Capitalism has both merits and demerits according to the document. The key merits are that capitalism is self-regulating through market forces, allows for faster economic growth as investors choose profitable projects, and ensures efficient allocation of resources. However, the document also notes several demerits such as rising inequality of income and wealth, differences in economic opportunities based on inheritance, distortion of production patterns due to unequal demand, and wasteful use of resources like on advertising. Capitalism may also underproduce public goods and overproduce some harmful products.
Competition a potent tool for economic development and Socio - Economic welfare
Merits and Demerits of Capitalism: Self-Regulation vs Inequality
1. What are the merits and demerits of Capitalism?
SUSHIL NANDA
Merits of Capitalism:
1. Capitalism is self-regulatory. It is regulated by market mechanism leading to several benefits for
the economy.
(i) Though the market structure has its own cost in terms of some resources used up in advertising
etc., these costs are far smaller than those are, which have to be incurred where the government has
to regulate it through some form of central planning. In the latter case, the authorities have to incur
expenditure in collecting and processing information, in formulating policies, in issuing directions
and in monitoring their implementation.
(ii) The decision-taking process of the government is always more time consuming than is the case
with private enterprise. This also causes an additional waste of resources.
2. It is claimed that the process of economic growth is faster under capitalism. This is because the
investors try to invest in only those projects, which are economically viable as dictated by the market
forces.
3. The capitalist system decides 'what to produce' and' how to produce' in consonance with the forces
of demand and supply. Every producer tries to maximize his profit by employing resources in such a
manner that the cost of production is reduced to the minimum possible. It, therefore, means that
resources are used to produce those goods and services in which they are most productive. This
results in an optimum allocation of productive resources of the economy.
4. It is generally believed that long-term projects are more productive. The financial system of the
capitalist economy helps the entrepreneurs in selecting long-term projects by providing sufficient
credit facilities.
5. Every economic unit tries to adopt a set of activities, which are in its best interest. Advocates of
capitalism claim that on account of this reason, there is an harmony of decisions in the economy as a
whole, They admit that in reality, capitalism is not able to remove the problems of unemployment or
cyclical fluctuations in national income etc. But they say that this is because, in practice, capitalism is
not allowed to work in a smooth and perfect manner. It faces several hurdles in the form of unfair
competition, monopoly elements, and activities of trade unions etc.
6. Capitalist system provides an incentive for efficient decisions and their implementation in the
form of economic gains to the decision makers. This ensures a high degree of operative efficiency in
the system.
7. The net result is that a capitalist economy has a tendency to register a high growth rate both in
national income and per capita income. It also produces a large and growing variety of products, and
has an inherent tendency to develop technology.
Demerits of Capitalism:
However, as in the case of every other economic system, capitalism also suffers from several
demerits. The leading ones are as follows.
1. Capitalism generates inequalities of income and wealth. They keep widening with the development
of capitalism. In the initial stages of capitalism, therefore, there is widespread poverty of the masses.
2. In later stages, the poverty is not acute in absolute terms, but inequalities remain. Some economists
are of the view that inequalities reduce aggregate economic welfare of the society as a whole.
2. The inequalities of income and wealth, together with the institution of inheritance, leads to wide
differences in economic opportunities. Those with more wealth and capital are able to get better
education and training. They are also able to get better employment, or they can manage the
businesses inherited by them. As a result, some members of the society start their career with higher
income simple because of inheritance.
3. The composition of production in capitalism follows the pattern of demand. However on account
of inequalities, the pattern of demand does not represent real needs the society. The result is a
distortion in the production pattern also.
4. It is maintained by critics that capitalism wastes its productive resources in several ways. We can
give the example of large-scale advertisement and other forms of selling expenses. To a large extent,
the expenses incurred by one firm get neutralized by the impact of selling expenses incurred by its
rivals. As a result, while competing firms do not gain, the resources of the economy are used up in
the process.
5. In a capitalist economy, it is not profitable to produce a number of ‘merit goods’ because they have
a high cost of production and large sections of consumers are not able to pay for them. Merit goods
are those the consumption of which benefits even those who are not consuming them. Examples of
merit goods are education, health care and the like.
6. In contrast, the capitalist system may be producing a number of goods and services, which are
positively harmful for the society. Business units produce only those goods and services, which are
profitable to do so even when they are harmful such as cigarette and tobacco.
7. On account of rapid technological progress, the existing capital machinery and equipment have a
high rate of obsolescence. The need to replace them keeps arising much before they are used for their
full technical life.