This document provides an overview of the approach to evaluating primary immunodeficiency. It discusses the importance of differentiating primary from secondary immunodeficiency. The most common presentations of primary immunodeficiency are recurrent infections, especially of the ear, sinus, lungs and gastrointestinal tract. A thorough history and physical exam can provide clues to the underlying immunodeficiency. Initial screening tests include a complete blood count, immunoglobulin levels and lymphocyte subset analysis. Further specialized testing helps characterize the specific immune deficiency.
2. Approach to primary immunodeficiency
• PRIMARY IMMUNODEFICINCY
• SECONDARY IMMUNODEFICINCY
• IMMUNODEFICINCY AND ATOPY
• HISTORY
• PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
• INVESTIGATION
• MEANGAMENT
3. INTRODUCTION TO PRIMARY
IMMUNODEFICINCY
• PIDs are inherited defects of the innate or adaptive arms of the immune
system that lead to an increase in the incidence, frequency, or severity of
infections.
• The overall incidence of PIDs is 1 in 10,000. The prevalence of diagnosed
PID in the United States in 2005 was 1 in 2000 children . More than 200
disorders have been characterized.
• It is important to differentiate the child with PIDs from "normal child"
who has more than average number of viral infections or from the child
who has an underlying disease that predisposes him to infections, results
in secondary immune system dysfunction.
4. INTRODUCTION TO PRIMARY
IMMUNODEFICINCY
• The most common presentations are recurrent ear, sinus, and pulmonary
infections, diarrhea and failure to thrive.
• The type and pattern of recurring infections depend on which components
of the immune system are affected
• Infection severity also varies, ranging from mild respiratory infections to
massive systemic infections
5. INTRODUCTION TO PRIMARY
IMMUNODEFICINCY
• Recurrent infections :
• two or more severe infections in one year
• three or more respiratory infections in one year
• the need for antibiotics for two months/year.
• Severe/serious infections
• persistent fever
• failure to respond to oral antibiotics or the need for intravenous antibiotics
• infections with an unusual pathogen, unusual complications (eg mastoiditis, pleural
effusion, abscesses)
• persistent laboratory abnormalities (eg, leukocytosis, elevated ESR or CRP
• persistent imaging abnormalities
6.
7. Clinical features suggestive of a primary
immunodeficiency
Adaptive immunity
T cell defectsB cell defects
Recurrent, severe, or unusual viral infections (VZV, CMV, HSV)
Recurrent bacterial sinopulmonary infections or
sepsis, particularly with polysaccharide
encapsulated organisms (S. pneumoniae, H.
influenzae type b)
Chronic diarrheaUnexplained bronchiectasis
Chronic candidiasis
Chronic or recurrent gastroenteritis (often with
Giardia or enterovirus)
Failure to thriveFailure to thrive
Lymphopenia during the neonatal period or in infancyChronic enteroviral meningoencephalitis
Pneumocystis pneumoniaArthritis
Graft-versus-host disease
Severe/neonatal eczematoid or seborrheic rashes
8. Clinical features suggestive of a primary
immunodeficiency
Innate immunity
Complement defectsPhagocytic defects
Angioedema of face, hands, feet, gastrointestinal tractPoor wound healing
Autoimmune disease, lupus-like symptomsDelayed separation of the umbilical cord
Pyogenic bacterial infections (eg, N. meningitidis)Lymphadenitis or soft tissue abscesses
History suggestive of autosomal dominant inheritanceHepatosplenomegaly
Chronic gingivitis, oral mucosal ,ulcerations
Infection with catalase positive bacteria and fungi
Recurrent gastrointestinal or genitourinary tract obstruction
9. Clinical features suggestive of a primary
immunodeficiency
• Family history of immunodeficiency or unexplained early death (eg,
before age 30 years)
• Complications from a live vaccine (eg, rotavirus, varicella, and BCG)
• Persistent lymphopenia (a count of <1500 cells/uL in patients over five
years and <2500 cells/uL in younger children
• Features typical of syndromic PIDs (eg, cartilage-hair hypoplasia,
Chediak-Higashi syndrome, ataxia-telangiectasia)
• absence of LN and tonsils or absence of thymus shadow on chest
radiograph
10. SECONDARY IMMUNODEFICINCY
• Underlying disease states, medications, injury, previous surgical
procedures, and prematurity can lead to immune system
dysfunction.
• more common than PIDs.
• Common examples:
11. IMMUNODEFICINCY WITH ATOPY
• Approximately 30 percent of children with recurrent infections have atopic
disease.
• Chronic allergic rhinitis may be mistaken for recurrent upper respiratory
infections.
• Asthma exacerbation frequently misdiagnosed as pneumonia or bronchitis
rather than reactive airways disease/asthma.
• These episodes respond poorly to antibiotics but well to allergy medications.
12. IMMUNODEFICINCY WITH ATOPY
• It is important to note that PIDs and allergic disease can coexist.
• Immunodeficiencies with associated atopy:
• selective IgA deficiency, CVID, CGD, and DiGeorge syndrome.
• Immunodeficiencies with elevated levels of IgE
• hyperimmunoglobulin E syndrome, Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome, Omenn syndrome, and
IPEX syndrome.
13. HISTORY
• Birth history :
• Growth and development
• often have poor weight gain or even weight loss
• Chronic disease and some PIDs can lead to delay in developmental milestones.
• Progressive neurologic dysfunction is seen in young adults with Chediak-Higashi
syndrome.
• Delayed speech can occur with recurrent and chronic otitis media
14. HISTORY
• Immunization history:
• any adverse effects from a vaccine, particularly live-virus vaccines
( CNS complications from oral polio, or diarrhea
following rotavirus vaccine) as well as vaccine failure (eg, chicken
pox in a varicella-vaccinated child).
• Live attenuated vaccines given in early infancy, including BCG,
rotavirus, and oral polio vaccine, are of special threat to patients
with congenital immunodeficiencies (eg, agammaglobulinemia or
combined immunodeficiency).
15. HISTORY
• Medications
• Use of any immunosuppressive medications, glucocorticoids
• If immunoglobulin has been given, the route, brand, dose, frequency, use of
premedication, and adverse effects should be noted.
• Other illnesses
• The severity of childhood diseases, such as chicken pox and febrile
illnesses, ICU admission , need of ventilation
• past hospitalizations, injuries or accidents, surgeries, or prolonged school
absences may provide clues to the present illness.
16. HISTORY
• Family history:
• similar diseases, recurrent infections, unexplained death, or
autoimmune disease
• Inheritance patterns are variable. X-linked transmission : X linked
agammaglobulinemia and CGD.
• autosomal-recessive pattern : some complement defects and ataxia-
telangiectasia. inconstant familial tendency (CVID, IgA deficiency,
hyperimmunoglobulin E syndrome) .
• Certain immunodeficiencies are more common in particular populations
• infections in family members: tuberculosis, hepatitis B, herpes simplex,
and HIV.
17. HISTORY
• Social history
• Daycare and school attendance increases the risk of exposure to
respiratory pathogens.
• Infection history
• The infection history should include the age of onset, duration,
frequency, sites, organisms, treatment, and response to therapy
18. HISTORY
• Recurrent pneumonia limited to a particular anatomic region is typically
caused by a local anatomic abnormality . By contrast, patients with
lower respiratory tract infections involving different regions of the lung
often have an underlying systemic disorder
• Abscesses of the skin, lymph nodes, or internal organs suggest a
phagocytic or antibody deficiency. Recurrent abscesses at the same site
may indicate an underlying anatomic defect
• Recurrent or chronic gastrointestinal infections occur in patients with IgA
deficiency or CVID .
• Recurrent urinary tract infections are uncommon in immunodeficiency
19. HISTORY
• Recurrent sinopulmonary infections with encapsulated organisms (eg,
pneumococcus, Haemophilus influenzae type b) suggest B cell
abnormalities.
• Pneumocystis jiroveci pneumonia is a hallmark of SCID and other
primary or secondary T cell immunodeficiencies, such as HIV or
immunosuppressive therapy
• Pseudomonas sepsis occur in phagocytic disorders or profound
antibody or T cell immunodeficiency
• Enteroviral meningoencephalitis can be the presenting infection in
children with X-linked agammaglobulinemia (XLA)
20. HISTORY
• Aspergillus, Staphylococcus aureus, coagulase-negative
staphylococci, Serratia marcescens, and Chromobacterium are common
organisms found in abscesses or soft-tissue infections in patients with
CGD
• Recurrent staphylococcal skin infections, abscesses, lung cysts, or
pneumonia are characteristic of hyperimmunoglobulin E syndrome.
• Invasive infection with Neisseria species (N. meningitidis, N.
gonorrhoeae) occurs in patients with deficiencies of the late components
of complement (C5 to C9)
• Infection with vaccine strains following live vaccines, including oral
rotavirus, oral polio, measles, varicella, or BCG, suggest PID. Vaccine
failure (eg, recurrent chicken pox or shingles in the vaccinated child)
also suggests immunodeficiency
21. PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
• Vital signs.
• dysmorphic appearance may signify a genetic syndrome.
• Growth and development is documented by growth charts
• acute or chronic otitis media should be determined since upper
respiratory infections are the most common recurrent infection.
Draining ears and perforated tympanic membranes suggest
immunodeficiency.
• Pallor without anemia, dark circles under the eyes, conjunctivitis,
a transverse nasal crease, congested turbinates, and clear nasal
discharge suggest allergy.
22. PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
• Purulent nasal discharge, postnasal drip, and diminished gag reflex
are consistent with chronic sinusitis.
• Mouth ulcers, gingivitis, mucosal candidiasis, and poor dentition
suggest immunodeficiency.
• Diminished or absent tonsils and cervical nodes in the presence of
recurrent respiratory infections suggest an antibody deficiency.
• Nasal polyps suggest cystic fibrosis.
• A productive or wheezy cough suggests bronchitis, pneumonia, or
asthma.
23. PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
• Digital clubbing suggests longstanding lung or heart disease,
inflammatory bowel disease, or chronic infection.
• Cutaneous granulomas, impetigo, or nonhealing sores suggest antibody
or phagocytic immunodeficiency.
• Facial rashes, vitiligo, alopecia, and vasculitic lesions suggest
autoimmunity
• The absence of lymph tissue suggests XLA or SCID.
• adenopathy and hepatosplenomegaly can be seen in B cell disorders (eg,
CVID, IgA deficiency) and HIV infection. Suppurative adenitis is common
in CGD.
24. PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
• Ataxia, telangiectasia, and developmental delay in ataxia-telangiectasia
• Petechiae, easy bleeding, eczema, and chronic draining ears in Wiskott-
Aldrich syndrome
• Coarse features, chronic infected eczema, and deep-seated abscesses in
hyperimmunoglobulin E syndrome
• Short stature with chondrodystrophy and fine hair in cartilage-hair
hypoplasia
• Congenital heart disease, developmental delay, and dysmorphic facies
with low-set ears, hypertelorism, downturning eyes, and micrognathia in
DiGeorge syndrome
25. PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
• Early onset of seborrheic dermatitis and alopecia in some forms of
SCID
• Oral ulcers, gingivitis, and impetigo in CGD, or leukocyte-adhesion
defects
• Oculocutaneous albinism in Chediak-Higashi disease
• Abnormal dentition, decreased sweating, and sparse hair
associated with frequent infection suggest ectodermal dysplasia
• Dermatomyositis-like rash in XLA
• Lupus-like rash in early complement component defects
26. INVESTIGATION(General screening tests)
• The screening evaluation should include both quantitative and
qualitative tests
• Abnormalities of the following initial tests may suggest allergy,
immunodeficiency, or a chronic illness and serve as a guide for
subsequent investigations
• Complete blood count with differential
• Electrolytes, glucose, blood urea nitrogen (BUN), creatinine, and albumin
• Urinalysis
• Erythrocyte-sedimentation rate (ESR) or C-reactive protein (CRP)
• Appropriate cultures
• Radiologic imaging of the site(s) of suspected infection
• Immunoglobulin levels
27. INVESTIGATION(General screening tests)
• Lymphopenia is defined as a count of <1500 cells/uL in patients over
five years and <2500 cells/uL in younger children.
• elevated ESR or CRP suggests systemic or regional infection or an
autoimmune process.
• A chest radiograph is indicated if the child has a chronic cough or
other features suggesting lung problems.
• Sinus and lateral neck films or sinus (CT) scan with a lateral
pharyngeal view for adenoidal size is indicated for the patient with
suspected sinusitis or obstructive breathing . Complete absence of
adenoidal tissue suggests immunodeficiency
28.
29. INVESTIGATION(General screening tests)
• Immunoglobulin levels
• IgG, IgM, IgA, and IgE, are included in the initial tests.
• Antibody deficiency is suggested by an IgG less than 200 mg/dL and a total Ig (IgG
plus IgM plus IgA) less than 400 mg/dL, or the complete absence of IgM or IgA (after
infancy).
• elevated IgE (>100 int. units/mL) suggests allergy, eczema, or chronic skin
infections, or may occur in Omenn syndrome, phagocytic disorders, or
hyperimmunoglobulin E syndrome (levels are generally >2000 int. units/mL for this
syndrome).
• Low or absent IgE levels suggest absence of IgE-mediated allergic disease.
31. INVESTIGATION
• Antibody titers
• Response to protein antigens can be assessed by measurement of titers to tetanus,
diphtheria, pneumococcal conjugate, and H. influenzae type b vaccines.
• Response to polysaccharide antigens can be determined by measurement of titers to
polysaccharide pneumococcal vaccine (unconjugated) in adults and children over 24
months of age
• Complement activity
• screening test is a total hemolytic complement determination (CH50). A normal CH50
level excludes nearly all hereditary complement deficiencies.
• IgG subclass determinations
• In patients with a slightly low total IgG level and poor antibody response to
vaccinations
• HIV testing
• (HIV) testing, antibody titers or PCR, should be done in any patient suspected of a T
cell deficiency
32. INVESTIGATION
• Lymphocyte-subset analysis:
• By flow cytometry,
• including CD3 (total T cells), CD4 (T helper), CD8 (T cytotoxic),
CD19 or CD20 (B cells), and CD16/56 (natural killer cells)
• The CD4 count is the most valuable reflection of the cellular
immune system. An absolute CD4 count of <500 cells/uL in a person
over five years of age or <1000 cells/uL in younger children
suggests a cellular immunodeficiency.
• An absolute B cell (CD19) count of <100 cells/uL suggests
hereditary agammaglobulinemia.
• A low CD16/56 count (<2 percent) suggests a natural killer cell
deficiency.
33. INVESTIGATION
• Delayed-cutaneous hypersensitivity:
• inflammatory reactions initiated by mononuclear leukocytes.
• mediated by T cells and monocytes/macrophages rather than by
antibodies. They are also termed type IV hypersensitivity reactions
• Children under age two years often have negative tests despite
intact cellular immunity.
• The usual skin tests employ Candida antigen, tetanus or tetanus-
diphtheria antigen, and/or tuberculin.
34. INVESTIGATION
• Lymphoproliferative assays
• Diminished or absent proliferation to mitogens signals a serious derangement of T
cell function, such as severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID).
• Phagocytic-oxidative responses
• correlated with the ability of leukocytes to kill bacteria. This is best assessed using a
fluorescent dye (dihydrorhodamine) and flow cytometry.
• A negative response is seen in CGD. This procedure is faster and more informative
than nitroblue tetrazolium dye reduction assays used previously
• Leukocyte-adhesion defect testing
• examination of cell surface marker expression by flow cytometry. CD11 and CD18 are
absent in LAD I and CD15a is absent in LAD II. Patients with LAD III have normal
integrin expression.
35. MEANGAMENT
• Infections must be recognized and aggressively treated.
• Empiric antibiotic therapy should be instituted pending culture results.
• Prophylactic antibiotics may be administered depending upon the type
of disorder suspected.
• Live-virus vaccines (eg, oral polio, oral rotavirus, varicella, MMR
smallpox, intranasal influenza) and live (BCG) vaccine must not be
administered
• Family members may receive varicella, MMR, and shingles vaccines, but
not oral polio or smallpox vaccines.
• Inactive influenza vaccine may be preferred for household contacts of
some immunocompromised individuals.
36. MEANGAMENT
• Post exposure infectious prophylaxis may be necessary following
exposure to varicella.
• Only irradiated, leukocyte-poor, virus-free products should be
used if blood transfusion is necessary.
• IVIG or SCIG should not be given until there has been a thorough
evaluation of the patient's immune system.
• IVIG and SCIG are expensive, will dismiss an antibody investigation
for several months, and have potential adverse effects. Their use
should be carefully considered only after the evaluation is
complete.
Editor's Notes
• Most often this can be done from the history, physical examination, and screening investigations
Almost three-fourths of the PIDs are caused by an antibody (B cell) deficiency or a combined antibody plus cellular (T cell) abnormality .
Isolated T cell defects, as well as phagocytic cell, complement, and other innate immune defects, are less common.
B cell (antibody) or combined B and T cell diseases should be considered initially, unless clinical features suggest otherwise
Family history of immunodeficiency was the most predictive factor of any PID in a retrospective survey of 563 children who presented to two pediatric immunodeficiency centers for evaluation of possible PID
Need for intravenous antibiotics and/or hospitalization to clear infections, Six or more new infections within one year, Two or more serious sinus infections or pneumonias within one year, Four or more new ear infections within one year, Two or more episodes of sepsis or meningitis in a lifetime, Two or more months of antibiotics with little effect
the use of intravenous antibiotics for sepsis and failure to thrive were strong identifiers of neutrophil PID and T cell PID, respectively.
Infections (e.g., HIV, EBV)
Nutritional deficiencies (e.g., protein, calorie, vitamin, or mineral malnutrition)
Protein-losing states (e.g., nephrotic syndrome, protein-losing enteropathy
diabetes mellitus
malignancy
Immunosuppressive agents (e.g., antineoplastic drugs, corticosteroids, radiation)
Atopy increased susceptibility to infection may be due to enhanced adherence of pathogens to inflamed respiratory epithelium, increased mucosal permeability, or an altered immune response to certain viral and bacterial pathogens
Growth and development are usually normal.
A normal total IgE tends to exclude IgE-mediated allergy.
An elevated IgE (eg, >100 int. units/mL) is suggestive of allergy, but an elevated IgE alone is not diagnostic for atopic disease.
exposure to toxins, prescription medications, illicit drugs, tobacco, and alcohol. These factors can increase the risk of secondary immunodeficiency in the newborn
Gestation age, birth weight, and neonatal problems, such as jaundice, respiratory distress, or need for intensive care. Transfusions , food intolerance and duration of breastfeeding
ataxia-telangiectasia and DiGeorge syndrome, can lead to delay in developmental milestones.
Patients with T cell deficiencies or who are on immunosuppressive drugs including glucocorticoids may develop progressive infections following live-virus vaccines.
Current and past medications, including duration, effectiveness, and adverse reactions.
home, parents' work environment, and daycare or school should be explored for exposures, such as ill classmates, allergens, tobacco smoke, contaminated water supply, farm animals, solvents, and toxins, as well as location near industrial plants . Prior residences and travel history may be important in exposure to infectious agents or allergens
Congenital antibody deficiencies and many combined immunodeficiencies (eg, zeta-chain associated protein 70 [ZAP-70] deficiency, CD25 deficiency) usually present at 7 to 12 months, as maternal immunoglobulin G (IgG) disappears.
reactive airways disease/asthma is often misdiagnosed as pneumonia or bronchitis in young children.
(eg, foreign body, bronchial compression by mediastinal adenopathy or vascular anomaly, bronchial sequestration or cyst).
(eg, cystic fibrosis, immotile cilia syndrome, recurrent aspiration.
such as a congenital branchial cleft cyst, pilonidal cyst, hidradenitis suppurativa, or a retained foreign body.
and usually reflect a structural abnormality, such as obstruction, reflux, or bladder dysmotility.
Certain immunodeficiencies commonly present with infections caused by "signature" organisms. Children who present with such infections should undergo laboratory evaluation for immunodeficiency. As examples :
Recurrent pneumococcal disease suggests a PID, such as agammaglobulinemia or complement defect. Secondary immunodeficiency, due to sickle cell disease, asplenia, HIV/AIDS, or nephrotic syndrome, also results in recurrent pneumococcal disease
Pseudomonas infection also occurs in patients with cystic fibrosis, burns or soft tissue injury, or neutropenia
Enteroviral meningoencephalitis is rare in children receiving regular doses of intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG)
Prolonged and severe candidiasis involving the buccal mucosa, tongue, and palate may be the earliest sign of abnormal T cell immunity
Deep or systemic infections with nontuberculous mycobacteria suggest an interferon-gamma receptor or interleukin-receptor deficiency.
Weight loss or failure to thrive is suggested by muscle wasting or atrophy of the buttock fat deposits
 certain findings are characteristic of specific immunodeficiency syndromes as example:
Look for any systemic disease
Evaluation for infection
The presence of anemia, thrombocytopenia, or an abnormal differential count warrants further investigation. Eosinophilia suggests allergy. Thrombocytosis suggests chronic inflammation.
The top chest radiograph shows a normal thymic shadow. The bottom radiograph shows absence of the thymic shadow in an infant with severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID).
Normal adenoid (left); absent adenoid in agammaglobulinemia (right)
Levels must be compared with age-matched controls, particularly in the first two years of life.
These tests are indicated when the screening tests are abnormal or the clinical picture is highly suggestive for an immunodeficiency
Specific Tests for Suspected Immunodeficiencies
Tests of B-Lymphocyte Function
Quantitative immunoglobulins: IgG (consider subclasses), IgA, IgM
B-lymphocyte quantitation by flow cytometry
Antibody response to protein vaccines (tetanus, diphtheria, polio, measles, mumps, rubella antibody titers)
Antibody response to polysaccharide vaccine (pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine)
Isohemagglutinins (only if child >1 yr; assesses IgM response to carbohydrate antigen)
Tests of T-Lymphocyte Function
Total lymphocyte count
T-cell and subset quantitation by flow cytometry (CD3/total T-cell, CD4/T-helper, CD8/T-suppressor/cytotoxic counts)
CXR for thymic shadow
Delayed-type hypersensitivity skin test (intradermal skin test with 0.1 mL heat-killed Candida 1:100 dilution)
In vitro T-cell proliferative responses to mitogens, antigens, or allogenic cells (day 3 and day 6 proliferations)
Thymic biopsy
Tests of Phagocytic Cell Function
Neutrophil count and morphology
NOBI by flow cytometry
Adhesion antigen (CD11/CD18) by flow cytometry
Chemotaxis assays
Tests of Complement System Function
Total hemolytic complement (CH50), C3, C4
Other Tests
HIV testing
ADA and PNP levels
Vaccine challenge — Vaccine responsiveness is used to further assess the antibody system. A killed vaccine that has not been administered previously is given, and titers are measured before and four to six weeks after vaccination.
Levels of individual complement components are measured if the CH50 is significantly reduced
A complete absence of IgG1, IgG2, or IgG3 suggests immune dysregulation and may indicate the early onset of common variable immunodeficiency (CVID).
indicated when a B or T cell defect is suspected. Comparison with age-matched controls is necessary (infants and young children normally have lymphocytosis compared with adults)
Low levels of any lymphocyte subset should be repeated and, if confirmed, followed by functional analysis of the respective immune system component.
The term delayed is used to differentiate a secondary cellular response, which appears 48-72 hours after antigen exposure, from an immediate hypersensitivity response, which generally appears within 12 minutes of an antigen challenge.
A documented history of Candida infection; a recent diphtheria, tetanus, or BCG vaccine; or a previously positive tuberculin reaction is necessary to interpret a response to these antigens
used to further assess the cellular immune system.
The ability of lymphocytes to proliferate to mitogens (phytohemagglutinin, concanavalin, pokeweed), stimulatory monoclonal antibodies (anti-CD3), or allogeneic cells (in a mixed leukocyte reaction) indicates intact lymphocyte activation to nonspecific stimuli.
Children undergoing evaluation for recurrent infection need special care during the evaluation process . This includes:
measle-mumps-rubella MMR