SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
Grassroots Organizing and Public Activation in
Climate Action
By: Mariah Harrod
Grassroots activism entails citizens organizing around some common value or goal. In
contrast, top-down efforts utilize overarching frameworks to impose large-scale change on
communities. Both approaches to environmentalism have been undertaken with their own merits
and pitfalls, yet in the face of such time-salient and globally threatening issues as climate change
in the midst of a lack of binding international governmental agreement, grassroots organizing
offers an accessible and universally motivating route to mitigation. To demonstrate these
advantages I highlight one grassroots organization working against climate change, the Kentucky
Student Environmental Coalition (KSEC). KSEC is a statewide network of students and their
allies holding the government, corporations, and other institutions accountable through education
and activism (“Our Mission”). By utilizing college campuses, KSEC is able to alter the actual
practices of communities and individuals and increase regional solidarity to empower the public
in a way that is imperative for the globally-affected populace to respond to climate change.
Within the past few months, KSEC has demonstrated remarkable success in reducing
carbon impacts through lobbying. This was chiefly accomplished through the work of one of
three teams subdividing KSEC, the Political Working Group. The PWG is composed of students
from Centre College, University of Kentucky, Transylvania University, Eastern Kentucky
University, and Covington Latin High School and administrated by KSEC President Cara
Cooper. Relying on biweekly conference calls and delegation, this team has recently managed to:
 organize a climate action rally at the state capital
 partner with a legislative sponsor and introduce a state bill (currently HB 339/SB 190)
establishing a feed-in tariff, mandating Kentucky utility companies purchase 12.5% of
their electricity from renewable sources, and setting an efficiency standard for these
companies to create energy savings over time
 collect over 700 student signatures on a petition indicating support of the bill
 hold a lobbying day and youth forum for the bill in which a new sponsor and supporters
were recruited
 persuade the EKU president to sign a climate commitment
KSEC members & allies join to listen to speeches relating to representative action on climate change.
KSEC students meet with a bill sponsor to discuss lobbying strategies.
These accomplishments are perhaps intangible in print but when enforced supremely efficacious
in catalyzing larger scale mitigation through citizens organizing. Additionally, the two less active
KSEC teams, the Local Food Working Group and the Just Transition Working Group, have held
their own planning meetings and lobby days to convince local and regional decision-makers to
cut fossil fuel use. These initiatives involved meeting with decision makers and demanding
adherence by merit of being a paying student or voting constituent. Grassroots organizing thus
allows an individual to amplify their voice on a more intimately personal scale than is possible
through a distant lens of democratic representation.
Though institutional change is powerful and pervasive in the battle for emission limits,
individual alterations in behavior as a result of public aggregation both arise from and establish
norms to influence the remainder of society. This is unique to small grassroots organizing which
relies heavily on interpersonal relationships and emotional appeal. Seasonally—with short
sessions in fall and spring and a week-long program in the summer—KSEC holds a “summit”
inviting students, graduates, teachers, and allied environmental associations to participate in
workshops for discussion of relevant issues and possible solutions. At these summits, provided
meals are often vegetarian, vegan, or local to reduce the resource consumption and emissions
associated with meat and distantly processed foods.
Spring 2016 Summit.
Participants remind each other to shut off lights, compost fruit peels, and exchange advice on
sustainable farming. These are important conversations unique to small-scale grassroots activism
in that they sidestep the larger scale tendency to overlook the individual. Indeed, mass media has
failed to significantly alter individual behavior by marketing a “one size fits all” distant,
impersonal, and uninspiring message (Moser and Dilling 165-168). Whereas top-down
approaches often justify climate change mitigation using mentally inaccessible information,
grassroots organizing engages interpersonal relationships in which social reinforcement—and the
tailoring of specific interests, narratives, and emotions—is strongest (Moser and Dilling 168;
Hoffman 79).
Top-down approaches to climate change mitigation rely heavily upon scientific and
economic analyses and, when political, are morphed through the lenses of several stakeholders
rarely held accountable for accurate constituent representation. This ivory towered information
alienates people and thus promotes contestation (Hoffman viii). Bottom-up grassroots
organizing—at least on a small scale—aggregates individuals and inspires using emotional
narrative. KSEC encourages story-telling as a catalyst of climate activism within events such as
the youth forum and upcoming Clean Energy Tour. At the former, student and ally speakers
(including members of KFTC and STAY Project, Senate candidate Sellus Wilder, and a Clean
Power Planet podcaster) spoke in the capitol rotunda on why renewable energy is important to
them. Explanations ranged from living in an industrial town with prominent health concerns to
fear for an economy dependent upon finite resources to desire for youth to remain in the state.
Similarly, the Clean Energy Tour recruits miners, farmers, students, and graduates to provide
narrative on renewable energy in Kentucky to an audience of legislators. These endeavors are
significant and unique to bottom-up approaches because story-telling provides a personally
relatable intrinsic motivation to change behavior (Kearns 414). By emphasizing the veritable
experiences of the individual, grassroots organizations are able to bridge the gap between people
to work in solidarity to mitigate climate change. The same cannot be true of national policies
formed by an elite oligarchy and seen as an imposition on a disconnected public; this motivates
pushback through both corporate lobbying against regulation and individual noncompliance
when people cannot genuinely appreciate the benefits of mitigation. Thus grassroots organizing
can establish social norms through emotional narrative in a way that top-down approaches can
only unsustainably enforce.
Grassroots organizing currently lacks the large scale solidarity necessary to effectively
address our climate crisis, but this does not make it less necessary. Where top-down frameworks
fail in persuading (rather than attempting to coerce) behavior and empowering the public to act
collaboratively, bottom-up frameworks haul ass. Fundamentally, a climate action plan issued by
an oligarchy without approval of the rest of the globe will fail. Humans require relatable
motivation to justify action, and it is individual humans who are both responsible for and capable
of altering climate change. Though localized organizing can seem too small or too
disharmonious, this is a flaw of current recruiting tactics rather than of bottom-up activism itself.
Effective, cohesive grassroots organizing capable of keeping our temperature rise well below 2°
Celsius must learn to appeal to common interests and become more inviting to those who may
not be economically or mentally on par with those affiliated. We must begin to find these
universal values and act in solidarity as a globe—not as representatives of it—if we are to save
ourselves. Climate change is undeniably a tragedy, but it also provides a historically unique
opportunity to form a unified international front against a collective threat. In light of renowned
Kentucky environmental lawyer Tom Fitzgerald’s speech topic at Centre College, I too would
agree that Margaret Mead was right: “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed
citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.” We must intertwine our
roots.
Works Cited
Hoffman, Andrew J. How Culture Shapes the Climate Change Debate. Palo Alto, US: Stanford
UP, 2015. Print.
Kearns, Laurel. “The Role of Religions in Activism.” Ed. Dryzek, John S., Richard B. Norgaard,
and David Schlosberg. Oxford Handbook of Climate Change and Society. Oxford, U.K.:
Oxford UP, 2011. Print. 414-425.
Moser, Susanne C., and Lisa Dilling. “Communicating Climate Change: Closing the Science-
Action Gap.” Ed. Dryzek, John S., Richard B. Norgaard, and David Schlosberg. Oxford
Handbook of Climate Change and Society. Oxford, U.K.: Oxford UP, 2011. Print. 161-
169.
"Our Mission." KY Student Environmental Coalition. N.p., n.d. Web. 13 Apr. 2016.

More Related Content

What's hot

Collective impact article
Collective impact articleCollective impact article
Collective impact articleGreenlights
 
Enhancing Justice and Sustainability at the Local Level: Affordable Policies ...
Enhancing Justice and Sustainability at the Local Level: Affordable Policies ...Enhancing Justice and Sustainability at the Local Level: Affordable Policies ...
Enhancing Justice and Sustainability at the Local Level: Affordable Policies ...ElisaMendelsohn
 
Rural Climate Dialogues: Morris
Rural Climate Dialogues: MorrisRural Climate Dialogues: Morris
Rural Climate Dialogues: MorrisJefferson Center
 
YOUR COLOUR IS GREEN - PAPER OF LUISA VINCIGUERRA ITALY
YOUR COLOUR IS GREEN - PAPER OF LUISA VINCIGUERRA ITALYYOUR COLOUR IS GREEN - PAPER OF LUISA VINCIGUERRA ITALY
YOUR COLOUR IS GREEN - PAPER OF LUISA VINCIGUERRA ITALYLuisa Vinciguerra
 
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal Cities
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal CitiesResilience By Design: The Future of Coastal Cities
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal CitiesThe Rockefeller Foundation
 
Em Friends Of Earth
Em Friends Of EarthEm Friends Of Earth
Em Friends Of Earthrajmohan670
 
Irene Dankelman_Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction are NOT...
Irene Dankelman_Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction are NOT...Irene Dankelman_Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction are NOT...
Irene Dankelman_Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction are NOT...hbs_Palestine_Jordan
 
Report_Faith_Ecology
Report_Faith_EcologyReport_Faith_Ecology
Report_Faith_EcologyAnnie Fortnow
 
Equity workshop: Balancing equity and efficiency in Payments for Ecosystem Se...
Equity workshop: Balancing equity and efficiency in Payments for Ecosystem Se...Equity workshop: Balancing equity and efficiency in Payments for Ecosystem Se...
Equity workshop: Balancing equity and efficiency in Payments for Ecosystem Se...IIED
 
Rural Climate Dialogues: Itasca
Rural Climate Dialogues: Itasca Rural Climate Dialogues: Itasca
Rural Climate Dialogues: Itasca Jefferson Center
 
12 domains of people powered change
12 domains of people powered change12 domains of people powered change
12 domains of people powered changeCormac Russell
 
Understanding Sustainable Development: Intergenerational Justice
Understanding Sustainable Development: Intergenerational JusticeUnderstanding Sustainable Development: Intergenerational Justice
Understanding Sustainable Development: Intergenerational JusticePreeti Sikder
 
Reconciling Participation And Benefits Sharing 1
Reconciling Participation And Benefits Sharing 1Reconciling Participation And Benefits Sharing 1
Reconciling Participation And Benefits Sharing 1Ln Perch
 

What's hot (19)

Collective impact article
Collective impact articleCollective impact article
Collective impact article
 
Enhancing Justice and Sustainability at the Local Level: Affordable Policies ...
Enhancing Justice and Sustainability at the Local Level: Affordable Policies ...Enhancing Justice and Sustainability at the Local Level: Affordable Policies ...
Enhancing Justice and Sustainability at the Local Level: Affordable Policies ...
 
Fme Iain 103108
Fme Iain 103108Fme Iain 103108
Fme Iain 103108
 
Rural Climate Dialogues: Morris
Rural Climate Dialogues: MorrisRural Climate Dialogues: Morris
Rural Climate Dialogues: Morris
 
Environmental Governance
Environmental GovernanceEnvironmental Governance
Environmental Governance
 
MDGs Systemic Change Strategies
MDGs Systemic Change StrategiesMDGs Systemic Change Strategies
MDGs Systemic Change Strategies
 
YOUR COLOUR IS GREEN - PAPER OF LUISA VINCIGUERRA ITALY
YOUR COLOUR IS GREEN - PAPER OF LUISA VINCIGUERRA ITALYYOUR COLOUR IS GREEN - PAPER OF LUISA VINCIGUERRA ITALY
YOUR COLOUR IS GREEN - PAPER OF LUISA VINCIGUERRA ITALY
 
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal Cities
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal CitiesResilience By Design: The Future of Coastal Cities
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal Cities
 
Em Friends Of Earth
Em Friends Of EarthEm Friends Of Earth
Em Friends Of Earth
 
Irene Dankelman_Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction are NOT...
Irene Dankelman_Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction are NOT...Irene Dankelman_Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction are NOT...
Irene Dankelman_Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction are NOT...
 
Report_Faith_Ecology
Report_Faith_EcologyReport_Faith_Ecology
Report_Faith_Ecology
 
Equity workshop: Balancing equity and efficiency in Payments for Ecosystem Se...
Equity workshop: Balancing equity and efficiency in Payments for Ecosystem Se...Equity workshop: Balancing equity and efficiency in Payments for Ecosystem Se...
Equity workshop: Balancing equity and efficiency in Payments for Ecosystem Se...
 
Transnational Solidairty 2009
Transnational Solidairty 2009Transnational Solidairty 2009
Transnational Solidairty 2009
 
5b2f5f87 27ea-408b-9021-42a5baede3e5ss
5b2f5f87 27ea-408b-9021-42a5baede3e5ss5b2f5f87 27ea-408b-9021-42a5baede3e5ss
5b2f5f87 27ea-408b-9021-42a5baede3e5ss
 
Rural Climate Dialogues: Itasca
Rural Climate Dialogues: Itasca Rural Climate Dialogues: Itasca
Rural Climate Dialogues: Itasca
 
11. mahmud
11. mahmud11. mahmud
11. mahmud
 
12 domains of people powered change
12 domains of people powered change12 domains of people powered change
12 domains of people powered change
 
Understanding Sustainable Development: Intergenerational Justice
Understanding Sustainable Development: Intergenerational JusticeUnderstanding Sustainable Development: Intergenerational Justice
Understanding Sustainable Development: Intergenerational Justice
 
Reconciling Participation And Benefits Sharing 1
Reconciling Participation And Benefits Sharing 1Reconciling Participation And Benefits Sharing 1
Reconciling Participation And Benefits Sharing 1
 

Viewers also liked

Proposals - FINAL1
Proposals - FINAL1Proposals - FINAL1
Proposals - FINAL1Ian Dews
 
2006 Reintegration Puzzle Prog Support Off LGCC
2006 Reintegration Puzzle Prog Support Off LGCC2006 Reintegration Puzzle Prog Support Off LGCC
2006 Reintegration Puzzle Prog Support Off LGCCKylie Nix
 
Birmingham governance seminar presentation
Birmingham governance seminar presentationBirmingham governance seminar presentation
Birmingham governance seminar presentationEffectiveStates
 
Digipac analysis
Digipac analysisDigipac analysis
Digipac analysisBridie Lacy
 
Foundation of organizational behavior
Foundation of organizational behaviorFoundation of organizational behavior
Foundation of organizational behaviorDavid Jaison
 
Diseños Experimentales Mixtos
Diseños Experimentales MixtosDiseños Experimentales Mixtos
Diseños Experimentales MixtosFabiana Garcia
 
La generación z. Redes sociales y tecnología en el ocio juvenil
La generación z. Redes sociales y tecnología en el ocio juvenilLa generación z. Redes sociales y tecnología en el ocio juvenil
La generación z. Redes sociales y tecnología en el ocio juvenilJose María Regalado
 
Teaching strategies - Pedagogy
Teaching strategies - PedagogyTeaching strategies - Pedagogy
Teaching strategies - PedagogyLigia Aguilar
 
ZutA Robotic printer
ZutA Robotic printerZutA Robotic printer
ZutA Robotic printerDavid Jaison
 

Viewers also liked (11)

Food Lab 3
Food Lab 3Food Lab 3
Food Lab 3
 
Proposals - FINAL1
Proposals - FINAL1Proposals - FINAL1
Proposals - FINAL1
 
2006 Reintegration Puzzle Prog Support Off LGCC
2006 Reintegration Puzzle Prog Support Off LGCC2006 Reintegration Puzzle Prog Support Off LGCC
2006 Reintegration Puzzle Prog Support Off LGCC
 
Birmingham governance seminar presentation
Birmingham governance seminar presentationBirmingham governance seminar presentation
Birmingham governance seminar presentation
 
Digipac analysis
Digipac analysisDigipac analysis
Digipac analysis
 
Foundation of organizational behavior
Foundation of organizational behaviorFoundation of organizational behavior
Foundation of organizational behavior
 
Diseños Experimentales Mixtos
Diseños Experimentales MixtosDiseños Experimentales Mixtos
Diseños Experimentales Mixtos
 
La generación z. Redes sociales y tecnología en el ocio juvenil
La generación z. Redes sociales y tecnología en el ocio juvenilLa generación z. Redes sociales y tecnología en el ocio juvenil
La generación z. Redes sociales y tecnología en el ocio juvenil
 
Teaching strategies - Pedagogy
Teaching strategies - PedagogyTeaching strategies - Pedagogy
Teaching strategies - Pedagogy
 
ZutA Robotic printer
ZutA Robotic printerZutA Robotic printer
ZutA Robotic printer
 
Viviana Meza
Viviana MezaViviana Meza
Viviana Meza
 

Similar to ENS 430 Essay 2

Revaluing Ecosystems: Visions of a better future
Revaluing Ecosystems: Visions of a better futureRevaluing Ecosystems: Visions of a better future
Revaluing Ecosystems: Visions of a better futureThe Rockefeller Foundation
 
Youth and Climate Change: Areas for Youth Development
Youth and Climate Change: Areas for Youth DevelopmentYouth and Climate Change: Areas for Youth Development
Youth and Climate Change: Areas for Youth DevelopmentLeneka Rhoden
 
HOW TO TALK EFFECTIVELY ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE
HOW TO TALK EFFECTIVELY ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGEHOW TO TALK EFFECTIVELY ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE
HOW TO TALK EFFECTIVELY ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGEHaulTail
 
372017 Opposing Viewpoints in Context­ Print18Green.docx
372017 Opposing Viewpoints in Context­ Print18Green.docx372017 Opposing Viewpoints in Context­ Print18Green.docx
372017 Opposing Viewpoints in Context­ Print18Green.docxtamicawaysmith
 
Environmentalism And Environment
Environmentalism And EnvironmentEnvironmentalism And Environment
Environmentalism And EnvironmentAmanda Reed
 
A Great Transition Initiative Viewpoint
A Great Transition Initiative ViewpointA Great Transition Initiative Viewpoint
A Great Transition Initiative ViewpointKatie Robinson
 
Around the Circle in 365 days
Around the Circle in 365 daysAround the Circle in 365 days
Around the Circle in 365 daysLeora Berman
 
Introduction to sustainability principles 101 june 2 2010
Introduction to sustainability principles 101 june 2 2010Introduction to sustainability principles 101 june 2 2010
Introduction to sustainability principles 101 june 2 2010lauraebrown
 
Essay On Conservation Of Environment. Article on conservation of environment...
Essay On Conservation Of Environment.  Article on conservation of environment...Essay On Conservation Of Environment.  Article on conservation of environment...
Essay On Conservation Of Environment. Article on conservation of environment...afjzdtooeofvaa
 
N Gillis_Sustainable Supply Chain
N Gillis_Sustainable Supply ChainN Gillis_Sustainable Supply Chain
N Gillis_Sustainable Supply ChainNancy Gillis
 
TNC_TheScienceOfSustainability_04.pdf
TNC_TheScienceOfSustainability_04.pdfTNC_TheScienceOfSustainability_04.pdf
TNC_TheScienceOfSustainability_04.pdfssuseradcd4b
 
RIDOH Policy Intern_CHRP Paper_Maloney
RIDOH Policy Intern_CHRP Paper_MaloneyRIDOH Policy Intern_CHRP Paper_Maloney
RIDOH Policy Intern_CHRP Paper_MaloneyJenna Maloney
 
campusgreenguide
campusgreenguidecampusgreenguide
campusgreenguideAdam Popper
 
Abubakar Koki
Abubakar KokiAbubakar Koki
Abubakar Kokiuuthmann
 
CSCR Community Track #1: Talking About Climate Using Tools of Media Literacy....
CSCR Community Track #1: Talking About Climate Using Tools of Media Literacy....CSCR Community Track #1: Talking About Climate Using Tools of Media Literacy....
CSCR Community Track #1: Talking About Climate Using Tools of Media Literacy....Sustainable Tompkins
 
Student Diplomacy for Climate Action: Inspiring Global Leadership and Collabo...
Student Diplomacy for Climate Action: Inspiring Global Leadership and Collabo...Student Diplomacy for Climate Action: Inspiring Global Leadership and Collabo...
Student Diplomacy for Climate Action: Inspiring Global Leadership and Collabo...CarmenLee205763
 
Exploring Community Resilience
Exploring Community ResilienceExploring Community Resilience
Exploring Community ResilienceKirsty Tait
 

Similar to ENS 430 Essay 2 (20)

Revaluing Ecosystems: Visions of a better future
Revaluing Ecosystems: Visions of a better futureRevaluing Ecosystems: Visions of a better future
Revaluing Ecosystems: Visions of a better future
 
Youth and Climate Change: Areas for Youth Development
Youth and Climate Change: Areas for Youth DevelopmentYouth and Climate Change: Areas for Youth Development
Youth and Climate Change: Areas for Youth Development
 
HOW TO TALK EFFECTIVELY ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE
HOW TO TALK EFFECTIVELY ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGEHOW TO TALK EFFECTIVELY ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE
HOW TO TALK EFFECTIVELY ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE
 
372017 Opposing Viewpoints in Context­ Print18Green.docx
372017 Opposing Viewpoints in Context­ Print18Green.docx372017 Opposing Viewpoints in Context­ Print18Green.docx
372017 Opposing Viewpoints in Context­ Print18Green.docx
 
Youth Forum_FinalReport
Youth Forum_FinalReportYouth Forum_FinalReport
Youth Forum_FinalReport
 
Environmentalism And Environment
Environmentalism And EnvironmentEnvironmentalism And Environment
Environmentalism And Environment
 
A Great Transition Initiative Viewpoint
A Great Transition Initiative ViewpointA Great Transition Initiative Viewpoint
A Great Transition Initiative Viewpoint
 
Around the Circle in 365 days
Around the Circle in 365 daysAround the Circle in 365 days
Around the Circle in 365 days
 
Introduction to sustainability principles 101 june 2 2010
Introduction to sustainability principles 101 june 2 2010Introduction to sustainability principles 101 june 2 2010
Introduction to sustainability principles 101 june 2 2010
 
Essay On Conservation Of Environment. Article on conservation of environment...
Essay On Conservation Of Environment.  Article on conservation of environment...Essay On Conservation Of Environment.  Article on conservation of environment...
Essay On Conservation Of Environment. Article on conservation of environment...
 
N Gillis_Sustainable Supply Chain
N Gillis_Sustainable Supply ChainN Gillis_Sustainable Supply Chain
N Gillis_Sustainable Supply Chain
 
ReadChapter4forwhymetricsmatter
ReadChapter4forwhymetricsmatterReadChapter4forwhymetricsmatter
ReadChapter4forwhymetricsmatter
 
TNC_TheScienceOfSustainability_04.pdf
TNC_TheScienceOfSustainability_04.pdfTNC_TheScienceOfSustainability_04.pdf
TNC_TheScienceOfSustainability_04.pdf
 
Co-Opportunity
Co-OpportunityCo-Opportunity
Co-Opportunity
 
RIDOH Policy Intern_CHRP Paper_Maloney
RIDOH Policy Intern_CHRP Paper_MaloneyRIDOH Policy Intern_CHRP Paper_Maloney
RIDOH Policy Intern_CHRP Paper_Maloney
 
campusgreenguide
campusgreenguidecampusgreenguide
campusgreenguide
 
Abubakar Koki
Abubakar KokiAbubakar Koki
Abubakar Koki
 
CSCR Community Track #1: Talking About Climate Using Tools of Media Literacy....
CSCR Community Track #1: Talking About Climate Using Tools of Media Literacy....CSCR Community Track #1: Talking About Climate Using Tools of Media Literacy....
CSCR Community Track #1: Talking About Climate Using Tools of Media Literacy....
 
Student Diplomacy for Climate Action: Inspiring Global Leadership and Collabo...
Student Diplomacy for Climate Action: Inspiring Global Leadership and Collabo...Student Diplomacy for Climate Action: Inspiring Global Leadership and Collabo...
Student Diplomacy for Climate Action: Inspiring Global Leadership and Collabo...
 
Exploring Community Resilience
Exploring Community ResilienceExploring Community Resilience
Exploring Community Resilience
 

More from Mariah Harrod

More from Mariah Harrod (18)

Law & Society Essay 3
Law & Society Essay 3Law & Society Essay 3
Law & Society Essay 3
 
ENG Paper 2
ENG Paper 2ENG Paper 2
ENG Paper 2
 
Was Aristotle an Environmentalist
Was Aristotle an EnvironmentalistWas Aristotle an Environmentalist
Was Aristotle an Environmentalist
 
The Watershed Protection & Flood Prevention Act
The Watershed Protection & Flood Prevention ActThe Watershed Protection & Flood Prevention Act
The Watershed Protection & Flood Prevention Act
 
ENS 430 Essay 1
ENS 430 Essay 1ENS 430 Essay 1
ENS 430 Essay 1
 
Second PHI 210 Paper
Second PHI 210 PaperSecond PHI 210 Paper
Second PHI 210 Paper
 
research paper
research paperresearch paper
research paper
 
Ecology Essay
Ecology EssayEcology Essay
Ecology Essay
 
EE Essay 1
EE Essay 1EE Essay 1
EE Essay 1
 
Bio Essay 4
Bio Essay 4Bio Essay 4
Bio Essay 4
 
Republican messaging
Republican messagingRepublican messaging
Republican messaging
 
Brief 3
Brief 3Brief 3
Brief 3
 
ANT 320 FINAL
ANT 320 FINALANT 320 FINAL
ANT 320 FINAL
 
ARH 383 ECO-ARTIVISM
ARH 383 ECO-ARTIVISMARH 383 ECO-ARTIVISM
ARH 383 ECO-ARTIVISM
 
ENS Research Paper
ENS Research PaperENS Research Paper
ENS Research Paper
 
Appalachia_MH_7.7
Appalachia_MH_7.7Appalachia_MH_7.7
Appalachia_MH_7.7
 
Mine Reclamation
Mine ReclamationMine Reclamation
Mine Reclamation
 
Nuclear Storage_MH_6.15
Nuclear Storage_MH_6.15Nuclear Storage_MH_6.15
Nuclear Storage_MH_6.15
 

ENS 430 Essay 2

  • 1. Grassroots Organizing and Public Activation in Climate Action By: Mariah Harrod Grassroots activism entails citizens organizing around some common value or goal. In contrast, top-down efforts utilize overarching frameworks to impose large-scale change on communities. Both approaches to environmentalism have been undertaken with their own merits and pitfalls, yet in the face of such time-salient and globally threatening issues as climate change in the midst of a lack of binding international governmental agreement, grassroots organizing offers an accessible and universally motivating route to mitigation. To demonstrate these advantages I highlight one grassroots organization working against climate change, the Kentucky Student Environmental Coalition (KSEC). KSEC is a statewide network of students and their allies holding the government, corporations, and other institutions accountable through education and activism (“Our Mission”). By utilizing college campuses, KSEC is able to alter the actual practices of communities and individuals and increase regional solidarity to empower the public in a way that is imperative for the globally-affected populace to respond to climate change. Within the past few months, KSEC has demonstrated remarkable success in reducing carbon impacts through lobbying. This was chiefly accomplished through the work of one of three teams subdividing KSEC, the Political Working Group. The PWG is composed of students from Centre College, University of Kentucky, Transylvania University, Eastern Kentucky University, and Covington Latin High School and administrated by KSEC President Cara Cooper. Relying on biweekly conference calls and delegation, this team has recently managed to:  organize a climate action rally at the state capital
  • 2.  partner with a legislative sponsor and introduce a state bill (currently HB 339/SB 190) establishing a feed-in tariff, mandating Kentucky utility companies purchase 12.5% of their electricity from renewable sources, and setting an efficiency standard for these companies to create energy savings over time  collect over 700 student signatures on a petition indicating support of the bill  hold a lobbying day and youth forum for the bill in which a new sponsor and supporters were recruited  persuade the EKU president to sign a climate commitment KSEC members & allies join to listen to speeches relating to representative action on climate change.
  • 3. KSEC students meet with a bill sponsor to discuss lobbying strategies. These accomplishments are perhaps intangible in print but when enforced supremely efficacious in catalyzing larger scale mitigation through citizens organizing. Additionally, the two less active KSEC teams, the Local Food Working Group and the Just Transition Working Group, have held their own planning meetings and lobby days to convince local and regional decision-makers to cut fossil fuel use. These initiatives involved meeting with decision makers and demanding adherence by merit of being a paying student or voting constituent. Grassroots organizing thus allows an individual to amplify their voice on a more intimately personal scale than is possible through a distant lens of democratic representation.
  • 4. Though institutional change is powerful and pervasive in the battle for emission limits, individual alterations in behavior as a result of public aggregation both arise from and establish norms to influence the remainder of society. This is unique to small grassroots organizing which relies heavily on interpersonal relationships and emotional appeal. Seasonally—with short sessions in fall and spring and a week-long program in the summer—KSEC holds a “summit” inviting students, graduates, teachers, and allied environmental associations to participate in workshops for discussion of relevant issues and possible solutions. At these summits, provided meals are often vegetarian, vegan, or local to reduce the resource consumption and emissions associated with meat and distantly processed foods. Spring 2016 Summit.
  • 5. Participants remind each other to shut off lights, compost fruit peels, and exchange advice on sustainable farming. These are important conversations unique to small-scale grassroots activism in that they sidestep the larger scale tendency to overlook the individual. Indeed, mass media has failed to significantly alter individual behavior by marketing a “one size fits all” distant, impersonal, and uninspiring message (Moser and Dilling 165-168). Whereas top-down approaches often justify climate change mitigation using mentally inaccessible information, grassroots organizing engages interpersonal relationships in which social reinforcement—and the tailoring of specific interests, narratives, and emotions—is strongest (Moser and Dilling 168; Hoffman 79). Top-down approaches to climate change mitigation rely heavily upon scientific and economic analyses and, when political, are morphed through the lenses of several stakeholders rarely held accountable for accurate constituent representation. This ivory towered information alienates people and thus promotes contestation (Hoffman viii). Bottom-up grassroots organizing—at least on a small scale—aggregates individuals and inspires using emotional narrative. KSEC encourages story-telling as a catalyst of climate activism within events such as the youth forum and upcoming Clean Energy Tour. At the former, student and ally speakers (including members of KFTC and STAY Project, Senate candidate Sellus Wilder, and a Clean Power Planet podcaster) spoke in the capitol rotunda on why renewable energy is important to them. Explanations ranged from living in an industrial town with prominent health concerns to fear for an economy dependent upon finite resources to desire for youth to remain in the state.
  • 6. Similarly, the Clean Energy Tour recruits miners, farmers, students, and graduates to provide narrative on renewable energy in Kentucky to an audience of legislators. These endeavors are significant and unique to bottom-up approaches because story-telling provides a personally relatable intrinsic motivation to change behavior (Kearns 414). By emphasizing the veritable experiences of the individual, grassroots organizations are able to bridge the gap between people to work in solidarity to mitigate climate change. The same cannot be true of national policies
  • 7. formed by an elite oligarchy and seen as an imposition on a disconnected public; this motivates pushback through both corporate lobbying against regulation and individual noncompliance when people cannot genuinely appreciate the benefits of mitigation. Thus grassroots organizing can establish social norms through emotional narrative in a way that top-down approaches can only unsustainably enforce. Grassroots organizing currently lacks the large scale solidarity necessary to effectively address our climate crisis, but this does not make it less necessary. Where top-down frameworks fail in persuading (rather than attempting to coerce) behavior and empowering the public to act collaboratively, bottom-up frameworks haul ass. Fundamentally, a climate action plan issued by an oligarchy without approval of the rest of the globe will fail. Humans require relatable motivation to justify action, and it is individual humans who are both responsible for and capable of altering climate change. Though localized organizing can seem too small or too disharmonious, this is a flaw of current recruiting tactics rather than of bottom-up activism itself. Effective, cohesive grassroots organizing capable of keeping our temperature rise well below 2° Celsius must learn to appeal to common interests and become more inviting to those who may not be economically or mentally on par with those affiliated. We must begin to find these universal values and act in solidarity as a globe—not as representatives of it—if we are to save ourselves. Climate change is undeniably a tragedy, but it also provides a historically unique opportunity to form a unified international front against a collective threat. In light of renowned Kentucky environmental lawyer Tom Fitzgerald’s speech topic at Centre College, I too would agree that Margaret Mead was right: “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.” We must intertwine our roots.
  • 8. Works Cited Hoffman, Andrew J. How Culture Shapes the Climate Change Debate. Palo Alto, US: Stanford UP, 2015. Print. Kearns, Laurel. “The Role of Religions in Activism.” Ed. Dryzek, John S., Richard B. Norgaard, and David Schlosberg. Oxford Handbook of Climate Change and Society. Oxford, U.K.: Oxford UP, 2011. Print. 414-425. Moser, Susanne C., and Lisa Dilling. “Communicating Climate Change: Closing the Science- Action Gap.” Ed. Dryzek, John S., Richard B. Norgaard, and David Schlosberg. Oxford Handbook of Climate Change and Society. Oxford, U.K.: Oxford UP, 2011. Print. 161- 169. "Our Mission." KY Student Environmental Coalition. N.p., n.d. Web. 13 Apr. 2016.