DAVID
REIMER
(The ‘John/Joan’
Case)
A CASE STUDY.
DAVID REIMER (1965 – 2004)
▪ born as Bruce Reimer, twin brother of Brain
Reimer, to parents; to Janet and Ronald
Reimer
▪ When 8 months old- unsuccessful
circumcision- resulting in a burnt off penis
▪ Turned to advise of Dr. John Money, John
Hopkins University, specializing in gender
identity
DAVID REIMER
▪ Dr. Money suggested sex change
operation
▪ Vulva construction and hormone
supplements were given
▪ Asked them to raise him as a female
▪ BRUCE REIMER BRENDA REIMER
JOHN MONEY’s AGENDA
▪ He wanted to prove
▪ Babies are gender neutral up to 2 years
▪ Nurture is greater than nature
▪ He called the brothers for sessions at different
stages
DAVID REIMER
▪ However, Brenda had difficulties in
living as a girl
▪ Was bullied at school
▪ Finally, her parents told her the truth
when she was 14 years old.
▪ Brenda got double mastectomy
▪ BRENDA REIMER DAVID
REIMER
▪ Married ‘Jane’ and became step-father
for 3 children
MILTON DIAMOND AND JOHN COLAPINTO
▪ In 1997, David publicized his
story with Dr. Milton
Diamond
▪ John Colapinto published an
interview of David in Rolling
Stones
▪ In 2001, Mr.Colapinto wrote
“As Nature Made Him”
DAVID REIMER KILLED HIMSELF IN 2004, WITH A
SHOT GUN.
‘Most suicides, experts say, have multiple motives, which
come together in a perfect storm of misery. So it was with
David.’(Colapinto,2005)
ETHICAL CONCERNS?
AND WHY?
REFERENCES:
Colapinto, J. (1997).TheTrue Story of John/Joan. Rolling Stone, 54-97.
Colapinto, J.(2001). As Nature Made Him:The BoyWhoWas Raised as a
Girl. Harper Perinnia
Diamond, Milton; Sigmundson, HK (1997). Sex reassignment at birth:
Long term review and clinical implications.
THANK YOU.

David Reimer A Case study in Psychology

  • 1.
  • 3.
    DAVID REIMER (1965– 2004) ▪ born as Bruce Reimer, twin brother of Brain Reimer, to parents; to Janet and Ronald Reimer ▪ When 8 months old- unsuccessful circumcision- resulting in a burnt off penis ▪ Turned to advise of Dr. John Money, John Hopkins University, specializing in gender identity
  • 4.
    DAVID REIMER ▪ Dr.Money suggested sex change operation ▪ Vulva construction and hormone supplements were given ▪ Asked them to raise him as a female ▪ BRUCE REIMER BRENDA REIMER
  • 5.
    JOHN MONEY’s AGENDA ▪He wanted to prove ▪ Babies are gender neutral up to 2 years ▪ Nurture is greater than nature ▪ He called the brothers for sessions at different stages
  • 6.
    DAVID REIMER ▪ However,Brenda had difficulties in living as a girl ▪ Was bullied at school ▪ Finally, her parents told her the truth when she was 14 years old. ▪ Brenda got double mastectomy ▪ BRENDA REIMER DAVID REIMER ▪ Married ‘Jane’ and became step-father for 3 children
  • 7.
    MILTON DIAMOND ANDJOHN COLAPINTO ▪ In 1997, David publicized his story with Dr. Milton Diamond ▪ John Colapinto published an interview of David in Rolling Stones ▪ In 2001, Mr.Colapinto wrote “As Nature Made Him”
  • 8.
    DAVID REIMER KILLEDHIMSELF IN 2004, WITH A SHOT GUN. ‘Most suicides, experts say, have multiple motives, which come together in a perfect storm of misery. So it was with David.’(Colapinto,2005)
  • 9.
  • 10.
    REFERENCES: Colapinto, J. (1997).TheTrueStory of John/Joan. Rolling Stone, 54-97. Colapinto, J.(2001). As Nature Made Him:The BoyWhoWas Raised as a Girl. Harper Perinnia Diamond, Milton; Sigmundson, HK (1997). Sex reassignment at birth: Long term review and clinical implications.
  • 11.