SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 19
The Art and Science of Cellulosic Fermentation Nicolai Panikov
Bioreactors
More rigorous experimental test requires advanced instrumental techniques  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Capacitance  ,[object Object],[object Object]
Gaseous Fermentation Products ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],CO2 on-line analysis
Mass-spectrometry
Example of gas monitoring with portable mass-spec: fermentation with cell recycle
Verification of analytical tools:   full recovery of C-balance (chemostat culture of  C. thermocellum
Conversion of cellulose to products Cellulose    CD + CB    Cells +  Enzymes  +  Fermentation Products
Easy case: cellulose degradation is tightly coupled to fermentation & cell growth Cellulose CO 2 Cellulose hydrolysis rate
Example of uncoupling: delay in fermentation & growth (not cellulose degradation!)  after prolonged cell starvation in batch culture  Residual cellulose  CO 2   Arrow  indicates addition of fresh medium with microcrystalline cellulose
Other intermediates and fermentation products during temporary metabolic arrest
Take home message: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cellulose fermentation:  How kinetic/mathematical model should be modified ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Simulation Biomass Cellulases Cellobiose and CD (cellodextrins) Residual cellulose Equation Variable
Fermentation Pathway 0.5 Glu Pyr Glycerol Lac EtOH Ace Acetyl-CoA Acetald H 2 CO 2 Fd(red) Fd(ox) NAD NADH 2H + ADP ATP SH-CoA NADH NAD SH-CoA NADH NAD NAD NADH NAD NADH ADP ATP SH-CoA 0.85  CD ADP ATP (C 6 H 10 O 5 ) n 6.67" 0.15  Cells ~8%
Unexpected results of  C. thermocellum : Simulation: Multistability of Steady States Residual cellulose Cell mass
C. thermocellum : Residual Solids (Cellulose + Cells) vs Dilution Rate  Observation Conventional chemostat model
Good agreement between calculation and experimental data

More Related Content

Similar to The Art And Science

Microbial catalysis of syngas fermentation into biofuels precursors - An expe...
Microbial catalysis of syngas fermentation into biofuels precursors - An expe...Microbial catalysis of syngas fermentation into biofuels precursors - An expe...
Microbial catalysis of syngas fermentation into biofuels precursors - An expe...Pratap Jung Rai
 
Metabolomic and thermodynamic analysis of C. thermocellum strains engineered ...
Metabolomic and thermodynamic analysis of C. thermocellum strains engineered ...Metabolomic and thermodynamic analysis of C. thermocellum strains engineered ...
Metabolomic and thermodynamic analysis of C. thermocellum strains engineered ...Jordan Brown
 
Fermentation ppt
Fermentation pptFermentation ppt
Fermentation pptpkdsshukla
 
JBEI Research Highlights - November 2017
JBEI Research Highlights - November 2017 JBEI Research Highlights - November 2017
JBEI Research Highlights - November 2017 Irina Silva
 
BioH2Conference, Alessandro Carmona
BioH2Conference, Alessandro CarmonaBioH2Conference, Alessandro Carmona
BioH2Conference, Alessandro CarmonaIMDEA-Water
 
Cellular respiration ppt wit turning pt qs
Cellular respiration ppt wit turning pt qsCellular respiration ppt wit turning pt qs
Cellular respiration ppt wit turning pt qstas11244
 
The Subliminal Toolbox: automating steps in the reconstruction of metabolic n...
The Subliminal Toolbox: automating steps in the reconstruction of metabolic n...The Subliminal Toolbox: automating steps in the reconstruction of metabolic n...
The Subliminal Toolbox: automating steps in the reconstruction of metabolic n...Neil Swainston
 
Chapt08 lecture
Chapt08 lectureChapt08 lecture
Chapt08 lecturecdobrow
 
F 15 Lab 22 Carbohydrate metabolism
F 15 Lab 22 Carbohydrate metabolismF 15 Lab 22 Carbohydrate metabolism
F 15 Lab 22 Carbohydrate metabolismBharat Patel
 
Fermentation ppt
Fermentation pptFermentation ppt
Fermentation pptpkdsshukla
 
Fermentation ppt
Fermentation pptFermentation ppt
Fermentation pptpkdsshukla
 
glycolisis: fate of pyruvate
glycolisis: fate of pyruvate glycolisis: fate of pyruvate
glycolisis: fate of pyruvate CHIRANTANMONDAL2
 
Monoclonal antibodies,Production + bioseperartion
Monoclonal antibodies,Production + bioseperartionMonoclonal antibodies,Production + bioseperartion
Monoclonal antibodies,Production + bioseperartionshadan87
 
Respiration5beyondglucose
Respiration5beyondglucoseRespiration5beyondglucose
Respiration5beyondglucosehursmi
 
ET Presentation - 2019BCHE024.pptx
ET Presentation - 2019BCHE024.pptxET Presentation - 2019BCHE024.pptx
ET Presentation - 2019BCHE024.pptxSartajSagroo
 

Similar to The Art And Science (20)

Microbial catalysis of syngas fermentation into biofuels precursors - An expe...
Microbial catalysis of syngas fermentation into biofuels precursors - An expe...Microbial catalysis of syngas fermentation into biofuels precursors - An expe...
Microbial catalysis of syngas fermentation into biofuels precursors - An expe...
 
Metabolomic and thermodynamic analysis of C. thermocellum strains engineered ...
Metabolomic and thermodynamic analysis of C. thermocellum strains engineered ...Metabolomic and thermodynamic analysis of C. thermocellum strains engineered ...
Metabolomic and thermodynamic analysis of C. thermocellum strains engineered ...
 
Fermentation ppt
Fermentation pptFermentation ppt
Fermentation ppt
 
JBEI Research Highlights - November 2017
JBEI Research Highlights - November 2017 JBEI Research Highlights - November 2017
JBEI Research Highlights - November 2017
 
Metabolism c
Metabolism cMetabolism c
Metabolism c
 
BioH2Conference, Alessandro Carmona
BioH2Conference, Alessandro CarmonaBioH2Conference, Alessandro Carmona
BioH2Conference, Alessandro Carmona
 
Cellular respiration ppt wit turning pt qs
Cellular respiration ppt wit turning pt qsCellular respiration ppt wit turning pt qs
Cellular respiration ppt wit turning pt qs
 
The Subliminal Toolbox: automating steps in the reconstruction of metabolic n...
The Subliminal Toolbox: automating steps in the reconstruction of metabolic n...The Subliminal Toolbox: automating steps in the reconstruction of metabolic n...
The Subliminal Toolbox: automating steps in the reconstruction of metabolic n...
 
Chapt08 lecture
Chapt08 lectureChapt08 lecture
Chapt08 lecture
 
F 15 Lab 22 Carbohydrate metabolism
F 15 Lab 22 Carbohydrate metabolismF 15 Lab 22 Carbohydrate metabolism
F 15 Lab 22 Carbohydrate metabolism
 
Fermentation ppt
Fermentation pptFermentation ppt
Fermentation ppt
 
Fermentation ppt
Fermentation pptFermentation ppt
Fermentation ppt
 
Cell Respiration APBio
Cell Respiration APBioCell Respiration APBio
Cell Respiration APBio
 
Celluar Respiration
Celluar RespirationCelluar Respiration
Celluar Respiration
 
Chapter 9
Chapter 9Chapter 9
Chapter 9
 
glycolisis: fate of pyruvate
glycolisis: fate of pyruvate glycolisis: fate of pyruvate
glycolisis: fate of pyruvate
 
Monoclonal antibodies,Production + bioseperartion
Monoclonal antibodies,Production + bioseperartionMonoclonal antibodies,Production + bioseperartion
Monoclonal antibodies,Production + bioseperartion
 
Respiration5beyondglucose
Respiration5beyondglucoseRespiration5beyondglucose
Respiration5beyondglucose
 
Ugi Poster_for_Open_House
Ugi Poster_for_Open_HouseUgi Poster_for_Open_House
Ugi Poster_for_Open_House
 
ET Presentation - 2019BCHE024.pptx
ET Presentation - 2019BCHE024.pptxET Presentation - 2019BCHE024.pptx
ET Presentation - 2019BCHE024.pptx
 

The Art And Science

  • 1. The Art and Science of Cellulosic Fermentation Nicolai Panikov
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 7. Example of gas monitoring with portable mass-spec: fermentation with cell recycle
  • 8. Verification of analytical tools: full recovery of C-balance (chemostat culture of C. thermocellum
  • 9. Conversion of cellulose to products Cellulose  CD + CB  Cells + Enzymes + Fermentation Products
  • 10. Easy case: cellulose degradation is tightly coupled to fermentation & cell growth Cellulose CO 2 Cellulose hydrolysis rate
  • 11. Example of uncoupling: delay in fermentation & growth (not cellulose degradation!) after prolonged cell starvation in batch culture Residual cellulose CO 2 Arrow indicates addition of fresh medium with microcrystalline cellulose
  • 12. Other intermediates and fermentation products during temporary metabolic arrest
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15. Simulation Biomass Cellulases Cellobiose and CD (cellodextrins) Residual cellulose Equation Variable
  • 16. Fermentation Pathway 0.5 Glu Pyr Glycerol Lac EtOH Ace Acetyl-CoA Acetald H 2 CO 2 Fd(red) Fd(ox) NAD NADH 2H + ADP ATP SH-CoA NADH NAD SH-CoA NADH NAD NAD NADH NAD NADH ADP ATP SH-CoA 0.85 CD ADP ATP (C 6 H 10 O 5 ) n 6.67" 0.15 Cells ~8%
  • 17. Unexpected results of C. thermocellum : Simulation: Multistability of Steady States Residual cellulose Cell mass
  • 18. C. thermocellum : Residual Solids (Cellulose + Cells) vs Dilution Rate Observation Conventional chemostat model
  • 19. Good agreement between calculation and experimental data