SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 23
Download to read offline
Safety and Sexual Violence against 
Women and Girls with Disabilities in 
Kumasi and the Ashanti Region 
Nicole Huyser, 1738186 
August, 2013 
Master Health Sciences; International Public Health (30 EC) 
VU Supervisor: Dr. W.H. van Brakel 
On Site Supervisor: Dr. (Sr.) Frances Emily Owusu-Ansah 
Center for Disability and Rehabilitation Studies, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and 
Technology 
Word count: 9056
1. Abstract 
Objective To identify the factors that influence the safety and sexual health of women and girls with 
disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region. Background Although there is a lack of data in Ghana, 
the vulnerability of women and girls with disabilities and with the worldwide underreporting of 
sexual violence against women combined with evidence of sexual violence against women and girls 
with disabilities in Malawi, suggests it may be taking place in Ghana as well. That leads to the 
question: which factors influence the safety and sexual health of women and girls with disabilities in 
Kumasi and the Ashanti region? Methods Purposive sampling and snowball sampling was used to 
draw participants from the study population. Qualitative methods using interviews with a semi-structured 
interview guide of women and girls with disabilities or their primary care taker. Data 
analysis was conducted using a coding guide derived from the multifactorial model of violence. 
Results Twenty-one women and girls with disabilities or their primary care taker were interviewed. 
Eight of the twenty-one women experienced sexual violence. Knowledge of the rights of people with 
disabilities is varied and access to justice is difficult. Conclusion Important risk factors influencing 
sexual violence are a lack of access to justice and a lack of knowledge of their rights. The bond with 
family members is a protective factor. In addition, membership of a DPO, age and the type of 
disability also influence sexual violence victimization. More efforts and research is needed to 
develop a suitable prevention program to reduce sexual violence and increase the level of knowledge 
of sexual health rights for women and girls with disabilities. 
2. Background 
About 15% of the world’s population has some form of disability and this number is increasing (WHO, 
2012). Persons with disabilities often have poorer health outcomes, lower education achievements, 
less economic participation and higher rates of poverty than people without disabilities, but those 
are not their only problems (WHO, 2011). Over the years is has become apparent that there is a 
strong link between disability and abuse (Petersilia, 2001). Numerous studies have shown that 
persons with disabilities have a higher risk of sexual abuse than persons without a disability (Kvam & 
Braathen, 2006) (Martin, et al., 2006) (Calderbank, 2000). In Bangladesh, half of all disabled children 
had been sexually abused and in a Canadian study, 30.5 percent of disabled women had experienced 
sexual violence (Yoshida, DuMont, Odette, & Lysy, 2011) (The News Today, 2010). There is also 
evidence of sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities in Malawi (Kvam & Braathen, 
2008). Factors that contribute to the higher chance on sexual abuse include a lack of accessibility, a 
lack of mobility and social isolation (Plummer & Findley, 2012). 
2.1 Definitions 
According to the United Nations (1994) the term "disability" summarizes a large number of different 
functional limitations occurring in any population in any country of the world. People may be 
disabled by physical, intellectual or sensory impairment, medical conditions or mental illness. Such 
impairments, conditions or illnesses may be permanent or transitory in nature. According to the 
International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF), disability occurs in interaction 
with contextual factors such as environmental and personal factors (WHO, 2012). The WHO defines 
sexual violence as: “Any sexual act, attempt to obtain a sexual act, unwanted sexual comments or 
advances, or acts to traffic, or otherwise directed, against a person’s sexuality using coercion, by any 
person regardless of their relationship to the victim, in any setting, including but not limited to home 
and work.” Sexual violence includes rape, defined as physically forced or otherwise coerced
penetration – even if slight – of the vulva or anus, using a penis, other body parts or an object. The 
attempt to do so is known as attempted rape. Rape of a person by two or more perpetrators is 
known as gang rape. Sexual violence can include other forms of assault involving a sexual organ, 
including coerced contact between the mouth and penis, vulva or anus. A wide range of sexually 
violent acts can take place in different circumstances and settings. These include, but are not limited 
to: 
 rape within marriage or dating relationships; 
 rape by strangers; 
 systematic rape during armed conflict; 
 unwanted sexual advances or sexual harassment, including demanding sex in return for 
favors; 
 sexual abuse of mentally or physically disabled people; 
 sexual abuse of children; 
 forced marriage or cohabitation, including the marriage of children; 
 denial of the right to use contraception or to adopt other measures to protect against 
sexually transmitted diseases; 
 forced abortion; 
 violent acts against the sexual integrity of women, including female genital mutilation 
and obligatory inspections for virginity (WHO, 2007). 
2.2 Underreporting of sexual violence 
Sexual violence is often underreported. A survey done in the United States revealed that only 19.1% 
of women that were raped since their 18th birthday reported this (Tjaden & Thoennes, 2006). A 
similar survey in Canada revealed that only 6% report the crime to the authorities (DuMont, Miller, & 
Myhr, 2003). Fear of retaliation from the rapist, shame and embarrassment, the belief that it was a 
minor incident and fears that the police and prosecutors would question their credibility were 
reasons not to report the crime. Victims are more likely to report the crime when the offender is a 
stranger than when the offender is an acquaintance and victims are more likely to report the crime if 
they feel the probability on a conviction is high (Spohn & Tellis, 2012). For women with disabilities 
there are even more reasons not to report sexual violence. One of which is that many services are 
not accessible for people with disabilities. Also, the behavior of service providers and first responders 
is often insensitive to people with disabilities (Plummer & Findley, 2012). 
2.3 Vulnerability of women and girls with disabilities 
Disabilities make women and girls more vulnerable to abuse because they often need help from 
different caretakers (Sobsey & Mansell, 1994). Lower self-confidence and fewer friendships also 
heighten their vulnerability (Armstrong, Rosenbaum, & King, 1992). They may also have 
communication difficulties and reduced mental capacities which prevents them from reporting the 
abuse and makes them attractive for offenders (Kvam & Braathen, 2008). 
2.4 Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 
The Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities was adopted in 2006 to give extra attention 
to the human rights of persons with disabilities and to provide an international legal framework for 
action against rights abuses. The goal of the Convention is to change how the world sees persons
with disabilities and reaffirm that they have human rights and fundamental freedoms; that they can 
make their own decisions and can be active members of society (UN Enable). Article 12, 13 and 16 of 
the CRPD give attention to the equal recognition before the law, access to justice and freedom from 
exploitation, violence and abuse. Article 23 and article 25 deal with the sexual and reproductive 
rights of persons with disabilities and raising awareness for human rights (United Nations , 2008). 
These rights should provide a legal foundation to take action to protect women and girls with 
disabilities from sexual violence. 
Article 12.3 States Parties shall take appropriate measures to provide access by persons with 
disabilities to the support they may require in exercising their legal capacity. 
Article 13.2 In order to help to ensure effective access to justice for persons with disabilities, States 
Parties shall promote appropriate training for those working in the field of administration of 
justice, including police and prison staff. 
Article 16.2 States Parties shall also take all appropriate measures to prevent all forms of exploitation, 
violence and abuse by ensuring, inter alia, appropriate forms of gender- and age-sensitive 
assistance and support for persons with disabilities and their families and caregivers, including 
through the provision of information and education on how to avoid, recognize and report 
instances of exploitation, violence and abuse. States Parties shall ensure that protection 
services are age-, gender- and disability-sensitive. 
Article 23.1b The rights of persons with disabilities to decide freely and responsibly on the number and 
spacing of their children and to have access to age-appropriate information, reproductive and 
family planning education are recognized, and the means necessary to enable them to exercise 
these rights are provided. 
Article 25d Require health professionals to provide care of the same quality to persons with disabilities 
as to others, including on the basis of free and informed consent by, inter alia, raising 
awareness of the human rights, dignity, autonomy and needs of persons with disabilities 
through training and the promulgation of ethical standards for public and private health care. 
2.5 Models of disability in Ghana 
There are a few models to enable an understanding of disability. In high-income countries the way 
people understand disability often fits in a medical model, a social model or a combination of both. 
The medical model defines people by their medical condition or illness. Someone with a disability has 
a fault that needs to be fixed; they need to become as close to “normal” as possible. The social 
model sees disability as imposed by society because of society’s conception of what is normal and 
because of environmental barriers (Rothman, 2010) (Anthony, 2011). In the past and even still today 
people in Ghana use a religious/magical worldview to understand disability (Avoke, 2002). In the 
religious/magical worldview, disability is seen as a punishment from the gods. The way people with 
disabilities are treated is justified by this belief. This view is still used in some communities and 
although there is shift towards a more social model, the religious/magical worldview still influences 
attitudes towards people with disabilities (Avoke, 2002).
2.6 Problem description 
According to estimations of the WHO, 7 to 9 percent of the Ghanaian population has a disability, in a 
population of 21 million, this means 1.5 - 2.2 million persons. Because Ghana has ratified the CRPD 
and has adopted the Disability Act, it would seem Ghana is well on its way to a life without abuse for 
PWD’s (Human Rights Watch, 2012). However there are no legal mechanisms to enforce this and 
prosecute the offenders (Kanter, 2003). On top of this, access to legal aid is generally unavailable and 
corruption and unreasonable delays create a loss of confidence in the justice system (UNODC, 2011). 
Even when legal aid schemes are available, people who earn a little more than US$ 50 per month do 
not qualify for legal aid although they still cannot afford legal fees (UNODC, 2011). In addition there 
is a geographical unbalance in court distribution; there are more courts in areas with a rising 
economy than in areas with a high population density (AfriMAP, 2007). 
In 2006, the Domestic Violence Victims Support Unit in Ghana recorded 345 cases of rape of children 
and adolescents, 1427 cases of defilement (carnal knowledge of any child under the age of 16 (Ghana 
Legal, 2013)), 52 cases of attempted rape and 4 cases of attempted defilement (Unicef, 2008). The 
records do not specify the sex and age of the victims and there is no mention of them being disabled. 
Furthermore, an estimated 27% of Ghanaian women have been sexually assaulted in their lifetime 
and 1 in 3 women had been touched or fondled against their will according to a national study 
performed by the Gender Studies and Human Rights Documentation Center (2013). Yet again there is 
no mention of these women being disabled or not. 
In a survey that was conducted in 1997 in Ghana, they found that women are most at risk for sexual 
violence between the age of 10 and 18 years. There are certain reasons for Ghanaian women not to 
report violence. In Ghanaian culture, any kind of violence against women is seen as a private matter 
that should not be discussed with others. Therefore violence is often not reported and if it is 
reported, it is not reported to state agencies. Another reason not to report violence is because it will 
negatively affect the woman’s status in society. Also, most offenders were lovers, family members 
and acquaintances, another reason not to report the violence, because of fear of abandonment. And 
lastly, most offenders will not be held responsible for their actions. This makes women doubt the 
effect of reporting violence (Ardayfio-Schandorf, 2005). 
Although there is little research done in Ghana itself, research in other countries suggests that there 
should be cases of abuse of disabled girls and women in Ghana as well. The absence of disabled 
people in the research literature on abuse shows a lack of social awareness and concern, which in 
turn perpetuates the resignation, acceptance and a reluctance of women with disabilities to take 
action against the perpetrators. 
3. Aim and objective, conceptual framework and research 
questions 
3.1 Aim and objective 
The aim is to improve the mechanisms in place to protect women and girls with disabilities from 
sexual violence. Therefor the objective is to identify the factors that influence the safety and sexual 
health of women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region.
3.2 Main research question 
Which factors influence the safety and sexual health of women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi 
and the Ashanti region? 
3.3 Conceptual framework 
To explain all the factors that influence sexual abuse of women and girls with disabilities, the 
multifactorial model of violence is used (Sobsey & Calder, 1999). The model combines other models 
and theories such as the routine activity theory and Skinner’s model of counter-control (Skinner, 
1953). It is the most comprehensive model considering factors that increase victimization of persons 
with disabilities (Petersilia, 2001). 
Environmental Factors 
Person A Person B 
Offender-Related Factors 
Perceived Vulnerability 
Profiles of offenders 
Victim-Related Factors 
Direct effects of 
vulnerability 
Socially mediated effects 
of disability 
Victim Precipitation 
Easy Victims 
Relationship Factors 
Fig. 1 Multifactorial model of violence 
In an equal relationship the power between person A and person B would be equally distributed. In 
the case of a victim (A) and an offender (B), the offender has more power than the victim, hence the 
thick arrow in the model in figure 1 (ICAD, 2008). There are certain factors that influence the 
victimization. 
3.3.1 Victim-related factors 
Victim-related factors are the factors that make a disabled person a probable victim. These factors 
are the direct effects of disability, socially mediated effects, victim precipitation, and victims that are 
easy for offenders. The direct effects of disability are the effects that are forced upon a disabled 
person because of their disability. This can be the dependency on a caregiver; the inability to escape 
or avoid the offender and the inability to seek help, but also the type of disability (Petersilia, 2001). A 
study in Taiwan points out that intellectually disabled people make out more than 50 percent of the 
sexual assault cases reported by PWD (Lin, Yen, Kuo, Wu, & Lin, 2009). Socially mediated effects are 
the effects that come from what they have learned or not learned. People with disabilities are often
not taught their human rights, they do not get sexual education and they are often taught to obey all 
the time and not taught assertiveness or to make their own choices (Groce, 2004). 
Victim precipitation is when a disabled person displays behavior that elicits a reaction from an 
offender. For example when an intellectually disabled person cannot recognize a dangerous situation 
and will therefore do nothing to avoid that situation, which creates an opportunity for an offender. 
Lastly, victims that are attractive for offenders have characteristics that motivate the offender to 
abuse the victim, as vulnerability alone is not enough for abuse. These motivating factors are: 
- Control over the victim: the offender wants control over the victim and uses abuse to get 
that control (Gilson, DePoy, & Cramer, 2001). 
- Sex: the offender is sexually attracted to people with specific disabilities. 
- Money: the victim receives money and the offender wants that money and will abuse the 
victim to get it. 
- Few alternatives to exploitation: the victim remains in the situation in which the abuse is 
taking place because the victim has few alternatives (Petersilia, 2001). For example, lack of 
access to justice will keep the offender out of jail and in the proximity of the victim. 
3.3.2 The offender-related factors 
The offender-related factors are the perceived vulnerability and the profiles of the offenders. 
Perceived vulnerability is the way the offender sees the victim as vulnerable; because the victim has 
a mental disability the crime will not be reported and the offender can get away with it or the victim 
is paralyzed and will not be able to fight the offender off. This may not be reality, but it adds to the 
risk of victimization (Petersilia, 2001). The media adds to this perceived vulnerability by portraying 
people with disabilities as helpless. 
Some of the offenders fit certain profiles of offenders. For caregivers, who make up a large part of all 
offenders, there are two types of offenders, the predatory caregiver and the corrupted caregiver 
(Sobsey & Calder, 1999). The predatory caregivers usually have feelings of inadequacy, a lack of 
control and the need to have control over vulnerable people (Crossmaker, 1991). They seek to be in 
the proximity of disabled people and they often plan their offenses. The corrupted caregiver can be a 
good caregiver but a lack of training, supervision or policy can result in abusive behavior. Often the 
abusive behavior starts gradually and without planning. However, not all abuse is committed by 
caregivers. Abuse can also be committed by other people with disabilities. This can be explained by 
the lifestyles exposure model. A lot of people with disabilities live in groups. This increases the 
exposure of potential victims to offenders with disabilities (Petersilia, 2001). These offenders with 
disabilities can be abused by caregivers and therefor start abusing other people; some may have 
brain damage that leads to reduced control over impulsive behavior and a lack of inhibition. 
3.3.3 Relationship Factors 
The relationships that persons with disabilities have influence the risk of abuse. Dependency on 
others, such as caregivers, increases the risk of abuse because of power inequities (Crossmaker, 
1991). When there are more contacts with caregivers, the risk that one of them will be abusive 
increases. A good connection with family members decreases the risk of abuse.
3.3.4 Environmental factors 
There are certain environmental factors that influence the risk of abuse. This can be living in 
institutions or group homes, being born in an abusive family or exposure to high risk environment, 
because the disability affects the routine activities, for example because of the disability the victim 
has to take a different route from home to work (Petersilia, 2001) (Crossmaker, 1991). 
3.4 Specific research questions 
Based on the conceptual model and the main research question, specific research questions were 
formulated: 
1. What do women and girls know of their rights in relation to safety and sexual health? 
2. What are the experiences of WWD in urban and rural areas with access to legal justice 
systems? 
3. What experiences do the WWD in the Ashanti region have with sexual exploitation and 
abuse? 
4. What factors of the multifactorial model of violence are influencing sexual violence against 
women and girls with disabilities? 
4. Methods 
4.1 Study design 
An exploratory study was conducted because the perspective of the women and girls with disabilities 
on the vulnerability for sexual violence is important to raise more awareness for this important and 
undervalued subject. 
4.2 Study Population and study sample 
The study took place in Kumasi and the Ashanti region. The Ashanti region is the biggest region in 
Ghana in terms of population and has the least equal allocation of health funds between the regions 
(Asante, Zwi, & Ho, 2006). All women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region were 
the study population; to select participants from the study population, the following inclusion and 
exclusion criteria were used. 
4.2.1 Inclusion criteria 
The inclusion criteria include: 
 Women and girls with disabilities (from the age of 10); 
 Primary care takers of women and girls with disabilities who are not able to communicate. 
4.2.2 Exclusion criteria 
The exclusion criteria include: 
 Women and girls with a disability that is not permanent; 
 Women and girls refusing informed consent; 
 Women and girls that offer communication difficulties and who do not have a primary care 
taker present.
4.3 Sample size and sampling method 
Purposive sampling and snowball sampling was used to draw participants from the study population. 
With the assistance of the Ghana Society for the Physically Disabled and members of the Ghana Blind 
Union, women were contacted by phone and asked if they were willing to participate. Some of the 
women knew other disabled women that would also want to participate. Also, the Ashanti School for 
the Deaf in Jamasi was contacted and a few students agreed to participate. In total 21 interviews 
were conducted. The age ranged from 15 to 65. Six of the interviewees were with primary care takers 
because the woman or girl in question was not able to respond to questions. Of the 21 respondents, 
ten were members of a DPO and eleven were not. 
4.4 Method of measurement 
In order to obtain the valuable information needed to get insight in the safety and sexual health of 
women and girls with disabilities, semi-structured interviews were conducted. Because of the 
sensitive nature face-to-face interviews were held instead of focus group discussion. The interviews 
were conducted using an interview guide with questions based on the concepts mentioned in the 
conceptual framework. The interviews were mostly conducted at the homes of the participants or a 
place near their work and at the Ashanti School for the Deaf. With consent of the participants the 
interviews were audio-recorded. The recorded interviews have been deleted after transcription and 
analysis of the interviews. 
4.5 Method of analysis 
The audio-recorded interviews were transcribed verbatim. The analysis of the interviews was done 
using Weft QDA. Weft QDA is a free qualitative data analysis program. The data was analyzed by 
performing a directed content analysis. Before starting data analysis a coding guide was constructed 
based on the concepts of the conceptual framework. With the coding guide fragments were coded 
accordingly. Any fragments that could not be categorized using the coding guide were given new 
codes (Hsieh & Shannon, 2005). 
5. Results 
The study sample consisted of 21 women and girls, of which six had a physical disability, five had an 
intellectual disability, three were visually impaired and another three were hearing impaired. Their 
age ranged from 15 to 64 and, except for four respondents, lived in an urban area. Nearly half (48%) 
of the respondents were members of a DPO. Eight of the 21 women and girls experienced sexual 
violence; three were intellectually disabled, one was visually impaired and four were hearing 
impaired. None of the women and girls that were members of a DPO experienced sexual violence. 
The themes the respondents were questioned about were their experience and knowledge of the 
rights of PWD, their experiences with and knowledge of the legal justice system and their 
experiences with sexual exploitation and abuse and other factors that might influence sexual 
exploitation and abuse of WWD. 
5.1 Rights 
All the women were questioned about reproductive health and family planning education, the legal 
justice system, the treatment of women with disabilities by the health care system and about equal 
rights in general.
5.1.1 Equal rights 
Almost all of the women participating in this study felt they do not have the same rights as women 
without disabilities because they cannot do the same things women without disabilities can do. A 
physically disabled woman (A.M.) mentions, 
“Because of their level of education it doesn’t allow them to enjoy the same rights as those without 
disabilities. And even in the family, those with disabilities aren’t allowed to go, because they question 
the relevance of education for them. That’s why it is not the same.” 
Another physically disabled woman (R.A.) feels disabled women cannot be compared to persons 
without disabilities. Two women felt they have the same rights as women without disabilities, on this 
a physically disabled woman (A.A.) said, “I have given birth because of that. I am aware of the rights. I 
know those rights exist; I have given birth because of that.” 
5.1.2 Treatment by the health care system 
The opinions on the treatment by the health care system are varied. Some women feel they are 
treated the same as persons without disabilities. A physically disabled woman said, “It is the same. 
But the problem is that when I go to the hospital, I have to stand in the cue for a long time just like 
any other person. But normally the treatment is the same.” Other women, however, feel they are 
treated different because of their disability. One visually impaired woman (M.O.) mentioned that she 
was being shouted at by a nurse when she came in to deliver. The deaf women and girls said that 
they are treated differently because in in the hospital there are no sign language interpreters so they 
cannot communicate with the hospital staff. 
5.1.3 Family planning education 
Most women see reproductive and family planning education as a means to space up the number of 
children. The women below the age of 30 received some reproductive and family planning education 
at school; some of the older women received family planning education at meetings with their DPO 
and some were given information about spacing up the pregnancies at the hospital when going in for 
labor or at church. But most didn’t get any education about the reproductive system and family 
planning. According to a physically disabled woman (S.O.), “At the hospital that is the only place 
where they normally give family planning education. Apart from that there is no other place.” When 
asked about whether or not women and girls with disabilities should receive such education a deaf 
woman (A.A.) said, “When you are young and you are taught… given such education, some will be 
tempted to practice some of that. That is why it is very bad when you are young.” 
5.1.4 Access to justice 
There are certain problems the women mention when it comes to accessing the legal system. 
Transport to and from the police station is a problem because taxi drivers are reluctant to pick up 
physically disabled women: “They normally prefer picking others than those that are disabled” (S.O.). 
There also need to be ramps to get physical access to the police station. Some know about the 
Disability Act but feel the laws are often not enacted. Money is also a problem, ‘you have to have 
money or find someone else who is willing to assist you to get justice’ or as R.A. puts it, “Unless you 
get a respectable person who can help you when you get problems, that can lead you. Without that
there is nothing that you can do.” None of the deaf women and girls had any knowledge of laws 
being in place: “We do not have anything like that for disabled in Ghana” (J.K.). 
5.2 Safety 
Also included in the interview guide were questions about if they feel they are well protected from 
violence and abuse, about the vulnerability of women and girls with disabilities, the influence of the 
community views and what they think could be done to improve the safety of women and girls with 
disabilities. 
5.2.1 Protection from violence and abuse 
When questioned if women and girls with disabilities are sufficiently protected from sexual violence 
and abuse, almost all of the women feel that they are not well protected. They say they are being 
discriminated against, verbally abused and submitted to beatings. One physically disabled woman 
(A.A.) said, “I may be alone in the house and someone comes in when the place is very quiet. We are 
protected by law but these situations make us prone to sexual violence.” Some mention DPOs as a 
protective factor because when something happens, their organization makes sure justice is done 
but it is also mentioned that in the villages it is harder to reach the organizations. They also say that 
they know there are laws that should protect them, but the laws are not enacted and that is why 
they feel they are not well protected, “We are not much protected by law. Although there are laws 
taking care of all of us but we are not well taken care of” (A.M.). 
5.2.2 Vulnerability 
The women that reported not to have been a victim of sexual violence were asked about the 
vulnerability of WWD with respect to sexual violence. Money has come up as an influence; most of 
the disabled women are not working so they can easily be influenced by men offering money or gifts. 
And one visually impaired woman (M.O.) told us, 
“There was a deaf person who lives in a compound house and because she was sleeping alone in the 
room, at dawn some people were sneaking in to go having an affair with her. Although they knew her 
condition and she was alone and cannot report. That was what they used to do on a daily basis. 
When she became pregnant, they will not see anybody who will come and take responsibility for it.” 
Although not all women see the same dangers as described in the previous quote; one visually 
impaired woman (A.O.) brings up that the disabled are not the most vulnerable because: 
“In our society people wouldn’t even think of going to a person with a disability because they think it 
is an abomination. Secondly, when the person is pregnant you may give birth to a child with a 
disability as well, so that scares them and prevents them from trying to abuse people sexually.” 
5.2.3 Community views on disabled people 
The mother of an intellectually disabled woman (A.M.) said that her daughter gets teased a lot 
because of her condition. Some people are afraid of coming to people with a disability and they look 
at them strangely and some of the women feel the community does not regard them as human 
beings: “Because people see us as if we are sick, so if there is something, they do not regard us as 
humans”(E.O). A feeling of neglect by the community is also present:
“Before I came blind, they used to involve me in community activities but since I became blind they 
have not even called me. It seems they don’t even know me. They neglect me and don’t tell me 
anything.”(S.J.) 
5.2.4 Improvements for safety 
The opinions of what can be done to improve the safety of women and girls with disabilities varied. It 
was mentioned that the family should take better care of them. Also, for disabled women to be 
working would make them less vulnerable for sexual exploitation, according to V.O. a physically 
disabled woman, 
“When they see that you are weak, like you are poor and do not have the necessary finances, they can 
make approaches. But if you are working and you have the means of life, you are very well protected 
against such things.” 
Raising more awareness and educating the community and disabled persons is also mentioned by 
multiple women as a means to improve safety. 
5.3 Sexual violence 
All women and primary care takers were asked if they or the woman they are responsible for ever 
experienced any kind of sexual exploitation or abuse. Nine women said they never heard about 
things like that happening, four women said they heard about it and eight of the woman and girls 
were victims of sexual violence. Half of these women and girls had an intellectual disability and the 
other half was hearing impaired. One visually impaired woman was approached by four different 
men to have an affair but according to her nothing happened. A deaf woman (A.A.) said, 
“When I was in primary 4, we were staying in a village. So my grandmother went to farm and she 
asked me to prepare food and bring it to her. So when I was going on the way a man met me, a man 
forced me and had sex with me. That was the first one. Also another one, another boy tried to rape 
me but then I was able to… by that time I was taught to protect myself. So I bite the boy and he left 
running.” 
The frequency of the sexual violence ranged from one to four times. The age of the seven women 
when it started ranges from 9 to 20 years old. Except for one deaf woman who cannot explain why 
she feels that way, all of the other women and girls feel the disability influenced the victimization. 
One deaf girl (B.A.) said, “There were so many girls of my age but none of them went into that 
problem. But I am disabled, that is why the boy called me to the bush.” And C.Y. the aunt of an 
intellectually disabled woman mentioned that her niece was taken for granted by the man, but that 
she had not seen it only heard others talk about it. If she had seen it, the offender would have to pay 
money for compensation. 
5.3.1 Offender 
None of the women were assaulted by family members, but most of the time it was someone in their 
close proximity; living in the same house or the same village. One girl was raped at school by another 
student and at the home of a teacher. The mother of an intellectually disabled woman (T.A.) said 
about the offender: “It is a drunkard who has been doing that. He has not been taking care of her. He 
didn’t give her anything. It is just a drunkard who is staying in the community.” One intellectually
disabled woman (A.S.) said that the offender gave her gifts and she felt it got to a point where she 
felt obliged to have sex with him. 
5.3.2 Bond with family members and friends 
Most women feel that if disabled women and girls have a good relationship with their family it will 
protect them from sexual violence. The mother of a disabled woman (A.M.) never lets her daughter 
out of her sight, 
“Looking at how I take care of my daughter, I don’t let her roam about. There are some people… the 
family has abandoned them, so they just roam about. They become… the people can easily get to 
them. In my case, I don’t allow that. We are always together, so it is not easy for people to come up 
to her.” 
If there is a problem it can be discussed within the family and the family will solve the problem and 
the family can give support financially. This is not sufficient protection according to physically 
disabled S.O., “regardless of whether you have a good relation with your family or not, the men will 
come around and maltreat you.” The deaf women and girls do not have a good relationship with 
their family because their families do not know sign language, as A.A. brought up: “I explained it to 
my grandmother but she did not understand. She doesn’t know sign language.” 
5.3.3 Reporting sexual exploitation and abuse 
The women that were victimized were asked if their cases were reported but none of them did. They 
had various reasons not to report their cases. One of the deaf women (A.A.) lived in a village where 
there is no police station present. The mother of intellectually disabled T.A. reports not having the 
money to pay the police and the transportation to go to the police station to report, “I am not having 
money so to be able to get to the police station, the means of transport and also… when you go to the 
police station they ask you to get proof of that and all of this involves money.” Two of the care takers 
told us that they did not report the sexual violence because they heard about it from other tenants 
living in the same house. One of them said: “It is not necessary to report since we have not seen it 
ourselves.” The woman that was approached by four different men responded when asked if she 
went to the police to report: “I do not think it is serious that is why I did not report it.” 
The women that were not victimized said they would go to the police station, to the family, to their 
DPO or to the village leaders to report if they were victims of sexual violence. As reasons why others 
might not report sexual violence, transportation is mentioned again. In addition, they find the case 
not serious enough when there is no visible injury, they do not like talking about their personal issues 
and they think that the police would not take them seriously. The mother of an intellectually disabled 
woman (A.T.) said about this, “Such people with such conditions, they can’t talk. So based on that, 
even if you go and report… they will treat it like… they will not follow up and just throw the case out.”
6. Discussion and conclusion 
6.1 What do women and girls know of their rights in relation to safety 
and sexual health? 
Most women interviewed did not experience the same rights as women and girls without disabilities. 
Some know that there are rights, especially the women that are a member of a DPO. However the 
intellectually disabled do not have any knowledge on their rights on safety and sexual health. At the 
DPOs they get education about their rights and some reproductive and family planning education 
and it is the place where they have their social contacts, where they can discuss these kinds of issues 
with their peers. However, the women who are not a member of DPO display a lower level of 
education and have less knowledge about their rights in relation to safety and sexual health and for 
most women the only reproductive and family planning education they received was when going to 
the hospital to deliver. This is in compliance with the findings from multiple other studies (Groce, 
2004) (Calderbank, 2000) (Isler, Beytut, Tas, & Conk, 2009) (McKenzie, 2013) (Rohleder & Swartz, 
2009). McKenzie (2013) feels that health services should be responsible for educating disabled 
people about their sexual rights. According to Isler et al. (2009) the responsibility of educating 
intellectually disabled about sexual health lies with the parents and the parents should be guided in 
their efforts to educate their intellectually disabled children. While Rohleder & Swartz (2009) feel 
that education for intellectually disabled about sexual health and HIV should be incorporated into the 
main stream campaigns and in schools. In Ghana most sexual health education focuses on HIV/AIDS 
prevention and education about sexual rights is not being taught at schools because of objections as 
a result of cultural and religious beliefs from parents and churches (Owusu, 2012). It is important to 
teach disabled women and girls with disabilities about their rights in relation to safety and sexual 
health because it teaches them to recognize which practices are normal and which are abnormal and 
empowers them to make decisions in difficult situations (Barger, Wacker, Macy, & Parish, 2009). 
6.2 What are the experiences of WWD in urban and rural areas with 
access to legal justice systems? 
Although Ghana has a special unit to deal with sexual violence, the Domestic Violence Victims 
Support Unit, none of the victimized women reported the abuse they experienced to official 
agencies, which support the findings from a survey done in 1998 (Boakye, 2009). One of the women 
even said that in her village there is no police present. This is the only difference between rural and 
urban in relation to access to justice found in this study. The women living in rural and urban areas 
face the same obstacles in their access to the legal justice system; the need for money to pay the 
police, the need for transportation; the fear of not being taken seriously. This is in line with what was 
found about police corruption and unequal court distributions in a review (AfriMAP, 2007). 
6.3 What experiences do the WWD in the Ashanti region have with 
sexual exploitation and abuse? 
As expected, sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities is taking place in the Ashanti 
region. Although Ardayfio-Schandorf (2005) finds in her research in Ghana that most women are 
victimized by people close to them, often family members, none of the women that were victims in 
this study reported the offender to be family members or spouses. The offenders were mostly 
people living in the same community. Some of the primary care takers mentioned that if the offender 
would give something in return or apologize, the case would be solved and also if the woman does
not get pregnant it is not very important. In Ghana, receiving gifts in return for sex is socially 
accepted and sometimes even encouraged (Baba-Djara, et al., 2013). After conversations with the 
women and girls that have participated in this study, I feel that accepting a gift or an apology after 
having experienced sexual violence does not make it any less traumatic. The emotions on their faces 
show that, even if the violence happened years ago, it is still difficult for them, especially when still 
living in close proximity to the offender. 
6.4 What factors of the multifactorial model of violence are influencing 
sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities? 
6.4.1 Victim related factors 
The victim related factors are elements that cause the disabled woman or girl to be at risk of sexual 
violence. This can be the age, gender, lifestyle, the socioeconomic status or the disability. As 
mentioned before the knowledge of their rights in relation to safety and sexual health is an 
important factor influencing sexual violence. The women and girls that experienced sexual violence 
were between the ages of nine and twenty-one when the sexual abuse or exploitation took place. 
This gives an average age of almost fifteen years which concurs with the survey done in 1997 that 
revealed that women in Ghana were most at risk for sexual violence between the ages of ten and 
eighteen (Ardayfio-Schandorf, 2005). In South-Africa Dickman and Roux (2005) assessed 100 sexual 
violence cases reported by people with an intellectual disability. They found that the average age of 
the sexual violence was 18 years and 5 months and 40,4 percent was under the age of 16. Another 
study in South Africa by Human Rights Watch (2001) found that women in general were most at risk 
for sexual violence between the age of 12-17. In a study carried out in Swaziland in women age 13- 
24, they found that 33 percent experienced some form of sexual violence before reaching the age of 
18 (WHO Regional Office for Africa, 2012). This suggests that age is also a factor influencing sexual 
violence that should be taken into account when developing a prevention program. The nature of the 
disability is also an important factor. The deaf women are not able to communicate with their family 
and the people in the community; this makes them easy victims for offenders. The primary care 
takers of the intellectually disabled women that experienced sexual violence mention that they have 
little control over what their protégés do and that they walk around alone often, which makes them 
easy victims. Also, because there is a lack of access to justice the offenders can stay in the proximity 
of the victims. 
6.4.2 Offender-related factors 
One offender-related factor is the relationship of the offender with the victim. As mentioned earlier, 
the offenders were not family members, spouses or care takers. Another offender related factor is 
the perceived vulnerability. An important influence on the perceived vulnerability is how the 
community sees women and girls with disabilities (Boakye, 2009). The women report that the 
community does not see them as human beings. They see them as sick and weak. According to a 
study by Bones (2013) disabled women with a visible sign of impairment are seen as very easy victims 
because they are viewed as less capable of engaging in self-guardianship. In the same study Bones 
(2013) argues that: “What constitutes a good victim is determined by societal beliefs about certain 
attributes and behaviors, many of which are uncontrollable and permanent.” The perceived
vulnerability of women in general is ingrained in society (Hollander, 2001). It is nearly impossible to 
change this perception in a few years. I believe it will take another decade to change this perception. 
This will make it even harder to change the perceived vulnerability of disabled women and girls 
because that will take an extra step. 
6.4.3 Relationship factors 
This study confirms the theory of Sobsey and Calder (1999) that the bond with family members and 
friends is an important influencing factor on the victimization of the disabled. The deaf women and 
girls did not have a good bond with their family members because they could not communicate with 
them. With the intellectually disabled women there was a clear distinction between primary care 
takers that had a good bond with their protégé and the primary care takers that did not have a good 
bond with their protégé. The intellectually disabled women that experienced sexual violence were 
not kept in sight and were able to walk around alone, while the intellectually disabled women who 
did not experience sexual violence were kept in constant sight of their primary care taker. Also, some 
of the women had heard stories of other disabled women who were abandoned by their families and 
therefore taken advantage of. According to Bones (2013)being isolated from others increases the risk 
of victimization by 54%. The offender feels that the possible victim is going to tell family members or 
friends about what happened and he could get into trouble because of that, he will not approach the 
possible victim. Therefor the bond with family members and friends is a protective factor. 
6.4.4 Environmental factors 
In Ghana religion is very important. Often, legal action against offenders is not taken because they 
feel everything is in the hands of God. This will keep the offenders in the proximity of the victims and 
the victims unable to escape the sexual violence. Also, one woman feels her daughter does not need 
reproductive and family planning education because she leaves it in the hands of God and will accept 
anything that happens. According to the Bible sexual violence is wrong: “But fornication, and all 
uncleanness, or covetousness, let it not be once named among you, as becometh saints; Neither 
filthiness, nor foolish talking, nor jesting, which are not convenient: but rather giving of thanks. For 
this ye know, that no whoremonger, nor unclean person, nor covetous man, who is an idolater, hath 
any inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and of God” (Hidden Hurt, 2012). Also, according to the 
Quran rape is forbidden and punishable by death (Huda, 2013). In theory these religions should 
prevent possible offenders from committing sexual violence and should encourage women and girls 
with disabilities to report sexual violence. However, according to Franiuk & Shain (2011) religion 
endorses rape myth acceptance. In the Muslim culture, for example, family honor is very important. 
Sexual violence brings dishonor to a family. Boakye (2009) uses the following definition for rape 
myths: prejudicial, stereotyped, or false beliefs about rape, rape victims, and rapists, which serve to 
create a climate hostile to rape victims. This will prevent victims from reporting sexual violence. Rape 
myth acceptance is present in Ghana, but unlike the findings from Franiuk & Shain (2011) religion is 
not associated with rape myth acceptance but with gender, education and age. Males and older 
people have a higher level of rape myth acceptance. Education lowers the level of rape myth 
acceptance (Boakye, 2009). 
6.5 Strengths and limitations 
One limitation was that the interpreter and the sign language interpreter were both males. Although 
eight cases of sexual violence were found and most of the women appeared to be very open and 
honest about themselves, the male interpreters could have held back some of the women. The
decision to stick to the male interpreters was because they were volunteers and money was an issue, 
they were knowledgeable on the subject and the sign language interpreter was trusted by the deaf 
women and girls and knew about their situation already. A comparison of sexual violence and access 
to justice between rural and urban areas is difficult to make as there were only four women from 
rural areas included in this study. As with the problem with access to justice in rural areas, reaching 
DPOs is also difficult which makes it harder to find participants in rural areas. Also, the sample size is 
small, which makes the findings not generalizable to the whole of Ghana and even the Ashanti 
region. This notwithstanding, the strength of this study is that it includes women and girls with 
intellectual disabilities, visual impairments, hearing impairments and physical disabilities. This makes 
the differences in the experience of sexual violence between the different disabilities identifiable. 
Also, this study is important because there is little research done on sexual violence against women 
and girls with disabilities in Ghana and this study provides recommendations to improve the safety 
situation of the disabled women and girls. 
6.6 Conclusions and Recommendations 
6.6.1 Conclusion 
There are a lot of factors that influence the safety and sexual health of women and girls with 
disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti Region. There are protective factors and risk factors. Factors 
that can be changed and factors that cannot be changed. DPO membership and a good bond with 
family members and friends are protective factors and these can be influenced by an intervention 
program. Risk factors are a lack of knowledge of the rights of women and girls with disabilities in 
relation to safety and sexual health, a lack of access to the legal justice system and the perceived 
vulnerability. A lack of knowledge and a lack of access to the legal justice system can be changed. The 
perceived vulnerability, however, cannot be changed that easily. Other factors that influence sexual 
violence against women and girls with disabilities are age and the type of disability a person has. The 
women and girls that experienced sexual violence were between the 9 and 21 years old when the 
sexual violence took place. Also, women and girls with a hearing impairment or who are intellectually 
disabled are more vulnerable for sexual violence than women that are visually impaired or physically 
disabled. 
6.6.2 What do women and girls know of their rights in relation to safety and 
sexual health? 
The overall knowledge of the women and girls with disabilities or their primary care taker is low. 
Most information about sexual health the women get is at the hospital when going in to give birth or 
at meetings from their DPOs. It is evident that DPOs educate women on sexual health and human 
rights, which will increase the level of knowledge of women and girls with disabilities and makes 
them less prone to sexual violence. Information about their rights in relation to safety and sexual 
health should also be taught at school and by the parents. When teaching the disabled girls about 
safety and sexual health rights in school the right age group can be reached. In a review by Barger, 
Wacker, Macy & Parish (2009) only four sexual violence intervention programs for women with 
intellectual disabilities were found. These four programs were assessed. Although none of the 
programs was able to evaluate if the programs actually reduced sexual violence victimization. The 
most promising intervention program was a program called ESCAPE by Khemka, Hickson & Reynolds 
(2005) that empowered the women with a self-directed decision making training so they were able
to recognize the difference between healthy and abusive interaction and make decisions accordingly. 
Barger, Wacker, Macy & Parish (2009) found the program promising but concluded that more 
research into intervention programs and their effectiveness was needed. Interventions for women 
against sexual violence are not directed at WWD. These intervention programs are mostly directed at 
university students in the United States and often consist of self-defense training. Of these 
intervention programs the effectiveness is not proven. Overall there is a lack of effective intervention 
programs for WWD dealing with sexual violence. More research is needed to develop suitable 
intervention programs for women and girls with disabilities. 
6.6.3 What are the experiences of WWD in urban and rural areas with access to 
legal justice systems? 
Most of the women have no experience with the legal justice system. Reaching legal justice systems 
is hard and money is needed. They would rather solve problems within their community than going 
to the police station. To get offenders prosecuted and to get the law enacted and work as a deterrent 
for offenders, transparent and easy to access information should become available for the women 
and girls with disabilities. DPOs could play an important role in getting this information to the women 
and girls. In addition, the government should take responsibility to ensure the law is enforced and 
people with disabilities can make use of their rights. 
6.6.4 What experiences do the WWD in the Ashanti region have with sexual 
exploitation and abuse? 
The deaf and intellectually disabled women and girls have experience with sexual exploitation and 
abuse. The visually impaired and physically disabled do not have any experience with sexual 
exploitation and abuse. It is noteworthy to mention that none of the women that experienced sexual 
violence were members of any DPO. An increased effort from the DPOs is needed to reach the 
women and girls in the more secluded areas to teach them the necessary tools to be able to avoid or 
escape sexual violence such as taught in the ESCAPE program. Special attention should be given to 
the intellectually disabled and their caretakers and the hearing impaired. These groups appear to be 
more vulnerable than the physically disabled and the visually impaired because they often encounter 
communication difficulties. Additionally the women and girls with disabilities and their caretakers 
should be made aware that transactional sex is not acceptable and that sexual violence should be 
reported to the official agencies. 
6.6.5 What factors of the multifactorial model of violence are influencing sexual 
violence against women and girls with disabilities? 
Most of the factors described in the multifactorial model of violence also apply in the Ashanti region. 
Some of the factors of the multifactorial model of violence are factors that can be influenced and 
changed; other factors are impossible or nearly impossible to change. The victim related factors that 
influence sexual violence are age, the type of disability, level of knowledge of their sexual health 
rights and a lack of access to the legal justice system. Interventions are not able to change someone’s 
age or the type of disability someone has, focus should lie on increasing the level of knowledge and 
ensuring the legal justice system is physically accessible and financially accessible. An offender 
related factor that influences sexual violence is the perceived vulnerability. This is a factor that is 
nearly impossible to change. To change the relationship factors, to improve the relationship with 
family members and friends, the views of the family members on their disabled family members
need to be changed. They need to be informed about the value of disabled people, that disabled can 
contribute something to the family and the community. In addition to the multifactorial model, being 
a member of a DPO also seems to be a protective factor as none of the women that were a member 
of a DPO experienced sexual violence. Ghana is a very religious country, Christianity and the Islam are 
against sexual violence. However, at this moment it does not stimulate the women and girls with 
disabilities or their caretakers to take action against sexual violence. There is an opportunity for an 
intervention to educate spiritual leaders so they can encourage women and girls with disabilities to 
report sexual violence. 
It is important to realize that one intervention that is appropriate for all types of disabilities is not 
possible as every disability and every individual has different needs.
7. References 
AfriMAP. (2007). Ghana: Justice Sector and the Rule of Law. South Africa: Open Society Initiative for West 
Africa. 
Anthony, J. (2011). Conceptualising disability in Ghana: implications for EFA and inclusive education. 
International Journal of Inclusive Education(15:10), 1073-1086. 
Ardayfio-Schandorf, E. (2005). Violence against women: The Ghanaian Case. Switzerland: UN Division for the 
Advancement of Women. 
Armstrong, R. W., Rosenbaum, P. L., & King, S. (1992). Self-perceived social function among disabled children in 
regular classrooms. Journal of Developmental and Behavioural Pediatrics(13), 12-20. 
Asante, A. D., Zwi, A. B., & Ho, M. T. (2006). Equity in resource allocation for health: A comparative studyof the 
Ashanti and Northern Regions of Ghana. Health Policy(78), 135-148. 
Avoke, M. (2002). Models of Disability in the Labelling and Attitudinal Discours in Ghana. Disability & 
Society(17:7), 769-777. 
Baba-Djara, M., Brennan, A., Corneliess, C., Agyarko-Poku, T., Akuoko, K., Opoku, K. B., et al. (2013). “Using 
what you have to get what you want”: Vulnerability to HIV and Prevention Needs of Female Post- 
Secondary Students Engaged in Transactional Sex in Kumasi, Ghana. USAID Ghana. 
Barger, E., Wacker, J., Macy, R., & Parish, S. (2009, August). Sexual Assault Prevention for Women With 
Intellectual Disabilities: A Criticial Review of the Evidence. Intellectual and Developmental 
Disabilities(47:4), 249-262. 
Boakye, K. E. (2009). Attitudes Toward Rape and Victims of Rape: A Test of the Feminist Theory in Ghana. 
Journal of Interpersonal Violence(24:10), 1633-1651. 
Boeije, H. (2005). Analyseren kwalitatief onderzoek. Stappenplan kwalitatief onderzoek. Amsterdam: Boom 
Onderwijs. 
Bones, P. D. (2013). Perceptions of Vulnerability: A Target Characteristics Approach to Disability, Gender, and 
Victimization. Deviant Behavior(34:9), 727-750. 
Calderbank, R. (2000). Abuse and Disabled People: Vulnerability or social indifference. Disability & 
Society(15:3), 521-534. 
Crossmaker, M. (1991). Behind Locked Doors - Instituational Sexual Abuse. Sexuality And Disability(9:3), 201- 
219. 
Dickman, B. J., & Roux, A. J. (2005). Complainants with learning disabilities in sexual abuse cases: a 10-year 
review of a psycho-legal project in Cape Town, South Africa. British Journal of Learning Disabilities(33), 
138-144. 
DuMont, J., Miller, K.-L., & Myhr, T. L. (2003). The Role of “Real Rape” and “Real Victim” Stereotypes in the 
Police Reporting Practices of Sexually Assaulted Women. Violence Against Women(9:4), 466-486. 
Franiuk, R., & Shain, E. A. (2011). Beyond Christianity: The Status of Women and Rape Myths. Sex Roles(65), 
783-791.
Gender Studies and Human Rights Documentation Centre. (2013). Statistics on Sexual Violence in Ghana. 
Retrieved March 24th, 2013, from Gender Studies and Human Rights Documentation Centre: 
http://www.gendercentreghana.org/statistics-on-sexual-violence-in-ghana/ 
Ghana Legal. (2013). Ghana legal. Retrieved October 01, 2013, from Criminal Offences Act: 
http://ghanalegal.com/?id=3&law=19&t=ghana-laws 
Gilson, S. F., DePoy, E., & Cramer, E. P. (2001). Linking the Assessment of Self-Reported Functional Capacity 
With Abuse Experiences of Women With Disabilities. Violence Against Women(7:4), 418-431. 
Groce, N. E. (2004). Adolescents And Youth With Disability: Issues And Challenges. Asia Pacific Disability 
Rehabilitation Journal(15:2), 13-32. 
Hidden Hurt. (2012). Bible Verses on Abuse & Violence. Retrieved October 18, 2013, from Hidden Hurt: 
http://www.hiddenhurt.co.uk/bible_verses.html 
Hollander, J. A. (2001). VULNERABILITY AND DANGEROUSNESS: The Construction of Gender through 
Conversation about Violence. Gender & Society(15), 83-109. 
Hsieh, H.-F., & Shannon, S. E. (2005). Three Approaches to Qualitative Content Analysis. Qualitative Health 
Research(15), 1277-1288. 
Huda. (2013). What Does Islam Say About Rape? Retrieved October 18, 2013, from About.com Islam: 
http://islam.about.com/od/crime/f/rape.htm 
Human Rights Watch. (2001). Scared at school: Sexual violence against girls in South African schools. New York: 
Human Rights Watch. 
Human Rights Watch. (2012, August 22). Ghana: Disability Rights Convention Ratified . Retrieved October 11, 
2012, from Human Rights Watch: http://www.hrw.org/news/2012/08/22/ghana-disability-rights-convention- 
ratified 
ICAD. (2008). Multifactorial Model. Retrieved December 5, 2012, from International Coalition on Abuse & 
Disability: http://icad.wordpress.com/multifactorial-model/ 
Isler, A., Beytut, B., Tas, F., & Conk, Z. (2009). A Study on Sexuality with the Parents of Adolescents with 
Intellectual Disability. Sexuality and Disability(27), 229-237. 
Kanter, A. S. (2003). The Globalization of Disability Rights Law. Journal of International Law, 241-270. 
Khemka, I., Hickson, L., & Reynolds, G. (2005). Evaluation of a decision-making curriculum designed to 
empower women with mental retardation to resist abuse. American Journal on Mental 
Retardation(110), 193-204. 
Kvam, M. H., & Braathen, S. H. (2006). Violence and abuse against women with disabilities in Malawi. Oslo: 
SINTEF. 
Kvam, M. H., & Braathen, S. H. (2008). Sexual Abuse Against Girls and Women With Disabilities in Malawi. 
Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment(20(1)), 5-24. 
Lin, L.-P., Yen, C.-F., Kuo, F.-Y., Wu, J.-L., & Lin, J.-D. (2009). Sexual assault of people with disabilities: Results of 
a 2002-2007 national report in Taiwan. Research in Developmental Disabilities(30), 969-975.
Maart, S., & Jelsma, J. (2010). The sexual behaviour of physically disabled adolescents. Disability and 
Rehabilitation(32:6), 438-443. 
Martin, S. L., Ray, N., Sotres-Alvarez, D., Kupper, L. L., Moracco, K. E., Dickens, P. A., et al. (2006). Physical and 
Sexual Assault of Women with Disabilities. Violence Against Women(12), 832-837. 
McKenzie, J. A. (2013). Disabled people in rural South Africa talk about sexuality. Culture, Health & Sexuality: An 
International Journal for Research, Intervention and Care(15:3), 372-386. 
Owusu, S. A. (2012, December 5). Modern Ghana. Retrieved October 3, 2013, from Cultural And Religious 
Impediments Against Sex Education In Ghanaian Schools: 
http://www.modernghana.com/news/434456/1/cultural-and-religious-impediments-against-sex-edu. 
html 
Petersilia, J. R. (2001). Crime Victims with Developmental Disabilities : A Review Essay. Criminal Justice and 
Behavior(28), 655-694. 
Plummer, S.-B., & Findley, P. A. (2012). Women With Disabilities' Experience With Physical and Sexual Abuse : 
Review of the Literature and Implications for the Field. Trauma, Violence, and Abuse(13), 15-29. 
Punch, K. F. (2005). Introduction to Social Research; Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches. London: SAGE 
Publications Ltd. 
Rohleder, P., & Swartz, L. (2009). Providing Sex Education to Persons with Learning Disabilities in the Era of 
HIV/AIDS: Tensions between Discourses of Human Rights and Restriction. Journal of Health 
Psychology, 601-610. 
Rothman, J. C. (2010). The Challenge of Disability and Access: Reconceptualizing the Role of the Medical Model. 
Journal of Social Work in Disability & Rehabilitation(9:2-3), 194-222. 
Skinner, B. F. (1953). Science and Human Behavior. New York: Macmillan. 
Sobsey, D., & Calder, P. (1999). Violence against people with disabilities: A conceptual analysis. Washington, 
DC: Committee on Law and Justice of the National Research Council. 
Sobsey, D., & Mansell, S. (1994). Sexual abuse patterns of children with disabilities. International Journal of 
Children's Rights(2), 96-100. 
Spohn, C., & Tellis, K. (2012). The Criminal Justice System's Response to Sexual Violence. Violence Against 
Women(18(2)), 169-192. 
The News Today. (2010, July 17). 50pc disabled children sexually abused in Bangladesh. Retrieved November 
15, 2012, from The News Today: 
http://www.newstoday.com.bd/index.php?option=details&news_id=2201&date=2010-07-17 
Tjaden, P., & Thoennes, N. (2006). Extent, Nature and Consequences of Rape Victimization: Findings From the 
National Violence Against Women Survey. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice, National 
Institute of Justice. 
UN Enable. (n.d.). Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities . Retrieved December 3, 2012, from UN 
Enable: http://www.un.org/disabilities/default.asp?navid=14&pid=150 
Unicef. (2008). FIGHTING THE SEXUAL EXPLOITATION OF CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS IN GHANA. Rio de 
Janeiro: Unicef.
United Nations . (2008). Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and Optional Protocol. United 
Nations. 
United Nations. (1994). The standard rules on the equalization of opportunities for persons with disabilities. 
New York: United Nations. 
UNODC. (2011). Access to Legal Aid in Criminal Justice Systems in Africa. New York: United Nations. 
WHO. (2007). WHO Ethical and safety recommendations for researching, documenting and monitoring sexual 
violence in emergencies. Switzerland. 
WHO. (2011). World Report on Disability. Malta: WHO Press. 
WHO. (2012, November). Disability and Health. Retrieved April 2, 2013, from WHO: 
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs352/en/ 
WHO Regional Office for Africa. (2012). Addressing the Challenge of Women’s Health in Africa. United Kingdom: 
WHO. 
Yoshida, K., DuMont, J., Odette, F., & Lysy, D. (2011). Factors Associated With Physical and Sexual Violence 
Among Canadian Women Living With Physical Disabilities. Health Care for Women International(32), 
762-775.

More Related Content

What's hot

Violence against women and gender equality in the philippines: Are they related?
Violence against women and gender equality in the philippines: Are they related?Violence against women and gender equality in the philippines: Are they related?
Violence against women and gender equality in the philippines: Are they related?Jabin Deguma
 
Gender-based violence: a threat to peace
Gender-based violence: a threat to peaceGender-based violence: a threat to peace
Gender-based violence: a threat to peaceRotary International
 
Understanding gender based violance
Understanding gender based violanceUnderstanding gender based violance
Understanding gender based violanceWEEKLYMEDIC
 
Gender LIDC - Gender in Development - De-Colonising Development
Gender LIDC - Gender in Development - De-Colonising DevelopmentGender LIDC - Gender in Development - De-Colonising Development
Gender LIDC - Gender in Development - De-Colonising DevelopmentCarolina Matos
 
Womensempowermentindiabriefs
WomensempowermentindiabriefsWomensempowermentindiabriefs
Womensempowermentindiabriefskhanwasim26
 
Social Determinants Health by Dr. Adewale Troutman
Social Determinants Health by Dr. Adewale TroutmanSocial Determinants Health by Dr. Adewale Troutman
Social Determinants Health by Dr. Adewale TroutmanMaileen Hamto
 
Women’s abuse experiences in Jordan: A comparative study using rural and urba...
Women’s abuse experiences in Jordan: A comparative study using rural and urba...Women’s abuse experiences in Jordan: A comparative study using rural and urba...
Women’s abuse experiences in Jordan: A comparative study using rural and urba...Rula alsawalqa
 
Factors affecting HIV infection - Gender
Factors affecting HIV infection - GenderFactors affecting HIV infection - Gender
Factors affecting HIV infection - GenderMunyaradzi Mataire
 
What is Social justice in a Nursing Context
What is Social justice in a Nursing ContextWhat is Social justice in a Nursing Context
What is Social justice in a Nursing Contextgriehl
 
Harmful practices report
Harmful practices reportHarmful practices report
Harmful practices reportThomas Müller
 
Juvenile corrections pp week 6
Juvenile corrections pp week  6Juvenile corrections pp week  6
Juvenile corrections pp week 6difordham
 
What covid 19 reveals about gender inequality
What covid 19 reveals about gender inequalityWhat covid 19 reveals about gender inequality
What covid 19 reveals about gender inequalityCPDI
 
Final project presentation
Final project presentationFinal project presentation
Final project presentationanhill
 

What's hot (20)

Vulnerable population
Vulnerable populationVulnerable population
Vulnerable population
 
Domestic violencw
Domestic violencwDomestic violencw
Domestic violencw
 
Violence against women and gender equality in the philippines: Are they related?
Violence against women and gender equality in the philippines: Are they related?Violence against women and gender equality in the philippines: Are they related?
Violence against women and gender equality in the philippines: Are they related?
 
Power point 2
Power point 2Power point 2
Power point 2
 
Gender-based violence: a threat to peace
Gender-based violence: a threat to peaceGender-based violence: a threat to peace
Gender-based violence: a threat to peace
 
Understanding gender based violance
Understanding gender based violanceUnderstanding gender based violance
Understanding gender based violance
 
Gender LIDC - Gender in Development - De-Colonising Development
Gender LIDC - Gender in Development - De-Colonising DevelopmentGender LIDC - Gender in Development - De-Colonising Development
Gender LIDC - Gender in Development - De-Colonising Development
 
Womensempowermentindiabriefs
WomensempowermentindiabriefsWomensempowermentindiabriefs
Womensempowermentindiabriefs
 
Social Determinants Health by Dr. Adewale Troutman
Social Determinants Health by Dr. Adewale TroutmanSocial Determinants Health by Dr. Adewale Troutman
Social Determinants Health by Dr. Adewale Troutman
 
Women’s abuse experiences in Jordan: A comparative study using rural and urba...
Women’s abuse experiences in Jordan: A comparative study using rural and urba...Women’s abuse experiences in Jordan: A comparative study using rural and urba...
Women’s abuse experiences in Jordan: A comparative study using rural and urba...
 
Factors affecting HIV infection - Gender
Factors affecting HIV infection - GenderFactors affecting HIV infection - Gender
Factors affecting HIV infection - Gender
 
Overview of the Health Equity Framework Through Social Justice
Overview of the Health Equity Framework Through Social JusticeOverview of the Health Equity Framework Through Social Justice
Overview of the Health Equity Framework Through Social Justice
 
The Power of You
The Power of YouThe Power of You
The Power of You
 
Gender and equality
Gender and equalityGender and equality
Gender and equality
 
What is Social justice in a Nursing Context
What is Social justice in a Nursing ContextWhat is Social justice in a Nursing Context
What is Social justice in a Nursing Context
 
Harmful practices report
Harmful practices reportHarmful practices report
Harmful practices report
 
Juvenile corrections pp week 6
Juvenile corrections pp week  6Juvenile corrections pp week  6
Juvenile corrections pp week 6
 
Safety of women
Safety of womenSafety of women
Safety of women
 
What covid 19 reveals about gender inequality
What covid 19 reveals about gender inequalityWhat covid 19 reveals about gender inequality
What covid 19 reveals about gender inequality
 
Final project presentation
Final project presentationFinal project presentation
Final project presentation
 

Similar to Safety and sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region

Indigenous women in Latin America and inequalities access to justice
Indigenous women in Latin America and inequalities access to justiceIndigenous women in Latin America and inequalities access to justice
Indigenous women in Latin America and inequalities access to justiceChirine Haddad ?
 
Restrictions-on-a-Woman-s-Reproductive-Choice
Restrictions-on-a-Woman-s-Reproductive-ChoiceRestrictions-on-a-Woman-s-Reproductive-Choice
Restrictions-on-a-Woman-s-Reproductive-ChoiceLucinda Lee
 
Crime victimization and disabilities 2012
Crime victimization and disabilities 2012Crime victimization and disabilities 2012
Crime victimization and disabilities 2012FHCCommunity
 
RIWC_ Dr Tom Shakespeare - RI Sexuality Presentation
RIWC_ Dr Tom Shakespeare - RI Sexuality PresentationRIWC_ Dr Tom Shakespeare - RI Sexuality Presentation
RIWC_ Dr Tom Shakespeare - RI Sexuality PresentationMarco Muscroft
 
Gender Based Violence and Health Care
Gender Based Violence and Health CareGender Based Violence and Health Care
Gender Based Violence and Health CareMeerambika
 
Importance of information system in raising public awareness about domestic v...
Importance of information system in raising public awareness about domestic v...Importance of information system in raising public awareness about domestic v...
Importance of information system in raising public awareness about domestic v...Masum Hussain
 
Kimberly Ballard Capstone Paper
Kimberly Ballard Capstone PaperKimberly Ballard Capstone Paper
Kimberly Ballard Capstone PaperKimberly Ballard
 
CPCJ_Module_9_Gender_in_the_Criminal_Justice_System.ppsx
CPCJ_Module_9_Gender_in_the_Criminal_Justice_System.ppsxCPCJ_Module_9_Gender_in_the_Criminal_Justice_System.ppsx
CPCJ_Module_9_Gender_in_the_Criminal_Justice_System.ppsxNIMMANAGANTI RAMAKRISHNA
 
MSc in Child Forensic Studies REDONE 19th Feb2015
MSc in Child Forensic Studies REDONE 19th Feb2015MSc in Child Forensic Studies REDONE 19th Feb2015
MSc in Child Forensic Studies REDONE 19th Feb2015Gerry Linke
 
MSc in Child Forensic Studies GL
MSc in Child Forensic Studies GLMSc in Child Forensic Studies GL
MSc in Child Forensic Studies GLGerry Linke
 
Monitoring and Evaluation of Global Sex Trafficking: What Do We Really Know? ...
Monitoring and Evaluation of Global Sex Trafficking: What Do We Really Know? ...Monitoring and Evaluation of Global Sex Trafficking: What Do We Really Know? ...
Monitoring and Evaluation of Global Sex Trafficking: What Do We Really Know? ...MEASURE Evaluation
 
Violation of Women’s Rights
Violation of Women’s RightsViolation of Women’s Rights
Violation of Women’s RightsAnoushkaBanerji
 
Understanding Gender Based Violence and Trends in the Caribbean
Understanding Gender Based Violence and Trends in the Caribbean Understanding Gender Based Violence and Trends in the Caribbean
Understanding Gender Based Violence and Trends in the Caribbean Taitu Heron
 
A critique of incessant violations of women’s health and reproductive rights ...
A critique of incessant violations of women’s health and reproductive rights ...A critique of incessant violations of women’s health and reproductive rights ...
A critique of incessant violations of women’s health and reproductive rights ...Alexander Decker
 
Internship presentation women with disabilities
Internship presentation women with disabilitiesInternship presentation women with disabilities
Internship presentation women with disabilitiesTherapist_Intern
 
Juror Perception of Intimate Partner Violence Cases Involving Victims with Di...
Juror Perception of Intimate Partner Violence Cases Involving Victims with Di...Juror Perception of Intimate Partner Violence Cases Involving Victims with Di...
Juror Perception of Intimate Partner Violence Cases Involving Victims with Di...Amanda Langley
 
A Qualitative Evaluation Of The Effects Of Mandatory Reporting Of Domestic Vi...
A Qualitative Evaluation Of The Effects Of Mandatory Reporting Of Domestic Vi...A Qualitative Evaluation Of The Effects Of Mandatory Reporting Of Domestic Vi...
A Qualitative Evaluation Of The Effects Of Mandatory Reporting Of Domestic Vi...Jackie Taylor
 
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docx
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docxSanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docx
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docxanhlodge
 
Wekerle CIHR Team - SV Youth Rights & Resilience
Wekerle CIHR Team -  SV Youth Rights & ResilienceWekerle CIHR Team -  SV Youth Rights & Resilience
Wekerle CIHR Team - SV Youth Rights & ResilienceChristine Wekerle
 
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docx
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docxDo you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docx
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docxelinoraudley582231
 

Similar to Safety and sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region (20)

Indigenous women in Latin America and inequalities access to justice
Indigenous women in Latin America and inequalities access to justiceIndigenous women in Latin America and inequalities access to justice
Indigenous women in Latin America and inequalities access to justice
 
Restrictions-on-a-Woman-s-Reproductive-Choice
Restrictions-on-a-Woman-s-Reproductive-ChoiceRestrictions-on-a-Woman-s-Reproductive-Choice
Restrictions-on-a-Woman-s-Reproductive-Choice
 
Crime victimization and disabilities 2012
Crime victimization and disabilities 2012Crime victimization and disabilities 2012
Crime victimization and disabilities 2012
 
RIWC_ Dr Tom Shakespeare - RI Sexuality Presentation
RIWC_ Dr Tom Shakespeare - RI Sexuality PresentationRIWC_ Dr Tom Shakespeare - RI Sexuality Presentation
RIWC_ Dr Tom Shakespeare - RI Sexuality Presentation
 
Gender Based Violence and Health Care
Gender Based Violence and Health CareGender Based Violence and Health Care
Gender Based Violence and Health Care
 
Importance of information system in raising public awareness about domestic v...
Importance of information system in raising public awareness about domestic v...Importance of information system in raising public awareness about domestic v...
Importance of information system in raising public awareness about domestic v...
 
Kimberly Ballard Capstone Paper
Kimberly Ballard Capstone PaperKimberly Ballard Capstone Paper
Kimberly Ballard Capstone Paper
 
CPCJ_Module_9_Gender_in_the_Criminal_Justice_System.ppsx
CPCJ_Module_9_Gender_in_the_Criminal_Justice_System.ppsxCPCJ_Module_9_Gender_in_the_Criminal_Justice_System.ppsx
CPCJ_Module_9_Gender_in_the_Criminal_Justice_System.ppsx
 
MSc in Child Forensic Studies REDONE 19th Feb2015
MSc in Child Forensic Studies REDONE 19th Feb2015MSc in Child Forensic Studies REDONE 19th Feb2015
MSc in Child Forensic Studies REDONE 19th Feb2015
 
MSc in Child Forensic Studies GL
MSc in Child Forensic Studies GLMSc in Child Forensic Studies GL
MSc in Child Forensic Studies GL
 
Monitoring and Evaluation of Global Sex Trafficking: What Do We Really Know? ...
Monitoring and Evaluation of Global Sex Trafficking: What Do We Really Know? ...Monitoring and Evaluation of Global Sex Trafficking: What Do We Really Know? ...
Monitoring and Evaluation of Global Sex Trafficking: What Do We Really Know? ...
 
Violation of Women’s Rights
Violation of Women’s RightsViolation of Women’s Rights
Violation of Women’s Rights
 
Understanding Gender Based Violence and Trends in the Caribbean
Understanding Gender Based Violence and Trends in the Caribbean Understanding Gender Based Violence and Trends in the Caribbean
Understanding Gender Based Violence and Trends in the Caribbean
 
A critique of incessant violations of women’s health and reproductive rights ...
A critique of incessant violations of women’s health and reproductive rights ...A critique of incessant violations of women’s health and reproductive rights ...
A critique of incessant violations of women’s health and reproductive rights ...
 
Internship presentation women with disabilities
Internship presentation women with disabilitiesInternship presentation women with disabilities
Internship presentation women with disabilities
 
Juror Perception of Intimate Partner Violence Cases Involving Victims with Di...
Juror Perception of Intimate Partner Violence Cases Involving Victims with Di...Juror Perception of Intimate Partner Violence Cases Involving Victims with Di...
Juror Perception of Intimate Partner Violence Cases Involving Victims with Di...
 
A Qualitative Evaluation Of The Effects Of Mandatory Reporting Of Domestic Vi...
A Qualitative Evaluation Of The Effects Of Mandatory Reporting Of Domestic Vi...A Qualitative Evaluation Of The Effects Of Mandatory Reporting Of Domestic Vi...
A Qualitative Evaluation Of The Effects Of Mandatory Reporting Of Domestic Vi...
 
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docx
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docxSanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docx
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docx
 
Wekerle CIHR Team - SV Youth Rights & Resilience
Wekerle CIHR Team -  SV Youth Rights & ResilienceWekerle CIHR Team -  SV Youth Rights & Resilience
Wekerle CIHR Team - SV Youth Rights & Resilience
 
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docx
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docxDo you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docx
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docx
 

Safety and sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region

  • 1. Safety and Sexual Violence against Women and Girls with Disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti Region Nicole Huyser, 1738186 August, 2013 Master Health Sciences; International Public Health (30 EC) VU Supervisor: Dr. W.H. van Brakel On Site Supervisor: Dr. (Sr.) Frances Emily Owusu-Ansah Center for Disability and Rehabilitation Studies, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology Word count: 9056
  • 2. 1. Abstract Objective To identify the factors that influence the safety and sexual health of women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region. Background Although there is a lack of data in Ghana, the vulnerability of women and girls with disabilities and with the worldwide underreporting of sexual violence against women combined with evidence of sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities in Malawi, suggests it may be taking place in Ghana as well. That leads to the question: which factors influence the safety and sexual health of women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region? Methods Purposive sampling and snowball sampling was used to draw participants from the study population. Qualitative methods using interviews with a semi-structured interview guide of women and girls with disabilities or their primary care taker. Data analysis was conducted using a coding guide derived from the multifactorial model of violence. Results Twenty-one women and girls with disabilities or their primary care taker were interviewed. Eight of the twenty-one women experienced sexual violence. Knowledge of the rights of people with disabilities is varied and access to justice is difficult. Conclusion Important risk factors influencing sexual violence are a lack of access to justice and a lack of knowledge of their rights. The bond with family members is a protective factor. In addition, membership of a DPO, age and the type of disability also influence sexual violence victimization. More efforts and research is needed to develop a suitable prevention program to reduce sexual violence and increase the level of knowledge of sexual health rights for women and girls with disabilities. 2. Background About 15% of the world’s population has some form of disability and this number is increasing (WHO, 2012). Persons with disabilities often have poorer health outcomes, lower education achievements, less economic participation and higher rates of poverty than people without disabilities, but those are not their only problems (WHO, 2011). Over the years is has become apparent that there is a strong link between disability and abuse (Petersilia, 2001). Numerous studies have shown that persons with disabilities have a higher risk of sexual abuse than persons without a disability (Kvam & Braathen, 2006) (Martin, et al., 2006) (Calderbank, 2000). In Bangladesh, half of all disabled children had been sexually abused and in a Canadian study, 30.5 percent of disabled women had experienced sexual violence (Yoshida, DuMont, Odette, & Lysy, 2011) (The News Today, 2010). There is also evidence of sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities in Malawi (Kvam & Braathen, 2008). Factors that contribute to the higher chance on sexual abuse include a lack of accessibility, a lack of mobility and social isolation (Plummer & Findley, 2012). 2.1 Definitions According to the United Nations (1994) the term "disability" summarizes a large number of different functional limitations occurring in any population in any country of the world. People may be disabled by physical, intellectual or sensory impairment, medical conditions or mental illness. Such impairments, conditions or illnesses may be permanent or transitory in nature. According to the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF), disability occurs in interaction with contextual factors such as environmental and personal factors (WHO, 2012). The WHO defines sexual violence as: “Any sexual act, attempt to obtain a sexual act, unwanted sexual comments or advances, or acts to traffic, or otherwise directed, against a person’s sexuality using coercion, by any person regardless of their relationship to the victim, in any setting, including but not limited to home and work.” Sexual violence includes rape, defined as physically forced or otherwise coerced
  • 3. penetration – even if slight – of the vulva or anus, using a penis, other body parts or an object. The attempt to do so is known as attempted rape. Rape of a person by two or more perpetrators is known as gang rape. Sexual violence can include other forms of assault involving a sexual organ, including coerced contact between the mouth and penis, vulva or anus. A wide range of sexually violent acts can take place in different circumstances and settings. These include, but are not limited to:  rape within marriage or dating relationships;  rape by strangers;  systematic rape during armed conflict;  unwanted sexual advances or sexual harassment, including demanding sex in return for favors;  sexual abuse of mentally or physically disabled people;  sexual abuse of children;  forced marriage or cohabitation, including the marriage of children;  denial of the right to use contraception or to adopt other measures to protect against sexually transmitted diseases;  forced abortion;  violent acts against the sexual integrity of women, including female genital mutilation and obligatory inspections for virginity (WHO, 2007). 2.2 Underreporting of sexual violence Sexual violence is often underreported. A survey done in the United States revealed that only 19.1% of women that were raped since their 18th birthday reported this (Tjaden & Thoennes, 2006). A similar survey in Canada revealed that only 6% report the crime to the authorities (DuMont, Miller, & Myhr, 2003). Fear of retaliation from the rapist, shame and embarrassment, the belief that it was a minor incident and fears that the police and prosecutors would question their credibility were reasons not to report the crime. Victims are more likely to report the crime when the offender is a stranger than when the offender is an acquaintance and victims are more likely to report the crime if they feel the probability on a conviction is high (Spohn & Tellis, 2012). For women with disabilities there are even more reasons not to report sexual violence. One of which is that many services are not accessible for people with disabilities. Also, the behavior of service providers and first responders is often insensitive to people with disabilities (Plummer & Findley, 2012). 2.3 Vulnerability of women and girls with disabilities Disabilities make women and girls more vulnerable to abuse because they often need help from different caretakers (Sobsey & Mansell, 1994). Lower self-confidence and fewer friendships also heighten their vulnerability (Armstrong, Rosenbaum, & King, 1992). They may also have communication difficulties and reduced mental capacities which prevents them from reporting the abuse and makes them attractive for offenders (Kvam & Braathen, 2008). 2.4 Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities The Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities was adopted in 2006 to give extra attention to the human rights of persons with disabilities and to provide an international legal framework for action against rights abuses. The goal of the Convention is to change how the world sees persons
  • 4. with disabilities and reaffirm that they have human rights and fundamental freedoms; that they can make their own decisions and can be active members of society (UN Enable). Article 12, 13 and 16 of the CRPD give attention to the equal recognition before the law, access to justice and freedom from exploitation, violence and abuse. Article 23 and article 25 deal with the sexual and reproductive rights of persons with disabilities and raising awareness for human rights (United Nations , 2008). These rights should provide a legal foundation to take action to protect women and girls with disabilities from sexual violence. Article 12.3 States Parties shall take appropriate measures to provide access by persons with disabilities to the support they may require in exercising their legal capacity. Article 13.2 In order to help to ensure effective access to justice for persons with disabilities, States Parties shall promote appropriate training for those working in the field of administration of justice, including police and prison staff. Article 16.2 States Parties shall also take all appropriate measures to prevent all forms of exploitation, violence and abuse by ensuring, inter alia, appropriate forms of gender- and age-sensitive assistance and support for persons with disabilities and their families and caregivers, including through the provision of information and education on how to avoid, recognize and report instances of exploitation, violence and abuse. States Parties shall ensure that protection services are age-, gender- and disability-sensitive. Article 23.1b The rights of persons with disabilities to decide freely and responsibly on the number and spacing of their children and to have access to age-appropriate information, reproductive and family planning education are recognized, and the means necessary to enable them to exercise these rights are provided. Article 25d Require health professionals to provide care of the same quality to persons with disabilities as to others, including on the basis of free and informed consent by, inter alia, raising awareness of the human rights, dignity, autonomy and needs of persons with disabilities through training and the promulgation of ethical standards for public and private health care. 2.5 Models of disability in Ghana There are a few models to enable an understanding of disability. In high-income countries the way people understand disability often fits in a medical model, a social model or a combination of both. The medical model defines people by their medical condition or illness. Someone with a disability has a fault that needs to be fixed; they need to become as close to “normal” as possible. The social model sees disability as imposed by society because of society’s conception of what is normal and because of environmental barriers (Rothman, 2010) (Anthony, 2011). In the past and even still today people in Ghana use a religious/magical worldview to understand disability (Avoke, 2002). In the religious/magical worldview, disability is seen as a punishment from the gods. The way people with disabilities are treated is justified by this belief. This view is still used in some communities and although there is shift towards a more social model, the religious/magical worldview still influences attitudes towards people with disabilities (Avoke, 2002).
  • 5. 2.6 Problem description According to estimations of the WHO, 7 to 9 percent of the Ghanaian population has a disability, in a population of 21 million, this means 1.5 - 2.2 million persons. Because Ghana has ratified the CRPD and has adopted the Disability Act, it would seem Ghana is well on its way to a life without abuse for PWD’s (Human Rights Watch, 2012). However there are no legal mechanisms to enforce this and prosecute the offenders (Kanter, 2003). On top of this, access to legal aid is generally unavailable and corruption and unreasonable delays create a loss of confidence in the justice system (UNODC, 2011). Even when legal aid schemes are available, people who earn a little more than US$ 50 per month do not qualify for legal aid although they still cannot afford legal fees (UNODC, 2011). In addition there is a geographical unbalance in court distribution; there are more courts in areas with a rising economy than in areas with a high population density (AfriMAP, 2007). In 2006, the Domestic Violence Victims Support Unit in Ghana recorded 345 cases of rape of children and adolescents, 1427 cases of defilement (carnal knowledge of any child under the age of 16 (Ghana Legal, 2013)), 52 cases of attempted rape and 4 cases of attempted defilement (Unicef, 2008). The records do not specify the sex and age of the victims and there is no mention of them being disabled. Furthermore, an estimated 27% of Ghanaian women have been sexually assaulted in their lifetime and 1 in 3 women had been touched or fondled against their will according to a national study performed by the Gender Studies and Human Rights Documentation Center (2013). Yet again there is no mention of these women being disabled or not. In a survey that was conducted in 1997 in Ghana, they found that women are most at risk for sexual violence between the age of 10 and 18 years. There are certain reasons for Ghanaian women not to report violence. In Ghanaian culture, any kind of violence against women is seen as a private matter that should not be discussed with others. Therefore violence is often not reported and if it is reported, it is not reported to state agencies. Another reason not to report violence is because it will negatively affect the woman’s status in society. Also, most offenders were lovers, family members and acquaintances, another reason not to report the violence, because of fear of abandonment. And lastly, most offenders will not be held responsible for their actions. This makes women doubt the effect of reporting violence (Ardayfio-Schandorf, 2005). Although there is little research done in Ghana itself, research in other countries suggests that there should be cases of abuse of disabled girls and women in Ghana as well. The absence of disabled people in the research literature on abuse shows a lack of social awareness and concern, which in turn perpetuates the resignation, acceptance and a reluctance of women with disabilities to take action against the perpetrators. 3. Aim and objective, conceptual framework and research questions 3.1 Aim and objective The aim is to improve the mechanisms in place to protect women and girls with disabilities from sexual violence. Therefor the objective is to identify the factors that influence the safety and sexual health of women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region.
  • 6. 3.2 Main research question Which factors influence the safety and sexual health of women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region? 3.3 Conceptual framework To explain all the factors that influence sexual abuse of women and girls with disabilities, the multifactorial model of violence is used (Sobsey & Calder, 1999). The model combines other models and theories such as the routine activity theory and Skinner’s model of counter-control (Skinner, 1953). It is the most comprehensive model considering factors that increase victimization of persons with disabilities (Petersilia, 2001). Environmental Factors Person A Person B Offender-Related Factors Perceived Vulnerability Profiles of offenders Victim-Related Factors Direct effects of vulnerability Socially mediated effects of disability Victim Precipitation Easy Victims Relationship Factors Fig. 1 Multifactorial model of violence In an equal relationship the power between person A and person B would be equally distributed. In the case of a victim (A) and an offender (B), the offender has more power than the victim, hence the thick arrow in the model in figure 1 (ICAD, 2008). There are certain factors that influence the victimization. 3.3.1 Victim-related factors Victim-related factors are the factors that make a disabled person a probable victim. These factors are the direct effects of disability, socially mediated effects, victim precipitation, and victims that are easy for offenders. The direct effects of disability are the effects that are forced upon a disabled person because of their disability. This can be the dependency on a caregiver; the inability to escape or avoid the offender and the inability to seek help, but also the type of disability (Petersilia, 2001). A study in Taiwan points out that intellectually disabled people make out more than 50 percent of the sexual assault cases reported by PWD (Lin, Yen, Kuo, Wu, & Lin, 2009). Socially mediated effects are the effects that come from what they have learned or not learned. People with disabilities are often
  • 7. not taught their human rights, they do not get sexual education and they are often taught to obey all the time and not taught assertiveness or to make their own choices (Groce, 2004). Victim precipitation is when a disabled person displays behavior that elicits a reaction from an offender. For example when an intellectually disabled person cannot recognize a dangerous situation and will therefore do nothing to avoid that situation, which creates an opportunity for an offender. Lastly, victims that are attractive for offenders have characteristics that motivate the offender to abuse the victim, as vulnerability alone is not enough for abuse. These motivating factors are: - Control over the victim: the offender wants control over the victim and uses abuse to get that control (Gilson, DePoy, & Cramer, 2001). - Sex: the offender is sexually attracted to people with specific disabilities. - Money: the victim receives money and the offender wants that money and will abuse the victim to get it. - Few alternatives to exploitation: the victim remains in the situation in which the abuse is taking place because the victim has few alternatives (Petersilia, 2001). For example, lack of access to justice will keep the offender out of jail and in the proximity of the victim. 3.3.2 The offender-related factors The offender-related factors are the perceived vulnerability and the profiles of the offenders. Perceived vulnerability is the way the offender sees the victim as vulnerable; because the victim has a mental disability the crime will not be reported and the offender can get away with it or the victim is paralyzed and will not be able to fight the offender off. This may not be reality, but it adds to the risk of victimization (Petersilia, 2001). The media adds to this perceived vulnerability by portraying people with disabilities as helpless. Some of the offenders fit certain profiles of offenders. For caregivers, who make up a large part of all offenders, there are two types of offenders, the predatory caregiver and the corrupted caregiver (Sobsey & Calder, 1999). The predatory caregivers usually have feelings of inadequacy, a lack of control and the need to have control over vulnerable people (Crossmaker, 1991). They seek to be in the proximity of disabled people and they often plan their offenses. The corrupted caregiver can be a good caregiver but a lack of training, supervision or policy can result in abusive behavior. Often the abusive behavior starts gradually and without planning. However, not all abuse is committed by caregivers. Abuse can also be committed by other people with disabilities. This can be explained by the lifestyles exposure model. A lot of people with disabilities live in groups. This increases the exposure of potential victims to offenders with disabilities (Petersilia, 2001). These offenders with disabilities can be abused by caregivers and therefor start abusing other people; some may have brain damage that leads to reduced control over impulsive behavior and a lack of inhibition. 3.3.3 Relationship Factors The relationships that persons with disabilities have influence the risk of abuse. Dependency on others, such as caregivers, increases the risk of abuse because of power inequities (Crossmaker, 1991). When there are more contacts with caregivers, the risk that one of them will be abusive increases. A good connection with family members decreases the risk of abuse.
  • 8. 3.3.4 Environmental factors There are certain environmental factors that influence the risk of abuse. This can be living in institutions or group homes, being born in an abusive family or exposure to high risk environment, because the disability affects the routine activities, for example because of the disability the victim has to take a different route from home to work (Petersilia, 2001) (Crossmaker, 1991). 3.4 Specific research questions Based on the conceptual model and the main research question, specific research questions were formulated: 1. What do women and girls know of their rights in relation to safety and sexual health? 2. What are the experiences of WWD in urban and rural areas with access to legal justice systems? 3. What experiences do the WWD in the Ashanti region have with sexual exploitation and abuse? 4. What factors of the multifactorial model of violence are influencing sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities? 4. Methods 4.1 Study design An exploratory study was conducted because the perspective of the women and girls with disabilities on the vulnerability for sexual violence is important to raise more awareness for this important and undervalued subject. 4.2 Study Population and study sample The study took place in Kumasi and the Ashanti region. The Ashanti region is the biggest region in Ghana in terms of population and has the least equal allocation of health funds between the regions (Asante, Zwi, & Ho, 2006). All women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti region were the study population; to select participants from the study population, the following inclusion and exclusion criteria were used. 4.2.1 Inclusion criteria The inclusion criteria include:  Women and girls with disabilities (from the age of 10);  Primary care takers of women and girls with disabilities who are not able to communicate. 4.2.2 Exclusion criteria The exclusion criteria include:  Women and girls with a disability that is not permanent;  Women and girls refusing informed consent;  Women and girls that offer communication difficulties and who do not have a primary care taker present.
  • 9. 4.3 Sample size and sampling method Purposive sampling and snowball sampling was used to draw participants from the study population. With the assistance of the Ghana Society for the Physically Disabled and members of the Ghana Blind Union, women were contacted by phone and asked if they were willing to participate. Some of the women knew other disabled women that would also want to participate. Also, the Ashanti School for the Deaf in Jamasi was contacted and a few students agreed to participate. In total 21 interviews were conducted. The age ranged from 15 to 65. Six of the interviewees were with primary care takers because the woman or girl in question was not able to respond to questions. Of the 21 respondents, ten were members of a DPO and eleven were not. 4.4 Method of measurement In order to obtain the valuable information needed to get insight in the safety and sexual health of women and girls with disabilities, semi-structured interviews were conducted. Because of the sensitive nature face-to-face interviews were held instead of focus group discussion. The interviews were conducted using an interview guide with questions based on the concepts mentioned in the conceptual framework. The interviews were mostly conducted at the homes of the participants or a place near their work and at the Ashanti School for the Deaf. With consent of the participants the interviews were audio-recorded. The recorded interviews have been deleted after transcription and analysis of the interviews. 4.5 Method of analysis The audio-recorded interviews were transcribed verbatim. The analysis of the interviews was done using Weft QDA. Weft QDA is a free qualitative data analysis program. The data was analyzed by performing a directed content analysis. Before starting data analysis a coding guide was constructed based on the concepts of the conceptual framework. With the coding guide fragments were coded accordingly. Any fragments that could not be categorized using the coding guide were given new codes (Hsieh & Shannon, 2005). 5. Results The study sample consisted of 21 women and girls, of which six had a physical disability, five had an intellectual disability, three were visually impaired and another three were hearing impaired. Their age ranged from 15 to 64 and, except for four respondents, lived in an urban area. Nearly half (48%) of the respondents were members of a DPO. Eight of the 21 women and girls experienced sexual violence; three were intellectually disabled, one was visually impaired and four were hearing impaired. None of the women and girls that were members of a DPO experienced sexual violence. The themes the respondents were questioned about were their experience and knowledge of the rights of PWD, their experiences with and knowledge of the legal justice system and their experiences with sexual exploitation and abuse and other factors that might influence sexual exploitation and abuse of WWD. 5.1 Rights All the women were questioned about reproductive health and family planning education, the legal justice system, the treatment of women with disabilities by the health care system and about equal rights in general.
  • 10. 5.1.1 Equal rights Almost all of the women participating in this study felt they do not have the same rights as women without disabilities because they cannot do the same things women without disabilities can do. A physically disabled woman (A.M.) mentions, “Because of their level of education it doesn’t allow them to enjoy the same rights as those without disabilities. And even in the family, those with disabilities aren’t allowed to go, because they question the relevance of education for them. That’s why it is not the same.” Another physically disabled woman (R.A.) feels disabled women cannot be compared to persons without disabilities. Two women felt they have the same rights as women without disabilities, on this a physically disabled woman (A.A.) said, “I have given birth because of that. I am aware of the rights. I know those rights exist; I have given birth because of that.” 5.1.2 Treatment by the health care system The opinions on the treatment by the health care system are varied. Some women feel they are treated the same as persons without disabilities. A physically disabled woman said, “It is the same. But the problem is that when I go to the hospital, I have to stand in the cue for a long time just like any other person. But normally the treatment is the same.” Other women, however, feel they are treated different because of their disability. One visually impaired woman (M.O.) mentioned that she was being shouted at by a nurse when she came in to deliver. The deaf women and girls said that they are treated differently because in in the hospital there are no sign language interpreters so they cannot communicate with the hospital staff. 5.1.3 Family planning education Most women see reproductive and family planning education as a means to space up the number of children. The women below the age of 30 received some reproductive and family planning education at school; some of the older women received family planning education at meetings with their DPO and some were given information about spacing up the pregnancies at the hospital when going in for labor or at church. But most didn’t get any education about the reproductive system and family planning. According to a physically disabled woman (S.O.), “At the hospital that is the only place where they normally give family planning education. Apart from that there is no other place.” When asked about whether or not women and girls with disabilities should receive such education a deaf woman (A.A.) said, “When you are young and you are taught… given such education, some will be tempted to practice some of that. That is why it is very bad when you are young.” 5.1.4 Access to justice There are certain problems the women mention when it comes to accessing the legal system. Transport to and from the police station is a problem because taxi drivers are reluctant to pick up physically disabled women: “They normally prefer picking others than those that are disabled” (S.O.). There also need to be ramps to get physical access to the police station. Some know about the Disability Act but feel the laws are often not enacted. Money is also a problem, ‘you have to have money or find someone else who is willing to assist you to get justice’ or as R.A. puts it, “Unless you get a respectable person who can help you when you get problems, that can lead you. Without that
  • 11. there is nothing that you can do.” None of the deaf women and girls had any knowledge of laws being in place: “We do not have anything like that for disabled in Ghana” (J.K.). 5.2 Safety Also included in the interview guide were questions about if they feel they are well protected from violence and abuse, about the vulnerability of women and girls with disabilities, the influence of the community views and what they think could be done to improve the safety of women and girls with disabilities. 5.2.1 Protection from violence and abuse When questioned if women and girls with disabilities are sufficiently protected from sexual violence and abuse, almost all of the women feel that they are not well protected. They say they are being discriminated against, verbally abused and submitted to beatings. One physically disabled woman (A.A.) said, “I may be alone in the house and someone comes in when the place is very quiet. We are protected by law but these situations make us prone to sexual violence.” Some mention DPOs as a protective factor because when something happens, their organization makes sure justice is done but it is also mentioned that in the villages it is harder to reach the organizations. They also say that they know there are laws that should protect them, but the laws are not enacted and that is why they feel they are not well protected, “We are not much protected by law. Although there are laws taking care of all of us but we are not well taken care of” (A.M.). 5.2.2 Vulnerability The women that reported not to have been a victim of sexual violence were asked about the vulnerability of WWD with respect to sexual violence. Money has come up as an influence; most of the disabled women are not working so they can easily be influenced by men offering money or gifts. And one visually impaired woman (M.O.) told us, “There was a deaf person who lives in a compound house and because she was sleeping alone in the room, at dawn some people were sneaking in to go having an affair with her. Although they knew her condition and she was alone and cannot report. That was what they used to do on a daily basis. When she became pregnant, they will not see anybody who will come and take responsibility for it.” Although not all women see the same dangers as described in the previous quote; one visually impaired woman (A.O.) brings up that the disabled are not the most vulnerable because: “In our society people wouldn’t even think of going to a person with a disability because they think it is an abomination. Secondly, when the person is pregnant you may give birth to a child with a disability as well, so that scares them and prevents them from trying to abuse people sexually.” 5.2.3 Community views on disabled people The mother of an intellectually disabled woman (A.M.) said that her daughter gets teased a lot because of her condition. Some people are afraid of coming to people with a disability and they look at them strangely and some of the women feel the community does not regard them as human beings: “Because people see us as if we are sick, so if there is something, they do not regard us as humans”(E.O). A feeling of neglect by the community is also present:
  • 12. “Before I came blind, they used to involve me in community activities but since I became blind they have not even called me. It seems they don’t even know me. They neglect me and don’t tell me anything.”(S.J.) 5.2.4 Improvements for safety The opinions of what can be done to improve the safety of women and girls with disabilities varied. It was mentioned that the family should take better care of them. Also, for disabled women to be working would make them less vulnerable for sexual exploitation, according to V.O. a physically disabled woman, “When they see that you are weak, like you are poor and do not have the necessary finances, they can make approaches. But if you are working and you have the means of life, you are very well protected against such things.” Raising more awareness and educating the community and disabled persons is also mentioned by multiple women as a means to improve safety. 5.3 Sexual violence All women and primary care takers were asked if they or the woman they are responsible for ever experienced any kind of sexual exploitation or abuse. Nine women said they never heard about things like that happening, four women said they heard about it and eight of the woman and girls were victims of sexual violence. Half of these women and girls had an intellectual disability and the other half was hearing impaired. One visually impaired woman was approached by four different men to have an affair but according to her nothing happened. A deaf woman (A.A.) said, “When I was in primary 4, we were staying in a village. So my grandmother went to farm and she asked me to prepare food and bring it to her. So when I was going on the way a man met me, a man forced me and had sex with me. That was the first one. Also another one, another boy tried to rape me but then I was able to… by that time I was taught to protect myself. So I bite the boy and he left running.” The frequency of the sexual violence ranged from one to four times. The age of the seven women when it started ranges from 9 to 20 years old. Except for one deaf woman who cannot explain why she feels that way, all of the other women and girls feel the disability influenced the victimization. One deaf girl (B.A.) said, “There were so many girls of my age but none of them went into that problem. But I am disabled, that is why the boy called me to the bush.” And C.Y. the aunt of an intellectually disabled woman mentioned that her niece was taken for granted by the man, but that she had not seen it only heard others talk about it. If she had seen it, the offender would have to pay money for compensation. 5.3.1 Offender None of the women were assaulted by family members, but most of the time it was someone in their close proximity; living in the same house or the same village. One girl was raped at school by another student and at the home of a teacher. The mother of an intellectually disabled woman (T.A.) said about the offender: “It is a drunkard who has been doing that. He has not been taking care of her. He didn’t give her anything. It is just a drunkard who is staying in the community.” One intellectually
  • 13. disabled woman (A.S.) said that the offender gave her gifts and she felt it got to a point where she felt obliged to have sex with him. 5.3.2 Bond with family members and friends Most women feel that if disabled women and girls have a good relationship with their family it will protect them from sexual violence. The mother of a disabled woman (A.M.) never lets her daughter out of her sight, “Looking at how I take care of my daughter, I don’t let her roam about. There are some people… the family has abandoned them, so they just roam about. They become… the people can easily get to them. In my case, I don’t allow that. We are always together, so it is not easy for people to come up to her.” If there is a problem it can be discussed within the family and the family will solve the problem and the family can give support financially. This is not sufficient protection according to physically disabled S.O., “regardless of whether you have a good relation with your family or not, the men will come around and maltreat you.” The deaf women and girls do not have a good relationship with their family because their families do not know sign language, as A.A. brought up: “I explained it to my grandmother but she did not understand. She doesn’t know sign language.” 5.3.3 Reporting sexual exploitation and abuse The women that were victimized were asked if their cases were reported but none of them did. They had various reasons not to report their cases. One of the deaf women (A.A.) lived in a village where there is no police station present. The mother of intellectually disabled T.A. reports not having the money to pay the police and the transportation to go to the police station to report, “I am not having money so to be able to get to the police station, the means of transport and also… when you go to the police station they ask you to get proof of that and all of this involves money.” Two of the care takers told us that they did not report the sexual violence because they heard about it from other tenants living in the same house. One of them said: “It is not necessary to report since we have not seen it ourselves.” The woman that was approached by four different men responded when asked if she went to the police to report: “I do not think it is serious that is why I did not report it.” The women that were not victimized said they would go to the police station, to the family, to their DPO or to the village leaders to report if they were victims of sexual violence. As reasons why others might not report sexual violence, transportation is mentioned again. In addition, they find the case not serious enough when there is no visible injury, they do not like talking about their personal issues and they think that the police would not take them seriously. The mother of an intellectually disabled woman (A.T.) said about this, “Such people with such conditions, they can’t talk. So based on that, even if you go and report… they will treat it like… they will not follow up and just throw the case out.”
  • 14. 6. Discussion and conclusion 6.1 What do women and girls know of their rights in relation to safety and sexual health? Most women interviewed did not experience the same rights as women and girls without disabilities. Some know that there are rights, especially the women that are a member of a DPO. However the intellectually disabled do not have any knowledge on their rights on safety and sexual health. At the DPOs they get education about their rights and some reproductive and family planning education and it is the place where they have their social contacts, where they can discuss these kinds of issues with their peers. However, the women who are not a member of DPO display a lower level of education and have less knowledge about their rights in relation to safety and sexual health and for most women the only reproductive and family planning education they received was when going to the hospital to deliver. This is in compliance with the findings from multiple other studies (Groce, 2004) (Calderbank, 2000) (Isler, Beytut, Tas, & Conk, 2009) (McKenzie, 2013) (Rohleder & Swartz, 2009). McKenzie (2013) feels that health services should be responsible for educating disabled people about their sexual rights. According to Isler et al. (2009) the responsibility of educating intellectually disabled about sexual health lies with the parents and the parents should be guided in their efforts to educate their intellectually disabled children. While Rohleder & Swartz (2009) feel that education for intellectually disabled about sexual health and HIV should be incorporated into the main stream campaigns and in schools. In Ghana most sexual health education focuses on HIV/AIDS prevention and education about sexual rights is not being taught at schools because of objections as a result of cultural and religious beliefs from parents and churches (Owusu, 2012). It is important to teach disabled women and girls with disabilities about their rights in relation to safety and sexual health because it teaches them to recognize which practices are normal and which are abnormal and empowers them to make decisions in difficult situations (Barger, Wacker, Macy, & Parish, 2009). 6.2 What are the experiences of WWD in urban and rural areas with access to legal justice systems? Although Ghana has a special unit to deal with sexual violence, the Domestic Violence Victims Support Unit, none of the victimized women reported the abuse they experienced to official agencies, which support the findings from a survey done in 1998 (Boakye, 2009). One of the women even said that in her village there is no police present. This is the only difference between rural and urban in relation to access to justice found in this study. The women living in rural and urban areas face the same obstacles in their access to the legal justice system; the need for money to pay the police, the need for transportation; the fear of not being taken seriously. This is in line with what was found about police corruption and unequal court distributions in a review (AfriMAP, 2007). 6.3 What experiences do the WWD in the Ashanti region have with sexual exploitation and abuse? As expected, sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities is taking place in the Ashanti region. Although Ardayfio-Schandorf (2005) finds in her research in Ghana that most women are victimized by people close to them, often family members, none of the women that were victims in this study reported the offender to be family members or spouses. The offenders were mostly people living in the same community. Some of the primary care takers mentioned that if the offender would give something in return or apologize, the case would be solved and also if the woman does
  • 15. not get pregnant it is not very important. In Ghana, receiving gifts in return for sex is socially accepted and sometimes even encouraged (Baba-Djara, et al., 2013). After conversations with the women and girls that have participated in this study, I feel that accepting a gift or an apology after having experienced sexual violence does not make it any less traumatic. The emotions on their faces show that, even if the violence happened years ago, it is still difficult for them, especially when still living in close proximity to the offender. 6.4 What factors of the multifactorial model of violence are influencing sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities? 6.4.1 Victim related factors The victim related factors are elements that cause the disabled woman or girl to be at risk of sexual violence. This can be the age, gender, lifestyle, the socioeconomic status or the disability. As mentioned before the knowledge of their rights in relation to safety and sexual health is an important factor influencing sexual violence. The women and girls that experienced sexual violence were between the ages of nine and twenty-one when the sexual abuse or exploitation took place. This gives an average age of almost fifteen years which concurs with the survey done in 1997 that revealed that women in Ghana were most at risk for sexual violence between the ages of ten and eighteen (Ardayfio-Schandorf, 2005). In South-Africa Dickman and Roux (2005) assessed 100 sexual violence cases reported by people with an intellectual disability. They found that the average age of the sexual violence was 18 years and 5 months and 40,4 percent was under the age of 16. Another study in South Africa by Human Rights Watch (2001) found that women in general were most at risk for sexual violence between the age of 12-17. In a study carried out in Swaziland in women age 13- 24, they found that 33 percent experienced some form of sexual violence before reaching the age of 18 (WHO Regional Office for Africa, 2012). This suggests that age is also a factor influencing sexual violence that should be taken into account when developing a prevention program. The nature of the disability is also an important factor. The deaf women are not able to communicate with their family and the people in the community; this makes them easy victims for offenders. The primary care takers of the intellectually disabled women that experienced sexual violence mention that they have little control over what their protégés do and that they walk around alone often, which makes them easy victims. Also, because there is a lack of access to justice the offenders can stay in the proximity of the victims. 6.4.2 Offender-related factors One offender-related factor is the relationship of the offender with the victim. As mentioned earlier, the offenders were not family members, spouses or care takers. Another offender related factor is the perceived vulnerability. An important influence on the perceived vulnerability is how the community sees women and girls with disabilities (Boakye, 2009). The women report that the community does not see them as human beings. They see them as sick and weak. According to a study by Bones (2013) disabled women with a visible sign of impairment are seen as very easy victims because they are viewed as less capable of engaging in self-guardianship. In the same study Bones (2013) argues that: “What constitutes a good victim is determined by societal beliefs about certain attributes and behaviors, many of which are uncontrollable and permanent.” The perceived
  • 16. vulnerability of women in general is ingrained in society (Hollander, 2001). It is nearly impossible to change this perception in a few years. I believe it will take another decade to change this perception. This will make it even harder to change the perceived vulnerability of disabled women and girls because that will take an extra step. 6.4.3 Relationship factors This study confirms the theory of Sobsey and Calder (1999) that the bond with family members and friends is an important influencing factor on the victimization of the disabled. The deaf women and girls did not have a good bond with their family members because they could not communicate with them. With the intellectually disabled women there was a clear distinction between primary care takers that had a good bond with their protégé and the primary care takers that did not have a good bond with their protégé. The intellectually disabled women that experienced sexual violence were not kept in sight and were able to walk around alone, while the intellectually disabled women who did not experience sexual violence were kept in constant sight of their primary care taker. Also, some of the women had heard stories of other disabled women who were abandoned by their families and therefore taken advantage of. According to Bones (2013)being isolated from others increases the risk of victimization by 54%. The offender feels that the possible victim is going to tell family members or friends about what happened and he could get into trouble because of that, he will not approach the possible victim. Therefor the bond with family members and friends is a protective factor. 6.4.4 Environmental factors In Ghana religion is very important. Often, legal action against offenders is not taken because they feel everything is in the hands of God. This will keep the offenders in the proximity of the victims and the victims unable to escape the sexual violence. Also, one woman feels her daughter does not need reproductive and family planning education because she leaves it in the hands of God and will accept anything that happens. According to the Bible sexual violence is wrong: “But fornication, and all uncleanness, or covetousness, let it not be once named among you, as becometh saints; Neither filthiness, nor foolish talking, nor jesting, which are not convenient: but rather giving of thanks. For this ye know, that no whoremonger, nor unclean person, nor covetous man, who is an idolater, hath any inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and of God” (Hidden Hurt, 2012). Also, according to the Quran rape is forbidden and punishable by death (Huda, 2013). In theory these religions should prevent possible offenders from committing sexual violence and should encourage women and girls with disabilities to report sexual violence. However, according to Franiuk & Shain (2011) religion endorses rape myth acceptance. In the Muslim culture, for example, family honor is very important. Sexual violence brings dishonor to a family. Boakye (2009) uses the following definition for rape myths: prejudicial, stereotyped, or false beliefs about rape, rape victims, and rapists, which serve to create a climate hostile to rape victims. This will prevent victims from reporting sexual violence. Rape myth acceptance is present in Ghana, but unlike the findings from Franiuk & Shain (2011) religion is not associated with rape myth acceptance but with gender, education and age. Males and older people have a higher level of rape myth acceptance. Education lowers the level of rape myth acceptance (Boakye, 2009). 6.5 Strengths and limitations One limitation was that the interpreter and the sign language interpreter were both males. Although eight cases of sexual violence were found and most of the women appeared to be very open and honest about themselves, the male interpreters could have held back some of the women. The
  • 17. decision to stick to the male interpreters was because they were volunteers and money was an issue, they were knowledgeable on the subject and the sign language interpreter was trusted by the deaf women and girls and knew about their situation already. A comparison of sexual violence and access to justice between rural and urban areas is difficult to make as there were only four women from rural areas included in this study. As with the problem with access to justice in rural areas, reaching DPOs is also difficult which makes it harder to find participants in rural areas. Also, the sample size is small, which makes the findings not generalizable to the whole of Ghana and even the Ashanti region. This notwithstanding, the strength of this study is that it includes women and girls with intellectual disabilities, visual impairments, hearing impairments and physical disabilities. This makes the differences in the experience of sexual violence between the different disabilities identifiable. Also, this study is important because there is little research done on sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities in Ghana and this study provides recommendations to improve the safety situation of the disabled women and girls. 6.6 Conclusions and Recommendations 6.6.1 Conclusion There are a lot of factors that influence the safety and sexual health of women and girls with disabilities in Kumasi and the Ashanti Region. There are protective factors and risk factors. Factors that can be changed and factors that cannot be changed. DPO membership and a good bond with family members and friends are protective factors and these can be influenced by an intervention program. Risk factors are a lack of knowledge of the rights of women and girls with disabilities in relation to safety and sexual health, a lack of access to the legal justice system and the perceived vulnerability. A lack of knowledge and a lack of access to the legal justice system can be changed. The perceived vulnerability, however, cannot be changed that easily. Other factors that influence sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities are age and the type of disability a person has. The women and girls that experienced sexual violence were between the 9 and 21 years old when the sexual violence took place. Also, women and girls with a hearing impairment or who are intellectually disabled are more vulnerable for sexual violence than women that are visually impaired or physically disabled. 6.6.2 What do women and girls know of their rights in relation to safety and sexual health? The overall knowledge of the women and girls with disabilities or their primary care taker is low. Most information about sexual health the women get is at the hospital when going in to give birth or at meetings from their DPOs. It is evident that DPOs educate women on sexual health and human rights, which will increase the level of knowledge of women and girls with disabilities and makes them less prone to sexual violence. Information about their rights in relation to safety and sexual health should also be taught at school and by the parents. When teaching the disabled girls about safety and sexual health rights in school the right age group can be reached. In a review by Barger, Wacker, Macy & Parish (2009) only four sexual violence intervention programs for women with intellectual disabilities were found. These four programs were assessed. Although none of the programs was able to evaluate if the programs actually reduced sexual violence victimization. The most promising intervention program was a program called ESCAPE by Khemka, Hickson & Reynolds (2005) that empowered the women with a self-directed decision making training so they were able
  • 18. to recognize the difference between healthy and abusive interaction and make decisions accordingly. Barger, Wacker, Macy & Parish (2009) found the program promising but concluded that more research into intervention programs and their effectiveness was needed. Interventions for women against sexual violence are not directed at WWD. These intervention programs are mostly directed at university students in the United States and often consist of self-defense training. Of these intervention programs the effectiveness is not proven. Overall there is a lack of effective intervention programs for WWD dealing with sexual violence. More research is needed to develop suitable intervention programs for women and girls with disabilities. 6.6.3 What are the experiences of WWD in urban and rural areas with access to legal justice systems? Most of the women have no experience with the legal justice system. Reaching legal justice systems is hard and money is needed. They would rather solve problems within their community than going to the police station. To get offenders prosecuted and to get the law enacted and work as a deterrent for offenders, transparent and easy to access information should become available for the women and girls with disabilities. DPOs could play an important role in getting this information to the women and girls. In addition, the government should take responsibility to ensure the law is enforced and people with disabilities can make use of their rights. 6.6.4 What experiences do the WWD in the Ashanti region have with sexual exploitation and abuse? The deaf and intellectually disabled women and girls have experience with sexual exploitation and abuse. The visually impaired and physically disabled do not have any experience with sexual exploitation and abuse. It is noteworthy to mention that none of the women that experienced sexual violence were members of any DPO. An increased effort from the DPOs is needed to reach the women and girls in the more secluded areas to teach them the necessary tools to be able to avoid or escape sexual violence such as taught in the ESCAPE program. Special attention should be given to the intellectually disabled and their caretakers and the hearing impaired. These groups appear to be more vulnerable than the physically disabled and the visually impaired because they often encounter communication difficulties. Additionally the women and girls with disabilities and their caretakers should be made aware that transactional sex is not acceptable and that sexual violence should be reported to the official agencies. 6.6.5 What factors of the multifactorial model of violence are influencing sexual violence against women and girls with disabilities? Most of the factors described in the multifactorial model of violence also apply in the Ashanti region. Some of the factors of the multifactorial model of violence are factors that can be influenced and changed; other factors are impossible or nearly impossible to change. The victim related factors that influence sexual violence are age, the type of disability, level of knowledge of their sexual health rights and a lack of access to the legal justice system. Interventions are not able to change someone’s age or the type of disability someone has, focus should lie on increasing the level of knowledge and ensuring the legal justice system is physically accessible and financially accessible. An offender related factor that influences sexual violence is the perceived vulnerability. This is a factor that is nearly impossible to change. To change the relationship factors, to improve the relationship with family members and friends, the views of the family members on their disabled family members
  • 19. need to be changed. They need to be informed about the value of disabled people, that disabled can contribute something to the family and the community. In addition to the multifactorial model, being a member of a DPO also seems to be a protective factor as none of the women that were a member of a DPO experienced sexual violence. Ghana is a very religious country, Christianity and the Islam are against sexual violence. However, at this moment it does not stimulate the women and girls with disabilities or their caretakers to take action against sexual violence. There is an opportunity for an intervention to educate spiritual leaders so they can encourage women and girls with disabilities to report sexual violence. It is important to realize that one intervention that is appropriate for all types of disabilities is not possible as every disability and every individual has different needs.
  • 20. 7. References AfriMAP. (2007). Ghana: Justice Sector and the Rule of Law. South Africa: Open Society Initiative for West Africa. Anthony, J. (2011). Conceptualising disability in Ghana: implications for EFA and inclusive education. International Journal of Inclusive Education(15:10), 1073-1086. Ardayfio-Schandorf, E. (2005). Violence against women: The Ghanaian Case. Switzerland: UN Division for the Advancement of Women. Armstrong, R. W., Rosenbaum, P. L., & King, S. (1992). Self-perceived social function among disabled children in regular classrooms. Journal of Developmental and Behavioural Pediatrics(13), 12-20. Asante, A. D., Zwi, A. B., & Ho, M. T. (2006). Equity in resource allocation for health: A comparative studyof the Ashanti and Northern Regions of Ghana. Health Policy(78), 135-148. Avoke, M. (2002). Models of Disability in the Labelling and Attitudinal Discours in Ghana. Disability & Society(17:7), 769-777. Baba-Djara, M., Brennan, A., Corneliess, C., Agyarko-Poku, T., Akuoko, K., Opoku, K. B., et al. (2013). “Using what you have to get what you want”: Vulnerability to HIV and Prevention Needs of Female Post- Secondary Students Engaged in Transactional Sex in Kumasi, Ghana. USAID Ghana. Barger, E., Wacker, J., Macy, R., & Parish, S. (2009, August). Sexual Assault Prevention for Women With Intellectual Disabilities: A Criticial Review of the Evidence. Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities(47:4), 249-262. Boakye, K. E. (2009). Attitudes Toward Rape and Victims of Rape: A Test of the Feminist Theory in Ghana. Journal of Interpersonal Violence(24:10), 1633-1651. Boeije, H. (2005). Analyseren kwalitatief onderzoek. Stappenplan kwalitatief onderzoek. Amsterdam: Boom Onderwijs. Bones, P. D. (2013). Perceptions of Vulnerability: A Target Characteristics Approach to Disability, Gender, and Victimization. Deviant Behavior(34:9), 727-750. Calderbank, R. (2000). Abuse and Disabled People: Vulnerability or social indifference. Disability & Society(15:3), 521-534. Crossmaker, M. (1991). Behind Locked Doors - Instituational Sexual Abuse. Sexuality And Disability(9:3), 201- 219. Dickman, B. J., & Roux, A. J. (2005). Complainants with learning disabilities in sexual abuse cases: a 10-year review of a psycho-legal project in Cape Town, South Africa. British Journal of Learning Disabilities(33), 138-144. DuMont, J., Miller, K.-L., & Myhr, T. L. (2003). The Role of “Real Rape” and “Real Victim” Stereotypes in the Police Reporting Practices of Sexually Assaulted Women. Violence Against Women(9:4), 466-486. Franiuk, R., & Shain, E. A. (2011). Beyond Christianity: The Status of Women and Rape Myths. Sex Roles(65), 783-791.
  • 21. Gender Studies and Human Rights Documentation Centre. (2013). Statistics on Sexual Violence in Ghana. Retrieved March 24th, 2013, from Gender Studies and Human Rights Documentation Centre: http://www.gendercentreghana.org/statistics-on-sexual-violence-in-ghana/ Ghana Legal. (2013). Ghana legal. Retrieved October 01, 2013, from Criminal Offences Act: http://ghanalegal.com/?id=3&law=19&t=ghana-laws Gilson, S. F., DePoy, E., & Cramer, E. P. (2001). Linking the Assessment of Self-Reported Functional Capacity With Abuse Experiences of Women With Disabilities. Violence Against Women(7:4), 418-431. Groce, N. E. (2004). Adolescents And Youth With Disability: Issues And Challenges. Asia Pacific Disability Rehabilitation Journal(15:2), 13-32. Hidden Hurt. (2012). Bible Verses on Abuse & Violence. Retrieved October 18, 2013, from Hidden Hurt: http://www.hiddenhurt.co.uk/bible_verses.html Hollander, J. A. (2001). VULNERABILITY AND DANGEROUSNESS: The Construction of Gender through Conversation about Violence. Gender & Society(15), 83-109. Hsieh, H.-F., & Shannon, S. E. (2005). Three Approaches to Qualitative Content Analysis. Qualitative Health Research(15), 1277-1288. Huda. (2013). What Does Islam Say About Rape? Retrieved October 18, 2013, from About.com Islam: http://islam.about.com/od/crime/f/rape.htm Human Rights Watch. (2001). Scared at school: Sexual violence against girls in South African schools. New York: Human Rights Watch. Human Rights Watch. (2012, August 22). Ghana: Disability Rights Convention Ratified . Retrieved October 11, 2012, from Human Rights Watch: http://www.hrw.org/news/2012/08/22/ghana-disability-rights-convention- ratified ICAD. (2008). Multifactorial Model. Retrieved December 5, 2012, from International Coalition on Abuse & Disability: http://icad.wordpress.com/multifactorial-model/ Isler, A., Beytut, B., Tas, F., & Conk, Z. (2009). A Study on Sexuality with the Parents of Adolescents with Intellectual Disability. Sexuality and Disability(27), 229-237. Kanter, A. S. (2003). The Globalization of Disability Rights Law. Journal of International Law, 241-270. Khemka, I., Hickson, L., & Reynolds, G. (2005). Evaluation of a decision-making curriculum designed to empower women with mental retardation to resist abuse. American Journal on Mental Retardation(110), 193-204. Kvam, M. H., & Braathen, S. H. (2006). Violence and abuse against women with disabilities in Malawi. Oslo: SINTEF. Kvam, M. H., & Braathen, S. H. (2008). Sexual Abuse Against Girls and Women With Disabilities in Malawi. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment(20(1)), 5-24. Lin, L.-P., Yen, C.-F., Kuo, F.-Y., Wu, J.-L., & Lin, J.-D. (2009). Sexual assault of people with disabilities: Results of a 2002-2007 national report in Taiwan. Research in Developmental Disabilities(30), 969-975.
  • 22. Maart, S., & Jelsma, J. (2010). The sexual behaviour of physically disabled adolescents. Disability and Rehabilitation(32:6), 438-443. Martin, S. L., Ray, N., Sotres-Alvarez, D., Kupper, L. L., Moracco, K. E., Dickens, P. A., et al. (2006). Physical and Sexual Assault of Women with Disabilities. Violence Against Women(12), 832-837. McKenzie, J. A. (2013). Disabled people in rural South Africa talk about sexuality. Culture, Health & Sexuality: An International Journal for Research, Intervention and Care(15:3), 372-386. Owusu, S. A. (2012, December 5). Modern Ghana. Retrieved October 3, 2013, from Cultural And Religious Impediments Against Sex Education In Ghanaian Schools: http://www.modernghana.com/news/434456/1/cultural-and-religious-impediments-against-sex-edu. html Petersilia, J. R. (2001). Crime Victims with Developmental Disabilities : A Review Essay. Criminal Justice and Behavior(28), 655-694. Plummer, S.-B., & Findley, P. A. (2012). Women With Disabilities' Experience With Physical and Sexual Abuse : Review of the Literature and Implications for the Field. Trauma, Violence, and Abuse(13), 15-29. Punch, K. F. (2005). Introduction to Social Research; Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches. London: SAGE Publications Ltd. Rohleder, P., & Swartz, L. (2009). Providing Sex Education to Persons with Learning Disabilities in the Era of HIV/AIDS: Tensions between Discourses of Human Rights and Restriction. Journal of Health Psychology, 601-610. Rothman, J. C. (2010). The Challenge of Disability and Access: Reconceptualizing the Role of the Medical Model. Journal of Social Work in Disability & Rehabilitation(9:2-3), 194-222. Skinner, B. F. (1953). Science and Human Behavior. New York: Macmillan. Sobsey, D., & Calder, P. (1999). Violence against people with disabilities: A conceptual analysis. Washington, DC: Committee on Law and Justice of the National Research Council. Sobsey, D., & Mansell, S. (1994). Sexual abuse patterns of children with disabilities. International Journal of Children's Rights(2), 96-100. Spohn, C., & Tellis, K. (2012). The Criminal Justice System's Response to Sexual Violence. Violence Against Women(18(2)), 169-192. The News Today. (2010, July 17). 50pc disabled children sexually abused in Bangladesh. Retrieved November 15, 2012, from The News Today: http://www.newstoday.com.bd/index.php?option=details&news_id=2201&date=2010-07-17 Tjaden, P., & Thoennes, N. (2006). Extent, Nature and Consequences of Rape Victimization: Findings From the National Violence Against Women Survey. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice. UN Enable. (n.d.). Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities . Retrieved December 3, 2012, from UN Enable: http://www.un.org/disabilities/default.asp?navid=14&pid=150 Unicef. (2008). FIGHTING THE SEXUAL EXPLOITATION OF CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS IN GHANA. Rio de Janeiro: Unicef.
  • 23. United Nations . (2008). Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and Optional Protocol. United Nations. United Nations. (1994). The standard rules on the equalization of opportunities for persons with disabilities. New York: United Nations. UNODC. (2011). Access to Legal Aid in Criminal Justice Systems in Africa. New York: United Nations. WHO. (2007). WHO Ethical and safety recommendations for researching, documenting and monitoring sexual violence in emergencies. Switzerland. WHO. (2011). World Report on Disability. Malta: WHO Press. WHO. (2012, November). Disability and Health. Retrieved April 2, 2013, from WHO: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs352/en/ WHO Regional Office for Africa. (2012). Addressing the Challenge of Women’s Health in Africa. United Kingdom: WHO. Yoshida, K., DuMont, J., Odette, F., & Lysy, D. (2011). Factors Associated With Physical and Sexual Violence Among Canadian Women Living With Physical Disabilities. Health Care for Women International(32), 762-775.