Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Name: ___________________________________                                The Arrival—Comparison SheetWhen we compare two t...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5

The Arrival - Comparrison Sheet (version 1.1)


Published on

"More and more I see fantasy worlds - as in The Arrival - as a way of tapping into the real world, of trying to understand reality better through a speculative lens. Shaun Tan"
I often start off reading this quote before having my students read Shaun Tan's graphic novel, The Arrival. I even wear a special pair of glasses while I read the quote. After each chapter, I put the glasses back on and ask the class what has happened in the story and what does it tell us about the real world.

Sometimes I get simple answers like:
"It was crowed when the people got off the boat and it was also crowded in the immigration office on Ellis Island."

Sometimes I get more complex answers like:
"The man in the hat had trouble keeping a job because he could not speak the language. He did better in the factory. In the real world, people who can't speak the language do better in jobs like factories, because there are less instructions to translate."

At the end of the book, I give them this worksheet to get a more formal written response to this question.

For more resources and podcasts about making and teaching visual narratives visit

  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

The Arrival - Comparrison Sheet (version 1.1)

  1. 1. Name: ___________________________________ The Arrival—Comparison SheetWhen we compare two things, we find all the ways that they are alike.Shaun Tan believes that we need to have fantasy in order to understand real world situations.Describe one fantasy situation in The Arrival and then tell what it helps us understand in the real world. Fantasy Situation Real-World Situation Version 1.1