SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
3D Printed Model: Scale 1:18
INTRODUCTION
Objective: Study the aerodynamics of the Baja car and reduce its drag coefficient to improve performance.
Marvin Bertin, Maximilien Brodel, Kieran Mak, Rahul Rughani
• Problem: the firewall on the Baja vehicle
produces significant drag and slows the car.
• Objective: reduce the drag from the firewall
and improve overall performance by designing
and manufacturing flow optimized body
panels that integrate seamlessly onto the
vehicle.
• Aerodynamics have never been investigated by McGill Baja.
• Other successful teams have added streamlined panels.
• Streamlining of trucks could be a source of inspiration as they too
have an abrupt aerodynamic profile.
BACKGROUND
CONCEPT GENERATION
CONCEPT EVALUATION
Fast Diagram Summary
Primary Function Secondary Function Evaluation Criteria Material Criteria
• Reduce drag
coefficient
• Minimize weight gain
• Unobtrusive with
current car design
• Easily Maintained
• Streamline vehicle
profile
• Minimal body panel size
• Structurally supported
• Access of components
• Compatible with car
frame
• Removable panels
• Durable
• Lightweight
• Smooth surface
• Strength
• Flexibility
• Thin
• Water & mud
resistant
CFD ANALYSIS
Concept Drag (N) % Change Drag Lift (N) % Change Lift
Datum (MB14) 258.2 NA -110.0 NA
MB15 (Baseline) 229.8 -10.99 % -93.5 +15.01 %
Concept 0 229.9 -10.94 % -95.0 +13.59 %
Concept 1 262.3 +1.58 % -106.6 +3.06 %
Concept 2 243.2 -5.81 % -107.5 +2.28 %
Concept 3 196.2 -24.00 % -61.7 +43.89 %
Concept 4 233.0 -9.75 % -89.3 +18.76 %
Concept 1
Concept 2
Concept 3
Concept 4
WIND TUNNEL TESTING
0.95
1
1.05
1.1
1.15
1.2
1.25
40,225 46,929 53,633 56,986 60,338 63,690 67,042
DragCoefficient
Reynolds Number
Drag Coefficient vs Reynolds Number
Baseline
Flat Panels
Curved Panels
Roof Scoop &
Curved Panels
Concept Average Drag
Coefficient
% difference
with baseline
Baseline 1.160 -
Flat Panels 1.116 - 3.79%
Curved Panels 1.105 - 4.74%
Roof Scoop & Curved
Panels
1.173 + 1.12%
FINAL CONCEPT
 Concept 3 (curved panels) obtained best results in CFD and wind tunnel
testing
Concept 150 ft accel.
Accel time
saved
Lap time Lap time saved
MB15 (base car) 5.9 s - 76.12 s -
MB 15 + Aero Panels 5.79 s 0.11 s 74.56 s 1.56 s
Performance improvement is evaluated with a Matlab drive train simulation
program
 Over 60 laps, time saved is 1 mn 34 s
MANUFACTURING / FASTENERS
CONCLUSION
Carbon Fiber Panel Manufacturing
A&P Technologies
+/- 45° biaxial fabric
Open mold wet layup with resin
5 plies
Vacuum hold, no curing
Material Requirements: Lightweight, Durable
 D8 DZUS® PANEX Quarter-Turn Fasteners, size 6
 Attach panels to chassis
Quarter turn: easily removable, tool free
Durable: steel plated with chrome
 D8 grade, size 6: high ultimate torque
and cyclic durability
• Results showed improved performance with limited streamlining. Therefore further
aerodynamic optimization of the Baja is worthwhile.
• CFD determined that adding a roof, as other teams have done, would hurt
performance.
• Panel design was limited by several constraints. Particularly, engine must be easily
accessible. Also, no parts should stick out of the frame as they could break upon
impact. Final design was best possible with constraints in mind.
 Next step: Testing on finished car
 Recommendations:
 Consider aerodynamics early on in design process of car. Next frame should be built
to integrate streamlining elements, instead of adapting panels to an existing frame.
 In the future, optimize flow over front of the car.
Department of Mechanical Engineering
2014-2015 Mech Eng Design Project
Baseline
Final Concept
CFD Results
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank McGill Baja Racing, its carbon fiber sponsor A&P Technologies as well
as Linus Lehnert, Jasmin de Campos, Alex Marotta and the McGill machinist team.

More Related Content

What's hot

Design Optimization of Axles using Inspire and OptiStruct
Design Optimization of Axles using Inspire and OptiStructDesign Optimization of Axles using Inspire and OptiStruct
Design Optimization of Axles using Inspire and OptiStructAltair
 
Structural Component Design Optimization for Additive Manufacture
Structural Component Design Optimization for Additive ManufactureStructural Component Design Optimization for Additive Manufacture
Structural Component Design Optimization for Additive ManufactureAltair
 
2016 Aerodynamics Design Event Poster
2016 Aerodynamics Design Event Poster2016 Aerodynamics Design Event Poster
2016 Aerodynamics Design Event PosterHashan Mendis
 
A way to reduce mass of gearbox housing
A way to reduce mass of gearbox housingA way to reduce mass of gearbox housing
A way to reduce mass of gearbox housingAltair
 
Surrogate Model-Based Reliability Analysis of Composite UAV Wing facilitation...
Surrogate Model-Based Reliability Analysis of Composite UAV Wing facilitation...Surrogate Model-Based Reliability Analysis of Composite UAV Wing facilitation...
Surrogate Model-Based Reliability Analysis of Composite UAV Wing facilitation...Altair
 
Airfield design methods
Airfield design methodsAirfield design methods
Airfield design methodsBhavya Jaiswal
 
Final Year Paper-Designing the 2016 RMIT Aero Package - Hashan Mendis
Final Year Paper-Designing the 2016 RMIT Aero Package - Hashan MendisFinal Year Paper-Designing the 2016 RMIT Aero Package - Hashan Mendis
Final Year Paper-Designing the 2016 RMIT Aero Package - Hashan MendisHashan Mendis
 
Optimization Culture Arena at Volvo Car Group
Optimization Culture Arena at Volvo Car GroupOptimization Culture Arena at Volvo Car Group
Optimization Culture Arena at Volvo Car GroupAltair
 
Mbd 06 kinematic-&_structural_simulation_of_the_automated_infotech
Mbd 06 kinematic-&_structural_simulation_of_the_automated_infotechMbd 06 kinematic-&_structural_simulation_of_the_automated_infotech
Mbd 06 kinematic-&_structural_simulation_of_the_automated_infotechAnand Kumar Chinni
 
Artificial Lift Screening and Selection - Focus on Reservoir Considerations
Artificial Lift Screening and Selection - Focus on Reservoir ConsiderationsArtificial Lift Screening and Selection - Focus on Reservoir Considerations
Artificial Lift Screening and Selection - Focus on Reservoir ConsiderationsAndres Martingano
 
Modeling of weight and vibration reduction using high performance LASD
Modeling of weight and vibration reduction using high performance LASDModeling of weight and vibration reduction using high performance LASD
Modeling of weight and vibration reduction using high performance LASDAltair
 
Large scale topological optimisation: aircraft engine pylon case
Large scale topological optimisation: aircraft engine pylon caseLarge scale topological optimisation: aircraft engine pylon case
Large scale topological optimisation: aircraft engine pylon caseAltair
 
HYDRAULIC TORQUE CONVERTER
HYDRAULIC TORQUE CONVERTERHYDRAULIC TORQUE CONVERTER
HYDRAULIC TORQUE CONVERTERNeha Deshpande
 

What's hot (14)

Design Optimization of Axles using Inspire and OptiStruct
Design Optimization of Axles using Inspire and OptiStructDesign Optimization of Axles using Inspire and OptiStruct
Design Optimization of Axles using Inspire and OptiStruct
 
IHHA 2015
IHHA 2015IHHA 2015
IHHA 2015
 
Structural Component Design Optimization for Additive Manufacture
Structural Component Design Optimization for Additive ManufactureStructural Component Design Optimization for Additive Manufacture
Structural Component Design Optimization for Additive Manufacture
 
2016 Aerodynamics Design Event Poster
2016 Aerodynamics Design Event Poster2016 Aerodynamics Design Event Poster
2016 Aerodynamics Design Event Poster
 
A way to reduce mass of gearbox housing
A way to reduce mass of gearbox housingA way to reduce mass of gearbox housing
A way to reduce mass of gearbox housing
 
Surrogate Model-Based Reliability Analysis of Composite UAV Wing facilitation...
Surrogate Model-Based Reliability Analysis of Composite UAV Wing facilitation...Surrogate Model-Based Reliability Analysis of Composite UAV Wing facilitation...
Surrogate Model-Based Reliability Analysis of Composite UAV Wing facilitation...
 
Airfield design methods
Airfield design methodsAirfield design methods
Airfield design methods
 
Final Year Paper-Designing the 2016 RMIT Aero Package - Hashan Mendis
Final Year Paper-Designing the 2016 RMIT Aero Package - Hashan MendisFinal Year Paper-Designing the 2016 RMIT Aero Package - Hashan Mendis
Final Year Paper-Designing the 2016 RMIT Aero Package - Hashan Mendis
 
Optimization Culture Arena at Volvo Car Group
Optimization Culture Arena at Volvo Car GroupOptimization Culture Arena at Volvo Car Group
Optimization Culture Arena at Volvo Car Group
 
Mbd 06 kinematic-&_structural_simulation_of_the_automated_infotech
Mbd 06 kinematic-&_structural_simulation_of_the_automated_infotechMbd 06 kinematic-&_structural_simulation_of_the_automated_infotech
Mbd 06 kinematic-&_structural_simulation_of_the_automated_infotech
 
Artificial Lift Screening and Selection - Focus on Reservoir Considerations
Artificial Lift Screening and Selection - Focus on Reservoir ConsiderationsArtificial Lift Screening and Selection - Focus on Reservoir Considerations
Artificial Lift Screening and Selection - Focus on Reservoir Considerations
 
Modeling of weight and vibration reduction using high performance LASD
Modeling of weight and vibration reduction using high performance LASDModeling of weight and vibration reduction using high performance LASD
Modeling of weight and vibration reduction using high performance LASD
 
Large scale topological optimisation: aircraft engine pylon case
Large scale topological optimisation: aircraft engine pylon caseLarge scale topological optimisation: aircraft engine pylon case
Large scale topological optimisation: aircraft engine pylon case
 
HYDRAULIC TORQUE CONVERTER
HYDRAULIC TORQUE CONVERTERHYDRAULIC TORQUE CONVERTER
HYDRAULIC TORQUE CONVERTER
 

Similar to Baja Aerodynamics Poster

Baja SAE USB 2010-2011 Portfolio
Baja SAE USB 2010-2011 PortfolioBaja SAE USB 2010-2011 Portfolio
Baja SAE USB 2010-2011 PortfolioReinaldo Wiener
 
SAE Brake Colloquium - Max Radial Downsize Package Wheel Bearing
SAE Brake Colloquium - Max Radial Downsize Package Wheel BearingSAE Brake Colloquium - Max Radial Downsize Package Wheel Bearing
SAE Brake Colloquium - Max Radial Downsize Package Wheel BearingMichael Gromosiak
 
Tractor Trailer Drag Reduction Study
Tractor Trailer Drag Reduction StudyTractor Trailer Drag Reduction Study
Tractor Trailer Drag Reduction StudyChristopher Frasson
 
DESIGN AND AERODYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF A CAR FOR REDUCING DRAG FORCE and LIFT FOR...
DESIGN AND AERODYNAMICANALYSIS OF A CAR FOR REDUCING DRAG FORCE and LIFT FOR...DESIGN AND AERODYNAMICANALYSIS OF A CAR FOR REDUCING DRAG FORCE and LIFT FOR...
DESIGN AND AERODYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF A CAR FOR REDUCING DRAG FORCE and LIFT FOR...Chanderveer Singh
 
Vehicle Light Weighting - A Greener, Composite Solution (for Class A Body Pan...
Vehicle Light Weighting - A Greener, Composite Solution (for Class A Body Pan...Vehicle Light Weighting - A Greener, Composite Solution (for Class A Body Pan...
Vehicle Light Weighting - A Greener, Composite Solution (for Class A Body Pan...OC_Composites
 
dyna cam engine.pptx
dyna cam engine.pptxdyna cam engine.pptx
dyna cam engine.pptxMuhdShabeebA
 
NMSU_Design_Report_2016
NMSU_Design_Report_2016NMSU_Design_Report_2016
NMSU_Design_Report_2016Arthur Cox
 
Engineering case study
Engineering case studyEngineering case study
Engineering case studyLabSharegroup
 
Ground-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ Compressor
Ground-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ CompressorGround-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ Compressor
Ground-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ CompressorPath Marketing Inc.
 
COST-EFFECTIVE COMPOSITE BODY-IN-WHITE FOR MASS PRODUCTION
COST-EFFECTIVE COMPOSITE BODY-IN-WHITE FOR MASS PRODUCTIONCOST-EFFECTIVE COMPOSITE BODY-IN-WHITE FOR MASS PRODUCTION
COST-EFFECTIVE COMPOSITE BODY-IN-WHITE FOR MASS PRODUCTIONDesignTeam8
 
Smoke Control in a Car Park with Cloud Based CFD
Smoke Control in a Car Park with Cloud Based CFDSmoke Control in a Car Park with Cloud Based CFD
Smoke Control in a Car Park with Cloud Based CFDSimScale
 
Streamline Solutions - Elements Vehicle CAE Suite
Streamline Solutions - Elements Vehicle CAE SuiteStreamline Solutions - Elements Vehicle CAE Suite
Streamline Solutions - Elements Vehicle CAE SuiteAngus Lock
 
2023 CalAPA Spring Conference presentation by John Harvey on compaction of as...
2023 CalAPA Spring Conference presentation by John Harvey on compaction of as...2023 CalAPA Spring Conference presentation by John Harvey on compaction of as...
2023 CalAPA Spring Conference presentation by John Harvey on compaction of as...California Asphalt Pavement Association
 

Similar to Baja Aerodynamics Poster (20)

Baja SAE USB 2010-2011 Portfolio
Baja SAE USB 2010-2011 PortfolioBaja SAE USB 2010-2011 Portfolio
Baja SAE USB 2010-2011 Portfolio
 
SAE Brake Colloquium - Max Radial Downsize Package Wheel Bearing
SAE Brake Colloquium - Max Radial Downsize Package Wheel BearingSAE Brake Colloquium - Max Radial Downsize Package Wheel Bearing
SAE Brake Colloquium - Max Radial Downsize Package Wheel Bearing
 
Project_PPT2.pptx
Project_PPT2.pptxProject_PPT2.pptx
Project_PPT2.pptx
 
Tractor Trailer Drag Reduction Study
Tractor Trailer Drag Reduction StudyTractor Trailer Drag Reduction Study
Tractor Trailer Drag Reduction Study
 
DESIGN AND AERODYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF A CAR FOR REDUCING DRAG FORCE and LIFT FOR...
DESIGN AND AERODYNAMICANALYSIS OF A CAR FOR REDUCING DRAG FORCE and LIFT FOR...DESIGN AND AERODYNAMICANALYSIS OF A CAR FOR REDUCING DRAG FORCE and LIFT FOR...
DESIGN AND AERODYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF A CAR FOR REDUCING DRAG FORCE and LIFT FOR...
 
Vehicle Light Weighting - A Greener, Composite Solution (for Class A Body Pan...
Vehicle Light Weighting - A Greener, Composite Solution (for Class A Body Pan...Vehicle Light Weighting - A Greener, Composite Solution (for Class A Body Pan...
Vehicle Light Weighting - A Greener, Composite Solution (for Class A Body Pan...
 
dyna cam engine.pptx
dyna cam engine.pptxdyna cam engine.pptx
dyna cam engine.pptx
 
2022 asphalt compaction presentation by DingXin Cheng
2022 asphalt compaction presentation by DingXin Cheng2022 asphalt compaction presentation by DingXin Cheng
2022 asphalt compaction presentation by DingXin Cheng
 
NMSU_Design_Report_2016
NMSU_Design_Report_2016NMSU_Design_Report_2016
NMSU_Design_Report_2016
 
Engineering case study
Engineering case studyEngineering case study
Engineering case study
 
Ground-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ Compressor
Ground-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ CompressorGround-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ Compressor
Ground-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ Compressor
 
Ground-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ Compressor
Ground-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ CompressorGround-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ Compressor
Ground-Up Re-Engineering of the New CleanCNG™ Compressor
 
Initial presentation
Initial presentationInitial presentation
Initial presentation
 
COST-EFFECTIVE COMPOSITE BODY-IN-WHITE FOR MASS PRODUCTION
COST-EFFECTIVE COMPOSITE BODY-IN-WHITE FOR MASS PRODUCTIONCOST-EFFECTIVE COMPOSITE BODY-IN-WHITE FOR MASS PRODUCTION
COST-EFFECTIVE COMPOSITE BODY-IN-WHITE FOR MASS PRODUCTION
 
Diesel Forum Presentation
Diesel Forum PresentationDiesel Forum Presentation
Diesel Forum Presentation
 
Smoke Control in a Car Park with Cloud Based CFD
Smoke Control in a Car Park with Cloud Based CFDSmoke Control in a Car Park with Cloud Based CFD
Smoke Control in a Car Park with Cloud Based CFD
 
Streamline Solutions - Elements Vehicle CAE Suite
Streamline Solutions - Elements Vehicle CAE SuiteStreamline Solutions - Elements Vehicle CAE Suite
Streamline Solutions - Elements Vehicle CAE Suite
 
Final report SMV
Final report SMVFinal report SMV
Final report SMV
 
2023 CalAPA Spring Conference presentation by John Harvey on compaction of as...
2023 CalAPA Spring Conference presentation by John Harvey on compaction of as...2023 CalAPA Spring Conference presentation by John Harvey on compaction of as...
2023 CalAPA Spring Conference presentation by John Harvey on compaction of as...
 
GDP Viva Slides
GDP Viva SlidesGDP Viva Slides
GDP Viva Slides
 

Baja Aerodynamics Poster

  • 1. 3D Printed Model: Scale 1:18 INTRODUCTION Objective: Study the aerodynamics of the Baja car and reduce its drag coefficient to improve performance. Marvin Bertin, Maximilien Brodel, Kieran Mak, Rahul Rughani • Problem: the firewall on the Baja vehicle produces significant drag and slows the car. • Objective: reduce the drag from the firewall and improve overall performance by designing and manufacturing flow optimized body panels that integrate seamlessly onto the vehicle. • Aerodynamics have never been investigated by McGill Baja. • Other successful teams have added streamlined panels. • Streamlining of trucks could be a source of inspiration as they too have an abrupt aerodynamic profile. BACKGROUND CONCEPT GENERATION CONCEPT EVALUATION Fast Diagram Summary Primary Function Secondary Function Evaluation Criteria Material Criteria • Reduce drag coefficient • Minimize weight gain • Unobtrusive with current car design • Easily Maintained • Streamline vehicle profile • Minimal body panel size • Structurally supported • Access of components • Compatible with car frame • Removable panels • Durable • Lightweight • Smooth surface • Strength • Flexibility • Thin • Water & mud resistant CFD ANALYSIS Concept Drag (N) % Change Drag Lift (N) % Change Lift Datum (MB14) 258.2 NA -110.0 NA MB15 (Baseline) 229.8 -10.99 % -93.5 +15.01 % Concept 0 229.9 -10.94 % -95.0 +13.59 % Concept 1 262.3 +1.58 % -106.6 +3.06 % Concept 2 243.2 -5.81 % -107.5 +2.28 % Concept 3 196.2 -24.00 % -61.7 +43.89 % Concept 4 233.0 -9.75 % -89.3 +18.76 % Concept 1 Concept 2 Concept 3 Concept 4 WIND TUNNEL TESTING 0.95 1 1.05 1.1 1.15 1.2 1.25 40,225 46,929 53,633 56,986 60,338 63,690 67,042 DragCoefficient Reynolds Number Drag Coefficient vs Reynolds Number Baseline Flat Panels Curved Panels Roof Scoop & Curved Panels Concept Average Drag Coefficient % difference with baseline Baseline 1.160 - Flat Panels 1.116 - 3.79% Curved Panels 1.105 - 4.74% Roof Scoop & Curved Panels 1.173 + 1.12% FINAL CONCEPT  Concept 3 (curved panels) obtained best results in CFD and wind tunnel testing Concept 150 ft accel. Accel time saved Lap time Lap time saved MB15 (base car) 5.9 s - 76.12 s - MB 15 + Aero Panels 5.79 s 0.11 s 74.56 s 1.56 s Performance improvement is evaluated with a Matlab drive train simulation program  Over 60 laps, time saved is 1 mn 34 s MANUFACTURING / FASTENERS CONCLUSION Carbon Fiber Panel Manufacturing A&P Technologies +/- 45° biaxial fabric Open mold wet layup with resin 5 plies Vacuum hold, no curing Material Requirements: Lightweight, Durable  D8 DZUS® PANEX Quarter-Turn Fasteners, size 6  Attach panels to chassis Quarter turn: easily removable, tool free Durable: steel plated with chrome  D8 grade, size 6: high ultimate torque and cyclic durability • Results showed improved performance with limited streamlining. Therefore further aerodynamic optimization of the Baja is worthwhile. • CFD determined that adding a roof, as other teams have done, would hurt performance. • Panel design was limited by several constraints. Particularly, engine must be easily accessible. Also, no parts should stick out of the frame as they could break upon impact. Final design was best possible with constraints in mind.  Next step: Testing on finished car  Recommendations:  Consider aerodynamics early on in design process of car. Next frame should be built to integrate streamlining elements, instead of adapting panels to an existing frame.  In the future, optimize flow over front of the car. Department of Mechanical Engineering 2014-2015 Mech Eng Design Project Baseline Final Concept CFD Results ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank McGill Baja Racing, its carbon fiber sponsor A&P Technologies as well as Linus Lehnert, Jasmin de Campos, Alex Marotta and the McGill machinist team.