SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 14
Hooks Research Paper 1
Running Ahead: THE INTEGRATION OF MOTIVATIONAL INTERVIEWING WITH THE
STAGES OF CHANGE TO HELP CLIENTS SET GOALS
The Integration of Motivational Interviewing with the Stages of Change to Help Clients Set
Goals
John Quincey Hooks, II (Quinn)
1 March 2015
Liberty University
Hooks Research Paper 2
Abstract
The field of coaching is being recognized for its ability to help clients improve their work
performance and satisfaction with their quality of life. Each day, more empirical data is being
gathered to improve the quality of coaching as the field grows as people and organizations
recognize the value of it. Goal setting is one of the areas which are being explored. This paper
sets to integrate the tool of motivational interviewing with the Stages of Change as proposed by
Prochaska and Norcross (2001) as well as DiClemente (2003) to help clients set goals by
understanding which stage of change they are experiencing then using that knowledge to tailor
motivational interviewing techniques to that stage in helping clients set their goals (Pavur, 2013).
Hooks Research Paper 3
Coaching is a field that is growing dramatically as time progresses. Corporations see the
advantages in helping their employees be more successful since success on the individual level
usually translate to success on the cooperate level. There are two measures for success on the
personal level. These two measures are health and self-actualization. Coaches can be employed
to help clients work on their mental and physical health as well as training and development of
leadership skills (Pavur, 2013).
It is important to understand goals, motivational interviewing, and the stages of change in
helping clients set realistic and attainable goals. Goals are the foundational basis for change in
clients. There are two types of goals. The first goal is the instructional goals which are difficult
to measure because it is usually subjective in nature with the main focus being the act of
discovering new techniques, processes, and strategies for accomplishing a task. The second goal
is the performance goal which is easier to measure due to it usually having concrete results and
firm deadlines as its measure (Latham & Locke, 2007).
Coaches may determine their clients’ readiness for change through the use of the stages
of change also known as the transtheoretical model. Coaches can make a goal unique to the
clients and the stage of change which they exhibit in their actions and words. Careful screening
questions can be used in the initial session and follow-up questions in subsequence sessions to
determine the clients’ stage and their progress through the stages as they work towards their
goals (DiClemente, 2003).
DiClemente (2003) puts forth five stages of change. The first stage is precontempalation
which is the clients becoming aware of their situation. The second stage is contemplation the
stages in which clients are motivated to take action. The third stage is preparation where they
make plans to change and commit to it. The fourth stage is the action phase where the planned
Hooks Research Paper 4
strategy for change is implemented. The final stage is maintenance the integration of the change
into clients’ lifestyle has occurred (DiClemente, 2003).
To further explore the use of the techniques of motivational interviewing with the
transtheoretical model for the stages of change, Rogers’ model for the diffusion of innovations
will be integrated with the transtheoretical model. The models share qualities in the
precontempalation, contemplation, and preparation stages which can help coaches work with
their clients to help bring about change (Hettema, et. al., 2014).
Goal Setting
Individuals are affected by their goals on many levels of their lives personally and
professionally. The attainment or lack of attainment of goals affects interpersonal relationships.
The pursuit of common goals can enhance the quality of relationships. The reason for this
enhanced quality is the feeling of closeness which common goals create. This effect has been
reported in the research done in this area. Whether a person is seen as a help or hindrance
towards achieving the desired goal affects the way the person pursuing the goal sees them
(Fitzsimons & Fishbach, 2009).
The research which has been done in recent times has been more empirical than earlier
research resulting in the Goal Setting Theory (GST). GST sees a relationship between the setting
of high goals and task performance. It recognizes the importance of the goal to the individual and
the self-confidence of the individual as being major factors in the prioritizing of goals. It is a
complex tapestry woven together by the elements of choice, effort, endurance, planning, and
complexity of the task all impacting the success achieved in reaching the goal (Latham & Locke,
2007).
Hooks Research Paper 5
Goal setting has been shown to have a beneficial effect on clients’ self-esteem. This
aspect is especially true when difficult goals are attained. Even if the goal is not attained, the
progress towards that goal results in improved self-esteem and overall feelings of well-being in
the individuals studied. The achievement of goals has been found to create higher expectations
for success thus creating a positive cycle of goal setting, goal commitment, and goal attainment
which increases the cognitive and motivational abilities of individuals (Morisano, et. al., 2010).
Goals should be created with the clients’ strengths in mind. It has been found in research
that goals which are focused on negative aspects of the clients’ lives and their faults were less
likely to improve the clients’ quality of life or performance. It have been found that goals
focusing on the strengths of the clients build a better rapport with the coaches and clients report a
greater overall satisfaction with the coaching relationship (Welch, et. al., 2014).
Research indicates that strength based coaching and goal setting leads to the development
of transformational leaders in organizations. These leaders affect their peers as they reach their
individual goals. These transformation leaders are able to create shared vision in their teams
which enhanced the performance of the team overall. As these leaders and teams succeeded, they
were given more difficult assignments (MacKie, 2014).
The study of setting goals is growing in the area of group dynamics. It is important to
understand the goals of individuals and the relationship to group goals in competitive settings.
This element is seen in competitive areas such as sales. Seeing this factor, the achievement of
individual goals will impact the success of reaching group goals (Kleingeld, Mierlo, & Arends,
2011).
Hooks Research Paper 6
Stages of Change
Prochaska and Norcross (2001) hold to there being six stages while DiClemente (2003)
holds to there being five stages. The extra stage for Prochaska and Norcross (2001) is the
termination phase. The Stages of Change is known as the transtheoretical model (Prochaska &
Norcross, 2001). Coaches must have a clear understanding of the stages so that they may help
their clients set goals.
The stages of change were researched and developed to help people struggling with
addictions. The information gathered by this research can be applied to helping clients achieve
their goals. It is important for coaches to adapt the information to individual clients to help them
set and reach their goals. Though initial and continuing assessment of the clients, coaches may
determine the stage which their client is experiencing and tailor the goals to that stage
(DiClemente, 2003).
The first stage of the transtheoretical model is precontempalation. This is the stage where
clients have no intention in changing a behavior. Clients in this stage are either unaware or
under-aware of their problem and need for change. Other people are aware of the client’s
problem and pressure them to seek help. If they seek help, it is due to pressure from others
(Prochaska & Norcross, 2001).
The second stage is contemplation. Clients are aware that a problem exists and have
started to think about strategies to overcome it. Clients have not yet made the commitment to
change at this point. It is possible for clients to remain stuck in this stage for long periods of
time. Those clients who state that they are thinking about making a change over the next six
months are considered to be in this stage (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001).
Hooks Research Paper 7
The third stage is the preparation stage where clients are intending to take action. It is
during this stage that clients may take small steps by making small changes in their behaviors.
Clients in this stage have not yet committed to taking effective action to undergo change
(Prochaska & Norcross, 2001).
The fourth stage is the action stage. It is during this stage in which clients commit to
overcoming their issues. It is the undertaking of overt behavior changes and is the stage which
requires the most time and energy. The changes in this stage are observable therefore clients
receive recognition for their changes. Successful alteration of behavior in a time period of one
day to six months qualifies clients as being in the action phase (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001).
The fifth stage is the maintenance stage. It is during this stage that clients work on
integrating the change into their lifestyle to prevent relapse while consolidating their gains. The
problem behavior must be extinguished for six months for clients to be considered to be in
maintenance. In addition, clients must consistently engage in new behaviors during this same
time frame (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001).
Prochaska and Norcross (2011) added a sixth stage to the transtheoretical model which is
termination. This quite simply defined as clients having the total confidence that they will not
relapse. This confidence can be seen as clients experience formerly high risk situations and
experience no temptation to relapse into their former behaviors (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001).
It has been found that change occurs over a period of time. In research done with college
students, Sullivan (2011) found that the participants in a health challenge project reported
fluctuation between the stages. People move through the various stages at their own pace.
Relapses are common and are part of the process in change (Sullivan, 2011).
Hooks Research Paper 8
Motivational Interviewing
Motivational interviewing is a technique used in counseling to facilitate change in clients
by the alteration of their self-talk from negative to positive. Motivational interviewing is client-
centered. The focus is on the concerns of the clients. It borrows heavily from Carl Rogers and his
counseling style. It is meant to focus on the current concerns and interests of the client (Miller &
Rollnick, 2002).
Motivational interviewing is based on three basic premises. The first premise is that
clients have an inherent desire to move towards health and wholeness. This desire is skewed by
various factors. Despite this distortion of the natural drive, it can be a powerful tool in helping
clients change. The second premise is that the client is the expert in bringing about change. The
coach acts as a resource to aid in the transformation by providing information and teaching skills
but the client is in control of the change process. The third premise is that clients’ investment and
ownership of the change process will increase the likelihood for success (Moyers, 2014).
The purpose of motivational interviewing is to strengthen clients’ motivation and
commitment to change through a collaborative conversation style. This strategy has found use in
various fields. Promising results are emerging in the area of prevention and treatment for various
health conditions. Research indicates that motivational interviewing can be a tool used for the
exploration of clients’ resistance to change (Hettema, et. al., 2014).
Motivational interviewing is directed towards dealing with solutions to resolving
uncertainty in regards to change. The technical aspect of motivational interviewing seeks to
evoke and strengthening the language of change in the clients. This language is known as
“change talk”. Coaches learn to listen for this language and reinforce it when it is manifested.
This attention to the change talk has been found to reinforce the likelihood for change in clients.
Hooks Research Paper 9
Coaches can use careful questioning and reflection to help clients create their change talk
vocabulary. The coach reinforces the positive self-talk by helping the client to create a change
vocabulary. In this way, motivational interviewing helps the client transition into the desired
change (Moyers, 2014).
Motivational interviewing is more than techniques. It is more than just a set of tactics to
be used to get clients to move in a direction they are reluctant to go. It is a means of
communicating with clients to facilitate the desired change by building a working collaboration
with the client. Motivational interviewing focuses on the clients’ innate desire to change.
Behavioral models and motivational strategies tend to use external means to bring about change
in clients. Motivational interviewing seeks out the internal motivation for change then enhances
it. This change in the clients therefore must be consistent with their beliefs and values.
Motivational interviewing seeks out ambivalence that clients may have about change then find
solutions to deal with the ambivalence (Miller & Rollnick, 2002).
Based on this research, it can be seen that how clients view coaches can impact the
coaching alliance and the clients achieving their goals. The clarity of goals and proper planning
is a critical element of the coaching relationship. The performance of clients can be increased
through the identification of their goals and working with their coach to create a strategy for
implementation to reach the goals. Feedback is crucial to the coaching relationship (Gregory,
Beck, & Carr, 2011).
The relationship matters in coaching. Motivational interview can build a solid foundation
which can be a springboard to help clients set goals and change. Motivational interviewing
differs from other strategies in that it helps clients make the decision to change of their own
volition. Motivational interviewing is effective because it deals with the ambivalence of clients
Hooks Research Paper 10
towards change. It can be supplemented with other strategies to build relationships and improve
social skills (Miller & Rollnick, 2009).
It is possible for clients to have several goals they are trying to reach at any one time.
Goals are reached as the brain adapts to the behaviors and attitudes necessary to reach goals.
Energy and efforts may be wasted if goals are not prioritized by clients. It is important that
coaches have a good working relationship with their clients. Working with coaches, clients can
create a hierarchy for the goals so that the most important ones are reached (Gregory, Beck, &
Carr, 2011).
Conclusion
Using the underlying premises of motivational interviewing, coaches seek to tap into the
intrinsic drive for change treating them as the expert in bringing about the change they desire so
that they will set goals which they will take ownership thus increasing the chances for success
(Moyers, 2014). Through motivation interviewing, coaches can assess the client’s stage of
change. Coaches must be careful not to assume that all clients are in the action stage. They may
be seeing the coach due to outside pressure from others. Motivational interviewing will help the
client to set realistic goals that move through the stages one at a time. Change is a process that
takes time. Motivational interviewing will help the coach to determine the best strategy to use
with the client and the best stance to take with the client while building rapport (Prochaska &
Norcross, 2001).
There are several evidence based models available to coaches to help understand how
clients make decisions about adopting changes. Rogers puts forth a model of diffusion in regards
to innovations with five stages which are knowledge, persuasion, decision, implementation, and
confirmation (Hettema, et. al., 2014). There is some continuity between Rogers’ model and the
Hooks Research Paper 11
transtheoretical model which can be used by coaches to further enhance their ability to help their
clients.
The knowledge phase is an awareness of an innovation. Rogers held that there were many
factors involved in the knowledge phase and one of the most important factors was
communication. Motivational interviewing as a strategy to determine how much information is
provided to clients and when it should be done. It has been found learning for clients through
informal channels is much more effective than scientific books and articles. This stage
corresponds to the precontempalation stage in the transtheoretical model (Hettema, et. al., 2014).
Coaches take different stances with clients based on the transtheoretical model. Coaches
working with clients who are in the precontempalation stage may build a nurturing relationship
with the client. The coach would use motivational interviewing in this case to build rapport and
to tap into the client’s intrinsic motivations for change. (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001).
The knowledge phase in Rogers’ model is an awareness of an innovation. This stage
corresponds to the precontempalation stage in the transtheoretical model. Rogers held that there
were many factors involved in the knowledge phase and one of the most important factors was
communication. Motivational interviewing as a strategy to determine how much information is
provided to clients and when it should be done. It has been found learning for clients through
informal channels is much more effective than scientific books and articles (Hettema, et. al.,
2014).
The second stage is persuasion which the point where clients develop positive or negative
attitudes towards innovations. This stage can be compared to the contemplation stage in the
transtheoretical model. A coach working with a client in the contemplation stage may use
motivational interviewing to help clients become more aware of their situation. It is this stage
Hooks Research Paper 12
where clients feel uncertainty about change. The clients are aware of the need for change but still
have feelings of ambivalence about it. Motivational interviewing can be used here to help clients
motivate themselves into changing through the process of self-discovery. The coach takes a
nonjudgmental and empathic stance with clients in this phase (Hettema, et. al., 2014).
The decision stage of Roger’s model compares with the preparation stage of the
transtheoretical model. The decision phase is the point in which clients make the decision either
to accept or reject the innovation. The foundation for this stage has been laid in the knowledge
and persuasion phases. It is during the decision stage that coaches can use motivational
interviewing techniques to creating an action plan in a collaborative effort with the clients.
(Hettema, et. al., 2014).
Coaches become collaborators through motivational interviewing to help clients in the
preparation stage to create an action plan so that they may progress to the next stage. In the final
stages, coaches become sojourners with the clients to offer support needed to help when they
encounter stumbling blocks (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001).
By using the stages of change and motivational interviewing, coaches can help clients
establish goals appropriate for the stage they are experiencing. Each stage has its own unique
characteristics therefore need goals unique to the client and the client’s stage of change.
Knowledge of Rogers’ model combined with the early stages of the transtheoretical model will
help the coach to determine the best stance to take with clients in setting goals. Motivational
interviewing will help find the client’s internal motivations for change allowing for the tailoring
of goals and actions to the client. Finally, motivational interviewing and understanding the stages
of change will help coach work with the clients to set goals that bring about successful change.
Hooks Research Paper 13
References
DiClemente, C. C. (2003). Addiction and change: How addictions develop and addicted people
recover. New York: The Guilford Press.
Fitzsimons, G., & Fishbach, A. (2009). Shifting closeness: Interpersonal effects of personal goal
progress. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 535-549.
Gregory, J., Beck, J., & Carr, A. (2011). Goals, feedback, and self-regulation: Control theory as a
natural framework for executive coaching. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and
Research, 26-38.
Hettman, J. E., Ernst, D., Wiliams, J. R., and Miller, K. J. (July 2014). Parallel processes: Using
motivational interviewing as an implementation coaching strategy. The Journal of
Behavioral Health Services and Research, 41(3), 324-336.
Kleingeld, A., Mierlo, H., & Arends, L. (2011). The effect of goal setting on group performance:
A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 96(6), 1289-1304. Retrieved September
29, 2014.
Latham, G., & Locke, E. (2007). New developments in and directions for goal-setting
Research. European Psychologist, 12(4), 290-300.
MacKie, D. (2014). The effectiveness of strength-based executive coaching in enhancing full
range leadership development: A controlled study. Consulting Psychology Journal:
Practice and Research, 66(2), 118–137-118–137.
Miller, W. R. and Rollnick, S. (2002). Motivational interviewing: Preparing people for change
(2nd ed). New York, NY: Guilford Press.
Hooks Research Paper 14
Miller, W. R., & Rollnick, S. (2009). Ten things that MI is not. Behavioural and Cognitive
Psychotherapy, 37, 129 –140. doi:10.1017/S1352465809005128
Morisano, D., Hirsh, J., Peterson, J., Pihl, R., & Shore, B. (2010). Setting, elaborating, and
reflecting on personal goals improves academic performance. Journal of Applied
Psychology, 95(2), 255-264.
Moyers, T. B. (2014). The relationship in motivational interviewing. Psychotherapy, 51(3), 358-
363.
Pavur, E. (2013). Why do organizations want their leaders to be coached? Consulting Psychology
Journal: Practice and Research, 65(4), 289-293.
Prochaska, J. O. and Norcross, J. C. (2001). Stages of change. Psychotherapy, 38 (4), 443-448.
Sullivan, C. F. (2011). Health behavior change challenge: Understanding stages of change.
Communication Teacher, 25(2), 108-114.
Welch, D., Reid, K., & Walker, C. (2014). Strengths-based leadership development: Insights
from expert coaches. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 66(1), 20-
37.

More Related Content

Similar to The Integration of Motivational Interviewing with the Stages of Change to Coach Clients

Educating social workers to establish well formed goals van voorhis et al
Educating social workers to establish well formed goals van voorhis et alEducating social workers to establish well formed goals van voorhis et al
Educating social workers to establish well formed goals van voorhis et alAriel. Christopher, BSW
 
AET/560 Communication Plan
AET/560 Communication PlanAET/560 Communication Plan
AET/560 Communication PlanSheilahoskin
 
Respond Using references, identity the research result that .docx
Respond Using references, identity the research result that .docxRespond Using references, identity the research result that .docx
Respond Using references, identity the research result that .docxwilfredoa1
 
2 postsReModule 1 DQ 1What are the characteristics of good .docx
2 postsReModule 1 DQ 1What are the characteristics of good .docx2 postsReModule 1 DQ 1What are the characteristics of good .docx
2 postsReModule 1 DQ 1What are the characteristics of good .docxfelicidaddinwoodie
 
The Efficacy of Executive Coaching inTimes of Organisational.docx
The Efficacy of Executive Coaching inTimes of Organisational.docxThe Efficacy of Executive Coaching inTimes of Organisational.docx
The Efficacy of Executive Coaching inTimes of Organisational.docxtodd701
 
Running head EXECURTIVE SUMMARY .docx
Running head EXECURTIVE SUMMARY                                  .docxRunning head EXECURTIVE SUMMARY                                  .docx
Running head EXECURTIVE SUMMARY .docxcowinhelen
 
Lectura del foro knowing when to set learning versus performance goals (1)
Lectura del foro knowing when to set learning versus performance goals (1)Lectura del foro knowing when to set learning versus performance goals (1)
Lectura del foro knowing when to set learning versus performance goals (1)Johanna López
 
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg 1]. organizational development implementing planned cha...
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg 1]. organizational development implementing planned cha...Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg 1]. organizational development implementing planned cha...
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg 1]. organizational development implementing planned cha...William Kritsonis
 
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement .docx
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement       .docxRunning Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement       .docx
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement .docxcharisellington63520
 
Change Evaluation And Sustainability Essay Paper.docx
Change Evaluation And Sustainability Essay Paper.docxChange Evaluation And Sustainability Essay Paper.docx
Change Evaluation And Sustainability Essay Paper.docx4934bk
 
Changes And Development Of The Aging Process
Changes And Development Of The Aging ProcessChanges And Development Of The Aging Process
Changes And Development Of The Aging ProcessMindi Schneider
 
Social Cognitive TheoryThis theory was introduced by Albert Band.docx
Social Cognitive TheoryThis theory was introduced by Albert Band.docxSocial Cognitive TheoryThis theory was introduced by Albert Band.docx
Social Cognitive TheoryThis theory was introduced by Albert Band.docxpbilly1
 
SOCW 6311 WK 1 responses Respond to at least two colleagues .docx
SOCW 6311 WK 1 responses Respond to at least two colleagues .docxSOCW 6311 WK 1 responses Respond to at least two colleagues .docx
SOCW 6311 WK 1 responses Respond to at least two colleagues .docxsamuel699872
 
Lunenburg, fred c[1]. organizational development implementing planned change ...
Lunenburg, fred c[1]. organizational development implementing planned change ...Lunenburg, fred c[1]. organizational development implementing planned change ...
Lunenburg, fred c[1]. organizational development implementing planned change ...William Kritsonis
 
analyzing the best practice points that were addressed. In  res.docx
analyzing the best practice points that were addressed. In  res.docxanalyzing the best practice points that were addressed. In  res.docx
analyzing the best practice points that were addressed. In  res.docxlanagore871
 
Comments by the professorWeek 1 Weekly Summary You have done a
Comments by the professorWeek 1 Weekly Summary You have done aComments by the professorWeek 1 Weekly Summary You have done a
Comments by the professorWeek 1 Weekly Summary You have done aLynellBull52
 

Similar to The Integration of Motivational Interviewing with the Stages of Change to Coach Clients (20)

Educating social workers to establish well formed goals van voorhis et al
Educating social workers to establish well formed goals van voorhis et alEducating social workers to establish well formed goals van voorhis et al
Educating social workers to establish well formed goals van voorhis et al
 
AET/560 Communication Plan
AET/560 Communication PlanAET/560 Communication Plan
AET/560 Communication Plan
 
Respond Using references, identity the research result that .docx
Respond Using references, identity the research result that .docxRespond Using references, identity the research result that .docx
Respond Using references, identity the research result that .docx
 
2 postsReModule 1 DQ 1What are the characteristics of good .docx
2 postsReModule 1 DQ 1What are the characteristics of good .docx2 postsReModule 1 DQ 1What are the characteristics of good .docx
2 postsReModule 1 DQ 1What are the characteristics of good .docx
 
The Efficacy of Executive Coaching inTimes of Organisational.docx
The Efficacy of Executive Coaching inTimes of Organisational.docxThe Efficacy of Executive Coaching inTimes of Organisational.docx
The Efficacy of Executive Coaching inTimes of Organisational.docx
 
Del Giudice - Consulting Psychology Journal
Del Giudice - Consulting Psychology JournalDel Giudice - Consulting Psychology Journal
Del Giudice - Consulting Psychology Journal
 
Running head EXECURTIVE SUMMARY .docx
Running head EXECURTIVE SUMMARY                                  .docxRunning head EXECURTIVE SUMMARY                                  .docx
Running head EXECURTIVE SUMMARY .docx
 
Lectura del foro knowing when to set learning versus performance goals (1)
Lectura del foro knowing when to set learning versus performance goals (1)Lectura del foro knowing when to set learning versus performance goals (1)
Lectura del foro knowing when to set learning versus performance goals (1)
 
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg 1]. organizational development implementing planned cha...
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg 1]. organizational development implementing planned cha...Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg 1]. organizational development implementing planned cha...
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg 1]. organizational development implementing planned cha...
 
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement .docx
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement       .docxRunning Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement       .docx
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement .docx
 
Change Evaluation And Sustainability Essay Paper.docx
Change Evaluation And Sustainability Essay Paper.docxChange Evaluation And Sustainability Essay Paper.docx
Change Evaluation And Sustainability Essay Paper.docx
 
Summative Essay
Summative EssaySummative Essay
Summative Essay
 
Changes And Development Of The Aging Process
Changes And Development Of The Aging ProcessChanges And Development Of The Aging Process
Changes And Development Of The Aging Process
 
Social Cognitive TheoryThis theory was introduced by Albert Band.docx
Social Cognitive TheoryThis theory was introduced by Albert Band.docxSocial Cognitive TheoryThis theory was introduced by Albert Band.docx
Social Cognitive TheoryThis theory was introduced by Albert Band.docx
 
SOCW 6311 WK 1 responses Respond to at least two colleagues .docx
SOCW 6311 WK 1 responses Respond to at least two colleagues .docxSOCW 6311 WK 1 responses Respond to at least two colleagues .docx
SOCW 6311 WK 1 responses Respond to at least two colleagues .docx
 
Lunenburg, fred c[1]. organizational development implementing planned change ...
Lunenburg, fred c[1]. organizational development implementing planned change ...Lunenburg, fred c[1]. organizational development implementing planned change ...
Lunenburg, fred c[1]. organizational development implementing planned change ...
 
analyzing the best practice points that were addressed. In  res.docx
analyzing the best practice points that were addressed. In  res.docxanalyzing the best practice points that were addressed. In  res.docx
analyzing the best practice points that were addressed. In  res.docx
 
Comments by the professorWeek 1 Weekly Summary You have done a
Comments by the professorWeek 1 Weekly Summary You have done aComments by the professorWeek 1 Weekly Summary You have done a
Comments by the professorWeek 1 Weekly Summary You have done a
 
44
4444
44
 
ImplementingChange
ImplementingChangeImplementingChange
ImplementingChange
 

More from jqh2

Family Counseling Approach Research Paper
Family Counseling Approach Research PaperFamily Counseling Approach Research Paper
Family Counseling Approach Research Paperjqh2
 
Book of Ephesians_Answered
Book of Ephesians_AnsweredBook of Ephesians_Answered
Book of Ephesians_Answeredjqh2
 
John 21 18 25 prezi
John 21 18 25 preziJohn 21 18 25 prezi
John 21 18 25 prezijqh2
 
The four beasts of daniel 7 pdf
The four beasts of daniel 7 pdfThe four beasts of daniel 7 pdf
The four beasts of daniel 7 pdfjqh2
 
Revised 2013 church resume
Revised 2013 church resumeRevised 2013 church resume
Revised 2013 church resumejqh2
 
Resume presentation
Resume presentationResume presentation
Resume presentationjqh2
 
Phil 2 The Humility of Christ notes
Phil 2 The Humility of Christ notesPhil 2 The Humility of Christ notes
Phil 2 The Humility of Christ notesjqh2
 

More from jqh2 (7)

Family Counseling Approach Research Paper
Family Counseling Approach Research PaperFamily Counseling Approach Research Paper
Family Counseling Approach Research Paper
 
Book of Ephesians_Answered
Book of Ephesians_AnsweredBook of Ephesians_Answered
Book of Ephesians_Answered
 
John 21 18 25 prezi
John 21 18 25 preziJohn 21 18 25 prezi
John 21 18 25 prezi
 
The four beasts of daniel 7 pdf
The four beasts of daniel 7 pdfThe four beasts of daniel 7 pdf
The four beasts of daniel 7 pdf
 
Revised 2013 church resume
Revised 2013 church resumeRevised 2013 church resume
Revised 2013 church resume
 
Resume presentation
Resume presentationResume presentation
Resume presentation
 
Phil 2 The Humility of Christ notes
Phil 2 The Humility of Christ notesPhil 2 The Humility of Christ notes
Phil 2 The Humility of Christ notes
 

The Integration of Motivational Interviewing with the Stages of Change to Coach Clients

  • 1. Hooks Research Paper 1 Running Ahead: THE INTEGRATION OF MOTIVATIONAL INTERVIEWING WITH THE STAGES OF CHANGE TO HELP CLIENTS SET GOALS The Integration of Motivational Interviewing with the Stages of Change to Help Clients Set Goals John Quincey Hooks, II (Quinn) 1 March 2015 Liberty University
  • 2. Hooks Research Paper 2 Abstract The field of coaching is being recognized for its ability to help clients improve their work performance and satisfaction with their quality of life. Each day, more empirical data is being gathered to improve the quality of coaching as the field grows as people and organizations recognize the value of it. Goal setting is one of the areas which are being explored. This paper sets to integrate the tool of motivational interviewing with the Stages of Change as proposed by Prochaska and Norcross (2001) as well as DiClemente (2003) to help clients set goals by understanding which stage of change they are experiencing then using that knowledge to tailor motivational interviewing techniques to that stage in helping clients set their goals (Pavur, 2013).
  • 3. Hooks Research Paper 3 Coaching is a field that is growing dramatically as time progresses. Corporations see the advantages in helping their employees be more successful since success on the individual level usually translate to success on the cooperate level. There are two measures for success on the personal level. These two measures are health and self-actualization. Coaches can be employed to help clients work on their mental and physical health as well as training and development of leadership skills (Pavur, 2013). It is important to understand goals, motivational interviewing, and the stages of change in helping clients set realistic and attainable goals. Goals are the foundational basis for change in clients. There are two types of goals. The first goal is the instructional goals which are difficult to measure because it is usually subjective in nature with the main focus being the act of discovering new techniques, processes, and strategies for accomplishing a task. The second goal is the performance goal which is easier to measure due to it usually having concrete results and firm deadlines as its measure (Latham & Locke, 2007). Coaches may determine their clients’ readiness for change through the use of the stages of change also known as the transtheoretical model. Coaches can make a goal unique to the clients and the stage of change which they exhibit in their actions and words. Careful screening questions can be used in the initial session and follow-up questions in subsequence sessions to determine the clients’ stage and their progress through the stages as they work towards their goals (DiClemente, 2003). DiClemente (2003) puts forth five stages of change. The first stage is precontempalation which is the clients becoming aware of their situation. The second stage is contemplation the stages in which clients are motivated to take action. The third stage is preparation where they make plans to change and commit to it. The fourth stage is the action phase where the planned
  • 4. Hooks Research Paper 4 strategy for change is implemented. The final stage is maintenance the integration of the change into clients’ lifestyle has occurred (DiClemente, 2003). To further explore the use of the techniques of motivational interviewing with the transtheoretical model for the stages of change, Rogers’ model for the diffusion of innovations will be integrated with the transtheoretical model. The models share qualities in the precontempalation, contemplation, and preparation stages which can help coaches work with their clients to help bring about change (Hettema, et. al., 2014). Goal Setting Individuals are affected by their goals on many levels of their lives personally and professionally. The attainment or lack of attainment of goals affects interpersonal relationships. The pursuit of common goals can enhance the quality of relationships. The reason for this enhanced quality is the feeling of closeness which common goals create. This effect has been reported in the research done in this area. Whether a person is seen as a help or hindrance towards achieving the desired goal affects the way the person pursuing the goal sees them (Fitzsimons & Fishbach, 2009). The research which has been done in recent times has been more empirical than earlier research resulting in the Goal Setting Theory (GST). GST sees a relationship between the setting of high goals and task performance. It recognizes the importance of the goal to the individual and the self-confidence of the individual as being major factors in the prioritizing of goals. It is a complex tapestry woven together by the elements of choice, effort, endurance, planning, and complexity of the task all impacting the success achieved in reaching the goal (Latham & Locke, 2007).
  • 5. Hooks Research Paper 5 Goal setting has been shown to have a beneficial effect on clients’ self-esteem. This aspect is especially true when difficult goals are attained. Even if the goal is not attained, the progress towards that goal results in improved self-esteem and overall feelings of well-being in the individuals studied. The achievement of goals has been found to create higher expectations for success thus creating a positive cycle of goal setting, goal commitment, and goal attainment which increases the cognitive and motivational abilities of individuals (Morisano, et. al., 2010). Goals should be created with the clients’ strengths in mind. It has been found in research that goals which are focused on negative aspects of the clients’ lives and their faults were less likely to improve the clients’ quality of life or performance. It have been found that goals focusing on the strengths of the clients build a better rapport with the coaches and clients report a greater overall satisfaction with the coaching relationship (Welch, et. al., 2014). Research indicates that strength based coaching and goal setting leads to the development of transformational leaders in organizations. These leaders affect their peers as they reach their individual goals. These transformation leaders are able to create shared vision in their teams which enhanced the performance of the team overall. As these leaders and teams succeeded, they were given more difficult assignments (MacKie, 2014). The study of setting goals is growing in the area of group dynamics. It is important to understand the goals of individuals and the relationship to group goals in competitive settings. This element is seen in competitive areas such as sales. Seeing this factor, the achievement of individual goals will impact the success of reaching group goals (Kleingeld, Mierlo, & Arends, 2011).
  • 6. Hooks Research Paper 6 Stages of Change Prochaska and Norcross (2001) hold to there being six stages while DiClemente (2003) holds to there being five stages. The extra stage for Prochaska and Norcross (2001) is the termination phase. The Stages of Change is known as the transtheoretical model (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001). Coaches must have a clear understanding of the stages so that they may help their clients set goals. The stages of change were researched and developed to help people struggling with addictions. The information gathered by this research can be applied to helping clients achieve their goals. It is important for coaches to adapt the information to individual clients to help them set and reach their goals. Though initial and continuing assessment of the clients, coaches may determine the stage which their client is experiencing and tailor the goals to that stage (DiClemente, 2003). The first stage of the transtheoretical model is precontempalation. This is the stage where clients have no intention in changing a behavior. Clients in this stage are either unaware or under-aware of their problem and need for change. Other people are aware of the client’s problem and pressure them to seek help. If they seek help, it is due to pressure from others (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001). The second stage is contemplation. Clients are aware that a problem exists and have started to think about strategies to overcome it. Clients have not yet made the commitment to change at this point. It is possible for clients to remain stuck in this stage for long periods of time. Those clients who state that they are thinking about making a change over the next six months are considered to be in this stage (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001).
  • 7. Hooks Research Paper 7 The third stage is the preparation stage where clients are intending to take action. It is during this stage that clients may take small steps by making small changes in their behaviors. Clients in this stage have not yet committed to taking effective action to undergo change (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001). The fourth stage is the action stage. It is during this stage in which clients commit to overcoming their issues. It is the undertaking of overt behavior changes and is the stage which requires the most time and energy. The changes in this stage are observable therefore clients receive recognition for their changes. Successful alteration of behavior in a time period of one day to six months qualifies clients as being in the action phase (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001). The fifth stage is the maintenance stage. It is during this stage that clients work on integrating the change into their lifestyle to prevent relapse while consolidating their gains. The problem behavior must be extinguished for six months for clients to be considered to be in maintenance. In addition, clients must consistently engage in new behaviors during this same time frame (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001). Prochaska and Norcross (2011) added a sixth stage to the transtheoretical model which is termination. This quite simply defined as clients having the total confidence that they will not relapse. This confidence can be seen as clients experience formerly high risk situations and experience no temptation to relapse into their former behaviors (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001). It has been found that change occurs over a period of time. In research done with college students, Sullivan (2011) found that the participants in a health challenge project reported fluctuation between the stages. People move through the various stages at their own pace. Relapses are common and are part of the process in change (Sullivan, 2011).
  • 8. Hooks Research Paper 8 Motivational Interviewing Motivational interviewing is a technique used in counseling to facilitate change in clients by the alteration of their self-talk from negative to positive. Motivational interviewing is client- centered. The focus is on the concerns of the clients. It borrows heavily from Carl Rogers and his counseling style. It is meant to focus on the current concerns and interests of the client (Miller & Rollnick, 2002). Motivational interviewing is based on three basic premises. The first premise is that clients have an inherent desire to move towards health and wholeness. This desire is skewed by various factors. Despite this distortion of the natural drive, it can be a powerful tool in helping clients change. The second premise is that the client is the expert in bringing about change. The coach acts as a resource to aid in the transformation by providing information and teaching skills but the client is in control of the change process. The third premise is that clients’ investment and ownership of the change process will increase the likelihood for success (Moyers, 2014). The purpose of motivational interviewing is to strengthen clients’ motivation and commitment to change through a collaborative conversation style. This strategy has found use in various fields. Promising results are emerging in the area of prevention and treatment for various health conditions. Research indicates that motivational interviewing can be a tool used for the exploration of clients’ resistance to change (Hettema, et. al., 2014). Motivational interviewing is directed towards dealing with solutions to resolving uncertainty in regards to change. The technical aspect of motivational interviewing seeks to evoke and strengthening the language of change in the clients. This language is known as “change talk”. Coaches learn to listen for this language and reinforce it when it is manifested. This attention to the change talk has been found to reinforce the likelihood for change in clients.
  • 9. Hooks Research Paper 9 Coaches can use careful questioning and reflection to help clients create their change talk vocabulary. The coach reinforces the positive self-talk by helping the client to create a change vocabulary. In this way, motivational interviewing helps the client transition into the desired change (Moyers, 2014). Motivational interviewing is more than techniques. It is more than just a set of tactics to be used to get clients to move in a direction they are reluctant to go. It is a means of communicating with clients to facilitate the desired change by building a working collaboration with the client. Motivational interviewing focuses on the clients’ innate desire to change. Behavioral models and motivational strategies tend to use external means to bring about change in clients. Motivational interviewing seeks out the internal motivation for change then enhances it. This change in the clients therefore must be consistent with their beliefs and values. Motivational interviewing seeks out ambivalence that clients may have about change then find solutions to deal with the ambivalence (Miller & Rollnick, 2002). Based on this research, it can be seen that how clients view coaches can impact the coaching alliance and the clients achieving their goals. The clarity of goals and proper planning is a critical element of the coaching relationship. The performance of clients can be increased through the identification of their goals and working with their coach to create a strategy for implementation to reach the goals. Feedback is crucial to the coaching relationship (Gregory, Beck, & Carr, 2011). The relationship matters in coaching. Motivational interview can build a solid foundation which can be a springboard to help clients set goals and change. Motivational interviewing differs from other strategies in that it helps clients make the decision to change of their own volition. Motivational interviewing is effective because it deals with the ambivalence of clients
  • 10. Hooks Research Paper 10 towards change. It can be supplemented with other strategies to build relationships and improve social skills (Miller & Rollnick, 2009). It is possible for clients to have several goals they are trying to reach at any one time. Goals are reached as the brain adapts to the behaviors and attitudes necessary to reach goals. Energy and efforts may be wasted if goals are not prioritized by clients. It is important that coaches have a good working relationship with their clients. Working with coaches, clients can create a hierarchy for the goals so that the most important ones are reached (Gregory, Beck, & Carr, 2011). Conclusion Using the underlying premises of motivational interviewing, coaches seek to tap into the intrinsic drive for change treating them as the expert in bringing about the change they desire so that they will set goals which they will take ownership thus increasing the chances for success (Moyers, 2014). Through motivation interviewing, coaches can assess the client’s stage of change. Coaches must be careful not to assume that all clients are in the action stage. They may be seeing the coach due to outside pressure from others. Motivational interviewing will help the client to set realistic goals that move through the stages one at a time. Change is a process that takes time. Motivational interviewing will help the coach to determine the best strategy to use with the client and the best stance to take with the client while building rapport (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001). There are several evidence based models available to coaches to help understand how clients make decisions about adopting changes. Rogers puts forth a model of diffusion in regards to innovations with five stages which are knowledge, persuasion, decision, implementation, and confirmation (Hettema, et. al., 2014). There is some continuity between Rogers’ model and the
  • 11. Hooks Research Paper 11 transtheoretical model which can be used by coaches to further enhance their ability to help their clients. The knowledge phase is an awareness of an innovation. Rogers held that there were many factors involved in the knowledge phase and one of the most important factors was communication. Motivational interviewing as a strategy to determine how much information is provided to clients and when it should be done. It has been found learning for clients through informal channels is much more effective than scientific books and articles. This stage corresponds to the precontempalation stage in the transtheoretical model (Hettema, et. al., 2014). Coaches take different stances with clients based on the transtheoretical model. Coaches working with clients who are in the precontempalation stage may build a nurturing relationship with the client. The coach would use motivational interviewing in this case to build rapport and to tap into the client’s intrinsic motivations for change. (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001). The knowledge phase in Rogers’ model is an awareness of an innovation. This stage corresponds to the precontempalation stage in the transtheoretical model. Rogers held that there were many factors involved in the knowledge phase and one of the most important factors was communication. Motivational interviewing as a strategy to determine how much information is provided to clients and when it should be done. It has been found learning for clients through informal channels is much more effective than scientific books and articles (Hettema, et. al., 2014). The second stage is persuasion which the point where clients develop positive or negative attitudes towards innovations. This stage can be compared to the contemplation stage in the transtheoretical model. A coach working with a client in the contemplation stage may use motivational interviewing to help clients become more aware of their situation. It is this stage
  • 12. Hooks Research Paper 12 where clients feel uncertainty about change. The clients are aware of the need for change but still have feelings of ambivalence about it. Motivational interviewing can be used here to help clients motivate themselves into changing through the process of self-discovery. The coach takes a nonjudgmental and empathic stance with clients in this phase (Hettema, et. al., 2014). The decision stage of Roger’s model compares with the preparation stage of the transtheoretical model. The decision phase is the point in which clients make the decision either to accept or reject the innovation. The foundation for this stage has been laid in the knowledge and persuasion phases. It is during the decision stage that coaches can use motivational interviewing techniques to creating an action plan in a collaborative effort with the clients. (Hettema, et. al., 2014). Coaches become collaborators through motivational interviewing to help clients in the preparation stage to create an action plan so that they may progress to the next stage. In the final stages, coaches become sojourners with the clients to offer support needed to help when they encounter stumbling blocks (Prochaska & Norcross, 2001). By using the stages of change and motivational interviewing, coaches can help clients establish goals appropriate for the stage they are experiencing. Each stage has its own unique characteristics therefore need goals unique to the client and the client’s stage of change. Knowledge of Rogers’ model combined with the early stages of the transtheoretical model will help the coach to determine the best stance to take with clients in setting goals. Motivational interviewing will help find the client’s internal motivations for change allowing for the tailoring of goals and actions to the client. Finally, motivational interviewing and understanding the stages of change will help coach work with the clients to set goals that bring about successful change.
  • 13. Hooks Research Paper 13 References DiClemente, C. C. (2003). Addiction and change: How addictions develop and addicted people recover. New York: The Guilford Press. Fitzsimons, G., & Fishbach, A. (2009). Shifting closeness: Interpersonal effects of personal goal progress. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 535-549. Gregory, J., Beck, J., & Carr, A. (2011). Goals, feedback, and self-regulation: Control theory as a natural framework for executive coaching. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 26-38. Hettman, J. E., Ernst, D., Wiliams, J. R., and Miller, K. J. (July 2014). Parallel processes: Using motivational interviewing as an implementation coaching strategy. The Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research, 41(3), 324-336. Kleingeld, A., Mierlo, H., & Arends, L. (2011). The effect of goal setting on group performance: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 96(6), 1289-1304. Retrieved September 29, 2014. Latham, G., & Locke, E. (2007). New developments in and directions for goal-setting Research. European Psychologist, 12(4), 290-300. MacKie, D. (2014). The effectiveness of strength-based executive coaching in enhancing full range leadership development: A controlled study. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 66(2), 118–137-118–137. Miller, W. R. and Rollnick, S. (2002). Motivational interviewing: Preparing people for change (2nd ed). New York, NY: Guilford Press.
  • 14. Hooks Research Paper 14 Miller, W. R., & Rollnick, S. (2009). Ten things that MI is not. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy, 37, 129 –140. doi:10.1017/S1352465809005128 Morisano, D., Hirsh, J., Peterson, J., Pihl, R., & Shore, B. (2010). Setting, elaborating, and reflecting on personal goals improves academic performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 95(2), 255-264. Moyers, T. B. (2014). The relationship in motivational interviewing. Psychotherapy, 51(3), 358- 363. Pavur, E. (2013). Why do organizations want their leaders to be coached? Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 65(4), 289-293. Prochaska, J. O. and Norcross, J. C. (2001). Stages of change. Psychotherapy, 38 (4), 443-448. Sullivan, C. F. (2011). Health behavior change challenge: Understanding stages of change. Communication Teacher, 25(2), 108-114. Welch, D., Reid, K., & Walker, C. (2014). Strengths-based leadership development: Insights from expert coaches. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 66(1), 20- 37.