SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 3
Download to read offline
Business Energy Efficiency Consultation
Findings and Recommendations
Gary Corlett, SCE Field Engineer Evaporator Fan Controls - Phase 4 - Building 1
(805) 458-4828 Page 3 of 62 June 26, 2014
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
http://www.sce.com/business/ems/appdownload.htm or contact your SCE Account Executive,
Caroline Lee at (760) 900-4495 for additional information.
Saving electrical energy at your site not only lowers your operating costs, but saves California’s
environment. By implementing all of the above recommendations you can potentially save as much
as 589,413 kWh per year and DEER peak demand savings of 32.0 kW. This translates into an
estimated 267.4 metric tons of Greenhouse Gas that will not be emitted into California’s
atmosphere.
Potential Demand Response Opportunities
Potential Demand Response opportunities are itemized below. Details of these specific opportunities
are included in Appendices B and C.
Potential Demand Response Opportunities
Soln Code Solution Description Strategy
DR-30001 Process Machinery – Other Charge batteries and battery-operated equipment prior to an
event, then disconnect battery chargers and use only pre-
charged equipment during an event
DR-31882 HVAC Controls Cycle air-cooled package units and/or constant volume air
handling units by controls
DR-39151 Controls for Package Units or Central
Plants
Global temperature adjustment for air-cooled package units or
central plants
DR-44991 Lighting Controls/Switching Dim lights and/or shut off portion of lighting
Site Information
Site information was obtained during a site visit by Gary Corlett, SCE Field Engineer with Bob Farmer,
Carlisle Energy Solutions representing Field Fresh Foods on April 25, 2014.
Key Contact Information
Contact Title Phone Number E-mail Address
Carlos Castaneda General Manager (310) 719-8422 carlosc@fieldfresh.com
Bob Farmer Vendor
Representative
(714) 865-2111 bob@cescool.com
Al Linder Frigitek (831) 768-8848 al@frigitek.com
Caroline Lee Account Manager –
SCE
(760) 900-4495 caroline.lee@sce.com
Business Energy Efficiency Consultation
Findings and Recommendations
Gary Corlett, SCE Field Engineer Evaporator Fan Controls - Phase 4 - Building 1
(805) 458-4828 Page 4 of 62 June 26, 2014
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
The Field Fresh Foods facility is located in Gardena, California approximately 11 miles south of Los
Angeles and approximately 9 miles inland from the Pacific Ocean. Field Fresh Foods serves the
western United States, providing service, distribution and manufacturing that is based around
freshness rather than shelf-life. Every
vegetable is cut to order. Besides
individual raw vegetables, the company
also provides fresh vegetable platters
and mixed green salads.
Gardena is in Climate Zone 8. For the
purpose of this evaluation, this facility is
considered Type 33 – Refrigerated
Warehouse.
Building 1 used 2,383,274 kWh over
the past year, an average of 198,606
kWh per month. The peak demand was
403 kW, while the average demand was 360 kW. The average monthly bill for this account was
$23,758.38 at an average of $0.11963. (See the annual usage and demand in the charts below.)
Project Information
The Field Fresh Foods facility covers an area of ~3.5 acres containing about 70,550 square foot (SF)
of refrigerated warehouse and approximately 10,000 SF of office/mechanical and maintenance area.
The refrigerated warehouse areas are broken up into many smaller areas, each cooled by one or two
small compressor/condenser units and multiple evaporator units. The evaporator fans vary in size
from ¼-hp to ¾-hp each and the quantity of fans per evaporator unit varies from 2 to 5. These fans
run continuously, even when the condenser unit is satisfied and shuts down.
This project is Phase 4 of a multiphase project. In the previous phases, the fans were replaced with
fans having electronically commutated (EC) motors for more efficient operation and the ability to vary
the speed of the fan. In addition, controllers were added to each evaporator unit to control the fan
speed, operating the fan speed at 100% when the condenser unit is cycled on and reducing the fan
speed to approximately 25% percent when the condenser unit has cycled off. Although the customer
achieves savings from changing to the EC motor driven fans, these savings are not recognized by the
program. Therefore, program savings are based on reduced operating hours of the EC motor driven
Business Energy Efficiency Consultation
Findings and Recommendations
Gary Corlett, SCE Field Engineer Evaporator Fan Controls - Phase 4 - Building 1
(805) 458-4828 Page 5 of 62 June 26, 2014
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
fans when the condenser unit is cycled off and the reduced heat load added to the room by reducing
the operating hours of the fans, thus enabling the condenser units to remain off for an extended
period of time.
Through phase 3, a total of 98 evaporator fans have been replaced and controlled with program
savings of 248,248 kWh and 4.61 kW demand reduction.
Building Phase
Fans
Controlled
Program
kWh Saved
kW Demand
Reduction
Incentive
2 2A 16 82,802 - $6,624.16
2B 28 45,777 5.22 $4,184.16
3 10 10,122 2.3 $1,039.76
3 2A 10 25,797 - $2,063.76
2B 9 9,533 1.09 $ 871.66
4 1 12 42,098 - $3,363.84
2B 8 22,888 2.61 $2,092.04
3 5 9,231 2.0 $938.48
Totals 98 248,248 4.61 $21,177.86
Phase 4 - Building 1 adds sixteen more evaporators and (61) fans to the total units controlled.
In addition to the evaporator fan controls, replacement of sixteen existing evaporator fan coil units has
been recommended. These units are sized to meet or exceed the estimated room loads while
requiring substantially less energy for the evaporator coil fans. Finally, this project evaluates the
replacement of several existing refrigeration condensing units.

More Related Content

What's hot

Sans healthcare watch
Sans healthcare watchSans healthcare watch
Sans healthcare watchSA FHE
 
ECA Conference Session 3: Stu Jerue
ECA Conference Session 3: Stu JerueECA Conference Session 3: Stu Jerue
ECA Conference Session 3: Stu JerueThomas Flaherty
 
Ally Updates & Automates Refrigeration System at Arizona Manufacturing Facility
Ally Updates & Automates Refrigeration System at Arizona Manufacturing FacilityAlly Updates & Automates Refrigeration System at Arizona Manufacturing Facility
Ally Updates & Automates Refrigeration System at Arizona Manufacturing FacilityAlly Energy Solutions
 
SEMi Presentation
SEMi PresentationSEMi Presentation
SEMi Presentationstirlingled
 
Gas turbine advisors review of a 9 e.03 ccgt power plant
Gas turbine advisors review of a 9 e.03 ccgt power plant Gas turbine advisors review of a 9 e.03 ccgt power plant
Gas turbine advisors review of a 9 e.03 ccgt power plant Gasturbineconsultants
 
South Carolina Research Authority 2010 M2G Certification
South Carolina Research Authority 2010 M2G CertificationSouth Carolina Research Authority 2010 M2G Certification
South Carolina Research Authority 2010 M2G CertificationCharles Rice
 
Energy Audit & Energy Conservation Opportunities in Electrical Equipments ...
Energy Audit & Energy  Conservation  Opportunities in  Electrical Equipments ...Energy Audit & Energy  Conservation  Opportunities in  Electrical Equipments ...
Energy Audit & Energy Conservation Opportunities in Electrical Equipments ...Manohar Tatwawadi
 
Power points bill insert
Power points   bill insertPower points   bill insert
Power points bill insertArden Redfern
 
Energy modelling of a three-story primary school building located in Phoenix,...
Energy modelling of a three-story primary school building located in Phoenix,...Energy modelling of a three-story primary school building located in Phoenix,...
Energy modelling of a three-story primary school building located in Phoenix,...Kirtan Gohel
 
Gard analytics DOE energy modeling
Gard analytics DOE energy modelingGard analytics DOE energy modeling
Gard analytics DOE energy modelingSteve Klein
 
Services & Equipment to Help You Reduce Energy and Emissions
Services & Equipment to Help You Reduce Energy and EmissionsServices & Equipment to Help You Reduce Energy and Emissions
Services & Equipment to Help You Reduce Energy and EmissionsStelter & Brinck
 
What are the benefits of boiler feed water economizer retrofit?
What are the benefits of boiler feed water economizer retrofit? What are the benefits of boiler feed water economizer retrofit?
What are the benefits of boiler feed water economizer retrofit? Magdy Aly
 
Melink Energy Savings Solutions
Melink Energy Savings SolutionsMelink Energy Savings Solutions
Melink Energy Savings Solutionsswallace01
 
Star rating of home appliances
Star rating  of home appliancesStar rating  of home appliances
Star rating of home appliancesAlbi Thomas
 
AgriFab_CaseStudy_61715GG-FORMAT
AgriFab_CaseStudy_61715GG-FORMATAgriFab_CaseStudy_61715GG-FORMAT
AgriFab_CaseStudy_61715GG-FORMATGreg Gillespie
 

What's hot (20)

Sans healthcare watch
Sans healthcare watchSans healthcare watch
Sans healthcare watch
 
ECA Conference Session 3: Stu Jerue
ECA Conference Session 3: Stu JerueECA Conference Session 3: Stu Jerue
ECA Conference Session 3: Stu Jerue
 
Cogeneration
CogenerationCogeneration
Cogeneration
 
Ally Updates & Automates Refrigeration System at Arizona Manufacturing Facility
Ally Updates & Automates Refrigeration System at Arizona Manufacturing FacilityAlly Updates & Automates Refrigeration System at Arizona Manufacturing Facility
Ally Updates & Automates Refrigeration System at Arizona Manufacturing Facility
 
SEMi Presentation
SEMi PresentationSEMi Presentation
SEMi Presentation
 
Gas turbine advisors review of a 9 e.03 ccgt power plant
Gas turbine advisors review of a 9 e.03 ccgt power plant Gas turbine advisors review of a 9 e.03 ccgt power plant
Gas turbine advisors review of a 9 e.03 ccgt power plant
 
South Carolina Research Authority 2010 M2G Certification
South Carolina Research Authority 2010 M2G CertificationSouth Carolina Research Authority 2010 M2G Certification
South Carolina Research Authority 2010 M2G Certification
 
Home energy audit
Home energy auditHome energy audit
Home energy audit
 
Energy Audit & Energy Conservation Opportunities in Electrical Equipments ...
Energy Audit & Energy  Conservation  Opportunities in  Electrical Equipments ...Energy Audit & Energy  Conservation  Opportunities in  Electrical Equipments ...
Energy Audit & Energy Conservation Opportunities in Electrical Equipments ...
 
O2E 21st Century Greenhouse power systems
O2E 21st Century Greenhouse power systemsO2E 21st Century Greenhouse power systems
O2E 21st Century Greenhouse power systems
 
Power points bill insert
Power points   bill insertPower points   bill insert
Power points bill insert
 
Energy modelling of a three-story primary school building located in Phoenix,...
Energy modelling of a three-story primary school building located in Phoenix,...Energy modelling of a three-story primary school building located in Phoenix,...
Energy modelling of a three-story primary school building located in Phoenix,...
 
Epa of cogen
Epa of cogenEpa of cogen
Epa of cogen
 
Gard analytics DOE energy modeling
Gard analytics DOE energy modelingGard analytics DOE energy modeling
Gard analytics DOE energy modeling
 
Services & Equipment to Help You Reduce Energy and Emissions
Services & Equipment to Help You Reduce Energy and EmissionsServices & Equipment to Help You Reduce Energy and Emissions
Services & Equipment to Help You Reduce Energy and Emissions
 
What are the benefits of boiler feed water economizer retrofit?
What are the benefits of boiler feed water economizer retrofit? What are the benefits of boiler feed water economizer retrofit?
What are the benefits of boiler feed water economizer retrofit?
 
Melink Energy Savings Solutions
Melink Energy Savings SolutionsMelink Energy Savings Solutions
Melink Energy Savings Solutions
 
Star rating of home appliances
Star rating  of home appliancesStar rating  of home appliances
Star rating of home appliances
 
Cogeneration power plant
Cogeneration power plantCogeneration power plant
Cogeneration power plant
 
AgriFab_CaseStudy_61715GG-FORMAT
AgriFab_CaseStudy_61715GG-FORMATAgriFab_CaseStudy_61715GG-FORMAT
AgriFab_CaseStudy_61715GG-FORMAT
 

Similar to Edison Case Study-Frigitek_7.20.14

How To Achieve a Green Energy Workspace
How To Achieve a Green Energy WorkspaceHow To Achieve a Green Energy Workspace
How To Achieve a Green Energy WorkspaceOakland Air
 
Webasto Idle Reduction Technology Presentation
Webasto Idle Reduction Technology PresentationWebasto Idle Reduction Technology Presentation
Webasto Idle Reduction Technology PresentationWisconsin Clean Cities
 
New Era of Energy-Efficiency Management
New Era of Energy-Efficiency ManagementNew Era of Energy-Efficiency Management
New Era of Energy-Efficiency ManagementPeter Armstrong
 
TOP-ECO Refrigeration Activation Device
TOP-ECO Refrigeration Activation DeviceTOP-ECO Refrigeration Activation Device
TOP-ECO Refrigeration Activation DeviceGenesys ECO Solutions
 
Slides: The Top 3 North America Data Center Trends for Cooling
Slides: The Top 3 North America Data Center Trends for CoolingSlides: The Top 3 North America Data Center Trends for Cooling
Slides: The Top 3 North America Data Center Trends for CoolingGraybar
 
DOE NREL TEST Report 2014
DOE NREL TEST Report 2014DOE NREL TEST Report 2014
DOE NREL TEST Report 2014Charles Rice
 
Enhancing competitiveness and achieving sustainability
Enhancing competitiveness and achieving sustainabilityEnhancing competitiveness and achieving sustainability
Enhancing competitiveness and achieving sustainabilitySimply Marcomms
 
Enhancing Sustainability in Automobile & Ancillaries; Boost productivity; red...
Enhancing Sustainability in Automobile & Ancillaries; Boost productivity; red...Enhancing Sustainability in Automobile & Ancillaries; Boost productivity; red...
Enhancing Sustainability in Automobile & Ancillaries; Boost productivity; red...A.T.E. Private Limited
 
Alinta Energy Geo Thermal
Alinta Energy Geo Thermal Alinta Energy Geo Thermal
Alinta Energy Geo Thermal AdrianHill46
 
Water Heater Research Paper-final 4-4-3
Water Heater Research Paper-final 4-4-3Water Heater Research Paper-final 4-4-3
Water Heater Research Paper-final 4-4-3Ray McGowan
 
Bill Chalmers- Gulf Coast Green 2010
Bill Chalmers- Gulf Coast Green 2010Bill Chalmers- Gulf Coast Green 2010
Bill Chalmers- Gulf Coast Green 2010Hayley Pallister
 
New Oorja Presentation
New Oorja PresentationNew Oorja Presentation
New Oorja Presentationleerts
 
Reduce energy reduce_carbon
Reduce energy reduce_carbonReduce energy reduce_carbon
Reduce energy reduce_carbonStelter & Brinck
 
Energy Modeling of Dedicated Outdoor Air System, DOAS, for a Small Commercial...
Energy Modeling of Dedicated Outdoor Air System, DOAS, for a Small Commercial...Energy Modeling of Dedicated Outdoor Air System, DOAS, for a Small Commercial...
Energy Modeling of Dedicated Outdoor Air System, DOAS, for a Small Commercial...energytrustor
 

Similar to Edison Case Study-Frigitek_7.20.14 (20)

How To Achieve a Green Energy Workspace
How To Achieve a Green Energy WorkspaceHow To Achieve a Green Energy Workspace
How To Achieve a Green Energy Workspace
 
Webasto Idle Reduction Technology Presentation
Webasto Idle Reduction Technology PresentationWebasto Idle Reduction Technology Presentation
Webasto Idle Reduction Technology Presentation
 
New Era of Energy-Efficiency Management
New Era of Energy-Efficiency ManagementNew Era of Energy-Efficiency Management
New Era of Energy-Efficiency Management
 
TOP-ECO Refrigeration Activation Device
TOP-ECO Refrigeration Activation DeviceTOP-ECO Refrigeration Activation Device
TOP-ECO Refrigeration Activation Device
 
Proa presentation
Proa presentationProa presentation
Proa presentation
 
Slides: The Top 3 North America Data Center Trends for Cooling
Slides: The Top 3 North America Data Center Trends for CoolingSlides: The Top 3 North America Data Center Trends for Cooling
Slides: The Top 3 North America Data Center Trends for Cooling
 
ASHRAE Standard 100
ASHRAE Standard 100ASHRAE Standard 100
ASHRAE Standard 100
 
DOE NREL TEST Report 2014
DOE NREL TEST Report 2014DOE NREL TEST Report 2014
DOE NREL TEST Report 2014
 
UFI Operations Award 2010 - Direct Energy Center
UFI Operations Award 2010 - Direct Energy CenterUFI Operations Award 2010 - Direct Energy Center
UFI Operations Award 2010 - Direct Energy Center
 
Commercial Condensing Boiler Optimization
Commercial Condensing Boiler OptimizationCommercial Condensing Boiler Optimization
Commercial Condensing Boiler Optimization
 
Enhancing competitiveness and achieving sustainability
Enhancing competitiveness and achieving sustainabilityEnhancing competitiveness and achieving sustainability
Enhancing competitiveness and achieving sustainability
 
Enhancing Sustainability in Automobile & Ancillaries; Boost productivity; red...
Enhancing Sustainability in Automobile & Ancillaries; Boost productivity; red...Enhancing Sustainability in Automobile & Ancillaries; Boost productivity; red...
Enhancing Sustainability in Automobile & Ancillaries; Boost productivity; red...
 
C5693028319.pdf
C5693028319.pdfC5693028319.pdf
C5693028319.pdf
 
Alinta Energy Geo Thermal
Alinta Energy Geo Thermal Alinta Energy Geo Thermal
Alinta Energy Geo Thermal
 
Water Heater Research Paper-final 4-4-3
Water Heater Research Paper-final 4-4-3Water Heater Research Paper-final 4-4-3
Water Heater Research Paper-final 4-4-3
 
Bill Chalmers- Gulf Coast Green 2010
Bill Chalmers- Gulf Coast Green 2010Bill Chalmers- Gulf Coast Green 2010
Bill Chalmers- Gulf Coast Green 2010
 
Pg hvac
Pg hvacPg hvac
Pg hvac
 
New Oorja Presentation
New Oorja PresentationNew Oorja Presentation
New Oorja Presentation
 
Reduce energy reduce_carbon
Reduce energy reduce_carbonReduce energy reduce_carbon
Reduce energy reduce_carbon
 
Energy Modeling of Dedicated Outdoor Air System, DOAS, for a Small Commercial...
Energy Modeling of Dedicated Outdoor Air System, DOAS, for a Small Commercial...Energy Modeling of Dedicated Outdoor Air System, DOAS, for a Small Commercial...
Energy Modeling of Dedicated Outdoor Air System, DOAS, for a Small Commercial...
 

Edison Case Study-Frigitek_7.20.14

  • 1. Business Energy Efficiency Consultation Findings and Recommendations Gary Corlett, SCE Field Engineer Evaporator Fan Controls - Phase 4 - Building 1 (805) 458-4828 Page 3 of 62 June 26, 2014 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION http://www.sce.com/business/ems/appdownload.htm or contact your SCE Account Executive, Caroline Lee at (760) 900-4495 for additional information. Saving electrical energy at your site not only lowers your operating costs, but saves California’s environment. By implementing all of the above recommendations you can potentially save as much as 589,413 kWh per year and DEER peak demand savings of 32.0 kW. This translates into an estimated 267.4 metric tons of Greenhouse Gas that will not be emitted into California’s atmosphere. Potential Demand Response Opportunities Potential Demand Response opportunities are itemized below. Details of these specific opportunities are included in Appendices B and C. Potential Demand Response Opportunities Soln Code Solution Description Strategy DR-30001 Process Machinery – Other Charge batteries and battery-operated equipment prior to an event, then disconnect battery chargers and use only pre- charged equipment during an event DR-31882 HVAC Controls Cycle air-cooled package units and/or constant volume air handling units by controls DR-39151 Controls for Package Units or Central Plants Global temperature adjustment for air-cooled package units or central plants DR-44991 Lighting Controls/Switching Dim lights and/or shut off portion of lighting Site Information Site information was obtained during a site visit by Gary Corlett, SCE Field Engineer with Bob Farmer, Carlisle Energy Solutions representing Field Fresh Foods on April 25, 2014. Key Contact Information Contact Title Phone Number E-mail Address Carlos Castaneda General Manager (310) 719-8422 carlosc@fieldfresh.com Bob Farmer Vendor Representative (714) 865-2111 bob@cescool.com Al Linder Frigitek (831) 768-8848 al@frigitek.com Caroline Lee Account Manager – SCE (760) 900-4495 caroline.lee@sce.com
  • 2. Business Energy Efficiency Consultation Findings and Recommendations Gary Corlett, SCE Field Engineer Evaporator Fan Controls - Phase 4 - Building 1 (805) 458-4828 Page 4 of 62 June 26, 2014 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION The Field Fresh Foods facility is located in Gardena, California approximately 11 miles south of Los Angeles and approximately 9 miles inland from the Pacific Ocean. Field Fresh Foods serves the western United States, providing service, distribution and manufacturing that is based around freshness rather than shelf-life. Every vegetable is cut to order. Besides individual raw vegetables, the company also provides fresh vegetable platters and mixed green salads. Gardena is in Climate Zone 8. For the purpose of this evaluation, this facility is considered Type 33 – Refrigerated Warehouse. Building 1 used 2,383,274 kWh over the past year, an average of 198,606 kWh per month. The peak demand was 403 kW, while the average demand was 360 kW. The average monthly bill for this account was $23,758.38 at an average of $0.11963. (See the annual usage and demand in the charts below.) Project Information The Field Fresh Foods facility covers an area of ~3.5 acres containing about 70,550 square foot (SF) of refrigerated warehouse and approximately 10,000 SF of office/mechanical and maintenance area. The refrigerated warehouse areas are broken up into many smaller areas, each cooled by one or two small compressor/condenser units and multiple evaporator units. The evaporator fans vary in size from ¼-hp to ¾-hp each and the quantity of fans per evaporator unit varies from 2 to 5. These fans run continuously, even when the condenser unit is satisfied and shuts down. This project is Phase 4 of a multiphase project. In the previous phases, the fans were replaced with fans having electronically commutated (EC) motors for more efficient operation and the ability to vary the speed of the fan. In addition, controllers were added to each evaporator unit to control the fan speed, operating the fan speed at 100% when the condenser unit is cycled on and reducing the fan speed to approximately 25% percent when the condenser unit has cycled off. Although the customer achieves savings from changing to the EC motor driven fans, these savings are not recognized by the program. Therefore, program savings are based on reduced operating hours of the EC motor driven
  • 3. Business Energy Efficiency Consultation Findings and Recommendations Gary Corlett, SCE Field Engineer Evaporator Fan Controls - Phase 4 - Building 1 (805) 458-4828 Page 5 of 62 June 26, 2014 PROPRIETARY INFORMATION fans when the condenser unit is cycled off and the reduced heat load added to the room by reducing the operating hours of the fans, thus enabling the condenser units to remain off for an extended period of time. Through phase 3, a total of 98 evaporator fans have been replaced and controlled with program savings of 248,248 kWh and 4.61 kW demand reduction. Building Phase Fans Controlled Program kWh Saved kW Demand Reduction Incentive 2 2A 16 82,802 - $6,624.16 2B 28 45,777 5.22 $4,184.16 3 10 10,122 2.3 $1,039.76 3 2A 10 25,797 - $2,063.76 2B 9 9,533 1.09 $ 871.66 4 1 12 42,098 - $3,363.84 2B 8 22,888 2.61 $2,092.04 3 5 9,231 2.0 $938.48 Totals 98 248,248 4.61 $21,177.86 Phase 4 - Building 1 adds sixteen more evaporators and (61) fans to the total units controlled. In addition to the evaporator fan controls, replacement of sixteen existing evaporator fan coil units has been recommended. These units are sized to meet or exceed the estimated room loads while requiring substantially less energy for the evaporator coil fans. Finally, this project evaluates the replacement of several existing refrigeration condensing units.