SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Download to read offline
“Don’t Waste a Perfectly Good Crisis”




                         13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum

           Event Summary by Squire, Sanders & Dempsey L.L.P.

           Spring 2009
INTRODUCTION




      The global downturn has caught up with Central and Eastern Europe and then some. The
      transactional scene in CEE is pin-drop quiet, LPs are spooked and several CEE stalwarts are
      wrestling with political and economic turmoil.

      In short, it is an opportunity in the making for private equity. As put by Daniel Lynch of 3TS Capital
      Partners, “don’t waste a perfectly good crisis.”

      C5 and global law firm Squire, Sanders & Dempsey L.L.P. are pleased to bring you an overview of
      perspectives and insights from the 13th Annual C5 CEE Private Equity Forum held in Vienna on 23-24
      March 2009. We would like to thank all presenters for their thoughtful comments on the current state
      of private equity in Central and Eastern Europe, and the Forum delegates for demonstrating
      continuing interest in private equity’s future.




                                                      Squire Sanders’ CEE Private Equity Team

                                                      Spring 2009




13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary                                                             2
C5 CEE PRIVATE EQUITY FORUM: EXPLORING OPPORTUNITIES IN UNCERTAIN TIMES

      Private equity in Central and Eastern Europe is bearing its share of fallout from the global downturn.
      Deal flow isn't even at a trickle, governments and economies are in turmoil and businesses are
      collapsing, not to mention the overarching anxiety caused by the ongoing financial crisis. But amid the
      gloom spark some new prospects for private equity.

          •    There has never been a one-size-fits-all solution for private equity in CEE. The financial crisis
               has highlighted regional winners and losers, although debate continues on final designations.
               Some conference presenters named the Czech Republic, Poland, the Slovak Republic and
               Slovenia as winners, while the Baltic states, Bulgaria, Hungary, Romania, Russia and Ukraine
               were generally named losers. Hobbled by higher debt and unstable currencies, the losers are
               expected to be slower to recover. In any case, private equity must have players on the ground
               who understand each country’s economic, social and political fundamentals before selecting
               investment targets.

          •    Crisis notwithstanding, private equity firms are believed to be sitting on US$3 billion to US$4
               billion of dry powder, and supply and demand for regional capital is bound to converge. While
               many observers urged private equity to go back to basics and get this capital into play, others
               noted that the industry needs to obtain clarity from banks about the availability of leverage or
               come up with financing alternatives.

          •    Fund managers need to evaluate the relative strength of existing portfolio companies with a
               view to managing towards increased efficiency and, as concerns non-performing or troubled
               assets, developing a realistic plan to address these problems.

          •    Highly leveraged mega-buyouts may be a dead model, so private equity needs to be creative
               and flexible. At the same time, private equity has to play it safe and smart, increasing
               diligence efforts, forcing valuations to match market realities and forecasting realistic exit
               opportunities.

          •    Private equity should be on the lookout for distressed assets, mezzanine finance
               opportunities, small deals in the €10-25 million range and family-owned companies with
               succession issues. The industry should also beware of potential difficulties caused by the call
               for increased governmental regulation.




13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary                                                                 3
WHAT THE EXPERTS SAID

      Winners and Losers

      While the “easy money” years (2004-2008) are gone, Nikolaus Bethlen of Mid Europa Partners
      observed that talk of gloom and doom in CEE doesn’t provide a complete picture. A more accurate
      view of CEE would focus on regional winners and losers instead of a unified region of equals. As a
      result, private equity needs to develop distinct strategies for each CEE country.

      Although debate continues on final designations, the winners were identified as Poland, the Slovak
      Republic, Slovenia and the Czech Republic. Jaroslav Hascak of Penta Investments is “very
      optimistic” about investing in CEE and believes that, on a macro level, the so-called winner countries
      will provide good opportunities for private equity.

      The so-called losers – those countries with unstable currencies and high rates of debt to GDP – were
      generally identified as Russia, Ukraine, the Baltic states, Hungary, Romania and Bulgaria. These
      countries are predicted to have a difficult time luring new investors. Mr. Bethlen noted that the losers
      have taken a double capital flight hit: as investors became more wary, banks also expatriated money
      from the region. Russia and Ukraine are particularly hard hit, he said.

      Michael Tojner of Global Equity Partners Beteiligungs-Management AG echoed that perspective,
      noting several short-term challenges that the region faces. He said he is very wary of investments in
      Eastern Europe, particularly Russia, where financing is hard to come by. Mid Europa’s Bethlen noted
      that while, for example, Hungary- or Ukraine-based deals will be hampered by financing difficulties,
      there are significant opportunities for managers who have been in and understand the region. He also
      stated there is at least US$3 billion to US$4 billion in dry powder awaiting investment opportunities in
      CEE that will surface as valuation levels align with expectations. As a result, private equity activity
      should pick up by late 2009.

      From the investors’ perspective, Roy Baumann of Partners Group said that his firm is earmarking
      5 to 10 percent of its European program to CEE investments, but that he is much more cautious about
      Russia and Ukraine. Thorsten Paul of Investkredit Bank AG predicts that Russia will be the last
      CEE country to find new investors, as he believes the bubble in Russia is bigger than in any of the
      other CEE countries. He added that he does not see a lot of fundraising activity in the region and
      observed that the funds his firm has invested in are sitting on cash. Paul does not expect a big
      shakeout in the market, although he does predict that the number of LPs investing in CEE will
      decrease over the next couple of years. Henry J. Owainati and Hannes Ambacher  of Bank
      Gutmann Group explained the importance of choosing the right private equity fund manager, due
      primarily to the great disparity in performance between the top-tier fund managers and bottom-tier
      fund managers. Owainati and Ambacher suggested that the most important factor an investor should
      consider is the management team.




13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary                                                               4
Global Equity Partners’ Tojner also sees opportunities in CEE, specifically real estate funds and
      restructuring funds targeting real estate assets. Tojner also said the niche market of high-tech
      companies – his organization’s target – presents excellent opportunities as valuations come down.
      Likewise, Vinarom Vilaihongs of SGAM Alternative Investments S.A., comparing CEE to Western
      Europe, sees opportunities arising from the fact that CEE is a very fragmented market with less
      competition. Jan Dewijngaert of Gimv, in contrast to many other speakers, found positives in the
      Russian market. While the macroeconomic indicators are certainly not good, because of low
      governmental debt, high foreign currency reserves and relatively modest unemployment, he believes
      Russia’s current troubles are different from the 1998 Russian crisis. Dewijngaert also predicts that the
      power of the oligarchs will decline as they are forced to restructure, consolidate or sell assets. He
      continues to see many interesting investment opportunities, particularly in consumer-oriented
      businesses.




      Private Equity Landscape: Where Are We Now?

      Country-by-country winners and losers notwithstanding, the speakers provided a frank assessment of
      the state of private equity in CEE in 2008 and early 2009, including analyzing the roots of its current
      troubles.

      Armando D’Amico of Acanthus Advisors attributed CEE’s problems to “too much investment, too
      quickly.” In that vein, Joanna James of Advent International cautioned that private equity in CEE
      had become accustomed to “instant gratification.” She stated that the industry as a whole must
      relearn that “debt is a burden to be paid off” and not an asset to be bought and sold. EIF’s Ulrich
      Grabenwarter stated that a review of deal dynamics over the past three years provided “warning
      signs” of the current crisis. He noted that the impact of the crisis will be larger in CEE than in Western
      markets because there will be a “flight to the more conservative risk/return profiles” typically found in
      more developed markets.

      David Bernard of Thomson Reuters provided grim statistics for 2008 and 2009: M&A activity in
      2008 was down 35 percent in Europe and 45 percent in CEE. Worse yet, Bernard noted that M&A
      activity is down 98 percent in 2009, demonstrating how few deals have been reported during the first
      quarter of this year. He indicated that no sector is safe, as all industries have been affected while PE-
      backed buy-side transactions decreased 93 percent over the past six months. There have been no
      syndicated loans this year and fundraising is also very quiet. At the same time, the exit market is
      suffering, with equity issuances down 29 percent in CEE and 17 percent globally. According to Mr.
      Bernard, the capital markets are “closed, for all intents and purposes.”

      Mid Europa’s Bethlen observed that now is the time to focus on portfolio companies and to
      contemplate strategies for investing amid a lack of acquisition financing. “We are still in a time lag,”
      remarked Bethlen, predicting that it may take a few more months for people to realize that the new
      valuations are here to stay. He advised being creative and opportunistic to achieve results. Brian
      Gimotty of Paul Capital Partners agreed that there is “a lot of disconnect in the market.” He believes
      that secondary valuations have started to “come down to earth” and that private equity firms are
      taking a more sober view of risk/reward scenarios.


13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary                                                                 5
A number of speakers expressed concern that investment capital has been flowing out of CEE and is
      not being replaced by new investors. At the same time, Robert Manz of Enterprise Investors
      expressed “strong concern” that investments in CEE have fallen out of favor, with investors not
      currently in CEE fearful of committing to the region. Though Alessandra Pasian of the European
      Bank for Reconstruction and Development confirmed that EBRD is committed to continue funding
      in CEE and is looking at new funds coming to market, Peeter Piho of Hansa Investment Funds,
      observed a lack of domestic institutional LPs, which is “an issue in CEE and an issue for the industry.”

      Compounding the problem of capital flight is the lack of clarity from banks about their ability and
      willingness to lend. Thomas Wilfling of AXA Private Equity Eastern Europe GmbH believes that a
      number of banks claiming to be open for business are, in fact, “not really open” or have not seriously
      tested their credit committees for some time, lacking internal guidance in terms of what can be
      achieved. He predicts that the lending situation may become somewhat clearer in a few months when
      banks know and have digested 2008 data. Supriya Saxena of UniCredit Markets & Investment
      Banking acknowledged that many banks do not have a defined lending strategy yet for this year,
      thereby contributing to the lack of visibility around liquidity. That said, she emphasized that banks are
      more critically assessing risk and there is generally more focus on due diligence. Given overall
      constraints on capital, and volatility in funding costs, banks are requiring higher up-front fees and
      margins to put money to work. Many banks have retreated to their home markets, and relationship
      and ancillary business has become increasingly important in the overall investment decision. Saxena
      said that in addition to liquidity provided by local lenders in each regional market, there is a very
      limited number of global banks still actively involved in LBOs in CEE. Some of the main players
      include UniCredit, ING and RZB. The model where arranging banks underwrite and syndicate is no
      longer viable, she observed. In 2009, most transactions are likely to be in the form of club deals, with
      three or four banks working together to provide financing without any one lender assuming a
      significant amount of underwriting risk.

      Bad news notwithstanding, conference presenters also expressed optimism about the prospects of
      private equity in CEE.

      Bethlen of Mid Europa claimed that the “portrait of doom and gloom” painted in the media about CEE
      is exaggerated. Comparing the current environment to Asia’s crisis in 1996, he observed that CEE is
      in a much better state of health because debt levels of CEE companies are fairly moderate. As a
      result, he forecasts the crisis “will be much better absorbed” in CEE than it was in Asia. Penta
      Investments’ Hascak reminded the audience that while you must be selective, there are “excellent
      opportunities” to find interesting companies at a good price. EIF’s Grabenwarter stated that the crisis
      can also be seen as a “tremendous opportunity for private equity” as it can demonstrate its real role in
      company building and strategic development of businesses. He added that those fund managers that
      prove they are capable of generating returns not only in times of “macroeconomic tailwind” will prevail.

      Another prominent theme was the role that mezzanine finance will play in private equity deals in 2009
      and beyond. Chris Buckle of Mezzanine Management GmbH observed that deal flow is beginning
      to improve compared to the past six to nine months. New deals include LBOs of distressed sellers.
      Buckle noted that distressed LBOs offer a significant role for mezzanine finance firms. Another
      speaker noted that returns are less squeezed than before the crisis and that deals are now being
      more conservatively leveraged.

13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary                                                                6
From the perspective of local mezzanine providers, Mezzanine Management’s Buckle also noted that
      the downturn has reduced competition for deals. In particular, many Western European funds are now
      staying in their home markets and no longer straying into CEE. A less competitive landscape is good
      news for local players. However, with LPs also shunning the region, specialist mezzanine funds in
      CEE now face the challenge of raising enough capital to finance the significant number of available
      opportunities anticipated. This view was echoed by Dr. Matthias Unser of Sal. Oppenheim Private
      Equity Partners.

      Advent’s James drew parallels between the tortoise-and-hare fable and private equity’s leverage-
      fueled growth. She said the industry must “redefine success” in order to manage expectations created
      by the unsustainable returns achieved during the boom years. Since private equity is flexible and
      creative, James said she has faith the industry will adapt to a new landscape that demands private
      equity to be cautious, methodical and to truly take a long-term view. In addition to her advice to “get
      back to basics,” James predicted that, in the near term, funds would target smaller companies holding
      not more debt than they can pay off, and that expansion capital investments, as compared to
      leveraged buyouts, will become increasingly common. EIF’s Grabenwarter agreed that private equity
      will see new deal dynamics going forward, with leverage as a value driver off the agenda and private
      equity going “back to its roots, which is value creation through strategic positioning and organic
      growth.”

      Manz of Enterprise Investors also expressed optimism about the future of private equity in CEE.
      “Private equity thrives on distortion,” he said, predicting that private equity’s current crunch will be
      relieved by decreases in both valuations and competition and bolstered by improved access to
      talented management. Manz expects valuations to come down to more acceptable levels within six to
      12 months.

      Finally, participants highlighted current regulatory trends and those on the horizon.

      Maurits Tausk of Baker & McKenzie advised that the new EU proposal to regulate private equity
      firms should be monitored closely. Advent’s James echoed this concern, noting that there is virtually
      no chance that the private equity industry will be allowed to self-regulate. Observing that there are no
      CEE representatives on the regulation task force, she expressed concern about the current talk of
      delegating oversight responsibility to local authorities or venture capital associations.

      Marc van Campen of Baker & McKenzie noted the recent attacks by the United States on tax haven
      jurisdictions and predicted that we are likely to see changes that affect private equity structuring, not
      all of which may be rational.




      Trends to Watch

      In the short term, Mezzanine Management’s Buckle sees many private equity funds focusing on
      portfolio companies while considering smaller acquisition opportunities in the US$10 million to US$25
      million range. That view was echoed by Lynch of 3TS, who noted that now is the right time to make
      any changes that need to be made to portfolio companies. Lynch also advised looking at
      consolidation and “bolt on” opportunities. Buckle does not envision many larger LBOs. UniCredit’s

13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary                                                                7
Saxena indicated that her bank remains committed to investing in LBOs in the region. The appetite for
      commitment to any particular transaction depends upon a number of factors, but institutionally the
      bank’s focus is on home markets and key sponsor relationships.

      AXA’s Wilfling predicted that future acquisition financing packages will see significant changes from
      deals structured just a year or two ago. For example, he does not expect to see many deals with
      much more than five times EBITDA debt multiples in the near term. Observing that “cooling off is a
      good thing,” Wilfling said that the current environment will force private equity to find creative ways to
      deal with the lack of debt and emphasized that private equity needs to be highly selective in these
      times. Brian Wardrop of ARX Equity Partners envisions a greater role for mezzanine finance due to
      banks’ changed incentive models.

      Johan Bastin of Darby Private Equity sees local banks still willing to provide senior debt, although
      they are considerably more selective and focused on defensive factors. With respect to the post-crisis
      leverage ratios, Bastin said, “In 2007 six became the new five and now four is becoming the new six.”
      Additionally, covenants have come back in fashion and equity kickers are no longer anathema. Bastin
      stated that he is much more interested in credit quality these days, “even at the cost of lower returns
      than could be realized elsewhere in the market.”

      Other speakers highlighted developments in the region that may result in new investment
      opportunities. According to Penta Investment’s Hascak, many family companies purchased out of
      privatizations are facing succession issues. He observed that private equity houses with local offices
      and knowledge can exploit the opportunities created by these changes.

      Anticipating increased interest from private equity in distressed investments, a panel of experts from
      Squire Sanders emphasized the importance of conducting speedy due diligence of financially
      troubled companies. “Review the metrics of the business and do not get hung up on minutiae as time
      is of the essence”, advised Squire Sanders partner Kevin T. Connor. As bankruptcy financing options
      are extremely limited in CEE, the panel advised that acquiring a target prior to entering into formal
      insolvency proceedings is “critical.” Additionally, acquirers of distressed companies should restrain
      themselves from bidding high early in the process. Squire Sanders partner Tomasz Z. Ujejski
      recommended reserving sufficient resources to outbid any later bidders that directors may seek to
      include in order to satisfy directors’ duties to maximize share price.

      Discussing exits, Manz of Enterprise Investors does not expect conditions to improve substantially
      until 2010.

      “We're living in unprecedented times, which means there are no definitive answers on how private
      equity will fare in the economic landscape being reshaped by the global financial crisis,” concluded
      Squire Sanders’ Kevin Connor, chairman of day one of the Forum. “But we do know that private equity
      thrives when the stakes are high and the odds are long. Our best practice now is to explore all
      opportunities and make the most of them.”




13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary                                                                 8
WHAT THE NUMBERS SAY

      Below is a sampling of the statistics that were shared by the speakers in their presentations. Thank
      you to David Bernard of Thomson Reuters, Nikolaus Bethlen of Mid Europa Partners, Henry J.
      Owainati and Hannes Ambacher of Bank Gutmann Group, Joanna James of Advent International and
      Brian Gimotty of Paul Capital Partners for permitting us to include these in our event summary.




13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary                                                           9
13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary   10
13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary   11
About Squire Sanders
                 Founded in 1890, Squire, Sanders & Dempsey L.L.P. has lawyers in 32 offices and 15 countries around the world.
                 On the ground in seven CEE countries, and backed by the global expertise of our Emerging Markets Private Equity Group, our tightly integrated
                 CEE Private Equity Team works together to seamlessly serve our clients’ transactional needs – whether the deal is undertaken in one of our resident
                 countries or across multiple borders.
                 We advise on all types of private equity investments and exits and have a deep understanding of the issues peculiar to key industry sectors including
                 chemicals, communications, energy, food and beverage, financial services, hospitality and leisure, logistics and infrastructure, media, natural
                 resources, real estate and technology.
                 For more information, please contact our CEE Private Equity Team:


                 Christopher A. Rose
                 Moscow +7.495.258.5250 | London +44.20.7189.8113 | crose@ssd.com

                 Kevin T. Connor
                 Bratislava +421.2.5930.3473 | Budapest +36.1.428.7115 | kconnor@ssd.com

                 Tomasz Z. H. Ujejski
                 Warsaw +48.22.395.5507 | London +44.20.7189.8130 | tujejski@ssd.com

                 Ákos Mester
                 Budapest +36.1.428.7168 | amester@ssd.com

                 Jeffrey A. McGehee
                 Prague +420.221.662.282 | jmcgehee@ssd.com

                 Peter Z. Teluk
                                                                                                            About C5
                 Kyiv +380.44.220.1400 | pteluk@ssd.com
                                                                                                            For over 15 years, conferences produced by C5 have provided
                                                                                                            the business intelligence that corporate decision-makers need to
                                                                                                            respond to modern challenges and opportunities. C5 is staffed by
                                                                                                            industry professionals, lawyers and CIS country specialists. The
                                                                                                            company operates as a think tank by monitoring trends and
                                                                                                            developments in major industry sectors with a view to provide
                                                                                                            cutting edge business information. Based in London, C5 holds
                                                                                                            events both across Europe and Russia and has recently grown to
                                                                                                            produce over 90 events a year, attended by hundreds of
                                                                                                            delegates.




               32 OFFICES                        15 C O U N T R I E S


CINCINNATI • CLEVELAND • COLUMBUS • HOUSTON • LOS ANGELES • MIAMI • NEW YORK • PALO ALTO • PHOENIX • SAN FRANCISCO • TALLAHASSEE • TAMPA • TYSONS CORNER • WASHINGTON DC
WEST PALM BEACH | BOGOTÁ+ • BUENOS AIRES+ • CARACAS • LA PAZ+ • LIMA+ • PANAMÁ+ • RIO DE JANEIRO • SANTIAGO+ • SANTO DOMINGO • SÃO PAULO | BRATISLAVA
BRUSSELS • BUCHAREST+ • BUDAPEST • DUBLIN+ • FRANKFURT • KYIV • LONDON • MOSCOW • PRAGUE • WARSAW | BEIJING • HONG KONG • SHANGHAI • TOKYO | +INDEPENDENT NETWORK FIRM

SQUIRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY L.L.P.                                                                                                                                         WWW.SSD.COM

More Related Content

What's hot

The $50BN Elephant - European Venture Capital
The $50BN Elephant - European Venture CapitalThe $50BN Elephant - European Venture Capital
The $50BN Elephant - European Venture CapitalCachette Capital Management
 
Quarterly reports - WIOF Global Listed Utilities Fund
Quarterly reports - WIOF Global Listed Utilities FundQuarterly reports - WIOF Global Listed Utilities Fund
Quarterly reports - WIOF Global Listed Utilities FundKen Teale
 
Buyouts September 2009_Panel
Buyouts September 2009_PanelBuyouts September 2009_Panel
Buyouts September 2009_Panelandrzejbinkowski
 
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016Tyler Stuart
 
Currency Articles May 2012 - iExpats.com
Currency Articles May 2012 - iExpats.comCurrency Articles May 2012 - iExpats.com
Currency Articles May 2012 - iExpats.comiExpats
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners 1Q12
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners  1Q12Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners  1Q12
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners 1Q12Michael Durante
 
Etude PwC sur les fusions-acquisitions dans le secteur europĂŠen des services ...
Etude PwC sur les fusions-acquisitions dans le secteur europĂŠen des services ...Etude PwC sur les fusions-acquisitions dans le secteur europĂŠen des services ...
Etude PwC sur les fusions-acquisitions dans le secteur europĂŠen des services ...PwC France
 
SAMPLE_BUSINESS_PLAN
SAMPLE_BUSINESS_PLANSAMPLE_BUSINESS_PLAN
SAMPLE_BUSINESS_PLANMatt Marshall
 
Threadneedle investments. inversiĂłn en bonos corporativos de mercados emerge...
Threadneedle investments.  inversiĂłn en bonos corporativos de mercados emerge...Threadneedle investments.  inversiĂłn en bonos corporativos de mercados emerge...
Threadneedle investments. inversiĂłn en bonos corporativos de mercados emerge...Observatorio-Inverco
 
CEE: Gearing up for a busier 2012
CEE: Gearing up for a busier 2012CEE: Gearing up for a busier 2012
CEE: Gearing up for a busier 2012rseewald
 
05.26.2014, PRESENTATION, Use of MSE for State Privatizations, Nick Cousyn
05.26.2014, PRESENTATION, Use of MSE for State Privatizations, Nick Cousyn05.26.2014, PRESENTATION, Use of MSE for State Privatizations, Nick Cousyn
05.26.2014, PRESENTATION, Use of MSE for State Privatizations, Nick CousynThe Business Council of Mongolia
 
The Advisory_Sept2016
The Advisory_Sept2016The Advisory_Sept2016
The Advisory_Sept2016Jim Tyson
 
2012 global powers of retailing deloitte
2012 global powers of retailing deloitte2012 global powers of retailing deloitte
2012 global powers of retailing deloittemymarketingnet
 
Sprung investment management commentary 1st quarter, 2015
Sprung investment management commentary   1st quarter, 2015Sprung investment management commentary   1st quarter, 2015
Sprung investment management commentary 1st quarter, 2015Robert Champion
 
The Advisory_Dec2015
The Advisory_Dec2015The Advisory_Dec2015
The Advisory_Dec2015Jim Tyson
 
Sovereign Wealth Funds & Private Equity
Sovereign Wealth Funds & Private EquitySovereign Wealth Funds & Private Equity
Sovereign Wealth Funds & Private EquityTuck Seng Low
 
THIRD QUARTER 2015 RETROSPECTIVE AND PROSPECTIVE We’ve Seen This Movie Before
THIRD QUARTER 2015   RETROSPECTIVE AND PROSPECTIVE  We’ve Seen This Movie BeforeTHIRD QUARTER 2015   RETROSPECTIVE AND PROSPECTIVE  We’ve Seen This Movie Before
THIRD QUARTER 2015 RETROSPECTIVE AND PROSPECTIVE We’ve Seen This Movie BeforeRobert Champion
 

What's hot (20)

The European article
The European  articleThe European  article
The European article
 
Vc's quit early stage financing
Vc's quit early stage financingVc's quit early stage financing
Vc's quit early stage financing
 
The $50BN Elephant - European Venture Capital
The $50BN Elephant - European Venture CapitalThe $50BN Elephant - European Venture Capital
The $50BN Elephant - European Venture Capital
 
Quarterly reports - WIOF Global Listed Utilities Fund
Quarterly reports - WIOF Global Listed Utilities FundQuarterly reports - WIOF Global Listed Utilities Fund
Quarterly reports - WIOF Global Listed Utilities Fund
 
Buyouts September 2009_Panel
Buyouts September 2009_PanelBuyouts September 2009_Panel
Buyouts September 2009_Panel
 
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016
 
Currency Articles May 2012 - iExpats.com
Currency Articles May 2012 - iExpats.comCurrency Articles May 2012 - iExpats.com
Currency Articles May 2012 - iExpats.com
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners 1Q12
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners  1Q12Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners  1Q12
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners 1Q12
 
Etude PwC sur les fusions-acquisitions dans le secteur europĂŠen des services ...
Etude PwC sur les fusions-acquisitions dans le secteur europĂŠen des services ...Etude PwC sur les fusions-acquisitions dans le secteur europĂŠen des services ...
Etude PwC sur les fusions-acquisitions dans le secteur europĂŠen des services ...
 
SAMPLE_BUSINESS_PLAN
SAMPLE_BUSINESS_PLANSAMPLE_BUSINESS_PLAN
SAMPLE_BUSINESS_PLAN
 
Threadneedle investments. inversiĂłn en bonos corporativos de mercados emerge...
Threadneedle investments.  inversiĂłn en bonos corporativos de mercados emerge...Threadneedle investments.  inversiĂłn en bonos corporativos de mercados emerge...
Threadneedle investments. inversiĂłn en bonos corporativos de mercados emerge...
 
CEE: Gearing up for a busier 2012
CEE: Gearing up for a busier 2012CEE: Gearing up for a busier 2012
CEE: Gearing up for a busier 2012
 
05.26.2014, PRESENTATION, Use of MSE for State Privatizations, Nick Cousyn
05.26.2014, PRESENTATION, Use of MSE for State Privatizations, Nick Cousyn05.26.2014, PRESENTATION, Use of MSE for State Privatizations, Nick Cousyn
05.26.2014, PRESENTATION, Use of MSE for State Privatizations, Nick Cousyn
 
The Advisory_Sept2016
The Advisory_Sept2016The Advisory_Sept2016
The Advisory_Sept2016
 
2012 global powers of retailing deloitte
2012 global powers of retailing deloitte2012 global powers of retailing deloitte
2012 global powers of retailing deloitte
 
Sprung investment management commentary 1st quarter, 2015
Sprung investment management commentary   1st quarter, 2015Sprung investment management commentary   1st quarter, 2015
Sprung investment management commentary 1st quarter, 2015
 
The Advisory_Dec2015
The Advisory_Dec2015The Advisory_Dec2015
The Advisory_Dec2015
 
Financing Globalisation
Financing GlobalisationFinancing Globalisation
Financing Globalisation
 
Sovereign Wealth Funds & Private Equity
Sovereign Wealth Funds & Private EquitySovereign Wealth Funds & Private Equity
Sovereign Wealth Funds & Private Equity
 
THIRD QUARTER 2015 RETROSPECTIVE AND PROSPECTIVE We’ve Seen This Movie Before
THIRD QUARTER 2015   RETROSPECTIVE AND PROSPECTIVE  We’ve Seen This Movie BeforeTHIRD QUARTER 2015   RETROSPECTIVE AND PROSPECTIVE  We’ve Seen This Movie Before
THIRD QUARTER 2015 RETROSPECTIVE AND PROSPECTIVE We’ve Seen This Movie Before
 

Viewers also liked

Koalas Fave Term 2 Week 1
Koalas Fave Term 2 Week 1Koalas Fave Term 2 Week 1
Koalas Fave Term 2 Week 1Gihan Lahoud
 
My Wish for Jacinda
My Wish for JacindaMy Wish for Jacinda
My Wish for Jacindajasonjohnstone
 
Nogelmini 2
Nogelmini 2Nogelmini 2
Nogelmini 2Olijohn
 
Stillwater N Sid Sen Dedication
Stillwater N Sid Sen DedicationStillwater N Sid Sen Dedication
Stillwater N Sid Sen DedicationJim CastroLang
 
Presentatie Iv Industrie
Presentatie Iv IndustriePresentatie Iv Industrie
Presentatie Iv IndustrieTriesscheijn
 
DE OLKDA DokumentĂĄciĂł, leletezĂŠs: Idegen szavak, szindrĂłmĂĄk
DE OLKDA DokumentĂĄciĂł, leletezĂŠs: Idegen szavak, szindrĂłmĂĄkDE OLKDA DokumentĂĄciĂł, leletezĂŠs: Idegen szavak, szindrĂłmĂĄk
DE OLKDA DokumentĂĄciĂł, leletezĂŠs: Idegen szavak, szindrĂłmĂĄkPĂŠter BĂĄgyi M.D.
 
W T S Resume Workshop 03
W T S  Resume  Workshop 03W T S  Resume  Workshop 03
W T S Resume Workshop 03lecipollo
 
Adobe connect set up instructions str
Adobe connect set up instructions strAdobe connect set up instructions str
Adobe connect set up instructions strGihan Lahoud
 
ZeroMQ at Oredev 2013
ZeroMQ at Oredev 2013ZeroMQ at Oredev 2013
ZeroMQ at Oredev 2013Ashic Mahtab
 
TeleradiolĂłgia ĂŠs osztĂĄlyos munkaszervezĂŠs
TeleradiolĂłgia ĂŠs osztĂĄlyos munkaszervezĂŠsTeleradiolĂłgia ĂŠs osztĂĄlyos munkaszervezĂŠs
TeleradiolĂłgia ĂŠs osztĂĄlyos munkaszervezĂŠsPĂŠter BĂĄgyi M.D.
 
Kitchen evolution
Kitchen evolutionKitchen evolution
Kitchen evolutionNatashaRDH
 
Week 2 Copyright
Week 2 CopyrightWeek 2 Copyright
Week 2 CopyrightGihan Lahoud
 
Marjoriepp
MarjorieppMarjoriepp
Marjorieppguestad468
 
The Museum of Tomorrow
The Museum of TomorrowThe Museum of Tomorrow
The Museum of Tomorrowfcmdsc
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Koalas Fave Term 2 Week 1
Koalas Fave Term 2 Week 1Koalas Fave Term 2 Week 1
Koalas Fave Term 2 Week 1
 
Prezentacija Sistema
Prezentacija SistemaPrezentacija Sistema
Prezentacija Sistema
 
My Wish for Jacinda
My Wish for JacindaMy Wish for Jacinda
My Wish for Jacinda
 
Nogelmini 2
Nogelmini 2Nogelmini 2
Nogelmini 2
 
Stillwater N Sid Sen Dedication
Stillwater N Sid Sen DedicationStillwater N Sid Sen Dedication
Stillwater N Sid Sen Dedication
 
Presentatie Iv Industrie
Presentatie Iv IndustriePresentatie Iv Industrie
Presentatie Iv Industrie
 
DE OLKDA DokumentĂĄciĂł, leletezĂŠs: Idegen szavak, szindrĂłmĂĄk
DE OLKDA DokumentĂĄciĂł, leletezĂŠs: Idegen szavak, szindrĂłmĂĄkDE OLKDA DokumentĂĄciĂł, leletezĂŠs: Idegen szavak, szindrĂłmĂĄk
DE OLKDA DokumentĂĄciĂł, leletezĂŠs: Idegen szavak, szindrĂłmĂĄk
 
Swpbs Change Process
Swpbs Change ProcessSwpbs Change Process
Swpbs Change Process
 
Mediaproof def
Mediaproof defMediaproof def
Mediaproof def
 
The Buckboard
The BuckboardThe Buckboard
The Buckboard
 
W T S Resume Workshop 03
W T S  Resume  Workshop 03W T S  Resume  Workshop 03
W T S Resume Workshop 03
 
Adobe connect set up instructions str
Adobe connect set up instructions strAdobe connect set up instructions str
Adobe connect set up instructions str
 
ZeroMQ at Oredev 2013
ZeroMQ at Oredev 2013ZeroMQ at Oredev 2013
ZeroMQ at Oredev 2013
 
TeleradiolĂłgia ĂŠs osztĂĄlyos munkaszervezĂŠs
TeleradiolĂłgia ĂŠs osztĂĄlyos munkaszervezĂŠsTeleradiolĂłgia ĂŠs osztĂĄlyos munkaszervezĂŠs
TeleradiolĂłgia ĂŠs osztĂĄlyos munkaszervezĂŠs
 
Kitchen evolution
Kitchen evolutionKitchen evolution
Kitchen evolution
 
Week 2 Copyright
Week 2 CopyrightWeek 2 Copyright
Week 2 Copyright
 
Vs Profile
Vs ProfileVs Profile
Vs Profile
 
Marjoriepp
MarjorieppMarjoriepp
Marjoriepp
 
Adjectives
AdjectivesAdjectives
Adjectives
 
The Museum of Tomorrow
The Museum of TomorrowThe Museum of Tomorrow
The Museum of Tomorrow
 

Similar to Don\'t Waste A Perfectly Good Crisis

Global Investor May 2004
Global Investor May 2004Global Investor May 2004
Global Investor May 2004dariusznowak
 
Euro zone debt crisis and impacts on
Euro zone debt crisis and impacts onEuro zone debt crisis and impacts on
Euro zone debt crisis and impacts onpnayak242
 
Corporate Image In Ukraine
Corporate Image In UkraineCorporate Image In Ukraine
Corporate Image In Ukrainemmd_ru
 
TheAdvisory_Sept2015_vFINAL
TheAdvisory_Sept2015_vFINALTheAdvisory_Sept2015_vFINAL
TheAdvisory_Sept2015_vFINALMalcolm Fitch
 
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4Open Knowledge
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 288 - Sources for financing domestic capita...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 288 - Sources for financing domestic capita...CASE Network Studies and Analyses 288 - Sources for financing domestic capita...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 288 - Sources for financing domestic capita...CASE Center for Social and Economic Research
 
Buyouts September 2009_Panel_Case
Buyouts September 2009_Panel_CaseBuyouts September 2009_Panel_Case
Buyouts September 2009_Panel_Caseandrzejbinkowski
 
Cee investment report by skanska
Cee investment report by skanskaCee investment report by skanska
Cee investment report by skanskaFRACTALGROUP
 
Catalyst Report (2013)
Catalyst Report (2013)Catalyst Report (2013)
Catalyst Report (2013)Grant Thornton
 
National capital markets & international financing
National capital markets & international financingNational capital markets & international financing
National capital markets & international financingGalih Honggo Baskoro
 
Amsterdam EuroFinance 2009
Amsterdam EuroFinance 2009Amsterdam EuroFinance 2009
Amsterdam EuroFinance 2009Greg Zabikow
 
EPI Summit 2018 - Yanis Varoufakis Shares His Views on the Global Economy, Br...
EPI Summit 2018 - Yanis Varoufakis Shares His Views on the Global Economy, Br...EPI Summit 2018 - Yanis Varoufakis Shares His Views on the Global Economy, Br...
EPI Summit 2018 - Yanis Varoufakis Shares His Views on the Global Economy, Br...Investments Network marcus evans
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 438 - Financial Integration in Emerging Eur...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 438 - Financial Integration in Emerging Eur...CASE Network Studies and Analyses 438 - Financial Integration in Emerging Eur...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 438 - Financial Integration in Emerging Eur...CASE Center for Social and Economic Research
 
Zecchini Financing Sme Innovation Sz Slides 15 4 09
Zecchini Financing Sme Innovation Sz Slides 15 4 09Zecchini Financing Sme Innovation Sz Slides 15 4 09
Zecchini Financing Sme Innovation Sz Slides 15 4 09nick terch
 

Similar to Don\'t Waste A Perfectly Good Crisis (20)

Private Debt Investor | Europe Report Highlights 2018
Private Debt Investor | Europe Report Highlights 2018Private Debt Investor | Europe Report Highlights 2018
Private Debt Investor | Europe Report Highlights 2018
 
Global Investor May 2004
Global Investor May 2004Global Investor May 2004
Global Investor May 2004
 
Euro zone debt crisis and impacts on
Euro zone debt crisis and impacts onEuro zone debt crisis and impacts on
Euro zone debt crisis and impacts on
 
Elevator 12 jpfs
Elevator 12 jpfsElevator 12 jpfs
Elevator 12 jpfs
 
IMDADECTHESIS290902
IMDADECTHESIS290902IMDADECTHESIS290902
IMDADECTHESIS290902
 
522F11-LON-E
522F11-LON-E522F11-LON-E
522F11-LON-E
 
Corporate Image In Ukraine
Corporate Image In UkraineCorporate Image In Ukraine
Corporate Image In Ukraine
 
TheAdvisory_Sept2015_vFINAL
TheAdvisory_Sept2015_vFINALTheAdvisory_Sept2015_vFINAL
TheAdvisory_Sept2015_vFINAL
 
Ukrainian Venture Capital and Private Equity Association (UVCA) and Kreston U...
Ukrainian Venture Capital and Private Equity Association (UVCA) and Kreston U...Ukrainian Venture Capital and Private Equity Association (UVCA) and Kreston U...
Ukrainian Venture Capital and Private Equity Association (UVCA) and Kreston U...
 
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 288 - Sources for financing domestic capita...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 288 - Sources for financing domestic capita...CASE Network Studies and Analyses 288 - Sources for financing domestic capita...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 288 - Sources for financing domestic capita...
 
Buyouts September 2009_Panel_Case
Buyouts September 2009_Panel_CaseBuyouts September 2009_Panel_Case
Buyouts September 2009_Panel_Case
 
Cee investment report by skanska
Cee investment report by skanskaCee investment report by skanska
Cee investment report by skanska
 
Catalyst Report (2013)
Catalyst Report (2013)Catalyst Report (2013)
Catalyst Report (2013)
 
National capital markets & international financing
National capital markets & international financingNational capital markets & international financing
National capital markets & international financing
 
Amsterdam EuroFinance 2009
Amsterdam EuroFinance 2009Amsterdam EuroFinance 2009
Amsterdam EuroFinance 2009
 
White & Case. The Rise of European Private Equity
White & Case. The Rise of European Private EquityWhite & Case. The Rise of European Private Equity
White & Case. The Rise of European Private Equity
 
EPI Summit 2018 - Yanis Varoufakis Shares His Views on the Global Economy, Br...
EPI Summit 2018 - Yanis Varoufakis Shares His Views on the Global Economy, Br...EPI Summit 2018 - Yanis Varoufakis Shares His Views on the Global Economy, Br...
EPI Summit 2018 - Yanis Varoufakis Shares His Views on the Global Economy, Br...
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 438 - Financial Integration in Emerging Eur...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 438 - Financial Integration in Emerging Eur...CASE Network Studies and Analyses 438 - Financial Integration in Emerging Eur...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 438 - Financial Integration in Emerging Eur...
 
Zecchini Financing Sme Innovation Sz Slides 15 4 09
Zecchini Financing Sme Innovation Sz Slides 15 4 09Zecchini Financing Sme Innovation Sz Slides 15 4 09
Zecchini Financing Sme Innovation Sz Slides 15 4 09
 

Recently uploaded

The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdfGale Pooley
 
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptxFinTech Belgium
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Talegaon Dabhade 6297143586 Call Hot ...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Talegaon Dabhade  6297143586 Call Hot ...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Talegaon Dabhade  6297143586 Call Hot ...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Talegaon Dabhade 6297143586 Call Hot ...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri 6297143586 Call Hot Ind...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri  6297143586 Call Hot Ind...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri  6297143586 Call Hot Ind...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri 6297143586 Call Hot Ind...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...priyasharma62062
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdfGale Pooley
 
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mumbai 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts ...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mumbai 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts ...VIP Independent Call Girls in Mumbai 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts ...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mumbai 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts ...dipikadinghjn ( Why You Choose Us? ) Escorts
 
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptxFinTech Belgium
 
Vasai-Virar Fantastic Call Girls-9833754194-Call Girls MUmbai
Vasai-Virar Fantastic Call Girls-9833754194-Call Girls MUmbaiVasai-Virar Fantastic Call Girls-9833754194-Call Girls MUmbai
Vasai-Virar Fantastic Call Girls-9833754194-Call Girls MUmbaipriyasharma62062
 
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptxFinTech Belgium
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 17.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 17.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 17.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 17.pdfGale Pooley
 
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdfAdnet Communications
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdfGale Pooley
 
Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )
Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )
Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )Pooja Nehwal
 
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...dipikadinghjn ( Why You Choose Us? ) Escorts
 
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...ssifa0344
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfGale Pooley
 
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptxFinTech Belgium
 

Recently uploaded (20)

The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdf
 
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Talegaon Dabhade 6297143586 Call Hot ...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Talegaon Dabhade  6297143586 Call Hot ...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Talegaon Dabhade  6297143586 Call Hot ...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Talegaon Dabhade 6297143586 Call Hot ...
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri 6297143586 Call Hot Ind...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri  6297143586 Call Hot Ind...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri  6297143586 Call Hot Ind...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri 6297143586 Call Hot Ind...
 
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdf
 
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mumbai 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts ...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mumbai 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts ...VIP Independent Call Girls in Mumbai 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts ...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mumbai 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts ...
 
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
 
Vasai-Virar Fantastic Call Girls-9833754194-Call Girls MUmbai
Vasai-Virar Fantastic Call Girls-9833754194-Call Girls MUmbaiVasai-Virar Fantastic Call Girls-9833754194-Call Girls MUmbai
Vasai-Virar Fantastic Call Girls-9833754194-Call Girls MUmbai
 
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 17.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 17.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 17.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 17.pdf
 
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
 
Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )
Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )
Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )
 
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...
 
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
 
(Vedika) Low Rate Call Girls in Pune Call Now 8250077686 Pune Escorts 24x7
(Vedika) Low Rate Call Girls in Pune Call Now 8250077686 Pune Escorts 24x7(Vedika) Low Rate Call Girls in Pune Call Now 8250077686 Pune Escorts 24x7
(Vedika) Low Rate Call Girls in Pune Call Now 8250077686 Pune Escorts 24x7
 
From Luxury Escort Service Kamathipura : 9352852248 Make on-demand Arrangemen...
From Luxury Escort Service Kamathipura : 9352852248 Make on-demand Arrangemen...From Luxury Escort Service Kamathipura : 9352852248 Make on-demand Arrangemen...
From Luxury Escort Service Kamathipura : 9352852248 Make on-demand Arrangemen...
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
 
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
 

Don\'t Waste A Perfectly Good Crisis

  • 1. “Don’t Waste a Perfectly Good Crisis” 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary by Squire, Sanders & Dempsey L.L.P. Spring 2009
  • 2. INTRODUCTION The global downturn has caught up with Central and Eastern Europe and then some. The transactional scene in CEE is pin-drop quiet, LPs are spooked and several CEE stalwarts are wrestling with political and economic turmoil. In short, it is an opportunity in the making for private equity. As put by Daniel Lynch of 3TS Capital Partners, “don’t waste a perfectly good crisis.” C5 and global law firm Squire, Sanders & Dempsey L.L.P. are pleased to bring you an overview of perspectives and insights from the 13th Annual C5 CEE Private Equity Forum held in Vienna on 23-24 March 2009. We would like to thank all presenters for their thoughtful comments on the current state of private equity in Central and Eastern Europe, and the Forum delegates for demonstrating continuing interest in private equity’s future. Squire Sanders’ CEE Private Equity Team Spring 2009 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary 2
  • 3. C5 CEE PRIVATE EQUITY FORUM: EXPLORING OPPORTUNITIES IN UNCERTAIN TIMES Private equity in Central and Eastern Europe is bearing its share of fallout from the global downturn. Deal flow isn't even at a trickle, governments and economies are in turmoil and businesses are collapsing, not to mention the overarching anxiety caused by the ongoing financial crisis. But amid the gloom spark some new prospects for private equity. • There has never been a one-size-fits-all solution for private equity in CEE. The financial crisis has highlighted regional winners and losers, although debate continues on final designations. Some conference presenters named the Czech Republic, Poland, the Slovak Republic and Slovenia as winners, while the Baltic states, Bulgaria, Hungary, Romania, Russia and Ukraine were generally named losers. Hobbled by higher debt and unstable currencies, the losers are expected to be slower to recover. In any case, private equity must have players on the ground who understand each country’s economic, social and political fundamentals before selecting investment targets. • Crisis notwithstanding, private equity firms are believed to be sitting on US$3 billion to US$4 billion of dry powder, and supply and demand for regional capital is bound to converge. While many observers urged private equity to go back to basics and get this capital into play, others noted that the industry needs to obtain clarity from banks about the availability of leverage or come up with financing alternatives. • Fund managers need to evaluate the relative strength of existing portfolio companies with a view to managing towards increased efficiency and, as concerns non-performing or troubled assets, developing a realistic plan to address these problems. • Highly leveraged mega-buyouts may be a dead model, so private equity needs to be creative and flexible. At the same time, private equity has to play it safe and smart, increasing diligence efforts, forcing valuations to match market realities and forecasting realistic exit opportunities. • Private equity should be on the lookout for distressed assets, mezzanine finance opportunities, small deals in the €10-25 million range and family-owned companies with succession issues. The industry should also beware of potential difficulties caused by the call for increased governmental regulation. 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary 3
  • 4. WHAT THE EXPERTS SAID Winners and Losers While the “easy money” years (2004-2008) are gone, Nikolaus Bethlen of Mid Europa Partners observed that talk of gloom and doom in CEE doesn’t provide a complete picture. A more accurate view of CEE would focus on regional winners and losers instead of a unified region of equals. As a result, private equity needs to develop distinct strategies for each CEE country. Although debate continues on final designations, the winners were identified as Poland, the Slovak Republic, Slovenia and the Czech Republic. Jaroslav Hascak of Penta Investments is “very optimistic” about investing in CEE and believes that, on a macro level, the so-called winner countries will provide good opportunities for private equity. The so-called losers – those countries with unstable currencies and high rates of debt to GDP – were generally identified as Russia, Ukraine, the Baltic states, Hungary, Romania and Bulgaria. These countries are predicted to have a difficult time luring new investors. Mr. Bethlen noted that the losers have taken a double capital flight hit: as investors became more wary, banks also expatriated money from the region. Russia and Ukraine are particularly hard hit, he said. Michael Tojner of Global Equity Partners Beteiligungs-Management AG echoed that perspective, noting several short-term challenges that the region faces. He said he is very wary of investments in Eastern Europe, particularly Russia, where financing is hard to come by. Mid Europa’s Bethlen noted that while, for example, Hungary- or Ukraine-based deals will be hampered by financing difficulties, there are significant opportunities for managers who have been in and understand the region. He also stated there is at least US$3 billion to US$4 billion in dry powder awaiting investment opportunities in CEE that will surface as valuation levels align with expectations. As a result, private equity activity should pick up by late 2009. From the investors’ perspective, Roy Baumann of Partners Group said that his firm is earmarking 5 to 10 percent of its European program to CEE investments, but that he is much more cautious about Russia and Ukraine. Thorsten Paul of Investkredit Bank AG predicts that Russia will be the last CEE country to find new investors, as he believes the bubble in Russia is bigger than in any of the other CEE countries. He added that he does not see a lot of fundraising activity in the region and observed that the funds his firm has invested in are sitting on cash. Paul does not expect a big shakeout in the market, although he does predict that the number of LPs investing in CEE will decrease over the next couple of years. Henry J. Owainati and Hannes Ambacher  of Bank Gutmann Group explained the importance of choosing the right private equity fund manager, due primarily to the great disparity in performance between the top-tier fund managers and bottom-tier fund managers. Owainati and Ambacher suggested that the most important factor an investor should consider is the management team. 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary 4
  • 5. Global Equity Partners’ Tojner also sees opportunities in CEE, specifically real estate funds and restructuring funds targeting real estate assets. Tojner also said the niche market of high-tech companies – his organization’s target – presents excellent opportunities as valuations come down. Likewise, Vinarom Vilaihongs of SGAM Alternative Investments S.A., comparing CEE to Western Europe, sees opportunities arising from the fact that CEE is a very fragmented market with less competition. Jan Dewijngaert of Gimv, in contrast to many other speakers, found positives in the Russian market. While the macroeconomic indicators are certainly not good, because of low governmental debt, high foreign currency reserves and relatively modest unemployment, he believes Russia’s current troubles are different from the 1998 Russian crisis. Dewijngaert also predicts that the power of the oligarchs will decline as they are forced to restructure, consolidate or sell assets. He continues to see many interesting investment opportunities, particularly in consumer-oriented businesses. Private Equity Landscape: Where Are We Now? Country-by-country winners and losers notwithstanding, the speakers provided a frank assessment of the state of private equity in CEE in 2008 and early 2009, including analyzing the roots of its current troubles. Armando D’Amico of Acanthus Advisors attributed CEE’s problems to “too much investment, too quickly.” In that vein, Joanna James of Advent International cautioned that private equity in CEE had become accustomed to “instant gratification.” She stated that the industry as a whole must relearn that “debt is a burden to be paid off” and not an asset to be bought and sold. EIF’s Ulrich Grabenwarter stated that a review of deal dynamics over the past three years provided “warning signs” of the current crisis. He noted that the impact of the crisis will be larger in CEE than in Western markets because there will be a “flight to the more conservative risk/return profiles” typically found in more developed markets. David Bernard of Thomson Reuters provided grim statistics for 2008 and 2009: M&A activity in 2008 was down 35 percent in Europe and 45 percent in CEE. Worse yet, Bernard noted that M&A activity is down 98 percent in 2009, demonstrating how few deals have been reported during the first quarter of this year. He indicated that no sector is safe, as all industries have been affected while PE- backed buy-side transactions decreased 93 percent over the past six months. There have been no syndicated loans this year and fundraising is also very quiet. At the same time, the exit market is suffering, with equity issuances down 29 percent in CEE and 17 percent globally. According to Mr. Bernard, the capital markets are “closed, for all intents and purposes.” Mid Europa’s Bethlen observed that now is the time to focus on portfolio companies and to contemplate strategies for investing amid a lack of acquisition financing. “We are still in a time lag,” remarked Bethlen, predicting that it may take a few more months for people to realize that the new valuations are here to stay. He advised being creative and opportunistic to achieve results. Brian Gimotty of Paul Capital Partners agreed that there is “a lot of disconnect in the market.” He believes that secondary valuations have started to “come down to earth” and that private equity firms are taking a more sober view of risk/reward scenarios. 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary 5
  • 6. A number of speakers expressed concern that investment capital has been flowing out of CEE and is not being replaced by new investors. At the same time, Robert Manz of Enterprise Investors expressed “strong concern” that investments in CEE have fallen out of favor, with investors not currently in CEE fearful of committing to the region. Though Alessandra Pasian of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development confirmed that EBRD is committed to continue funding in CEE and is looking at new funds coming to market, Peeter Piho of Hansa Investment Funds, observed a lack of domestic institutional LPs, which is “an issue in CEE and an issue for the industry.” Compounding the problem of capital flight is the lack of clarity from banks about their ability and willingness to lend. Thomas Wilfling of AXA Private Equity Eastern Europe GmbH believes that a number of banks claiming to be open for business are, in fact, “not really open” or have not seriously tested their credit committees for some time, lacking internal guidance in terms of what can be achieved. He predicts that the lending situation may become somewhat clearer in a few months when banks know and have digested 2008 data. Supriya Saxena of UniCredit Markets & Investment Banking acknowledged that many banks do not have a defined lending strategy yet for this year, thereby contributing to the lack of visibility around liquidity. That said, she emphasized that banks are more critically assessing risk and there is generally more focus on due diligence. Given overall constraints on capital, and volatility in funding costs, banks are requiring higher up-front fees and margins to put money to work. Many banks have retreated to their home markets, and relationship and ancillary business has become increasingly important in the overall investment decision. Saxena said that in addition to liquidity provided by local lenders in each regional market, there is a very limited number of global banks still actively involved in LBOs in CEE. Some of the main players include UniCredit, ING and RZB. The model where arranging banks underwrite and syndicate is no longer viable, she observed. In 2009, most transactions are likely to be in the form of club deals, with three or four banks working together to provide financing without any one lender assuming a significant amount of underwriting risk. Bad news notwithstanding, conference presenters also expressed optimism about the prospects of private equity in CEE. Bethlen of Mid Europa claimed that the “portrait of doom and gloom” painted in the media about CEE is exaggerated. Comparing the current environment to Asia’s crisis in 1996, he observed that CEE is in a much better state of health because debt levels of CEE companies are fairly moderate. As a result, he forecasts the crisis “will be much better absorbed” in CEE than it was in Asia. Penta Investments’ Hascak reminded the audience that while you must be selective, there are “excellent opportunities” to find interesting companies at a good price. EIF’s Grabenwarter stated that the crisis can also be seen as a “tremendous opportunity for private equity” as it can demonstrate its real role in company building and strategic development of businesses. He added that those fund managers that prove they are capable of generating returns not only in times of “macroeconomic tailwind” will prevail. Another prominent theme was the role that mezzanine finance will play in private equity deals in 2009 and beyond. Chris Buckle of Mezzanine Management GmbH observed that deal flow is beginning to improve compared to the past six to nine months. New deals include LBOs of distressed sellers. Buckle noted that distressed LBOs offer a significant role for mezzanine finance firms. Another speaker noted that returns are less squeezed than before the crisis and that deals are now being more conservatively leveraged. 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary 6
  • 7. From the perspective of local mezzanine providers, Mezzanine Management’s Buckle also noted that the downturn has reduced competition for deals. In particular, many Western European funds are now staying in their home markets and no longer straying into CEE. A less competitive landscape is good news for local players. However, with LPs also shunning the region, specialist mezzanine funds in CEE now face the challenge of raising enough capital to finance the significant number of available opportunities anticipated. This view was echoed by Dr. Matthias Unser of Sal. Oppenheim Private Equity Partners. Advent’s James drew parallels between the tortoise-and-hare fable and private equity’s leverage- fueled growth. She said the industry must “redefine success” in order to manage expectations created by the unsustainable returns achieved during the boom years. Since private equity is flexible and creative, James said she has faith the industry will adapt to a new landscape that demands private equity to be cautious, methodical and to truly take a long-term view. In addition to her advice to “get back to basics,” James predicted that, in the near term, funds would target smaller companies holding not more debt than they can pay off, and that expansion capital investments, as compared to leveraged buyouts, will become increasingly common. EIF’s Grabenwarter agreed that private equity will see new deal dynamics going forward, with leverage as a value driver off the agenda and private equity going “back to its roots, which is value creation through strategic positioning and organic growth.” Manz of Enterprise Investors also expressed optimism about the future of private equity in CEE. “Private equity thrives on distortion,” he said, predicting that private equity’s current crunch will be relieved by decreases in both valuations and competition and bolstered by improved access to talented management. Manz expects valuations to come down to more acceptable levels within six to 12 months. Finally, participants highlighted current regulatory trends and those on the horizon. Maurits Tausk of Baker & McKenzie advised that the new EU proposal to regulate private equity firms should be monitored closely. Advent’s James echoed this concern, noting that there is virtually no chance that the private equity industry will be allowed to self-regulate. Observing that there are no CEE representatives on the regulation task force, she expressed concern about the current talk of delegating oversight responsibility to local authorities or venture capital associations. Marc van Campen of Baker & McKenzie noted the recent attacks by the United States on tax haven jurisdictions and predicted that we are likely to see changes that affect private equity structuring, not all of which may be rational. Trends to Watch In the short term, Mezzanine Management’s Buckle sees many private equity funds focusing on portfolio companies while considering smaller acquisition opportunities in the US$10 million to US$25 million range. That view was echoed by Lynch of 3TS, who noted that now is the right time to make any changes that need to be made to portfolio companies. Lynch also advised looking at consolidation and “bolt on” opportunities. Buckle does not envision many larger LBOs. UniCredit’s 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary 7
  • 8. Saxena indicated that her bank remains committed to investing in LBOs in the region. The appetite for commitment to any particular transaction depends upon a number of factors, but institutionally the bank’s focus is on home markets and key sponsor relationships. AXA’s Wilfling predicted that future acquisition financing packages will see significant changes from deals structured just a year or two ago. For example, he does not expect to see many deals with much more than five times EBITDA debt multiples in the near term. Observing that “cooling off is a good thing,” Wilfling said that the current environment will force private equity to find creative ways to deal with the lack of debt and emphasized that private equity needs to be highly selective in these times. Brian Wardrop of ARX Equity Partners envisions a greater role for mezzanine finance due to banks’ changed incentive models. Johan Bastin of Darby Private Equity sees local banks still willing to provide senior debt, although they are considerably more selective and focused on defensive factors. With respect to the post-crisis leverage ratios, Bastin said, “In 2007 six became the new five and now four is becoming the new six.” Additionally, covenants have come back in fashion and equity kickers are no longer anathema. Bastin stated that he is much more interested in credit quality these days, “even at the cost of lower returns than could be realized elsewhere in the market.” Other speakers highlighted developments in the region that may result in new investment opportunities. According to Penta Investment’s Hascak, many family companies purchased out of privatizations are facing succession issues. He observed that private equity houses with local offices and knowledge can exploit the opportunities created by these changes. Anticipating increased interest from private equity in distressed investments, a panel of experts from Squire Sanders emphasized the importance of conducting speedy due diligence of financially troubled companies. “Review the metrics of the business and do not get hung up on minutiae as time is of the essence”, advised Squire Sanders partner Kevin T. Connor. As bankruptcy financing options are extremely limited in CEE, the panel advised that acquiring a target prior to entering into formal insolvency proceedings is “critical.” Additionally, acquirers of distressed companies should restrain themselves from bidding high early in the process. Squire Sanders partner Tomasz Z. Ujejski recommended reserving sufficient resources to outbid any later bidders that directors may seek to include in order to satisfy directors’ duties to maximize share price. Discussing exits, Manz of Enterprise Investors does not expect conditions to improve substantially until 2010. “We're living in unprecedented times, which means there are no definitive answers on how private equity will fare in the economic landscape being reshaped by the global financial crisis,” concluded Squire Sanders’ Kevin Connor, chairman of day one of the Forum. “But we do know that private equity thrives when the stakes are high and the odds are long. Our best practice now is to explore all opportunities and make the most of them.” 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary 8
  • 9. WHAT THE NUMBERS SAY Below is a sampling of the statistics that were shared by the speakers in their presentations. Thank you to David Bernard of Thomson Reuters, Nikolaus Bethlen of Mid Europa Partners, Henry J. Owainati and Hannes Ambacher of Bank Gutmann Group, Joanna James of Advent International and Brian Gimotty of Paul Capital Partners for permitting us to include these in our event summary. 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary 9
  • 10. 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary 10
  • 11. 13th Annual CEE Private Equity Forum Event Summary 11
  • 12. About Squire Sanders Founded in 1890, Squire, Sanders & Dempsey L.L.P. has lawyers in 32 offices and 15 countries around the world. On the ground in seven CEE countries, and backed by the global expertise of our Emerging Markets Private Equity Group, our tightly integrated CEE Private Equity Team works together to seamlessly serve our clients’ transactional needs – whether the deal is undertaken in one of our resident countries or across multiple borders. We advise on all types of private equity investments and exits and have a deep understanding of the issues peculiar to key industry sectors including chemicals, communications, energy, food and beverage, financial services, hospitality and leisure, logistics and infrastructure, media, natural resources, real estate and technology. For more information, please contact our CEE Private Equity Team: Christopher A. Rose Moscow +7.495.258.5250 | London +44.20.7189.8113 | crose@ssd.com Kevin T. Connor Bratislava +421.2.5930.3473 | Budapest +36.1.428.7115 | kconnor@ssd.com Tomasz Z. H. Ujejski Warsaw +48.22.395.5507 | London +44.20.7189.8130 | tujejski@ssd.com Ákos Mester Budapest +36.1.428.7168 | amester@ssd.com Jeffrey A. McGehee Prague +420.221.662.282 | jmcgehee@ssd.com Peter Z. Teluk About C5 Kyiv +380.44.220.1400 | pteluk@ssd.com For over 15 years, conferences produced by C5 have provided the business intelligence that corporate decision-makers need to respond to modern challenges and opportunities. C5 is staffed by industry professionals, lawyers and CIS country specialists. The company operates as a think tank by monitoring trends and developments in major industry sectors with a view to provide cutting edge business information. Based in London, C5 holds events both across Europe and Russia and has recently grown to produce over 90 events a year, attended by hundreds of delegates. 32 OFFICES 15 C O U N T R I E S CINCINNATI • CLEVELAND • COLUMBUS • HOUSTON • LOS ANGELES • MIAMI • NEW YORK • PALO ALTO • PHOENIX • SAN FRANCISCO • TALLAHASSEE • TAMPA • TYSONS CORNER • WASHINGTON DC WEST PALM BEACH | BOGOTÁ+ • BUENOS AIRES+ • CARACAS • LA PAZ+ • LIMA+ • PANAMÁ+ • RIO DE JANEIRO • SANTIAGO+ • SANTO DOMINGO • SÃO PAULO | BRATISLAVA BRUSSELS • BUCHAREST+ • BUDAPEST • DUBLIN+ • FRANKFURT • KYIV • LONDON • MOSCOW • PRAGUE • WARSAW | BEIJING • HONG KONG • SHANGHAI • TOKYO | +INDEPENDENT NETWORK FIRM SQUIRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY L.L.P. WWW.SSD.COM