In 2015 the Plainfield-Guilford Township Public Library had an all-too-familiar problem to solve: how to fulfill the need for technology help in the community. While they previously offered formal computer classes, the library found that customers were wanting technology help on their terms. The technology team at the library took a step back and decided to take a very informal approach to tackle the problem, and thus “Digital Drop In” was born. “Digital Drop In” is a weekly 2-hour window where people can come in with any and all technology questions, and team with tech-savvy library staff are available to help as best they can. From old answering machines to brand new tablets and laptops, and from quick questions to weekly visitors, the “Digital Drop In” has been a great success and has eliminated the library’s need for traditional computer classes.
Presenter: Laura Brack / Plainfield-Guilford Township Public Library
1. Simplified Technology Training
for the Public
How One Library Evolved to Fit the Technology Needs
of Their Community
Laura E Brack
IT Manager
Plainfield-Guilford Twp Public Library
Lbrack@plainfieldlibrary.net
317-839-6602 x2152
www.plainfieldlibrary.net
4. When did you start offering computer classes?
What kind of struggles have you had?
What are your success stories?
5. A Brief History of our “Computer Classes”
Prior to 2007…
Introduction & Intermediate series
Computer Savvy Seniors
Cost per class
But…
At the mercy of a company
Cost us time and $ to prep
Cost to the students
Prerequisites
Too many rules/ifs/buts
Classes were too long, too much of
a commitment
OK at the time, but not good enough anymore.
6. More History of our “Computer Classes”
2007 - 2014
Introductory series & standalones
Shorter classes, help from volunteers
Seniors Helping Seniors
Great opportunities + relationships
Cost per class/for supplies
Thorough registration booklet
Thorough attendance stats
Training Needs Log…
But…
Registration always full, waitlist,
no-shows
Volunteers unreliable
There’s always that one person…
Still cost us time and $ to prep
Still cost the students
Still prerequisites
Still too many rules/ifs/buts
OK at the time, but *still* not good enough.
7. Technology Training Needs Log…
Tapered formal class offerings down to twice a year
Took info for people who wanted tech training
Asked what they needed to learn
…Some people thought that meant they were then signed up for a class
Felt pressure to offer the obscure suggestions
9. What Do They Need? What Do They Want?
Their own stuff
Their own terms
Their own time
10. How often have you heard “My kids got me this eReader, but I don’t
know how to use it?
Do you cringe when new technologies and services are offered at the
library?
How do you cope with desk staff who aren’t as tech-savvy?
11. Rethinking Our Customers’ Needs
Variety of devices
Not everyone wants a class
Varying needs (not always tech-
related)
Different levels of know-how
Customers and Staff!
12.
13. What We’ve Learned
This July will be 3 years!
In 2014 we helped 89 people
In 2015 we helped 196 people
In 2016 we helped 198 people
Attendance:
As few as 0 and as many 14
“You guys are better than the Geek
Squad!”
“This was free?”
“You’re here every week?”
Keep track of weird questions and
fixes
Staff strengths/weaknesses
Set an alarm for “closing time”
Be ready for anything!
14. Questions, Comments, Stories?
Laura E Brack
IT Manager
Plainfield-Guilford Twp Public Library
Lbrack@plainfieldlibrary.net
317-839-6602 x2152
www.plainfieldlibrary.net
Editor's Notes
-Started working at PGTPL as a 15-year old high-school page, then as a sub until mid-way through my undergrad.
-Dabbling in technology at the library grew to an interest and enrollment in the school of Informatics, where I received a BS in Informatics teaching.
-I returned to PGTPL in 2007, and have been here ever since. After about a year back, I decided to dive in for my MLS. My BS and MLS allow me to combine my love for technology, information, and teaching.
-I’ve been able to fill many roles in the library: started as a page, then AYAS substitute, Interlibrary Loan specialist, Adult Programmer, Webmaster, Technology Instructor, IT Manager. I refer to myself as a jack of all trades… I like to dabble in all things library and technology-related, but I’m the first to admit that I’m no expert… there’s always room to learn.
-I’m a single mom to 2 awesome and hilarious kids. When I’m not working I like to garden with my boys, dabble in food preservation, knit, challenge my kids in various video games
Plainfield Library serves Plainfield and Guilford Township. In 2016, we had over 433,000 checkouts and 15,000 cardholders! We have an average of 550 customers per day who want to check things out, use our free computers and WIFI, or participate in programs.
-Service population is nearly 30,000
-We are mid-way through a rebranding
-We aren’t a “quiet” library. We like to try new things. We were one of the first Hoosier libraries to plant Little Free Libraries, and currently have 16. In 2015-2016 we offered STEM/Maker programs and interactive opportunities to almost 1,000 kids and teens.
Before I returned in 2007 we were offering computer classes at our library but through an outside company. Introductory and intermediate classes were offered, but there were lots of caveats.
First, the library was at the mercy of the company. No one on our staff was involved with teaching the classes, so we were totally reliant upon the company and the instructors they provided. If students needed help beyond the class while practicing in the library it was up to library staff to answer questions. Also, because the company taught at multiple libraries there was often confusion as to what instructors went where and which library students were signed up at. Though the company provided the manuals, we were responsible for printing and comb-binding them. So although we paid the company we still had to use staff time and our own resources.
The classes came with a lot of prerequisites, rules, and ifs or buts. First, there were no refunds. People could repeat classes if they felt they didn’t learn much the first time, but they had to pay another fee. People signed up for a series like Computer Savvy seniors had to attend all sessions, and the class times were so long it became unrealistic.
The classes met our patrons’ needs, but they weren’t perfect.
In 2007 the adult programmer librarian asked me to develop some introductory computer classes to replace what the company had been doing. I tried a series of 4 introductory classes and a 4-week “Seniors Helping Seniors” initiative, where seniors from Plainfield High School worked one-on-one to help Senior Citizens learn to use computers. This initiative was successful and built some great relationships and created great opportunities for local students, but unfortunately, as many of us know, volunteers are hard to manage and hard to rely on, and the work that went into this became more than the payout was worth.
We thought we could save money and resources by doing the classes ourselves. I used Publisher to create a booklet to go with each class that ended up being about 15-20 pages. We wanted to eliminate the fee for classes, and did for awhile, but found that the lack of payment made people feel like it wasn’t an obligation. At times we would have classes fully registered and with full waiting lists, but people would meander in late (I once had a woman show up 30 minutes late and ask to leave 60 minutes early) or not show up at all, which wasn’t fair to people who were waitlisted. We also had people who signed up for every single class, taking up seats that new students could have used. We had to implement rules and reinstate fees (basically a 10 cent per page fee) to get people to stay committed to the class. It really felt like pulling teeth.
At one point in time I was doing two sessions of the classes per month (morning and evening), every other month. It was hard on staff when I had to stay home sick, and we usually ended up having to cancel classes when that happened. I also had a baby and took FMLA during this time, and the lack of classes was frustrating for the public.
In 2012 registration and attendance for the introductory classes really waned. This was when we realized the classes weren’t meeting the technology-training needs of our community. But what did they need?
When Windows 8 rolled out we had an influx of people who needed or wanted to learn it. Many people were buying new computers with Windows 8 on them, but our machines all still used 7. Our staff wasn’t familiar with 8, I wasn’t familiar with 8, and we weren’t planning on upgrading our public computers to 8. This was also around the time that I was completing my MLS, and I had another baby, so my time was getting more and more stretched. We decreased the frequency of the computer classes. At the desk when people would come to ask about computer classes, we would explain we offered them twice a year, then ask what they specifically were looking for. More often than not, they weren’t looking for regular-old introductory computer classes anymore.
FOR EXAMPLE, one woman (let’s call her Roberta) left her information and came back repeatedly asking about computer classes. Her husband, who took care of all the finances and things, had recently and unexpectedly passed away, and she was lost. Unfortunately, probably due to her stress, Roberta mistakenly thought she was signed up for the next round of classes, and was disappointed to find she wasn’t.
The technology training log seemed like a blessing and a curse. It gave me ideas for different classes, and those classes went okay.
I tried introducing people to Facebook, but Facebook changes so quickly there were times I found myself scrambling to find answers in front of a group of people. Goodreads seemed like a great idea, but everyone wanted to use it their own way.
I still had to teach the organized formal classes because they still kept getting requested. But attendance still went downhill.
DEVICES: Ancient answering machine, digital camera, residential-sized all-in-one printer,
VARYING NEEDS: One older woman wanted to get on Facebook to see her kids and grandkids, wanted to be able to post messages to her family, see pictures, and share things. She was concerned about privacy, and was at a very beginner level. She didn’t need the whole Facebook experience, so one staff member helped her with the basics and got her in touch with family.
A similar story: We have one patron who comes in several times a week for books and DVDs. When she found out about the Digital Drop-In she brought her tablet in and asked us to help her get started with Facebook. She already had an account, but didn’t know what to do next. An hour later she was messaging with a cousin she hadn’t seen or heard from in over 20 years.
Remember Roberta? Roberta was pleased to hear about the Digital Drop-In… in fact, she was happy to hear this was an alternative to the classes she had missed out on. Roberta became a regular drop-in visitor for 18 months. She learned how to check her email, and dabbled in paying bills. We all noticed that the biggest things she seemed to get out of Digital Drop-In, however, was her new-found confidence and social-time.
Staff who aren’t comfortable helping someone with tech-involved questions have an “out” by offering Digital Drop-In on Mondays
When we can’t have Digital Drop-In (due to staff absences, holidays, etc.) people are very understanding because it always comes back. We have a sign we can put on the door when we have to unexpectedly cancel that directs people to our Desk, and it has always worked out just fine.
One woman brought in an old cell phone she’d been meaning to throw away for months. She was afraid she couldn’t “just throw it away.” We showed her our recycling bins and assured her it was an okay way to dispose of it. She felt so good about it she went home and got an old router she’d had forever and we helped her dispose of it too.
Non-smartphones aren’t an option anymore. We had one man who had to get a smartphone because his carrier didn’t offer anything more simplified. He was able to get started with our help.
At a fundraiser event one man stepped up to our table and had lots of comments for us about our library. “You guys are still around? Do people still even read? Now that we have Google, what do we need librarians for?” As he berated us it came out that he was having trouble with his cell phone. We handed him information about our Digital Drop-In and he was there the very next week. After we helped him get going with his phone he had a few more compliments for us.