A comparison between the work done by CEDD on Peng Chau and their plans for Yung Shue Wan - an appeal for common sense.

1. Do we want CEDD to redesign our harbour? Some examples from the Peng Chau redevelopment of 2003: photos taken 4 th April 2011

2. CEDD’s proposed plan 2011

3. A seawall with rubble mound?

4. Surely not this?

5. Or this?

6. The view of the harbour on Peng Chau from every bench along the wall

7. They will tell you they will landscape it later – it won’t help much

8. You’ll still see the concrete wall

9. They might tell you they’ll put in access to the water

10. And that we need emergency vehicle access?

11. And lots of signs like this?

12. Or an LPG store on the harbour front?

13. Or a wet market?

14. Or a piazza?

15. Or a supermarket?

16. We already have a nullah like Peng Chau’s

17. And a monster clock in our harbour

18. A seawall with waste facilities

19. And a rubble mound

20. Do we want more of this?

21. And a plaque to commemorate it?