علي حرب - ثورات القوة الناعمة

udb JLU QJsJ~J~~~
Arab Scientific Publishers, incv

J~UG ~GLJ&W! ~~IJI~I
Arab Scientific Publishers, 1nc.u~

J.r.U: Ijgpiilipglnll &~ljlla ll
Arab Scientific Publishers, 1nc.s~~

dplj JL&J2I 'ali L jyl 3,~c-p 'awl; si &
,
L~G~,+J >)I +- $ 'J+I >b $ &+I 21 ;+&I
R & j igiWl+l~ &kJJ Wk.4' wl
&LJLJ &IJ$ id1 al+Jy+Y1 irk p, JJSll -
+j +.ia- +.L. J ug' &!Pi&3&% I3
&ljLJk ;_~b~6;o 69ri p), '&Lo$& GI jy-3 'b3l&&
. . . +,UI

&p6 ;))"J Lr,r-cijl Y LI, .&pd lJ$ elj! j; tk]&
JU jis lib .dp J& 2 j +fi i>-LLi. alj; PI jl & .((&>
"3'i" &+ +
'jl &Uy '4L& - pu &$I aL+dC, '+&+ *4
.0;1;;j -+ r+* IrS 9% '4j J& IrS +Y& j3 bIJ1
2-,2lhr;l* CL&d~l I~L-~f- -Qj. "Ij91 A h-L .3 A
j. &bj& j41~ '4" jr '+I ++I C+ 'dl& .&+I>

, i&.L .I C I-,i A*JI + &I Y di ~-.wI
.+UI rki JWI ?IJ sk + By ELI Y .+L - @
+La . " bd
6 j&YI b3i j + ,i +kg LJp 2134 241 jy yJi
&&I ik-Y kj4I jy 'LC !bJ+ 29 p &dl Lc;j
.f+ y, 2-2 v; A 6- 6"'
>& 6-1 4b9$ 3 >- &*JL Isg
&-$ ci&l >-LL S Lki .&+I1 oL+dl+-
",I.++ @I 1ju1 &I 91+ -LL S , i'ULZ+; bi
'+&dl L~P ELI i>lEl (51 'd ~.JL + kjy JS jp
.UP,r .i& &s~, i c;+Jl +i+rlj , i+&I CA
41

p-gu~2t-23i3 + MI j +k; +
pYIj .+j +IJ+ '+-j + '+Wb .pIJI 4
';+ k,, LLL+ ,I i- C.JK ';++ J + & + 4
Jly& iipdl, +I, &JI >ELI jp+ &.ill #I -4 j.
-- L $1 ilk 'Ul; s*; 641 0j_6: lip 'PJWI
,i k~;.,* a+ - '$5 @I j. JL .L
+Jl j. ALL j GUY1 +- j dYl d- p . lib F 'L,+
48

$1 k -J34! iJ&j 0- L GE 3
d~TG,Y I 'LJL &t.~, I ZL OI,L-: ~-C-.L i
cL-@. 13 +Ig +>I iJ$l gxJl lib kS 'SLJI Ls
.&A iJ$! w3
3 kJk6 - 2 k.. .- w' iJ>JI. i~U21 63 L
Jul> ye 6 L-L .4VI -J~.~JY +J!$lS +&dl +.A. .
.IJj; .*C~JI$ 31k ,, 'SZ~JI6 i>*~CIJJI +WIj SZIJI
JL ,i (cgL sli ~j ikik U- U&i Y ipL ~GUI
Y 4,; ++ -LL i+ ,i dlkkol h Lgl+- Y, 'h
+jL ,i & k.6 >I ciu~ a&- L +i A IJ, .+
L ,l;r: +'A igP <JI. 01;L~ I,; L~.&II >ji+ K ,I J
.is+ &a L ,3;i i>3-i;O9 'L+ &a
70

I 9 *
LkL '>& JS j 'pj-i - 41 (E spI&r,it) + o~ 2
Gu! djE # >dl JF dE3 .bm 2 && &
dlh @-J .j?+l jpll j ((~~$1i >li) L &-'( 2010)
dL -+ bJ'j Jn ig;S ((&$I as!))j r
'dF~olh I dL2 >JS +lJY &k && dl-6 'as!
.>lp3+ Jbi
4@-2 -n LL+ ';>- ~J-IJI ji uw
~h$> .-I~I ++J ! bA+i &i >Li OI+~i
iJdl JLJI)) jg p3 LU 991 +I +id --&I
?+I& > .rb2J + ji & iJdI L J+'a y- ji
+Y -3 jfi @ 2 b-++> dp jr JLJI Jl>k
.&I! j ((Jpli )JL)J I ji &i' d+ 4il1
alJ~el3 7 ~~1~ '-b dill L! -+Lb j3
9
+i @ +i ji $ LL++~ Li~Y/+I>~ J
,;r> ~LI~ ;uj :&WI 2 LD .il+r- j +I
&Z JS '>j L L+ >%Lc3b b 3 .*>
-L& ds! a!)) J* di 3 Le.5 '&G~JII -4 1 jIyY + F
75

s~ rws~i + - . .- . *~Jir>t&~ I I&,
-2 dl5 &-ill FWIJ .- bj j. I*; *i 'k4ksJ 13 J*,

...+& lj '+jlj 'j&jYI +jL:& I jLLill ii
# &L'196 9 ?LG$ -dl pI;J&c bl ++ U%4 d jLiJ t.
+s Jk j db '1952 rU +&I dn Cyb c-+
.k;;llJ &YI j,.. . A; j jJUl ~~Ldl
al>pJ13 alJUlj s LZLL' i+.. .s U jIdI e I&>
+ .kS 'L9*!I> +J>+YI al>$I js bbl;J I
L..A . I i...u.. lL .. S. ~I +~W:dIJ>& &i &UI A; &
.&I I;Sl;L;Yl
Jr p 'awlJ aIJWI ah L.& 6 jldl4Lj L yUJ
Zj>L.PIj ?%YI >GIJ UIPY I PJ &I+!! &k9 aLGI
10 all ~kj91 j T CS_~di &%I jpylJ ...~L~JI
~-u+1,$I >aL JJ1 p ' d l 0 43L &I &yJ -? 4&
.+>$I a11&+1> +>$I
&dl e A-ui j Igg uj;UJ- ;Jl+ j 10 lhg
L~:~~~;>;Y~L~'~SGY>+~>J-?~~'~--. . .+ a>+-
.i'>UI> -1 & 'ZjUI LJUYIJ &-rill &IS Uj
~ggJ L.Y L &>k.J~i L~JjIT > jldti
61~jki, Y LY ++I ~SLGIk J!+ .. L
w-apJ~J L S +S >r" +A '&ij~ - a~>I d~+lj k
I;Y ?%YI $L> +I + kc&! Y I;!)) A; j .,G '41> J
O>I+I t. 4>~L~i;;YU I;ZYI &iJ 'L+I, ,* cxk; + .
41p a4- YI +E ~Y~I+!AI >'il J*14 +J
85

'owJ)+ + a+ ai a ~b+s) C;~JI LS I~WjK l ib
1-ai & p41.JL I 6p ~i+2 +L a+ ai Q
5 193 ;- 31~ gliy JF- ji CSIJI + + &.ill ;ell j. c+: + AJ' WWI i.. U.. I+I
4
>UlG UI+ J)LrU% & aLG1 sLT '~jl
GUI >'1- v&d!J) +Ul +-dl '+YI e~JJ!>y)l
.+UWI +;3I L-. UI
101

dl CJdI jj .>;-;pll JWI AS ~GJLL ~G3-~ +IiJ J
ijL->JI> (+#I) &l&Lakll a a- 9+i 3y -b ~2
+GI, ~UaI,;I lA>& *, Y! q;C- s+; yJ (h?jYl)
&1+..*11 isJ+ '9 J! &I +.LJI~
&> rWI uUl JL +U a>> Jb 2 6 jdI+I J
hk&I>, J.5 JS 'eZ"*- 31 ,*-rl, UJI +>+I
... j ....& >UI j k-9 >ui &~j Ji
'+Sr &p &,& di big e-+ !Ip -31 oLJA
31 +ii 3 &I j +y k~ +YI~ ,dlg asdl
9 j.. c.&. UI &.. I 4lc4G9 oh
&+I> &l;-;pll LO .+dl +w1 ;~Yg(,LnjlI> +LJl altjkdl

~I+JI; ++MI 9% i2b 31 (g4- &+-
jL+l 3 a w l rG J jLb~Y1jl+ l qJI cLL- rl..j U ij
X+I LUI, iuWl ~IGUII ,& >i &>
+ 3 d+ (4 3 &&-MI e-&I +&I albJl>
3--' jl a+yd e-& .*iz > .icg;49> +GI> @S-ik;
IgJ-Ls; a'-jll j.. d.. ldA la 1b. .LBjb>jl> I LibJ- &jLe;>
.&I +Wl j iJLY13 41 y j ;>k>l JJ> I+> +I31
'+WI &+> ~6;1,9 .I,> U~.IJJI&-- ji ~i
awljp ; i41L aw 31 a++ &-+ Ui Jk
'$9 -4 2 $6- ~JY&JL l% jaJjl1 ib>>* gi>
dl r li. .ecM13 rlyJIJ HroJIJ 491 +>y UJ
#
(+-" +JY 'Y K.5 L!> &$i8 + I2-. rlyJl +>y
.&?Y-J1> +I ij;.2 &W>
'3>Yl +,*IL 'sL +*I1 jrgJ 41 irL)!l jjj L;s 3
djdl + jJ)r++- dl lc-gl 'Lp j+I+> +--ill p
'Lb..,). !I +Us&# I pIJL ly-l;llJ h1413A jL;IIJ
2 $ ;>wl j>> Js- &h-> +Id1 tJ$->>I - &I
-69
11 0

is$, 'W J~CCI S IPS ijjJl+ >IC ji Y b

'+li &! -I J+- ji 4 YL ... ~LJ.I;I cikki
_jL j JWI 2 Ohg T+Lb J! +&I +lrg '3% J! -1,
.QL&Z!l, @Lc2! + p .~Ul

al&+Y a
&IJ bJLI (~L.- 4& ~~dI~Ijka~~CU;s
&dl -n 04 y J44 bjYI v;lI .A LAW .*zjYI
&- 3i 41 +- di .& u + &+-
I+ .A; j ski Y3 .+LY I3 %&I+ +-318 &&A c-L
&I elk,- 'J LL; Y 'oS-3 46 G J$ &I Jg bL 4p
&& Ls 'us' Ac~ bj+ - li4 .&%YI +Wl cby
vjrp LjZ! -3 Lgikrj o& i3WI &$ &jk; Jl PWI
!+ Lk-. 31
&-! %jl+Jl aY+l $3 6j.j L '&I ijrp J.d
&3WlJ &>I ejll iJ+I Jji 'eliJ1 J-- j hJ*rl
,+& 6% j L+ j 2131 LJILJI &IJ 6 j3Y 23 Js ;i .$dl
k;k;3 ~Y&I& &JA & c;b J! i&J! & 053
.& IJI~ L &&I ji j. @k 'w3
Jj ""I ~uJ1Ih j . dlk -2 I;!'&jljl &kd
&3J cly'& IS 3UI93 l+Yl 3Jq! &dl Ulg
.~I,UI c$ 4-+ pl .&I j. L A,I3-i-L UI 3I~ SWI
.i++ijl Z J! cis; i+l?JI aIjJ;JU

$> .+Lj>, p k 2j Y d19Ui. 'zip J>> 'b j.
J+Yl> +b$I> ;>MI Jw dljl 9 +,w dlJ$! & L +i
lib JS JJy >I dQl ;plL ,+I &y ui aY 'dLUI 'y
*& 'Li JSL: &I. . rWl jd i L+ LJ'+ Jl3 ;jl
I
alyWI 2 dli>+!I >+ Y 6 J~;IyU il dlI L++ j
+>& y>> >+ 'Lgl *l2all +dl alyWl, L',.lzN zr~_Jdl
2 ILL TJJ> +J ~GWI+ &I OI~WI ek]& .ipJ~
L.b 2 '&pl> ;yUi. 2 pj gp Ab &> .UYl L+
c-;.2 >I +>+I JA,$L 31 J4.j' >+ ;i&L .L&>
j. J-L >* 23' r &I> dIIJI> ;,LAY> +&I dJUJS
Awl> dl&> dbJYI .. . s+! & .&L> il.L.4 dl+ p >I>
ihpll &+I Jr@I> ?dl @IJ dJWl +Idyl 23 '+ j.
.&pl+ j. jjCCIl>
+IJIJL .j we ldl jk. k e-Y d ;,l +ljlL ! LWId l
rJJb L. +lAi!l ,k aK I;!> .;>+I> 4LJl zyu pYl +Jl 8
+-@I i;lp UlaQ ~Y+JIl d b '+L;II aL; *.JI> -@I 9
blJl -- di :+IAi!I ;u libJ, .4,L >I dl; JS JZL +J!>
.dllrl >I u- >I +,L >I JZL 6-j 3-1 3 4
'WI >&i JP>I LJAI lib h*,&~I L,,-~/I~
>I & >I, Ibj. 'UI I;&b ;pliJI> i;L;1I> ilU&'b y
JJ b j. .iJW1> I iYI> I $,; IJJG &+of! dJ&irJ JIG
JSa h*I - +S >I UI,$I L a&
.b+~&-> i b+ki
149

& Ld '&I LA, & 'LdL;JI ;>w ;,.d & >I GZJI
.++ 441 A+ >I $1 +,o
;>A q@ jY .LAl+Jl +@I $1 Y 3d~
o+ 3Gi + & L~LXYI+I~ & L- 439 G+-
*Y I >ri+ 3 >Li+ -ILP~ L ‘~YWI ,JLZI . j
...+ I&> ju jT 6 JWj
I ru1 '&$I &I 3 J& 'bljl L.. . dl a>$-K
* I
&l S3Ul j '3*z;~ &j? Lk-1 b '2@13
-'++&I3 &uI o*w y-43 jp.3 2 9 ++
dlr e~ a~~JiK -J+YI dl,+! ji &i Y
>A+ ~~d>&I lja lJL Ld iwir & &I LgUj
GjL aL.. ;k. & L >lh3 'a3In Jl dp- L
'&>&jl pLiJ,p 3&I3 j, '(WL y; & plu+- &G
6
L-Z. Jlab+l (y -* -&93 31 'd~1@3P >3 1
9
,u+l i! 'LpLe ;U ,J>1 +-+ ir _;, Ls L2 ;*?&I
6
>+ '+LJ j +&I L.- o+- 21 '-1 2 -i
F F U.. I . .. . :&-&I 2 L iFi 3 ,I2 L j, F-L
...J.. +I rW13 +-A! +U '>$I 3+Y13
dd +.ill jyi '&pii3 '4,~sLi ;L b ,
pli~.l"i-& I L+ 3 jriJI & -.4. . 1~ I>+I ji
+ pl i! 6cJ~32~1~3+1E ~k;!. &i crl; Jpi i>~ei~
y~+ 9
'3 '&- plJ &I j, '9 5'13L YI '3 jLk;> A b
$Loell +Ls + 6 J3L+Jl3k-sYI y j.. rJe..i WIJ
152

...& .. >.. L&3 b0JjJ3 J &dLJ k,
j. I&=L p , j JS 'L.*JI ~41 +.-.s+ 'ILLJ
&+JJ " -LO p &Ir JS, .L+! ri 6 i-;~i ',+I
jk~ iJilJ .b+ j ~3 +p b,+
ihiJL klp d d&" 4;'~ lhS j.d bJc ,rvj & 2
.a ,I ,b &I dL ';I,uI, +&I, OILJ1,
rlJl ,p *; p' iru ,~dL,Oi .&k ~JUI -31 - 3
,p *; p] +ljy..*ll di ks j3YI Jl &YI ,*d a, jJ
.dl+ pi $ dfl L~.Y 6 LA &I
rlA 31 yj+Yl j?3b LG Y irUl d! 'p7 C%+
L $I+ L/, LLfJ 4 Lb .ruI dlJljJ ul;rYI
J+Jl >.. &b.. y! AIAIk Cp,d IdJj.b +
~'UI j& dlJ jklIb WI+ p L ,L'+aLc UIS
.aL+j+Ij dblkll A -k j.
a!-+ +-, & + C% 9 $,L A& &I+Y~ +i
& c4;k. cdLlknh 2 A+ 21, j irl j p L ,L+ ~~"241 .... j& dpi LA t&+, &I,L+ 3~ 'i~kjl
-- 's
j. c+ %I 9 219 A! L,~YI ',GI &L,
.&w! & 1 ,&I+ & ~Ljlpj L ,A+ '&Li,L,& LUI
r' I*" J";" ,pUIAI fllsJL p"j- ?IJ $ 6~4i1c J&ji , uiXj
& 22 JUYI j~, ,YI .+WI C;LIL,, -WI C;L&
&+YL .awl, SIJAYI jr a ~Y*UI +.. ,i 'b~i
.jJQ13~ JIJ~~WI ~Q4I 91& JAIp 155

, idl,+! ,I.baYiJc~l sL LI, JL& - ji..
.4jC C;;K 31 >+ (jl ,roY~ L;>L &+ -5 ,i LL LS
i>YJ y. j, ulni UY p~JSLd~ jLT+++p$G;b:
+- >L ... OJf9J 4S7ildfr b&+ ALl
bil&IJ, UIJ, bJ'llJ +>LYI ~9jl3y ; r. -)pdL!
I,&,11;11+, WI ;r. --Ob ,- L JS +i
.uI&I, Awl
/+ b'k + uiL ji +-LJI 691e -ji k '11j
LLI :dbJ p IL, .4-OIJUl9 ;L11d19 +l>gP?*II kL&
ssL-dl u p& &-L .. .p a- irk I>,j
&, . . .&I, 4.... 1 ,91 3 >u1, ~Ckoil,
156

>I +-b i j 6Y- b&fi +-.& b I&>
UCL~ .% $ ii% &Li j- 2.. a>*% ~5%c zl> L +-LY
-I~> &L+ L+LG zJ* +- $ J.& ~i &- ~i
,
2 PIi;--;-0 Ap 6iolJSa aliL Ij LYli k -IS 1i19 .oJUl
CZUI e-$1 UIJL Y- L b$>>jYI> >l~jY& UYI
. ..Qij> Lplj+l >I be aU &
+&I & Lg.rb JeS iiJl &dl klprl L.41 b j. " $ e- # 6241 &,-dl> >w! # dbG> dlJ+
F F $9o yL >I i-L;ic 4,. L. -% L LIG 6- c;i ii%
. . Eip; >I hi o w -
$ .d~jiG>~;,I +9 1@L, +-L A LWIJ L+ .L>
&j-dI pLJ@ I EiL3ic lgl .+iI+ ijl >I + JS
1g4&->~ +S ai lgl6 L~~;JI,G YI 3 .&LA ~I>>I>
~ibl@>I JS >I c$l JS kJA dl &&IJ A&l j
WI ,b LLI .. 2.. 1,G YL . ui.x. i .~SI;P i3>1 J+
..19 .--J>A

-ji >IJ 11' ~b&i- L IL .b+ljj - &I &+I LJI
e-_~s; j. GflJ, 1- &I :+A1 j Cdlv. L. I
+bJ2 j. L..L jr +,+dl 4k !&I 0~;yc jl4JY18
'+WLJ, 414 ds +j ;>bI !&IFJ jI 4s;; LG& jI GpY
b j& 'bjJrkrj @C1 &jW a,,&Ja w3 &-& -J r; &
t
$ iS-lUj ,L+YIJ, ;,'>+l,JI j bey&> WJ @%I &
. jUI ~9
LJL j- 41&Li LJS 'ds~Li IL 'q!J L~+j i $j
jj+I ;jI>! j ZL+ JI >yeei+ l zw .L$jjI
$1 a14j1. ;> UYI ji ,#I & z~'a~~f6g~~ W I~
LSI+I~ L$I~ >&I 3. ,. ii~YJ~ iL ~_J~0;Y-1I
JG .j~;WI~ i;jl ?I *;~I j~IL SYI~ ~;krjklz~ + j i
.i;.t+ - jl "'p; LkJlj rSlj- p+
*i +Wl j &,WI cJUI C I S lij '&WI jJ
+JI j y- kS IjKiYI j JkJb 'a;; sl ihk;i
'+Wl ~l~r+Jy.+lYI j ij+Ilj r&;;JI &>LYIj '+MI
6yj 'al,+Jl j. J&l jyJls ialUl y WAI ;bLdIj
'LqJlj +I &I ;JI +Ad1 C($JIj L+Jl jKiYl 'y CijJ'
.&lj F~d$jj~ij
6,LsiYI &-&I $ -WI eiU &u& j 'csii b 3
dl3++ j,+- ji dp! '~,L~JI +L&YI,
'jWI &+Is 'elJ jldIj r~d+I3l 'Xl;JIj GlpYl
...?I JI jjQIj C*QI G$lj
1 64

.c>L;JI $ J,YL +I , J,I c;L &Id1
$-..dl &I. &ul #I di *, 6 dl-1 j JWI U&

@ @ @ @ , IkbJ ri Ih*. J1 ;kJ . IL. L I ,~b-I & '/PIJ
..&AA ?I
ubJYI9 >l*;YI >I IL~YI~ ,%YI ~glL iyC; j+ &libJ
I&UI aqp,~Y+ 3 ply ~~j&dl+ - L IL .uljJlg
&J d~p L+ di *L+ !:IL~~JILJ>
~alj&YI, a&-&Jl +b IJ1 pt;. di IG~IU4I 44 e-dp
YL .+WI iGbj i 5'jUld~J 9 db >IJ !:l
..L. . dIJ +UI &dl 3WpPY1 + 3 G'I+9
I.J,$J,~I :J,, id>^^ fi (JWI ;,I>I a~+~ 4
ohJ .&I3 4 L+-J &j j &wI 4 &- b1JL .... +iSp
9 L JG +y 9 GJs 4 y-.JlIpL- U;" 641 JL
&I JJ I& 9 L j~JL+J 1279 L J+t jLaJ i&I;il
--Jk*9 9 ~4

i>L @ kS '~SGjL5 1i1 &UI -I;, j I, 'rWI L9-3
YI~~, ~JT 4GI>, ak,JJi -> ,2~
"I-. j pg-Lz; $, L.~... %i bL vi lir&- +
9 j. '+-dl ,l'+Jl *-9 u -- +LA+¶ +-,
.A- ,I cbJl
'29WI 21 j, +-dl &I2 y &k 4' 'L A-9
*; $JI ij$I + 'UIi b ~''j+= -dlff j!, &
@ OL ai &I, .,IS~YI, JPJI Y, ,ab,ill, J,~I -,
Fklr aqpi >I igi+-, hJL: $.9 + '"i,~l+Y" iiS; Jb
+ F-rr> ;?Y d .+> ui I,LS; I,
.;si Y WI, 9 dp ilp ,I
+-dl uw 3.k- .+I dj5~; &&YI ~i
j. ~9 .ak+d14&3 LYI cKPY -4% t3+.+A
+l;zYI, abWl 692& loi 'P+ ++I 54&&
.+%Yl awl,

*+a *w
~ydibiirKell~:jdl~1;*ell~ii~l+~(3)
+*ell Lljdl irlJL& 'L-.A ! alJ$I LYLI + ils li +%YI
YE jp9 k~ '"GLYI iljd~i"L > 3 I+ ji + '+3*il1
i!d h-@ .>bdl JGI J -41 41 +2p j
.+I i;4 &Ad &%YI ~-9jys j yp2
ji+ .GYY>~- +~~4r42k~jj cj~J ~~Jji +lpllj GKzll> &I dl ds+- 2 cj Y jkil el
&.ill &*ail Cisu -Y .j,;lpllJ jLbj Yl J JjdI ;p
3% jA @ pW1 .AL"3 J .G3~ + +I 641+ -
UI?~-J3 +Y! c>kJ Y kS k+ki Jy!jY! ~a 37
i+ Jl i;-djiJj kil &I ;bjj +, IcjKF
.+i i*I 21 JjdI Aye9 irk+,Jl
4
I li ciM,- &dl &I& >+I1 9 jkil tcizre/l 3J 3
2" J3 29 y-illj L~L~;&YI I~ j &&I G-YI

,i +dl C~~ dg3 Y LL. ;r.
>dl-L " L+Y +lj,"dl++ p L+l12JC) .kJW &by1
LdIjL .L - AI,~I, 91 b+ dY +lktll *b 2 -1~31~
&" 641, 'am!9 d9UI kY y 4,k"
t' W"Y GWI, L~?+~I;k ," ~ "4S Ii,S ij~
CAI ;r JJ &I L,I'~~31;*JL, . k.j j 45' ~Llyil
41 jt? &I &= a- &Y iljUI !+ r&YIJ '4
.iJl*jl , iG~WYI,J I &LI& = Y '4,1i JLJI +i &=
/dl 'dl 4" r 9 ij! 'G-b dJ> a9taXII $- Y ,W&
a 1 Y d+Lb *r
+ljed13 C%yl jt? awl d'~ 'b
@I2 L& .&%YI +I?VI &,L; L &= LL'I~>Ii
iwl 4 *lJ>y '&+> ikX; '&-yl &$I
.GI, ~dLLi; PL; ,*O ,LI~
Y 'dL)'l s+ rjsd 21 dl Gl>y-dl d3db
(eil r 4, Li; L ,A+ '++I &&I, &&dl yeJl y ck~k
a4;ikll 4- &1sjJ '121~&1i jls 1231+ &I, ~J'YI
541i -;, y 4,Li; pLjt U.. . l& +s y 4,k L
QLL'L .. . j& A ai +I jF-*ll d,*u Y I& .j41jw J

..&I 2% Jl+ A!+ j pgU ++Id 3 .A+ L iagi
U. C. p 'A~vI3 ;>$ I 3 di +WIa h3 &+I3
$ *@I dJj% +~ p~$3 ~j Jj.i 32 YLL;~
.>uI, >*l.;yr ai JL j +I i~r'+ kk ijwlj ~I+I
~J~JIt*b" 3yI i;d~i + LAY! il4143~1C; LS &-
.bL> I A-$ '&;$I~ JS-WI~G C g'.ll3 &&I
~JPC j. t4QJ ti IdJ ,bi,I3 +I irj j. &i CIS &+ti
c+-3 'dyJI3 dl>L- A-$ iJl$ Jl cG &IS &LJl
.*I &I> +-3 i+l &jIY & t>l+l >I i>>b
cJb 1j1 d+ti i++ ~jj :&A d+.~
i,bLi IJJp- L ,A+ '&dl3 +JAl 'iSWI aL+!13
I*+- ,.J> L+WI dlJI d+- Y +bi3 d3Y1
b elg-, '&UI uI~YI j I$+- ,.J3 +sWI dJldl 3
>ti[ JI d+- .i+U1S3Id l> I +-dl3 GI$!
.* 9 & +tJI i)Y+lg otilk.;Ylg dl>$! j. a>ljl

$ jvl j+- 'Kyl 3 I, kJJJ3I ely '&dPl JWl j! +
,>L di &is! YJ ... JJdl &%! yJdI ijl '&dl ijl '&j!
LUi > 3 .cWL; & jr ~LpG k j &LAG ~IlyIp
.I~YI & +& c~ 21 ui ZL; F-
.a*d, alyiJ eb~;;u, awl

&.in &+I -I ci+ *;, di js b .JLI>I +I,
"I, z+JI j,J2 &, 'Cp^" $La & @g '+lh AG
.GLYI, dlA13
oJLib3jl /jL- &jJl jg---ipjl L)jL;JI b ;ro
,LA sJ 29 rblr 31 iJL 29 6 jI 31 L,oL 2 JLZY4
.eGjl & +I /UI, (manstreet)
ip! ji :c+ .L, .4hz IL t+y CI*a-i1 4 @L
jY-,+I JW-ji J -?;;i, .LUL +Z LL~, .A,
j. 1,3~i L '&*-JI ,,+.I.jl.i~~,+Y I d
--L+ 'J+YI
.Law-, & 21 +MI bJ+CJI

Lgr&9 Lgik~y EJW I, 4-1 31. ~j 5ii '~giiilkib
31 +&, ,I !I*+-'$1 31 A~LYI .~u i.&YI G>*IL
31 d+kWI, 'Zldl asL.c &I d41dlg tib3l i+L
dl >I+YI +Log ti19UlS JIdI &I dg?JL-3Jlg ckt;Wlj
.iyW1 +dl 8 &-, .+&Ig
s3+i y~$.++I +>I + & .+I> Y ,
&2-* . Y &- dl '@I, 33lpilj +L +; r. Li:
j-& JW JA 'IpL dl+! I,#L, 3uLG A 'LgSLe;l
di 4 +-& dl yY I 'ojk~ljd p '+nLJI dLYI 4slj
ijljYl dl) + iuilrS; 'JW iWk ii+ 21 dlUl
# jlb;jcc-~L;z.i;~i&~i&J+;=iY~~ j'ilbdi
&l;i; 4 && 9l '042Y 4 31I; >+- 9 'i@I9 &I
.&,lfi, +u1, GjUl jr UbI, LJGI*
F+,l +al jr 'WI3 +* Jr;llj d l jr +-L IL
& Ji + +-9 L & L 2 'irldYIg
#
G ~b '+91 -u +..dl UI~ ...A -- I ,i AI~>YI
oJGI & '+&I9 JFUL' FA! ~ I S 4~;! .d 9YI GJ*IL 3(Ul
I& .a4jY13 glJrJI &dl aUIJ aL+dlg aLal+Jl jr
djF- Y dUl + &- &ill ‘+dl e.. . l3 dl& -&I
&u (;1 dL&YI u ci7; dl d l /d! .dlG Yjd l+
'LdgJl, '&U, o*- JX, 231 31 611 'A+ 'dP
41j1yJI 4_ i4J&4 j+ ....G I+, djj~&Ijj- JXlg
,
.&I J~UI, jjW~& y;ils ~Q.I - @I J~I*~~I,
238

علي حرب - ثورات القوة الناعمة

علي حرب - ثورات القوة الناعمة

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

What's hot

What's hot (18)

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (20)

More from Ali Alaaraj

More from Ali Alaaraj (20)

علي حرب - ثورات القوة الناعمة