The document discusses the biological nature of optimal orthodontic forces from various perspectives. It describes histological studies that show how bone cells respond to mechanical stress from orthodontic forces. The studies indicate periodontal ligament and alveolar bone marrow cells are most sensitive. Optimal forces are light, avoid ischemic damage, and allow time for tissue recovery. Finite element analyses show force distribution varies by tooth configuration. The concept of optimal force was first introduced in 1932 to mean below blood pressure to avoid tissue injury. Histology has provided insights into optimizing force magnitude, duration, and direction of tooth movement within alveolar bone.
16. Maxillary histology after Tx
with SWA. Wherbein, Fuhrmann, and
Diedrich, 1995
• A 19 yr old female after 19 mos Tx with
SWA, including 2 mos torque with a
0.017 x 0.025” stainless steal arch wire.
• Histologic findings of damage (bony
dehiscences, fenestrations, and root
resorption) were more pronounced than
the radiographs would suggest.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
33. Conclusions
• Bone cells respond readily in vivo to applied
mechanical stress
• This response depends upon variables such as
stress magnitude, rate, distribution, and
duration
• Osteocytes are main target cells in orthopedics,
while PDL and alveolar bone marrow cells
appear to be the principal cell types sensitive to
applied mechanical stress in orthodontics
www.indiandentalacademy.com
45. Conclusions
• Understanding the biological effects of
orthodontic forces and correlating them
with clinical events may facilitate and
promote the development and utilization
of means to optimize mechanotherapy.
• Magnets and electric currents are
examples of such optimizing means.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
46. A. Martin Schwarz was the
first author to coin the term
“optimal force” in
orthodontics (1932)
www.indiandentalacademy.com
50. Points worth remembering
from Schwarz’s 1932 article
• An optimal force does not exceed the
blood pressure in the capillaries, thereby
avoids ischemic injuries to dental and
paradental tissues.
• Orthodontic forces must be estimated
and measured for each tooth.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
54. A comment regarding orthodontic
force distribution in jaws
• Finite element analyses in the 1980s and
90s have revealed that the distribution of
forces around orthodontically-treated
teeth depends on the type of applied force
and the configuration of the teeth and
their surrounding tissues.
• In every case, the distribution of these
forces is never equal.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
55. In the quest for an optimal
orthodontic force, what have
we learned from histological
studies?
www.indiandentalacademy.com
77. In the quest for an optimal
orthodontic force, what have we
learned from histological studies?
• That the magnitude of the applied force
is an important determinant of tooth
movement. However, the effects of
magnitude are influenced by other co-
factors, such as mechanical principles,
the duration of force application, and the
specific anatomical details of the involved
tissues.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
96. Conclusions from Reitan and Rygh’s
histological studies on the features of
optimal orthodontic forces
• They should be patient-friendly: cause
minimal pain and discomfort, and move
teeth efficiently to new correct positions.
• They should be tissue- and cell-friendly:
promote cell proliferation,
differentiation, and activation, and evoke
proper remodeling of paradental tissues.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
97. Conclusions from Reitan and Rygh’s
histological studies on the features of
optimal orthodontic forces
• Any type of tooth movement, i.e.,
intrusion, translation, etc., should result
from the application of light forces, that
do not harm or kill large numbers of
PDL and alveolar bone cells, but rather
strain them, while maintaining their
vitality in both areas of compression and
tension.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
98. Conclusions from Reitan and Rygh’s
histological studies on the features of
optimal orthodontic forces
• Tipping of teeth, especially uncontrolled
tipping, may bring root apices into
contact with compact plates of bone, thus
increasing the risk for severe root
resorption.
• Interrupted forces are biologically better
than continuously applied forces, because
they provide time for recovery.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
99. By subjecting the cells to either
positive or negative
hydrostatic pressures in vitro.
Yousefian J, Shanfeld J, Davidovitch Z, 1995
www.indiandentalacademy.com
106. These results demonstrate that human
PDL fibroblasts in culture respond to
applied hydrostatic pressures, either
positive or negative, within well
defined numerical boundaries.
It is, therefore, reasonable to assume
that a similar situation exists in vivo.
Orthodontic forces within this range
may be defined as optimal or effective.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
110. The Amalgamated Technique:
A practical and effective
method of moving teeth in an
optimal fashion
De Angelis V, 1975, 1980, 2004
www.indiandentalacademy.com
111. Fundamental principles of the
Amalgamated Technique
1. Forces are light, continuous, and
relatively non-traumatic (low load
deflection rates due to the use of extra-
slot torque).
2. Root movements are deliberate, non-
redundant, and remain within the
confines of the alveolar bone
throughout treatment.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
112. Fundamental principles of the
Amalgamated Technique
3. Shortened treatment duration results in
limited exposure to root resorbing cells.
4. Limits irreversible tissue changes even
in individuals with compromised
immune systems.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
113. Radiographic images of damaged
incisor roots following treatment
with conventional Edgewise
appliances
www.indiandentalacademy.com
122. Observations
• Periapical radiographs show incisor root
shortening in the facial plane. This view
usually does not reveal the reason for the
root resorption.
• Lateral cephalograms show it in the
sagittal plane. This view exposes
alterations in root-bone plate contacts,
the leading etiology of root resorption.
www.indiandentalacademy.com
123. Observations
• An optimal orthodontic force avoids
moving dental roots into surrounding
plates of compact bone, or moving them
redundantly, thereby preserving the
roots’ length.
• The Amalgamated Technique is capable
of correcting malocclusions without
causing tissue damage. It can, therefore,
be classified as a biologically optimal
method. www.indiandentalacademy.com
124. Conclusions
• An optimal orthodontic force can thus be
defined as one which is light, continuous
or intermittent, moving the roots non-
redundantly within the confines of the
alveolar bone.
• This kind of force is tolerable by patients,
does not damage tissues, and moves teeth
efficiently.
www.indiandentalacademy.com