1. How to Make Behavior Change Last
Home Articles Interviews Past Issues Advertise Directory Contact us Subscribe Blog Events
Healthcare Reform
How to Make Behavior Change Last
Michael White
Jul 8, 2010
One in five of American adults smoke. Half of the smoking population tries and fails to quit each year. Two thirds
of us are overweight or obese and 95% of our diet plans fail. The medical community tells us that 70% of
premature death and aging is lifestyle-related – a result of our bad health habits. Changing behavior is not easy.
We keep trying, but, in most cases, we fail. It is robbing us of happiness, health, energy, and life.
Threats and enticements are external forces that can lead to short-term changes. Changes that result from outside
pressure, whether it is a “carrot” or a “stick”, often do not last. Such pressure causes reactionary behavior that is
not sustainable. When the carrot is no longer enough, or when the stick is no longer threatening to us, we revert to
old behaviors. “Lasting” change requires more than a carrot or stick approach. Lasting change requires a
conscious choice.
http://www.corporatewellnessmagazine.com/article-detail.php?issue=issue-12&article=how-to-make-behavior-change-last[8/2/2010 4:10:46 PM]
2. How to Make Behavior Change Last
A Workplace Wellness “Learning” Experience
Creating lasting behavior change in the workplace, to increase the happiness, health, and productivity of the
workforce, is not an easy task. A company that I recently worked with learned just how hard it can be. The
company had implemented an in-house wellness program for its 70 employees. Half of the workforce was obese
and a third used tobacco products. Health care claims and costs, as well as employee sick days, were rising.
Management came up with the idea to offer a carrot to employees who were willing to make an effort to be more
fit and healthy. It rewarded people with a cash incentive, of up to $40 per month, for doing things like: not
smoking, getting at least seven hours of sleep, drinking 32 oz. of water during the work day, and doing some form
of aerobic exercise – all aimed at improving health, and increasing energy and productivity on the job.
Participation was over 90% the first month. For those that stuck with it, incredible gains were made. Some
employees lost as much as 60 lbs. Other people were taken off medications by their doctors when cholesterol and
blood pressure numbers improved. However, by the end of six months, only one third of employees were
participating and weight loss was beginning to reverse itself. What happened? The carrot was no longer enough.
New habits went away and old habits returned. Behavior change did not last. Failure to produce lasting change in
the workforce encouraged management to understand how such change occurs, or new habits develop, before
considering a new wellness initiative.
Understanding Behavior Change
Stephen Covey, in his Seven Habits of Highly Effective People, suggests that three things have to be present to
form a habit: 1) desire – the “why to do”, 2) knowledge – the “what to do”, and 3) skill – the “how to do”. Covey
further explains that change “has to be motivated
by a higher purpose, by the willingness to subordinate what you think you want now for what you want later”.
Let us look at a change in diet as a habit-forming example. You recognize that you do not eat a well-balanced
diet. The pleasure you find in your current eating habits is outweighed by health concerns, declining energy level,
and a bathroom scale that will not lie! These concerns provide a higher purpose to take action. The “desire” to eat
healthier is joined with“knowledge” of “what” good nutrition is, and the “skill” of “how” to shop for and prepare
healthy foods. All the ingredients of forming a new habit are present: desire, skill, and knowledge. How successful
we are in making this behavior change last will be mostly influenced by how powerful the desire is.
The initial desire is easy. Sustaining it is the challenge. Too often, we think of the change process in a negative
way. We want a quick fix. We are not patient with the process of creating “new normals” in our lives, which is
critical for lasting change to occur. We will walk that mile per day for a week or two, but, when the weight does not
drop precipitously, we revert to our former sedentary ways.
Chicago Life Coach, Sara McIntosh, offers advice on how to avoid this. Sara says, “We need to change our
thinking. We need to nurture a belief that our life is better with the changes that we are making. As we see
progress and experience success, the new habits will powerfully enhance our lives and perpetuate a desire to
continue. It becomes more important to remain at our new normal than to return to old behaviors. When we think
this and believe this, we can sustain lasting change.”
Lasting Change = Lasting Benefits
The majority of employees who returned to old behaviors in the first few months of the in-house wellness program
did not have a powerful desire to change. The carrot offered by management did not sustain changes in behavior.
Without sufficient desire, employees became discouraged and returned to comfortable old behaviors.
http://www.corporatewellnessmagazine.com/article-detail.php?issue=issue-12&article=how-to-make-behavior-change-last[8/2/2010 4:10:46 PM]