-partnership-during-conversion
Case Study: The Value of Partnership during DITA Conversion

Case Study: The Value of Partnership during DITA Conversion

  • 1.
    Nicki L Davis,PhD nickinmr@gmail.com STC Berkeley 9 July 2014
  • 4.
    “Nobody should haveto go through this to get their work done!”
  • 5.
    “Nobody should haveto go through this to get their work done!”
  • 6.
    • Project initiation • Content analysis • Writer training and pilot • Content conversion • Lessons learned • Q&A
  • 8.
    Device proliferation Contentsilos • Duplication of effort • Content lacked standardization and consistency • Individual stakeholders had only a limited grasp of the big picture
  • 9.
    • Beth Fryer,Timothy Martin, Dan Claessens • Faith Weber, Doug O’Neill
  • 10.
    • Evaluate tools(CMS and authoring tools) • Choose vendors for tools and other services • Determine where we needed outside help • Calculate costs • Negotiate with vendors • Submit proposal and get management approval • Manage training and rollout to writing team
  • 11.
    Partner Report Card Partner Activity Mark Analyze content Train writers in DITA Train writers in XML and CMS tools Assist with information model (pilot) Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) Create publication scripts Create conversion scripts Clean up migrated content
  • 13.
    Problem Design Goals People want Google, we delivered books • Put all user documentation in one place • Provide navigational context • Provide versioning Internal users created overlapping content; volume not maintainable • Technical documentation deliverables must be fully searchable with Technical Support external website. • Establish clarity of ownership (governance) SMEs frustrated by overlapping content and glacial pace of review/correction cycle • Allow SMEs to comment on topics, and have that feedback delivered directly to the writer in charge No information on which pages (out of 40,000) are viewed most often • Provide analytics to prioritize work on content
  • 14.
    Partner Report Card Partner Activity Mark 1 Analyze content A+ Train writers in DITA Train writers in XML and CMS tools Assist with information model (pilot) Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) Create publication scripts Create conversion scripts Clean up migrated content
  • 16.
    Our existing CMSdid not meet our requirements. Core team found two CMS vendors whose systems did meet our requirements. Both systems required Darwin Information Typing Architecture (DITA). Writing team evaluated each system for one week in mid-2010.
  • 17.
    Books on DITA 1-week training class in DITA 3-day training class on the CMS 6-month pilot to develop information model and implement CMS
  • 18.
    One partner (#2)helped trained writers in DITA and helped with the information model Individual writers conducted research projects in areas of interest (context-sensitive help, reuse strategy, cross-references, and so on.) CMS vendor (#3) helped with training and implementation of the CMS Writers devoted about 20% of their time to the pilot Writing team met weekly in conference call with partners
  • 19.
    Partner Report Card Partner Activity Mark 1 Analyze content A+ 2 Train writers in DITA A+ 3 Train writers in XML and CMS tools A- 2 Assist with information model (pilot) A- 3 Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) A+ Create publication scripts Create conversion scripts Clean up migrated content
  • 21.
    Mark topics withDITA information type (task, concept, reference) in original CMS Inventory shared topics in original CMS Inventory shared graphics in original CMS Inventory instances of “conrefs” in original CMS
  • 22.
    Old CMS Export Import to new CMS DITA Convert XML Staging Server Production Server Output Publish Transfer Clean up
  • 23.
    Some cleanup isalways necessary The less “intelligent” the original content, the more manual cleanup will be necessary
  • 24.
    PDF Smartphone 1. Click the Alert button. The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box. Click the Alert button. On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.
  • 25.
    Non-semantic (unintelligent) Semantic(intelligent) 1. Click the Alert button. The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box. 1. Click the Alert button. The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.
  • 26.
    Non-semantic (unintelligent) Semantic(intelligent) <steps> <step><cmd>Click the Alert button </cmd> <stepresult>The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. </stepresult> </step> <step><cmd>On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. </cmd> <info>The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.</info> </step> </steps>
  • 27.
    Non-semantic (unintelligent) Semantic(intelligent) <ol> <li>Click the Alert button. <p>The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. <p> </li> <li>On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. <p>The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box</p> </li> </ol> <steps> <step><cmd>Click the Alert button </cmd> <stepresult>The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. </stepresult> </step> <step><cmd>On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. </cmd> <info>The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.</info> </step> </steps>
  • 28.
    Non-semantic (unintelligent) Semantic(intelligent) <p> to ?? <ol> <li>Click the Alert button. <p>The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. <p> </li> <li>On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. <p>The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box</p> </li> </ol> <steps> <step><cmd>Click the Alert button </cmd> <stepresult>The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. </stepresult> </step> <step><cmd>On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. </cmd> <info>The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.</info> </step> </steps> <p> to ??
  • 29.
    Non-semantic (unintelligent) Semantic(intelligent) 1. Click the Alert button. The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box. 1. Click the Alert button. The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.
  • 30.
    Partner Report Card Partner Activity Mark 1 Analyze content A+ 2 Train writers in DITA A+ 3 Train writers in XML and CMS tools A- 2 Assist with information model (pilot) A- 3 Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) A+ Create publication scripts Create conversion scripts 4 Clean up migrated content A+
  • 31.
    Original As migrated 1. Click the Alert button. The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 2.On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box. 1. Click the Alert button. The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 2. The Create/Edit Alert dialog box appears. 3. On the Create/Edit Alert dialog box, select the Enable check box. The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box. 4. The Enable check box is located at the bottom of the dialog box.
  • 32.
    Partner Report Card Partner Activity Mark 1 Analyze content A+ 2 Train writers in DITA A+ 3 Train writers in XML and CMS tools A- 2 Assist with information model (pilot) A- 3 Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) A+ Create publication scripts D Create conversion scripts F 4 Clean up migrated content A+
  • 33.
    Partner Report Card Partner Activity Mark 1 Analyze content A+ 2 Train writers in DITA A+ 3 Train writers in XML and CMS tools A- 2 Assist with information model (pilot) A- 3 Assist implementation of CMS (pilot) A+ 2 Create publication scripts D 2 Create conversion scripts F 4 Clean up migrated content A+
  • 34.
    Partner #2 ReportCard Partner Activity Mark 2 Train writers in DITA A+ 2 Assist with information model (pilot) A- 2 Create publication scripts D 2 Create conversion scripts F
  • 36.
    You won’t reallyunderstand intelligent content and semantic markup until you’ve done it on your own content. Professional DITA training and assistance with information model during pilot worked well. CMS vendor support during pilot kept things running smoothly. Mechanics of moving from unintelligent to intelligent content are challenging. Manual cleanup is no fun. Intelligent content rocks!
  • 37.
    When a partnershipworks, it saves time and prevents frustration. Go for a partner with experience in the areas where you need help. Hiring an inexperienced partner is a false economy. Even with the inexperienced partner, it was still worth it to get outside help.
  • 38.
    • Beth Fryer,Timothy Martin, Dan Claessens • Faith Weber, Doug O’Neill http://www.dclab.com/webinars/case-study-the-value- of-partnership-during-conversion