SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 220
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Submitted by:
EcoConServ Environmental Solutions
January 2017
Submitted to:
United Nation Development program (UNDP)
For
The project “Protect human health and the environment from unintentional releases
of POPs originating from incineration and open burning of health care and electronic
waste”
Of
Global Environmental Facility (GEF)
This study is part of the inception phase of “Protect human health and the environment from
unintentional releases of POPs originating from incineration and open burning of health care and
electronic waste” project being implemented by the Ministry of Environment in collaboration with
the Ministry of Health and Population (MoHP) and the Ministry of Communications and
Information Technology (MCIT) with the technical support of United Nation Development
Program as mandated by the Global Environmental Facility (GEF). This report prepared by
EcoConServ environmental solutions (local consultancy firm).
Presented to:
United Nation Development Program
Att: Dr.Mohamed Bayoumi
UNDP Assistant Resident
Submitted by:
EcoConServ Environmental Solutions
12 El-Saleh Ayoub St., Zamalek, Cairo, Egypt 11211
Tel: +2 02 2735 9078 – +2 02 2736 4818
Fax: + 2 02 2736 5397
E-mail: genena@ecoconserv.com
URL: http/www.ecoconserv.com
Assessment of WEEE Management In
Egypt
Final Report
January 2017
Acknowledgement of Contributors and Peer Reviewers
The authors would like to thank the interviewed stakeholders for their contribution with this study.
Special thanks go to Dr.Tarek M.Araby and Ms.Hoda Shakra for their contribution, relentless effort
in data acquisition, coordination and interface with governmental entities that allowed the
completion of this study.
We greatly appreciate and thank the following individuals for serving as peer reviewers of the
content of this study and qualifying it.
Eng. Ghada Abdel
Elmoneim
Manager of Hazardous Waste and Substances- Waste Management
Regulatory Agency(WMRA), Ministry of Environment
Eng. Essam Abd Elaziz Manger of Hazardous Substances, Waste Management Regulatory
Agency(WMRA), Ministry of Environment
Eng. Ghada Abdelmonem General Manager of Hazardous Substances and Waste
Department, Waste Management Regulatory Agency (WMRA),
Ministry of Environment
Eng. Yasser Abd El-Bary Program Manager of Electronics Industry, Information
Technology Industry Development Agency (ITIDA)
Eng. Mona Darwish Project Manager, Information Infrastructure Sector-Ministry of
Communication and Information Technology(MCIT)
Eng. Ahmed Hammam Unit Manager, Telecommunications Projects Planning
Department, Ministry of Communication and Information
Technology(MCIT)
Eng. Hoda Shakra Technical officer, GEF-UNDP Project on Protect Human Health
and the Environment from Unintentional Releases of POPs
Originating from Incineration and Open Burning of Health Care
and Electronic Waste
Ms. Anahide Bondolfi Senior Consultant , Sofies group
Issue and Revision Record
Information Class: Secure
EcoConServ Environmental Solutions herein
by referred to as the Consultant has prepared
this report with all care and diligence, and
taking account of the Services and the Terms
agreed solely between EcoConServ
Environmental Solutions and the Client,
which commissioned it.
No representation, warranty or undertaking, is
made and no responsibility or liability is
accepted by the consultant to any party other
than the Client or any Recipient(s), as to the
accuracy or completeness of the report
content. This report does not include any
legal, insurance or financial advice or opinion.
The consultant accepts no responsibility for
data, information or statements supplied to us
by other parties including the client (‘Data’).
EcoConServ has not verified such Data and
has assumed it accurate, complete, and
reliable. Forecasts presented in this document
were prepared using Data and the report is
dependent /based on Data. Inevitably, some
of the assumptions used to develop the
forecasts will not be realized and
unanticipated events and circumstances may
occur. Consequently, EcoConServ does not
guarantee or warrant the conclusions
contained in the report, as there are likely to
be differences between the forecasts and the
actual results and those differences may be
material. While we consider the information
and opinions given in this report are sound,
all parties must rely on their own skill and
judgement when making use of it.
Version Control Log
Revision Date Made by Checked by Description
1 21/06/2016 As above Emad Raouf Draft Report
2 08/09/2016 As above Emad Raouf II Draft Report
3 15/12/2016 As above Emad Raouf Final Report
4 22/01/2017 As above Emad Raouf Final Report
[Updated]
5 30/01/2017 As above Emad Raouf Final Report
[Updated I]
Table of Content
TABLE OF CONTENT ...................................................................................................................................... 3
LIST OF FIGURES.............................................................................................................................................. 6
LIST OF TABLES................................................................................................................................................ 6
LIST OF ACRONYMS AND DEFINITIONS.................................................................................................... 8
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ..................................................................................................................................10
1 INTRODUCTION .....................................................................................................................................21
1.1 OVERVIEW ..........................................................................................................................................................................21
1.2 PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION .............................................................................................................................................22
1.3 OBJECTIVE OF THE ASSESSMENT....................................................................................................................................23
2 METHODS................................................................................................................................................ 24
2.1 DATA ACQUISITION ..........................................................................................................................................................24
2.1.1 Literature and Statistical Analysis...............................................................................................................................24
2.1.2 Meetings and Interviews..............................................................................................................................................25
2.1.3 Surveys and Questionnaires........................................................................................................................................25
2.1.4 Field Studies...................................................................................................................................................................25
2.2 MASS FLOW ASSESSMENT.................................................................................................................................................26
2.3 LIMITATIONS.......................................................................................................................................................................26
3 SYSTEM DEFINITION ........................................................................................................................... 28
3.1 GEOGRAPHICAL SCOPE ....................................................................................................................................................28
3.2 PRODUCT SCOPE................................................................................................................................................................28
3.2.1 Development of ICT Sector.......................................................................................................................................28
3.3 DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ..........................................................................................................................................29
4 POLICY AND LEGISLATION................................................................................................................. 32
4.1 ENVIRONMENTAL LAW AND ARTICLES.........................................................................................................................32
4.2 SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT RELATED LAWS ...........................................................................................................32
4.2.1 Law number 38 of 1967, General Public Cleansing ...............................................................................................33
4.2.2 Law Number 4 of 1994 and its amendments Law 9/2009, Environment Law ................................................33
4.2.3 Law Number 48 of 1982, Protection of the River Nile and its Canals...............................................................33
4.2.4 Laws Concerning Public Ways ...................................................................................................................................33
4.3 LAWS ON WEEE MANAGEMENT ...................................................................................................................................33
4.4 LAWS INFLUENCING WEEE RECYCLING INDUSTRY .................................................................................................33
4.4.1 Age of Imports..............................................................................................................................................................34
4.4.2 Second Hand Telecommunication Equipment Import .........................................................................................34
4.4.3 WEEE Import...............................................................................................................................................................34
4.4.4 The Egyptian Law of Auction....................................................................................................................................34
4.5 SOCIAL LAWS ......................................................................................................................................................................34
4.5.1 Law Number 137 of 1981, Labor Law .....................................................................................................................34
4.5.2 Child Labor....................................................................................................................................................................34
4.5.3 Freedom of Association ..............................................................................................................................................34
4.6 INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT ............................................................................34
4.7 GOVERNMENTAL BODIES AFFILIATED WITH WEEE MANAGEMENT ...................................................................36
5 STAKEHOLDER ASSESSMENT............................................................................................................. 45
5.1 MANUFACTURERS AND IMPORTS ....................................................................................................................................46
5.2 DISTRIBUTERS.....................................................................................................................................................................48
5.3 CONSUMERS........................................................................................................................................................................49
5.3.1 Households ....................................................................................................................................................................50
5.3.2 Enterprises .....................................................................................................................................................................52
5.3.3 Governmental Sector ...................................................................................................................................................54
5.4 END-OF-LIFE MANAGEMENT..........................................................................................................................................54
5.4.1 Informal Sector .............................................................................................................................................................56
5.4.2 Formal Sector ................................................................................................................................................................67
5.5 CIVIL SOCIETY....................................................................................................................................................................75
6 WEEE INVENTORY ASSESSMENT...................................................................................................... 77
6.1 METHODOLOGY ................................................................................................................................................................77
6.1.1 Conclusion .....................................................................................................................................................................81
6.2 CONCEPTUAL APPROACH.................................................................................................................................................81
6.3 ESTABLISHMENT OF INSTALLED BASE OF SELECTED TRACERS...............................................................................81
6.4 CURRENT WEEE INVENTORY AND MASS FLOW........................................................................................................85
6.4.1 Scenario Analysis – WEEE Inventory......................................................................................................................85
6.4.2 Mass flow .......................................................................................................................................................................85
6.5 FUTURE MASS FLOW TRENDS .........................................................................................................................................88
7 IMPACTS................................................................................................................................................... 92
7.1 HOT SPOTS..........................................................................................................................................................................92
7.2 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS.............................................................................................................................................93
7.3 SOCIAL IMPACTS.................................................................................................................................................................94
7.3.1 Impacts on Employees ................................................................................................................................................94
7.3.2 Impacts on Society........................................................................................................................................................95
7.4 ECONOMIC IMPACT...........................................................................................................................................................95
8 COUNTRY ANALYSIS - CHALLENGES IN RECYCLING WEEE...................................................... 98
8.1 PROPOSED ROADMAP FOR WEEE MANAGEMENT IN EGYPT................................................................................101
9 RECOMMENDATIONS..........................................................................................................................102
10 CONCLUSION.........................................................................................................................................106
11 LIST OF REFERENCES .........................................................................................................................108
12 ANNEXES ................................................................................................................................................ 110
Annex 1: Overview of Stakeholders & Contacts Who Agreed To Be Onymous
Annex 2: Field Survey Findings Report
Annex 3: Questionnaire/Survey Employed in Field Survey
Annex 4: Questionnaire Intended for Governmental Sector Survey
Annex 5: Imports Data Received From CAPMAS
Annex 6: Employees Number, Sectorial and Enterprise Category Received From CAPMAS
Annex 7: Weight, Composition and Category of Tracers
Annex 8: Detailed Calculation of Current WEEE Mass Flow
Annex 9: Overview of Hazardous Waste Legal Text and Classification
Page 6 of 112
List of Figures
Figure 1. WEEE in Egypt at glance...............................................................................................................................22
Figure 2. Life cycle chain of EEE/WEEE...................................................................................................................45
Figure 3. Computer Screen units Import. Display unit (x1000). Source: CAPMAS..............................................46
Figure 4. Mobile units Import. Display unit (x1000). Source: CAPMAS................................................................47
Figure 5. Telephone set units Import. Display unit (x1000). Source: CAPMAS....................................................48
Figure 6. Smart Phone Market Share Q3 of 2015 .......................................................................................................49
Figure 7. Mobile Subscription and penetration rate. Source: MCIT indicators......................................................50
Figure 8. Major findings on mobiles from household survey....................................................................................50
Figure 9. Telephone Subscription and penetration rate. Source: MCIT indicators ...............................................51
Figure 10. Major findings on telephones from survey................................................................................................51
Figure 11. PC in Households - survey findings ...........................................................................................................52
Figure 12. Survey findings – large enterprises..............................................................................................................53
Figure 13. Survey findings – SMEs................................................................................................................................53
Figure 14. Disposal Method of selected tracers - survey findings ............................................................................55
Figure 15. Overview on informal sector .......................................................................................................................59
Figure 16. WEEE Stock of Merchant in Kollaly district............................................................................................60
Figure 17. Type of cables burnt to retrieve copper.....................................................................................................60
Figure 18. Dismantled WEEE stock in Mr.Amar workshop ....................................................................................63
Figure 19. Sorted WEEE streams..................................................................................................................................63
Figure 20. Packed WEEE commodities for export ....................................................................................................63
Figure 21. Collected dismantled PCBs by Mr.Dani (first row) plus photos during transect and tracer walk....65
Figure 22. Photo documentation during transect and tracer walk in Alexandria WEEE hubs...........................66
Figure 23. Dismantling and sorting area .......................................................................................................................71
Figure 24. Mechanical crushing unit..............................................................................................................................71
Figure 25. Plastic crushing unit.......................................................................................................................................71
Figure 26. One product of mechanical crushing and magnetic separation .............................................................72
Figure 27. One gram of refined 24 carat gold..............................................................................................................72
Figure 28. Recyclobekia warehouse ...............................................................................................................................56
Figure 29. Sorting and dismantling in Eco Integrated Industrial Systems...............................................................57
Figure 30. Tentative source for data collection............................................................................................................79
Figure 31. WEEE mass flow chart ................................................................................................................................86
Figure 32. Mass percentage of major fractions in Category 3 ...................................................................................96
List of Tables
Table 1. Data acquisition .................................................................................................................................................24
Table 2. Social development indicators.........................................................................................................................29
Table 3. Environmental Indicators (2012)....................................................................................................................30
Table 4. Economic development indicators.................................................................................................................30
Table 5. Governmental bodies related to WEEE management................................................................................36
Table 6. Laws with influence on WEEE management...............................................................................................37
Table 7. Prices of WEEE streams. Source: Primary source - transect and tracer walk.........................................63
Table 8. EEE & WEEE Markets and Hubs ................................................................................................................64
Table 9. Processes performed on WEEE.....................................................................................................................68
Table 10. Reimbursable value of WEEE extracted commodities.............................................................................70
Page 7 of 112
Table 11. Price for hazardous waste/treatment...........................................................................................................74
Table 12. Quantities and prices of used mobile handsets collected by Resala NGO in 2014, 2013, 2012........76
Table 13. Tentative Sources of Data..............................................................................................................................77
Table 14. Constraint Table..............................................................................................................................................80
Table 15. Installed base of selected tracers...................................................................................................................84
Table 16. Average lifetime and cycle of selected tracers.............................................................................................85
Table 17. Mass flow chart calculation............................................................................................................................87
Table 18. Forecasted annual sales of tracers each succeeding years.........................................................................90
Table 19. Increase in installed volume of stock and WEEE– cumulative. .............................................................91
Table 20. Environmental Impacts..................................................................................................................................93
Table 21. Material composition of tracers - Umicore.................................................................................................95
Table 22. Economic magnitude of the WEEE mass flow.........................................................................................97
Table 23. List of recommendations .............................................................................................................................102
Page 8 of 112
List of Acronyms and Definitions
ARF Advanced Recycling Fee
CAPMAS Central Agency For Public Mobilization and Statistics
CAGR Cumulative Annual Growth Rate
CDD Compact Disk Drive
CEDARE Center For Environment & Development For The Arab Region & Europe
CRT Cathode Ray Tube
ECS EcoConServ Environmental Solutions
EEAA Egyptian Environmental Affairs Authority
ENCPC Egypt National Cleaner Production Centre
EPR Extended Producer Responsibility
WEEE Electronic Waste
FDD Floppy Disk Drive
GAGS General Authority of Government Services
HDD Hard Disk Drive
HWMU Hazardous Waste Management Unit
ICs Integrated Circuits
ICT Information and Communication Technology
ITU International Telecommunication Union
LCD Liquid Crystal Display
MTI Ministry Of Trade and Industry
NEAP National Environmental Action Plan
NTRA National Telecom Regulatory Authority
PC Personal Computer
PCBs Printed Circuit Boards
PPP Public Private Partnership
SMEs Small And Medium Enterprises
MSMEs Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises
UNIDO United Nations Industrial Development Organization
WEEE Waste Of Electric And Electronic Equipment
VOIP Voice Over Internet Protocol
WEEE Formal
Management
Firms
In the context of this report, the Consultant used this term to describe WEEE
management firms with established office/firm/plant that possess
environmental permit from Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency and
operational permit from Industrial Development Authority to perform their
respective activity with WEEE.
WEEE Informal
Management
Firms
In the context of this report, the Consultant used this term to describe WEEE
management firms that do not possess environmental permit from Egyptian
Environmental Affairs Agency and operational permit from Industrial
Page 9 of 112
Development Authority to perform their respective activity with WEEE.
Tons A tonne, also known as metric tons, is a unit of mass equaling 1,000 kilograms.
Page 10 of 112
Executive Summary
Overview
“WEEE is a term used to cover all items of electrical and electronic equipment (EEE) and its parts
that have been discarded by its owner as waste without the intent of reuse” (Step Initiative 2014).
The amout of electronic waste (WEEE/WEEE) has increased rapidly over the past years with
estimated generation capacity of 20-50 million tonnes annualy. WEEE impose a global challenge on
both develped and developing worlds due to the complex characterstic of this waste stream, where
its constitutent includes toxic and other resoureces that varies significanlty by product. Currently
electronic waste makes up around 5% of municipale waste world wide and is counted as the fastest
growing component of municipal solid waste stream.
Problem Identification
Egypt is among top three African countries with the highest WEEE generation in absolute
quantities, amounting 0.37 million tons in 2014. With no proper management of WEEE, this
signpost adverse environmental and health impact because of the constituents of this complex waste
stream which includes hazardous resources. As large quantities are generated per year, not enough
are collected/recycled by formal sector, leaving majority of WEEE treated or dumped, according to
the informal sector treatment.
Objective of the Assessment
The assessment will include:
 Analysis of local context and stakeholders identification
 Describe WEEE practices in the country by formal and informal sector
 Describe and analyze national policies and regulatory framework on WEEE handling and
recycling
 Establish baseline for current and future WEEE inventory and mass flow
 Identify hot spots and develop road map for WEEE management in Egypt
 Social and economic evaluation
 Environmental and social impacts of current WEEE practices
 Identify the challenges Egypt face with WEEE recycling industry
 Recommendations based on this study
Page 11 of 112
Data Acquisition
The consultant adopted multi-approach data collection, comprising of quantitative and qualitative
data from primary and secondary resources, followed by refining gathered data thorough reviewing
process to deduce reliable information.
Data input Source
Governmental Sources  Tracers Imports and
Exports Data Base
 Development indicators
(Population, education and
Economy)
 Households data
 ICT Indicators
 Quantitative data on selected
traceri
s
 Penetration rate on selected
tracers
 Tracers stock in
governmental bodies
 WEEE practices in
governmental entities
 Amount of disposed WEEE
from formal supplier
 Central Agency for Public
Mobilization and Statistics
(CAPMAS)
 Egyptian Ministry of
Communications and Information
Technology (MCIT)
 Information and Decision Support
Center (IDSC)
 General Authority of
Governmental Services (GAGS)
 National Telecom Regulatory
Authority (NTRA)
Regional and
International Data
Base
 EEE imports and exports
 Country profile
 International trade in goods
 Country solid waste profile
 WEEE developments –
country specific
 WEEE initiatives
 Economic opportunities
 UN Comtrade Database
 World Bank
 The Organization for Economic
Co-operation and Development
(OECD)
 the Regional Solid Waste Exchange
of Information and Expertise
Network (SWEEP-Net)
 Basel Convention Regional Center
(BCRC-Egypt)
 United Nations specialized agency
for information and
communication technologies (ITU)
Literatures  WEEE classification
 WEEE recycling potentials
 Best practices
 WEEE development in the
country
 Country practices
 Stakeholders mapping
 ArabDev
 Environmental protection Agency
(EPA) – U.S.A
 United Nation University (UNU)
 step-initiative
 Centre for Environment and
Development for the Arab Region
and Europe (CEDARE)
Page 12 of 112
Data input Source
Meetings & Interviews A number of meetings and interviews took place with institutions
representative, private sector representative, distributers, NGOs, formal
collectors, informal collectors and recyclers. The purpose was to draw the
current country practices with WEEE practices, collect quantitative and
qualitative information on WEEE, suggest recommendations as well as
gather scoped information on the selected tracers.
Surveys and
Questionnaires
The household survey was conducted on a sample of 1806 respondents at
households in the five target governorates (Cairo, Giza, Qalyubia,
Alexandria and Sharkeya). Private households were considered the survey
unit, hence each response to the questionnaire represents one family. The
total number of enterprises surveyed were 27 (9 companies in each of the
target governorates.) representing 19 SMEs and 8 large enterprise.
Enterprises were selected according to their sizes as well as to represent
different economic sectors. Total surveyed SMEs and large enterprises
were 19 and 8 respectively.
Product Scope (Tracers)
This assessment focuses on tracers that are considered the fasted growing waste streams and are
widely used among private and governmental sector in Egyptian population. As per the terms of
reference of the project, the tracers of category 1 chosen are Personal Computers comprising
desktop computers and laptops, tracers of category 2 chosen are mobile phones and tracer of
category 3 chosen are telephone sets. According to UK environmental agency, selected tracers falls
under IT and telecommunications equipment categories. Additional attention will be given on the
recycling practices of electrical cables in the Egyptian market. The composition of these categories
of equipment in terms of weight and materials is provided in Annex 7.
Policy and Legislation
Law 4 /1994 on the Environment and its amendments in Law 9/2009 are the over-riding
environmental laws for Egypt. Article 3 of the Presidential Decree issuing Law 4/1994 repeals all
provisions of other laws running counter to the provisions of Law 4/1994. One article in Law
4/1994 addresses general solid waste management and another addresses the management of
construction and demolition debris. In addition, five articles address hazardous waste management.
Egypt has no stipulated solid waste management law however Law 38/1967 on General Public
Cleaning and their amendments are the main legislation enforcing the establishment of solid waste
management.
Law 38/1967 on General Public Cleansing is the primary law governing the management of solid
waste in Egypt. It was enacted in 1967 and replaced all previous laws dealing with solid waste
Page 13 of 112
including Law 97/1956 on Organization of Garbage Collection and Transfer, Law 159/1953 on
Cleansing Public Squares, Streets and Highways, and Law 151/1947 on Cleansing Fences and
Unused Areas. Since 1967, it has been amended four times. In 1968, the Minister of Housing (MoH)
issued the executive regulations for the law (MoH 134/1968).
Law 48/1982 is the law for protection of the Nile and its canals. The executive regulations for Law
48/1982 were issued by Minister of Irrigation Decree Number 8 of 1983 (MoI 8/1983). The law and
its executive regulations and amendments in January 2013 by ministerial decision 92/2013 is
primarily focus on wastewater discharges to the Nile and its canals, but also contain articles that
include solid waste.
Two laws concerning public ways, such as highways, streets, and squares, Law 140/1956,
Occupation of Public Ways and Law 84/1968, Concerning Public Ways, contain restrictions on
solid waste management and disposal.
Egypt has listed WEEE is under the category of the hazardous waste list issued by the Ministry of
Industry (decision 165/2002), item 16. As WEEE is identified as hazardous waste by the
aforementioned decision articles addressing hazardous waste management in law 4/94 regulate it
Page 14 of 112
Governmental Bodies affiliated with WEEE Management
Entity Note
Ministry of Environment (MoE)
Egyptian Environmental Affairs
Agency (EEAA)
Waste Management Regulatory
Authority (WMRA)
Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency is the executive arm of the
Ministry of Environment
Ministry of Communication and
Information Technology
(MCIT)
The MCIT and MoE have signed Memorandum of Understanding
(MOU) in February 2010 to launch the Egyptian Green ICT Strategy.
MCIT and MoE have conducted several initiatives to introduce WEEE
management principles. The MCIT is keen to address the WEEE
management in the green ICT strategy
Ministry of Trade and Industry
(MTI)
Egyptian National Cleaner
Production Center (ENCPC)
The Egypt National Cleaner Production Centre (ENCPC) was
established in 2005 by the Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI) in
close cooperation with the United Nations Industrial Development
Organization (UNIDO) with the aim to promote green technologies,
revolutionize current national and local practices and transfer the
required knowledge for environmental friendly industries.
Ministry of Finance The auction of absolute EEE in public organizations is regulated and
supervised by the Ministry of Finance. Furthermore, The Egyptian
Customs Authority as part of Ministry of Finance inspect and monitors
the flow of electric and electronic equipment in and out of Egypt
National Telecom Regulatory
Authority (NTRA)
NTRA requires importers of telecommunication equipment to manage
safely telecommunication electronic waste in order to issue them
permit. This is intercepted through Waste Tracking Form, where
telecommunication equipment importers require submitting annually.
NTRA accepts the following ways of safely managing electronic waste:
Sending the waste to Nasreya hazardous landfill, delivering the
electronic waste to WEEE management firms (e.g. ITG) and selling of
telecommunication electronic waste in public auctions.
General Authority of
Government Services (GAGS)
The GAGS auctions the movable and immovable property of
administrative body and public authorities after being authorized by
those entities, in order to eliminate the problem of overstock and scrap
(this includes electronic waste). Also, the GAGS auctions goods and
commodities that are obsolete or confiscated by customs.
Hazardous Waste Management
Unit (HWMU) in Nasreya
recycling and disposal center
It was established as part of Finnish Egyptian cooperation for the
design and construction of hazardous waste treatment system. Where
the Governor of Alexandria issue a decree No.416 in 2000 to establish a
unit of hazardous management. The project constitute of two phases,
Phase I of the facility includes a secure landfill and solar evaporation
ponds to receive wastes, and Phase II includes mechanical and chemical
treatment, solidification, and interim storage.
Page 15 of 112
Method Employed, Installed Base of Tracers and Mass Flow
The application of Approximation 1 Stock method that is also referred as “Consumption and Use”
requires data on saturation level, number of households, stock data and average life time. These data
are available from different governmental and private secondary sources and supported by
survey/questionnaire carried out. The inventory assessment is based upon approximation 1 stock
method that would form the baseline for the future WEEE projections according to imports and
market research agencies finding.
The conceptual approach of tracers’ inventory assessment is based on three steps are employed to
described as following:
Step 1: Establish the installed base of selected tracers with medium term future projections (5 years)
to ensure the reliability of the projections
Step 2: Identify obsolescence rate and average life cycle data using “upper limit” and “lower limit”
Step 3: Quantify WEEE inventory and mass flow with medium future projections
The following table provides the installed base of selected tracers
Page 16 of 112
Installed base of selected tracers
Quantity Unit
2,407,911.0 enterprise
1,631.0 enterprise
91,508,084.0 capita
21,787,639.0 households
5,752,039.0 employee
Assumptions for calculation
Goveronmental sector
employees
Private MSMEs
Private large enter
Egypt Population 2015
Egypt HHs 2015
subject Tracer kg
Mobile 0.1
Telephone 1.0
Computer 9.9
Laptop 3.5
CRT monitor 14.1
LCD monitor 4.7
Weights
Unit Weight Unit Weight(kg) Unit Weight(kg) Unit Weight(kg) Unit Weight(kg) Unit Weight(kg) Subtotal
[-] [kg] [-] [kg] [-] [kg] [-] [kg] [-] [kg] [-] [kg] Weight(kg)
94,020,000.0 9,402,000.0 6,240,000.0 6,240,000.0 15,642,000.0
8,375,342.8 82,915,893.2 3,869,310.4 13,542,586.4 4,941,452.2 69,674,476.3 3,433,890.5 16,139,285.5 182,272,241.4
24,242,210.0 24,242,210.0 26,522,903.0 262,576,739.7 24,258,520.0 84,904,820.0 5,304,580.60 74,794,586.5 21,218,322.4 99,726,115.3 546,244,471.4
958,673.2 958,673.2 563,699.8 5,580,628.2 241,585.6 845,549.7 169,109.9 2,384,450.2 394,589.9 1,854,572.4 11,623,873.8
94,020,000.0 9,402,000.0 31,440,883.2 31,440,883.2 35,461,945.57 351,073,261.17 28,369,416.03 99,292,956.11 10,415,142.77 146,853,513.05 25,046,802.80 117,719,973.18
755,782,586.7
Total (tons) 755,782.59
LCD Monitor
Population
Actor
Total of installed base of tracers (Stock
istalled)
Mobile Telephone Desktop Computer Laptop CRT Monitor
Total (kg)
Sub Total
Goveronmental Sector
Enterprises
Households
Page 17 of 112
Mass flow of Tracers
Legend
Stock tons
WEEE1 Scenario 1 tons/year
WEEE2 Scenario 2 tons/year
Imports data not incorporated due
to Data limitation in receiving the
annual tracers import.
Product Waste
Page 18 of 112
The governmental sector and enterprises electronic obsolete equipment is mostly disposed in
auctions. The largest electronic waste generated is by enterprises (amounting ≈58%), followed by
households (amounting ≈23%) and governmental sector (amounting ≈19%). Based on scenario 1
the mass flow is 72,992.7 tons/year and based on scenario 2 the mass flow is 66,203.8 tons/year.
The largest amount of mass flow is generated by the enterprises, followed by households then
governmental sector. Post dismantling of tracers, extracted commodities as plastics, iron, etc. is
processed and reinstalled in the market as feedstock for other industries. Currently only around
1,608.0 tons/year of electronic waste is been collected from the total generated electronic waste
mass flow, which only represents 2.2% to 2.4% based on WEEE1 and WEEE2 respectively. For
the selected tracers, the stock of equipment/inhabitant and stock of equipment/household is around
8.3 kg and 34.69 kg respectively. As for the waste mass /year/inhabitant is around 0.80 kg (WEEE1)
and 0.72 kg (WEEE2).
Hot spots
Eol from consumer
1 Waste auction by public sector has no recycling regulation on collectors – ending with informal sector.
2 Waste auction by enterprises is not subjected to regulation on sustainable recycling.
3 Consumer dump WEEE with household waste. No EPR, WEEE goes to maintenance and service shops and
downstream end with informal sector.
Material recovery
4 WEEE management firms: “Cherry picking” of WEEE - WEEE which requires careful handling or low
economic revenue eventually ends with informal sector.
5 Informal sector: inappropriate dismantling of hazardous component; child labour; negative health impacts; wires
and cables burning.
Informal Dumping
6 Emissions from dumped waste; emissions from informal burning sites; not all secondary recourses efficiently are
recovered.
Section ‎8.1 suggest the interventions in form of roadmap for WEEE management in Egypt
Page 19 of 112
Conclusion
In this study, assessment for electronic waste in Egypt has been performed encompassing legal
assessment, stakeholder assessment, installed stock and mass flow assessment, scenario analysis of
mass flow, assessment of country challenges in recycling WEEE, proposed roadmap and
recommendations. In Egypt, there is no specific regulation regarding electronic waste management,
it is strongly recommended to enact a definition of electronic waste and regulations on electronic
waste management. Most of households electronic waste downstream ends with informal sector, the
electronic wastes from governmental sector and enterprises is mostly auctioned and this occur with
no environmental health and safety requirement neither end treatment requirement on participants.
Up to date of this study, six WEEE management firms practice in depth dismantling and recycling
some of base metals in local industries, of which only two of the six WEEE management firms are
formal as per the definition stipulated in this study. Only two of the six WEEE management firms
do recycle PCBs and other electronic boards by employing mechanical and chemical processing. It is
well noted that most of the WEEE management firms are facing challenges in dealing with CRT
monitors and batteries due to lack of knowledge treatment and negative economic value,
consequently, the behavior of “cherry picking” of specific electronic waste has been observed.
During the process of mapping the informal sector, transect and tracer walk, no chemical processing
on electronic waste has been reported. However, improper handling of electronic waste and open air
burning was been reported. At the time being, there are persons in the informal sector who are
managing to export PCBs and electronic boards abroad. This WEEE practices by the formal and
informal sector impact is rated as medium with medium sensitivity, because there is no chemical
processing reported in the informal sector, the sensitivity of impact is not critical. Nevertheless,
currently the practices in informal sector are ignoring safety, health, and environment concern,
which necessitate timely interventions on many levels to minimize the impact and the sensitivity of
the impact.
With respect to electronic waste quantification, a number of tracers has been selected that are
considered most being employed within the population, also because the appliances contain a
considerable amount of precious metals and base metals, the tracers represent category 3 as per UK
environmental agency WEEE categorization. The tracers are mobile, telephone, desktop PC, laptop
PC, CRT monitor and LCD monitor. There has been difficulty in quantifying the tracers’
penetration, demand and waste in governmental sector, given the limited time and financial scope,
the consultant adopted alternative approach based on official data and indicative survey. However, it
is strongly recommended to perform survey across governmental sector and maintain non-fiscal
database for any future studies affiliated with electronic waste.
For year 2015, installed base of tracers reached around 755,782.59 tons with enterprises having the
largest volume of installed tracers, followed by households and governmental sector respectively.
This represents 8.3kg stock of tracer/inhabitant and 34.89kg stock of tracer/household. As for the
waste mass flow of selected tracers, it ranged between 72,992.7 tons/year to 66,203.8 tons/year
Page 20 of 112
based on scenario 1 and scenario 2 respectively. This amounts 0.80kg WEEE/inhabitant based on
scenario 1 and 0.72 kg/inhabitant based on scenario 2. As reported during interviews, only around
1584.0 tons/year of WEEE is collected from the market, which only represents 2.2 % to 2.4%. This
suggests the market is very promising for electronic waste recycling initiatives. But also suggest
timely intervention is required, because the majority of electronic waste has unidentified final
destination, which indicates a large loss of valuable economic potential as well as added negative
value of environmental and health degradation if most of the mass flow is subjected to informal
sector treatment.
The study suggests road map for WEEE management in Egypt. To ensure the sustainability of the
WEEE recycling business in Egypt, This study recommends that existing informal sector be
integrated in the formal waste management system in “safe” recycling processes. This can take form
accrediting and empowering informal sector for collection and dismantling, supported by
environmental health and safety regulations. Cumulatively, this would be time saving for WEEE
management firms and lower labour cost. To reinforce the sustainability of the WEEE recycling
business in Egypt, alternative business models with financial incentives need to be studied, other
financial support to provide additional revenue and an effective collection design system need to be
established. Consequently, this would foster the recycling operations, smelting and refinery plants by
having constant feedstock from the collection points. Finally, the Consultant recommends that
future initiatives and pilot projects in the WEEE industry is advised to focus more on ensuring
effective collection of WEEE, given that the two current existing WEEE recycling plants are
encountering challenges with respect to employ effective processes on various encountered WEEE
to efficiently recover the precious metals.
End of Executive Summary
Page 21 of 112
1 Introduction
1.1 Overview
“WEEE is a term used to cover all items of electrical and electronic equipment (EEE) and its parts
that have been discarded by its owner as waste without the intent of reuse” (Step Initiative 2014).
The amout of electronic waste (WEEE/WEEE) has increased rapidly over the past years with
estimated generation capacity of 20-50 million tonnes annualy1
. WEEE impose a global challenge on
both develped and developing worlds due to the complex characterstic of this waste stream, where
its constitutent includes toxic and other resoureces that varies significanlty by product. Currently
electronic waste makes up around 5% of municipale waste world wide and is counted as the fastest
growing component of municipal solid waste stream2
.
302 million personal computers3
in 2014 and 336.3 million mobiles in 2015 were sold world wide4
,
which represents 65% percent annual sales rise than in 2004 for personal computers and over 100%
annual sales rise than in 2008 for mobiles. This sharp growth is expected to accelerate more, since
electronic equipment life span is decreasing over years while accompanied by consumer behaviour
that tend to acquire newer products attributed to technological progress in the market that offers
better services to end users. Among all devices, mobile phones and personal computers represent
the major problem as they are replaced in high frequency. In Europe WEEE is growing at a rate of
three to five percent annualy, and this figure is expected to triple for developing conutires in the
following five years5
.
United Nation University estimated that 41.8 million tons of electronic waste was generated in 2014
world wide, where only 6.5 million tons were collected by official collection companies or take back
system, which makes 35.3 million tonnes of electronic waste with ananymous fate. WEEE currently
is majorly dealt by the informal sector in the developing world. United Nation University's report
indicates that large quantites of WEEE shipped to west Africa and Asia are shipped from
industrialized countries6
.
It is widely unknown that WEEE not only contains hazardous substances but also includes highly
valuable materials such as gold, silver, copper, platinum, palladium, iron, aluminum, indium, gallium
and rare earth metals that may be recovered. The extraction of these metals from the Earth comes
along with a significant environmental impact. WEEE recycling thus contributes to sustainable
1
UNEP environment alert bulletin, http://www.grid.unep.ch/products/3_Reports/ew_ewaste.en.pdf
2
Greenpeace international, http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/campaigns/detox/electronics/the-
WEEE-problem/
3
International data corporation, global worldwide pc sales, http://www.statisticbrain.com/computer-sales-
statistics/
4
Gartner, IT research company, worldwide smartphone sales, retrieved April 2016
http://www.gartner.com/newsroom/id/3323017
5
Eurostat, environmental data center on waste, http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/waste/key-waste-
streams/weee
6
UNU our world portal, http://ourworld.unu.edu/en/toxic-WEEE-dumped-in-poor-nations-says-united-nations
Page 22 of 112
resource management and presents a viable economical opportunity which invite to develop WEEE
management system. For every 1 million cell phones that are recycled, 16000 kg of copper, 350 kg
of silver, 34 kg of gold, and 15 kg of palladium can be recovered7
.
1.2 Problem Identification
Egypt is among the top three African countries with the highest WEEE generation in absolute
quantities, amounting 0.37 million tons in 20148
. With no proper management of WEEE, this
signpost adverse environmental and health impact because of the constituents of this complex waste
stream which includes hazardous resources. As large quantities are generated per year, not enough
are collected/recycled by formal sector, leaving majority of WEEE treated or dumped, according to
the informal sector treatment.
The country faces challenges at the level of consumer awareness, but significantly more on the
collection, recycling processes, and the disposal of WEEE. A cooperative effort is required with all
stakeholders to foster developing integrated WEEE management system that would be beneficial to
all parties enforced by legal and institutional framework.
7
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. "Wastes - Resource Conservation - Common Wastes & Materials -
eCycling." Web Accessed April 11, 2015
8
Baldé, C.P., Wang, F., Kuehr, R., Huisman, J. (2015), The global WEEE monitor – 2014, United Nations University,
IAS – SCYCLE, Bonn, Germany.
WEEE in Egypt at Glance
EEE Put
in Market
[2012]
WEEE
Generated
[2014]
Kg/Inhabitant 7.7 4.3
Total Metric
kilotons
635 373
[Total inhabitants in 2012: 82.01 million]
Figure 1.WEEE in Egypt at glance
Page 23 of 112
1.3 Objective of the Assessment
The objective of the assessment is to provide evaluation on the current WEEE management and
practices in Egypt, develop baseline information to help in drawing structure for WEEE
management system, and to identify economic and social opportunities.
The assessment will include:
 Analysis of local context and stakeholders identification
 Describe WEEE practices in the country by formal and informal sector
 Describe and analyze national policies and regulatory framework on WEEE handling and
recycling
 Establish baseline for current and future WEEE inventory and mass flow
 Identify hot spots and develop road map for WEEE management in Egypt
 Social and economic evaluation
 Environmental and social impacts of current WEEE practices
 Identify the challenges Egypt face with WEEE recycling industry
 Recommendations based on this study
The scope of the assessment covers whole Egypt, with field visits and surveys focused on Greater
Cairo, Alexandria and Sharkia, which encompasses surveys to business enterprises and households.
Page 24 of 112
2 Methods
2.1 Data Acquisition
The consultant adopted multi-approach data collection, comprising of quantitative and qualitative
sources, followed by refining gathered data thorough reviewing process to collate reliable
information.
2.1.1 Literature and Statistical Analysis
Literature and documentary analysis prominently included but not limited to the following
Table 1. Data acquisition
Data input Source
Governmental Sources  Tracers9
Imports and
Exports Data Base
 Development indicators
(Population, education and
Economy)
 Households data
 ICT Indicators
 Quantitative data on selected
tracers
 Penetration rate on selected
tracers
 Tracers stock in
governmental bodies
 WEEE practices in
governmental entities
 Amount of disposed WEEE
from formal supplier
 Central Agency for Public
Mobilization and Statistics
(CAPMAS)
 Egyptian Ministry of
Communications and Information
Technology (MCIT)
 Information and Decision Support
Center (IDSC)
 General Authority of
Governmental Services (GAGS)
 National Telecom Regulatory
Authority (NTRA)
Regional and
International Data
Base
 EEE imports and exports
 Country profile
 International trade in goods
 Country solid waste profile
 WEEE developments –
country specific
 WEEE initiatives
 Economic opportunities
 UN Comtrade Database
 World Bank
 The Organization for Economic
Co-operation and Development
(OECD)
 the Regional Solid Waste Exchange
of Information and Expertise
Network (SWEEP-Net)
 Basel Convention Regional Center
(BCRC-Egypt)
 United Nations specialized agency
9
Tracers: Desktop PC, Laptop PC, CRT monitors, LCD monitors, mobiles and telephones
Page 25 of 112
Data input Source
for information and
communication technologies (ITU)
Literatures  WEEE classification
 WEEE recycling potentials
 Best practices
 WEEE development in the
country
 Country practices
 Stakeholders mapping
 ArabDev
 Environmental protection Agency
(EPA) – U.S.A
 United Nation University (UNU)
 step-initiative
 Centre for Environment and
Development for the Arab Region
and Europe (CEDARE)
2.1.2 Meetings and Interviews
A number of meetings and interviews took place with institutions representative, private sector
representative, distributers, NGOs, formal collectors, informal collectors and recyclers. The purpose
was to draw the current country practices with WEEE practices, collect quantitative and qualitative
information on WEEE, suggest recommendations as well as gather scoped information on the
selected tracers.
A list of stakeholders’ contacts who agreed to be onymous are found in annex 1
2.1.3 Surveys and Questionnaires
The household survey was conducted on a sample of 1806 respondents at households in the five
target governorates (Cairo, Giza, Qalyubia, Alexandria and Sharkeya). Private households were
considered the survey unit, hence each response to the questionnaire represents one family. The
total number of enterprises surveyed were 27 (9 companies in each of the target governorates.)
representing 19 SMEs and 8 large enterprises. Enterprises were selected according to their size to
represent different economic sectors. Total surveyed SMEs and large enterprises were 19 and 8
respectively.
Initially it was planned to conduct survey across governmental sectors but at later stage it did not
take place due to limitations in issuing the required permissions and time frame constraints. Instead,
a series of interviews with different governmental sector representatives took place for qualitative
assessment and indicative quantitation.
2.1.4 Field Studies
To obtain data with respect to the informal sector treatment with WEEE and on quantities of
collected WEEE and destinations, the Consultant adopted a number of interviews with WEEE
merchants, dismantlers, recyclers and landfill operator, this was supported by the transect and tracer
walk in a number of areas and 2nd
hand markets, details are covered in Section ‎5.4.
Page 26 of 112
2.2 Mass Flow Assessment
In general, WEEE inventory of a country is based on either stock data, sales data or both together.
In case of Egypt, the consultant calculated the WEEE mass flow based on stock methodology.
Selected method is attributed to the reliable information, which provides stock quantified data.
The WEEE mass flow equation is estimated according to the Approximation 1 Stock method
(Burea B&G, 1993) in WEEE Management Manual produced by United Nation Environment
Program. This method is also referred as “Consumption and Use” in some literatures. This method
is presented mathematically in the following equation:
WEEE generation [Tons/Year] =
𝑆𝑡𝑜𝑐𝑘 (𝐼)+𝑆𝑡𝑜𝑐𝑘 (𝐻.𝐻) [𝑇𝑜𝑛𝑒𝑠]
𝐴𝑣𝑒𝑟𝑎𝑔𝑒 𝐿𝑖𝑓𝑒 𝑇𝑖𝑚𝑒 [𝑌𝑒𝑎𝑟]
Where Stock (H.H) = H.H × 𝑊𝐴× 𝑃𝑟
Stock (I) = I.S × 𝑊𝐴× 𝑃𝑟
H.H: House Holds and Workplaces
I.S: Industry stock (private and public entities)
𝑊𝐴: Average Weight
Pr ∶ Penetration Rate
2.3 Limitations
During the process of collecting information to develop this study, a set of difficulties have been
encountered in order to conduct a thorough extensive assessment of the WEEE quantities due to
the following reasons.
- Limitation in information disclosure by suppliers and manufacturers thus difficulty in
assessing the tracers data
- Limitation on quantifying specific WEEE equipment/tracers due to lack of WEEE sorting
in storage and recycling process.
- Limitations in conducting survey with governomental sectors
- Many governomental sectors are running on paper-based information management system.
Furthemore, most of the information is based on fiscal values, which presents a challenge to
properly measure quantities.
The assessment is based on stock data method, which gives consistent results when reliable stock
data is avaialable. The main assumption associated with the stock method assessment is that the life
span of the tracer is presumed with no major deviation, which is a subjective and variable matter
with bearing in mind the new technological penetration in the market.
Page 27 of 112
The estimates are based on sources such as national data and coorelated with internationl data
therefore the results are reliable. The estimated WEEE generated between 2016 and 2021 is be
regarded as medium and the results of the survey on the population's practices are indicative.
Page 28 of 112
3 System Definition
3.1 Geographical Scope
The scope of the assessment covers whole Egypt, with field visits and surveys focused on Greater
Cairo, Alexandria and Sharkia, which encompasses surveys to business enterprises, households and
informal sector.
3.2 Product Scope
This assessment focuses on tracers that are considered the fasted growing waste streams and are
widely used among private and public sectors in the Egyptian population.
The selected tracers are composed of 3 categories10
as follows:
 Category 1 :Personal Computers comprising desktop computers and laptops,
 Category 2 : mobile phones
 Category 3: telephone sets.
According to directive 2012/19/EU11
on Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) the
selected tracers fall under category 3 (IT and telecommunication equipment). Additional attention
will be given on the recycling practices of electrical cables in the Egyptian market. The composition
of these categories of equipment in terms of weight and materials is provided in Annex 7.
3.2.1 Development of ICT Sector
The selected tracers fall under the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) appliance12
.
Egypt ICT sector has witnessed a substantial growth in the past 10 years. Egypt falls in the top 100
places in the United Nations index in 2015 from 167 countries for development in the
communication and information technology sector as well as citizens access to communication
technology. During 2008/2009 The ICT value added EGP 30.9 billion (US$ 5.6 billion), with an
annual growth rate of 14.5%. The ICT sector recorded the highest growth rate among economic
sectors in Egypt, proving that it can maintain its growth momentum even during times of crisis. The
private sector is playing a leading role contributing with about 69 % of the ICT's total value added to
the ones generated in 2008/2009. The ICT sector’s share in the total gross domestic product (GDP)
increased from EGP 48bn in 2010 to approximately EGP 66bn in 2014, recording a share of 4.1%.13
Egypt has successfully nurtured one of the most competitive and successful ICT economies in the
world. Already an ICT leader in the MENA region, Egypt is ranked 4th worldwide in A.T. Kearney’s
2011 Global Services Location Index, with the sector accounting for almost 4% of GDP, over US$
10 billion of total investment from some 5500 companies in 2013, and an annual growth rate of
10
As per project terms of reference
11
EU Directive on WEEE. “WEEE Categorization” archived on 6 January 2012.
12
Environmental Association for Universities and Colleges, ewaste_insight_guide_1%20(1).pdf
13
MCIT, http://www.egyptictindicators.gov.eg/
Page 29 of 112
around 13%. The Government has set a target of doubling the share of ICT in the national
economy to 8.5% by 2020, creating 250,000 new jobs in the process
As part of fostering the Egyptian economy market, the Egyptian Ministry of Communication and
Information Technology (MICT) has set a new ICT strategy to boost the nation investment in the
ICT sector to 44 billion EGP. The ministry plans is to invest in improving the infrastructure,
assuring 75% of Egyptian household internet access with 2Mbps by 2015, and increasing households
internet access to 90% at 25Mbps by 2021. MCIT also aspires to offer 3G service to 98% of users
by 2015, 4G service to 90% of the population by 2021.
3.3 Development Indicators
People
Table 2. Social development indicators
Indicator In millions Source
Total Population (2016) 90,984,725 CAPMAS
Urban Population (estimations on 1/1/2016
based on 2006 census projections)
42.7% CAPMAS
Rural Population (estimations on 1/1/2016 based
on 2006 census projections)
57.3% CAPMAS
Number of households (2006 census survey) 17,289,299 CAPMAS
Size of households in 2006 4.18 % CAPMAS
Number of urban households 7,844,852 CAPMAS
Number of rural households 9,444,447 CAPMAS
Unemployment in 2014 13.2 World Bank
Youth unemployment in 2014 female male World Bank
64.8 % 32.7 %
Population below international poverty line in
2010
2.25% World Bank
Environment
The Capacity 21 Unit at the Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency (EEAA) is responsible of the
development and fostering of the environmental indicators through a set of strategic action plans,
which is UNDP sponsored, called National Environmental Action Plan (NEAP) 2002-2017. It
represents Egypt’s agenda for environmental actions for the coming fifteen years. It complements
and integrates with other sectoral plans for economic growth and social development. As identified
by NEAP, Major environmental issues and concerns that challenge Egypt today covers the
degradation of land, air and water resources and the pressing need to preserve our cultural heritage
and natural biodiversity.
The following table demonstrate Egypt environmental indicators
Page 30 of 112
Table 3. Environmental Indicators (2012)
Electricity- International Energy Statistics
Scale Unit Quantity
Power consumption per capita KWh 1,700.45
Total Net Consumption Billion KWh 136.0
Total Net Generation Billion KWh 155.0
Total Installed Capacity Million KW 29.45
Total Renewable Energy Installed Million KW 3.63
GDP per unit of energy use $ per kg of oil equivalent 11.22
Emissions – World Bank Development Indicators
Scale Unit Quantity
GHG (CO2 equivalent) Kilotons 295,499.75
CO2 Emissions per Capita – 2011 Metric tons 2.64
Land Use - World Bank Development Indicators
Scale Unit Quantity
Land area Sq.km 995,450.0
Forest area Sq.km 712.0
Arable land area Hectare 2,829,000.0
Arable land area per person Hectare per person 0.03
Population - World Bank Development Indicators
Scale Unit Quantity
Population in Largest City Person 17,642,712.0
Population in Urban Agglomerations of
more than 1 million
Person 22,152,524.0
Rural Population Person 48,824,001.0
Urban Population Person 36,835,901.0
Egypt took set of actions to contribute in reducing the carbon dioxide print and greenhouse gases,
one of major developments is an overarching regulatory framework with the aim of securing 20% of
its energy generation from renewable sources by 2020 and is currently installing largest solar PV
power plant in the world with 1.8GW in Aswan.
Economy
Table 4. Economic development indicators
Indicators In millions/ Billion Source
Gross domestic product in
2014
$301.5 Billion –2.4 trillion Egyptian pounds
World Bank
GNI, PPP (current
international $)
(2011-2015)
920,696,746,178
GDP per capita in 2014 $3,210 - (30.49 thousand EGP CAPMAS)
GDP(ppp) per capita in
2014
10.280.0
GDP composition by sector Agriculture Industry Services
15% 36% 49%
Page 31 of 112
Indicators In millions/ Billion Source
Labor force by sector
In 2013
services agriculture industry
female male female male female male
52.1 46.9 42.9 24.1 5.0 29.0
States and Markets
Indicator In millions Source
Number of subscribers – Fixed lines (2015) 6.06 CAPMAS
Number of subscribers – Mobile phones (2015) 93.13 CAPMAS
Number of subscribers – Internet (2015) 27.25 CAPMAS
Internet users per 100 inhabitants (2015) 31.7 MCIT – ICT indicators
Number of mobile phone connections per 100
inhabitant (2015)
107.17 MCIT – ICT indicators
Fixed telephone lines per 100 inhabitant (2015) 7.23 MCIT – ICT indicators
ICT Contribution To GDP (%) at fixed prices (2015) 2.80 MCIT – ICT indicators
ICT Sector Revenues (thousands) (2015) 77.82
Micro, small and medium enterprises (2013) 2,407,911 CAPMAS
Page 32 of 112
4 Policy and Legislation
4.1 Environmental Law and Articles
Environmental protection is governed by Law No. 4 of 1994, and amended by Law 9/2009 with
decree No 1095/2011, 710/2012 and 964/2015 and its executive regulations.
Ambient Air Quality and Gaseous Emissions
Articles 35 and 34 of Law 4 of its Executive Regulations amended by Decree 1741/2005 provide the
maximum load of the ambient air and the permissible levels of air pollutants in emissions
Wastewater
Law 93/1962 regulates the disposal of wastewater, untreated substances, wastes or liquids which
may cause pollution along the Egyptian sea shores or adjoining waters either directly or indirectly,
intentionally or unintentionally (Article 69) and liquids in general, to the sewerage network. The
Executive Regulations (Decree 44/2000) in Article 14 details the physical/chemical standards that
should be complied with.
Solid Waste
Article 37 of Law 4/1994, articles 38 and 39 of its Executive Regulations, and Law 38 of 1967,
amended by Law number 31 of 1976, deal with the collection, transportation, and safe disposal of
solid wastes.
Hazardous and Dangerous Wastes
Articles 29 to 32 of Law 4/1994 provide regulations for the handling and storage of hazardous
materials, including hazardous waste. Article 33 of Law 4/1994 specifies that all precautions must be
taken when handling or storing hazardous material in any form (i.e.: gaseous, liquid, or solid).
Articles 35 to 36 address the responsibility of companies in ensuring safety of workers against
chemical risks.
Articles 26, 31, and Decree 211/2003 of Minister of Man-power & immigration, specify conditions
for the storage of flammable material, fuel, raw material, products and equipment.
4.2 Solid Waste Management Related Laws
Egypt has no stipulated solid waste management law however Law 38/1967 on General Public
Cleaning and their amendments are the main legislation enforcing the establishment of solid waste
management.
Page 33 of 112
4.2.1 Law number 38 of 1967, General Public Cleansing
Law 38/1967 on General Public Cleansing is the primary law governing the management of solid
waste in Egypt. It was enacted in 1967 and replaced all previous laws dealing with solid waste
including Law 97/1956 on Organization of Garbage Collection and Transfer, Law 159/1953 on
Cleansing Public Squares, Streets and Highways, and Law 151/1947 on Cleansing Fences and
Unused Areas. Since 1967, it has been amended four times. In 1968, the Minister of Housing (MoH)
issued the executive regulations for the law (MoH 134/1968).
4.2.2 Law Number 4 of 1994 and its amendments Law 9/2009, Environment Law
Law 4 /1994 on the Environment and its amendments in Law 9/2009 are the over-riding
environmental laws for Egypt. Article 3 of the Presidential Decree issuing Law 4/1994 repeals all
provisions of other laws running counter to the provisions of Law 4/1994. One article in Law
4/1994 addresses general solid waste management and another addresses the management of
construction and demolition debris. In addition, five articles address hazardous waste management.
4.2.3 Law Number 48 of 1982, Protection of the River Nile and its Canals
Law 48/1982 is the law for protection of the Nile and its canals. The executive regulations for Law
48/1982 were issued by Minister of Irrigation Decree Number 8 of 1983 (MoI 8/1983). The law and
its executive regulations and amendments in January 2013 by ministerial decision 92/2013 is
primarily focus on wastewater discharges to the Nile and its canals, but also contain articles that
include solid waste.
4.2.4 Laws Concerning Public Ways
Two laws concerning public ways, such as highways, streets, and squares, Law 140/1956,
Occupation of Public Ways and Law 84/1968, Concerning Public Ways, contain restrictions on
solid waste management and disposal.
4.3 Laws on WEEE Management
Egypt has listed WEEE is under the category of the hazardous waste list issued by the Ministry of
Industry (decision 165/2002), item 16. As WEEE is identified as hazardous waste by the
aforementioned decision articles addressing hazardous waste management in law 4/94 regulate it
Following table provides a summary the laws/regulations stated above and influence it has on
WEEE management process
4.4 Laws Influencing WEEE Recycling Industry
There is no law on WEEE in Egypt. Following are the laws that have impact on the WEEE industry
of the country
Page 34 of 112
4.4.1 Age of Imports
A decree restricting the imports of old EEE equipment with exception of some EEE goods
conditional it is not longer than 5 years from day of production.
Decree 603 of year 2007 of the Ministry of Trade and Industry amending parts of the Executive
Regulations of the Law of Import and Export and the operational procedures for inspection of
goods.
4.4.2 Second Hand Telecommunication Equipment Import
Law No.10 of 2003 provides in Article 46 prohibits the import of used telecommunication
equipment for purpose of trading
4.4.3 WEEE Import
Decree 165 of year 2002 of ministry of industry prohibits the importing of WEEE
4.4.4 The Egyptian Law of Auction
The Egyptian Law of Auction is Law 89 for 1998 about Tenders and Auctions. It is only enforced
over the public sector and the governmental sectors. This law does not apply to the private sector;
otherwise, it is only the company's policy to undergo an auction.
4.5 Social Laws
4.5.1 Law Number 137 of 1981, Labor Law
Law 137/1981 requires employers to inform employees of the dangers associated with handling
solid waste and requires employers to provide safety equipment and training to employees handling
solid waste. This law is enforced the Ministry of Manpower.
4.5.2 Child Labor
Egypt has ratified both ILO (International Labor organization) conventions No. 138 (minimum age
Convention) and ILO convention No. 182 (convention concerning the prohibition and immediate
action for the elimination of the worst forms of child labor).
4.5.3 Freedom of Association
Article 55 of Egypt’s 1971 constitution guarantees freedom of association and Article 56 of the
constitution guarantees the right to unionize, however in practice these rights are heavily restricted.
4.6 Institutional Framework of Solid Waste Management
Institutional framework in Egypt works over three phases. First phase is national scale policy and
planning where the Central Government is affiliated with this task. Second phase is implementation,
Page 35 of 112
where in case polices dealing with environment and waste, A steering committee Ministry of
Environment (MoE), Ministry of Local Development and Ministry of Finance are affiliated with
this task. Last phase which is the operation, either the governorates are responsible for all the
activities by itself and can contract private enterprise or the municipalities responsible for
implementation of the system, monitoring, inspection and trainings.
Page 36 of 112
4.7 Governmental Bodies Affiliated with WEEE Management
Table 5. Governmental bodies related to WEEE management
Entity Note
Ministry of Environment (MoE)
Egyptian Environmental Affairs
Agency (EEAA)
Waste Management Regulatory
Authority (WMRA)
Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency is the executive arm of the
Ministry of Environment
Ministry of Communication and
Information Technology
(MCIT)
The MCIT and MoE have signed Memorandum of Understanding
(MOU) in February 2010 to launch the Egyptian Green ICT Strategy.
MCIT and MoE have conducted several initiatives to introduce WEEE
management principles. The MCIT is keen to address the WEEE
management in the green ICT strategy
Ministry of Trade and Industry
(MTI)
Egyptian National Cleaner
Production Center (ENCPC)
The Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI) established the Egypt
National Cleaner Production Centre (ENCPC) in 2005 in close
cooperation with the United Nations Industrial Development
Organization (UNIDO) with the aim to promote green technologies,
revolutionize current national and local practices and transfer the
required knowledge for environmental friendly industries.
Ministry of Finance The auction of absolute EEE in public organizations is regulated and
supervised by the Ministry of Finance. Furthermore, The Egyptian
Customs Authority as part of Ministry of Finance inspect and monitors
the flow of electric and electronic equipment in and out of Egypt
National Telecom Regulatory
Authority (NTRA)
NTRA requires importers of telecommunication equipment to manage
safely telecommunication electronic14
waste in order to issue them
permit. This is intercepted through Waste Tracking Form, where
telecommunication equipment importers require submitting annually.
NTRA accepts the following ways of safely managing electronic waste:
Sending the waste to Nasreya hazardous landfill, delivering the
electronic waste to WEEE management firms (e.g. ITG) and selling of
telecommunication electronic waste in public auctions.
General Authority of
Government Services (GAGS)
The GAGS auctions the movable and immovable property of
administrative body and public authorities after being authorized by
those entities, in order to eliminate the problem of overstock and scrap
(this includes electronic waste). Also, the GAGS auctions goods and
commodities that are obsolete or confiscated by customs.
Hazardous Waste Management
Unit (HWMU) in Nasreya
recycling and disposal center
It was established as part of Finnish Egyptian cooperation for the
design and construction of hazardous waste treatment system where the
Governor of Alexandria issued a decree No.416 in 2000 to establish a
unit of hazardous management. The project constitute of two phases,
Phase I of the facility includes a secure landfill and solar evaporation
ponds to receive wastes, and Phase II includes mechanical and chemical
treatment, solidification, and interim storage.
14
Includes but not limited to: mobiles, telephones, radio telephones, telephone systems, IP cameras
Page 37 of 112
Table 6.Laws with influence on WEEE management
Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles
1. Egyptian National Regulations relevant to WEEE
Law of the Environment
No. 4/1994 and its
amendments by law
number 9/2009 and its
executive regulations
Law 4/1994 and its executive
regulations represent the main
regulation concerned with
environment issues in Egypt.
The law addresses managing of the
different types of waste including
solid waste, construction waste and
hazardous waste. The law does not
address or mention WEEE of any
type. The Law however addresses
wastes in a clear manner and
implicitly addresses WEEE among
other types of wastes described as
hazardous and dangerous
Law 4/1994 and its executive
regulations also contain provisions
requiring environmental impact
assessment of establishments,
control of air and noise emissions
from establishments, and worker
safety.
The law requires the ministers, each
in his field of competence, to issue in
coordination with the Minister of
Health and EEAA a table of the
hazardous substances and waste
referred in paragraph one of article
29
Provisions related to hazardous waste
 Under the law of the environment WEEE
is considered a form of hazardous waste.
 As well as determining the obligations of
producers of hazardous wastes.
 Stipulations of the law are related to the
conditions and requirements for the
management and treatment of hazardous
wastes in general which are applicable for
WEEE in this case.
Provisions related to import of hazardous waste
 Article 32 of law 4/1994 forbids to import
hazardous waste or to allow its
introduction into or its passage through
Egyptian territories. It is forbidden
without a permit from the competent
authority to allow the passage of ships
carrying hazardous waste in territorial seas
or in the exclusive maritime economic
zone of Egypt.
 Relevant international conventions signed
by Egypt are applicable in this concern. i.e.
Basel convention which controls the
transboundary movement of hazardous
wastes and their disposal. As mandated in
Article 4 not to allow the export of
hazardous wastes or other wastes to a State
or group of States belonging to an
economic and/or political integration
organization that are Parties, particularly
Local authorities
 They are empowered to enforce
Law 4/1994 and its executive
regulations that address solid waste
management.
EEAA
 EEAA is responsible for
approving sites for treatment,
burning and disposal of solid
waste
 EEAA is granting permission for
transportation of hazardous waste.
 Implementing the specifications
for solid waste containers and
collection vehicles.
Other Ministers
 Ministers (within their respective
scope), and in coordination with
the Minister of Health and the
Environmental Affairs Agency, are
responsible to issue a list of
hazardous materials.
Judicial officers
 Local government authorities are
granted the right to enforce Law
4/1994, by the Minister of Justice
decree number 1353 (MoJ
1353/1996) including governor’s
Page 38 of 112
Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles
developing countries, which have
prohibited by their legislation all imports,
or if it has reason to believe that the wastes
in question will not be managed in an
environmentally sound manner, according
to criteria to be decided on by the Parties
at their first meeting represents the legal
base for prohibition of importing
hazardous waste. In which, this can
represent the legal base to limit the
importing of some hazardous waste.
 Executive regulation number 338/1995,
amended by decrees 1095/2011 and
964/2015, stipulates that handling of
hazardous wastes requires prior permit
from EEAA. It also specifies the
documentation, procedures, and conditions
for obtaining the permit. As well as the
general requirements and procedures for
the collection, storage, transportation,
treatment, disposal of hazardous wastes
(articles 29 to 30 of the law and 25-33 of
the executive regulation).
Provisions related to requirements for waste
treatment facilities
 Provisions related to EIA (articles 12, 20,
21 and 23) for waste management facilities
are applicable to facilities that will be
working with WEEE such as recycling and
composting plants, medical waste
treatment facilities, and sanitary landfills.
Hence these regulations are also relevant.
Provisions related to waste treatment and
deputies, town mayors, district and
village heads, and the managers of
environment offices in the
governorates.
Article 103 of Law 4/1994 gives every
citizen and organization concerned with
the protection of the environment the right
to report violations of the law to
competent authorities.
Page 39 of 112
Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles
disposal
 Law 4/1994 and its executive regulations
prohibit disposing or treating garbage and
solid waste anywhere except in an area
designated by the local authorities.
 This law prohibits burning of solid waste
(article 37 of the law and 35 of the
executive regulations). Prohibition is
absolute for open burning, but allows
incineration, provided it meets the
specifications in the regulations.
Provision related to safe work environment and
protection of environment from pollutant
 Law 4/1994 article 34 to 47 requires
WEEE treatment facility to comply with
national permissible level of emissions.
Law number 38 of 1967,
General Public Cleansing
(amended by law 31/1976,
Law 209/1980, Law
177/1981, and Law
129/1982)
Law 38/1967 on General Public
Cleansing is the primary law
governing the management of solid
waste in Egypt. It was enacted in
1967 and replaced all previous laws
dealing with solid waste including
Law 97/1956 on Organization of
Garbage Collection and Transfer,
Law 159/1953 on Cleansing Public
Squares, Streets and Highways, and
Law 151/1947 on Cleansing Fences
and Unused Areas. Since 1967, it has
been amended four times. In 1968,
the Minister of Housing (MoH)
issued the executive regulations for
the law (MoH 134/1968).
 Law 38 of 1967 and its executive
regulations prohibit placing solid waste
anywhere except in an area designated by
the local council.
 This prohibition applies to treatment and
disposal of solid waste as well as to
temporary placement in an undesignated
container.
 Law 38/1967 authorizes the local council
to impose a fee on building inhabitants of
not more than two percent of their rent to
fund solid waste management. This fee,
along with all fines collected for violation
of Law 38/1967, must be placed in a
 The law and its regulations require
the local government authority
responsible for general cleansing
or a contractor licensed by the
local authority to collect, transfer,
and dispose of solid waste in
accordance with the specifications
in the executive regulations as well
as those of the local council.
 If a local authority contracts solid
waste services, the contractor is
responsible for the actions of the
garbage collectors it hires.
General Cleansing
Page 40 of 112
Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles
general cleansing fund established by the
local council. The fund must be used for
general cleansing. These funds can be
augmented by funds from the general
budget to insure adequate funding for solid
waste management.
 Law 38/1967 also requires owners of open
land to remove accumulated waste and
keep the land cleansed. The executive
regulations authorize the local authority to
remove solid waste from open land at the
owner’s expense, if the owner does not do
so within 15 days after notification.
 Article 1 in Presidential Decree
Number 272 of 1982 (PD
272/1982) transferred jurisdiction
for general cleansing from the
Ministry of Housing to local
administrative units.
Law Number 48 of 1982,
amended by ministerial
decree (92/2013)
concerning the Protection
of the River Nile and its
Canals
Law 48/1982 is the law for
protection of the Nile river, canals
and drains as well as ground water.
The executive regulations for Law
48/1982 were issued by Minister of
Irrigation Decree Number 8 of 1983
(MoI 8/1983). The law and its
executive regulations and
amendments in January 2013 by
ministerial decision 92/2013 is
primarily focus on wastewater
discharges to the Nile river, canals
and drains, but also contain articles
that prohibit disposal of solid waste
close to the banks.
Both Law 48/1982 and its executive regulations
prohibit the disposal of solid waste in the Nile,
canals and drains. The executive regulations extend
this prohibition to the temporary or permanent
placement of solid wastes on the banks of the Nile
and its canals. The executive regulations define
solid wastes as solid materials (including refuse,
garbage, sweeping materials, dry rubbish, fractured
stons, construction and demolition debris, and
workshop scraps) generated by individuals,
residential units, non-residential units
(governmental, commercial, industrial, tourist), and
means of transportation.
Article 19 of Law 48/1982 authorizes
Irrigation Engineers in the Ministry of
Irrigation to enforce the law within their
jurisdictions. Article 13 assigns the Water
Police of the Ministry of Interior with the
responsibility to assist the implementing
authorities in identifying violations of Law
48/1982, informing violators, and
removing the causes of violations.
Laws Concerning Public
Roads
Two laws concerning public ways,
such as highways, streets, and
squares, Law 140/1956, Occupation
of Public Ways and Law 84/1968,
Concerning Public Ways, contain
restrictions on solid waste
management and disposal.
Law 84/1968 prohibits placing solid wastes on
public ways. Law 140/1956 and its executive
regulations, issued by Minister of Municipal and
Rural Affairs (MoMRA) Decree number 395 of
1956 (MoMRA 395/1956), deal primarily with
granting licenses for occupation of public ways
within the borders of areas with local councils. One
Page 41 of 112
Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles
of the activities that require a license is placement
of construction and demolition debris in a public
way.
Law Number 12/2003
Labor Law
Law 137/1981 requires employers to
inform employees of the dangers
associated with handling solid waste
and requires employers to provide
safety equipment and training to
employees handling solid waste.
This law mandates all workers handling WEEE to
wear appropriate personal protective equipment
(PPE).
Law 12/2013 also prohibits child labor.
This law is enforced by the Ministry of
Manpower.
Ministerial Decree
770/2005 and Decree 603
of year 2007– Issued by
the Minister of Trade and
Industry
During 2005, the Minister of Trade
and Industry has issued a decree
prohibiting importing personal
computers that are older than 5 years
(instead of 10 years in the previous
decrees).
Decree 603 of year 2007 restricting
the imports of old EEE equipment
with exception of some EEE goods
conditional it is not longer than 5
years from day of production.
This Ministerial Decree 770/2005 of the import
regulations of the Customs Law allows importing
used Computer sets and assistant hardware
provided that their production date is not later than
five years, which results in importing computer sets
with lifetime almost at end.
Telecommunications law
number 10/2003
Law No.10 of 2003 provides in
Article 46 that it is “It is prohibited
to import used Telecommunication
Terminal Equipment for the purpose
of trading”
The definition of the telecommunication equipment
here is telecommunication equipment used by a
user to connect with a public or private
telecommunication network.
The Egyptian Law of
Auction (law 89/1998)
The Egyptian Law of Auction is Law
89 for 1998 about Tenders and
Auctions.
Governmental and public institutions are obligated
to do tenders and auctions in accordance to law
89/1998. As there is no particular environmental
sound management/requirement on auctions for
obsolete items/WEEE that participants require
adhering to, this subjects WEEE auctions
vulnerable to informal sector collection.
This law does not apply to the private sector;
otherwise, it is only the company's policy to
undergo an auction
Ministerial Decree No. In relation to the General Conditions Disposal of solid wastes in a safely manner.
Page 42 of 112
Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles
380/1975 issued by the
Ministry of Housing and
Development
of Industrial and Commercial
Establishments, and Other
Establishments Adversely Affects
Health and Dangerous.
Determining the location of the establishments the
activity of which adversely affects the safety of
housing areas.
Ministerial decree 165 of
year 2002 by the Ministry
of Industry and Trade
List of hazardous waste15 pertinent
to the Ministry of Industry and
Industrial Development that prohibit
importing of the hazardous waste
stipulated in the list to Egypt.
Egypt Green ICT strategy Reducing the adverse environmental
impacts related to the use of
Telecommunications and
Information Technologies
equipment
 The policy aims to mainstream green ICT
with all sectors to help wise management
of Egypt's resources and provide
innovative solutions to enhance the quality
of life of the Egyptians.
 The strategy calls for ensuring the
sustainable management of WEEE
2. International Regulations relevant to WEEE
Basel Convention on the
Control of Transboundary
Movements of Hazardous
Wastes and their Disposal
The Rotterdam
Convention on
multilateral agreement to
promote shared
responsibilities in relation
to the international trade
of certain hazardous
chemicals
Determination of the categories and
characteristics of hazardous wastes.
Stipulations on minimizing the
generation of hazardous wastes.
Stipulations on the environmentally
sound management of hazardous
wastes. Prohibition of exporting
hazardous wastes to contracting
parties in specific cases. Prohibition
of importation of hazardous wastes
in specific cases. Regulations and
obligations relating to the
transportation and transboundary
movement of hazardous wastes.
The Nairobi Declaration on the
Environmentally Sound Management of
Electrical and Electronic Waste and
decision IX/6 adopted by the ninth
meeting of the Conference of the Parties
gave a mandate to the Secretariat to
implement a work plan for the
environmentally sound management of
WEEE.
Stockholm Convention on
Persistent Organic
Key elements of the Convention
include the requirement that
15
http://www.nasreya.com/List1Ar.html
Page 43 of 112
Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles
Pollutants (POPs) is an
international
environmental treaty that
aims to eliminate or
restrict the production and
use of persistent organic
pollutants (POPs).
developed countries provide new and
additional financial resources and
measures to eliminate production
and use of intentionally produced
POPs, eliminate unintentionally
produced POPs where feasible, and
manage and dispose of POPs wastes
in an environmentally sound manner.
Precaution is exercised throughout
the Stockholm Convention, with
specific references in the preamble,
the objective, and the provision on
identifying new POPs. Egypt has
ratified the convention on
02/05/2003
Bamako Convention on
the Ban of the Import into
Africa and the Control of
Transboundary Movement
and Management of
Hazardous Wastes within
Africa
Prohibition of importation of
hazardous wastes. Prohibition of
dumping hazardous wastes at sea and
internal waters. Determination of
the hazardous wastes categories and
characteristics. Stipulations on
environmentally sound management
of hazardous wastes. Stipulations on
minimizing the generation of
hazardous wastes. Regulations and
obligations relating to the
transportation and transboundary
movement of hazardous wastes.
International Labor
Organization (ILO)
convention No. 138 and
convention No.182
Egypt has ratified ILO convention
No.138 and No.182, which mandates
minimum age for working and
prohibits and immediate action for
elimination of the worst forms of
child labor respectively.
2004 - Ratification of the Identification of used products/articles
allowed for import.
Page 44 of 112
Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles
Ban Amendment.
2004 - Ratification of
Bamako Convention.
2006 - Ratification of
hazardous waste protocol
of Barcelona Convention.
Development of trade
policies and regulations.
Egypt commitments at
CTE/WTO
Egypt-EU Partnership
Agreement/ Egypt-EU
Free Trade Agreement.
Continuous determination of industry
needs (secondary raw materials e.g. used
plastics, paper, glass…)
Limitation of imports of used e-products.
Specific measure to protect local
manufacture of EEE. (quality control,
efficiency, incentives..…)
Page 45 of 112
5 Stakeholder Assessment
Overview
There is no formal legislation to manage and enforce WEEE management in Egypt. Electronic
waste is majorly dealt by informal sector, after extracting the recyclable streams it is generally either
burned or thrown into landfills/dump sites in slums such as Manshiet Nasser, mokattam or Dewei’a.
Over time, harmful emissions start to affect the people who are living near those landfills. In the
absence of serious national programs for WEEE management, along with decreasing cost of buying
new technologies especially mobile phones and personal computers and the surge in perceptive
obsolescence due to better technologies introduced in market, it is anticipated that more WEEE will
be disposed in such dumpsites/landfills and unknown fate.
The life cycle chain of the EEE/WEEE will assist in identifying the stakeholders connecting
different phases of the life cycle of the electrical and electronic equipment. The following chain
reflects the life cycle of the electric and electronic equipment in Egypt. It is a five-step value chain
covering the following:
1. EEE production/import: Electrical and electronic equipment imported into the country or
manufactured within the country.
2. EEE sales: Electrical and Electronic equipment in the market, ready for sales to end user.
3. EEE consumption: Consumption by households, private and public entities.
4. WEEE generation: The end of useful use of EEE and disposing to collectors/merchants.
5. Re-use / down cycle: Disposed EEE, which can be fixed or refurbished for second hand
consumer
6. WEEE treatment/ Re-cycle: Applied process to EEE (e.g. dismantling) to extract useful
fractions.
7. Secondary raw material: Specific fractions, which are reused as a feedstock for other industries
(e.g. copper, plastics, iron and etc..)
8. Secondary raw material: Fractions such as electric boards, which are exported to other countries
e.g. Belgium
Figure 2. Life cycle chain of EEE/WEEE
Page 46 of 112
5.1 Manufacturers and Imports
Personal Computers and Computer Monitors
The International Telecommunication Union (ITU) country's ICT profile for 2013 indicates that
45.1 % of Egyptian households have computers and the official statistics show household PC
penetration reached 51.8% in Egypt at the end of 2013. 36.8 % of individuals are using a computer
in 201416
. In this study, it is assumed that the computer's monitors in use are directly proportional to
the desktop computer penetration rate in the country. According to BMI market research Company
in 2012, personal computer's (PC) penetration is expected to grow 20% by 2015 with annual
personal computer sales that can reach 500,000 pieces. This goes in line with Egypt’s IT sustained
initiatives to leverage personal computer's penetration, one of such major initiatives is the
“Computer for Every Student” and “PC for Every Home”. Households represents 20-25% of the
computer annual sales17
There is not thorough quantification of CRT and LCD computer monitors installed in household,
but CRT production was seized in 2009/2010 in many parts of the world due to the environmental
hazardous it imposes and the surge of LCD monitor technology. The last CRT factory in Europe
was closed on the 28th
of September 201218
and it is assumed that that CRT monitors were no
longer put in the market since 2009.
The following graph illustrates the number of computer monitors imported to Egypt by the Central
Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics
16
Egypt Information Technology Report Q1 2016, BMI Research Firm
17
Egypt Information Technology Report Q4 2011, BMI Research Firm
18
http://www.crtsite.com/page3-2.html, retrieved August 15, 2016
Figure 3.Computer Screen units Import. Display unit (x1000). Source: CAPMAS
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
ComputermonitorunitsImport(x1000)
Year
Year
Computer monitor
units import
2006 131007
2007 287251
2008 297973
2009 405005
2010 422588
2011 444689
2012 1090339
2013 914530
2014 400500
2015 290137
Imports of year 2015 is not final
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt
Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt

More Related Content

Similar to Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt

African Development Bank Strategic Impact Assessment Guidelines Final Report
African Development Bank Strategic Impact Assessment Guidelines Final ReportAfrican Development Bank Strategic Impact Assessment Guidelines Final Report
African Development Bank Strategic Impact Assessment Guidelines Final Reportzubeditufail
 
Role of IT & Computer in Environment
Role of IT & Computer in EnvironmentRole of IT & Computer in Environment
Role of IT & Computer in EnvironmentNeil Mathew
 
DRR_Hoa_Cac_Final_Report_EN.PDF
DRR_Hoa_Cac_Final_Report_EN.PDFDRR_Hoa_Cac_Final_Report_EN.PDF
DRR_Hoa_Cac_Final_Report_EN.PDFTorsten Kowal
 
Report on UNDP LDCF GEF ToT training held on 1 - 10 January 2015 Nairobi Kenya
Report on UNDP LDCF GEF ToT  training held on 1 - 10 January 2015 Nairobi KenyaReport on UNDP LDCF GEF ToT  training held on 1 - 10 January 2015 Nairobi Kenya
Report on UNDP LDCF GEF ToT training held on 1 - 10 January 2015 Nairobi KenyaAlmaz Demessie
 
Al Azhar - International Seminar on Science, Technology and Innovations
Al Azhar - International Seminar on Science, Technology and InnovationsAl Azhar - International Seminar on Science, Technology and Innovations
Al Azhar - International Seminar on Science, Technology and Innovationspariatmono
 
Extended producer-responsibility
Extended producer-responsibilityExtended producer-responsibility
Extended producer-responsibilityMEWM Egypt
 
impact assesment .pptx
impact assesment .pptximpact assesment .pptx
impact assesment .pptxSaikumar281375
 
Eiar physical report
Eiar physical reportEiar physical report
Eiar physical reportcenafrica
 
World Energy Outlook Special Report 2016 - Energy and Air Pollution
World Energy Outlook Special Report 2016 - Energy and Air PollutionWorld Energy Outlook Special Report 2016 - Energy and Air Pollution
World Energy Outlook Special Report 2016 - Energy and Air PollutionOmstar Africa
 
Success stories and drivers of cdm project development in sub saharan africa
Success stories and drivers of cdm project development in sub saharan africaSuccess stories and drivers of cdm project development in sub saharan africa
Success stories and drivers of cdm project development in sub saharan africaDr Lendy Spires
 
Green jobs documento unep e oil
Green jobs   documento unep e oilGreen jobs   documento unep e oil
Green jobs documento unep e oilideaTRE60
 
Pollution Monitoring System using Arduino and various gas sensor
Pollution Monitoring System using Arduino and various gas sensorPollution Monitoring System using Arduino and various gas sensor
Pollution Monitoring System using Arduino and various gas sensorUtkarsh Jaiswal
 
Auditing implementation of_me_as
Auditing implementation of_me_asAuditing implementation of_me_as
Auditing implementation of_me_asDr Lendy Spires
 
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF PPE KIT USING OPEN -LCA SOFTWARE
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF PPE KIT USING OPEN -LCA SOFTWARELIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF PPE KIT USING OPEN -LCA SOFTWARE
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF PPE KIT USING OPEN -LCA SOFTWAREIRJET Journal
 
Green ICT-Calculation of carbon footprint of an academic facility
Green ICT-Calculation of carbon footprint of an academic facilityGreen ICT-Calculation of carbon footprint of an academic facility
Green ICT-Calculation of carbon footprint of an academic facilityKriti Doneria
 
Environmental Impact assessment
Environmental Impact assessmentEnvironmental Impact assessment
Environmental Impact assessmentDavis Ciprikis
 
Environmental impact assessment 2020
Environmental impact assessment 2020Environmental impact assessment 2020
Environmental impact assessment 2020Chandrakant Singh
 
I-CCAN Workshop Highlights
I-CCAN Workshop HighlightsI-CCAN Workshop Highlights
I-CCAN Workshop HighlightsSanasaleem2
 
What are there behind the eco-labels?
What are there behind the eco-labels?What are there behind the eco-labels?
What are there behind the eco-labels?Frank Gergaud
 
Natural Capital at Risk: The Top 100 Externalities of Business
Natural Capital at Risk: The Top 100 Externalities of BusinessNatural Capital at Risk: The Top 100 Externalities of Business
Natural Capital at Risk: The Top 100 Externalities of BusinessSustainable Brands
 

Similar to Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt (20)

African Development Bank Strategic Impact Assessment Guidelines Final Report
African Development Bank Strategic Impact Assessment Guidelines Final ReportAfrican Development Bank Strategic Impact Assessment Guidelines Final Report
African Development Bank Strategic Impact Assessment Guidelines Final Report
 
Role of IT & Computer in Environment
Role of IT & Computer in EnvironmentRole of IT & Computer in Environment
Role of IT & Computer in Environment
 
DRR_Hoa_Cac_Final_Report_EN.PDF
DRR_Hoa_Cac_Final_Report_EN.PDFDRR_Hoa_Cac_Final_Report_EN.PDF
DRR_Hoa_Cac_Final_Report_EN.PDF
 
Report on UNDP LDCF GEF ToT training held on 1 - 10 January 2015 Nairobi Kenya
Report on UNDP LDCF GEF ToT  training held on 1 - 10 January 2015 Nairobi KenyaReport on UNDP LDCF GEF ToT  training held on 1 - 10 January 2015 Nairobi Kenya
Report on UNDP LDCF GEF ToT training held on 1 - 10 January 2015 Nairobi Kenya
 
Al Azhar - International Seminar on Science, Technology and Innovations
Al Azhar - International Seminar on Science, Technology and InnovationsAl Azhar - International Seminar on Science, Technology and Innovations
Al Azhar - International Seminar on Science, Technology and Innovations
 
Extended producer-responsibility
Extended producer-responsibilityExtended producer-responsibility
Extended producer-responsibility
 
impact assesment .pptx
impact assesment .pptximpact assesment .pptx
impact assesment .pptx
 
Eiar physical report
Eiar physical reportEiar physical report
Eiar physical report
 
World Energy Outlook Special Report 2016 - Energy and Air Pollution
World Energy Outlook Special Report 2016 - Energy and Air PollutionWorld Energy Outlook Special Report 2016 - Energy and Air Pollution
World Energy Outlook Special Report 2016 - Energy and Air Pollution
 
Success stories and drivers of cdm project development in sub saharan africa
Success stories and drivers of cdm project development in sub saharan africaSuccess stories and drivers of cdm project development in sub saharan africa
Success stories and drivers of cdm project development in sub saharan africa
 
Green jobs documento unep e oil
Green jobs   documento unep e oilGreen jobs   documento unep e oil
Green jobs documento unep e oil
 
Pollution Monitoring System using Arduino and various gas sensor
Pollution Monitoring System using Arduino and various gas sensorPollution Monitoring System using Arduino and various gas sensor
Pollution Monitoring System using Arduino and various gas sensor
 
Auditing implementation of_me_as
Auditing implementation of_me_asAuditing implementation of_me_as
Auditing implementation of_me_as
 
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF PPE KIT USING OPEN -LCA SOFTWARE
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF PPE KIT USING OPEN -LCA SOFTWARELIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF PPE KIT USING OPEN -LCA SOFTWARE
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF PPE KIT USING OPEN -LCA SOFTWARE
 
Green ICT-Calculation of carbon footprint of an academic facility
Green ICT-Calculation of carbon footprint of an academic facilityGreen ICT-Calculation of carbon footprint of an academic facility
Green ICT-Calculation of carbon footprint of an academic facility
 
Environmental Impact assessment
Environmental Impact assessmentEnvironmental Impact assessment
Environmental Impact assessment
 
Environmental impact assessment 2020
Environmental impact assessment 2020Environmental impact assessment 2020
Environmental impact assessment 2020
 
I-CCAN Workshop Highlights
I-CCAN Workshop HighlightsI-CCAN Workshop Highlights
I-CCAN Workshop Highlights
 
What are there behind the eco-labels?
What are there behind the eco-labels?What are there behind the eco-labels?
What are there behind the eco-labels?
 
Natural Capital at Risk: The Top 100 Externalities of Business
Natural Capital at Risk: The Top 100 Externalities of BusinessNatural Capital at Risk: The Top 100 Externalities of Business
Natural Capital at Risk: The Top 100 Externalities of Business
 

More from MEWM Egypt

E-waste management
E-waste management E-waste management
E-waste management MEWM Egypt
 
EEW under Basel convention
EEW under Basel conventionEEW under Basel convention
EEW under Basel conventionMEWM Egypt
 
E waste, health & enviroment-may2019
E waste, health & enviroment-may2019E waste, health & enviroment-may2019
E waste, health & enviroment-may2019MEWM Egypt
 
Guide Book “Hazardous chemicals and waste with special focus on Electronic w...
Guide Book  “Hazardous chemicals and waste with special focus on Electronic w...Guide Book  “Hazardous chemicals and waste with special focus on Electronic w...
Guide Book “Hazardous chemicals and waste with special focus on Electronic w...MEWM Egypt
 
Weee dismantling-business-opportunities-formal-sector
Weee dismantling-business-opportunities-formal-sectorWeee dismantling-business-opportunities-formal-sector
Weee dismantling-business-opportunities-formal-sectorMEWM Egypt
 
Mapping of-informal-sector
Mapping of-informal-sectorMapping of-informal-sector
Mapping of-informal-sectorMEWM Egypt
 
Legislations report
Legislations reportLegislations report
Legislations reportMEWM Egypt
 
Entrepreneurship support-intervention-programme
Entrepreneurship support-intervention-programmeEntrepreneurship support-intervention-programme
Entrepreneurship support-intervention-programmeMEWM Egypt
 
تقييم ممارسات إدارة مخلفات المعدات الكهربائية والإلكترونية في جمهورية مصر ال...
تقييم ممارسات إدارة مخلفات المعدات الكهربائية والإلكترونية  في جمهورية مصر ال...تقييم ممارسات إدارة مخلفات المعدات الكهربائية والإلكترونية  في جمهورية مصر ال...
تقييم ممارسات إدارة مخلفات المعدات الكهربائية والإلكترونية في جمهورية مصر ال...MEWM Egypt
 
Medical and E-waste management project
Medical and E-waste management projectMedical and E-waste management project
Medical and E-waste management projectMEWM Egypt
 
Training manual final arabic version
Training manual  final arabic versionTraining manual  final arabic version
Training manual final arabic versionMEWM Egypt
 

More from MEWM Egypt (11)

E-waste management
E-waste management E-waste management
E-waste management
 
EEW under Basel convention
EEW under Basel conventionEEW under Basel convention
EEW under Basel convention
 
E waste, health & enviroment-may2019
E waste, health & enviroment-may2019E waste, health & enviroment-may2019
E waste, health & enviroment-may2019
 
Guide Book “Hazardous chemicals and waste with special focus on Electronic w...
Guide Book  “Hazardous chemicals and waste with special focus on Electronic w...Guide Book  “Hazardous chemicals and waste with special focus on Electronic w...
Guide Book “Hazardous chemicals and waste with special focus on Electronic w...
 
Weee dismantling-business-opportunities-formal-sector
Weee dismantling-business-opportunities-formal-sectorWeee dismantling-business-opportunities-formal-sector
Weee dismantling-business-opportunities-formal-sector
 
Mapping of-informal-sector
Mapping of-informal-sectorMapping of-informal-sector
Mapping of-informal-sector
 
Legislations report
Legislations reportLegislations report
Legislations report
 
Entrepreneurship support-intervention-programme
Entrepreneurship support-intervention-programmeEntrepreneurship support-intervention-programme
Entrepreneurship support-intervention-programme
 
تقييم ممارسات إدارة مخلفات المعدات الكهربائية والإلكترونية في جمهورية مصر ال...
تقييم ممارسات إدارة مخلفات المعدات الكهربائية والإلكترونية  في جمهورية مصر ال...تقييم ممارسات إدارة مخلفات المعدات الكهربائية والإلكترونية  في جمهورية مصر ال...
تقييم ممارسات إدارة مخلفات المعدات الكهربائية والإلكترونية في جمهورية مصر ال...
 
Medical and E-waste management project
Medical and E-waste management projectMedical and E-waste management project
Medical and E-waste management project
 
Training manual final arabic version
Training manual  final arabic versionTraining manual  final arabic version
Training manual final arabic version
 

Recently uploaded

VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Gorakhpur
VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service GorakhpurVIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Gorakhpur
VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service GorakhpurSuhani Kapoor
 
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...Delhi Escorts
 
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BH
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BHFreegle User Survey as visual display - BH
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BHbill846304
 
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...ranjana rawat
 
(RIYA) Kalyani Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(RIYA) Kalyani Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(RIYA) Kalyani Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(RIYA) Kalyani Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...ranjana rawat
 
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012sapnasaifi408
 
Dwarka Call Girls 9643097474 Phone Number 24x7 Best Services
Dwarka Call Girls 9643097474 Phone Number 24x7 Best ServicesDwarka Call Girls 9643097474 Phone Number 24x7 Best Services
Dwarka Call Girls 9643097474 Phone Number 24x7 Best Servicesnajka9823
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一z xss
 
Soil pollution causes effects remedial measures
Soil pollution causes effects remedial measuresSoil pollution causes effects remedial measures
Soil pollution causes effects remedial measuresvasubhanot1234
 
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170simranguptaxx69
 
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikRussian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashikranjana rawat
 
Species composition, diversity and community structure of mangroves in Barang...
Species composition, diversity and community structure of mangroves in Barang...Species composition, diversity and community structure of mangroves in Barang...
Species composition, diversity and community structure of mangroves in Barang...Open Access Research Paper
 
Mumbai Call Girls, 💞 Prity 9892124323, Navi Mumbai Call girls
Mumbai Call Girls, 💞  Prity 9892124323, Navi Mumbai Call girlsMumbai Call Girls, 💞  Prity 9892124323, Navi Mumbai Call girls
Mumbai Call Girls, 💞 Prity 9892124323, Navi Mumbai Call girlsPooja Nehwal
 
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130Suhani Kapoor
 
Joint GBIF Biodiversa+ symposium in Helsinki on 2024-04-16
Joint GBIF Biodiversa+ symposium in  Helsinki on 2024-04-16Joint GBIF Biodiversa+ symposium in  Helsinki on 2024-04-16
Joint GBIF Biodiversa+ symposium in Helsinki on 2024-04-16Dag Endresen
 
webinaire-green-mirror-episode-2-Smart contracts and virtual purchase agreeme...
webinaire-green-mirror-episode-2-Smart contracts and virtual purchase agreeme...webinaire-green-mirror-episode-2-Smart contracts and virtual purchase agreeme...
webinaire-green-mirror-episode-2-Smart contracts and virtual purchase agreeme...Cluster TWEED
 
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Educationz xss
 

Recently uploaded (20)

VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Gorakhpur
VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service GorakhpurVIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Gorakhpur
VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Gorakhpur
 
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
 
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BH
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BHFreegle User Survey as visual display - BH
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BH
 
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
 
(RIYA) Kalyani Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(RIYA) Kalyani Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(RIYA) Kalyani Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(RIYA) Kalyani Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
 
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012
 
Call Girls In Dhaula Kuan꧁❤ 🔝 9953056974🔝❤꧂ Escort ServiCe
Call Girls In Dhaula Kuan꧁❤ 🔝 9953056974🔝❤꧂ Escort ServiCeCall Girls In Dhaula Kuan꧁❤ 🔝 9953056974🔝❤꧂ Escort ServiCe
Call Girls In Dhaula Kuan꧁❤ 🔝 9953056974🔝❤꧂ Escort ServiCe
 
Dwarka Call Girls 9643097474 Phone Number 24x7 Best Services
Dwarka Call Girls 9643097474 Phone Number 24x7 Best ServicesDwarka Call Girls 9643097474 Phone Number 24x7 Best Services
Dwarka Call Girls 9643097474 Phone Number 24x7 Best Services
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
 
Soil pollution causes effects remedial measures
Soil pollution causes effects remedial measuresSoil pollution causes effects remedial measures
Soil pollution causes effects remedial measures
 
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170
 
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikRussian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
 
Species composition, diversity and community structure of mangroves in Barang...
Species composition, diversity and community structure of mangroves in Barang...Species composition, diversity and community structure of mangroves in Barang...
Species composition, diversity and community structure of mangroves in Barang...
 
Mumbai Call Girls, 💞 Prity 9892124323, Navi Mumbai Call girls
Mumbai Call Girls, 💞  Prity 9892124323, Navi Mumbai Call girlsMumbai Call Girls, 💞  Prity 9892124323, Navi Mumbai Call girls
Mumbai Call Girls, 💞 Prity 9892124323, Navi Mumbai Call girls
 
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
 
Joint GBIF Biodiversa+ symposium in Helsinki on 2024-04-16
Joint GBIF Biodiversa+ symposium in  Helsinki on 2024-04-16Joint GBIF Biodiversa+ symposium in  Helsinki on 2024-04-16
Joint GBIF Biodiversa+ symposium in Helsinki on 2024-04-16
 
webinaire-green-mirror-episode-2-Smart contracts and virtual purchase agreeme...
webinaire-green-mirror-episode-2-Smart contracts and virtual purchase agreeme...webinaire-green-mirror-episode-2-Smart contracts and virtual purchase agreeme...
webinaire-green-mirror-episode-2-Smart contracts and virtual purchase agreeme...
 
Escort Service Call Girls In Shakti Nagar, 99530°56974 Delhi NCR
Escort Service Call Girls In Shakti Nagar, 99530°56974 Delhi NCREscort Service Call Girls In Shakti Nagar, 99530°56974 Delhi NCR
Escort Service Call Girls In Shakti Nagar, 99530°56974 Delhi NCR
 
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education
885MTAMount DMU University Bachelor's Diploma in Education
 

Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt

  • 1. Assessment of WEEE Management in Egypt Submitted by: EcoConServ Environmental Solutions January 2017 Submitted to: United Nation Development program (UNDP) For The project “Protect human health and the environment from unintentional releases of POPs originating from incineration and open burning of health care and electronic waste” Of Global Environmental Facility (GEF)
  • 2. This study is part of the inception phase of “Protect human health and the environment from unintentional releases of POPs originating from incineration and open burning of health care and electronic waste” project being implemented by the Ministry of Environment in collaboration with the Ministry of Health and Population (MoHP) and the Ministry of Communications and Information Technology (MCIT) with the technical support of United Nation Development Program as mandated by the Global Environmental Facility (GEF). This report prepared by EcoConServ environmental solutions (local consultancy firm).
  • 3.
  • 4. Presented to: United Nation Development Program Att: Dr.Mohamed Bayoumi UNDP Assistant Resident Submitted by: EcoConServ Environmental Solutions 12 El-Saleh Ayoub St., Zamalek, Cairo, Egypt 11211 Tel: +2 02 2735 9078 – +2 02 2736 4818 Fax: + 2 02 2736 5397 E-mail: genena@ecoconserv.com URL: http/www.ecoconserv.com Assessment of WEEE Management In Egypt Final Report January 2017
  • 5. Acknowledgement of Contributors and Peer Reviewers The authors would like to thank the interviewed stakeholders for their contribution with this study. Special thanks go to Dr.Tarek M.Araby and Ms.Hoda Shakra for their contribution, relentless effort in data acquisition, coordination and interface with governmental entities that allowed the completion of this study. We greatly appreciate and thank the following individuals for serving as peer reviewers of the content of this study and qualifying it. Eng. Ghada Abdel Elmoneim Manager of Hazardous Waste and Substances- Waste Management Regulatory Agency(WMRA), Ministry of Environment Eng. Essam Abd Elaziz Manger of Hazardous Substances, Waste Management Regulatory Agency(WMRA), Ministry of Environment Eng. Ghada Abdelmonem General Manager of Hazardous Substances and Waste Department, Waste Management Regulatory Agency (WMRA), Ministry of Environment Eng. Yasser Abd El-Bary Program Manager of Electronics Industry, Information Technology Industry Development Agency (ITIDA) Eng. Mona Darwish Project Manager, Information Infrastructure Sector-Ministry of Communication and Information Technology(MCIT) Eng. Ahmed Hammam Unit Manager, Telecommunications Projects Planning Department, Ministry of Communication and Information Technology(MCIT) Eng. Hoda Shakra Technical officer, GEF-UNDP Project on Protect Human Health and the Environment from Unintentional Releases of POPs Originating from Incineration and Open Burning of Health Care and Electronic Waste Ms. Anahide Bondolfi Senior Consultant , Sofies group
  • 6. Issue and Revision Record Information Class: Secure EcoConServ Environmental Solutions herein by referred to as the Consultant has prepared this report with all care and diligence, and taking account of the Services and the Terms agreed solely between EcoConServ Environmental Solutions and the Client, which commissioned it. No representation, warranty or undertaking, is made and no responsibility or liability is accepted by the consultant to any party other than the Client or any Recipient(s), as to the accuracy or completeness of the report content. This report does not include any legal, insurance or financial advice or opinion. The consultant accepts no responsibility for data, information or statements supplied to us by other parties including the client (‘Data’). EcoConServ has not verified such Data and has assumed it accurate, complete, and reliable. Forecasts presented in this document were prepared using Data and the report is dependent /based on Data. Inevitably, some of the assumptions used to develop the forecasts will not be realized and unanticipated events and circumstances may occur. Consequently, EcoConServ does not guarantee or warrant the conclusions contained in the report, as there are likely to be differences between the forecasts and the actual results and those differences may be material. While we consider the information and opinions given in this report are sound, all parties must rely on their own skill and judgement when making use of it. Version Control Log Revision Date Made by Checked by Description 1 21/06/2016 As above Emad Raouf Draft Report 2 08/09/2016 As above Emad Raouf II Draft Report 3 15/12/2016 As above Emad Raouf Final Report 4 22/01/2017 As above Emad Raouf Final Report [Updated] 5 30/01/2017 As above Emad Raouf Final Report [Updated I]
  • 7. Table of Content TABLE OF CONTENT ...................................................................................................................................... 3 LIST OF FIGURES.............................................................................................................................................. 6 LIST OF TABLES................................................................................................................................................ 6 LIST OF ACRONYMS AND DEFINITIONS.................................................................................................... 8 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ..................................................................................................................................10 1 INTRODUCTION .....................................................................................................................................21 1.1 OVERVIEW ..........................................................................................................................................................................21 1.2 PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION .............................................................................................................................................22 1.3 OBJECTIVE OF THE ASSESSMENT....................................................................................................................................23 2 METHODS................................................................................................................................................ 24 2.1 DATA ACQUISITION ..........................................................................................................................................................24 2.1.1 Literature and Statistical Analysis...............................................................................................................................24 2.1.2 Meetings and Interviews..............................................................................................................................................25 2.1.3 Surveys and Questionnaires........................................................................................................................................25 2.1.4 Field Studies...................................................................................................................................................................25 2.2 MASS FLOW ASSESSMENT.................................................................................................................................................26 2.3 LIMITATIONS.......................................................................................................................................................................26 3 SYSTEM DEFINITION ........................................................................................................................... 28 3.1 GEOGRAPHICAL SCOPE ....................................................................................................................................................28 3.2 PRODUCT SCOPE................................................................................................................................................................28 3.2.1 Development of ICT Sector.......................................................................................................................................28 3.3 DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ..........................................................................................................................................29 4 POLICY AND LEGISLATION................................................................................................................. 32 4.1 ENVIRONMENTAL LAW AND ARTICLES.........................................................................................................................32 4.2 SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT RELATED LAWS ...........................................................................................................32 4.2.1 Law number 38 of 1967, General Public Cleansing ...............................................................................................33 4.2.2 Law Number 4 of 1994 and its amendments Law 9/2009, Environment Law ................................................33 4.2.3 Law Number 48 of 1982, Protection of the River Nile and its Canals...............................................................33 4.2.4 Laws Concerning Public Ways ...................................................................................................................................33 4.3 LAWS ON WEEE MANAGEMENT ...................................................................................................................................33 4.4 LAWS INFLUENCING WEEE RECYCLING INDUSTRY .................................................................................................33 4.4.1 Age of Imports..............................................................................................................................................................34 4.4.2 Second Hand Telecommunication Equipment Import .........................................................................................34 4.4.3 WEEE Import...............................................................................................................................................................34 4.4.4 The Egyptian Law of Auction....................................................................................................................................34 4.5 SOCIAL LAWS ......................................................................................................................................................................34 4.5.1 Law Number 137 of 1981, Labor Law .....................................................................................................................34 4.5.2 Child Labor....................................................................................................................................................................34 4.5.3 Freedom of Association ..............................................................................................................................................34 4.6 INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT ............................................................................34 4.7 GOVERNMENTAL BODIES AFFILIATED WITH WEEE MANAGEMENT ...................................................................36 5 STAKEHOLDER ASSESSMENT............................................................................................................. 45 5.1 MANUFACTURERS AND IMPORTS ....................................................................................................................................46 5.2 DISTRIBUTERS.....................................................................................................................................................................48
  • 8. 5.3 CONSUMERS........................................................................................................................................................................49 5.3.1 Households ....................................................................................................................................................................50 5.3.2 Enterprises .....................................................................................................................................................................52 5.3.3 Governmental Sector ...................................................................................................................................................54 5.4 END-OF-LIFE MANAGEMENT..........................................................................................................................................54 5.4.1 Informal Sector .............................................................................................................................................................56 5.4.2 Formal Sector ................................................................................................................................................................67 5.5 CIVIL SOCIETY....................................................................................................................................................................75 6 WEEE INVENTORY ASSESSMENT...................................................................................................... 77 6.1 METHODOLOGY ................................................................................................................................................................77 6.1.1 Conclusion .....................................................................................................................................................................81 6.2 CONCEPTUAL APPROACH.................................................................................................................................................81 6.3 ESTABLISHMENT OF INSTALLED BASE OF SELECTED TRACERS...............................................................................81 6.4 CURRENT WEEE INVENTORY AND MASS FLOW........................................................................................................85 6.4.1 Scenario Analysis – WEEE Inventory......................................................................................................................85 6.4.2 Mass flow .......................................................................................................................................................................85 6.5 FUTURE MASS FLOW TRENDS .........................................................................................................................................88 7 IMPACTS................................................................................................................................................... 92 7.1 HOT SPOTS..........................................................................................................................................................................92 7.2 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS.............................................................................................................................................93 7.3 SOCIAL IMPACTS.................................................................................................................................................................94 7.3.1 Impacts on Employees ................................................................................................................................................94 7.3.2 Impacts on Society........................................................................................................................................................95 7.4 ECONOMIC IMPACT...........................................................................................................................................................95 8 COUNTRY ANALYSIS - CHALLENGES IN RECYCLING WEEE...................................................... 98 8.1 PROPOSED ROADMAP FOR WEEE MANAGEMENT IN EGYPT................................................................................101 9 RECOMMENDATIONS..........................................................................................................................102 10 CONCLUSION.........................................................................................................................................106 11 LIST OF REFERENCES .........................................................................................................................108 12 ANNEXES ................................................................................................................................................ 110 Annex 1: Overview of Stakeholders & Contacts Who Agreed To Be Onymous Annex 2: Field Survey Findings Report Annex 3: Questionnaire/Survey Employed in Field Survey Annex 4: Questionnaire Intended for Governmental Sector Survey Annex 5: Imports Data Received From CAPMAS Annex 6: Employees Number, Sectorial and Enterprise Category Received From CAPMAS Annex 7: Weight, Composition and Category of Tracers Annex 8: Detailed Calculation of Current WEEE Mass Flow Annex 9: Overview of Hazardous Waste Legal Text and Classification
  • 9. Page 6 of 112 List of Figures Figure 1. WEEE in Egypt at glance...............................................................................................................................22 Figure 2. Life cycle chain of EEE/WEEE...................................................................................................................45 Figure 3. Computer Screen units Import. Display unit (x1000). Source: CAPMAS..............................................46 Figure 4. Mobile units Import. Display unit (x1000). Source: CAPMAS................................................................47 Figure 5. Telephone set units Import. Display unit (x1000). Source: CAPMAS....................................................48 Figure 6. Smart Phone Market Share Q3 of 2015 .......................................................................................................49 Figure 7. Mobile Subscription and penetration rate. Source: MCIT indicators......................................................50 Figure 8. Major findings on mobiles from household survey....................................................................................50 Figure 9. Telephone Subscription and penetration rate. Source: MCIT indicators ...............................................51 Figure 10. Major findings on telephones from survey................................................................................................51 Figure 11. PC in Households - survey findings ...........................................................................................................52 Figure 12. Survey findings – large enterprises..............................................................................................................53 Figure 13. Survey findings – SMEs................................................................................................................................53 Figure 14. Disposal Method of selected tracers - survey findings ............................................................................55 Figure 15. Overview on informal sector .......................................................................................................................59 Figure 16. WEEE Stock of Merchant in Kollaly district............................................................................................60 Figure 17. Type of cables burnt to retrieve copper.....................................................................................................60 Figure 18. Dismantled WEEE stock in Mr.Amar workshop ....................................................................................63 Figure 19. Sorted WEEE streams..................................................................................................................................63 Figure 20. Packed WEEE commodities for export ....................................................................................................63 Figure 21. Collected dismantled PCBs by Mr.Dani (first row) plus photos during transect and tracer walk....65 Figure 22. Photo documentation during transect and tracer walk in Alexandria WEEE hubs...........................66 Figure 23. Dismantling and sorting area .......................................................................................................................71 Figure 24. Mechanical crushing unit..............................................................................................................................71 Figure 25. Plastic crushing unit.......................................................................................................................................71 Figure 26. One product of mechanical crushing and magnetic separation .............................................................72 Figure 27. One gram of refined 24 carat gold..............................................................................................................72 Figure 28. Recyclobekia warehouse ...............................................................................................................................56 Figure 29. Sorting and dismantling in Eco Integrated Industrial Systems...............................................................57 Figure 30. Tentative source for data collection............................................................................................................79 Figure 31. WEEE mass flow chart ................................................................................................................................86 Figure 32. Mass percentage of major fractions in Category 3 ...................................................................................96 List of Tables Table 1. Data acquisition .................................................................................................................................................24 Table 2. Social development indicators.........................................................................................................................29 Table 3. Environmental Indicators (2012)....................................................................................................................30 Table 4. Economic development indicators.................................................................................................................30 Table 5. Governmental bodies related to WEEE management................................................................................36 Table 6. Laws with influence on WEEE management...............................................................................................37 Table 7. Prices of WEEE streams. Source: Primary source - transect and tracer walk.........................................63 Table 8. EEE & WEEE Markets and Hubs ................................................................................................................64 Table 9. Processes performed on WEEE.....................................................................................................................68 Table 10. Reimbursable value of WEEE extracted commodities.............................................................................70
  • 10. Page 7 of 112 Table 11. Price for hazardous waste/treatment...........................................................................................................74 Table 12. Quantities and prices of used mobile handsets collected by Resala NGO in 2014, 2013, 2012........76 Table 13. Tentative Sources of Data..............................................................................................................................77 Table 14. Constraint Table..............................................................................................................................................80 Table 15. Installed base of selected tracers...................................................................................................................84 Table 16. Average lifetime and cycle of selected tracers.............................................................................................85 Table 17. Mass flow chart calculation............................................................................................................................87 Table 18. Forecasted annual sales of tracers each succeeding years.........................................................................90 Table 19. Increase in installed volume of stock and WEEE– cumulative. .............................................................91 Table 20. Environmental Impacts..................................................................................................................................93 Table 21. Material composition of tracers - Umicore.................................................................................................95 Table 22. Economic magnitude of the WEEE mass flow.........................................................................................97 Table 23. List of recommendations .............................................................................................................................102
  • 11. Page 8 of 112 List of Acronyms and Definitions ARF Advanced Recycling Fee CAPMAS Central Agency For Public Mobilization and Statistics CAGR Cumulative Annual Growth Rate CDD Compact Disk Drive CEDARE Center For Environment & Development For The Arab Region & Europe CRT Cathode Ray Tube ECS EcoConServ Environmental Solutions EEAA Egyptian Environmental Affairs Authority ENCPC Egypt National Cleaner Production Centre EPR Extended Producer Responsibility WEEE Electronic Waste FDD Floppy Disk Drive GAGS General Authority of Government Services HDD Hard Disk Drive HWMU Hazardous Waste Management Unit ICs Integrated Circuits ICT Information and Communication Technology ITU International Telecommunication Union LCD Liquid Crystal Display MTI Ministry Of Trade and Industry NEAP National Environmental Action Plan NTRA National Telecom Regulatory Authority PC Personal Computer PCBs Printed Circuit Boards PPP Public Private Partnership SMEs Small And Medium Enterprises MSMEs Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises UNIDO United Nations Industrial Development Organization WEEE Waste Of Electric And Electronic Equipment VOIP Voice Over Internet Protocol WEEE Formal Management Firms In the context of this report, the Consultant used this term to describe WEEE management firms with established office/firm/plant that possess environmental permit from Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency and operational permit from Industrial Development Authority to perform their respective activity with WEEE. WEEE Informal Management Firms In the context of this report, the Consultant used this term to describe WEEE management firms that do not possess environmental permit from Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency and operational permit from Industrial
  • 12. Page 9 of 112 Development Authority to perform their respective activity with WEEE. Tons A tonne, also known as metric tons, is a unit of mass equaling 1,000 kilograms.
  • 13. Page 10 of 112 Executive Summary Overview “WEEE is a term used to cover all items of electrical and electronic equipment (EEE) and its parts that have been discarded by its owner as waste without the intent of reuse” (Step Initiative 2014). The amout of electronic waste (WEEE/WEEE) has increased rapidly over the past years with estimated generation capacity of 20-50 million tonnes annualy. WEEE impose a global challenge on both develped and developing worlds due to the complex characterstic of this waste stream, where its constitutent includes toxic and other resoureces that varies significanlty by product. Currently electronic waste makes up around 5% of municipale waste world wide and is counted as the fastest growing component of municipal solid waste stream. Problem Identification Egypt is among top three African countries with the highest WEEE generation in absolute quantities, amounting 0.37 million tons in 2014. With no proper management of WEEE, this signpost adverse environmental and health impact because of the constituents of this complex waste stream which includes hazardous resources. As large quantities are generated per year, not enough are collected/recycled by formal sector, leaving majority of WEEE treated or dumped, according to the informal sector treatment. Objective of the Assessment The assessment will include:  Analysis of local context and stakeholders identification  Describe WEEE practices in the country by formal and informal sector  Describe and analyze national policies and regulatory framework on WEEE handling and recycling  Establish baseline for current and future WEEE inventory and mass flow  Identify hot spots and develop road map for WEEE management in Egypt  Social and economic evaluation  Environmental and social impacts of current WEEE practices  Identify the challenges Egypt face with WEEE recycling industry  Recommendations based on this study
  • 14. Page 11 of 112 Data Acquisition The consultant adopted multi-approach data collection, comprising of quantitative and qualitative data from primary and secondary resources, followed by refining gathered data thorough reviewing process to deduce reliable information. Data input Source Governmental Sources  Tracers Imports and Exports Data Base  Development indicators (Population, education and Economy)  Households data  ICT Indicators  Quantitative data on selected traceri s  Penetration rate on selected tracers  Tracers stock in governmental bodies  WEEE practices in governmental entities  Amount of disposed WEEE from formal supplier  Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics (CAPMAS)  Egyptian Ministry of Communications and Information Technology (MCIT)  Information and Decision Support Center (IDSC)  General Authority of Governmental Services (GAGS)  National Telecom Regulatory Authority (NTRA) Regional and International Data Base  EEE imports and exports  Country profile  International trade in goods  Country solid waste profile  WEEE developments – country specific  WEEE initiatives  Economic opportunities  UN Comtrade Database  World Bank  The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)  the Regional Solid Waste Exchange of Information and Expertise Network (SWEEP-Net)  Basel Convention Regional Center (BCRC-Egypt)  United Nations specialized agency for information and communication technologies (ITU) Literatures  WEEE classification  WEEE recycling potentials  Best practices  WEEE development in the country  Country practices  Stakeholders mapping  ArabDev  Environmental protection Agency (EPA) – U.S.A  United Nation University (UNU)  step-initiative  Centre for Environment and Development for the Arab Region and Europe (CEDARE)
  • 15. Page 12 of 112 Data input Source Meetings & Interviews A number of meetings and interviews took place with institutions representative, private sector representative, distributers, NGOs, formal collectors, informal collectors and recyclers. The purpose was to draw the current country practices with WEEE practices, collect quantitative and qualitative information on WEEE, suggest recommendations as well as gather scoped information on the selected tracers. Surveys and Questionnaires The household survey was conducted on a sample of 1806 respondents at households in the five target governorates (Cairo, Giza, Qalyubia, Alexandria and Sharkeya). Private households were considered the survey unit, hence each response to the questionnaire represents one family. The total number of enterprises surveyed were 27 (9 companies in each of the target governorates.) representing 19 SMEs and 8 large enterprise. Enterprises were selected according to their sizes as well as to represent different economic sectors. Total surveyed SMEs and large enterprises were 19 and 8 respectively. Product Scope (Tracers) This assessment focuses on tracers that are considered the fasted growing waste streams and are widely used among private and governmental sector in Egyptian population. As per the terms of reference of the project, the tracers of category 1 chosen are Personal Computers comprising desktop computers and laptops, tracers of category 2 chosen are mobile phones and tracer of category 3 chosen are telephone sets. According to UK environmental agency, selected tracers falls under IT and telecommunications equipment categories. Additional attention will be given on the recycling practices of electrical cables in the Egyptian market. The composition of these categories of equipment in terms of weight and materials is provided in Annex 7. Policy and Legislation Law 4 /1994 on the Environment and its amendments in Law 9/2009 are the over-riding environmental laws for Egypt. Article 3 of the Presidential Decree issuing Law 4/1994 repeals all provisions of other laws running counter to the provisions of Law 4/1994. One article in Law 4/1994 addresses general solid waste management and another addresses the management of construction and demolition debris. In addition, five articles address hazardous waste management. Egypt has no stipulated solid waste management law however Law 38/1967 on General Public Cleaning and their amendments are the main legislation enforcing the establishment of solid waste management. Law 38/1967 on General Public Cleansing is the primary law governing the management of solid waste in Egypt. It was enacted in 1967 and replaced all previous laws dealing with solid waste
  • 16. Page 13 of 112 including Law 97/1956 on Organization of Garbage Collection and Transfer, Law 159/1953 on Cleansing Public Squares, Streets and Highways, and Law 151/1947 on Cleansing Fences and Unused Areas. Since 1967, it has been amended four times. In 1968, the Minister of Housing (MoH) issued the executive regulations for the law (MoH 134/1968). Law 48/1982 is the law for protection of the Nile and its canals. The executive regulations for Law 48/1982 were issued by Minister of Irrigation Decree Number 8 of 1983 (MoI 8/1983). The law and its executive regulations and amendments in January 2013 by ministerial decision 92/2013 is primarily focus on wastewater discharges to the Nile and its canals, but also contain articles that include solid waste. Two laws concerning public ways, such as highways, streets, and squares, Law 140/1956, Occupation of Public Ways and Law 84/1968, Concerning Public Ways, contain restrictions on solid waste management and disposal. Egypt has listed WEEE is under the category of the hazardous waste list issued by the Ministry of Industry (decision 165/2002), item 16. As WEEE is identified as hazardous waste by the aforementioned decision articles addressing hazardous waste management in law 4/94 regulate it
  • 17. Page 14 of 112 Governmental Bodies affiliated with WEEE Management Entity Note Ministry of Environment (MoE) Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency (EEAA) Waste Management Regulatory Authority (WMRA) Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency is the executive arm of the Ministry of Environment Ministry of Communication and Information Technology (MCIT) The MCIT and MoE have signed Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) in February 2010 to launch the Egyptian Green ICT Strategy. MCIT and MoE have conducted several initiatives to introduce WEEE management principles. The MCIT is keen to address the WEEE management in the green ICT strategy Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI) Egyptian National Cleaner Production Center (ENCPC) The Egypt National Cleaner Production Centre (ENCPC) was established in 2005 by the Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI) in close cooperation with the United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO) with the aim to promote green technologies, revolutionize current national and local practices and transfer the required knowledge for environmental friendly industries. Ministry of Finance The auction of absolute EEE in public organizations is regulated and supervised by the Ministry of Finance. Furthermore, The Egyptian Customs Authority as part of Ministry of Finance inspect and monitors the flow of electric and electronic equipment in and out of Egypt National Telecom Regulatory Authority (NTRA) NTRA requires importers of telecommunication equipment to manage safely telecommunication electronic waste in order to issue them permit. This is intercepted through Waste Tracking Form, where telecommunication equipment importers require submitting annually. NTRA accepts the following ways of safely managing electronic waste: Sending the waste to Nasreya hazardous landfill, delivering the electronic waste to WEEE management firms (e.g. ITG) and selling of telecommunication electronic waste in public auctions. General Authority of Government Services (GAGS) The GAGS auctions the movable and immovable property of administrative body and public authorities after being authorized by those entities, in order to eliminate the problem of overstock and scrap (this includes electronic waste). Also, the GAGS auctions goods and commodities that are obsolete or confiscated by customs. Hazardous Waste Management Unit (HWMU) in Nasreya recycling and disposal center It was established as part of Finnish Egyptian cooperation for the design and construction of hazardous waste treatment system. Where the Governor of Alexandria issue a decree No.416 in 2000 to establish a unit of hazardous management. The project constitute of two phases, Phase I of the facility includes a secure landfill and solar evaporation ponds to receive wastes, and Phase II includes mechanical and chemical treatment, solidification, and interim storage.
  • 18. Page 15 of 112 Method Employed, Installed Base of Tracers and Mass Flow The application of Approximation 1 Stock method that is also referred as “Consumption and Use” requires data on saturation level, number of households, stock data and average life time. These data are available from different governmental and private secondary sources and supported by survey/questionnaire carried out. The inventory assessment is based upon approximation 1 stock method that would form the baseline for the future WEEE projections according to imports and market research agencies finding. The conceptual approach of tracers’ inventory assessment is based on three steps are employed to described as following: Step 1: Establish the installed base of selected tracers with medium term future projections (5 years) to ensure the reliability of the projections Step 2: Identify obsolescence rate and average life cycle data using “upper limit” and “lower limit” Step 3: Quantify WEEE inventory and mass flow with medium future projections The following table provides the installed base of selected tracers
  • 19. Page 16 of 112 Installed base of selected tracers Quantity Unit 2,407,911.0 enterprise 1,631.0 enterprise 91,508,084.0 capita 21,787,639.0 households 5,752,039.0 employee Assumptions for calculation Goveronmental sector employees Private MSMEs Private large enter Egypt Population 2015 Egypt HHs 2015 subject Tracer kg Mobile 0.1 Telephone 1.0 Computer 9.9 Laptop 3.5 CRT monitor 14.1 LCD monitor 4.7 Weights Unit Weight Unit Weight(kg) Unit Weight(kg) Unit Weight(kg) Unit Weight(kg) Unit Weight(kg) Subtotal [-] [kg] [-] [kg] [-] [kg] [-] [kg] [-] [kg] [-] [kg] Weight(kg) 94,020,000.0 9,402,000.0 6,240,000.0 6,240,000.0 15,642,000.0 8,375,342.8 82,915,893.2 3,869,310.4 13,542,586.4 4,941,452.2 69,674,476.3 3,433,890.5 16,139,285.5 182,272,241.4 24,242,210.0 24,242,210.0 26,522,903.0 262,576,739.7 24,258,520.0 84,904,820.0 5,304,580.60 74,794,586.5 21,218,322.4 99,726,115.3 546,244,471.4 958,673.2 958,673.2 563,699.8 5,580,628.2 241,585.6 845,549.7 169,109.9 2,384,450.2 394,589.9 1,854,572.4 11,623,873.8 94,020,000.0 9,402,000.0 31,440,883.2 31,440,883.2 35,461,945.57 351,073,261.17 28,369,416.03 99,292,956.11 10,415,142.77 146,853,513.05 25,046,802.80 117,719,973.18 755,782,586.7 Total (tons) 755,782.59 LCD Monitor Population Actor Total of installed base of tracers (Stock istalled) Mobile Telephone Desktop Computer Laptop CRT Monitor Total (kg) Sub Total Goveronmental Sector Enterprises Households
  • 20. Page 17 of 112 Mass flow of Tracers Legend Stock tons WEEE1 Scenario 1 tons/year WEEE2 Scenario 2 tons/year Imports data not incorporated due to Data limitation in receiving the annual tracers import. Product Waste
  • 21. Page 18 of 112 The governmental sector and enterprises electronic obsolete equipment is mostly disposed in auctions. The largest electronic waste generated is by enterprises (amounting ≈58%), followed by households (amounting ≈23%) and governmental sector (amounting ≈19%). Based on scenario 1 the mass flow is 72,992.7 tons/year and based on scenario 2 the mass flow is 66,203.8 tons/year. The largest amount of mass flow is generated by the enterprises, followed by households then governmental sector. Post dismantling of tracers, extracted commodities as plastics, iron, etc. is processed and reinstalled in the market as feedstock for other industries. Currently only around 1,608.0 tons/year of electronic waste is been collected from the total generated electronic waste mass flow, which only represents 2.2% to 2.4% based on WEEE1 and WEEE2 respectively. For the selected tracers, the stock of equipment/inhabitant and stock of equipment/household is around 8.3 kg and 34.69 kg respectively. As for the waste mass /year/inhabitant is around 0.80 kg (WEEE1) and 0.72 kg (WEEE2). Hot spots Eol from consumer 1 Waste auction by public sector has no recycling regulation on collectors – ending with informal sector. 2 Waste auction by enterprises is not subjected to regulation on sustainable recycling. 3 Consumer dump WEEE with household waste. No EPR, WEEE goes to maintenance and service shops and downstream end with informal sector. Material recovery 4 WEEE management firms: “Cherry picking” of WEEE - WEEE which requires careful handling or low economic revenue eventually ends with informal sector. 5 Informal sector: inappropriate dismantling of hazardous component; child labour; negative health impacts; wires and cables burning. Informal Dumping 6 Emissions from dumped waste; emissions from informal burning sites; not all secondary recourses efficiently are recovered. Section ‎8.1 suggest the interventions in form of roadmap for WEEE management in Egypt
  • 22. Page 19 of 112 Conclusion In this study, assessment for electronic waste in Egypt has been performed encompassing legal assessment, stakeholder assessment, installed stock and mass flow assessment, scenario analysis of mass flow, assessment of country challenges in recycling WEEE, proposed roadmap and recommendations. In Egypt, there is no specific regulation regarding electronic waste management, it is strongly recommended to enact a definition of electronic waste and regulations on electronic waste management. Most of households electronic waste downstream ends with informal sector, the electronic wastes from governmental sector and enterprises is mostly auctioned and this occur with no environmental health and safety requirement neither end treatment requirement on participants. Up to date of this study, six WEEE management firms practice in depth dismantling and recycling some of base metals in local industries, of which only two of the six WEEE management firms are formal as per the definition stipulated in this study. Only two of the six WEEE management firms do recycle PCBs and other electronic boards by employing mechanical and chemical processing. It is well noted that most of the WEEE management firms are facing challenges in dealing with CRT monitors and batteries due to lack of knowledge treatment and negative economic value, consequently, the behavior of “cherry picking” of specific electronic waste has been observed. During the process of mapping the informal sector, transect and tracer walk, no chemical processing on electronic waste has been reported. However, improper handling of electronic waste and open air burning was been reported. At the time being, there are persons in the informal sector who are managing to export PCBs and electronic boards abroad. This WEEE practices by the formal and informal sector impact is rated as medium with medium sensitivity, because there is no chemical processing reported in the informal sector, the sensitivity of impact is not critical. Nevertheless, currently the practices in informal sector are ignoring safety, health, and environment concern, which necessitate timely interventions on many levels to minimize the impact and the sensitivity of the impact. With respect to electronic waste quantification, a number of tracers has been selected that are considered most being employed within the population, also because the appliances contain a considerable amount of precious metals and base metals, the tracers represent category 3 as per UK environmental agency WEEE categorization. The tracers are mobile, telephone, desktop PC, laptop PC, CRT monitor and LCD monitor. There has been difficulty in quantifying the tracers’ penetration, demand and waste in governmental sector, given the limited time and financial scope, the consultant adopted alternative approach based on official data and indicative survey. However, it is strongly recommended to perform survey across governmental sector and maintain non-fiscal database for any future studies affiliated with electronic waste. For year 2015, installed base of tracers reached around 755,782.59 tons with enterprises having the largest volume of installed tracers, followed by households and governmental sector respectively. This represents 8.3kg stock of tracer/inhabitant and 34.89kg stock of tracer/household. As for the waste mass flow of selected tracers, it ranged between 72,992.7 tons/year to 66,203.8 tons/year
  • 23. Page 20 of 112 based on scenario 1 and scenario 2 respectively. This amounts 0.80kg WEEE/inhabitant based on scenario 1 and 0.72 kg/inhabitant based on scenario 2. As reported during interviews, only around 1584.0 tons/year of WEEE is collected from the market, which only represents 2.2 % to 2.4%. This suggests the market is very promising for electronic waste recycling initiatives. But also suggest timely intervention is required, because the majority of electronic waste has unidentified final destination, which indicates a large loss of valuable economic potential as well as added negative value of environmental and health degradation if most of the mass flow is subjected to informal sector treatment. The study suggests road map for WEEE management in Egypt. To ensure the sustainability of the WEEE recycling business in Egypt, This study recommends that existing informal sector be integrated in the formal waste management system in “safe” recycling processes. This can take form accrediting and empowering informal sector for collection and dismantling, supported by environmental health and safety regulations. Cumulatively, this would be time saving for WEEE management firms and lower labour cost. To reinforce the sustainability of the WEEE recycling business in Egypt, alternative business models with financial incentives need to be studied, other financial support to provide additional revenue and an effective collection design system need to be established. Consequently, this would foster the recycling operations, smelting and refinery plants by having constant feedstock from the collection points. Finally, the Consultant recommends that future initiatives and pilot projects in the WEEE industry is advised to focus more on ensuring effective collection of WEEE, given that the two current existing WEEE recycling plants are encountering challenges with respect to employ effective processes on various encountered WEEE to efficiently recover the precious metals. End of Executive Summary
  • 24. Page 21 of 112 1 Introduction 1.1 Overview “WEEE is a term used to cover all items of electrical and electronic equipment (EEE) and its parts that have been discarded by its owner as waste without the intent of reuse” (Step Initiative 2014). The amout of electronic waste (WEEE/WEEE) has increased rapidly over the past years with estimated generation capacity of 20-50 million tonnes annualy1 . WEEE impose a global challenge on both develped and developing worlds due to the complex characterstic of this waste stream, where its constitutent includes toxic and other resoureces that varies significanlty by product. Currently electronic waste makes up around 5% of municipale waste world wide and is counted as the fastest growing component of municipal solid waste stream2 . 302 million personal computers3 in 2014 and 336.3 million mobiles in 2015 were sold world wide4 , which represents 65% percent annual sales rise than in 2004 for personal computers and over 100% annual sales rise than in 2008 for mobiles. This sharp growth is expected to accelerate more, since electronic equipment life span is decreasing over years while accompanied by consumer behaviour that tend to acquire newer products attributed to technological progress in the market that offers better services to end users. Among all devices, mobile phones and personal computers represent the major problem as they are replaced in high frequency. In Europe WEEE is growing at a rate of three to five percent annualy, and this figure is expected to triple for developing conutires in the following five years5 . United Nation University estimated that 41.8 million tons of electronic waste was generated in 2014 world wide, where only 6.5 million tons were collected by official collection companies or take back system, which makes 35.3 million tonnes of electronic waste with ananymous fate. WEEE currently is majorly dealt by the informal sector in the developing world. United Nation University's report indicates that large quantites of WEEE shipped to west Africa and Asia are shipped from industrialized countries6 . It is widely unknown that WEEE not only contains hazardous substances but also includes highly valuable materials such as gold, silver, copper, platinum, palladium, iron, aluminum, indium, gallium and rare earth metals that may be recovered. The extraction of these metals from the Earth comes along with a significant environmental impact. WEEE recycling thus contributes to sustainable 1 UNEP environment alert bulletin, http://www.grid.unep.ch/products/3_Reports/ew_ewaste.en.pdf 2 Greenpeace international, http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/campaigns/detox/electronics/the- WEEE-problem/ 3 International data corporation, global worldwide pc sales, http://www.statisticbrain.com/computer-sales- statistics/ 4 Gartner, IT research company, worldwide smartphone sales, retrieved April 2016 http://www.gartner.com/newsroom/id/3323017 5 Eurostat, environmental data center on waste, http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/waste/key-waste- streams/weee 6 UNU our world portal, http://ourworld.unu.edu/en/toxic-WEEE-dumped-in-poor-nations-says-united-nations
  • 25. Page 22 of 112 resource management and presents a viable economical opportunity which invite to develop WEEE management system. For every 1 million cell phones that are recycled, 16000 kg of copper, 350 kg of silver, 34 kg of gold, and 15 kg of palladium can be recovered7 . 1.2 Problem Identification Egypt is among the top three African countries with the highest WEEE generation in absolute quantities, amounting 0.37 million tons in 20148 . With no proper management of WEEE, this signpost adverse environmental and health impact because of the constituents of this complex waste stream which includes hazardous resources. As large quantities are generated per year, not enough are collected/recycled by formal sector, leaving majority of WEEE treated or dumped, according to the informal sector treatment. The country faces challenges at the level of consumer awareness, but significantly more on the collection, recycling processes, and the disposal of WEEE. A cooperative effort is required with all stakeholders to foster developing integrated WEEE management system that would be beneficial to all parties enforced by legal and institutional framework. 7 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. "Wastes - Resource Conservation - Common Wastes & Materials - eCycling." Web Accessed April 11, 2015 8 Baldé, C.P., Wang, F., Kuehr, R., Huisman, J. (2015), The global WEEE monitor – 2014, United Nations University, IAS – SCYCLE, Bonn, Germany. WEEE in Egypt at Glance EEE Put in Market [2012] WEEE Generated [2014] Kg/Inhabitant 7.7 4.3 Total Metric kilotons 635 373 [Total inhabitants in 2012: 82.01 million] Figure 1.WEEE in Egypt at glance
  • 26. Page 23 of 112 1.3 Objective of the Assessment The objective of the assessment is to provide evaluation on the current WEEE management and practices in Egypt, develop baseline information to help in drawing structure for WEEE management system, and to identify economic and social opportunities. The assessment will include:  Analysis of local context and stakeholders identification  Describe WEEE practices in the country by formal and informal sector  Describe and analyze national policies and regulatory framework on WEEE handling and recycling  Establish baseline for current and future WEEE inventory and mass flow  Identify hot spots and develop road map for WEEE management in Egypt  Social and economic evaluation  Environmental and social impacts of current WEEE practices  Identify the challenges Egypt face with WEEE recycling industry  Recommendations based on this study The scope of the assessment covers whole Egypt, with field visits and surveys focused on Greater Cairo, Alexandria and Sharkia, which encompasses surveys to business enterprises and households.
  • 27. Page 24 of 112 2 Methods 2.1 Data Acquisition The consultant adopted multi-approach data collection, comprising of quantitative and qualitative sources, followed by refining gathered data thorough reviewing process to collate reliable information. 2.1.1 Literature and Statistical Analysis Literature and documentary analysis prominently included but not limited to the following Table 1. Data acquisition Data input Source Governmental Sources  Tracers9 Imports and Exports Data Base  Development indicators (Population, education and Economy)  Households data  ICT Indicators  Quantitative data on selected tracers  Penetration rate on selected tracers  Tracers stock in governmental bodies  WEEE practices in governmental entities  Amount of disposed WEEE from formal supplier  Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics (CAPMAS)  Egyptian Ministry of Communications and Information Technology (MCIT)  Information and Decision Support Center (IDSC)  General Authority of Governmental Services (GAGS)  National Telecom Regulatory Authority (NTRA) Regional and International Data Base  EEE imports and exports  Country profile  International trade in goods  Country solid waste profile  WEEE developments – country specific  WEEE initiatives  Economic opportunities  UN Comtrade Database  World Bank  The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)  the Regional Solid Waste Exchange of Information and Expertise Network (SWEEP-Net)  Basel Convention Regional Center (BCRC-Egypt)  United Nations specialized agency 9 Tracers: Desktop PC, Laptop PC, CRT monitors, LCD monitors, mobiles and telephones
  • 28. Page 25 of 112 Data input Source for information and communication technologies (ITU) Literatures  WEEE classification  WEEE recycling potentials  Best practices  WEEE development in the country  Country practices  Stakeholders mapping  ArabDev  Environmental protection Agency (EPA) – U.S.A  United Nation University (UNU)  step-initiative  Centre for Environment and Development for the Arab Region and Europe (CEDARE) 2.1.2 Meetings and Interviews A number of meetings and interviews took place with institutions representative, private sector representative, distributers, NGOs, formal collectors, informal collectors and recyclers. The purpose was to draw the current country practices with WEEE practices, collect quantitative and qualitative information on WEEE, suggest recommendations as well as gather scoped information on the selected tracers. A list of stakeholders’ contacts who agreed to be onymous are found in annex 1 2.1.3 Surveys and Questionnaires The household survey was conducted on a sample of 1806 respondents at households in the five target governorates (Cairo, Giza, Qalyubia, Alexandria and Sharkeya). Private households were considered the survey unit, hence each response to the questionnaire represents one family. The total number of enterprises surveyed were 27 (9 companies in each of the target governorates.) representing 19 SMEs and 8 large enterprises. Enterprises were selected according to their size to represent different economic sectors. Total surveyed SMEs and large enterprises were 19 and 8 respectively. Initially it was planned to conduct survey across governmental sectors but at later stage it did not take place due to limitations in issuing the required permissions and time frame constraints. Instead, a series of interviews with different governmental sector representatives took place for qualitative assessment and indicative quantitation. 2.1.4 Field Studies To obtain data with respect to the informal sector treatment with WEEE and on quantities of collected WEEE and destinations, the Consultant adopted a number of interviews with WEEE merchants, dismantlers, recyclers and landfill operator, this was supported by the transect and tracer walk in a number of areas and 2nd hand markets, details are covered in Section ‎5.4.
  • 29. Page 26 of 112 2.2 Mass Flow Assessment In general, WEEE inventory of a country is based on either stock data, sales data or both together. In case of Egypt, the consultant calculated the WEEE mass flow based on stock methodology. Selected method is attributed to the reliable information, which provides stock quantified data. The WEEE mass flow equation is estimated according to the Approximation 1 Stock method (Burea B&G, 1993) in WEEE Management Manual produced by United Nation Environment Program. This method is also referred as “Consumption and Use” in some literatures. This method is presented mathematically in the following equation: WEEE generation [Tons/Year] = 𝑆𝑡𝑜𝑐𝑘 (𝐼)+𝑆𝑡𝑜𝑐𝑘 (𝐻.𝐻) [𝑇𝑜𝑛𝑒𝑠] 𝐴𝑣𝑒𝑟𝑎𝑔𝑒 𝐿𝑖𝑓𝑒 𝑇𝑖𝑚𝑒 [𝑌𝑒𝑎𝑟] Where Stock (H.H) = H.H × 𝑊𝐴× 𝑃𝑟 Stock (I) = I.S × 𝑊𝐴× 𝑃𝑟 H.H: House Holds and Workplaces I.S: Industry stock (private and public entities) 𝑊𝐴: Average Weight Pr ∶ Penetration Rate 2.3 Limitations During the process of collecting information to develop this study, a set of difficulties have been encountered in order to conduct a thorough extensive assessment of the WEEE quantities due to the following reasons. - Limitation in information disclosure by suppliers and manufacturers thus difficulty in assessing the tracers data - Limitation on quantifying specific WEEE equipment/tracers due to lack of WEEE sorting in storage and recycling process. - Limitations in conducting survey with governomental sectors - Many governomental sectors are running on paper-based information management system. Furthemore, most of the information is based on fiscal values, which presents a challenge to properly measure quantities. The assessment is based on stock data method, which gives consistent results when reliable stock data is avaialable. The main assumption associated with the stock method assessment is that the life span of the tracer is presumed with no major deviation, which is a subjective and variable matter with bearing in mind the new technological penetration in the market.
  • 30. Page 27 of 112 The estimates are based on sources such as national data and coorelated with internationl data therefore the results are reliable. The estimated WEEE generated between 2016 and 2021 is be regarded as medium and the results of the survey on the population's practices are indicative.
  • 31. Page 28 of 112 3 System Definition 3.1 Geographical Scope The scope of the assessment covers whole Egypt, with field visits and surveys focused on Greater Cairo, Alexandria and Sharkia, which encompasses surveys to business enterprises, households and informal sector. 3.2 Product Scope This assessment focuses on tracers that are considered the fasted growing waste streams and are widely used among private and public sectors in the Egyptian population. The selected tracers are composed of 3 categories10 as follows:  Category 1 :Personal Computers comprising desktop computers and laptops,  Category 2 : mobile phones  Category 3: telephone sets. According to directive 2012/19/EU11 on Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) the selected tracers fall under category 3 (IT and telecommunication equipment). Additional attention will be given on the recycling practices of electrical cables in the Egyptian market. The composition of these categories of equipment in terms of weight and materials is provided in Annex 7. 3.2.1 Development of ICT Sector The selected tracers fall under the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) appliance12 . Egypt ICT sector has witnessed a substantial growth in the past 10 years. Egypt falls in the top 100 places in the United Nations index in 2015 from 167 countries for development in the communication and information technology sector as well as citizens access to communication technology. During 2008/2009 The ICT value added EGP 30.9 billion (US$ 5.6 billion), with an annual growth rate of 14.5%. The ICT sector recorded the highest growth rate among economic sectors in Egypt, proving that it can maintain its growth momentum even during times of crisis. The private sector is playing a leading role contributing with about 69 % of the ICT's total value added to the ones generated in 2008/2009. The ICT sector’s share in the total gross domestic product (GDP) increased from EGP 48bn in 2010 to approximately EGP 66bn in 2014, recording a share of 4.1%.13 Egypt has successfully nurtured one of the most competitive and successful ICT economies in the world. Already an ICT leader in the MENA region, Egypt is ranked 4th worldwide in A.T. Kearney’s 2011 Global Services Location Index, with the sector accounting for almost 4% of GDP, over US$ 10 billion of total investment from some 5500 companies in 2013, and an annual growth rate of 10 As per project terms of reference 11 EU Directive on WEEE. “WEEE Categorization” archived on 6 January 2012. 12 Environmental Association for Universities and Colleges, ewaste_insight_guide_1%20(1).pdf 13 MCIT, http://www.egyptictindicators.gov.eg/
  • 32. Page 29 of 112 around 13%. The Government has set a target of doubling the share of ICT in the national economy to 8.5% by 2020, creating 250,000 new jobs in the process As part of fostering the Egyptian economy market, the Egyptian Ministry of Communication and Information Technology (MICT) has set a new ICT strategy to boost the nation investment in the ICT sector to 44 billion EGP. The ministry plans is to invest in improving the infrastructure, assuring 75% of Egyptian household internet access with 2Mbps by 2015, and increasing households internet access to 90% at 25Mbps by 2021. MCIT also aspires to offer 3G service to 98% of users by 2015, 4G service to 90% of the population by 2021. 3.3 Development Indicators People Table 2. Social development indicators Indicator In millions Source Total Population (2016) 90,984,725 CAPMAS Urban Population (estimations on 1/1/2016 based on 2006 census projections) 42.7% CAPMAS Rural Population (estimations on 1/1/2016 based on 2006 census projections) 57.3% CAPMAS Number of households (2006 census survey) 17,289,299 CAPMAS Size of households in 2006 4.18 % CAPMAS Number of urban households 7,844,852 CAPMAS Number of rural households 9,444,447 CAPMAS Unemployment in 2014 13.2 World Bank Youth unemployment in 2014 female male World Bank 64.8 % 32.7 % Population below international poverty line in 2010 2.25% World Bank Environment The Capacity 21 Unit at the Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency (EEAA) is responsible of the development and fostering of the environmental indicators through a set of strategic action plans, which is UNDP sponsored, called National Environmental Action Plan (NEAP) 2002-2017. It represents Egypt’s agenda for environmental actions for the coming fifteen years. It complements and integrates with other sectoral plans for economic growth and social development. As identified by NEAP, Major environmental issues and concerns that challenge Egypt today covers the degradation of land, air and water resources and the pressing need to preserve our cultural heritage and natural biodiversity. The following table demonstrate Egypt environmental indicators
  • 33. Page 30 of 112 Table 3. Environmental Indicators (2012) Electricity- International Energy Statistics Scale Unit Quantity Power consumption per capita KWh 1,700.45 Total Net Consumption Billion KWh 136.0 Total Net Generation Billion KWh 155.0 Total Installed Capacity Million KW 29.45 Total Renewable Energy Installed Million KW 3.63 GDP per unit of energy use $ per kg of oil equivalent 11.22 Emissions – World Bank Development Indicators Scale Unit Quantity GHG (CO2 equivalent) Kilotons 295,499.75 CO2 Emissions per Capita – 2011 Metric tons 2.64 Land Use - World Bank Development Indicators Scale Unit Quantity Land area Sq.km 995,450.0 Forest area Sq.km 712.0 Arable land area Hectare 2,829,000.0 Arable land area per person Hectare per person 0.03 Population - World Bank Development Indicators Scale Unit Quantity Population in Largest City Person 17,642,712.0 Population in Urban Agglomerations of more than 1 million Person 22,152,524.0 Rural Population Person 48,824,001.0 Urban Population Person 36,835,901.0 Egypt took set of actions to contribute in reducing the carbon dioxide print and greenhouse gases, one of major developments is an overarching regulatory framework with the aim of securing 20% of its energy generation from renewable sources by 2020 and is currently installing largest solar PV power plant in the world with 1.8GW in Aswan. Economy Table 4. Economic development indicators Indicators In millions/ Billion Source Gross domestic product in 2014 $301.5 Billion –2.4 trillion Egyptian pounds World Bank GNI, PPP (current international $) (2011-2015) 920,696,746,178 GDP per capita in 2014 $3,210 - (30.49 thousand EGP CAPMAS) GDP(ppp) per capita in 2014 10.280.0 GDP composition by sector Agriculture Industry Services 15% 36% 49%
  • 34. Page 31 of 112 Indicators In millions/ Billion Source Labor force by sector In 2013 services agriculture industry female male female male female male 52.1 46.9 42.9 24.1 5.0 29.0 States and Markets Indicator In millions Source Number of subscribers – Fixed lines (2015) 6.06 CAPMAS Number of subscribers – Mobile phones (2015) 93.13 CAPMAS Number of subscribers – Internet (2015) 27.25 CAPMAS Internet users per 100 inhabitants (2015) 31.7 MCIT – ICT indicators Number of mobile phone connections per 100 inhabitant (2015) 107.17 MCIT – ICT indicators Fixed telephone lines per 100 inhabitant (2015) 7.23 MCIT – ICT indicators ICT Contribution To GDP (%) at fixed prices (2015) 2.80 MCIT – ICT indicators ICT Sector Revenues (thousands) (2015) 77.82 Micro, small and medium enterprises (2013) 2,407,911 CAPMAS
  • 35. Page 32 of 112 4 Policy and Legislation 4.1 Environmental Law and Articles Environmental protection is governed by Law No. 4 of 1994, and amended by Law 9/2009 with decree No 1095/2011, 710/2012 and 964/2015 and its executive regulations. Ambient Air Quality and Gaseous Emissions Articles 35 and 34 of Law 4 of its Executive Regulations amended by Decree 1741/2005 provide the maximum load of the ambient air and the permissible levels of air pollutants in emissions Wastewater Law 93/1962 regulates the disposal of wastewater, untreated substances, wastes or liquids which may cause pollution along the Egyptian sea shores or adjoining waters either directly or indirectly, intentionally or unintentionally (Article 69) and liquids in general, to the sewerage network. The Executive Regulations (Decree 44/2000) in Article 14 details the physical/chemical standards that should be complied with. Solid Waste Article 37 of Law 4/1994, articles 38 and 39 of its Executive Regulations, and Law 38 of 1967, amended by Law number 31 of 1976, deal with the collection, transportation, and safe disposal of solid wastes. Hazardous and Dangerous Wastes Articles 29 to 32 of Law 4/1994 provide regulations for the handling and storage of hazardous materials, including hazardous waste. Article 33 of Law 4/1994 specifies that all precautions must be taken when handling or storing hazardous material in any form (i.e.: gaseous, liquid, or solid). Articles 35 to 36 address the responsibility of companies in ensuring safety of workers against chemical risks. Articles 26, 31, and Decree 211/2003 of Minister of Man-power & immigration, specify conditions for the storage of flammable material, fuel, raw material, products and equipment. 4.2 Solid Waste Management Related Laws Egypt has no stipulated solid waste management law however Law 38/1967 on General Public Cleaning and their amendments are the main legislation enforcing the establishment of solid waste management.
  • 36. Page 33 of 112 4.2.1 Law number 38 of 1967, General Public Cleansing Law 38/1967 on General Public Cleansing is the primary law governing the management of solid waste in Egypt. It was enacted in 1967 and replaced all previous laws dealing with solid waste including Law 97/1956 on Organization of Garbage Collection and Transfer, Law 159/1953 on Cleansing Public Squares, Streets and Highways, and Law 151/1947 on Cleansing Fences and Unused Areas. Since 1967, it has been amended four times. In 1968, the Minister of Housing (MoH) issued the executive regulations for the law (MoH 134/1968). 4.2.2 Law Number 4 of 1994 and its amendments Law 9/2009, Environment Law Law 4 /1994 on the Environment and its amendments in Law 9/2009 are the over-riding environmental laws for Egypt. Article 3 of the Presidential Decree issuing Law 4/1994 repeals all provisions of other laws running counter to the provisions of Law 4/1994. One article in Law 4/1994 addresses general solid waste management and another addresses the management of construction and demolition debris. In addition, five articles address hazardous waste management. 4.2.3 Law Number 48 of 1982, Protection of the River Nile and its Canals Law 48/1982 is the law for protection of the Nile and its canals. The executive regulations for Law 48/1982 were issued by Minister of Irrigation Decree Number 8 of 1983 (MoI 8/1983). The law and its executive regulations and amendments in January 2013 by ministerial decision 92/2013 is primarily focus on wastewater discharges to the Nile and its canals, but also contain articles that include solid waste. 4.2.4 Laws Concerning Public Ways Two laws concerning public ways, such as highways, streets, and squares, Law 140/1956, Occupation of Public Ways and Law 84/1968, Concerning Public Ways, contain restrictions on solid waste management and disposal. 4.3 Laws on WEEE Management Egypt has listed WEEE is under the category of the hazardous waste list issued by the Ministry of Industry (decision 165/2002), item 16. As WEEE is identified as hazardous waste by the aforementioned decision articles addressing hazardous waste management in law 4/94 regulate it Following table provides a summary the laws/regulations stated above and influence it has on WEEE management process 4.4 Laws Influencing WEEE Recycling Industry There is no law on WEEE in Egypt. Following are the laws that have impact on the WEEE industry of the country
  • 37. Page 34 of 112 4.4.1 Age of Imports A decree restricting the imports of old EEE equipment with exception of some EEE goods conditional it is not longer than 5 years from day of production. Decree 603 of year 2007 of the Ministry of Trade and Industry amending parts of the Executive Regulations of the Law of Import and Export and the operational procedures for inspection of goods. 4.4.2 Second Hand Telecommunication Equipment Import Law No.10 of 2003 provides in Article 46 prohibits the import of used telecommunication equipment for purpose of trading 4.4.3 WEEE Import Decree 165 of year 2002 of ministry of industry prohibits the importing of WEEE 4.4.4 The Egyptian Law of Auction The Egyptian Law of Auction is Law 89 for 1998 about Tenders and Auctions. It is only enforced over the public sector and the governmental sectors. This law does not apply to the private sector; otherwise, it is only the company's policy to undergo an auction. 4.5 Social Laws 4.5.1 Law Number 137 of 1981, Labor Law Law 137/1981 requires employers to inform employees of the dangers associated with handling solid waste and requires employers to provide safety equipment and training to employees handling solid waste. This law is enforced the Ministry of Manpower. 4.5.2 Child Labor Egypt has ratified both ILO (International Labor organization) conventions No. 138 (minimum age Convention) and ILO convention No. 182 (convention concerning the prohibition and immediate action for the elimination of the worst forms of child labor). 4.5.3 Freedom of Association Article 55 of Egypt’s 1971 constitution guarantees freedom of association and Article 56 of the constitution guarantees the right to unionize, however in practice these rights are heavily restricted. 4.6 Institutional Framework of Solid Waste Management Institutional framework in Egypt works over three phases. First phase is national scale policy and planning where the Central Government is affiliated with this task. Second phase is implementation,
  • 38. Page 35 of 112 where in case polices dealing with environment and waste, A steering committee Ministry of Environment (MoE), Ministry of Local Development and Ministry of Finance are affiliated with this task. Last phase which is the operation, either the governorates are responsible for all the activities by itself and can contract private enterprise or the municipalities responsible for implementation of the system, monitoring, inspection and trainings.
  • 39. Page 36 of 112 4.7 Governmental Bodies Affiliated with WEEE Management Table 5. Governmental bodies related to WEEE management Entity Note Ministry of Environment (MoE) Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency (EEAA) Waste Management Regulatory Authority (WMRA) Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency is the executive arm of the Ministry of Environment Ministry of Communication and Information Technology (MCIT) The MCIT and MoE have signed Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) in February 2010 to launch the Egyptian Green ICT Strategy. MCIT and MoE have conducted several initiatives to introduce WEEE management principles. The MCIT is keen to address the WEEE management in the green ICT strategy Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI) Egyptian National Cleaner Production Center (ENCPC) The Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI) established the Egypt National Cleaner Production Centre (ENCPC) in 2005 in close cooperation with the United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO) with the aim to promote green technologies, revolutionize current national and local practices and transfer the required knowledge for environmental friendly industries. Ministry of Finance The auction of absolute EEE in public organizations is regulated and supervised by the Ministry of Finance. Furthermore, The Egyptian Customs Authority as part of Ministry of Finance inspect and monitors the flow of electric and electronic equipment in and out of Egypt National Telecom Regulatory Authority (NTRA) NTRA requires importers of telecommunication equipment to manage safely telecommunication electronic14 waste in order to issue them permit. This is intercepted through Waste Tracking Form, where telecommunication equipment importers require submitting annually. NTRA accepts the following ways of safely managing electronic waste: Sending the waste to Nasreya hazardous landfill, delivering the electronic waste to WEEE management firms (e.g. ITG) and selling of telecommunication electronic waste in public auctions. General Authority of Government Services (GAGS) The GAGS auctions the movable and immovable property of administrative body and public authorities after being authorized by those entities, in order to eliminate the problem of overstock and scrap (this includes electronic waste). Also, the GAGS auctions goods and commodities that are obsolete or confiscated by customs. Hazardous Waste Management Unit (HWMU) in Nasreya recycling and disposal center It was established as part of Finnish Egyptian cooperation for the design and construction of hazardous waste treatment system where the Governor of Alexandria issued a decree No.416 in 2000 to establish a unit of hazardous management. The project constitute of two phases, Phase I of the facility includes a secure landfill and solar evaporation ponds to receive wastes, and Phase II includes mechanical and chemical treatment, solidification, and interim storage. 14 Includes but not limited to: mobiles, telephones, radio telephones, telephone systems, IP cameras
  • 40. Page 37 of 112 Table 6.Laws with influence on WEEE management Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles 1. Egyptian National Regulations relevant to WEEE Law of the Environment No. 4/1994 and its amendments by law number 9/2009 and its executive regulations Law 4/1994 and its executive regulations represent the main regulation concerned with environment issues in Egypt. The law addresses managing of the different types of waste including solid waste, construction waste and hazardous waste. The law does not address or mention WEEE of any type. The Law however addresses wastes in a clear manner and implicitly addresses WEEE among other types of wastes described as hazardous and dangerous Law 4/1994 and its executive regulations also contain provisions requiring environmental impact assessment of establishments, control of air and noise emissions from establishments, and worker safety. The law requires the ministers, each in his field of competence, to issue in coordination with the Minister of Health and EEAA a table of the hazardous substances and waste referred in paragraph one of article 29 Provisions related to hazardous waste  Under the law of the environment WEEE is considered a form of hazardous waste.  As well as determining the obligations of producers of hazardous wastes.  Stipulations of the law are related to the conditions and requirements for the management and treatment of hazardous wastes in general which are applicable for WEEE in this case. Provisions related to import of hazardous waste  Article 32 of law 4/1994 forbids to import hazardous waste or to allow its introduction into or its passage through Egyptian territories. It is forbidden without a permit from the competent authority to allow the passage of ships carrying hazardous waste in territorial seas or in the exclusive maritime economic zone of Egypt.  Relevant international conventions signed by Egypt are applicable in this concern. i.e. Basel convention which controls the transboundary movement of hazardous wastes and their disposal. As mandated in Article 4 not to allow the export of hazardous wastes or other wastes to a State or group of States belonging to an economic and/or political integration organization that are Parties, particularly Local authorities  They are empowered to enforce Law 4/1994 and its executive regulations that address solid waste management. EEAA  EEAA is responsible for approving sites for treatment, burning and disposal of solid waste  EEAA is granting permission for transportation of hazardous waste.  Implementing the specifications for solid waste containers and collection vehicles. Other Ministers  Ministers (within their respective scope), and in coordination with the Minister of Health and the Environmental Affairs Agency, are responsible to issue a list of hazardous materials. Judicial officers  Local government authorities are granted the right to enforce Law 4/1994, by the Minister of Justice decree number 1353 (MoJ 1353/1996) including governor’s
  • 41. Page 38 of 112 Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles developing countries, which have prohibited by their legislation all imports, or if it has reason to believe that the wastes in question will not be managed in an environmentally sound manner, according to criteria to be decided on by the Parties at their first meeting represents the legal base for prohibition of importing hazardous waste. In which, this can represent the legal base to limit the importing of some hazardous waste.  Executive regulation number 338/1995, amended by decrees 1095/2011 and 964/2015, stipulates that handling of hazardous wastes requires prior permit from EEAA. It also specifies the documentation, procedures, and conditions for obtaining the permit. As well as the general requirements and procedures for the collection, storage, transportation, treatment, disposal of hazardous wastes (articles 29 to 30 of the law and 25-33 of the executive regulation). Provisions related to requirements for waste treatment facilities  Provisions related to EIA (articles 12, 20, 21 and 23) for waste management facilities are applicable to facilities that will be working with WEEE such as recycling and composting plants, medical waste treatment facilities, and sanitary landfills. Hence these regulations are also relevant. Provisions related to waste treatment and deputies, town mayors, district and village heads, and the managers of environment offices in the governorates. Article 103 of Law 4/1994 gives every citizen and organization concerned with the protection of the environment the right to report violations of the law to competent authorities.
  • 42. Page 39 of 112 Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles disposal  Law 4/1994 and its executive regulations prohibit disposing or treating garbage and solid waste anywhere except in an area designated by the local authorities.  This law prohibits burning of solid waste (article 37 of the law and 35 of the executive regulations). Prohibition is absolute for open burning, but allows incineration, provided it meets the specifications in the regulations. Provision related to safe work environment and protection of environment from pollutant  Law 4/1994 article 34 to 47 requires WEEE treatment facility to comply with national permissible level of emissions. Law number 38 of 1967, General Public Cleansing (amended by law 31/1976, Law 209/1980, Law 177/1981, and Law 129/1982) Law 38/1967 on General Public Cleansing is the primary law governing the management of solid waste in Egypt. It was enacted in 1967 and replaced all previous laws dealing with solid waste including Law 97/1956 on Organization of Garbage Collection and Transfer, Law 159/1953 on Cleansing Public Squares, Streets and Highways, and Law 151/1947 on Cleansing Fences and Unused Areas. Since 1967, it has been amended four times. In 1968, the Minister of Housing (MoH) issued the executive regulations for the law (MoH 134/1968).  Law 38 of 1967 and its executive regulations prohibit placing solid waste anywhere except in an area designated by the local council.  This prohibition applies to treatment and disposal of solid waste as well as to temporary placement in an undesignated container.  Law 38/1967 authorizes the local council to impose a fee on building inhabitants of not more than two percent of their rent to fund solid waste management. This fee, along with all fines collected for violation of Law 38/1967, must be placed in a  The law and its regulations require the local government authority responsible for general cleansing or a contractor licensed by the local authority to collect, transfer, and dispose of solid waste in accordance with the specifications in the executive regulations as well as those of the local council.  If a local authority contracts solid waste services, the contractor is responsible for the actions of the garbage collectors it hires. General Cleansing
  • 43. Page 40 of 112 Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles general cleansing fund established by the local council. The fund must be used for general cleansing. These funds can be augmented by funds from the general budget to insure adequate funding for solid waste management.  Law 38/1967 also requires owners of open land to remove accumulated waste and keep the land cleansed. The executive regulations authorize the local authority to remove solid waste from open land at the owner’s expense, if the owner does not do so within 15 days after notification.  Article 1 in Presidential Decree Number 272 of 1982 (PD 272/1982) transferred jurisdiction for general cleansing from the Ministry of Housing to local administrative units. Law Number 48 of 1982, amended by ministerial decree (92/2013) concerning the Protection of the River Nile and its Canals Law 48/1982 is the law for protection of the Nile river, canals and drains as well as ground water. The executive regulations for Law 48/1982 were issued by Minister of Irrigation Decree Number 8 of 1983 (MoI 8/1983). The law and its executive regulations and amendments in January 2013 by ministerial decision 92/2013 is primarily focus on wastewater discharges to the Nile river, canals and drains, but also contain articles that prohibit disposal of solid waste close to the banks. Both Law 48/1982 and its executive regulations prohibit the disposal of solid waste in the Nile, canals and drains. The executive regulations extend this prohibition to the temporary or permanent placement of solid wastes on the banks of the Nile and its canals. The executive regulations define solid wastes as solid materials (including refuse, garbage, sweeping materials, dry rubbish, fractured stons, construction and demolition debris, and workshop scraps) generated by individuals, residential units, non-residential units (governmental, commercial, industrial, tourist), and means of transportation. Article 19 of Law 48/1982 authorizes Irrigation Engineers in the Ministry of Irrigation to enforce the law within their jurisdictions. Article 13 assigns the Water Police of the Ministry of Interior with the responsibility to assist the implementing authorities in identifying violations of Law 48/1982, informing violators, and removing the causes of violations. Laws Concerning Public Roads Two laws concerning public ways, such as highways, streets, and squares, Law 140/1956, Occupation of Public Ways and Law 84/1968, Concerning Public Ways, contain restrictions on solid waste management and disposal. Law 84/1968 prohibits placing solid wastes on public ways. Law 140/1956 and its executive regulations, issued by Minister of Municipal and Rural Affairs (MoMRA) Decree number 395 of 1956 (MoMRA 395/1956), deal primarily with granting licenses for occupation of public ways within the borders of areas with local councils. One
  • 44. Page 41 of 112 Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles of the activities that require a license is placement of construction and demolition debris in a public way. Law Number 12/2003 Labor Law Law 137/1981 requires employers to inform employees of the dangers associated with handling solid waste and requires employers to provide safety equipment and training to employees handling solid waste. This law mandates all workers handling WEEE to wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE). Law 12/2013 also prohibits child labor. This law is enforced by the Ministry of Manpower. Ministerial Decree 770/2005 and Decree 603 of year 2007– Issued by the Minister of Trade and Industry During 2005, the Minister of Trade and Industry has issued a decree prohibiting importing personal computers that are older than 5 years (instead of 10 years in the previous decrees). Decree 603 of year 2007 restricting the imports of old EEE equipment with exception of some EEE goods conditional it is not longer than 5 years from day of production. This Ministerial Decree 770/2005 of the import regulations of the Customs Law allows importing used Computer sets and assistant hardware provided that their production date is not later than five years, which results in importing computer sets with lifetime almost at end. Telecommunications law number 10/2003 Law No.10 of 2003 provides in Article 46 that it is “It is prohibited to import used Telecommunication Terminal Equipment for the purpose of trading” The definition of the telecommunication equipment here is telecommunication equipment used by a user to connect with a public or private telecommunication network. The Egyptian Law of Auction (law 89/1998) The Egyptian Law of Auction is Law 89 for 1998 about Tenders and Auctions. Governmental and public institutions are obligated to do tenders and auctions in accordance to law 89/1998. As there is no particular environmental sound management/requirement on auctions for obsolete items/WEEE that participants require adhering to, this subjects WEEE auctions vulnerable to informal sector collection. This law does not apply to the private sector; otherwise, it is only the company's policy to undergo an auction Ministerial Decree No. In relation to the General Conditions Disposal of solid wastes in a safely manner.
  • 45. Page 42 of 112 Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles 380/1975 issued by the Ministry of Housing and Development of Industrial and Commercial Establishments, and Other Establishments Adversely Affects Health and Dangerous. Determining the location of the establishments the activity of which adversely affects the safety of housing areas. Ministerial decree 165 of year 2002 by the Ministry of Industry and Trade List of hazardous waste15 pertinent to the Ministry of Industry and Industrial Development that prohibit importing of the hazardous waste stipulated in the list to Egypt. Egypt Green ICT strategy Reducing the adverse environmental impacts related to the use of Telecommunications and Information Technologies equipment  The policy aims to mainstream green ICT with all sectors to help wise management of Egypt's resources and provide innovative solutions to enhance the quality of life of the Egyptians.  The strategy calls for ensuring the sustainable management of WEEE 2. International Regulations relevant to WEEE Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal The Rotterdam Convention on multilateral agreement to promote shared responsibilities in relation to the international trade of certain hazardous chemicals Determination of the categories and characteristics of hazardous wastes. Stipulations on minimizing the generation of hazardous wastes. Stipulations on the environmentally sound management of hazardous wastes. Prohibition of exporting hazardous wastes to contracting parties in specific cases. Prohibition of importation of hazardous wastes in specific cases. Regulations and obligations relating to the transportation and transboundary movement of hazardous wastes. The Nairobi Declaration on the Environmentally Sound Management of Electrical and Electronic Waste and decision IX/6 adopted by the ninth meeting of the Conference of the Parties gave a mandate to the Secretariat to implement a work plan for the environmentally sound management of WEEE. Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Key elements of the Convention include the requirement that 15 http://www.nasreya.com/List1Ar.html
  • 46. Page 43 of 112 Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles Pollutants (POPs) is an international environmental treaty that aims to eliminate or restrict the production and use of persistent organic pollutants (POPs). developed countries provide new and additional financial resources and measures to eliminate production and use of intentionally produced POPs, eliminate unintentionally produced POPs where feasible, and manage and dispose of POPs wastes in an environmentally sound manner. Precaution is exercised throughout the Stockholm Convention, with specific references in the preamble, the objective, and the provision on identifying new POPs. Egypt has ratified the convention on 02/05/2003 Bamako Convention on the Ban of the Import into Africa and the Control of Transboundary Movement and Management of Hazardous Wastes within Africa Prohibition of importation of hazardous wastes. Prohibition of dumping hazardous wastes at sea and internal waters. Determination of the hazardous wastes categories and characteristics. Stipulations on environmentally sound management of hazardous wastes. Stipulations on minimizing the generation of hazardous wastes. Regulations and obligations relating to the transportation and transboundary movement of hazardous wastes. International Labor Organization (ILO) convention No. 138 and convention No.182 Egypt has ratified ILO convention No.138 and No.182, which mandates minimum age for working and prohibits and immediate action for elimination of the worst forms of child labor respectively. 2004 - Ratification of the Identification of used products/articles allowed for import.
  • 47. Page 44 of 112 Law or Regulation Main Content Influence on WEEE management process Institutional Roles Ban Amendment. 2004 - Ratification of Bamako Convention. 2006 - Ratification of hazardous waste protocol of Barcelona Convention. Development of trade policies and regulations. Egypt commitments at CTE/WTO Egypt-EU Partnership Agreement/ Egypt-EU Free Trade Agreement. Continuous determination of industry needs (secondary raw materials e.g. used plastics, paper, glass…) Limitation of imports of used e-products. Specific measure to protect local manufacture of EEE. (quality control, efficiency, incentives..…)
  • 48. Page 45 of 112 5 Stakeholder Assessment Overview There is no formal legislation to manage and enforce WEEE management in Egypt. Electronic waste is majorly dealt by informal sector, after extracting the recyclable streams it is generally either burned or thrown into landfills/dump sites in slums such as Manshiet Nasser, mokattam or Dewei’a. Over time, harmful emissions start to affect the people who are living near those landfills. In the absence of serious national programs for WEEE management, along with decreasing cost of buying new technologies especially mobile phones and personal computers and the surge in perceptive obsolescence due to better technologies introduced in market, it is anticipated that more WEEE will be disposed in such dumpsites/landfills and unknown fate. The life cycle chain of the EEE/WEEE will assist in identifying the stakeholders connecting different phases of the life cycle of the electrical and electronic equipment. The following chain reflects the life cycle of the electric and electronic equipment in Egypt. It is a five-step value chain covering the following: 1. EEE production/import: Electrical and electronic equipment imported into the country or manufactured within the country. 2. EEE sales: Electrical and Electronic equipment in the market, ready for sales to end user. 3. EEE consumption: Consumption by households, private and public entities. 4. WEEE generation: The end of useful use of EEE and disposing to collectors/merchants. 5. Re-use / down cycle: Disposed EEE, which can be fixed or refurbished for second hand consumer 6. WEEE treatment/ Re-cycle: Applied process to EEE (e.g. dismantling) to extract useful fractions. 7. Secondary raw material: Specific fractions, which are reused as a feedstock for other industries (e.g. copper, plastics, iron and etc..) 8. Secondary raw material: Fractions such as electric boards, which are exported to other countries e.g. Belgium Figure 2. Life cycle chain of EEE/WEEE
  • 49. Page 46 of 112 5.1 Manufacturers and Imports Personal Computers and Computer Monitors The International Telecommunication Union (ITU) country's ICT profile for 2013 indicates that 45.1 % of Egyptian households have computers and the official statistics show household PC penetration reached 51.8% in Egypt at the end of 2013. 36.8 % of individuals are using a computer in 201416 . In this study, it is assumed that the computer's monitors in use are directly proportional to the desktop computer penetration rate in the country. According to BMI market research Company in 2012, personal computer's (PC) penetration is expected to grow 20% by 2015 with annual personal computer sales that can reach 500,000 pieces. This goes in line with Egypt’s IT sustained initiatives to leverage personal computer's penetration, one of such major initiatives is the “Computer for Every Student” and “PC for Every Home”. Households represents 20-25% of the computer annual sales17 There is not thorough quantification of CRT and LCD computer monitors installed in household, but CRT production was seized in 2009/2010 in many parts of the world due to the environmental hazardous it imposes and the surge of LCD monitor technology. The last CRT factory in Europe was closed on the 28th of September 201218 and it is assumed that that CRT monitors were no longer put in the market since 2009. The following graph illustrates the number of computer monitors imported to Egypt by the Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics 16 Egypt Information Technology Report Q1 2016, BMI Research Firm 17 Egypt Information Technology Report Q4 2011, BMI Research Firm 18 http://www.crtsite.com/page3-2.html, retrieved August 15, 2016 Figure 3.Computer Screen units Import. Display unit (x1000). Source: CAPMAS 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 ComputermonitorunitsImport(x1000) Year Year Computer monitor units import 2006 131007 2007 287251 2008 297973 2009 405005 2010 422588 2011 444689 2012 1090339 2013 914530 2014 400500 2015 290137 Imports of year 2015 is not final