SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 11
An Investor View of Post‐Combustion CO2 Capture
Carbon Capture Summit
Long Beach, California October 19th, 2022
Table of contents
2
3 CCS Infrastructure Investing Objectives and Perspectives
Wolf Carbon Solutions: Canada and US
1
CCS Post‐Combustion Capture Opportunity
2
Appendices (Pore Space, Pipeline Specifications)
4
Wolf Carbon Solutions Canada – An Operating CCUS Hub
Wolf developed and operates the only multi‐client anthropogenic CCUS system in North America
3
Wolf Assets: CO2 Capture / Compression
• Two sources totalling ~4,400 Mt/day – NWR (refinery) and Nutrien
(fertilizer plant) (2 additional Fortune 500 sources pending)
• Wolf built/owns/operates 35,000 hp of CO2 compression and water
removal / disposal
Wolf Assets: CO2 Transport
• Currently delivers CO2 to EOR fields
• Wolf built / owns / operates the 150 mile, 10 Mtpa capacity CO2
pipeline
• 27 months of operation with >3.0 million tonnes CO2 captured to
date
Wolf Assets: CO2 Sequestration / Pore Space
• Extensive area of well‐known deep saline aquifer pore space
adjacent to ACTL, secured in March 2022
• Initial test drilling 1Q 2023, service on‐line in ~2024
1
Wolf CO2
Pore Space
CO2 Transport
(EOR pore space)
CO2 Capture &
Compression
Pending Sources:
2000‐6000 Mt/day
4
Wolf Carbon Solutions US – Mount Simon Hub CCS Project
Project Attributes
1. Capital Efficiency: Maximizing tonne CO2/capex
2. Customer‐sponsored, proven, and operating
sequestration already in place (ADM Decatur)
3. Full value chain offering (Capture, transport,
sequestration)
4. Minimized pipeline stakeholder impact. Only 2
states, modest mileage, avoid eminent domain,
highest tons CO2 moved per mile
Wolf project is best in class on volume / capital
efficiency attributes vs. competing Midwest projects
Archer Daniels Midland CO2 Sources
Other CO2 Emitters
Mount Simon Sequestration
Wolf CO2 Pipeline region
5
Combustion Is the Largest Source of Stationary CO2 for CCS Infrastructure
100% Combustion. Electric power is 2/3 of CO2
emissions from stationary sources.
Mostly Combustion. Fossil fuels burned in industrial
furnaces / boilers plus some other misc. process CO2
Higher‐Purity Process CO2. Usually originates from
chemical processing / reforming of hydrocarbons
Mostly Biogenic. CO2 originates from ‘new’ biomass,
not liberated from ancient biomass (fossil fuel)
Most recent and pending CCS infrastructure
investment is focused on non‐combustion CO2:
High‐purity, low‐capture‐cost, process sources
Niche opportunities where there are select
higher‐purity CO2 streams, often from
hydrocarbon reforming (e.g. hydrogen
production from natural gas)
Source: Great Plains Institute Regional White Paper 2020
MM Mtpa
2
6
Post‐Combustion: CO2 Capture Cost is Still the Key Hurdle for Widespread CCS
Transport and storage costs benefit from
natural economy of scale per multi‐user
volumes. (Capture generally does not)
Capture cost per tonne is inversely
proportional to source CO2 concentration.
Capture cost ‘floor’ is the compression/
liquefaction cost for low‐pressure CO2
(almost all sources) at $20‐$30 / tonne
Post‐combustion CO2 sources are all
generally >$100/tonne CCS cost, primarily
in capture. Still doesn’t generally work at
the new $85 45Q value.
CCS
Unit
Cost
Source
CO
2
Content
Post‐combustion
dilute CO2 Sources
Process & Higher‐Purity CO2 Sources
7
CCS Infrastructure ‐ Investing Perspectives
What Attributes Are Infrastructure Investors Looking For?
• Intrinsic value – an essential service to the infra users, usage not ‘cyclical’, periodic, or boom‐bust
• Structured Return Drivers ‐ underlying service contracts are the economic foundation, not
correlated to the macro economy
• Continuous and Stable Income ‐ regular cash flow with low volatility, and not requiring cash
reinvesting for growth
• Known and manageable risks – higher levels of manageable risks will require a higher cost of capital,
major loss risks must be insurable.
What are the Inherent Challenges with CCS (and Other) Infrastructure Assets
• Single source of income/return. A failure at any link of the CCS chain will undermine the revenue
• Technical Chain: Complex and intensive processing from capture through to sequestration
• Business Partner Chain: Emitter companies, special technology suppliers, governments
• Large and illiquid Assets: Exit, repurposing, or redeployment are generally impossible if there is a
significant adverse structural event. (e.g. Tech: Kemper Mi. CCS Partner: Nord Stream 2 Pipeline)
3
8
Miles’ Law* Applies to CCS Risks: “WhereYou Stand Dependson WhereYou Sit”
CO2 Emitters already own the downside risks of
• Emissions: Producing assets and/or products will be competitively disadvantaged by a high CO2
footprint via carbon taxes/regs or market preference for lower carbon‐index competitor product.
(The “do nothing” case for emitters has some risk, depending on product and jurisdiction)
• Core Business: (non‐emission related items) input costs, market demand, and the general
competitive environment of their product
CCS infrastructure investors are putting up new money to enter a business in hopes of making a return.
• Large quantum (hundreds of millions $) complex assets that must reliably operate for years to get
return OF capital and return ON capital
• CCS infrastructure generally does not support high‐margin/quick payback, and unforseen income
windfalls are rare. (…..but on the other hand, the “do nothing case” is entirely risk‐free)
*Rufus Edward Miles: Chief of the labor and welfare branch of the Bureau of the Budget 1948‐1949
Emitter engagement in the CCS business model – different ends of the spectrum
Low: send flue gas over the plant fence to capture a small free ‘incremental uplift’ (e.g. share of 45Q credits)
High: Mission‐critical core business dependence on cost and reliability of CCS (e.g. regulatory requirement)
9
What are some risks borne by the long‐term CCS infrastructure stakeholders?
1. Regulatory timing: Pipeline and sequestration permits have risk of delay or even possible suspension.
Potential for significant loss of front‐end capital (10%‐20% of total project cost, e.g. energy pipelines)
2. Greenfield Construction: Major project execution capital cost risk (overruns)
3. Source CO2 volumes:
• Market and life‐cycle of underlying emitter assets (e.g. oil refinery, chemical plant, etc.)
• CO2 capture facilities recovery rates, on‐line time, (new capture technology reliability risk)
4. Third Party CO2 volumes: Additional accretive third‐party volumes are added to the system
5. Long Term Energy / Power costs: Electrical power cost for CO2 liquefaction and other energy for
capture processes are key. (energy for pipeline transport and CO2 injection is minimal)
6. CCS O&M costs: e.g. CO2 solvent absorption media performance and life‐cycle , rotating/complex
equipment operational efficiency, overhaul frequency and cost, etc.
7. Geological Risk: Sequestration CO2 migrates, or formation pressure increases, faster than expected
(more capital for pore‐space and wells required)
8. CO2 Revenue and Market Shifts: 45Q program is discontinued some years down the road, value of
carbon offsets changes
These outcomes have the potential to provide material “upside” (most other risks above do not have any upside materiality).
10
Decarbonization: Pathways for Electrical Power Generation and Industrials
Continue Using Fossil Fuels and Decarbonize with CCS
1. Take the carbon out of the fuel before mixing with air and sending to the burner tip. CO2 is easier
to extract from a Hydrogen reformer process than from flue gas.
2. Pick a Winner In Dilute CO2 Capture Technology. Amine absorption, Inorganic Chemical Sorbents,
Temperature/Pressure/Electro Swing Adsorption, Cryogenic Separation
3. Combine pure oxygen (instead of air) with a fossil fuel for combustion to produce “pure CO2 and
water” flue gas.
In all cases above: Operate the combustion‐capture (or hydrogen reformer) at elevated pressure to
save some portion of the $20‐$30 CO2 liquefaction energy, O&M, and capital expense
Competing Alternative Pathways: Eliminate the Use of Fossil Fuels and Forget CCS
• Electricity Generation. “Renewable power plus storage” is approaching competitive parity with gas
• Industrial Heat: Electrify with green power, use a fuel with no carbon (green hydrogen), find a
breakthrough new technology for specific hard‐to‐abate industries. (cement, steel, etc.)
0.49
Cook
11
Commercial Foundation Issues Comments, examples
One‐and‐done: single supply to single disposition point All risks are amplified by lack of supply diversity for the infra investment
Stroke‐of‐pen legislation change risk Infra developer typically does not take 100% of future 45Q risk‐reward
Capital Market Retreat and Retrenchment Some banks and equity investors not funding coal‐based or EOR‐based CCS
Misalignment / lack of alignment with the emitter Emitter is apathetic to decarbonization – CCS is purely ancillary revenue
Emitter base business market and regulatory risks Major CCS infra needs a creditworthy emitter to backstop the investment
CO2 Capture Related Investment Barriers
Sustainability paradox – compounding energy consumption
E.g. 1000 MTpd incremental energy use to capture 2000 MTpd CO2 (Wolf
estimate) Includes the unavoidable compression‐liquefaction energy(!)
New chemical or new use of old chemical Unproven in long term – performance, degradation rate, cost (e.g. new solvent)
No operating history for new hardware or new process
“New” is a matter of degree, not typically black and white. Any new patented
process with serial number 001 is difficult. (e.g. hydrogen‐fueled turbines)
Unknown environmental wildcard E.g. trace amounts of sorbent / solvent in scrubbed flue gas and atmosphere
Adverse affect on emitter assets or process Flue gas CO2 capture system backpressure voids a gas turbine warranty
Trace CO2 impurities impact on pipeline metallurgy E.g. SOx NOx combustion products affect corrosion and CO2 phase properties
Critical long‐term component or supply from a start‐up supplier Proprietary custom sorbent media, pellets, beds, etc.
Examples of Investability / Financeability Barriers for Large CCS Infrastructure

More Related Content

Similar to AN INVESTOR VIEW OF POST-COMBUSTION CO₂ CAPTURE

Economics of promotions_of_r&d_of_carbon_capture
Economics of promotions_of_r&d_of_carbon_captureEconomics of promotions_of_r&d_of_carbon_capture
Economics of promotions_of_r&d_of_carbon_capture
Suresh Malluswamy
 
Eor Brd Ppt 25 Aug09
Eor Brd Ppt 25 Aug09Eor Brd Ppt 25 Aug09
Eor Brd Ppt 25 Aug09
princeslea79
 
Carbon Capture Status & Outlook 2007
Carbon Capture Status & Outlook 2007Carbon Capture Status & Outlook 2007
Carbon Capture Status & Outlook 2007
Anthony Cirillo, PE
 
Carbon Accounting Buildings | Sue Roaf
Carbon Accounting Buildings | Sue Roaf Carbon Accounting Buildings | Sue Roaf
Carbon Accounting Buildings | Sue Roaf
icarb
 
2 co making the business case for ccs
2 co   making the business case for ccs2 co   making the business case for ccs
2 co making the business case for ccs
Global CCS Institute
 

Similar to AN INVESTOR VIEW OF POST-COMBUSTION CO₂ CAPTURE (20)

Techno-economic assessment and global sensitivity analysis for biomass-based ...
Techno-economic assessment and global sensitivity analysis for biomass-based ...Techno-economic assessment and global sensitivity analysis for biomass-based ...
Techno-economic assessment and global sensitivity analysis for biomass-based ...
 
Economics of promotions_of_r&d_of_carbon_capture
Economics of promotions_of_r&d_of_carbon_captureEconomics of promotions_of_r&d_of_carbon_capture
Economics of promotions_of_r&d_of_carbon_capture
 
Dr Julio Friedmann - The next decade of CCS projects and technology
Dr Julio Friedmann - The next decade of CCS  projects and technologyDr Julio Friedmann - The next decade of CCS  projects and technology
Dr Julio Friedmann - The next decade of CCS projects and technology
 
Green Capitalism: India, August 7, 2014
Green Capitalism: India, August 7, 2014Green Capitalism: India, August 7, 2014
Green Capitalism: India, August 7, 2014
 
Technological Challenges and Opportunities for CO2 Capture and Sequestration ...
Technological Challenges and Opportunities for CO2 Capture and Sequestration ...Technological Challenges and Opportunities for CO2 Capture and Sequestration ...
Technological Challenges and Opportunities for CO2 Capture and Sequestration ...
 
Overview of Current Directions in Carbon Capture R&D
Overview of Current Directions in Carbon Capture R&DOverview of Current Directions in Carbon Capture R&D
Overview of Current Directions in Carbon Capture R&D
 
CCUS-2021 FactBook.pdf
CCUS-2021 FactBook.pdfCCUS-2021 FactBook.pdf
CCUS-2021 FactBook.pdf
 
Carbon capture and storage
Carbon capture and storage Carbon capture and storage
Carbon capture and storage
 
Carbon Capture and Utilization Outlook
Carbon Capture and Utilization OutlookCarbon Capture and Utilization Outlook
Carbon Capture and Utilization Outlook
 
Panel 5. CCS projects in action - Professor Jon Gibbins, University of Edinburgh
Panel 5. CCS projects in action - Professor Jon Gibbins, University of EdinburghPanel 5. CCS projects in action - Professor Jon Gibbins, University of Edinburgh
Panel 5. CCS projects in action - Professor Jon Gibbins, University of Edinburgh
 
Eor Brd Ppt 25 Aug09
Eor Brd Ppt 25 Aug09Eor Brd Ppt 25 Aug09
Eor Brd Ppt 25 Aug09
 
Carbon Capture Status & Outlook 2007
Carbon Capture Status & Outlook 2007Carbon Capture Status & Outlook 2007
Carbon Capture Status & Outlook 2007
 
Costs of capturing CO2 from industrial sources - Morgan Summers, National Ene...
Costs of capturing CO2 from industrial sources - Morgan Summers, National Ene...Costs of capturing CO2 from industrial sources - Morgan Summers, National Ene...
Costs of capturing CO2 from industrial sources - Morgan Summers, National Ene...
 
Carbon Accounting Buildings | Sue Roaf
Carbon Accounting Buildings | Sue Roaf Carbon Accounting Buildings | Sue Roaf
Carbon Accounting Buildings | Sue Roaf
 
2 co making the business case for ccs
2 co   making the business case for ccs2 co   making the business case for ccs
2 co making the business case for ccs
 
Update on CCS Activities in Canada and Possible Topics for European Collabora...
Update on CCS Activities in Canada and Possible Topics for European Collabora...Update on CCS Activities in Canada and Possible Topics for European Collabora...
Update on CCS Activities in Canada and Possible Topics for European Collabora...
 
WB alternative energy
WB alternative energyWB alternative energy
WB alternative energy
 
CCUS_Fracking
CCUS_FrackingCCUS_Fracking
CCUS_Fracking
 
Blueprint for Industrial CCS in the UK, Mark Lewis, Tees Valley Unlimited - U...
Blueprint for Industrial CCS in the UK, Mark Lewis, Tees Valley Unlimited - U...Blueprint for Industrial CCS in the UK, Mark Lewis, Tees Valley Unlimited - U...
Blueprint for Industrial CCS in the UK, Mark Lewis, Tees Valley Unlimited - U...
 
Global CCS Institute Presentation
Global CCS Institute PresentationGlobal CCS Institute Presentation
Global CCS Institute Presentation
 

More from iQHub

CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS: THE TRANSITION FROM CREWED TO UNCREWED UAM
CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS: THE TRANSITION FROM CREWED TO UNCREWED UAMCONCEPT OF OPERATIONS: THE TRANSITION FROM CREWED TO UNCREWED UAM
CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS: THE TRANSITION FROM CREWED TO UNCREWED UAM
iQHub
 
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS FOR HIGH-POWER-DENSITY E-MOTORS FOR AEROSPACE PROPULSION
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS FOR HIGH-POWER-DENSITY E-MOTORS FOR AEROSPACE PROPULSIONINNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS FOR HIGH-POWER-DENSITY E-MOTORS FOR AEROSPACE PROPULSION
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS FOR HIGH-POWER-DENSITY E-MOTORS FOR AEROSPACE PROPULSION
iQHub
 
AN ELECTRIC FUTURE - READYING AIRPORTS FOR ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT
AN ELECTRIC FUTURE - READYING AIRPORTS FOR ELECTRIC AIRCRAFTAN ELECTRIC FUTURE - READYING AIRPORTS FOR ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT
AN ELECTRIC FUTURE - READYING AIRPORTS FOR ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT
iQHub
 
HYBRIDIZATION IS THE MISSING LINK BETWEEN ELECTRIFICATION AND SUSTAINABLE FUELS
HYBRIDIZATION IS THE MISSING LINK BETWEEN ELECTRIFICATION AND SUSTAINABLE FUELSHYBRIDIZATION IS THE MISSING LINK BETWEEN ELECTRIFICATION AND SUSTAINABLE FUELS
HYBRIDIZATION IS THE MISSING LINK BETWEEN ELECTRIFICATION AND SUSTAINABLE FUELS
iQHub
 
LAUNCHING UAM SERVICES IN A LARGE CITY: THE ROME EXPERIENCE
LAUNCHING UAM SERVICES IN A LARGE CITY: THE ROME EXPERIENCELAUNCHING UAM SERVICES IN A LARGE CITY: THE ROME EXPERIENCE
LAUNCHING UAM SERVICES IN A LARGE CITY: THE ROME EXPERIENCE
iQHub
 
ADVANCED BIO-CIRCULAR MATERIALS: HIGH-PERFORMANCE AND DURABLE PRODUCTS
ADVANCED BIO-CIRCULAR MATERIALS: HIGH-PERFORMANCE AND DURABLE PRODUCTSADVANCED BIO-CIRCULAR MATERIALS: HIGH-PERFORMANCE AND DURABLE PRODUCTS
ADVANCED BIO-CIRCULAR MATERIALS: HIGH-PERFORMANCE AND DURABLE PRODUCTS
iQHub
 
HOW TO CREATE A NET ZERO PLASTIC SOCIETY FROM THE CONVERTORS POINT OF VIEW?
HOW TO CREATE A NET ZERO PLASTIC SOCIETY FROM THE CONVERTORS POINT OF VIEW?HOW TO CREATE A NET ZERO PLASTIC SOCIETY FROM THE CONVERTORS POINT OF VIEW?
HOW TO CREATE A NET ZERO PLASTIC SOCIETY FROM THE CONVERTORS POINT OF VIEW?
iQHub
 
BIO-BASED ADDITIVES TO IMPROVE THE PERFORMANCE & PROCESSING OF BIOPOLYMERS
BIO-BASED ADDITIVES TO IMPROVE THE PERFORMANCE & PROCESSING OF BIOPOLYMERSBIO-BASED ADDITIVES TO IMPROVE THE PERFORMANCE & PROCESSING OF BIOPOLYMERS
BIO-BASED ADDITIVES TO IMPROVE THE PERFORMANCE & PROCESSING OF BIOPOLYMERS
iQHub
 
CLOSING THE LOOP ON MATERIALS COLLECTED AND SORTING: CURBSIDE COLLECTION
CLOSING THE LOOP ON MATERIALS COLLECTED AND SORTING: CURBSIDE COLLECTIONCLOSING THE LOOP ON MATERIALS COLLECTED AND SORTING: CURBSIDE COLLECTION
CLOSING THE LOOP ON MATERIALS COLLECTED AND SORTING: CURBSIDE COLLECTION
iQHub
 
STAGES OF SUSTAINABILITY: TRANSITION FROM BROAD TERMINOLOGY TO MARKET UNDERS...
 STAGES OF SUSTAINABILITY: TRANSITION FROM BROAD TERMINOLOGY TO MARKET UNDERS... STAGES OF SUSTAINABILITY: TRANSITION FROM BROAD TERMINOLOGY TO MARKET UNDERS...
STAGES OF SUSTAINABILITY: TRANSITION FROM BROAD TERMINOLOGY TO MARKET UNDERS...
iQHub
 
MAKING PLASTICS FULLY SUSTAINABLE, THE DECARBONIZED PLASTICS-TO-HYDROGEN PATHWAY
MAKING PLASTICS FULLY SUSTAINABLE, THE DECARBONIZED PLASTICS-TO-HYDROGEN PATHWAYMAKING PLASTICS FULLY SUSTAINABLE, THE DECARBONIZED PLASTICS-TO-HYDROGEN PATHWAY
MAKING PLASTICS FULLY SUSTAINABLE, THE DECARBONIZED PLASTICS-TO-HYDROGEN PATHWAY
iQHub
 
GLOBAL EXTENDED PRODUCERS' RESPONSIBILITY DEVELOPMENTS AND WHAT THEY MEAN
GLOBAL EXTENDED PRODUCERS' RESPONSIBILITY DEVELOPMENTS AND WHAT THEY MEANGLOBAL EXTENDED PRODUCERS' RESPONSIBILITY DEVELOPMENTS AND WHAT THEY MEAN
GLOBAL EXTENDED PRODUCERS' RESPONSIBILITY DEVELOPMENTS AND WHAT THEY MEAN
iQHub
 
UTILIZING AMI TO IDENTIFY LEAKS, IRRIGATION, AND EDUCATE CUSTOMERS ABOUT WAT...
 UTILIZING AMI TO IDENTIFY LEAKS, IRRIGATION, AND EDUCATE CUSTOMERS ABOUT WAT... UTILIZING AMI TO IDENTIFY LEAKS, IRRIGATION, AND EDUCATE CUSTOMERS ABOUT WAT...
UTILIZING AMI TO IDENTIFY LEAKS, IRRIGATION, AND EDUCATE CUSTOMERS ABOUT WAT...
iQHub
 

More from iQHub (20)

ENABLING EVTOL WITH BREAKTHROUGH BATTERIES
ENABLING EVTOL WITH BREAKTHROUGH BATTERIESENABLING EVTOL WITH BREAKTHROUGH BATTERIES
ENABLING EVTOL WITH BREAKTHROUGH BATTERIES
 
CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS: THE TRANSITION FROM CREWED TO UNCREWED UAM
CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS: THE TRANSITION FROM CREWED TO UNCREWED UAMCONCEPT OF OPERATIONS: THE TRANSITION FROM CREWED TO UNCREWED UAM
CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS: THE TRANSITION FROM CREWED TO UNCREWED UAM
 
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS FOR HIGH-POWER-DENSITY E-MOTORS FOR AEROSPACE PROPULSION
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS FOR HIGH-POWER-DENSITY E-MOTORS FOR AEROSPACE PROPULSIONINNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS FOR HIGH-POWER-DENSITY E-MOTORS FOR AEROSPACE PROPULSION
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS FOR HIGH-POWER-DENSITY E-MOTORS FOR AEROSPACE PROPULSION
 
AN ELECTRIC FUTURE - READYING AIRPORTS FOR ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT
AN ELECTRIC FUTURE - READYING AIRPORTS FOR ELECTRIC AIRCRAFTAN ELECTRIC FUTURE - READYING AIRPORTS FOR ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT
AN ELECTRIC FUTURE - READYING AIRPORTS FOR ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT
 
ELECTRIFICATION OF AVIATION: HYPE OR GAME-CHANGER?
ELECTRIFICATION OF AVIATION: HYPE OR GAME-CHANGER?ELECTRIFICATION OF AVIATION: HYPE OR GAME-CHANGER?
ELECTRIFICATION OF AVIATION: HYPE OR GAME-CHANGER?
 
HYBRIDIZATION IS THE MISSING LINK BETWEEN ELECTRIFICATION AND SUSTAINABLE FUELS
HYBRIDIZATION IS THE MISSING LINK BETWEEN ELECTRIFICATION AND SUSTAINABLE FUELSHYBRIDIZATION IS THE MISSING LINK BETWEEN ELECTRIFICATION AND SUSTAINABLE FUELS
HYBRIDIZATION IS THE MISSING LINK BETWEEN ELECTRIFICATION AND SUSTAINABLE FUELS
 
LAUNCHING UAM SERVICES IN A LARGE CITY: THE ROME EXPERIENCE
LAUNCHING UAM SERVICES IN A LARGE CITY: THE ROME EXPERIENCELAUNCHING UAM SERVICES IN A LARGE CITY: THE ROME EXPERIENCE
LAUNCHING UAM SERVICES IN A LARGE CITY: THE ROME EXPERIENCE
 
ADVANCED BIO-CIRCULAR MATERIALS: HIGH-PERFORMANCE AND DURABLE PRODUCTS
ADVANCED BIO-CIRCULAR MATERIALS: HIGH-PERFORMANCE AND DURABLE PRODUCTSADVANCED BIO-CIRCULAR MATERIALS: HIGH-PERFORMANCE AND DURABLE PRODUCTS
ADVANCED BIO-CIRCULAR MATERIALS: HIGH-PERFORMANCE AND DURABLE PRODUCTS
 
HOW TO CREATE A NET ZERO PLASTIC SOCIETY FROM THE CONVERTORS POINT OF VIEW?
HOW TO CREATE A NET ZERO PLASTIC SOCIETY FROM THE CONVERTORS POINT OF VIEW?HOW TO CREATE A NET ZERO PLASTIC SOCIETY FROM THE CONVERTORS POINT OF VIEW?
HOW TO CREATE A NET ZERO PLASTIC SOCIETY FROM THE CONVERTORS POINT OF VIEW?
 
BIO-BASED ADDITIVES TO IMPROVE THE PERFORMANCE & PROCESSING OF BIOPOLYMERS
BIO-BASED ADDITIVES TO IMPROVE THE PERFORMANCE & PROCESSING OF BIOPOLYMERSBIO-BASED ADDITIVES TO IMPROVE THE PERFORMANCE & PROCESSING OF BIOPOLYMERS
BIO-BASED ADDITIVES TO IMPROVE THE PERFORMANCE & PROCESSING OF BIOPOLYMERS
 
CLOSING THE LOOP ON MATERIALS COLLECTED AND SORTING: CURBSIDE COLLECTION
CLOSING THE LOOP ON MATERIALS COLLECTED AND SORTING: CURBSIDE COLLECTIONCLOSING THE LOOP ON MATERIALS COLLECTED AND SORTING: CURBSIDE COLLECTION
CLOSING THE LOOP ON MATERIALS COLLECTED AND SORTING: CURBSIDE COLLECTION
 
ARE "NATURAL" POLYMERS PLANT-DERIVED POLYMERS? - CONSUMERS PERSPECTIVES
ARE "NATURAL" POLYMERS PLANT-DERIVED POLYMERS? - CONSUMERS PERSPECTIVESARE "NATURAL" POLYMERS PLANT-DERIVED POLYMERS? - CONSUMERS PERSPECTIVES
ARE "NATURAL" POLYMERS PLANT-DERIVED POLYMERS? - CONSUMERS PERSPECTIVES
 
BIO-BASED ENGINEERING PLASTICS WITH SUSTAINABILITY, HIGH FUNCTIONALITY, AND ...
 BIO-BASED ENGINEERING PLASTICS WITH SUSTAINABILITY, HIGH FUNCTIONALITY, AND ... BIO-BASED ENGINEERING PLASTICS WITH SUSTAINABILITY, HIGH FUNCTIONALITY, AND ...
BIO-BASED ENGINEERING PLASTICS WITH SUSTAINABILITY, HIGH FUNCTIONALITY, AND ...
 
STAGES OF SUSTAINABILITY: TRANSITION FROM BROAD TERMINOLOGY TO MARKET UNDERS...
 STAGES OF SUSTAINABILITY: TRANSITION FROM BROAD TERMINOLOGY TO MARKET UNDERS... STAGES OF SUSTAINABILITY: TRANSITION FROM BROAD TERMINOLOGY TO MARKET UNDERS...
STAGES OF SUSTAINABILITY: TRANSITION FROM BROAD TERMINOLOGY TO MARKET UNDERS...
 
MAKING PLASTICS FULLY SUSTAINABLE, THE DECARBONIZED PLASTICS-TO-HYDROGEN PATHWAY
MAKING PLASTICS FULLY SUSTAINABLE, THE DECARBONIZED PLASTICS-TO-HYDROGEN PATHWAYMAKING PLASTICS FULLY SUSTAINABLE, THE DECARBONIZED PLASTICS-TO-HYDROGEN PATHWAY
MAKING PLASTICS FULLY SUSTAINABLE, THE DECARBONIZED PLASTICS-TO-HYDROGEN PATHWAY
 
ECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMY
ECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMYECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMY
ECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMY
 
SUPPORTING SUSTAINABLE PLASTICS THROUGH ADDITIVES
SUPPORTING SUSTAINABLE PLASTICS THROUGH ADDITIVESSUPPORTING SUSTAINABLE PLASTICS THROUGH ADDITIVES
SUPPORTING SUSTAINABLE PLASTICS THROUGH ADDITIVES
 
AUTOMATED VISCOMETERS FOR MEASURING THE DIVIDING LINES AMONG RECYCLED PLASTICS
AUTOMATED VISCOMETERS FOR MEASURING THE DIVIDING LINES AMONG RECYCLED PLASTICSAUTOMATED VISCOMETERS FOR MEASURING THE DIVIDING LINES AMONG RECYCLED PLASTICS
AUTOMATED VISCOMETERS FOR MEASURING THE DIVIDING LINES AMONG RECYCLED PLASTICS
 
GLOBAL EXTENDED PRODUCERS' RESPONSIBILITY DEVELOPMENTS AND WHAT THEY MEAN
GLOBAL EXTENDED PRODUCERS' RESPONSIBILITY DEVELOPMENTS AND WHAT THEY MEANGLOBAL EXTENDED PRODUCERS' RESPONSIBILITY DEVELOPMENTS AND WHAT THEY MEAN
GLOBAL EXTENDED PRODUCERS' RESPONSIBILITY DEVELOPMENTS AND WHAT THEY MEAN
 
UTILIZING AMI TO IDENTIFY LEAKS, IRRIGATION, AND EDUCATE CUSTOMERS ABOUT WAT...
 UTILIZING AMI TO IDENTIFY LEAKS, IRRIGATION, AND EDUCATE CUSTOMERS ABOUT WAT... UTILIZING AMI TO IDENTIFY LEAKS, IRRIGATION, AND EDUCATE CUSTOMERS ABOUT WAT...
UTILIZING AMI TO IDENTIFY LEAKS, IRRIGATION, AND EDUCATE CUSTOMERS ABOUT WAT...
 

Recently uploaded

obat aborsi bandung wa 081336238223 jual obat aborsi cytotec asli di bandung9...
obat aborsi bandung wa 081336238223 jual obat aborsi cytotec asli di bandung9...obat aborsi bandung wa 081336238223 jual obat aborsi cytotec asli di bandung9...
obat aborsi bandung wa 081336238223 jual obat aborsi cytotec asli di bandung9...
yulianti213969
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Chennai Call Gril 80022//12248 Only For Sex And High Profile Best Gril Sex Av...
Chennai Call Gril 80022//12248 Only For Sex And High Profile Best Gril Sex Av...Chennai Call Gril 80022//12248 Only For Sex And High Profile Best Gril Sex Av...
Chennai Call Gril 80022//12248 Only For Sex And High Profile Best Gril Sex Av...
 
Berhampur 70918*19311 CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Berhampur 70918*19311 CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDINGBerhampur 70918*19311 CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Berhampur 70918*19311 CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
 
Only Cash On Delivery Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Escorts...
Only Cash On Delivery Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Escorts...Only Cash On Delivery Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Escorts...
Only Cash On Delivery Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Escorts...
 
Berhampur 70918*19311 CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Berhampur 70918*19311 CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDINGBerhampur 70918*19311 CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Berhampur 70918*19311 CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
 
obat aborsi bandung wa 081336238223 jual obat aborsi cytotec asli di bandung9...
obat aborsi bandung wa 081336238223 jual obat aborsi cytotec asli di bandung9...obat aborsi bandung wa 081336238223 jual obat aborsi cytotec asli di bandung9...
obat aborsi bandung wa 081336238223 jual obat aborsi cytotec asli di bandung9...
 
Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
 
Call 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All Time
Call 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All TimeCall 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All Time
Call 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All Time
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail Accounts
 
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration PresentationUneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
 
Phases of Negotiation .pptx
 Phases of Negotiation .pptx Phases of Negotiation .pptx
Phases of Negotiation .pptx
 
Berhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Berhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableBerhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Berhampur Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDINGParadip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
 
QSM Chap 10 Service Culture in Tourism and Hospitality Industry.pptx
QSM Chap 10 Service Culture in Tourism and Hospitality Industry.pptxQSM Chap 10 Service Culture in Tourism and Hospitality Industry.pptx
QSM Chap 10 Service Culture in Tourism and Hospitality Industry.pptx
 
WheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond Insights
WheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond InsightsWheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond Insights
WheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond Insights
 
KOTA 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in Escort service book now
KOTA 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in  Escort service book nowKOTA 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in  Escort service book now
KOTA 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in Escort service book now
 
Arti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdf
Arti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdfArti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdf
Arti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdf
 
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAIGetting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
 
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptxPutting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
 
KALYANI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in Escort service book now
KALYANI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in  Escort service book nowKALYANI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in  Escort service book now
KALYANI 💋 Call Girl 9827461493 Call Girls in Escort service book now
 
Cuttack Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Cuttack Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCuttack Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Cuttack Call Girl Just Call 8084732287 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 

AN INVESTOR VIEW OF POST-COMBUSTION CO₂ CAPTURE

  • 1. An Investor View of Post‐Combustion CO2 Capture Carbon Capture Summit Long Beach, California October 19th, 2022
  • 2. Table of contents 2 3 CCS Infrastructure Investing Objectives and Perspectives Wolf Carbon Solutions: Canada and US 1 CCS Post‐Combustion Capture Opportunity 2 Appendices (Pore Space, Pipeline Specifications) 4
  • 3. Wolf Carbon Solutions Canada – An Operating CCUS Hub Wolf developed and operates the only multi‐client anthropogenic CCUS system in North America 3 Wolf Assets: CO2 Capture / Compression • Two sources totalling ~4,400 Mt/day – NWR (refinery) and Nutrien (fertilizer plant) (2 additional Fortune 500 sources pending) • Wolf built/owns/operates 35,000 hp of CO2 compression and water removal / disposal Wolf Assets: CO2 Transport • Currently delivers CO2 to EOR fields • Wolf built / owns / operates the 150 mile, 10 Mtpa capacity CO2 pipeline • 27 months of operation with >3.0 million tonnes CO2 captured to date Wolf Assets: CO2 Sequestration / Pore Space • Extensive area of well‐known deep saline aquifer pore space adjacent to ACTL, secured in March 2022 • Initial test drilling 1Q 2023, service on‐line in ~2024 1 Wolf CO2 Pore Space CO2 Transport (EOR pore space) CO2 Capture & Compression Pending Sources: 2000‐6000 Mt/day
  • 4. 4 Wolf Carbon Solutions US – Mount Simon Hub CCS Project Project Attributes 1. Capital Efficiency: Maximizing tonne CO2/capex 2. Customer‐sponsored, proven, and operating sequestration already in place (ADM Decatur) 3. Full value chain offering (Capture, transport, sequestration) 4. Minimized pipeline stakeholder impact. Only 2 states, modest mileage, avoid eminent domain, highest tons CO2 moved per mile Wolf project is best in class on volume / capital efficiency attributes vs. competing Midwest projects Archer Daniels Midland CO2 Sources Other CO2 Emitters Mount Simon Sequestration Wolf CO2 Pipeline region
  • 5. 5 Combustion Is the Largest Source of Stationary CO2 for CCS Infrastructure 100% Combustion. Electric power is 2/3 of CO2 emissions from stationary sources. Mostly Combustion. Fossil fuels burned in industrial furnaces / boilers plus some other misc. process CO2 Higher‐Purity Process CO2. Usually originates from chemical processing / reforming of hydrocarbons Mostly Biogenic. CO2 originates from ‘new’ biomass, not liberated from ancient biomass (fossil fuel) Most recent and pending CCS infrastructure investment is focused on non‐combustion CO2: High‐purity, low‐capture‐cost, process sources Niche opportunities where there are select higher‐purity CO2 streams, often from hydrocarbon reforming (e.g. hydrogen production from natural gas) Source: Great Plains Institute Regional White Paper 2020 MM Mtpa 2
  • 6. 6 Post‐Combustion: CO2 Capture Cost is Still the Key Hurdle for Widespread CCS Transport and storage costs benefit from natural economy of scale per multi‐user volumes. (Capture generally does not) Capture cost per tonne is inversely proportional to source CO2 concentration. Capture cost ‘floor’ is the compression/ liquefaction cost for low‐pressure CO2 (almost all sources) at $20‐$30 / tonne Post‐combustion CO2 sources are all generally >$100/tonne CCS cost, primarily in capture. Still doesn’t generally work at the new $85 45Q value. CCS Unit Cost Source CO 2 Content Post‐combustion dilute CO2 Sources Process & Higher‐Purity CO2 Sources
  • 7. 7 CCS Infrastructure ‐ Investing Perspectives What Attributes Are Infrastructure Investors Looking For? • Intrinsic value – an essential service to the infra users, usage not ‘cyclical’, periodic, or boom‐bust • Structured Return Drivers ‐ underlying service contracts are the economic foundation, not correlated to the macro economy • Continuous and Stable Income ‐ regular cash flow with low volatility, and not requiring cash reinvesting for growth • Known and manageable risks – higher levels of manageable risks will require a higher cost of capital, major loss risks must be insurable. What are the Inherent Challenges with CCS (and Other) Infrastructure Assets • Single source of income/return. A failure at any link of the CCS chain will undermine the revenue • Technical Chain: Complex and intensive processing from capture through to sequestration • Business Partner Chain: Emitter companies, special technology suppliers, governments • Large and illiquid Assets: Exit, repurposing, or redeployment are generally impossible if there is a significant adverse structural event. (e.g. Tech: Kemper Mi. CCS Partner: Nord Stream 2 Pipeline) 3
  • 8. 8 Miles’ Law* Applies to CCS Risks: “WhereYou Stand Dependson WhereYou Sit” CO2 Emitters already own the downside risks of • Emissions: Producing assets and/or products will be competitively disadvantaged by a high CO2 footprint via carbon taxes/regs or market preference for lower carbon‐index competitor product. (The “do nothing” case for emitters has some risk, depending on product and jurisdiction) • Core Business: (non‐emission related items) input costs, market demand, and the general competitive environment of their product CCS infrastructure investors are putting up new money to enter a business in hopes of making a return. • Large quantum (hundreds of millions $) complex assets that must reliably operate for years to get return OF capital and return ON capital • CCS infrastructure generally does not support high‐margin/quick payback, and unforseen income windfalls are rare. (…..but on the other hand, the “do nothing case” is entirely risk‐free) *Rufus Edward Miles: Chief of the labor and welfare branch of the Bureau of the Budget 1948‐1949 Emitter engagement in the CCS business model – different ends of the spectrum Low: send flue gas over the plant fence to capture a small free ‘incremental uplift’ (e.g. share of 45Q credits) High: Mission‐critical core business dependence on cost and reliability of CCS (e.g. regulatory requirement)
  • 9. 9 What are some risks borne by the long‐term CCS infrastructure stakeholders? 1. Regulatory timing: Pipeline and sequestration permits have risk of delay or even possible suspension. Potential for significant loss of front‐end capital (10%‐20% of total project cost, e.g. energy pipelines) 2. Greenfield Construction: Major project execution capital cost risk (overruns) 3. Source CO2 volumes: • Market and life‐cycle of underlying emitter assets (e.g. oil refinery, chemical plant, etc.) • CO2 capture facilities recovery rates, on‐line time, (new capture technology reliability risk) 4. Third Party CO2 volumes: Additional accretive third‐party volumes are added to the system 5. Long Term Energy / Power costs: Electrical power cost for CO2 liquefaction and other energy for capture processes are key. (energy for pipeline transport and CO2 injection is minimal) 6. CCS O&M costs: e.g. CO2 solvent absorption media performance and life‐cycle , rotating/complex equipment operational efficiency, overhaul frequency and cost, etc. 7. Geological Risk: Sequestration CO2 migrates, or formation pressure increases, faster than expected (more capital for pore‐space and wells required) 8. CO2 Revenue and Market Shifts: 45Q program is discontinued some years down the road, value of carbon offsets changes These outcomes have the potential to provide material “upside” (most other risks above do not have any upside materiality).
  • 10. 10 Decarbonization: Pathways for Electrical Power Generation and Industrials Continue Using Fossil Fuels and Decarbonize with CCS 1. Take the carbon out of the fuel before mixing with air and sending to the burner tip. CO2 is easier to extract from a Hydrogen reformer process than from flue gas. 2. Pick a Winner In Dilute CO2 Capture Technology. Amine absorption, Inorganic Chemical Sorbents, Temperature/Pressure/Electro Swing Adsorption, Cryogenic Separation 3. Combine pure oxygen (instead of air) with a fossil fuel for combustion to produce “pure CO2 and water” flue gas. In all cases above: Operate the combustion‐capture (or hydrogen reformer) at elevated pressure to save some portion of the $20‐$30 CO2 liquefaction energy, O&M, and capital expense Competing Alternative Pathways: Eliminate the Use of Fossil Fuels and Forget CCS • Electricity Generation. “Renewable power plus storage” is approaching competitive parity with gas • Industrial Heat: Electrify with green power, use a fuel with no carbon (green hydrogen), find a breakthrough new technology for specific hard‐to‐abate industries. (cement, steel, etc.)
  • 11. 0.49 Cook 11 Commercial Foundation Issues Comments, examples One‐and‐done: single supply to single disposition point All risks are amplified by lack of supply diversity for the infra investment Stroke‐of‐pen legislation change risk Infra developer typically does not take 100% of future 45Q risk‐reward Capital Market Retreat and Retrenchment Some banks and equity investors not funding coal‐based or EOR‐based CCS Misalignment / lack of alignment with the emitter Emitter is apathetic to decarbonization – CCS is purely ancillary revenue Emitter base business market and regulatory risks Major CCS infra needs a creditworthy emitter to backstop the investment CO2 Capture Related Investment Barriers Sustainability paradox – compounding energy consumption E.g. 1000 MTpd incremental energy use to capture 2000 MTpd CO2 (Wolf estimate) Includes the unavoidable compression‐liquefaction energy(!) New chemical or new use of old chemical Unproven in long term – performance, degradation rate, cost (e.g. new solvent) No operating history for new hardware or new process “New” is a matter of degree, not typically black and white. Any new patented process with serial number 001 is difficult. (e.g. hydrogen‐fueled turbines) Unknown environmental wildcard E.g. trace amounts of sorbent / solvent in scrubbed flue gas and atmosphere Adverse affect on emitter assets or process Flue gas CO2 capture system backpressure voids a gas turbine warranty Trace CO2 impurities impact on pipeline metallurgy E.g. SOx NOx combustion products affect corrosion and CO2 phase properties Critical long‐term component or supply from a start‐up supplier Proprietary custom sorbent media, pellets, beds, etc. Examples of Investability / Financeability Barriers for Large CCS Infrastructure