SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Grammar is a challenge because the student has been learning about grammar in his first language but
may not know how to apply all of the rules. The student is able to identify the following types of
sentences: Interrogative, Declarative, Imperative, and Exclamatory. However, in Spanish the question
mark is placed in the beginning and the end of a sentence. When the author of this paper wrote, “Did
you grow up in Puerto Rico?”, the student did not realize that it was a question because there was not a
question mark at the beginning and the end of the sentence.



Many students struggle going from L1 to L2 because they do not have a strong foundation in L1. What
can we do to help them improve their grammar skills?



I plan to explore how the nature of Spanish and its relationship to English may impact errors and which
of these errors are developmental. I have observed that many students struggle in the writing process
and it can be difficult for ESL learners to decide which grammar rule to apply at the correct time. For
example irregular verbs can be a difficult topic.

Passive Voice was another component that was difficult for the student. The phrase: The deck was

washed by my brother did not make sense. The student thought that the sentence meant that the deck

washed the brother. The teacher used charades and games to illustrate this point. They also drew a


picture of this sentence on a white board. They examined the picture together and encouraged the
student to describe the sentence in detail. Freeman and Freeman write that, “Students acquire
conversational language fairly rapidly, especially students living in an English speaking environment.
However, developing academic language takes more time” (Freeeman and Freeman,p.247).

More Related Content

What's hot

Souder u11a1
Souder u11a1Souder u11a1
Souder u11a1Amy Lee
 
10 Stages of Language Learning: How to Get Started and Keep Going
10 Stages of Language Learning: How to Get Started and Keep Going10 Stages of Language Learning: How to Get Started and Keep Going
10 Stages of Language Learning: How to Get Started and Keep GoingTransparent Language, Inc.
 
Case Study - English as Second Language (ESL)
Case Study - English as Second Language (ESL)Case Study - English as Second Language (ESL)
Case Study - English as Second Language (ESL)Ajez Ahmad
 
What is the role played by the Native Language in SLA
What is the role played by the Native Language in SLAWhat is the role played by the Native Language in SLA
What is the role played by the Native Language in SLAHitesh Galthariya
 
Pronunciation improvement as a by-product of synthetic phonics instruction
Pronunciation improvement as a by-product of synthetic phonics instructionPronunciation improvement as a by-product of synthetic phonics instruction
Pronunciation improvement as a by-product of synthetic phonics instructionpaulsze
 
Vietnamese phonologicaldisorders kimberly jones
Vietnamese phonologicaldisorders kimberly jonesVietnamese phonologicaldisorders kimberly jones
Vietnamese phonologicaldisorders kimberly joneskmbrlyslp
 
What is progression in language lea
What is progression in language leaWhat is progression in language lea
What is progression in language leaJo Rhys-Jones
 
Grammer Translation Method
Grammer Translation MethodGrammer Translation Method
Grammer Translation Methodniks884
 
Draw Me a Picture - Pronunciation Aids for Visual Learners
Draw Me a Picture - Pronunciation Aids for Visual LearnersDraw Me a Picture - Pronunciation Aids for Visual Learners
Draw Me a Picture - Pronunciation Aids for Visual LearnersJudy Thompson
 
Top 8 Reasons for Poor Performance in English
Top 8 Reasons for Poor Performance in EnglishTop 8 Reasons for Poor Performance in English
Top 8 Reasons for Poor Performance in EnglishMaybe Wanji
 
Stages of second language acquisition
Stages of second language acquisitionStages of second language acquisition
Stages of second language acquisitionAMaashi2000
 
Pronunciation with Colors - Learning 2gether
Pronunciation with Colors - Learning 2gether Pronunciation with Colors - Learning 2gether
Pronunciation with Colors - Learning 2gether Judy Thompson
 
The difference-between-esl-and-efl
The difference-between-esl-and-eflThe difference-between-esl-and-efl
The difference-between-esl-and-efladamalmarzuki
 
HOW TO TEACH VOCABULARY
HOW TO TEACH VOCABULARYHOW TO TEACH VOCABULARY
HOW TO TEACH VOCABULARYFerhat K.
 
Elementary ESL Parent Information 2010-2011
Elementary ESL Parent Information 2010-2011Elementary ESL Parent Information 2010-2011
Elementary ESL Parent Information 2010-2011IST
 

What's hot (20)

Souder u11a1
Souder u11a1Souder u11a1
Souder u11a1
 
How to get rid of mother tongue influence while speaking English.
How to get rid of mother tongue influence while speaking English.How to get rid of mother tongue influence while speaking English.
How to get rid of mother tongue influence while speaking English.
 
10 Stages of Language Learning: How to Get Started and Keep Going
10 Stages of Language Learning: How to Get Started and Keep Going10 Stages of Language Learning: How to Get Started and Keep Going
10 Stages of Language Learning: How to Get Started and Keep Going
 
Case Study - English as Second Language (ESL)
Case Study - English as Second Language (ESL)Case Study - English as Second Language (ESL)
Case Study - English as Second Language (ESL)
 
What is the role played by the Native Language in SLA
What is the role played by the Native Language in SLAWhat is the role played by the Native Language in SLA
What is the role played by the Native Language in SLA
 
Minimizing mother tongue influence in english speaking
Minimizing mother tongue influence in english speakingMinimizing mother tongue influence in english speaking
Minimizing mother tongue influence in english speaking
 
Pronunciation improvement as a by-product of synthetic phonics instruction
Pronunciation improvement as a by-product of synthetic phonics instructionPronunciation improvement as a by-product of synthetic phonics instruction
Pronunciation improvement as a by-product of synthetic phonics instruction
 
Vietnamese phonologicaldisorders kimberly jones
Vietnamese phonologicaldisorders kimberly jonesVietnamese phonologicaldisorders kimberly jones
Vietnamese phonologicaldisorders kimberly jones
 
The difficulties that students face to speak English
The difficulties that students face to speak  EnglishThe difficulties that students face to speak  English
The difficulties that students face to speak English
 
What is progression in language lea
What is progression in language leaWhat is progression in language lea
What is progression in language lea
 
Stages of Second Language Acquisition
Stages of Second Language AcquisitionStages of Second Language Acquisition
Stages of Second Language Acquisition
 
Grammer Translation Method
Grammer Translation MethodGrammer Translation Method
Grammer Translation Method
 
Draw Me a Picture - Pronunciation Aids for Visual Learners
Draw Me a Picture - Pronunciation Aids for Visual LearnersDraw Me a Picture - Pronunciation Aids for Visual Learners
Draw Me a Picture - Pronunciation Aids for Visual Learners
 
Top 8 Reasons for Poor Performance in English
Top 8 Reasons for Poor Performance in EnglishTop 8 Reasons for Poor Performance in English
Top 8 Reasons for Poor Performance in English
 
Stages of second language acquisition
Stages of second language acquisitionStages of second language acquisition
Stages of second language acquisition
 
Pronunciation with Colors - Learning 2gether
Pronunciation with Colors - Learning 2gether Pronunciation with Colors - Learning 2gether
Pronunciation with Colors - Learning 2gether
 
The difference-between-esl-and-efl
The difference-between-esl-and-eflThe difference-between-esl-and-efl
The difference-between-esl-and-efl
 
HOW TO TEACH VOCABULARY
HOW TO TEACH VOCABULARYHOW TO TEACH VOCABULARY
HOW TO TEACH VOCABULARY
 
Language Learner Profile
Language Learner ProfileLanguage Learner Profile
Language Learner Profile
 
Elementary ESL Parent Information 2010-2011
Elementary ESL Parent Information 2010-2011Elementary ESL Parent Information 2010-2011
Elementary ESL Parent Information 2010-2011
 

Similar to Slide share 2

Academic language for Secondary
Academic language for SecondaryAcademic language for Secondary
Academic language for SecondaryJill A. Aguilar
 
Language Learner Profile
Language Learner ProfileLanguage Learner Profile
Language Learner ProfileAngy Lagos
 
Grammar translation method
Grammar translation methodGrammar translation method
Grammar translation methodotokonoko
 
Writing when english is not my first language viola gjylbegaj
Writing when english is not my first language viola gjylbegajWriting when english is not my first language viola gjylbegaj
Writing when english is not my first language viola gjylbegajViola Gjylbegaj
 
Contrastive-Analysis.pptx
Contrastive-Analysis.pptxContrastive-Analysis.pptx
Contrastive-Analysis.pptxsaberbouzara
 
Chapter 2 second language learning
Chapter 2   second language learningChapter 2   second language learning
Chapter 2 second language learningTshen Tashi
 
Engaging Your BeginnersHill.indd 18 123015 718 PM.docx
Engaging  Your BeginnersHill.indd   18 123015   718 PM.docxEngaging  Your BeginnersHill.indd   18 123015   718 PM.docx
Engaging Your BeginnersHill.indd 18 123015 718 PM.docxkhanpaulita
 
Scott kuntzeira may12012translatingasatechniqueduringguidedreading
Scott kuntzeira may12012translatingasatechniqueduringguidedreadingScott kuntzeira may12012translatingasatechniqueduringguidedreading
Scott kuntzeira may12012translatingasatechniqueduringguidedreadingSharon Pajka
 
Lesson plan 4 Secondary Level
Lesson plan 4  Secondary LevelLesson plan 4  Secondary Level
Lesson plan 4 Secondary LevelEmili López
 
Challenges in teaching prepositions in a language classroom
Challenges in teaching prepositions in a language classroomChallenges in teaching prepositions in a language classroom
Challenges in teaching prepositions in a language classroomAlexander Decker
 
Grammar-translation method-Reflection
Grammar-translation method-ReflectionGrammar-translation method-Reflection
Grammar-translation method-ReflectionFiona Lee
 
ELT Project Presentation
ELT Project PresentationELT Project Presentation
ELT Project PresentationRanjanvelari
 
Language Learner Profile
Language Learner ProfileLanguage Learner Profile
Language Learner Profilefpereaonate
 
Data Analysis and Language Comparison
Data Analysis and Language ComparisonData Analysis and Language Comparison
Data Analysis and Language Comparisonsummerjs
 

Similar to Slide share 2 (20)

Academic language for Secondary
Academic language for SecondaryAcademic language for Secondary
Academic language for Secondary
 
Language Learner Profile
Language Learner ProfileLanguage Learner Profile
Language Learner Profile
 
Academic language
Academic languageAcademic language
Academic language
 
Grammar translation method
Grammar translation methodGrammar translation method
Grammar translation method
 
My autobiography
My autobiographyMy autobiography
My autobiography
 
gggg
gggggggg
gggg
 
Writing when english is not my first language viola gjylbegaj
Writing when english is not my first language viola gjylbegajWriting when english is not my first language viola gjylbegaj
Writing when english is not my first language viola gjylbegaj
 
CHAPTER 2.pdf
CHAPTER 2.pdfCHAPTER 2.pdf
CHAPTER 2.pdf
 
Contrastive-Analysis.pptx
Contrastive-Analysis.pptxContrastive-Analysis.pptx
Contrastive-Analysis.pptx
 
Chapter 2 second language learning
Chapter 2   second language learningChapter 2   second language learning
Chapter 2 second language learning
 
Learner language ppt
Learner language pptLearner language ppt
Learner language ppt
 
Engaging Your BeginnersHill.indd 18 123015 718 PM.docx
Engaging  Your BeginnersHill.indd   18 123015   718 PM.docxEngaging  Your BeginnersHill.indd   18 123015   718 PM.docx
Engaging Your BeginnersHill.indd 18 123015 718 PM.docx
 
Scott kuntzeira may12012translatingasatechniqueduringguidedreading
Scott kuntzeira may12012translatingasatechniqueduringguidedreadingScott kuntzeira may12012translatingasatechniqueduringguidedreading
Scott kuntzeira may12012translatingasatechniqueduringguidedreading
 
Lesson plan 4 Secondary Level
Lesson plan 4  Secondary LevelLesson plan 4  Secondary Level
Lesson plan 4 Secondary Level
 
Challenges in teaching prepositions in a language classroom
Challenges in teaching prepositions in a language classroomChallenges in teaching prepositions in a language classroom
Challenges in teaching prepositions in a language classroom
 
Grammar-translation method-Reflection
Grammar-translation method-ReflectionGrammar-translation method-Reflection
Grammar-translation method-Reflection
 
ELT Project Presentation
ELT Project PresentationELT Project Presentation
ELT Project Presentation
 
Language Learner Profile
Language Learner ProfileLanguage Learner Profile
Language Learner Profile
 
Data Analysis and Language Comparison
Data Analysis and Language ComparisonData Analysis and Language Comparison
Data Analysis and Language Comparison
 
Lesson analysis
Lesson analysis Lesson analysis
Lesson analysis
 

Slide share 2

  • 1. Grammar is a challenge because the student has been learning about grammar in his first language but may not know how to apply all of the rules. The student is able to identify the following types of sentences: Interrogative, Declarative, Imperative, and Exclamatory. However, in Spanish the question mark is placed in the beginning and the end of a sentence. When the author of this paper wrote, “Did you grow up in Puerto Rico?”, the student did not realize that it was a question because there was not a question mark at the beginning and the end of the sentence. Many students struggle going from L1 to L2 because they do not have a strong foundation in L1. What can we do to help them improve their grammar skills? I plan to explore how the nature of Spanish and its relationship to English may impact errors and which of these errors are developmental. I have observed that many students struggle in the writing process and it can be difficult for ESL learners to decide which grammar rule to apply at the correct time. For example irregular verbs can be a difficult topic. Passive Voice was another component that was difficult for the student. The phrase: The deck was washed by my brother did not make sense. The student thought that the sentence meant that the deck washed the brother. The teacher used charades and games to illustrate this point. They also drew a picture of this sentence on a white board. They examined the picture together and encouraged the student to describe the sentence in detail. Freeman and Freeman write that, “Students acquire conversational language fairly rapidly, especially students living in an English speaking environment. However, developing academic language takes more time” (Freeeman and Freeman,p.247).