1) The study evaluated the effects of high acceleration forces (9G) on visual performance and ocular responses in 14 men using a human centrifuge.
2) Transient visual acuity reduction and temporary corneal thickening were observed immediately after centrifugation. Prolonged increases in anterior chamber depth and pupillary dilation were also observed up to 30 minutes after.
3) Contrast sensitivity was found to decrease significantly at low and medium spatial frequencies and did not return to baseline levels within 30 minutes of centrifugation.
2. IOVS, October 2009, Vol. 50, No. 10 Visual and Ocular Changes after High G-Force Exposure 4837
TABLE 1. The Cornea-Related Parameters before and after Gravitational Stress
Immediately After After
Before After 15 min 30 min
Sim K
Maximum 44.52 0.43 45.08 0.63 45.21 1.17 44.89 1.31
Minimum 43.91 0.67 44.57 0.81 44.32 0.61 44.21 0.87
Anterior BFS (D) 43.23 1.51 42.94 1.32 42.98 0.94 43.11 1.34
Posterior BFS (D) 52.37 2.03 52.02 2.21 52.11 0.97 52.29 1.47
CCT ( m) 553.7 21.7 591.2 20.6* 567.4 21.6 556.2 23.6
n 14 eyes.
* Statistically significant difference (P 0.05).
tory of ocular or systemic disease, such as hypertension, diabetes, itational stress. All data were collected and analyzed. Fundus
glaucoma, cataract, or uveitis, were excluded from the investiga- examination was performed 2 hours after centrifugation. Throughout
tion. the experiment, blood pressure (BP) and pulse rate were monitored by
All examinations were performed at the Air Force Health Exam- a digital BP monitor (HDM 704 cm; Omron, Tokyo, Japan). All results
ination and Physiological Training Center, Kan-Shan Armed Forces are expressed as the mean SD. A paired t-test was used to compare
Hospital, Taiwan. All subjects had remained at sea level for the the physiological parameters before and after centrifugation. P 0.05
previous month. Before centrifugation, each subject underwent a was accepted as significant.
complete ocular examination that included tests of visual acuity
(Early Treatment of Diabetic Retinopathy [ETDRS] logMAR chart)
and refraction (AR310; Nidek, Tokyo, Japan) and examination with
RESULTS
the biomicroscope. The letter stimuli of the ETDRS logMAR chart in One subject withdrew from the study because of nausea after
this study are printed on an illuminated cabinet (background lumi- the centrifugation. All data were collected from 14 eyes. Most
nance, 350 cd/ m2). The chart has five letters per row ranging in size of the ocular-related parameters, such as anterior BFS, poste-
from 1.0 to 0.30 logMAR. Visual acuity was tested at 4 m rior BFS, and Sim K, did not change significantly from before to
distance. The corneal topography system (Orbscan II; Bausch & after centrifugation. However, the CCT increased significantly
Lomb) was used to assess the various ocular responses including immediately after centrifugation compared with the value be-
Sim K (maximum K and minimum K values), anterior best-fit sphere fore centrifugation (553.7 21.7 vs. 591.2 20.6, P 0.05),
(BFS), posterior BSF, ACD, pupillary diameter (PD), and central but this was not maintained beyond 15 minutes after high
corneal thickness (CCT). Macular responses such as metamorphop- gravitational stress (Table 1).
sia were detected by using the Amsler grid test, and visual perfor- ACD increased considerably immediately after (3.19 0.26
mance was assessed further by testing CS with the CS was tested mm vs. 4.53 0.34 mm, P 0.05) and 15 minutes after
monocularly before and after 9-Gz exposure by a CS test chart (4.39 0.27, P 0.05) 9-Gz force stress. ACD returned to
(VCTS 6500; Vistech Consultants, Inc., Dayton, OH). The chart the pretest value by 30 minutes after exposure to acceleration
consists of 45 circular targets with gratings of different size and (3.24 0.29, P 0.05; Table 2).
contrast. The target size in the distance test is 7.5 cm. The gratings PD enlarged significantly immediately after (3.54 0.73
in the targets are vertical or 15° left or right from the vertical mm vs. 5.76 0.61 mm; P 0.05) and 15 minutes (5.56
direction. In the test chart, the contrast decreases horizontally from 0.67 mm; P 0.05) after centrifugation. PD remained enlarged
left to right, and gratings become smaller vertically from top to 30 minutes after exposure to acceleration (5.47 0.59 mm;
bottom (from 1.5 to 18 cyc/deg; from target A to target E). The P 0.05; Table 3).
subject began at the top horizontal line A and stated whether the In the tests of visual performance, transient visual acuity
gratings in targets 1 to 9 are vertical, left, or right. The last target decreased immediately after the gravitational stress (0.02
that the subject reported correctly was marked down on a result 0.04 vs. 0.19 0.07, P 0.05; Table 4). CS reduction was also
paper provided by the test. The same procedure was repeated in all observed at 30 minutes after exposure to acceleration, and
the other horizontal test lines from B to E. At measurement time, the significant depression of CS was found at low and medium
room luminance was approximately 200 cd/m2 and the test dis- frequencies. CS in the right eye decreased at 1.5 (P 0.05), 3.0
tance, 3 m. (P 0.05), and 6.0 cyc/deg (P 0.05; Fig. 1). Refraction
After these examinations, the subject entered the human centri- remained stable at 30 minutes after gravitational stress (Table
fuge and donned an aviation helmet with a microphone attached so 4). The Amsler grid examination revealed no particular finding
that he could communicate with the aerospace physician outside. A such as metamorphopsia in any subject.
TV monitor was mounted outside the human centrifuge to monitor Throughout the experiment, ocular posterior segment re-
the status of each subject. When the setting was complete, a vealed no specific observations. In addition, no particular oc-
gravitational stress of 9-Gz force was established with a human ular finding was noted such as hyphema, lens dislocation, or
centrifuge which also applied G-forces parallel to the subject’s retinal hemorrhage.
body. The technician outside the centrifuge accelerated the speed
until it reached 9 Gz and held this constant for 15 seconds. The
operating protocol to induced 9 Gz in this experiment was as TABLE 2. Anterior Chamber Depth before and after
follows. The centrifuge was accelerated to 2 G/s from 1 to 1.4 G for Gravitational Stress
15 seconds, then accelerated to 2 G/s from 1.4 to 4 G and held
Immediately After After
constant for 20 seconds, and then reduced to 1.4 G for 30 seconds. Before After 15 min 30 min
The centrifuge was then accelerated rapidly to 6 G/s and then to 9
G for 15 seconds before slowing to 2 G/s and finally to 1 G.4,11 ACD (mm) 3.19 0.26 4.53 0.34* 4.39 0.27* 3.24 0.29
Visual acuity was checked and the corneal topographer was ap-
plied again immediately, 15 minutes, and 30 minutes after the centrif- n 14 eyes.
ugation. Refraction and CS were measured 30 minutes after the grav- * Statistically significant difference (P 0.05).
3. 4838 Tsai et al. IOVS, October 2009, Vol. 50, No. 10
TABLE 3. Pupillary Diameter before and after Gravitational Stress
Immediately After After
Before After 15 min 30 min
PD (mm) 3.54 0.73 5.76 0.61* 5.56 0.67* 5.47 0.59*
n 14 eyes.
* Statistically significant difference (P 0.05).
DISCUSSION
In this study, we observed a 10% increase in CCT after 9-Gz
force exposure. We assume that the transient hydrostatic pres-
sure increase may explain this finding. The ocular anterior
chamber in the eye is full of aqueous humor.12,13 An exposure
to high gravity may increase hydrostatic pressure in the ante-
rior chamber and increase the tendency for fluid to flow across
the corneal endothelium into the stroma, which would in- FIGURE 1. Mean CS before and after 9-Gz force exposure. *Signifi-
crease the corneal thickness.14 The CCT returned to its initial cant differences at P 0.05.
value within 15 minutes, suggesting that the corneal endothe-
lium was not compromised by high gravitational exposure,
even at 9-Gz force. An interesting observation was that a 10% stress.12,13 When subjects are under high-gravity stress, the aque-
increase in CCT occurred without significant concomitant ous hydrostatic pressure in the anterior and posterior chambers
changes in the corneal curvature. Our data are consistent with may increase toward the gravity direction. Because the volume is
those of Rom et al.,15 who found no significant correlation greater in the anterior chamber than in the posterior chamber, the
between corneal thickness and curvature, even when the cor- aqueous humor pressure is also greater in the anterior chamber
neal thickness increases up to 16%. during high G-force exposure.12,13 The greater hydrostatic pres-
PD increased significantly after high G-force exposure in our sure in the anterior chamber may push the iris toward the poste-
study. Before the stress, PD was 3.54 0.73 mm, and the marked rior chamber and cause the ACD to increase. At the same time,
pupillary dilation persisted for 30 minutes after the stress. The size this iris diaphragm may rest on the lens surface and trap fluid in
of the pupil is regulated by the autonomic nervous system, which the anterior chamber. When the hydrostatic pressure is relieved,
is influenced by many environmental, physiological, and psycho- the trapped aqueous humor maintains the ACD, which may ex-
logical factors. Previous studies show that gravitational stress can plain the prolonged deepening of the anterior chamber. The
increase sympathetic tone to prevent body fluid shifting down- trapped aqueous humor drains with time, and the ACD returns to
ward with gravity.16 This transient sympathetic tone elevation baseline.12,13,19 We also observed that the refractive power did
may account for the early pupil dilation immediately after centrif- not reveal a significant finding at 30 minutes after 9-Gz expo-
ugation. However, an increase in sympathetic activity cannot sure. This observation suggests that axial length did not change at
clarify completely why the pupil enlargement persisted for 30 30 minutes after gravitational stress. However, further research is
minutes. Tran et al.17 reported that high G-force exposure causes necessary to confirm this finding.
a persistent reduction in parasympathetic activity. This prolonged In our study, visual acuity showed a transient reduction imme-
reduction in parasympathetic activity may also explain the persis- diately after centrifugation and returned to baseline at 15 minutes.
tent pupil enlargement after gravitational stress. Neurohormonal We assume that temporary corneal edema plays a role, because a
regulation is another possible explanation for this persistent pupil study has shown that corneal edema can disturb visual acuity.20
dilation. Gravitational stress increases the blood somatostatin con- However, the Amsler grid examination revealed no specific find-
centration. Yamaji et al.18 found that somatostatin may induce ings in our study, suggesting that the macular structure was not
mydriasis by attenuating cholinergic neurotransmitter release. compromised even after the high G-force exposure. For clarifica-
Therefore, neurohormonal regulation may also be involved in this tion of our supposition, further study may be helpful, such as
prolonged pupil enlargement. pinhole, potential acuity testing, and laser interferometry. Visual
In our experiment, the ACD increased immediately and 15 acuity is usually evaluated with the ETDRS visual chart, a basic
minutes after 9-Gz force exposure but returned to baseline method of evaluating visual performance by estimating the visual
within 30 minutes after gravitational stress. Pupil enlargement response to black-and-white contrast. However, performance on
may explain the increase in ACD at 15 minutes after gravitational the ETDRS chart represents one extreme of CS, and in reality,
stress, but it cannot explain why the ACD returned to baseline objects and their surroundings are of varying contrasts. The CS
when mydriasis persisted 30 minutes after centrifugation. We test was developed based on the measurement of visual resolution
believe that the increase in hydrostatic pressure caused by the for a wide range of contrasts. The CS test is useful for evaluating
9-Gz force explains this finding. The aqueous humor in the eye visual quality more precisely, by plotting the reciprocal of the
may shift toward the gravity direction under gravitational threshold contrast for sinusoidal gratings as a function of their
TABLE 4. Visual Acuity and Refraction before and after Gravitational Stress
Immediately After After
Before After 15 min 30 min
VA (logMAR) 0.02 0.04 0.19 0.07* 0.05 0.06 0.04 0.07
Refraction (D) 0.37 0.47 0.23 0.51
n 14 eyes.
* Statistically significant difference (P 0.05).
4. IOVS, October 2009, Vol. 50, No. 10 Visual and Ocular Changes after High G-Force Exposure 4839
spatial frequency. It thus gives information on visual performance 5. Simons R, Krol J. Visual loss from bungee jumping. Lancet. 1994;
for a range of object scales.21 343:853.
In this investigation, we observed remarkable CS loss after 6. Emerson MV, Jakobs E, Green WR. Ocular autopsy and histopatho-
gravitational stress and that more than 30 minutes was needed for logic features of child abuse. Ophthalmology. 2007;114:1384 –
recovery. Several ocular anterior chamber reactions observed in 1394.
the study may account for this finding, including corneal clarity 7. Schneider S, Guardiera S, Kleinert J, et al. Centrifugal acceleration
to 3Gz is related to increased release of stress hormones and
and pupillary mydriasis. Hess and Garner21 reported that corneal
decreased mood in men and women. Stress. 2008;11:339 –347.
edema leads to depression of CS. Other researchers have also
8. Elias PZ, Jarchow T, Young LR. Incremental adaptation to yaw
demonstrated that pupil mydriasis may compromise CS func- head turns during 30 RPM centrifugation. Exp Brain Res. 2008;
tion.22,23 However, the changes of ocular anterior segment reac- 189:269 –277.
tion cannot fully elucidate why the CS was significantly reduced at 9. Sahin A, Yildirim N, Basmak H. Two-year interval changes in
low and medium but not at high spatial frequency at 30 minutes Orbscan II topography in eyes with keratoconus. J Cataract Re-
after gravitational stress. Factors other than ocular anterior seg- fract Surg. 2008;34:1295–1299.
ment response are thought to explain this observation. We as- 10. Wei RH, Lim L, Chan WK, Tan DT. Evaluation of Orbscan II corneal
sume that the changes in neuroretinal function may play a role in topography in individuals with myopia. Ophthalmology. 2006;
this phenomenon. Ossard et al.24 have demonstrated that gravi- 113:177–183.
tational stress can cause body fluid to shift toward the lower body, 11. Balldin UI, O’Connor RB, Isdahl WM, Werchan PM. Pressure breath-
which decreases ocular blood flow and leads to hypoxia. Several ing without a counter-pressure vest does not impair acceleration
studies have reported that hypoxia may compromise neuroretinal tolerance up to 9 G. Aviat Space Environ Med. 2005;76:456 – 462.
function and lead to prolonged CS reduction.25–27 Visual acuity 12. Fitt AD, Gonzalez G. Fluid mechanics of the human eye: aqueous
was coupled to changes in microcirculation in the retina such as humour flow in the anterior chamber. Bull Math Biol. 2006;68:
53–71.
retinal capillary density and the size of the free avascular zone
13. Brubaker RF. The flow of aqueous humor in the human eye. Trans
(FAZ). In a past study, Arend et al.26 showed that CS is a more Am Ophthalmol Soc. 1982;80:391– 474.
sensitive examination for detecting the change of microcircula- 14. Muir KW, Jin J, Freedman SF. Central corneal thickness and its
tion in retina. DiLeo et al.28 reported that hypoxia may affect relationship to intraocular pressure in children. Ophthalmology.
magnocellular ganglion cells more severely than parvocellular 2004;111:2220 –2223.
ganglion cells. The magnocellular ganglion cells are more sensi- 15. Rom ME, Keller WB, Meyer CJ, et al. Relationship between corneal
tive to low-contrast stimuli, whereas parvocellular ganglion cells edema and topography. CLAO J. 1995;21:191–194.
are more sensitive to high-contrast stimuli.29 Therefore, they also 16. Norsk P. Cardiovascular and fluid volume control in humans in
reported that hypoxia may result in contrast losses, particularly at space. Curr Pharm Biotechnol. 2005;6:325–330.
low and medium spatial frequency.28 Because parvocellular gan- 17. Tran CC, Berthelot M, Etienne X, et al. Cerebral oxygenation
glion cells were affected less severely than magnocellular ganglion declines despite maintained orthostatic tolerance after brief expo-
cells, Harris et al.30 showed that CS in a patient with minimal sure to gravitational stress. Neurosci Lett. 2005;380:181–186.
diabetic changes in the retina improved significantly, especially at 18. Yamaji K, Yoshitomi T, Usui S. Effect of somatostatin and galanin
high spatial frequencies, when the patient was subjected to hy- on isolated rabbit iris sphincter and dilator muscles. Exp Eye Res.
peroxia. In our study, the CS examination was performed at 30 2003 Nov.;77:609 – 614.
minutes after gravitational stress. CS still was significantly reduced 19. Cionni RJ, Barros MG, Osher RH. Management of lens-iris dia-
phragm retropulsion syndrome during phacoemulsification. J Cat-
at low and medium spatial frequency at 30 minutes, perhaps
aract Refract Surg. 2004;30:953–956.
because magnocellular ganglion cells are affected more severely
20. Hess RF, Garner LF. The effect of corneal edema on visual func-
than parvocellular ganglion cells during gravitational stress. Simul- tion. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 1977;16:5–13.
taneously, we observed that differences in CS were unremarkable 21. Cohen AI. The retina and optic nerve. In: Moses RA, ed. Adler’s
high special frequency, perhaps because parvocellular ganglion Physiology of the Eye. St. Louis: CV Mosby; 1981:370 – 410.
cells are affected less severely than magnocellular ganglion cells 22. Vizmanos JG, de la Fuente I, Matesanz BM, Aparicio JA. Influence
during gravitational stress. of surround illumination on pupil size and contrast sensitivity.
In this study, we observed that high-acceleration force in- Ophthalmic Physiol Opt. 2004;24:464 – 468.
duces noteworthy ocular anterior segment reactions and com- 23. Woodhouse JM. The effect of pupil size on grating detection at
promises visual performance. There observations may assist various contrast levels. Vision Res. 1975 Jun.;15(6):645– 648.
individuals on flight or space missions in preparing for such 24. Ossard G, Cle’re JM, Kerguelen M, et al. Response of human cerebral
visual phenomenon. However, these phenomena have not flow to Gz acceleration. J Appl Physiol. 1994;76:2114 –2118.
been studied thoroughly to date. Moreover, the effect of grav- 25. Chou PI, Wen TS, Horng CT, Liu CC. Pulsatile ocular blood flow
itational stress on neuroretinal structure and function, such as after Gz acceleration (abstract). Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2002;
retinal thickness and cone cell function, has not been com- 30(suppl):A404.
pletely clarified. Further research is necessary. 26. Arend O, Wolf S, Harris A, Reim M. The relationship of macular
microcirculation to visual acuity in diabetic patients. Arch Oph-
References thalmol. 1995;113:610 – 614.
27. Kappel PJ, Monnet D, Yu F, Brezin AP, Levinson RD, Holland GN.
1. Rickards CA, Newman DG. G-induced visual and cognitive distur- Contrast sensitivity among patients with birdshot chorioretinopa-
bances in a survey of 65 operational fighter pilots. Aviat Space thy. Am J Ophthalmol. 2009;147:351–356.
Environ Med. 2005;76:496 –500. 28. DiLeo MAS, Falsini B, Caputo S, Ghirlanda G, Porciatti V, Greco AV.
2. Chou PI, Wen TS, Wu YC, Horng CT, Liu CC. Contrast sensitivity Spatial frequency-selective losses with pattern electroretinogram
after Gz acceleration. Aviat Space Environ Med. 2003;74:1048 – type I (insulin-dependent) diabetic patients without retinopathy.
1051. Diabetologia. 1990;33:726 –730.
3. Cheung B, Hofer K. Acceleration effects on pupil size with control 29. Solomon SG, Peirce JW, Dhruv NT, Lennie P. Profound contrast
of mental and environmental factors. Aviat Space Environ Med. adaptation early in the visual pathway. Neuron. 2004;42:155–162.
2003;74:669 – 674. 30. Harris A, Arend O, Danis RP, Evans D, Wolf S, Martin BJ. Hyperoxia
4. Daumann FJ, Draeger J. Aviation and space flight ophthalmology improves contrast sensitivity in early diabetic retinopathy. Br J
(in German). Ophthalmologe. 1993;90:380 –386. Ophthalmol. 1996;80:209 –213.