SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
M4P Experience
Pakistan - Afghanistan
Experience
Coriander Value Chain
 Sub-sector Analysis to
identify potentials and gaps
 Conducted research for
reasons behind
 Facilitated to develop:
 Technical support
 Extension Program
 Implemented through
Public sector
Features
1. Helps better
understanding of the sub-
sector (Impediments &
Opportunities)
2. Underlines reasons of the
impediments
3. Capacity building of the
services sector
4. Synergies with market
actors
5. Helps design appropriate
intervention/s
Relevance & Strength
• Need-based
• Potential to Upscale
• Sustainablity
Questions
• Sustainable Livelihoods vs M4P
• How to deal with the monopolizing market actors
(private sector – controlled by political elite)
• Rules (should we go for policy advocacy to improve
regulations/standards/laws for market) it requires
process, lots of time & money
• How to deal with Development Actors with heavily
subsidized market development strategy
• Is gender or social equity applicable in each market
• How to deal unpredictable security issues

More Related Content

What's hot

Value Chain Analysis and Development Training
Value Chain Analysis and Development Training Value Chain Analysis and Development Training
Value Chain Analysis and Development Training Teshale Endalamaw
 
Operational guide for_the_m4_p_approach
Operational guide for_the_m4_p_approachOperational guide for_the_m4_p_approach
Operational guide for_the_m4_p_approachAumm Sermsiri
 
The Value Chain Approach to Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction
The Value Chain Approach to Economic Growth and Poverty ReductionThe Value Chain Approach to Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction
The Value Chain Approach to Economic Growth and Poverty ReductionJason Wolfe
 
Value Chain Development and The Poor
Value Chain Development and The Poor   Value Chain Development and The Poor
Value Chain Development and The Poor IFPRI-PIM
 
Lecture 1 intro to market ana & tools
Lecture 1 intro to market ana & toolsLecture 1 intro to market ana & tools
Lecture 1 intro to market ana & toolsBKMEA
 
Industry and Competitor Analysis-SM-MBA
Industry and Competitor Analysis-SM-MBAIndustry and Competitor Analysis-SM-MBA
Industry and Competitor Analysis-SM-MBAChandra Shekar Immani
 
FoodTrade ESA approach to political economy of staple foods trade
FoodTrade ESA approach to political economy of staple foods tradeFoodTrade ESA approach to political economy of staple foods trade
FoodTrade ESA approach to political economy of staple foods tradeFoodTradeESA2013
 
ASIA FISH MODELING
ASIA FISH MODELINGASIA FISH MODELING
ASIA FISH MODELINGHermanto .
 

What's hot (20)

Day 3 Skills Building Training
Day 3 Skills Building Training Day 3 Skills Building Training
Day 3 Skills Building Training
 
Value Chain Analysis and Development Training
Value Chain Analysis and Development Training Value Chain Analysis and Development Training
Value Chain Analysis and Development Training
 
Merger Control in Dynamic Markets – OECD – December 2019 OECD discussion
Merger Control in Dynamic Markets – OECD – December 2019 OECD discussionMerger Control in Dynamic Markets – OECD – December 2019 OECD discussion
Merger Control in Dynamic Markets – OECD – December 2019 OECD discussion
 
Operational guide for_the_m4_p_approach
Operational guide for_the_m4_p_approachOperational guide for_the_m4_p_approach
Operational guide for_the_m4_p_approach
 
Methodologies to Measure Market Competition – CABRAL PIRES-ALVES – June 2021 ...
Methodologies to Measure Market Competition – CABRAL PIRES-ALVES – June 2021 ...Methodologies to Measure Market Competition – CABRAL PIRES-ALVES – June 2021 ...
Methodologies to Measure Market Competition – CABRAL PIRES-ALVES – June 2021 ...
 
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...
 
#CPAF15 WS2: Value Chain Integration (Monika Sopov, Joost Guijt, Centre for D...
#CPAF15 WS2: Value Chain Integration (Monika Sopov, Joost Guijt, Centre for D...#CPAF15 WS2: Value Chain Integration (Monika Sopov, Joost Guijt, Centre for D...
#CPAF15 WS2: Value Chain Integration (Monika Sopov, Joost Guijt, Centre for D...
 
Ex-Ante Regulation and Competition in Digital Markets – OECD Secretariat – De...
Ex-Ante Regulation and Competition in Digital Markets – OECD Secretariat – De...Ex-Ante Regulation and Competition in Digital Markets – OECD Secretariat – De...
Ex-Ante Regulation and Competition in Digital Markets – OECD Secretariat – De...
 
October 2021 Newsletter: OECD KPC Asia-Pacific Competition News
October 2021 Newsletter: OECD KPC Asia-Pacific Competition NewsOctober 2021 Newsletter: OECD KPC Asia-Pacific Competition News
October 2021 Newsletter: OECD KPC Asia-Pacific Competition News
 
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 3 – The role o...
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 3 – The role o...Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 3 – The role o...
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 3 – The role o...
 
Merger assessment in publicly funded markets
Merger assessment in publicly funded marketsMerger assessment in publicly funded markets
Merger assessment in publicly funded markets
 
The Value Chain Approach to Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction
The Value Chain Approach to Economic Growth and Poverty ReductionThe Value Chain Approach to Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction
The Value Chain Approach to Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction
 
Value Chain Development and The Poor
Value Chain Development and The Poor   Value Chain Development and The Poor
Value Chain Development and The Poor
 
Lecture 1 intro to market ana & tools
Lecture 1 intro to market ana & toolsLecture 1 intro to market ana & tools
Lecture 1 intro to market ana & tools
 
Industry and Competitor Analysis-SM-MBA
Industry and Competitor Analysis-SM-MBAIndustry and Competitor Analysis-SM-MBA
Industry and Competitor Analysis-SM-MBA
 
Ensuring Effective Competition in public procurement
Ensuring Effective Competition in public procurementEnsuring Effective Competition in public procurement
Ensuring Effective Competition in public procurement
 
Competition in Publicly Funded Markets – Chris Pike – OECD Competition Divisi...
Competition in Publicly Funded Markets – Chris Pike – OECD Competition Divisi...Competition in Publicly Funded Markets – Chris Pike – OECD Competition Divisi...
Competition in Publicly Funded Markets – Chris Pike – OECD Competition Divisi...
 
FoodTrade ESA approach to political economy of staple foods trade
FoodTrade ESA approach to political economy of staple foods tradeFoodTrade ESA approach to political economy of staple foods trade
FoodTrade ESA approach to political economy of staple foods trade
 
Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – CALCAGNO – December 2021 OECD...
Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – CALCAGNO – December 2021 OECD...Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – CALCAGNO – December 2021 OECD...
Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – CALCAGNO – December 2021 OECD...
 
ASIA FISH MODELING
ASIA FISH MODELINGASIA FISH MODELING
ASIA FISH MODELING
 

Similar to Group discussion Pakistan & Afghanistan

Gender in the participatory market chain approach
Gender in the participatory market chain approachGender in the participatory market chain approach
Gender in the participatory market chain approachCGIAR
 
Unit 2 rorest based enterprse.pptx
Unit 2 rorest based enterprse.pptxUnit 2 rorest based enterprse.pptx
Unit 2 rorest based enterprse.pptxNabarajUpadhaya
 
Ppt soc as a service market
Ppt  soc as a service marketPpt  soc as a service market
Ppt soc as a service marketDheerajPawar4
 
Student information system market ppt
Student information system market pptStudent information system market ppt
Student information system market pptDheerajPawar4
 
Content intelligence market ppt
Content intelligence market pptContent intelligence market ppt
Content intelligence market pptDheerajPawar4
 
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013cgxchange
 
Customer success platforms market ppt
Customer success platforms market  pptCustomer success platforms market  ppt
Customer success platforms market pptDheerajPawar4
 
Customer success platforms market ppt
Customer success platforms market  pptCustomer success platforms market  ppt
Customer success platforms market pptDheerajPawar4
 
Physical identity and access management market industry analysis and forecast
Physical identity and access management market industry analysis and forecastPhysical identity and access management market industry analysis and forecast
Physical identity and access management market industry analysis and forecastDheerajPawar4
 
Physical identity and access management market vendors by share & growth ...
Physical identity and access management market vendors by share & growth ...Physical identity and access management market vendors by share & growth ...
Physical identity and access management market vendors by share & growth ...DheerajPawar4
 
Connected mining market worth 9.98 billion usd by 2020
Connected mining market worth 9.98 billion usd by 2020Connected mining market worth 9.98 billion usd by 2020
Connected mining market worth 9.98 billion usd by 2020DheerajPawar4
 
E-Learning Market.pdf
E-Learning Market.pdfE-Learning Market.pdf
E-Learning Market.pdfpujarathod4
 
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013CGIAR
 
Factors that Influence Demand
Factors that Influence DemandFactors that Influence Demand
Factors that Influence DemandwaQas ilYas
 
Assessment and commercialization of entrepreneurial opportunities
Assessment and commercialization of entrepreneurial opportunitiesAssessment and commercialization of entrepreneurial opportunities
Assessment and commercialization of entrepreneurial opportunitiesTecnológico de Monterrey
 
Session 5 - Socio-Economic Futures_Datuk Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour_
Session 5 - Socio-Economic Futures_Datuk Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour_Session 5 - Socio-Economic Futures_Datuk Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour_
Session 5 - Socio-Economic Futures_Datuk Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour_KhazanahResearchInstitute
 
2016 - Developang the Framework for an Innovation Strategy
2016 - Developang the Framework for an Innovation Strategy2016 - Developang the Framework for an Innovation Strategy
2016 - Developang the Framework for an Innovation StrategyNadia Lushchak
 

Similar to Group discussion Pakistan & Afghanistan (20)

Chain analysis
Chain analysisChain analysis
Chain analysis
 
Gender in the participatory market chain approach
Gender in the participatory market chain approachGender in the participatory market chain approach
Gender in the participatory market chain approach
 
Unit 2 rorest based enterprse.pptx
Unit 2 rorest based enterprse.pptxUnit 2 rorest based enterprse.pptx
Unit 2 rorest based enterprse.pptx
 
Ppt soc as a service market
Ppt  soc as a service marketPpt  soc as a service market
Ppt soc as a service market
 
Student information system market ppt
Student information system market pptStudent information system market ppt
Student information system market ppt
 
Content intelligence market ppt
Content intelligence market pptContent intelligence market ppt
Content intelligence market ppt
 
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013
 
Customer success platforms market ppt
Customer success platforms market  pptCustomer success platforms market  ppt
Customer success platforms market ppt
 
Customer success platforms market ppt
Customer success platforms market  pptCustomer success platforms market  ppt
Customer success platforms market ppt
 
Physical identity and access management market industry analysis and forecast
Physical identity and access management market industry analysis and forecastPhysical identity and access management market industry analysis and forecast
Physical identity and access management market industry analysis and forecast
 
Physical identity and access management market vendors by share & growth ...
Physical identity and access management market vendors by share & growth ...Physical identity and access management market vendors by share & growth ...
Physical identity and access management market vendors by share & growth ...
 
Connected mining market worth 9.98 billion usd by 2020
Connected mining market worth 9.98 billion usd by 2020Connected mining market worth 9.98 billion usd by 2020
Connected mining market worth 9.98 billion usd by 2020
 
2014-Navigate-Essentials Foundations of Market Entry Strategies
2014-Navigate-Essentials Foundations of Market Entry Strategies2014-Navigate-Essentials Foundations of Market Entry Strategies
2014-Navigate-Essentials Foundations of Market Entry Strategies
 
E-Learning Market.pdf
E-Learning Market.pdfE-Learning Market.pdf
E-Learning Market.pdf
 
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013
PIM - Presentation for Discussion with Donors and Partners - June 2013
 
Factors that Influence Demand
Factors that Influence DemandFactors that Influence Demand
Factors that Influence Demand
 
Assessment and commercialization of entrepreneurial opportunities
Assessment and commercialization of entrepreneurial opportunitiesAssessment and commercialization of entrepreneurial opportunities
Assessment and commercialization of entrepreneurial opportunities
 
MARKETING FUNCTION
 MARKETING FUNCTION MARKETING FUNCTION
MARKETING FUNCTION
 
Session 5 - Socio-Economic Futures_Datuk Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour_
Session 5 - Socio-Economic Futures_Datuk Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour_Session 5 - Socio-Economic Futures_Datuk Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour_
Session 5 - Socio-Economic Futures_Datuk Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour_
 
2016 - Developang the Framework for an Innovation Strategy
2016 - Developang the Framework for an Innovation Strategy2016 - Developang the Framework for an Innovation Strategy
2016 - Developang the Framework for an Innovation Strategy
 

More from HELVETAS Swiss Intercooperation Viet Nam (8)

Eco-Cocoa Project Presentation
Eco-Cocoa Project PresentationEco-Cocoa Project Presentation
Eco-Cocoa Project Presentation
 
Women Economic Empowerment
Women Economic EmpowermentWomen Economic Empowerment
Women Economic Empowerment
 
Moving from a Livelihood to Market Development Approach
Moving from a Livelihood to Market Development ApproachMoving from a Livelihood to Market Development Approach
Moving from a Livelihood to Market Development Approach
 
Achieving Scale in Value Chain/Market System Development
Achieving Scale in Value Chain/Market System DevelopmentAchieving Scale in Value Chain/Market System Development
Achieving Scale in Value Chain/Market System Development
 
The role of Farmer Organizations in Building bridges between Suppliers and Bu...
The role of Farmer Organizations in Building bridges between Suppliers and Bu...The role of Farmer Organizations in Building bridges between Suppliers and Bu...
The role of Farmer Organizations in Building bridges between Suppliers and Bu...
 
Working with private sector enterprise
Working with private sector enterpriseWorking with private sector enterprise
Working with private sector enterprise
 
Group discussion Kyrzystan & Takjikistan
Group discussion Kyrzystan & TakjikistanGroup discussion Kyrzystan & Takjikistan
Group discussion Kyrzystan & Takjikistan
 
Group discussion Nepal & Bhutan
Group discussion Nepal & BhutanGroup discussion Nepal & Bhutan
Group discussion Nepal & Bhutan
 

Group discussion Pakistan & Afghanistan

  • 2. Experience Coriander Value Chain  Sub-sector Analysis to identify potentials and gaps  Conducted research for reasons behind  Facilitated to develop:  Technical support  Extension Program  Implemented through Public sector Features 1. Helps better understanding of the sub- sector (Impediments & Opportunities) 2. Underlines reasons of the impediments 3. Capacity building of the services sector 4. Synergies with market actors 5. Helps design appropriate intervention/s
  • 3. Relevance & Strength • Need-based • Potential to Upscale • Sustainablity
  • 4. Questions • Sustainable Livelihoods vs M4P • How to deal with the monopolizing market actors (private sector – controlled by political elite) • Rules (should we go for policy advocacy to improve regulations/standards/laws for market) it requires process, lots of time & money • How to deal with Development Actors with heavily subsidized market development strategy • Is gender or social equity applicable in each market • How to deal unpredictable security issues