SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 33
Particularized and Generalized Trust: The Indirect Relationship of Trust on Economic Development Saqer Al-Khalifa Claremont Graduate University Saqer.al-khalifa@cgu.edu
Question How important is Trust or Networks in a society?Does it matter if one society has more trust than another?
dilemma Institutional adjustments in developing world are withheld because of fear from political spillover. Thus, rejection to such shifts is at the expense of the economic wellbeing.
Neoclassical Growth Models Eventually growth to reach steady state because of diminishing returns to capital. Blamed exogenous factors when predictions and explanations did not match. Theorists argued technology and institutions continuously develop and prevent decrease in growth. The growth models developed when critical non-economic factors were included.
The process of democratization Conflicting arguments with regards to the relationship between democracy and economics. Democracy & Autocracy: Two faces of a coin. Roving versus stationary bandit. Mancur Olson (1993) Politics in democracies is two edged sword. Boix (1999), Bueno De Mesquita et al. (2005)
Institutions ,[object Object]
Schedler et. al (1999): Accountability and Enforcement.
North (1991): Cooperation is better achieved when individuals have information about each other.? Societal Development Institutions
Trust ,[object Object]
Fukuyama (2000): Social capital is “the circle of people among whom cooperative norms are operative.”
Uslaner and Brown (2003): “Greater equality and higher levels of trust are two pathways to participation.”,[object Object]
Wang and Gordon (2006): “We would think that whether trust could be taken as a causal factor can boil down to basically a definitional issue.”
Deduced that trust is:
Particularized: Trusting people you know or know something about. (Berggren and Jordahl)
Generalized: Trusting people in general.,[object Object]
 What is the relationship between both types of Trust?,[object Object]
Theory: Simplified Particularized Trust Generalized Trust Particularized Trust Institutions Institutions Economic Wellbeing Institutions Generalized Trust
Cooperate  Defect Parallel Analogy 3,3 0,5 Cooperate X 6 Defect 0,5 1,1 Conclusion: Rational individuals in a society  act selfish and therefore cooperate to maximize  self-gain.
Theory Individual Level Particularized Trust Institutions Generalized Trust Particularized Trust Institutions Economic Wellbeing National Level Generalized Trust
Hypothesis P.T.			    Institutions			 G.T. H1: An increase in Particularized Trust is associated with an Increase in Generalized Trust, mediated by institutions.
Hypothesis P.T.			     Institutions			(Individual) P.T.			     Institutions			(National) H2: At both the individual and national level, an increase in Particularized leads to a positive change in formal institutions.
Hypothesis Particularized Trust		Institutions       			GDP/Cap H3: Institutions mediate apositive relationship between Particularized Trust and Economic Progress.
Methodology:Casual Steps Approach Introduced by Baron and Kenny (1986) IV		DV = Significant when mediator not included IV		Mediator = Significant Mediator	DV = Significant when IV included (given absolute value of IV here is less than absolute value in #1)
Individual/National Level:Equations EQ.1 EQ.2 EQ.3
Particularized and Generalized Trust in Unites States Substantive Effects
Particularized and Generalized Trust in Italy Substantive Effects
National Level Analysis
National Level Analysis II Eq. 4 Eq. 5 Eq. 6
Ending Remarks Results falsify literature that argue Institutions effect Economic Development through ‘trust’. Increase in trusting people you know or know something about is vital for economic development. Shifts in domestic and foreign policy: Ex. Instead of establishing new institutions, invest in increasing Particularized Trust in societies.
Questions?

More Related Content

Similar to Trust and Institutions

International organization membership the human return on investment
International organization membership  the human return on investmentInternational organization membership  the human return on investment
International organization membership the human return on investment
jpeterson2058
 
338555ms_master_thesis
338555ms_master_thesis338555ms_master_thesis
338555ms_master_thesis
Matthew Seely
 
Bachelor thesis_value creation_event_management
Bachelor thesis_value creation_event_managementBachelor thesis_value creation_event_management
Bachelor thesis_value creation_event_management
Tudor Carstoiu
 
Review Essay Example
Review Essay ExampleReview Essay Example
Review Essay Example
zseetlnfg
 
Modernism And Symbolic-Interpretivism Theory &Amp;...
Modernism And Symbolic-Interpretivism Theory &Amp;...Modernism And Symbolic-Interpretivism Theory &Amp;...
Modernism And Symbolic-Interpretivism Theory &Amp;...
Carla Jardine
 
Response with 250 words each. Response 1Intergovernmenta.docx
Response with 250 words each.  Response 1Intergovernmenta.docxResponse with 250 words each.  Response 1Intergovernmenta.docx
Response with 250 words each. Response 1Intergovernmenta.docx
zmark3
 

Similar to Trust and Institutions (20)

International organization membership the human return on investment
International organization membership  the human return on investmentInternational organization membership  the human return on investment
International organization membership the human return on investment
 
Removal of subsidy a question of trust
Removal of subsidy a question of trustRemoval of subsidy a question of trust
Removal of subsidy a question of trust
 
Power and trust
Power and trustPower and trust
Power and trust
 
Independent study -danika tynes--analysis of indicator well-being gap
Independent study -danika tynes--analysis of indicator well-being gapIndependent study -danika tynes--analysis of indicator well-being gap
Independent study -danika tynes--analysis of indicator well-being gap
 
Trust and Economic Policy
Trust and Economic PolicyTrust and Economic Policy
Trust and Economic Policy
 
338555ms_master_thesis
338555ms_master_thesis338555ms_master_thesis
338555ms_master_thesis
 
Institutional Trust, Sector Confidence, and Charitable Giving
Institutional Trust, Sector Confidence, and Charitable GivingInstitutional Trust, Sector Confidence, and Charitable Giving
Institutional Trust, Sector Confidence, and Charitable Giving
 
Bachelor thesis_value creation_event_management
Bachelor thesis_value creation_event_managementBachelor thesis_value creation_event_management
Bachelor thesis_value creation_event_management
 
DISSERTATION
DISSERTATIONDISSERTATION
DISSERTATION
 
Structure For Essay
Structure For EssayStructure For Essay
Structure For Essay
 
Review Essay Example
Review Essay ExampleReview Essay Example
Review Essay Example
 
Institutional and Capacity Development
Institutional and Capacity DevelopmentInstitutional and Capacity Development
Institutional and Capacity Development
 
Independent study -danika tynes--the road for the healthcare system in uganda
Independent study -danika tynes--the road for the healthcare system in ugandaIndependent study -danika tynes--the road for the healthcare system in uganda
Independent study -danika tynes--the road for the healthcare system in uganda
 
Modernism And Symbolic-Interpretivism Theory &Amp;...
Modernism And Symbolic-Interpretivism Theory &Amp;...Modernism And Symbolic-Interpretivism Theory &Amp;...
Modernism And Symbolic-Interpretivism Theory &Amp;...
 
Effect of Govt Funding
Effect of Govt FundingEffect of Govt Funding
Effect of Govt Funding
 
Capstone Paper 2014
Capstone Paper 2014Capstone Paper 2014
Capstone Paper 2014
 
2009 Trajkov Social Capital
2009 Trajkov Social Capital2009 Trajkov Social Capital
2009 Trajkov Social Capital
 
HLEG thematic workshop on Measuring Trust and Social Capital, Bo Rothstein
HLEG thematic workshop on Measuring Trust and Social Capital, Bo RothsteinHLEG thematic workshop on Measuring Trust and Social Capital, Bo Rothstein
HLEG thematic workshop on Measuring Trust and Social Capital, Bo Rothstein
 
Challenging power and challenging the way we think about power
Challenging power and challenging the way we think about powerChallenging power and challenging the way we think about power
Challenging power and challenging the way we think about power
 
Response with 250 words each. Response 1Intergovernmenta.docx
Response with 250 words each.  Response 1Intergovernmenta.docxResponse with 250 words each.  Response 1Intergovernmenta.docx
Response with 250 words each. Response 1Intergovernmenta.docx
 

Trust and Institutions

  • 1. Particularized and Generalized Trust: The Indirect Relationship of Trust on Economic Development Saqer Al-Khalifa Claremont Graduate University Saqer.al-khalifa@cgu.edu
  • 2. Question How important is Trust or Networks in a society?Does it matter if one society has more trust than another?
  • 3. dilemma Institutional adjustments in developing world are withheld because of fear from political spillover. Thus, rejection to such shifts is at the expense of the economic wellbeing.
  • 4. Neoclassical Growth Models Eventually growth to reach steady state because of diminishing returns to capital. Blamed exogenous factors when predictions and explanations did not match. Theorists argued technology and institutions continuously develop and prevent decrease in growth. The growth models developed when critical non-economic factors were included.
  • 5. The process of democratization Conflicting arguments with regards to the relationship between democracy and economics. Democracy & Autocracy: Two faces of a coin. Roving versus stationary bandit. Mancur Olson (1993) Politics in democracies is two edged sword. Boix (1999), Bueno De Mesquita et al. (2005)
  • 6.
  • 7. Schedler et. al (1999): Accountability and Enforcement.
  • 8. North (1991): Cooperation is better achieved when individuals have information about each other.? Societal Development Institutions
  • 9.
  • 10. Fukuyama (2000): Social capital is “the circle of people among whom cooperative norms are operative.”
  • 11.
  • 12. Wang and Gordon (2006): “We would think that whether trust could be taken as a causal factor can boil down to basically a definitional issue.”
  • 14. Particularized: Trusting people you know or know something about. (Berggren and Jordahl)
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17. Theory: Simplified Particularized Trust Generalized Trust Particularized Trust Institutions Institutions Economic Wellbeing Institutions Generalized Trust
  • 18. Cooperate Defect Parallel Analogy 3,3 0,5 Cooperate X 6 Defect 0,5 1,1 Conclusion: Rational individuals in a society act selfish and therefore cooperate to maximize self-gain.
  • 19. Theory Individual Level Particularized Trust Institutions Generalized Trust Particularized Trust Institutions Economic Wellbeing National Level Generalized Trust
  • 20. Hypothesis P.T. Institutions G.T. H1: An increase in Particularized Trust is associated with an Increase in Generalized Trust, mediated by institutions.
  • 21. Hypothesis P.T. Institutions (Individual) P.T. Institutions (National) H2: At both the individual and national level, an increase in Particularized leads to a positive change in formal institutions.
  • 22. Hypothesis Particularized Trust Institutions GDP/Cap H3: Institutions mediate apositive relationship between Particularized Trust and Economic Progress.
  • 23. Methodology:Casual Steps Approach Introduced by Baron and Kenny (1986) IV DV = Significant when mediator not included IV Mediator = Significant Mediator DV = Significant when IV included (given absolute value of IV here is less than absolute value in #1)
  • 25. Particularized and Generalized Trust in Unites States Substantive Effects
  • 26. Particularized and Generalized Trust in Italy Substantive Effects
  • 28. National Level Analysis II Eq. 4 Eq. 5 Eq. 6
  • 29. Ending Remarks Results falsify literature that argue Institutions effect Economic Development through ‘trust’. Increase in trusting people you know or know something about is vital for economic development. Shifts in domestic and foreign policy: Ex. Instead of establishing new institutions, invest in increasing Particularized Trust in societies.
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35. Proposed Theory Particularized Trust Institutions Economic Wellbeing ? Generalized Trust
  • 36.
  • 37. Goals How to approach foreign and domestic policies that care for societal development without threatening the stability of governance.
  • 38.
  • 39.

Editor's Notes

  1. It is important here to understand that when attempting to explain a certain phenomenon, one should not limit himself to the prism at hand. Thus, I am attempting to explain….
  2. Boix: democracies not efficient if they lack the proper institutions that constrain leaders from altering the system.
  3. Boix: democracies not efficient if they lack the proper institutions that constrain leaders from altering the system.
  4. Boix: democracies not efficient if they lack the proper institutions that constrain leaders from altering the system.
  5. payoff
  6. Increased mobility: Ju and Wei 2007