SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 33
Operational Excellence diagnostic
Easier – Faster - Better
DILO (Day In the Life Of)
How-To practical guide
Methodology - details
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
2
Introduction
 This document is a practical guide to perform a DILO. It is a follow up of the “DILO
methodology” document describing what is a DILO, its objectives and the general
methodology.
 We make the following assumptions on the DILO context:
 the people performing the job observation are consultants, external or internal to the
organisation
 the job observations are all or part of an Operational Excellence assessment
 there is a key ‘client’ contact (an internal client for internal consultants) knowledgeable of the
context of the assessment and DILOs
 Some circumstances may prevent to apply all recommendations
 this is at risk to not reduce the quality of output and the overall credibility of the consultants
(and the client as well)
 DILO’s are incredibly powerful, they look easy to perform (and they are when everything is
done well) but they may be risky. Because they are visible in the organisation and they are
about people who could feel judged, pressured, stressed…
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
3
There are eight steps to perform a DILO
1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations
2. Define the exact objective
3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who
4. Customise and validate the DILO templates
5. Prepare the job observation
6. Execute the job observation
7. Build the report and feedback
8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
4
There are eight steps to perform a DILO
1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations
2. Define the exact objective
3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who
4. Customise and validate the DILO templates
5. Prepare the job observation
6. Execute the job observation
7. Build the report and feedback
8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
5
Validate it is possible to perform DILOs
 It is not always possible to perform job observations, mainly because of Unions
or personnel representatives’ opposition.
 This step needs to be taken very seriously:
 We have seen job observations stopped half the way through by the Unions, even
when the top client thought we could and authorized to perform them; it jeopardized
the entire assessment and considerable efforts were needed to improve the situation,
but we could not continue job observations.
 Always involve the Human Resource Director, double check, triple check
 When there are unions or personnel representatives
 don’t be afraid to be proactive and to meet them
 or ask the HR director to validate the DILO study with them.
 Anyway, they will know, sooner or later; sooner is better
 Show them what a DILO is, and what it is not (see “DILO methodology”)
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
6
There are eight steps to perform a DILO
1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations
2. Define the exact objective
3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who
4. Customise and validate the DILO templates
5. Prepare the job observation
6. Execute the job observation
7. Build the report and feedback
8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
7
Two very different types of objectives, qualitative or
quantitative
 The DILO schematically provides two types of outputs:
 a qualitative insight of a person activities and issues he encountered
 a more quantitative evaluation of the Non-Value-Add activities (for an operator DILO)
or of the breakdown of different managerial type of activities (for a supervisor DILO)
 The first is the easiest and minimum output coming from a DILO; it is almost a
given.
 However, the level of quantification and details needed for the second output
has a significant impact on the overall DILO process; it must be clearly defined
to execute the right DILO in the right way.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
8
The quantitative objective has four levels impacting
differently the DILO process
 We have defined four ‘levels’ of objective related to the quantification
importance:
 Level 1: Get an understanding of ‘real life’ activities, with examples and interesting
stories; no quantification
 Level 2: Roughly evaluate the proportion of Value-Add (VA) vs. Non-Value-Add
activities (NVA)
 Level 3: Identify as precisely as possible the NVA activities and whenever possible
their root causes
 Level 4: Though the DILO exercise isn’t fit for full representativity, you may want to get
as much representativity as possible.
 The impact of these four levels on the DILO process will be described in the
following next steps.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
9
There are eight steps to perform a DILO
1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations
2. Define the exact objective
3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who
4. Customise and validate the DILO templates
5. Prepare the job observation
6. Execute the job observation
7. Build the report and feedback
8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
10
Define where, when, how long, how many and who
 The major driver to define these five criteria is the representativity of the
observations
 By nature, it is very difficult to get a good DILO representativity without spending
a considerable effort.
 Therefore, there is always the need to take the best ‘sample’, which is a mix of
the five criteria.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
11
Where
 The ‘where’ can be a functional or a physical area or a combination of both
 For example, in a production plant, we may want to analyse the ‘production’
area and the ‘maintenance’ area, which may also be subdivided. Example:
 production line A, B, C for the production
 electrical, mechanical…for the maintenance
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
12
When
 The ‘when’ can be split in several categories:
 selecting the different ‘teams’ if the operations are organised with several shifts (e.g.
morning, afternoon, night or week, week-end)
 selecting representative days when the operations are supposed to be ‘normal’
 an alternative is to select ‘extreme days’ if they have an important impact on the
overall performance of the organisation
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
13
How long
 The ‘how long’ means ‘how long should each individual observation last’.
 The baseline duration is the person entire work duration.
 However, it might be shortened if:
 the activities are supposed to be very similar through the entire person work duration
 there is a lack of time to perform full day job observation
 or if the need for representativity is high (Objective level 4)
 it is better to have a high number of shorter observations than the opposite since it enables
to cover more people, in more areas, at different times, for the same total amount of
observation time.
 that can be statistically challenged, but this is at least generally better in terms of people
perception, mostly because more people are met, so it is more visible. And perception is key
in this type of analysis.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
14
How many
 ‘How many’ is directly driven by the objective Level
 Level 1: even one job observation may be enough to have at least some ‘feeling’ about
the operations
 Level 2 and 3:
 at least one job observation in each core area.
 It is generally not necessary to cover all the combinations possible. For example, in a two-shift
production area with two production lines, performing two job observations may be enough
and saves two job observations:
 one in production line 1 during the morning shift
 one in production line 2 during the afternoon shift
 Level 4:
 without being statistically rigorous, the number of observations should reach or be above
twenty
 all or most of the combinations should be observed, and possibly with several observations for
each combination.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
15
Who
 The ideal candidates to be observed are:
 people who are willing to be observed or at least not afraid of having someone
observing them
 people who have an ‘average’ performance to get some representativity. Alternatively,
people with low or high performance could be observed but that automatically
generates more observations.
 If only Level 1 objective is desired (pure qualitative), and specially if there are
very few job observations, it is best to select someone who is likely to speak up
to get a good level of qualitative outputs.
 When there are strong unions or personnel representative the choice of people
may have to be discussed with them.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
16
Where, when, how long, how many and who: Summary
Criteria Level 1 Level 2 and 3 Level 4
Where & when Small sample Core combinations Most combinations
How long Full job duration Full job duration
Full job duration
Partial duration if similar
all time
How many Few Variable Many (>20)
Who Average and Talkative Average
Average or a combination
of high, average, low
performers
Criteria best fit for the different objectives*
*These are indicative and must be adapted to each situation
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
17
How to actually review these criteria and decide who
to observe
 Whether you are external or internal consultant, the criteria above and the final choice
of persons might be discussed in three phases:
1. the ‘client’ contact; he is in general the main person able to review the criteria and give the
first choice or recommendations
2. the key stakeholders of the overall assessment in which the DILO takes place. The larger
the scope of observations, the more managers might be involved (e.g. one for each area) to
discuss and validate the choices
3. finally, the direct managers of the people (pre)selected should be involved; at minimal they
are informed so they can help in the next ‘preparation step’, but they may also participate in
the final people selection.
 When there is a team of several consultants:
 sub-steps 1, and possibly 2 are generally managed by the team manager (or the nominated
consultant in charge)
 the consultant actually performing the observation may be involved in sub-step 2 while he is
often involved in sub-step 3.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
18
There are eight steps to perform a DILO
1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations
2. Define the exact objective
3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who
4. Customise and validate the DILO templates
5. Prepare the job observation
6. Execute the job observation
7. Build the report and feedback
8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
19
Customise and validate the DILO templates
 The actual templates to use for each type of job observation must be reviewed,
and customised if necessary, to make sure they are adapted to the type of jobs
that are observed, and to the objectives.
 A good practice to review the DILO activity categories with the key client.
 That is an opportunity to demonstrate your expertise in what is a Value-Add / Non-
Value-Add activity (or Muda type 1 and 2 in Lean terminology) and to coach the client
 It reduces the risk that he doesn’t really understand and challenges you on the
findings, especially when it is already ‘too late’ (e.g. when officially presenting the
results in a Steering Committee).
 For more details, look at the “DILO templates ” document
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
20
There are eight steps to perform a DILO
1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations
2. Define the exact objective
3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who
4. Customise and validate the DILO templates
5. Prepare the job observation
6. Execute the job observation
7. Build the report and feedback
8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
21
Prepare the observation
 This step is about the preparation of each individual observation. It must be
carried out by the actual consultant who will perform the work observation.
 There are three sub-steps:
 Get information about the job to be observed
 Book actual observation slot and Communicate with the person to be observed
 Review and customise the observation template
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
22
Prepare the observation: Get information about the
job to be observed
 The higher the level of understanding of the job that will be observed the higher the chances to
execute it well
 During the observation, the chances to ask the person what is going on are limited; hence, we may
record incorrect information (or none) and damage our credibility.
 Collect the following information when accessible; either by reading some documentation or
interviewing someone knowledgeable
 Description of the process(s) that the person observed uses with the key activities to perform
 List or description of typical issues: bottlenecks, product defects or service quality…
 Typical volume of output during a normal day (e.g. production volume in production, number of calls in
helpdesk centre…)
 Go and visit the physical location with someone (in general the manager of the area) to give you
some explanations:
 Familiarize yourself with the environment and ask questions to clarify the process
 Observe shortly a colleague of the person who will be fully observed, doing the same job
 Even better, observe directly the person you will observe during the actual job observation so he gets to know
you (and you do the sub-step 3 at the same time)
 this time you may ask questions to your accompanying person because you don’t mind interfering a bit (shortly!)
with the person activities.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
23
Prepare the observation: Communicate with the person to be
observed and book actual job observation slot
 If you haven’t met yet with the person in the previous sub-step, this is time to do it.
 Ask the person’s manager to introduce you to him.
 Tell who you are, what is the objective of the job observation, and most specifically
what it is not: not a time and motion study, not an evaluation of the person, not
judgmental.
 Ask them if they have questions and answer them.
 Be friendly; you are here to understand the issues and ultimately to make their job
more interesting by reducing them (though you may find people who love issues
because that is what makes their job interesting in a sort of ‘Hero culture’!).
 Validate the exact work hours of the person, the day you are supposed to observe them;
they may have different work hours than supposed, this day.
 Validate where and when you will meet them.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
24
Prepare the observation: Review the DILO template
 Review the template, especially the activity breakdown.
 It will help you understand what to focus on during the observation.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
25
There are eight steps to perform a DILO
1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations
2. Define the exact objective
3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who
4. Customise and validate the DILO templates
5. Prepare the job observation
6. Execute the job observation
7. Build the report and feedback
8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
26
Execute the DILO: DO’s (1/2)
 Be on time to meet the person to observe.
 Follow completely all safety requirements (e.g. clothing, Personal Protection
Equipment)
 Again, be friendly with the person, emphasize that your interest is in
understanding the problems they typically face, the systems and processes they
use – it is not an individual evaluation or a time & motion exercise
 Use a notebook, and write down every activity; replicate the appropriate
template "Timesheet" columns; it is not recommended to print and use the
"Timesheet" since the row’s height may not fit your notes
 Take notes as it happens - You will miss detail if you don’t; after a full day of
observation you may get confused.
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
27
Execute the DILO: DO’s (2/2)
 Keep a dialogue going with the person observed but minimise your own perturbation on the activities;
don’t create Non-Value-Add yourself!
 Ask questions to understand possible causes of problems as they occur - use their quotes / comments in the
study.
 If you don’t understand an activity, ask the person to explain it to you
 When the person is busy, write down the question to ask it later; use the moments the person is idle, waiting
for something…
 Understand use of and compliance to standard operating procedures, processes…
 Respect the person break times:
 ask them if they are ok that you take the coffee or cigarette break with them; it is a good opportunity to talk,
but some people prefer being alone during their breaks
 this is even more important to ask for the meal break
 don’t follow them to the bathroom
 Collect all volume / waste info... as it happens (when not preventing you to perform the observation;
which is the main goal); it often cannot be collected afterwards
 At the end of the observation, do ask whether it is a “typical” day; if not ask why
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
28
Execute the DILO: DON’Ts
 Use a “stop watch”. Record the time of the activities with a normal watch
without too much insistence; we don’t need to be 100% accurate, this is an
estimation.
 Comment, criticize or make jokes about the work; don’t share your judgements
on what is VA/NVA during the study
 Confront or try and problem solve for them – leave that for the project! The only
exception is when there is a safety issue
 Don’t write vague comments like: “Entered something into computer”. You must
know what they are entering, into what system
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
29
There are eight steps to perform a DILO
1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations
2. Define the exact objective
3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who
4. Customise and validate the DILO templates
5. Prepare the job observation
6. Execute the job observation
7. Build the report and feedback
8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
30
Build the report and feedback
 Fill in the template just after the observation when your memory is still good.
 The text of the DILO should refer to the person you are following as ‘subject’,
‘the person’…; don’t use names.
 Compare the performance (volume, quality…) of the area observed during the
DILO and the historical performance to see if the day of the work observation is
typical. Adjust the message if not.
 After having validated with the person observed, come back to him/she to
ensure that what you captured in the ‘Timesheet’ is correct, to ask for
clarification if necessary and to find root causes of issues you identified
 Build your final report in the appropriate format.
 Review the outputs with the area manager; ask for root causes if some are still
unclear
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
31
There are eight steps to perform a DILO
1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations
2. Define the exact objective
3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who
4. Customise and validate the DILO templates
5. Prepare the job observation
6. Execute the job observation
7. Build the report and feedback
8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18
32
Perform additional analysis – Value-Add increase
 DILOs can be quite helpful to identify root causes (or drivers) as well as how
their resolution (or implementation) would impact the personal, typically:
 reducing the Non-Value-Add activities for the operational roles / DILO
 increasing the active supervision activities proportion for a supervisor
 This step is optional and is in general possible only if there are many
observations and the root causes are well identified. This typical applies when
the objective is a Level 4 objective.
 This analysis may be quite complex, involving other inputs or workshops, and
isn’t described here since this is not the goal of this section
Operational Excellence diagnostic
Easier – Faster - Better
Get more Operational
Excellence content on
www.wevalgo.com
Follow us on:
Linkedin
Twitter

More Related Content

What's hot

Store officer kpi
Store officer kpiStore officer kpi
Store officer kpi
jomcerfus
 
Office boy kpi
Office boy kpiOffice boy kpi
Office boy kpi
vetfurijom
 
Hr & admin manager kpi
Hr & admin manager kpiHr & admin manager kpi
Hr & admin manager kpi
zawemiter
 
Demand planning session
Demand planning sessionDemand planning session
Demand planning session
AlfaPeople US
 

What's hot (20)

Value Engineering
Value EngineeringValue Engineering
Value Engineering
 
Kpi for hr department
Kpi for hr departmentKpi for hr department
Kpi for hr department
 
Key Performance Indicators-KPIs
Key Performance Indicators-KPIsKey Performance Indicators-KPIs
Key Performance Indicators-KPIs
 
KPI for HR Manager - Sample of KPIs for HR
KPI for HR Manager - Sample of KPIs for HRKPI for HR Manager - Sample of KPIs for HR
KPI for HR Manager - Sample of KPIs for HR
 
Store officer kpi
Store officer kpiStore officer kpi
Store officer kpi
 
Definition of linear programming problem model decision variable, objective ...
Definition of linear programming problem model decision variable, objective ...Definition of linear programming problem model decision variable, objective ...
Definition of linear programming problem model decision variable, objective ...
 
Office boy kpi
Office boy kpiOffice boy kpi
Office boy kpi
 
project management information system
project management information systemproject management information system
project management information system
 
KPI Human Resources Management
KPI Human Resources ManagementKPI Human Resources Management
KPI Human Resources Management
 
Value Analysis and Value Engineering in Material Management
Value Analysis and Value Engineering in Material ManagementValue Analysis and Value Engineering in Material Management
Value Analysis and Value Engineering in Material Management
 
Introducing Deloitte Hcas
Introducing Deloitte HcasIntroducing Deloitte Hcas
Introducing Deloitte Hcas
 
Ramp up project
Ramp up projectRamp up project
Ramp up project
 
Microsoft Project
Microsoft ProjectMicrosoft Project
Microsoft Project
 
Basics of Operations Research
Basics of Operations ResearchBasics of Operations Research
Basics of Operations Research
 
KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATOR
KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORKEY PERFORMANCE INDICATOR
KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATOR
 
Hr & admin manager kpi
Hr & admin manager kpiHr & admin manager kpi
Hr & admin manager kpi
 
Demand planning session
Demand planning sessionDemand planning session
Demand planning session
 
Project Management: NETWORK ANALYSIS - CPM and PERT
Project Management: NETWORK ANALYSIS - CPM and PERTProject Management: NETWORK ANALYSIS - CPM and PERT
Project Management: NETWORK ANALYSIS - CPM and PERT
 
Hr kpi dashboard
Hr kpi dashboardHr kpi dashboard
Hr kpi dashboard
 
Project Scheduling
Project SchedulingProject Scheduling
Project Scheduling
 

Similar to Day In the Life Of (DILO) - How To Do it - Practical guide

Creating the Performance Culture
Creating the Performance CultureCreating the Performance Culture
Creating the Performance Culture
Scott Staunton
 
WRIT111.A1 – Prof. Murphy – Summer 2015 Essay 5 Argumentat.docx
WRIT111.A1 – Prof. Murphy – Summer 2015 Essay 5 Argumentat.docxWRIT111.A1 – Prof. Murphy – Summer 2015 Essay 5 Argumentat.docx
WRIT111.A1 – Prof. Murphy – Summer 2015 Essay 5 Argumentat.docx
ericbrooks84875
 
Session 5 additional analytics operations
Session 5   additional analytics operationsSession 5   additional analytics operations
Session 5 additional analytics operations
Angela Ferrara
 
How to-measure-the-return-on-your-hr-investment
How to-measure-the-return-on-your-hr-investmentHow to-measure-the-return-on-your-hr-investment
How to-measure-the-return-on-your-hr-investment
Ahmed A.samra
 
Managing the portfolio
Managing the portfolioManaging the portfolio
Managing the portfolio
Stuart Robb
 
Insurance Risk and Operations 2015
Insurance Risk and Operations 2015Insurance Risk and Operations 2015
Insurance Risk and Operations 2015
Anthony Siggers
 

Similar to Day In the Life Of (DILO) - How To Do it - Practical guide (20)

Financial Services storyboard
Financial Services storyboardFinancial Services storyboard
Financial Services storyboard
 
Give Me an Hour and i will triple your ROI
Give Me an Hour and i will triple your ROIGive Me an Hour and i will triple your ROI
Give Me an Hour and i will triple your ROI
 
Creating the Performance Culture
Creating the Performance CultureCreating the Performance Culture
Creating the Performance Culture
 
Role of the virtual ciso
Role of the virtual cisoRole of the virtual ciso
Role of the virtual ciso
 
International Auditing Standards (ISA)
International Auditing Standards (ISA)International Auditing Standards (ISA)
International Auditing Standards (ISA)
 
An overview of agile practices
An overview of agile practicesAn overview of agile practices
An overview of agile practices
 
WRIT111.A1 – Prof. Murphy – Summer 2015 Essay 5 Argumentat.docx
WRIT111.A1 – Prof. Murphy – Summer 2015 Essay 5 Argumentat.docxWRIT111.A1 – Prof. Murphy – Summer 2015 Essay 5 Argumentat.docx
WRIT111.A1 – Prof. Murphy – Summer 2015 Essay 5 Argumentat.docx
 
Tier 4 Events - Operational Discipline - Do you know how are you performing i...
Tier 4 Events - Operational Discipline - Do you know how are you performing i...Tier 4 Events - Operational Discipline - Do you know how are you performing i...
Tier 4 Events - Operational Discipline - Do you know how are you performing i...
 
Lean Software Development
Lean Software DevelopmentLean Software Development
Lean Software Development
 
Session 5 additional analytics operations
Session 5   additional analytics operationsSession 5   additional analytics operations
Session 5 additional analytics operations
 
PMI-ACP Lesson 12 Knowledge and Skills Nugget 4
PMI-ACP Lesson 12 Knowledge and Skills Nugget 4PMI-ACP Lesson 12 Knowledge and Skills Nugget 4
PMI-ACP Lesson 12 Knowledge and Skills Nugget 4
 
How to-measure-the-return-on-your-hr-investment
How to-measure-the-return-on-your-hr-investmentHow to-measure-the-return-on-your-hr-investment
How to-measure-the-return-on-your-hr-investment
 
Managing the portfolio
Managing the portfolioManaging the portfolio
Managing the portfolio
 
Business plan template
Business plan templateBusiness plan template
Business plan template
 
Reflective Piece on Icarus
Reflective Piece on IcarusReflective Piece on Icarus
Reflective Piece on Icarus
 
How To Build A Credible Performance Measurement Baseline
How To Build A Credible Performance Measurement BaselineHow To Build A Credible Performance Measurement Baseline
How To Build A Credible Performance Measurement Baseline
 
How To Build A Credible Performance Measurement Baseline
How To Build A Credible Performance Measurement BaselineHow To Build A Credible Performance Measurement Baseline
How To Build A Credible Performance Measurement Baseline
 
Management Techniques
Management TechniquesManagement Techniques
Management Techniques
 
Erp – overcoming the fear of change
Erp – overcoming the fear of changeErp – overcoming the fear of change
Erp – overcoming the fear of change
 
Insurance Risk and Operations 2015
Insurance Risk and Operations 2015Insurance Risk and Operations 2015
Insurance Risk and Operations 2015
 

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (10)

Travis Hills of Minnesota Leads Livestock Water and Energy in Sustainable Inn...
Travis Hills of Minnesota Leads Livestock Water and Energy in Sustainable Inn...Travis Hills of Minnesota Leads Livestock Water and Energy in Sustainable Inn...
Travis Hills of Minnesota Leads Livestock Water and Energy in Sustainable Inn...
 
TEST BANK for Operations Management, 14th Edition by William J. Stevenson,.pdf
TEST BANK for Operations Management, 14th Edition by William J. Stevenson,.pdfTEST BANK for Operations Management, 14th Edition by William J. Stevenson,.pdf
TEST BANK for Operations Management, 14th Edition by William J. Stevenson,.pdf
 
Presentation On "Yusuf Ibn Tashfin" a true leader (1061 to 1106)_ prepared by...
Presentation On "Yusuf Ibn Tashfin" a true leader (1061 to 1106)_ prepared by...Presentation On "Yusuf Ibn Tashfin" a true leader (1061 to 1106)_ prepared by...
Presentation On "Yusuf Ibn Tashfin" a true leader (1061 to 1106)_ prepared by...
 
Team Dynamics: A Journey to Excellence
Team Dynamics: A Journey to ExcellenceTeam Dynamics: A Journey to Excellence
Team Dynamics: A Journey to Excellence
 
Create the recognition your teams deserve.pptx
Create the recognition your teams deserve.pptxCreate the recognition your teams deserve.pptx
Create the recognition your teams deserve.pptx
 
Principles of Management analyze how Zara manage
Principles of Management analyze how Zara managePrinciples of Management analyze how Zara manage
Principles of Management analyze how Zara manage
 
Leading People - Harvard Manage Mentor Certificate
Leading People - Harvard Manage Mentor CertificateLeading People - Harvard Manage Mentor Certificate
Leading People - Harvard Manage Mentor Certificate
 
UX in an Agile World - Scrum Gathering
UX in an Agile World -   Scrum GatheringUX in an Agile World -   Scrum Gathering
UX in an Agile World - Scrum Gathering
 
Risk Management in Banks - Overview (May 2024)
Risk Management in Banks - Overview (May 2024)Risk Management in Banks - Overview (May 2024)
Risk Management in Banks - Overview (May 2024)
 
Project Management Professional (PMP)® from PMI
Project Management Professional (PMP)® from PMIProject Management Professional (PMP)® from PMI
Project Management Professional (PMP)® from PMI
 

Day In the Life Of (DILO) - How To Do it - Practical guide

  • 1. Operational Excellence diagnostic Easier – Faster - Better DILO (Day In the Life Of) How-To practical guide Methodology - details
  • 2. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 2 Introduction  This document is a practical guide to perform a DILO. It is a follow up of the “DILO methodology” document describing what is a DILO, its objectives and the general methodology.  We make the following assumptions on the DILO context:  the people performing the job observation are consultants, external or internal to the organisation  the job observations are all or part of an Operational Excellence assessment  there is a key ‘client’ contact (an internal client for internal consultants) knowledgeable of the context of the assessment and DILOs  Some circumstances may prevent to apply all recommendations  this is at risk to not reduce the quality of output and the overall credibility of the consultants (and the client as well)  DILO’s are incredibly powerful, they look easy to perform (and they are when everything is done well) but they may be risky. Because they are visible in the organisation and they are about people who could feel judged, pressured, stressed…
  • 3. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 3 There are eight steps to perform a DILO 1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations 2. Define the exact objective 3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who 4. Customise and validate the DILO templates 5. Prepare the job observation 6. Execute the job observation 7. Build the report and feedback 8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
  • 4. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 4 There are eight steps to perform a DILO 1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations 2. Define the exact objective 3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who 4. Customise and validate the DILO templates 5. Prepare the job observation 6. Execute the job observation 7. Build the report and feedback 8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
  • 5. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 5 Validate it is possible to perform DILOs  It is not always possible to perform job observations, mainly because of Unions or personnel representatives’ opposition.  This step needs to be taken very seriously:  We have seen job observations stopped half the way through by the Unions, even when the top client thought we could and authorized to perform them; it jeopardized the entire assessment and considerable efforts were needed to improve the situation, but we could not continue job observations.  Always involve the Human Resource Director, double check, triple check  When there are unions or personnel representatives  don’t be afraid to be proactive and to meet them  or ask the HR director to validate the DILO study with them.  Anyway, they will know, sooner or later; sooner is better  Show them what a DILO is, and what it is not (see “DILO methodology”)
  • 6. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 6 There are eight steps to perform a DILO 1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations 2. Define the exact objective 3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who 4. Customise and validate the DILO templates 5. Prepare the job observation 6. Execute the job observation 7. Build the report and feedback 8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
  • 7. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 7 Two very different types of objectives, qualitative or quantitative  The DILO schematically provides two types of outputs:  a qualitative insight of a person activities and issues he encountered  a more quantitative evaluation of the Non-Value-Add activities (for an operator DILO) or of the breakdown of different managerial type of activities (for a supervisor DILO)  The first is the easiest and minimum output coming from a DILO; it is almost a given.  However, the level of quantification and details needed for the second output has a significant impact on the overall DILO process; it must be clearly defined to execute the right DILO in the right way.
  • 8. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 8 The quantitative objective has four levels impacting differently the DILO process  We have defined four ‘levels’ of objective related to the quantification importance:  Level 1: Get an understanding of ‘real life’ activities, with examples and interesting stories; no quantification  Level 2: Roughly evaluate the proportion of Value-Add (VA) vs. Non-Value-Add activities (NVA)  Level 3: Identify as precisely as possible the NVA activities and whenever possible their root causes  Level 4: Though the DILO exercise isn’t fit for full representativity, you may want to get as much representativity as possible.  The impact of these four levels on the DILO process will be described in the following next steps.
  • 9. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 9 There are eight steps to perform a DILO 1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations 2. Define the exact objective 3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who 4. Customise and validate the DILO templates 5. Prepare the job observation 6. Execute the job observation 7. Build the report and feedback 8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
  • 10. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 10 Define where, when, how long, how many and who  The major driver to define these five criteria is the representativity of the observations  By nature, it is very difficult to get a good DILO representativity without spending a considerable effort.  Therefore, there is always the need to take the best ‘sample’, which is a mix of the five criteria.
  • 11. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 11 Where  The ‘where’ can be a functional or a physical area or a combination of both  For example, in a production plant, we may want to analyse the ‘production’ area and the ‘maintenance’ area, which may also be subdivided. Example:  production line A, B, C for the production  electrical, mechanical…for the maintenance
  • 12. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 12 When  The ‘when’ can be split in several categories:  selecting the different ‘teams’ if the operations are organised with several shifts (e.g. morning, afternoon, night or week, week-end)  selecting representative days when the operations are supposed to be ‘normal’  an alternative is to select ‘extreme days’ if they have an important impact on the overall performance of the organisation
  • 13. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 13 How long  The ‘how long’ means ‘how long should each individual observation last’.  The baseline duration is the person entire work duration.  However, it might be shortened if:  the activities are supposed to be very similar through the entire person work duration  there is a lack of time to perform full day job observation  or if the need for representativity is high (Objective level 4)  it is better to have a high number of shorter observations than the opposite since it enables to cover more people, in more areas, at different times, for the same total amount of observation time.  that can be statistically challenged, but this is at least generally better in terms of people perception, mostly because more people are met, so it is more visible. And perception is key in this type of analysis.
  • 14. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 14 How many  ‘How many’ is directly driven by the objective Level  Level 1: even one job observation may be enough to have at least some ‘feeling’ about the operations  Level 2 and 3:  at least one job observation in each core area.  It is generally not necessary to cover all the combinations possible. For example, in a two-shift production area with two production lines, performing two job observations may be enough and saves two job observations:  one in production line 1 during the morning shift  one in production line 2 during the afternoon shift  Level 4:  without being statistically rigorous, the number of observations should reach or be above twenty  all or most of the combinations should be observed, and possibly with several observations for each combination.
  • 15. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 15 Who  The ideal candidates to be observed are:  people who are willing to be observed or at least not afraid of having someone observing them  people who have an ‘average’ performance to get some representativity. Alternatively, people with low or high performance could be observed but that automatically generates more observations.  If only Level 1 objective is desired (pure qualitative), and specially if there are very few job observations, it is best to select someone who is likely to speak up to get a good level of qualitative outputs.  When there are strong unions or personnel representative the choice of people may have to be discussed with them.
  • 16. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 16 Where, when, how long, how many and who: Summary Criteria Level 1 Level 2 and 3 Level 4 Where & when Small sample Core combinations Most combinations How long Full job duration Full job duration Full job duration Partial duration if similar all time How many Few Variable Many (>20) Who Average and Talkative Average Average or a combination of high, average, low performers Criteria best fit for the different objectives* *These are indicative and must be adapted to each situation
  • 17. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 17 How to actually review these criteria and decide who to observe  Whether you are external or internal consultant, the criteria above and the final choice of persons might be discussed in three phases: 1. the ‘client’ contact; he is in general the main person able to review the criteria and give the first choice or recommendations 2. the key stakeholders of the overall assessment in which the DILO takes place. The larger the scope of observations, the more managers might be involved (e.g. one for each area) to discuss and validate the choices 3. finally, the direct managers of the people (pre)selected should be involved; at minimal they are informed so they can help in the next ‘preparation step’, but they may also participate in the final people selection.  When there is a team of several consultants:  sub-steps 1, and possibly 2 are generally managed by the team manager (or the nominated consultant in charge)  the consultant actually performing the observation may be involved in sub-step 2 while he is often involved in sub-step 3.
  • 18. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 18 There are eight steps to perform a DILO 1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations 2. Define the exact objective 3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who 4. Customise and validate the DILO templates 5. Prepare the job observation 6. Execute the job observation 7. Build the report and feedback 8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
  • 19. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 19 Customise and validate the DILO templates  The actual templates to use for each type of job observation must be reviewed, and customised if necessary, to make sure they are adapted to the type of jobs that are observed, and to the objectives.  A good practice to review the DILO activity categories with the key client.  That is an opportunity to demonstrate your expertise in what is a Value-Add / Non- Value-Add activity (or Muda type 1 and 2 in Lean terminology) and to coach the client  It reduces the risk that he doesn’t really understand and challenges you on the findings, especially when it is already ‘too late’ (e.g. when officially presenting the results in a Steering Committee).  For more details, look at the “DILO templates ” document
  • 20. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 20 There are eight steps to perform a DILO 1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations 2. Define the exact objective 3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who 4. Customise and validate the DILO templates 5. Prepare the job observation 6. Execute the job observation 7. Build the report and feedback 8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
  • 21. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 21 Prepare the observation  This step is about the preparation of each individual observation. It must be carried out by the actual consultant who will perform the work observation.  There are three sub-steps:  Get information about the job to be observed  Book actual observation slot and Communicate with the person to be observed  Review and customise the observation template
  • 22. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 22 Prepare the observation: Get information about the job to be observed  The higher the level of understanding of the job that will be observed the higher the chances to execute it well  During the observation, the chances to ask the person what is going on are limited; hence, we may record incorrect information (or none) and damage our credibility.  Collect the following information when accessible; either by reading some documentation or interviewing someone knowledgeable  Description of the process(s) that the person observed uses with the key activities to perform  List or description of typical issues: bottlenecks, product defects or service quality…  Typical volume of output during a normal day (e.g. production volume in production, number of calls in helpdesk centre…)  Go and visit the physical location with someone (in general the manager of the area) to give you some explanations:  Familiarize yourself with the environment and ask questions to clarify the process  Observe shortly a colleague of the person who will be fully observed, doing the same job  Even better, observe directly the person you will observe during the actual job observation so he gets to know you (and you do the sub-step 3 at the same time)  this time you may ask questions to your accompanying person because you don’t mind interfering a bit (shortly!) with the person activities.
  • 23. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 23 Prepare the observation: Communicate with the person to be observed and book actual job observation slot  If you haven’t met yet with the person in the previous sub-step, this is time to do it.  Ask the person’s manager to introduce you to him.  Tell who you are, what is the objective of the job observation, and most specifically what it is not: not a time and motion study, not an evaluation of the person, not judgmental.  Ask them if they have questions and answer them.  Be friendly; you are here to understand the issues and ultimately to make their job more interesting by reducing them (though you may find people who love issues because that is what makes their job interesting in a sort of ‘Hero culture’!).  Validate the exact work hours of the person, the day you are supposed to observe them; they may have different work hours than supposed, this day.  Validate where and when you will meet them.
  • 24. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 24 Prepare the observation: Review the DILO template  Review the template, especially the activity breakdown.  It will help you understand what to focus on during the observation.
  • 25. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 25 There are eight steps to perform a DILO 1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations 2. Define the exact objective 3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who 4. Customise and validate the DILO templates 5. Prepare the job observation 6. Execute the job observation 7. Build the report and feedback 8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
  • 26. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 26 Execute the DILO: DO’s (1/2)  Be on time to meet the person to observe.  Follow completely all safety requirements (e.g. clothing, Personal Protection Equipment)  Again, be friendly with the person, emphasize that your interest is in understanding the problems they typically face, the systems and processes they use – it is not an individual evaluation or a time & motion exercise  Use a notebook, and write down every activity; replicate the appropriate template "Timesheet" columns; it is not recommended to print and use the "Timesheet" since the row’s height may not fit your notes  Take notes as it happens - You will miss detail if you don’t; after a full day of observation you may get confused.
  • 27. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 27 Execute the DILO: DO’s (2/2)  Keep a dialogue going with the person observed but minimise your own perturbation on the activities; don’t create Non-Value-Add yourself!  Ask questions to understand possible causes of problems as they occur - use their quotes / comments in the study.  If you don’t understand an activity, ask the person to explain it to you  When the person is busy, write down the question to ask it later; use the moments the person is idle, waiting for something…  Understand use of and compliance to standard operating procedures, processes…  Respect the person break times:  ask them if they are ok that you take the coffee or cigarette break with them; it is a good opportunity to talk, but some people prefer being alone during their breaks  this is even more important to ask for the meal break  don’t follow them to the bathroom  Collect all volume / waste info... as it happens (when not preventing you to perform the observation; which is the main goal); it often cannot be collected afterwards  At the end of the observation, do ask whether it is a “typical” day; if not ask why
  • 28. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 28 Execute the DILO: DON’Ts  Use a “stop watch”. Record the time of the activities with a normal watch without too much insistence; we don’t need to be 100% accurate, this is an estimation.  Comment, criticize or make jokes about the work; don’t share your judgements on what is VA/NVA during the study  Confront or try and problem solve for them – leave that for the project! The only exception is when there is a safety issue  Don’t write vague comments like: “Entered something into computer”. You must know what they are entering, into what system
  • 29. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 29 There are eight steps to perform a DILO 1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations 2. Define the exact objective 3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who 4. Customise and validate the DILO templates 5. Prepare the job observation 6. Execute the job observation 7. Build the report and feedback 8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
  • 30. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 30 Build the report and feedback  Fill in the template just after the observation when your memory is still good.  The text of the DILO should refer to the person you are following as ‘subject’, ‘the person’…; don’t use names.  Compare the performance (volume, quality…) of the area observed during the DILO and the historical performance to see if the day of the work observation is typical. Adjust the message if not.  After having validated with the person observed, come back to him/she to ensure that what you captured in the ‘Timesheet’ is correct, to ask for clarification if necessary and to find root causes of issues you identified  Build your final report in the appropriate format.  Review the outputs with the area manager; ask for root causes if some are still unclear
  • 31. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 31 There are eight steps to perform a DILO 1. Validate it is possible to perform job observations 2. Define the exact objective 3. Define where, when, how long, how many and who 4. Customise and validate the DILO templates 5. Prepare the job observation 6. Execute the job observation 7. Build the report and feedback 8. Perform additional analysis –Value-Add increase
  • 32. ©2017-2019Wevalgo.Allrightsreserved.Proprietaryandconfidential3-Oct-18 32 Perform additional analysis – Value-Add increase  DILOs can be quite helpful to identify root causes (or drivers) as well as how their resolution (or implementation) would impact the personal, typically:  reducing the Non-Value-Add activities for the operational roles / DILO  increasing the active supervision activities proportion for a supervisor  This step is optional and is in general possible only if there are many observations and the root causes are well identified. This typical applies when the objective is a Level 4 objective.  This analysis may be quite complex, involving other inputs or workshops, and isn’t described here since this is not the goal of this section
  • 33. Operational Excellence diagnostic Easier – Faster - Better Get more Operational Excellence content on www.wevalgo.com Follow us on: Linkedin Twitter