Open Badges
   Carles Bellver
       2012
www.openbadges.org
 Mozilla Foundation
$1 million grant
MacArthur Foundation
Accreditation/
credentialing system
Accreditation/
credentialing system
    - “open”


{   - “alternative”

    - “micro”
“
If we’re successful, the
benefits to learners will
be tremendous.
         — blog.mozilla.org
“
There is a real chance to
create learning that
works more like the web.
         — blog.mozilla.org
Badges?
“
badge |baj|
noun
a distinctive emblem worn as a mark of
office, membership, achievement, licensed
employment, etc.: name badges | a Girl
Scout badge.
— The New Oxford American Dictionary
http://www.flickr.com/photos/benthomasphoto/1592354369




                Insignias
http://www.flickr.com/photos/35703177@N00/2987260527/




                 Medals
http://www.flickr.com/photos/eezpictures/3299183468/




    Accomplishment
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Lincoln_button_1860.jpg




             Campaigns
http://www.flickr.com/photos/tamiment/2784387585/




              Support
pepe@uji.es




Affiliation
Web badges
Foursquare




More web badges
Google News



http://youtu.be/QP5szEn2dxs




  And more
People like badges.
OB Background
■ Learners are learning everywhere
  – But most of that learning doesn’t
  “count”.
■ Skills assessment and communication
  is limited in current system.
■ Few alternatives to the current
  accreditation/credentialing system.
OB Goals
■ Develop badges as an alternative
  (micro-)accreditation/(micro-)credentialing
  system.
■ Avoid silos. Support badges from multiple
  issuers across the web.
■ Optimize value: make badges remixable and
  shareable with different audiences/sites.
■ Develop an open and decentralized
  supporting infrastructure to give learners
  control of the entire ecosystem.
Open Badge
Infrastructure
wiki.mozilla.org/File:Badge-diagram-2.2.jpg
wiki.mozilla.org/File:Badge-diagram-2.2.jpg
wiki.mozilla.org/File:Badge-diagram-2.2.jpg
OBI ecosystem
                          AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING

 ISSUERS                                                                             DISPLAYERS

                                           BADGE
EDUCATION                  API                                       API              BLOG
PROVIDERS                                 BACKPACK
                       METADATA                                   METADATA
                                                                                      FACEBOOK
ORGANIZATIONS
                       ✔ BADGES                 BADGES            ✔ BADGES            EPORTFOLIO
WEBSITES




              Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure
            ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display
              Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
Issuers
■ Organization, consortium or individual
  who issues badges into the OBI.
■ Issuer issues a badge on their site, then
  prompts the Badge Earner to push the
  badge into their Backpack.
■ Issuer badge systems are independent
  of the Infrastructure.
[]
ORG   ASSESSMENT



ME
      ACCREDITATION

      CREDENTIALS     }   OBI
[]
                      anybody
ORG   ASSESSMENT      anything




ME
      ACCREDITATION

      CREDENTIALS     }    OBI
“
Badges are not
assessments.
         — David Wiley
Badge Earner
■ A person storing their badges within
  the OBI.
■ The Earner has interactions with
  Issuers to earn badges, then can
  manage and share the badges in their
  Backpack out to various Display sites.
■ Learners are a type of Badge Earners.
Badge Backpack
■ An authorized data storage plus a
  management interface (control, share)
  for Earners.
■ Open source and federated – anyone
  can take the code and fork it.
■ Mozilla is building a reference or default
  Backpack.
Badge

■ A single credential demonstrating a
  skill, achievement, quality or affiliation.
■ More than a static image or button: its
  value comes from the information or
  metadata attached to it.
Badge – inside
■ A JSON blob of metadata embedded in
  a PNG file (“Badge Baking”).
 ‣ Easily portable, an actual “thing” that
   can be emailed around carrying all
   the information with it.
 ‣ Important for decentralization, so that
   Earners have more control.
Badge – metadata
■ Who issued the badge.
■ The issue date.
■ How the badge was earned.
■ Hyperlinks back to artifacts,
  documents, or testimonials
  demonstrating the work that lead to
  earning the badge.
■ Authentication back to the issuer.
Verification
■ “Did the Issuer issue this badge?”,
  “Is it still valid or has it expired?”, etc.
■ Verification happens between the
  Displayer and the Issuer.
■ Hosted Assertions: metadata points to
  a URL that the Displayers can ping.
■ In the future OBI will support Signed
  Assertions.
Displayers
■ Display of badges is where a significant
  part of the value lies: badges are not
  siloed or stuck within one site.
■ Earner controls through the Backpack
  where badges are displayed.
■ Earners can also make badges public
  and discoverable through the Earner’s
  email address.
Identity
■ Identity is a critical part of the OBI.
■ Identity needs to be open and
  decentralized.
■ How? Persona, fka BrowserID.
  browserid.org wiki.mozilla.org/Identity
  ‣ People understand email address
    ■ They don’t understand OpenID
Conclusions (1)
■ Anyone can issue accreditations about
  anything.
■ People can keep their own backpacks
  full of credentials.
 ‣ Access & display control.
 ‣ Attached to detailed accreditation
   info and evidence.
 ‣ Linked back to issuers.
“
Compared with the new open
badge systems, the standard
college transcript looks like a
sad and archaic thing.
— The Chronicle of Higher Education
Conclusions (2)
■ OBI as an open infrastructure for
  presentation portfolios.
■ OBI separates the credentialing and
  teaching functions of higher education.
■ What about assessment?
“
…no one is paying sufficient
attention to the gap between
learning anything anywhere (OER)
and receiving a recognition (OBI)
– this gap is called “assessment.”
               — David Wiley
“
…many in the field are overlooking
the place where badges make the
most sense of all – the formal
higher education institution.
               — David Wiley
Moodle & Mahara
■ Totara Learning Solutions will be
  developing an Open Badges solution
  for Moodle and Mahara.
 ‣ Moodle as Issuer.
 ‣ Mahara as Displayer.
OBI ecosystem
                          AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING

 ISSUERS                                                                             DISPLAYERS

                                           BADGE
EDUCATION                  API                                       API              BLOG
PROVIDERS                                 BACKPACK
                       METADATA                                   METADATA
                                                                                      FACEBOOK
ORGANIZATIONS
                       ✔ BADGES                 BADGES            ✔ BADGES            EPORTFOLIO
WEBSITES




              Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure
            ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display
              Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
OBI ecosystem
                          AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING

 ISSUERS                                                                             DISPLAYERS

                                           BADGE
EDUCATION                  API                                       API              BLOG
PROVIDERS                                 BACKPACK
                       METADATA                                   METADATA
                                                                                      FACEBOOK
ORGANIZATIONS
                       ✔ BADGES                 BADGES            ✔ BADGES            EPORTFOLIO
WEBSITES




              Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure
            ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display
              Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
OBI ecosystem
                          AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING

 ISSUERS                                                                             DISPLAYERS
    moodle
EDUCATION                  API
                                           BADGE
                                                                     API              BLOG
PROVIDERS                                 BACKPACK
                       METADATA                                   METADATA
                                                                                      FACEBOOK
ORGANIZATIONS
                       ✔ BADGES                 BADGES            ✔ BADGES            EPORTFOLIO
WEBSITES




              Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure
            ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display
              Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
OBI ecosystem
                          AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING

 ISSUERS                                                                             DISPLAYERS
    moodle
EDUCATION                  API
                                           BADGE
                                                                     API              BLOG
PROVIDERS                                 BACKPACK
                       METADATA                                   METADATA
                                                                                      FACEBOOK
ORGANIZATIONS
                       ✔ BADGES                 BADGES            ✔ BADGES            EPORTFOLIO
WEBSITES




              Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure
            ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display
              Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
OBI ecosystem
                          AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING

 ISSUERS                                                                             DISPLAYERS
    moodle
EDUCATION                  API
                                           BADGE
                                                                     API              BLOG
PROVIDERS                                 BACKPACK
                       METADATA                                   METADATA
                                                                                      FACEBOOK
ORGANIZATIONS
                       ✔ BADGES                 BADGES            ✔ BADGES            EPORTFOLIO
WEBSITES
                                                                                  mahara



              Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure
            ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display
              Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
Details
■   Integration with Moodle’s Activity and Course completion
    functionality.

■   Certificate module will dispense Open Badge PNG
    instead of PDF files.

■   Badges will be stored in Moodle and can also be
    downloadable by users once they have earned them.

■   A web service will provide badge authenticity verification.

■   New blocks for Moodle and Mahara will display badges
    on users' profiles pages.

■   Use of Moodle Portfolio API to push badges
    automatically to Mahara.
OBI Tech Overview
■ Issuer API
■ Displayer API
■ Verification API
■ Endorsement API
■ Metadata Specification
■ Reference Implementation
OBI 2012 Roadmap

Q1 OBI Beta ✓
Q2 Website
Q3 Research and Planning for 1.0
Q4 OBI 1.0
More info
www.openbadges.org
wiki.mozilla.org/Badges
Open Badges and Moodle
moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=197834

Openness and the Future of Assessment
http://opencontent.org/blog/archives/237
Carles Bellver
 bellverc@uji.es
http://cent.uji.es

Open Badges - CENT UJI 2012

  • 1.
    Open Badges Carles Bellver 2012
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
    Accreditation/ credentialing system - “open” { - “alternative” - “micro”
  • 6.
    “ If we’re successful,the benefits to learners will be tremendous. — blog.mozilla.org
  • 7.
    “ There is areal chance to create learning that works more like the web. — blog.mozilla.org
  • 8.
  • 9.
    “ badge |baj| noun a distinctiveemblem worn as a mark of office, membership, achievement, licensed employment, etc.: name badges | a Girl Scout badge. — The New Oxford American Dictionary
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    OB Background ■ Learnersare learning everywhere – But most of that learning doesn’t “count”. ■ Skills assessment and communication is limited in current system. ■ Few alternatives to the current accreditation/credentialing system.
  • 21.
    OB Goals ■ Developbadges as an alternative (micro-)accreditation/(micro-)credentialing system. ■ Avoid silos. Support badges from multiple issuers across the web. ■ Optimize value: make badges remixable and shareable with different audiences/sites. ■ Develop an open and decentralized supporting infrastructure to give learners control of the entire ecosystem.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
    OBI ecosystem AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING ISSUERS DISPLAYERS BADGE EDUCATION API API BLOG PROVIDERS BACKPACK METADATA METADATA FACEBOOK ORGANIZATIONS ✔ BADGES BADGES ✔ BADGES EPORTFOLIO WEBSITES Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
  • 27.
    Issuers ■ Organization, consortiumor individual who issues badges into the OBI. ■ Issuer issues a badge on their site, then prompts the Badge Earner to push the badge into their Backpack. ■ Issuer badge systems are independent of the Infrastructure.
  • 28.
    [] ORG ASSESSMENT ME ACCREDITATION CREDENTIALS } OBI
  • 29.
    [] anybody ORG ASSESSMENT anything ME ACCREDITATION CREDENTIALS } OBI
  • 30.
  • 31.
    Badge Earner ■ Aperson storing their badges within the OBI. ■ The Earner has interactions with Issuers to earn badges, then can manage and share the badges in their Backpack out to various Display sites. ■ Learners are a type of Badge Earners.
  • 32.
    Badge Backpack ■ Anauthorized data storage plus a management interface (control, share) for Earners. ■ Open source and federated – anyone can take the code and fork it. ■ Mozilla is building a reference or default Backpack.
  • 33.
    Badge ■ A singlecredential demonstrating a skill, achievement, quality or affiliation. ■ More than a static image or button: its value comes from the information or metadata attached to it.
  • 34.
    Badge – inside ■A JSON blob of metadata embedded in a PNG file (“Badge Baking”). ‣ Easily portable, an actual “thing” that can be emailed around carrying all the information with it. ‣ Important for decentralization, so that Earners have more control.
  • 35.
    Badge – metadata ■Who issued the badge. ■ The issue date. ■ How the badge was earned. ■ Hyperlinks back to artifacts, documents, or testimonials demonstrating the work that lead to earning the badge. ■ Authentication back to the issuer.
  • 36.
    Verification ■ “Did theIssuer issue this badge?”, “Is it still valid or has it expired?”, etc. ■ Verification happens between the Displayer and the Issuer. ■ Hosted Assertions: metadata points to a URL that the Displayers can ping. ■ In the future OBI will support Signed Assertions.
  • 37.
    Displayers ■ Display ofbadges is where a significant part of the value lies: badges are not siloed or stuck within one site. ■ Earner controls through the Backpack where badges are displayed. ■ Earners can also make badges public and discoverable through the Earner’s email address.
  • 38.
    Identity ■ Identity isa critical part of the OBI. ■ Identity needs to be open and decentralized. ■ How? Persona, fka BrowserID. browserid.org wiki.mozilla.org/Identity ‣ People understand email address ■ They don’t understand OpenID
  • 41.
    Conclusions (1) ■ Anyonecan issue accreditations about anything. ■ People can keep their own backpacks full of credentials. ‣ Access & display control. ‣ Attached to detailed accreditation info and evidence. ‣ Linked back to issuers.
  • 42.
    “ Compared with thenew open badge systems, the standard college transcript looks like a sad and archaic thing. — The Chronicle of Higher Education
  • 43.
    Conclusions (2) ■ OBIas an open infrastructure for presentation portfolios. ■ OBI separates the credentialing and teaching functions of higher education. ■ What about assessment?
  • 44.
    “ …no one ispaying sufficient attention to the gap between learning anything anywhere (OER) and receiving a recognition (OBI) – this gap is called “assessment.” — David Wiley
  • 45.
    “ …many in thefield are overlooking the place where badges make the most sense of all – the formal higher education institution. — David Wiley
  • 46.
    Moodle & Mahara ■Totara Learning Solutions will be developing an Open Badges solution for Moodle and Mahara. ‣ Moodle as Issuer. ‣ Mahara as Displayer.
  • 47.
    OBI ecosystem AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING ISSUERS DISPLAYERS BADGE EDUCATION API API BLOG PROVIDERS BACKPACK METADATA METADATA FACEBOOK ORGANIZATIONS ✔ BADGES BADGES ✔ BADGES EPORTFOLIO WEBSITES Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
  • 48.
    OBI ecosystem AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING ISSUERS DISPLAYERS BADGE EDUCATION API API BLOG PROVIDERS BACKPACK METADATA METADATA FACEBOOK ORGANIZATIONS ✔ BADGES BADGES ✔ BADGES EPORTFOLIO WEBSITES Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
  • 49.
    OBI ecosystem AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING ISSUERS DISPLAYERS moodle EDUCATION API BADGE API BLOG PROVIDERS BACKPACK METADATA METADATA FACEBOOK ORGANIZATIONS ✔ BADGES BADGES ✔ BADGES EPORTFOLIO WEBSITES Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
  • 50.
    OBI ecosystem AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING ISSUERS DISPLAYERS moodle EDUCATION API BADGE API BLOG PROVIDERS BACKPACK METADATA METADATA FACEBOOK ORGANIZATIONS ✔ BADGES BADGES ✔ BADGES EPORTFOLIO WEBSITES Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
  • 51.
    OBI ecosystem AUTHENTICATION / CLAIM MAKING ISSUERS DISPLAYERS moodle EDUCATION API BADGE API BLOG PROVIDERS BACKPACK METADATA METADATA FACEBOOK ORGANIZATIONS ✔ BADGES BADGES ✔ BADGES EPORTFOLIO WEBSITES mahara Independent and agnostic. Outside of Open Badge Infrastructure ✔ Users consents to accept badges into backpack & send to website for display Source: wiki.mozilla.org/Badges/Onboarding-Issuer
  • 52.
    Details ■ Integration with Moodle’s Activity and Course completion functionality. ■ Certificate module will dispense Open Badge PNG instead of PDF files. ■ Badges will be stored in Moodle and can also be downloadable by users once they have earned them. ■ A web service will provide badge authenticity verification. ■ New blocks for Moodle and Mahara will display badges on users' profiles pages. ■ Use of Moodle Portfolio API to push badges automatically to Mahara.
  • 53.
    OBI Tech Overview ■Issuer API ■ Displayer API ■ Verification API ■ Endorsement API ■ Metadata Specification ■ Reference Implementation
  • 54.
    OBI 2012 Roadmap Q1OBI Beta ✓ Q2 Website Q3 Research and Planning for 1.0 Q4 OBI 1.0
  • 55.
    More info www.openbadges.org wiki.mozilla.org/Badges Open Badgesand Moodle moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=197834 Openness and the Future of Assessment http://opencontent.org/blog/archives/237
  • 56.