SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 24
Download to read offline
BRIC Case Analysis 1
BRIC Emerging Economies
Lisa M. Hammond
February 14, 2012
MBA-575-MBOL1 Global Business Management
BRIC Case Analysis 2
The four original BRIC economies have each traveled different paths to open
markets. Russia was catapulted, China planned, Brazil embraced, and India
serendipitously. The BRIC economics, Brazil, Russia, India and China, comprise almost
2.9 billion people or 42 percent of the world’s population. Their collective land area
covers more than a quarter of the world over three continents, and account for more
than 25 percent of global GDP.
A country’s population, demographics, infrastructure and education, among other
factors, directly affect the potential size of its economy and its capacity to function as an
engine of global economic growth and development.
The rapid development of telecommunications has had a profound effect on
consumers. Previously undeveloped markets could prevent information infiltration
through autocratic media control and isolationism. However with today’s technology
even censorship is inadequate. As manufacturers multinationals seek new markets to
source cheaper resources and grow revenue, those previously isolated and
undeveloped countries can no longer contain information and knowledge exchange.
However, many of these emerging markets still have great swaths of their
population mired in poverty. It is those countries who are investing in infrastructure
development, such as energy distribution, education, potable water, transportation, etc.
that will more rapidly reap the benefits of globalization. The economies that have a great
divide between wealth and subsistence run the risk of dissension and pressures from
the masses to redistribute resources and create equality.
BRIC Case Analysis 3
Brazil
In terms of history, Brazil is the baby of the BRIC’s. Brazil was colonized by
Portugal in 1500 and her history is replete with military coups. Brazil’s current status as
a republic is less than 20 years old. Brazil does not command the population size of
China or India, and although wealthy in natural resources, her geography poses
transportation challenges.
“Roughly one-third of Brazil's 8.5 million square kilometers is composed of vast
tracts of challenging jungle, with the Amazon Basin being the most intractable of
all. While there are many potential opportunities to exploit minerals, they come
with daunting infrastructure costs” (Mauldin, 2011).
Brazil’s geography has resulted in very few major highways and railways.
However, most of Brazil’s arable land lay in the interior where access requires massive
amounts of capital to build roads. At the time of Portuguese settlement, it was the rich
Portuguese who built oligarchic plantation farms often in excess of 1,000 kilometers
from Brazil's ports. The Portuguese were “the only people who had the capacity to
"build" Brazil [because they] entered the country with their own pre-existing fortunes”
(Mauldin, 2011). The Oligarchs continue to wield great influence with Brazil’s
development and perpetuate a state of inequality. According to the UNDP's 2010
Human Development Report for Latin America and the Caribbean, Brazil ranks tenth in
the world's most unequal countries. “Failing education systems lie at the very heart of
this problem” (Herbert, 2010).
BRIC Case Analysis 4
Education is the cornerstone of developing a skilled labor force. But
“the problem is that Brazil’s educational system is in disarray. In the Organization
of Economic Cooperation and Development’s tests of academic performance
given every three years to 15-year-olds in 57 nations, Brazilian students finished
fourth from the bottom in science and third from the bottom in math” (Downie,
2008).
The average Brazilian worker has six years of schooling. Although Brazil has
made enormous advances with school enrollment, this is largely due to “Brazil's very
effective program, Bolsa Família, which pays poor families if their children attend
school. This fund has pushed children off the street and into the school room, while also
providing the poorest with a well-needed form of income support” (Herbert, 2010).
However, enrollment does not mean learning. Brazil has an average illiteracy
rate of 12 percent, with 27 percent of those over 50 years of age illiterate.
Human capital is an important determinant of a region’s economic growth. “Data
on growth of income per person … reveals that at least one important measure of skills
that is consistently correlated with future growth is education” (Lacker, 2007). However,
Brazil’s education system is under-funded, inefficient and of poor quality. Therefore, “in
an era of global competition, the current state of education in Brazil means it is likely to
fall behind other developing economies in the search for new investment and economic
growth opportunities" (Herbert, 2010).
“The lack of civil and construction engineers threatens infrastructure projects
[and] companies are turning to foreign labor because there are not enough qualified
Brazilians to go around” (Downie, 2008). Marcos Coelho, president of the administrative
BRIC Case Analysis 5
council at Esteio, an engineering firm that conducts topographic studies had to reduce
the size of his company, stating due to the dearth of qualified labor.
Brazil began economic transformation in earnest in 1994 with the election of
President Cardoso. However it was during his tenure as Minister of Foreign Affairs that
“he began the transformation … by introducing a plan to curb the hyperinflation which
for decades had been the single most destructive force in Brazil’s political economy”
(Bradley, 2008).
Cardoso served two terms and was replaced by President Lula in 2002. Lula and
“his adviser’s saw the value, especially to the poor, of low inflation and a stable, growing
economy” (Bradley, 2008). Lula continued Cardoso’s economic practices including
“floating exchange rate, budget surpluses (before debt payments), inflation targeting
and central bank independence” (Bradley, 2008).
Dilma Rousseff, Brazil’s new president and Lula’s former chief of staff, has
vowed to continue to fight poverty and boost economic stability. However, the main
challenges to Brazil’s continued growth will be strengthening her fragile democracy,
improving poor infrastructure, and the ever present threat of inflation. “Although Brazil
enjoys a big overall trade surplus … most of its exports are of commodities (mainly iron
ore, soya beans and crude oil). It has a big deficit in manufacturing” (Brazil's Trade
Policy: Seeking Protection, 2012). Commodity prices are subject to the vicissitudes of
the market and transporting goods from the interior to port is usually done by truck,
these “logistics costs can be as high as 20 percent of GDP” (de Ferranti, 2004, p. 264).
Domestic consumption drives Brazil's GDP as its large population becomes more
prosperous, making the country the world's tenth largest economy. “Over 60% of
BRIC Case Analysis 6
Brazil's GDP is driven by domestic consumption” (INVESTMENT TRUSTS: Belief in
Brazils domestic miracle, 2011, p. 37). However, Brazil’s rising current-account deficit
may suggest that domestic demand is rising too fast. This may be attributed to “the
legacy of inflation [where] consumers still save less than in many other countries and
[may be] one reason for lower levels of investment in Brazil” (Smith, 2011, p. 56). A
widening current-account deficit can indicate overheating as domestic demand
outpaces supply
The economic reforms of the last 20 years have assisted Brazil’s economic
growth rate. However, tight labor markets will impair the sustainability of growth. Brazil’s
unemployment rate of 6.1 percent is well below its ten-year average, and credit is
outpacing GDP by an alarming margin. “core inflation (excluding food and energy) … is
a worrying 5.5% in Brazil . Where growth is bumping up against capacity constraints
and labor markets are tight, wages are accelerating, [and] inflation may spill over into
prices (Economics Focus: Some Like It Hot, 201).
Brazil’s manufacturers have been hobbled by a strong currency, high interest
rates, high taxes, poor infrastructure and a poorly educated workforce. “Brazil faces a
big competitive challenge, and the relationship with China only dramatizes that,”
(Brazil's Trade Policy: Seeking Protection, 2012)
China is influencing Brazil in three ways.
“The first is direct competition for market share in Brazil. The Chinese yuan is de
facto pegged to the dollar, so Brazilian goods are now even less competitive
versus Chinese goods on the domestic. Second, China is engaging in indirect
competition for market share by shipping goods into Brazil via other Mercosur
BRIC Case Analysis 7
member states — a fact that has prompted Brazil to raise non-tariff barriers that
penalize Mercosur partners in an effort to stem Chinese competition. Third, the
Chinese are among those international investors whose cash is pushing the
value of the real ever upward. With every dollar the Chinese invest into Brazilian
commodity production, the real goes just a bit higher and Chinese goods edge
out their Brazilian counterparts just a bit more” (Mauldin, 2011).
It is imperative that Brazil address its internal deficiencies of infrastructure,
education, and continued political stability, before it finds China cannibalizing Brazil’s
trade surplus and wielding its influence with commodity pricing. Additionally, industry
wants to see fewer taxes, cheaper energy, less bureaucracy and better transport
networks, says Paulo Skaf, FIESP’s president. On these things the government is
moving far too slowly, if at all
Brazil’s public debt is almost 55 percent of GDP. Strong reliance on short-term
funding and/or floating-interest-rate debt instruments exposes governments to a
worsening in overall financial market conditions and potentially a funding crisis. “Brazil
faces large annual roll-over needs at around 8.6% of GDP” (Becker, 2011). Although
Brazil requires low external roll-over due to a low share of external debt, Brazil’s internal
debt funding has come at the price of crowding out indigenous investment.
Russia
Russia, once part of the Soviet Union, was a centrally planned, communist
country. The socialist system is based on a very specific set of comprehensive
institutions that give precise orders for what is to be done, when, how and where. For
example, the State gives orders to
BRIC Case Analysis 8
“the grain producers telling them what to produce, where to send the grain, [and]
what to do with the grain. This very comprehensive system is based not on
vested interest but on power … if you withdraw power from the system, the
Communist Party, the KGB, the fear, … you will be confronted with complete
economic collapse” (Kreisler, 1996).
When the Soviet Union collapsed and all mechanisms failed, the result was no food, no
electricity, and no paychecks for soldiers,
With the collapse of the Soviet Union, the country was faced with systemic
challenges. The collapse was not merely political, but plunged the entire county into
economic chaos where “all the mechanisms of microeconomic regulation [failed]”
(Kreisler, 1996). In order to address the most immediate problems of inefficient money
and the food supply, Russia rapidly introduced a central bank, established a zero-import
tax, and opened the markets to allow trade to “everybody, anyplace, without any
restrictions” (Kreisler, 1996)
It was critical to start the Russian economy moving and create the preconditions
for stable economic growth. Yeltsin’s advisors understood that to implement reforms
and create an efficient and stable market economy, was critical to reducing the
possibilities of radical nationalists to use the pressing problems to grab power in
Moscow.
“By 1990, Gorbachev was cautiously promoting a market economy including the
individual's right to possess private property… [and] religious freedoms.
Meanwhile, contacts with the outside world, especially the west, began to
intensify. [Glasnost revealed the atrocities of Stalin] and Perestroika and glasnost
BRIC Case Analysis 9
also revealed the widespread ecological damage the Soviets had caused on the
environment. Gorbachev's reforms polarized opinion in ways that even
Gorbachev and his stalwart supporters could never have foreseen. All that
restructuring and all that openness had increased the diversity of opinions and in
the end, led to little more than nationalist and ethnic in-fighting” (Kreis, 2009)
“Since 1998, Russia has enjoyed robust growth and foreign debt has fallen from
64% of gross domestic product (GDP) to 10%” (RUSSIA: The rising star of the east,
2006, p. 30). Lower foreign debt has resulted in Russia investing an estimated “21.9%
of GDP” (Russia World Fact Book, 2012).
However, corruption is still rife, and “the shadow economy accounts for
30% of GDP, legal protection of ownership is shaky and businesses find themselves
forced to deal regularly with multiple levels of government just to function” (RUSSIA:
The rising star of the east, 2006, p. 30). Without enforcement mechanisms to combat
corruption and lowering all trade barriers, GDP will not reflect the Russia’s true
economic performance.
Russia holds 38 percent of the world’s natural resources. These
resources represent 80 percent of Russia’s exports, and like Brazil are
subject to price volatility.
However, Russia’s proximity to China, and China’s growing energy consumption
provide “clear benefits: Russia's energy companies secure a stake in China, which is
set to become the world's biggest energy consumer within five years, according to the
International Energy Agency in Paris. And for China, Russia provides a safer, more
BRIC Case Analysis 10
direct source for gas and oil than either the Persian Gulf or the Horn of Africa {Russia
and china: An old alliance hinges on energy, 2009)
The Chinese and Soviet relations have warmed significantly since the fall of the
Soviet Union. Through this evolving relationship, the two powers recently
commemorated the 10th anniversary of the China-Russia Treaty of Good-
Neighbourliness, Friendship and Cooperation and are pursuing a five-point agenda to
boost Beijing-Moscow ties.
A significant point on the 2011 agenda is that “the two sides should strengthen
local cooperation, speed up infrastructure construction for cross-border highways,
railways, bridges, power grids, oil and gas pipelines and telecommunication and
promote border trade, as well as explore the possibility of establishing a border
economic zone” (Chinese vice premier prepares five-point agenda to boost Beijing-
Moscow ties, 2011).
As China's energy demands are expected to climb steeply over the next two
decades, Russia provides a convenient supply of the resources needed. China “now
gets 70% of its power from coal-fired generation and just 3% from cleaner-burning
natural gas. China has rich coal resources, but the material is generally of low quality
and contributes heavily to the country's severe air pollution” (Russia and china: An old
alliance hinges on energy, 2009).
The Russian educational system has achieved nearly 100 percent literacy. “The
Russian labor force, amounting to nearly 76 million workers in 2010, is undergoing
tremendous changes. Although well educated and skilled, it is largely mismatched to the
rapidly changing needs of the Russian economy” (Russian Federation Profile, 2011).
BRIC Case Analysis 11
Russia’s population is the smallest of the BRICs at 143 million. Furthermore,
“The death rate is twice the birth rate and in the next 50 years the population is
projected to drop to 100 million or below” (Marketing Week, 2006, p. 30). Population
shrinkage poses unique problems for Russia given its current export market of natural
resources which can be labor intensive. Innovation’s in harvesting and extraction will be
critical to continue the mining of the resources, and develop industries requiring highly
skilled and efficient labor.
In 2011, Russia reported a trade surplus equivalent to 17.4 Billion USD. Natural
resources including metals and energy make up more than 80 percent of Russia's
exports. But like Brazil, natural resources are subject to price volatility and Russia’s
disproportionate reliance could create economic instability with market swings.
Russia's long-term challenges include a shrinking workforce, a high
level of corruption, and poor infrastructure in need of large investments.
Although Russia’s relationship with China to build infrastructure along their
borders will aid in transporting energy commodities to China, Russia still
needs to address broader infrastructure needs to effectively compete on the
global stage.
India
Although India is one of the world’s oldest civilizations, British rule of India did not
formally end until1947. After independence India’s economic growth was slow. The
State seized control of the economy and all actions of business needed permission.
Business expansion needed a license. Foreign exchange required an industrial license
BRIC Case Analysis 12
to expand. “The government effectively controlled everything through a series of
interlocking controls” (Williamson, 2006).
During the early 1990’s Manmohan Singh was the finance minister of India and
pursued microeconomic liberalization. Singh eliminated many of the business controls,
“the requirements to obtain permission from the Capital Issues Committee to raise new
money, and the ban on foreign direct investment” (Williamson, 2006). Singh’s initial
actions were to eliminate the quantitative trade restrictions, reduced tariffs, modernize
the tax system and pursue divestiture of public sector ownership. Singh’s policies
resulted in growth and a decline in poverty.
At the outset of independence from Britain, India recognized the need for post
war industrial development and established the Indian Institute of Technology in 1950.
The serendipitous result is “India's large English-speaking and information technology
competent workforce has lent strength to its growing international economic might. It
has already made headway in the knowledge-intensive IT industry services sector that
contributes largely to its export earnings” (Taking advantage of India’s economic boom,
2010).
Although India has made an indelible imprint on technology services, education
for the masses is still a problem. A small elite minority receive excellent education, but
the poor and women may not receive any. Part of difficulty with distributing educational
services is due to corruption.
“Transparency International India "India Corruption Study 2008" has estimated
that below poverty line households spent over 883 crore paying bribes of which
Rs.223 crore were paid by the poorest to avail 11 basic public services such as
BRIC Case Analysis 13
hospital, education and water that they are entitled to. Nearly two-thirds of these
below poverty households could not avail of basic public services, school
education and electricity because they could not pay [the] bribe or use contact or
influence to avail of service” (Ray, 2011).
However, 25 percent of the population lives below the poverty level and PPP is at
3,582 US dollars in December of 2010. India’s PPP is the lowest of the BRIC
economies and less than half of China’s.
Education is critical to innovation and India’s future development. Poverty will
drag on resources and civil strife is always a risk. India’s literacy rate is improving and
reached 74 percent in 2011, a “9.2 percent increase from 2001” (Census: India's literacy
rate rises by 9.2 pc , 2011). However, India needs to continue to make strides to take
advantage of its young and growing labor market.
This high level of inequality and a great section of the country not participating in
prosperity may impair the government’s ability to pursue further economic changes that
will capture more of the global marketplace.” If the government fails to convince these
sections of society that high growth will benefit them (by providing the resources for
vastly improved health and education facilities, access to markets by better roads etc)
… then these voters could be very reluctant to sanction change in the future” (India -
robust long-term growth prospects, 2010).
Another major concern is the country's infrastructure. “While the government is
fully aware of the huge importance of dramatically increasing this over the next decade
(increased electricity production, more ports, roads, airports and other civil engineering
infrastructure) to help facilitate the hoped-for increase in private sector activity,
BRIC Case Analysis 14
obstacles to this could come from either political problems or from a lack of finance”
(India - robust long-term growth prospects, 2010). “As a result of India's chronic
infrastructure deficit, logistics costs are as high as 13-14% of GDP, considerably higher
than 8% in United States” (Ray, 2011)
India is attractive to foreign investors, who see the potential size of the domestic
market. However, the indication of pent up demand needs to be tempered with the high
degree of poverty at 25 percent
“A range of imposing hurdles lie along India's path to development, including the
need to transform its swelling population of young people into a skilled pool of labor”
(India can use diversity, 2006). And developing an expansive infrastructure network to
reduce logistics expenses and tap into the burgeoning populations of the rural citizenry.
China
China has witnessed thousands of years of cultural continuity. China’s strategies
span decades, if not centuries, and she is presently pursuing her 12th
Five-Year-Plan.
China's First Five-Year Plan (1953-57), was characterized by efforts to achieve
industrialization, collectivization of agriculture, and political centralization. Planning is a
key characteristic of China’s historically centralized, communist economy. Although
China has moved to a more market oriented economy, long term planning is a central
tenet. “China is a long term oriented society in which persistence and perseverance are
normal” (Hofstede, 2012). This is most evident in her planning. As a highly collectivist
culture people act in the interests of the group and not necessarily of themselves. This
high degree of obedience to authority and centuries of enculturation have provided
BRIC Case Analysis 15
China with citizens that are “influenced by formal authority and sanctions” (Hofstede,
2012).
China is the third largest country in the world with a land mass in excess of 9.4
million sq km, and is slightly larger than the U.S. China boasts a population of 1.3 billion
people, the most populous country in the world.
China’s economic transformation is the result of a combination of structural and
politically based factors, a complex web of education, demographics, and enculturation.
China requires nine years of compulsory education and has achieved a 92.2 percent
literacy rate. Only 2.8 percent of China’s population is below poverty.
China is at the forefront of a massive infrastructure investment in order to
capitalize on her extensive labor pool and either connect the masses to the cities or
build manufacturing enclaves near dense populations centers.
China’s 12th five-year plan calls for “raising household disposable income by 7
percent a year; thus the government may urge large state-owned enterprises to
increase wages across the board, which would pressure other companies to follow suit”
(Wale, 2012). Through raising disposable income, China expects to increase domestic
demand. However, the Chinese are a risk adverse culture and increasing disposable
income may not translate into additional spending. Additional incentives to spend may
be necessary to reduce its high domestic savings rate and generate demand.
As with China’s planning, China applies the same reiterative process to
innovation. When the Chinese have an idea, they test it in the marketplace, rather than
spending resources to test theory. “The Chinese view is that it’s not going to be perfect,
and they’re not trying to make it perfect from day one. They’ve got a few more series of
BRIC Case Analysis 16
improvements to go, and they’ll work on them in parallel with finding out what the
customer really likes and adapting to that. That’s an innovative way of doing innovation,
something that the rest of the world is struggling to understand” (Wale, 2012).
China’s “Prowess in innovation will not only become an increasingly important
differentiator inside China but should also yield ideas and products that become serious
competitors on the international stage” (Orr, 2012).
China has become quite adept at acquiring intellectual property through bartering
access and partnering with multinationals desirous of access to her markets. However,
China’s ultimate goal is to reduce dependence on foreign technologies, as delineated in
“a new, two-pronged initiative that will increase the pressure on global
companies to share their IP with Chinese partners. The first part involves
stepped-up investments and new policy directives that will advance large, next-
generation technology platforms such as cloud computing, the Internet of Things,
and hybrid electric vehicles. These three markets represent tens of billions of
dollars in opportunities for global and domestic semiconductor companies. The
second part sets targets for indigenous innovation, with the goal of reducing
dependence on foreign technologies to 30 percent, from the current 50 percent.
Government purchases of products and services, from mobile phones to cloud-
computing networks, will favor products that incorporate high levels of
domestically developed technology. (Wale, 2012)
This strategy may advantage China, but will not bode well for the long term
prospects of selling to China. China already has a $27. 2 Billion USD trade surplus and
mainly imports commodities. However with China’s ever developing relations with
BRIC Case Analysis 17
Russia, even commodity imports may be curtail. Furthermore, through satisfying
domestic demand internally, China’s surplus will only grow. But this strategy rings well
with Chinese companies who “are now moving to the forefront of a “built in China, for
China” movement”. (Orr G. , 2012)
The China-Russia strategic partnership of cooperation is unique, important to
both parties and sound for their combined global economic development.
“Deepening political cooperation, economic and trade cooperation, scientific and
technological cooperation, humanities cooperation, and security cooperation
between China and Russia is not only of utmost importance to the vital interests of
both countries but is of great significance for the maintenance of peace and stability
in the Eurasian region and the whole world” (Premier Wens at China-Russia
Economic Trade Forum, 2008).
China is the only emerging nation among all the BRICs that seems destined to
convert itself into a dominant economy, as well as a technological and military power.
(de Almeida, 2009)
China’s methodical and meticulous planning, coupled with her growing alliance
with Russia, provide a glimpse into her longer term objectives. The coming years will
most likely see China power its way up the value-added chain and develop its huge
domestic market to become an even more vital global player.
Conclusion
. Although Russia and Brazil are benefiting from high commodity prices, their need
to invest these proceeds into infrastructure and long-term economic development is
crucial to securing their position on the global stage. With a caveat that Russia’s
BRIC Case Analysis 18
developing alliance with China may bolster her commodities market due to China’s high
demand.
There are fundamental differences between “China and India on one hand, and
Russia and Brazil on the other , in that the former are competing with the west for
"intellectual capital" by seeking to build top- notch universities, investing in high, value-
added and technologically intensive industries and utilizing successful diasporas to
generate entrepreneurial activity in the mother country. Chinese officials, for example,
are committed to developing 100 world-class universities, with a focus on science and
engineering” (Lloyd, 2006, p. 17).
“To date, the scale of China’s economy and pace of its development has out-
distanced those of its BRIC peers. China alone contributed more than half of the BRIC
countries’ share and greater than 15 percent of the growth in world economic output
from 2000 to 2008” (Shappell, 2011).
China’s discipline and methodical and meticulous planning, coupled with her
numerous entrées into both emerging and developed markets and her strategic
partnering with Russia, provide a glimpse into her longer term objectives. The coming
years will most likely see China power its way up the value-added chain and develop its
huge domestic market to become an even more vital global player.
BRIC Case Analysis 19
References
Becker, S. (2011, Jan 21). Public debt in 2020:Structure Matters. Retrieved Feb 10,
2012, from Deutshe Bank Research:
http://www.dbresearch.com/PROD/DBR_INTERNET_EN-
PROD/PROD0000000000268770.pdf
Bradley, F. (2008, July). Brazil: The Best Investment in the BRIC Countries?
Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from Bradley, Foster & Sargent Quarterly Market
Commentary: http://www.bfsinvest.com/pdf/2_2008.pdf
Brazil's Trade Policy: Seeking Protection. (2012, Jan 12). Retrieved Feb 10, 2012,
from The Economist: http://www.economist.com/node/21542780
Census: India's literacy rate rises by 9.2 pc . (2011, Mar 31). Retrieved FEb 11,
2012, from IBN Live: http://ibnlive.in.com/news/indias-literacy-rate-rises-by-
92-per-cent/147643-3.html
China World Fact Book. (2012, Jan 10). Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from Central
Intelligenct Agency: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-
factbook/geos/ch.html
Chinese vice premier prepares five-point agenda to boost Beijing-Moscow ties.
(2011, Oct 11). BBC Monitoring Asia Pacific, pp. n/a. Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/896
974507?accountid=4870
de Almeida, P. (2009). The BRICs Role in the Global Economy. Trade and
Internation Negotiations for Journalists , 146-154.
BRIC Case Analysis 20
de Ferranti, D. (2004). Brazil: equitable, competitive, sustainable. Washington, DC:
The World Bank.
Downie. (2008, July 2). Wanted: Skilled Workers for a Growing Economy in Brazil .
Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from The New York Times:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/02/business/worldbusiness/02real.html?pag
ewanted=all
Economics Focus: Some Like It Hot. (201, Jun 30). Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from
The Economist: http://www.economist.com/node/18895150
Economics Focus: Some Like It Hot. (2011, Jun 30). Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from
The Economist: http://www.economist.com/node/18895150
Herbert, S. (2010, Sept 27). Can Brazil learn from its success? Retrieved Feb 10,
2012, from The Guardian:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/cifamerica/2010/sep/27/brazil
History of Indian Institute of Technology. (n.d.). Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from Indian
Institute of Technology: http://www.iitkgp.ac.in/institute/history.php
Hofstede, G. (2012). Geert Hofstede National Cultures. Retrieved Feb 11, 2012,
from Geert Hofstede: http://geert-hofstede.com/china.html
India can use diversity, democracy to mitigate risks to growth. (2006, Nov 27). Info -
Prod Research (Middle East), pp. 1-1. Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/457
294124?accountid=4870
India - robust long-term growth prospects provided that large budget deficit is
reduced and the benefits of growth are more widely shared across society.
BRIC Case Analysis 21
(2010). Oxford, United States, Oxford: Oxford Economics Ltd. Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/197
476759?accountid=4870
India World Fact Book. (2012, Feb 6). Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from The Central
Intelligence Agency: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-
factbook/geos/in.html
INVESTMENT TRUSTS: Belief in Brazils domestic miracle. (2011). Fund Strategy,
(14723042), 37-37. Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/846
913038?accountid=4870
Kreis, S. (2009, Aug 4). 1989: The Walls Came Tumbling Down. Retrieved Feb 12,
2012, from The HIstory Guide: Lectures on 20th Century Europe:
http://www.historyguide.org/europe/lecture16.html
Kreisler, H. (1996, Nov 20). From Central Planning to Markets: Guiding the
Transformation of the Russian Economy. Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from
Institute of International Studies, UC Berkeley :
http://globetrotter.berkeley.edu/conversations/Gaidar/gaidar-con4.html
Lacker, J. (2007, July 27). Early Childhood Development and Economic Growth.
Governor'sSummit on Early Childhood Education . Richmond, VA.
Lloyd, J. and Turkeltaub, A. (2006, Dec 04), India and China are the Only Real
BRICS in the Financial Times, pp. 17-17. Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/249
974238?accountid=4870
BRIC Case Analysis 22
Mauldin, J. (2011, July 14). The Geopolitics of Brazil: An Emergent Power’s Struggle
with Geography. Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from Stratfor:
http://www.johnmauldin.com/outsidethebox/the-geopolitics-of-brazil-an-
emergent-powers-struggle-with-geography/
Orr, G. a. (2012, Feb). A CEO's Guide to Innovation in China. Retrieved FEb 11,
2012, from McKinsey Quarterly:
http://www.mckinseyquarterly.com/Strategy/Innovation/A_CEOs_guide_to_in
novation_in_China_2919
Orr, G. (2012, Feb). What's in store for China in 2012? Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from
McKinsey Quarterly:
https://www.mckinseyquarterly.com/Whats_in_store_for_China_in_2012_292
5
Premier Wens Speech at China-Russia Economic, Trade Forum. (2008, Oct 30).
BBC Monitoring Asia Pacific, pp. n/a. Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/460
806755?accountid=4870
Ray, G. (2011). Doing business in India: Opportunities and challenges. Journal of
Marketing Development and Competitiveness, 5(4), 77-95. Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/902
574950?accountid=4870
Russia and China: An old alliance hinges on energy. (2009, Sep 19). South Asian
Media Net, pp. n/a. Retrieved from
BRIC Case Analysis 23
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/698
563701?accountid=48
RUSSIA: The rising star of the east. (2006). Marketing Week, (01419285), 30-30.
Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/228
167008?accountid=4870
Russia World Fact Book. (2012, Jan 9). Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from Central
Intelligence Agency: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-
factbook/geos/rs.html
Russian Federation Profile. (2011, Nov 2). Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from U.S.
Department of State: http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/3183.htm
Shappell, B. (2011). History ready to repeat? Business Credit, 113(6), 18-21.
Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/872
082924?accountid=4870
Smith, T. (2011). Brazil: More than just a resource play. Investment Week, , 56-56.
Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/905
164014?accountid=4870
Taking advantage of India's economic boom. (2010, Oct 31). The Financial Express,
pp. n/a. Retrieved from
http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/761
186267?accountid=4870
BRIC Case Analysis 24
Williamson, J. (2006). The Rise of the Indian Economcy. American Diplomacy:
Commentary and Analysis. Philadelphia: Foreign Policy Research Inst.
.

More Related Content

What's hot

Failed governments of pt (workers party) in brazil
Failed governments of pt (workers party) in brazilFailed governments of pt (workers party) in brazil
Failed governments of pt (workers party) in brazilFernando Alcoforado
 
How demographic change affects development
How demographic change affects developmentHow demographic change affects development
How demographic change affects developmentAshikurRahman177
 
South african welfare state and the demographic dividend's window of opportunity
South african welfare state and the demographic dividend's window of opportunitySouth african welfare state and the demographic dividend's window of opportunity
South african welfare state and the demographic dividend's window of opportunityFabio Torreggiani
 
Analysis of HRD Problems in the Developing Country
Analysis of HRD Problems in the Developing CountryAnalysis of HRD Problems in the Developing Country
Analysis of HRD Problems in the Developing CountryTri Widodo W. UTOMO
 
Jamestown Latin America | Trends+Views | Brazil: Aiming for a Return to Grow...
Jamestown Latin America | Trends+Views |  Brazil: Aiming for a Return to Grow...Jamestown Latin America | Trends+Views |  Brazil: Aiming for a Return to Grow...
Jamestown Latin America | Trends+Views | Brazil: Aiming for a Return to Grow...Ferhat Guven
 
Brazil poverty and inequality. Where to next?
Brazil poverty and inequality. Where to next?Brazil poverty and inequality. Where to next?
Brazil poverty and inequality. Where to next?Oxfam Brasil
 
83171062 case-study-on-starbucks
83171062 case-study-on-starbucks83171062 case-study-on-starbucks
83171062 case-study-on-starbuckshomeworkping3
 
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIA
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIATHE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIA
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIAalimoses282
 
The inevitable impeachment of dilma rousseff
The inevitable impeachment of dilma rousseffThe inevitable impeachment of dilma rousseff
The inevitable impeachment of dilma rousseffFernando Alcoforado
 
The Brazil Opportunity: A Guide for Marketers
The Brazil Opportunity: A Guide for Marketers The Brazil Opportunity: A Guide for Marketers
The Brazil Opportunity: A Guide for Marketers Karen Sanchez
 
BelizePopulationBrief
BelizePopulationBriefBelizePopulationBrief
BelizePopulationBriefIlse Munoz
 
Youth Unemployment and Poverty in Nigeria: Effective Social Protection as a P...
Youth Unemployment and Poverty in Nigeria: Effective Social Protection as a P...Youth Unemployment and Poverty in Nigeria: Effective Social Protection as a P...
Youth Unemployment and Poverty in Nigeria: Effective Social Protection as a P...ijtsrd
 

What's hot (20)

Failed governments of pt (workers party) in brazil
Failed governments of pt (workers party) in brazilFailed governments of pt (workers party) in brazil
Failed governments of pt (workers party) in brazil
 
How demographic change affects development
How demographic change affects developmentHow demographic change affects development
How demographic change affects development
 
South african welfare state and the demographic dividend's window of opportunity
South african welfare state and the demographic dividend's window of opportunitySouth african welfare state and the demographic dividend's window of opportunity
South african welfare state and the demographic dividend's window of opportunity
 
Analysis of HRD Problems in the Developing Country
Analysis of HRD Problems in the Developing CountryAnalysis of HRD Problems in the Developing Country
Analysis of HRD Problems in the Developing Country
 
Jamestown Latin America | Trends+Views | Brazil: Aiming for a Return to Grow...
Jamestown Latin America | Trends+Views |  Brazil: Aiming for a Return to Grow...Jamestown Latin America | Trends+Views |  Brazil: Aiming for a Return to Grow...
Jamestown Latin America | Trends+Views | Brazil: Aiming for a Return to Grow...
 
Essay 3; example
Essay   3; exampleEssay   3; example
Essay 3; example
 
Brazil poverty and inequality. Where to next?
Brazil poverty and inequality. Where to next?Brazil poverty and inequality. Where to next?
Brazil poverty and inequality. Where to next?
 
83171062 case-study-on-starbucks
83171062 case-study-on-starbucks83171062 case-study-on-starbucks
83171062 case-study-on-starbucks
 
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIA
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIATHE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIA
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIA
 
Oecd forum 2012_report
Oecd forum 2012_reportOecd forum 2012_report
Oecd forum 2012_report
 
Brazil6 Forbes
Brazil6 ForbesBrazil6 Forbes
Brazil6 Forbes
 
The inevitable impeachment of dilma rousseff
The inevitable impeachment of dilma rousseffThe inevitable impeachment of dilma rousseff
The inevitable impeachment of dilma rousseff
 
EB-5 Presentation
EB-5 Presentation EB-5 Presentation
EB-5 Presentation
 
Brazil7 Forbes
Brazil7 ForbesBrazil7 Forbes
Brazil7 Forbes
 
The Brazil Opportunity: A Guide for Marketers
The Brazil Opportunity: A Guide for Marketers The Brazil Opportunity: A Guide for Marketers
The Brazil Opportunity: A Guide for Marketers
 
Fear won hope in brazil
Fear won hope in brazilFear won hope in brazil
Fear won hope in brazil
 
BelizePopulationBrief
BelizePopulationBriefBelizePopulationBrief
BelizePopulationBrief
 
Brazil towards ungovernability
Brazil towards ungovernabilityBrazil towards ungovernability
Brazil towards ungovernability
 
Poverty and Decent Work- The Effects of Globalization
Poverty and Decent Work- The Effects of GlobalizationPoverty and Decent Work- The Effects of Globalization
Poverty and Decent Work- The Effects of Globalization
 
Youth Unemployment and Poverty in Nigeria: Effective Social Protection as a P...
Youth Unemployment and Poverty in Nigeria: Effective Social Protection as a P...Youth Unemployment and Poverty in Nigeria: Effective Social Protection as a P...
Youth Unemployment and Poverty in Nigeria: Effective Social Protection as a P...
 

Viewers also liked

3 eso. unidad_19._conceptos_de_lexicologia_y_semantica
3 eso. unidad_19._conceptos_de_lexicologia_y_semantica3 eso. unidad_19._conceptos_de_lexicologia_y_semantica
3 eso. unidad_19._conceptos_de_lexicologia_y_semanticaleidy katherine becerra garcia
 
Houston Economy at a glance
Houston Economy at a glanceHouston Economy at a glance
Houston Economy at a glanceMagda Knop
 
Pharyngitis oleh virus dan jamur
Pharyngitis oleh virus dan jamurPharyngitis oleh virus dan jamur
Pharyngitis oleh virus dan jamurMuch Ikbal
 
Cad newsletter april
Cad newsletter aprilCad newsletter april
Cad newsletter aprilRene Jack
 
CareerFair_banner_pns_small
CareerFair_banner_pns_smallCareerFair_banner_pns_small
CareerFair_banner_pns_smallRene Jack
 
Fearless Five - Unique Opportunity Deck
Fearless Five - Unique Opportunity DeckFearless Five - Unique Opportunity Deck
Fearless Five - Unique Opportunity DeckSteve Johnson
 
B2b newsletter_april
B2b newsletter_aprilB2b newsletter_april
B2b newsletter_aprilRene Jack
 
Resume-Rahul Ragit
Resume-Rahul RagitResume-Rahul Ragit
Resume-Rahul RagitRahul Ragit
 
Cmp pilot 2 b summary
Cmp pilot 2 b summaryCmp pilot 2 b summary
Cmp pilot 2 b summaryBarry Woods
 
Post911_Banner_PNS
Post911_Banner_PNSPost911_Banner_PNS
Post911_Banner_PNSRene Jack
 

Viewers also liked (12)

3 eso. unidad_19._conceptos_de_lexicologia_y_semantica
3 eso. unidad_19._conceptos_de_lexicologia_y_semantica3 eso. unidad_19._conceptos_de_lexicologia_y_semantica
3 eso. unidad_19._conceptos_de_lexicologia_y_semantica
 
Conheça as principais diretivas do php.ini
Conheça as principais diretivas do php.iniConheça as principais diretivas do php.ini
Conheça as principais diretivas do php.ini
 
Houston Economy at a glance
Houston Economy at a glanceHouston Economy at a glance
Houston Economy at a glance
 
Pharyngitis oleh virus dan jamur
Pharyngitis oleh virus dan jamurPharyngitis oleh virus dan jamur
Pharyngitis oleh virus dan jamur
 
Cad newsletter april
Cad newsletter aprilCad newsletter april
Cad newsletter april
 
CareerFair_banner_pns_small
CareerFair_banner_pns_smallCareerFair_banner_pns_small
CareerFair_banner_pns_small
 
Texas
TexasTexas
Texas
 
Fearless Five - Unique Opportunity Deck
Fearless Five - Unique Opportunity DeckFearless Five - Unique Opportunity Deck
Fearless Five - Unique Opportunity Deck
 
B2b newsletter_april
B2b newsletter_aprilB2b newsletter_april
B2b newsletter_april
 
Resume-Rahul Ragit
Resume-Rahul RagitResume-Rahul Ragit
Resume-Rahul Ragit
 
Cmp pilot 2 b summary
Cmp pilot 2 b summaryCmp pilot 2 b summary
Cmp pilot 2 b summary
 
Post911_Banner_PNS
Post911_Banner_PNSPost911_Banner_PNS
Post911_Banner_PNS
 

Similar to BRIC_Case_Analysis_Hammond

THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIA
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIATHE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIA
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIAalimoses282
 
Investing In Brazil (1)
Investing In Brazil (1)Investing In Brazil (1)
Investing In Brazil (1)Naeem Iqbal
 
January 2012 - Brazil’s fiscal dilemma
January 2012 - Brazil’s fiscal dilemmaJanuary 2012 - Brazil’s fiscal dilemma
January 2012 - Brazil’s fiscal dilemmaFGV Brazil
 
The disastrous dilma rousseff government in brazil
The disastrous dilma rousseff government in brazilThe disastrous dilma rousseff government in brazil
The disastrous dilma rousseff government in brazilFernando Alcoforado
 
The government and the financial system united against the progress of brazil
The government and the financial system united against the progress of brazilThe government and the financial system united against the progress of brazil
The government and the financial system united against the progress of brazilFernando Alcoforado
 
3 BRAZIL STRATEGY_DRAFT( 3)
3 BRAZIL STRATEGY_DRAFT( 3)3 BRAZIL STRATEGY_DRAFT( 3)
3 BRAZIL STRATEGY_DRAFT( 3)Denise DeSanto
 
Globalisation (Brazil) Speech
Globalisation (Brazil) SpeechGlobalisation (Brazil) Speech
Globalisation (Brazil) SpeechJack Bennett
 
October 2010 - Construction takes a great leap forward
October 2010 - Construction takes a great leap forwardOctober 2010 - Construction takes a great leap forward
October 2010 - Construction takes a great leap forwardFGV Brazil
 
Brazil: Doing business Assignment
Brazil: Doing business AssignmentBrazil: Doing business Assignment
Brazil: Doing business AssignmentVishal Gupta
 
The dilma rousseff government and banks united against brazilian people
The dilma rousseff government and banks united against brazilian peopleThe dilma rousseff government and banks united against brazilian people
The dilma rousseff government and banks united against brazilian peopleFernando Alcoforado
 
November 2011 - Brazil: World’s breadbasket
November 2011 - Brazil: World’s breadbasketNovember 2011 - Brazil: World’s breadbasket
November 2011 - Brazil: World’s breadbasketFGV Brazil
 
November 2013 - Avoiding the middle-income trap
November 2013 - Avoiding the middle-income trapNovember 2013 - Avoiding the middle-income trap
November 2013 - Avoiding the middle-income trapFGV Brazil
 
The uncontrolled imminent of public debt in brazil and its serious consequences
The uncontrolled imminent of public debt in brazil and its serious consequencesThe uncontrolled imminent of public debt in brazil and its serious consequences
The uncontrolled imminent of public debt in brazil and its serious consequencesFernando Alcoforado
 
External and internal economic vulnerabilities of brazilian economy and how ...
External and internal  economic vulnerabilities of brazilian economy and how ...External and internal  economic vulnerabilities of brazilian economy and how ...
External and internal economic vulnerabilities of brazilian economy and how ...Fernando Alcoforado
 
Inequality matters: BRICS inequalities fact sheet
Inequality matters: BRICS inequalities fact sheetInequality matters: BRICS inequalities fact sheet
Inequality matters: BRICS inequalities fact sheetOxfam Brasil
 

Similar to BRIC_Case_Analysis_Hammond (20)

THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIA
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIATHE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIA
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF BOLSA FAMILIA
 
Brazil_141217_r4
Brazil_141217_r4Brazil_141217_r4
Brazil_141217_r4
 
The end of an illusion
The end of an illusionThe end of an illusion
The end of an illusion
 
Investing In Brazil (1)
Investing In Brazil (1)Investing In Brazil (1)
Investing In Brazil (1)
 
January 2012 - Brazil’s fiscal dilemma
January 2012 - Brazil’s fiscal dilemmaJanuary 2012 - Brazil’s fiscal dilemma
January 2012 - Brazil’s fiscal dilemma
 
The disastrous dilma rousseff government in brazil
The disastrous dilma rousseff government in brazilThe disastrous dilma rousseff government in brazil
The disastrous dilma rousseff government in brazil
 
The government and the financial system united against the progress of brazil
The government and the financial system united against the progress of brazilThe government and the financial system united against the progress of brazil
The government and the financial system united against the progress of brazil
 
brazil
brazilbrazil
brazil
 
3 BRAZIL STRATEGY_DRAFT( 3)
3 BRAZIL STRATEGY_DRAFT( 3)3 BRAZIL STRATEGY_DRAFT( 3)
3 BRAZIL STRATEGY_DRAFT( 3)
 
Globalisation (Brazil) Speech
Globalisation (Brazil) SpeechGlobalisation (Brazil) Speech
Globalisation (Brazil) Speech
 
Brazil
BrazilBrazil
Brazil
 
October 2010 - Construction takes a great leap forward
October 2010 - Construction takes a great leap forwardOctober 2010 - Construction takes a great leap forward
October 2010 - Construction takes a great leap forward
 
Brazil: Doing business Assignment
Brazil: Doing business AssignmentBrazil: Doing business Assignment
Brazil: Doing business Assignment
 
The dilma rousseff government and banks united against brazilian people
The dilma rousseff government and banks united against brazilian peopleThe dilma rousseff government and banks united against brazilian people
The dilma rousseff government and banks united against brazilian people
 
IMSFinalGroupProject
IMSFinalGroupProjectIMSFinalGroupProject
IMSFinalGroupProject
 
November 2011 - Brazil: World’s breadbasket
November 2011 - Brazil: World’s breadbasketNovember 2011 - Brazil: World’s breadbasket
November 2011 - Brazil: World’s breadbasket
 
November 2013 - Avoiding the middle-income trap
November 2013 - Avoiding the middle-income trapNovember 2013 - Avoiding the middle-income trap
November 2013 - Avoiding the middle-income trap
 
The uncontrolled imminent of public debt in brazil and its serious consequences
The uncontrolled imminent of public debt in brazil and its serious consequencesThe uncontrolled imminent of public debt in brazil and its serious consequences
The uncontrolled imminent of public debt in brazil and its serious consequences
 
External and internal economic vulnerabilities of brazilian economy and how ...
External and internal  economic vulnerabilities of brazilian economy and how ...External and internal  economic vulnerabilities of brazilian economy and how ...
External and internal economic vulnerabilities of brazilian economy and how ...
 
Inequality matters: BRICS inequalities fact sheet
Inequality matters: BRICS inequalities fact sheetInequality matters: BRICS inequalities fact sheet
Inequality matters: BRICS inequalities fact sheet
 

BRIC_Case_Analysis_Hammond

  • 1. BRIC Case Analysis 1 BRIC Emerging Economies Lisa M. Hammond February 14, 2012 MBA-575-MBOL1 Global Business Management
  • 2. BRIC Case Analysis 2 The four original BRIC economies have each traveled different paths to open markets. Russia was catapulted, China planned, Brazil embraced, and India serendipitously. The BRIC economics, Brazil, Russia, India and China, comprise almost 2.9 billion people or 42 percent of the world’s population. Their collective land area covers more than a quarter of the world over three continents, and account for more than 25 percent of global GDP. A country’s population, demographics, infrastructure and education, among other factors, directly affect the potential size of its economy and its capacity to function as an engine of global economic growth and development. The rapid development of telecommunications has had a profound effect on consumers. Previously undeveloped markets could prevent information infiltration through autocratic media control and isolationism. However with today’s technology even censorship is inadequate. As manufacturers multinationals seek new markets to source cheaper resources and grow revenue, those previously isolated and undeveloped countries can no longer contain information and knowledge exchange. However, many of these emerging markets still have great swaths of their population mired in poverty. It is those countries who are investing in infrastructure development, such as energy distribution, education, potable water, transportation, etc. that will more rapidly reap the benefits of globalization. The economies that have a great divide between wealth and subsistence run the risk of dissension and pressures from the masses to redistribute resources and create equality.
  • 3. BRIC Case Analysis 3 Brazil In terms of history, Brazil is the baby of the BRIC’s. Brazil was colonized by Portugal in 1500 and her history is replete with military coups. Brazil’s current status as a republic is less than 20 years old. Brazil does not command the population size of China or India, and although wealthy in natural resources, her geography poses transportation challenges. “Roughly one-third of Brazil's 8.5 million square kilometers is composed of vast tracts of challenging jungle, with the Amazon Basin being the most intractable of all. While there are many potential opportunities to exploit minerals, they come with daunting infrastructure costs” (Mauldin, 2011). Brazil’s geography has resulted in very few major highways and railways. However, most of Brazil’s arable land lay in the interior where access requires massive amounts of capital to build roads. At the time of Portuguese settlement, it was the rich Portuguese who built oligarchic plantation farms often in excess of 1,000 kilometers from Brazil's ports. The Portuguese were “the only people who had the capacity to "build" Brazil [because they] entered the country with their own pre-existing fortunes” (Mauldin, 2011). The Oligarchs continue to wield great influence with Brazil’s development and perpetuate a state of inequality. According to the UNDP's 2010 Human Development Report for Latin America and the Caribbean, Brazil ranks tenth in the world's most unequal countries. “Failing education systems lie at the very heart of this problem” (Herbert, 2010).
  • 4. BRIC Case Analysis 4 Education is the cornerstone of developing a skilled labor force. But “the problem is that Brazil’s educational system is in disarray. In the Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development’s tests of academic performance given every three years to 15-year-olds in 57 nations, Brazilian students finished fourth from the bottom in science and third from the bottom in math” (Downie, 2008). The average Brazilian worker has six years of schooling. Although Brazil has made enormous advances with school enrollment, this is largely due to “Brazil's very effective program, Bolsa Família, which pays poor families if their children attend school. This fund has pushed children off the street and into the school room, while also providing the poorest with a well-needed form of income support” (Herbert, 2010). However, enrollment does not mean learning. Brazil has an average illiteracy rate of 12 percent, with 27 percent of those over 50 years of age illiterate. Human capital is an important determinant of a region’s economic growth. “Data on growth of income per person … reveals that at least one important measure of skills that is consistently correlated with future growth is education” (Lacker, 2007). However, Brazil’s education system is under-funded, inefficient and of poor quality. Therefore, “in an era of global competition, the current state of education in Brazil means it is likely to fall behind other developing economies in the search for new investment and economic growth opportunities" (Herbert, 2010). “The lack of civil and construction engineers threatens infrastructure projects [and] companies are turning to foreign labor because there are not enough qualified Brazilians to go around” (Downie, 2008). Marcos Coelho, president of the administrative
  • 5. BRIC Case Analysis 5 council at Esteio, an engineering firm that conducts topographic studies had to reduce the size of his company, stating due to the dearth of qualified labor. Brazil began economic transformation in earnest in 1994 with the election of President Cardoso. However it was during his tenure as Minister of Foreign Affairs that “he began the transformation … by introducing a plan to curb the hyperinflation which for decades had been the single most destructive force in Brazil’s political economy” (Bradley, 2008). Cardoso served two terms and was replaced by President Lula in 2002. Lula and “his adviser’s saw the value, especially to the poor, of low inflation and a stable, growing economy” (Bradley, 2008). Lula continued Cardoso’s economic practices including “floating exchange rate, budget surpluses (before debt payments), inflation targeting and central bank independence” (Bradley, 2008). Dilma Rousseff, Brazil’s new president and Lula’s former chief of staff, has vowed to continue to fight poverty and boost economic stability. However, the main challenges to Brazil’s continued growth will be strengthening her fragile democracy, improving poor infrastructure, and the ever present threat of inflation. “Although Brazil enjoys a big overall trade surplus … most of its exports are of commodities (mainly iron ore, soya beans and crude oil). It has a big deficit in manufacturing” (Brazil's Trade Policy: Seeking Protection, 2012). Commodity prices are subject to the vicissitudes of the market and transporting goods from the interior to port is usually done by truck, these “logistics costs can be as high as 20 percent of GDP” (de Ferranti, 2004, p. 264). Domestic consumption drives Brazil's GDP as its large population becomes more prosperous, making the country the world's tenth largest economy. “Over 60% of
  • 6. BRIC Case Analysis 6 Brazil's GDP is driven by domestic consumption” (INVESTMENT TRUSTS: Belief in Brazils domestic miracle, 2011, p. 37). However, Brazil’s rising current-account deficit may suggest that domestic demand is rising too fast. This may be attributed to “the legacy of inflation [where] consumers still save less than in many other countries and [may be] one reason for lower levels of investment in Brazil” (Smith, 2011, p. 56). A widening current-account deficit can indicate overheating as domestic demand outpaces supply The economic reforms of the last 20 years have assisted Brazil’s economic growth rate. However, tight labor markets will impair the sustainability of growth. Brazil’s unemployment rate of 6.1 percent is well below its ten-year average, and credit is outpacing GDP by an alarming margin. “core inflation (excluding food and energy) … is a worrying 5.5% in Brazil . Where growth is bumping up against capacity constraints and labor markets are tight, wages are accelerating, [and] inflation may spill over into prices (Economics Focus: Some Like It Hot, 201). Brazil’s manufacturers have been hobbled by a strong currency, high interest rates, high taxes, poor infrastructure and a poorly educated workforce. “Brazil faces a big competitive challenge, and the relationship with China only dramatizes that,” (Brazil's Trade Policy: Seeking Protection, 2012) China is influencing Brazil in three ways. “The first is direct competition for market share in Brazil. The Chinese yuan is de facto pegged to the dollar, so Brazilian goods are now even less competitive versus Chinese goods on the domestic. Second, China is engaging in indirect competition for market share by shipping goods into Brazil via other Mercosur
  • 7. BRIC Case Analysis 7 member states — a fact that has prompted Brazil to raise non-tariff barriers that penalize Mercosur partners in an effort to stem Chinese competition. Third, the Chinese are among those international investors whose cash is pushing the value of the real ever upward. With every dollar the Chinese invest into Brazilian commodity production, the real goes just a bit higher and Chinese goods edge out their Brazilian counterparts just a bit more” (Mauldin, 2011). It is imperative that Brazil address its internal deficiencies of infrastructure, education, and continued political stability, before it finds China cannibalizing Brazil’s trade surplus and wielding its influence with commodity pricing. Additionally, industry wants to see fewer taxes, cheaper energy, less bureaucracy and better transport networks, says Paulo Skaf, FIESP’s president. On these things the government is moving far too slowly, if at all Brazil’s public debt is almost 55 percent of GDP. Strong reliance on short-term funding and/or floating-interest-rate debt instruments exposes governments to a worsening in overall financial market conditions and potentially a funding crisis. “Brazil faces large annual roll-over needs at around 8.6% of GDP” (Becker, 2011). Although Brazil requires low external roll-over due to a low share of external debt, Brazil’s internal debt funding has come at the price of crowding out indigenous investment. Russia Russia, once part of the Soviet Union, was a centrally planned, communist country. The socialist system is based on a very specific set of comprehensive institutions that give precise orders for what is to be done, when, how and where. For example, the State gives orders to
  • 8. BRIC Case Analysis 8 “the grain producers telling them what to produce, where to send the grain, [and] what to do with the grain. This very comprehensive system is based not on vested interest but on power … if you withdraw power from the system, the Communist Party, the KGB, the fear, … you will be confronted with complete economic collapse” (Kreisler, 1996). When the Soviet Union collapsed and all mechanisms failed, the result was no food, no electricity, and no paychecks for soldiers, With the collapse of the Soviet Union, the country was faced with systemic challenges. The collapse was not merely political, but plunged the entire county into economic chaos where “all the mechanisms of microeconomic regulation [failed]” (Kreisler, 1996). In order to address the most immediate problems of inefficient money and the food supply, Russia rapidly introduced a central bank, established a zero-import tax, and opened the markets to allow trade to “everybody, anyplace, without any restrictions” (Kreisler, 1996) It was critical to start the Russian economy moving and create the preconditions for stable economic growth. Yeltsin’s advisors understood that to implement reforms and create an efficient and stable market economy, was critical to reducing the possibilities of radical nationalists to use the pressing problems to grab power in Moscow. “By 1990, Gorbachev was cautiously promoting a market economy including the individual's right to possess private property… [and] religious freedoms. Meanwhile, contacts with the outside world, especially the west, began to intensify. [Glasnost revealed the atrocities of Stalin] and Perestroika and glasnost
  • 9. BRIC Case Analysis 9 also revealed the widespread ecological damage the Soviets had caused on the environment. Gorbachev's reforms polarized opinion in ways that even Gorbachev and his stalwart supporters could never have foreseen. All that restructuring and all that openness had increased the diversity of opinions and in the end, led to little more than nationalist and ethnic in-fighting” (Kreis, 2009) “Since 1998, Russia has enjoyed robust growth and foreign debt has fallen from 64% of gross domestic product (GDP) to 10%” (RUSSIA: The rising star of the east, 2006, p. 30). Lower foreign debt has resulted in Russia investing an estimated “21.9% of GDP” (Russia World Fact Book, 2012). However, corruption is still rife, and “the shadow economy accounts for 30% of GDP, legal protection of ownership is shaky and businesses find themselves forced to deal regularly with multiple levels of government just to function” (RUSSIA: The rising star of the east, 2006, p. 30). Without enforcement mechanisms to combat corruption and lowering all trade barriers, GDP will not reflect the Russia’s true economic performance. Russia holds 38 percent of the world’s natural resources. These resources represent 80 percent of Russia’s exports, and like Brazil are subject to price volatility. However, Russia’s proximity to China, and China’s growing energy consumption provide “clear benefits: Russia's energy companies secure a stake in China, which is set to become the world's biggest energy consumer within five years, according to the International Energy Agency in Paris. And for China, Russia provides a safer, more
  • 10. BRIC Case Analysis 10 direct source for gas and oil than either the Persian Gulf or the Horn of Africa {Russia and china: An old alliance hinges on energy, 2009) The Chinese and Soviet relations have warmed significantly since the fall of the Soviet Union. Through this evolving relationship, the two powers recently commemorated the 10th anniversary of the China-Russia Treaty of Good- Neighbourliness, Friendship and Cooperation and are pursuing a five-point agenda to boost Beijing-Moscow ties. A significant point on the 2011 agenda is that “the two sides should strengthen local cooperation, speed up infrastructure construction for cross-border highways, railways, bridges, power grids, oil and gas pipelines and telecommunication and promote border trade, as well as explore the possibility of establishing a border economic zone” (Chinese vice premier prepares five-point agenda to boost Beijing- Moscow ties, 2011). As China's energy demands are expected to climb steeply over the next two decades, Russia provides a convenient supply of the resources needed. China “now gets 70% of its power from coal-fired generation and just 3% from cleaner-burning natural gas. China has rich coal resources, but the material is generally of low quality and contributes heavily to the country's severe air pollution” (Russia and china: An old alliance hinges on energy, 2009). The Russian educational system has achieved nearly 100 percent literacy. “The Russian labor force, amounting to nearly 76 million workers in 2010, is undergoing tremendous changes. Although well educated and skilled, it is largely mismatched to the rapidly changing needs of the Russian economy” (Russian Federation Profile, 2011).
  • 11. BRIC Case Analysis 11 Russia’s population is the smallest of the BRICs at 143 million. Furthermore, “The death rate is twice the birth rate and in the next 50 years the population is projected to drop to 100 million or below” (Marketing Week, 2006, p. 30). Population shrinkage poses unique problems for Russia given its current export market of natural resources which can be labor intensive. Innovation’s in harvesting and extraction will be critical to continue the mining of the resources, and develop industries requiring highly skilled and efficient labor. In 2011, Russia reported a trade surplus equivalent to 17.4 Billion USD. Natural resources including metals and energy make up more than 80 percent of Russia's exports. But like Brazil, natural resources are subject to price volatility and Russia’s disproportionate reliance could create economic instability with market swings. Russia's long-term challenges include a shrinking workforce, a high level of corruption, and poor infrastructure in need of large investments. Although Russia’s relationship with China to build infrastructure along their borders will aid in transporting energy commodities to China, Russia still needs to address broader infrastructure needs to effectively compete on the global stage. India Although India is one of the world’s oldest civilizations, British rule of India did not formally end until1947. After independence India’s economic growth was slow. The State seized control of the economy and all actions of business needed permission. Business expansion needed a license. Foreign exchange required an industrial license
  • 12. BRIC Case Analysis 12 to expand. “The government effectively controlled everything through a series of interlocking controls” (Williamson, 2006). During the early 1990’s Manmohan Singh was the finance minister of India and pursued microeconomic liberalization. Singh eliminated many of the business controls, “the requirements to obtain permission from the Capital Issues Committee to raise new money, and the ban on foreign direct investment” (Williamson, 2006). Singh’s initial actions were to eliminate the quantitative trade restrictions, reduced tariffs, modernize the tax system and pursue divestiture of public sector ownership. Singh’s policies resulted in growth and a decline in poverty. At the outset of independence from Britain, India recognized the need for post war industrial development and established the Indian Institute of Technology in 1950. The serendipitous result is “India's large English-speaking and information technology competent workforce has lent strength to its growing international economic might. It has already made headway in the knowledge-intensive IT industry services sector that contributes largely to its export earnings” (Taking advantage of India’s economic boom, 2010). Although India has made an indelible imprint on technology services, education for the masses is still a problem. A small elite minority receive excellent education, but the poor and women may not receive any. Part of difficulty with distributing educational services is due to corruption. “Transparency International India "India Corruption Study 2008" has estimated that below poverty line households spent over 883 crore paying bribes of which Rs.223 crore were paid by the poorest to avail 11 basic public services such as
  • 13. BRIC Case Analysis 13 hospital, education and water that they are entitled to. Nearly two-thirds of these below poverty households could not avail of basic public services, school education and electricity because they could not pay [the] bribe or use contact or influence to avail of service” (Ray, 2011). However, 25 percent of the population lives below the poverty level and PPP is at 3,582 US dollars in December of 2010. India’s PPP is the lowest of the BRIC economies and less than half of China’s. Education is critical to innovation and India’s future development. Poverty will drag on resources and civil strife is always a risk. India’s literacy rate is improving and reached 74 percent in 2011, a “9.2 percent increase from 2001” (Census: India's literacy rate rises by 9.2 pc , 2011). However, India needs to continue to make strides to take advantage of its young and growing labor market. This high level of inequality and a great section of the country not participating in prosperity may impair the government’s ability to pursue further economic changes that will capture more of the global marketplace.” If the government fails to convince these sections of society that high growth will benefit them (by providing the resources for vastly improved health and education facilities, access to markets by better roads etc) … then these voters could be very reluctant to sanction change in the future” (India - robust long-term growth prospects, 2010). Another major concern is the country's infrastructure. “While the government is fully aware of the huge importance of dramatically increasing this over the next decade (increased electricity production, more ports, roads, airports and other civil engineering infrastructure) to help facilitate the hoped-for increase in private sector activity,
  • 14. BRIC Case Analysis 14 obstacles to this could come from either political problems or from a lack of finance” (India - robust long-term growth prospects, 2010). “As a result of India's chronic infrastructure deficit, logistics costs are as high as 13-14% of GDP, considerably higher than 8% in United States” (Ray, 2011) India is attractive to foreign investors, who see the potential size of the domestic market. However, the indication of pent up demand needs to be tempered with the high degree of poverty at 25 percent “A range of imposing hurdles lie along India's path to development, including the need to transform its swelling population of young people into a skilled pool of labor” (India can use diversity, 2006). And developing an expansive infrastructure network to reduce logistics expenses and tap into the burgeoning populations of the rural citizenry. China China has witnessed thousands of years of cultural continuity. China’s strategies span decades, if not centuries, and she is presently pursuing her 12th Five-Year-Plan. China's First Five-Year Plan (1953-57), was characterized by efforts to achieve industrialization, collectivization of agriculture, and political centralization. Planning is a key characteristic of China’s historically centralized, communist economy. Although China has moved to a more market oriented economy, long term planning is a central tenet. “China is a long term oriented society in which persistence and perseverance are normal” (Hofstede, 2012). This is most evident in her planning. As a highly collectivist culture people act in the interests of the group and not necessarily of themselves. This high degree of obedience to authority and centuries of enculturation have provided
  • 15. BRIC Case Analysis 15 China with citizens that are “influenced by formal authority and sanctions” (Hofstede, 2012). China is the third largest country in the world with a land mass in excess of 9.4 million sq km, and is slightly larger than the U.S. China boasts a population of 1.3 billion people, the most populous country in the world. China’s economic transformation is the result of a combination of structural and politically based factors, a complex web of education, demographics, and enculturation. China requires nine years of compulsory education and has achieved a 92.2 percent literacy rate. Only 2.8 percent of China’s population is below poverty. China is at the forefront of a massive infrastructure investment in order to capitalize on her extensive labor pool and either connect the masses to the cities or build manufacturing enclaves near dense populations centers. China’s 12th five-year plan calls for “raising household disposable income by 7 percent a year; thus the government may urge large state-owned enterprises to increase wages across the board, which would pressure other companies to follow suit” (Wale, 2012). Through raising disposable income, China expects to increase domestic demand. However, the Chinese are a risk adverse culture and increasing disposable income may not translate into additional spending. Additional incentives to spend may be necessary to reduce its high domestic savings rate and generate demand. As with China’s planning, China applies the same reiterative process to innovation. When the Chinese have an idea, they test it in the marketplace, rather than spending resources to test theory. “The Chinese view is that it’s not going to be perfect, and they’re not trying to make it perfect from day one. They’ve got a few more series of
  • 16. BRIC Case Analysis 16 improvements to go, and they’ll work on them in parallel with finding out what the customer really likes and adapting to that. That’s an innovative way of doing innovation, something that the rest of the world is struggling to understand” (Wale, 2012). China’s “Prowess in innovation will not only become an increasingly important differentiator inside China but should also yield ideas and products that become serious competitors on the international stage” (Orr, 2012). China has become quite adept at acquiring intellectual property through bartering access and partnering with multinationals desirous of access to her markets. However, China’s ultimate goal is to reduce dependence on foreign technologies, as delineated in “a new, two-pronged initiative that will increase the pressure on global companies to share their IP with Chinese partners. The first part involves stepped-up investments and new policy directives that will advance large, next- generation technology platforms such as cloud computing, the Internet of Things, and hybrid electric vehicles. These three markets represent tens of billions of dollars in opportunities for global and domestic semiconductor companies. The second part sets targets for indigenous innovation, with the goal of reducing dependence on foreign technologies to 30 percent, from the current 50 percent. Government purchases of products and services, from mobile phones to cloud- computing networks, will favor products that incorporate high levels of domestically developed technology. (Wale, 2012) This strategy may advantage China, but will not bode well for the long term prospects of selling to China. China already has a $27. 2 Billion USD trade surplus and mainly imports commodities. However with China’s ever developing relations with
  • 17. BRIC Case Analysis 17 Russia, even commodity imports may be curtail. Furthermore, through satisfying domestic demand internally, China’s surplus will only grow. But this strategy rings well with Chinese companies who “are now moving to the forefront of a “built in China, for China” movement”. (Orr G. , 2012) The China-Russia strategic partnership of cooperation is unique, important to both parties and sound for their combined global economic development. “Deepening political cooperation, economic and trade cooperation, scientific and technological cooperation, humanities cooperation, and security cooperation between China and Russia is not only of utmost importance to the vital interests of both countries but is of great significance for the maintenance of peace and stability in the Eurasian region and the whole world” (Premier Wens at China-Russia Economic Trade Forum, 2008). China is the only emerging nation among all the BRICs that seems destined to convert itself into a dominant economy, as well as a technological and military power. (de Almeida, 2009) China’s methodical and meticulous planning, coupled with her growing alliance with Russia, provide a glimpse into her longer term objectives. The coming years will most likely see China power its way up the value-added chain and develop its huge domestic market to become an even more vital global player. Conclusion . Although Russia and Brazil are benefiting from high commodity prices, their need to invest these proceeds into infrastructure and long-term economic development is crucial to securing their position on the global stage. With a caveat that Russia’s
  • 18. BRIC Case Analysis 18 developing alliance with China may bolster her commodities market due to China’s high demand. There are fundamental differences between “China and India on one hand, and Russia and Brazil on the other , in that the former are competing with the west for "intellectual capital" by seeking to build top- notch universities, investing in high, value- added and technologically intensive industries and utilizing successful diasporas to generate entrepreneurial activity in the mother country. Chinese officials, for example, are committed to developing 100 world-class universities, with a focus on science and engineering” (Lloyd, 2006, p. 17). “To date, the scale of China’s economy and pace of its development has out- distanced those of its BRIC peers. China alone contributed more than half of the BRIC countries’ share and greater than 15 percent of the growth in world economic output from 2000 to 2008” (Shappell, 2011). China’s discipline and methodical and meticulous planning, coupled with her numerous entrées into both emerging and developed markets and her strategic partnering with Russia, provide a glimpse into her longer term objectives. The coming years will most likely see China power its way up the value-added chain and develop its huge domestic market to become an even more vital global player.
  • 19. BRIC Case Analysis 19 References Becker, S. (2011, Jan 21). Public debt in 2020:Structure Matters. Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from Deutshe Bank Research: http://www.dbresearch.com/PROD/DBR_INTERNET_EN- PROD/PROD0000000000268770.pdf Bradley, F. (2008, July). Brazil: The Best Investment in the BRIC Countries? Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from Bradley, Foster & Sargent Quarterly Market Commentary: http://www.bfsinvest.com/pdf/2_2008.pdf Brazil's Trade Policy: Seeking Protection. (2012, Jan 12). Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from The Economist: http://www.economist.com/node/21542780 Census: India's literacy rate rises by 9.2 pc . (2011, Mar 31). Retrieved FEb 11, 2012, from IBN Live: http://ibnlive.in.com/news/indias-literacy-rate-rises-by- 92-per-cent/147643-3.html China World Fact Book. (2012, Jan 10). Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from Central Intelligenct Agency: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world- factbook/geos/ch.html Chinese vice premier prepares five-point agenda to boost Beijing-Moscow ties. (2011, Oct 11). BBC Monitoring Asia Pacific, pp. n/a. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/896 974507?accountid=4870 de Almeida, P. (2009). The BRICs Role in the Global Economy. Trade and Internation Negotiations for Journalists , 146-154.
  • 20. BRIC Case Analysis 20 de Ferranti, D. (2004). Brazil: equitable, competitive, sustainable. Washington, DC: The World Bank. Downie. (2008, July 2). Wanted: Skilled Workers for a Growing Economy in Brazil . Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from The New York Times: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/02/business/worldbusiness/02real.html?pag ewanted=all Economics Focus: Some Like It Hot. (201, Jun 30). Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from The Economist: http://www.economist.com/node/18895150 Economics Focus: Some Like It Hot. (2011, Jun 30). Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from The Economist: http://www.economist.com/node/18895150 Herbert, S. (2010, Sept 27). Can Brazil learn from its success? Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from The Guardian: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/cifamerica/2010/sep/27/brazil History of Indian Institute of Technology. (n.d.). Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from Indian Institute of Technology: http://www.iitkgp.ac.in/institute/history.php Hofstede, G. (2012). Geert Hofstede National Cultures. Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from Geert Hofstede: http://geert-hofstede.com/china.html India can use diversity, democracy to mitigate risks to growth. (2006, Nov 27). Info - Prod Research (Middle East), pp. 1-1. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/457 294124?accountid=4870 India - robust long-term growth prospects provided that large budget deficit is reduced and the benefits of growth are more widely shared across society.
  • 21. BRIC Case Analysis 21 (2010). Oxford, United States, Oxford: Oxford Economics Ltd. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/197 476759?accountid=4870 India World Fact Book. (2012, Feb 6). Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from The Central Intelligence Agency: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world- factbook/geos/in.html INVESTMENT TRUSTS: Belief in Brazils domestic miracle. (2011). Fund Strategy, (14723042), 37-37. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/846 913038?accountid=4870 Kreis, S. (2009, Aug 4). 1989: The Walls Came Tumbling Down. Retrieved Feb 12, 2012, from The HIstory Guide: Lectures on 20th Century Europe: http://www.historyguide.org/europe/lecture16.html Kreisler, H. (1996, Nov 20). From Central Planning to Markets: Guiding the Transformation of the Russian Economy. Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from Institute of International Studies, UC Berkeley : http://globetrotter.berkeley.edu/conversations/Gaidar/gaidar-con4.html Lacker, J. (2007, July 27). Early Childhood Development and Economic Growth. Governor'sSummit on Early Childhood Education . Richmond, VA. Lloyd, J. and Turkeltaub, A. (2006, Dec 04), India and China are the Only Real BRICS in the Financial Times, pp. 17-17. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/249 974238?accountid=4870
  • 22. BRIC Case Analysis 22 Mauldin, J. (2011, July 14). The Geopolitics of Brazil: An Emergent Power’s Struggle with Geography. Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from Stratfor: http://www.johnmauldin.com/outsidethebox/the-geopolitics-of-brazil-an- emergent-powers-struggle-with-geography/ Orr, G. a. (2012, Feb). A CEO's Guide to Innovation in China. Retrieved FEb 11, 2012, from McKinsey Quarterly: http://www.mckinseyquarterly.com/Strategy/Innovation/A_CEOs_guide_to_in novation_in_China_2919 Orr, G. (2012, Feb). What's in store for China in 2012? Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from McKinsey Quarterly: https://www.mckinseyquarterly.com/Whats_in_store_for_China_in_2012_292 5 Premier Wens Speech at China-Russia Economic, Trade Forum. (2008, Oct 30). BBC Monitoring Asia Pacific, pp. n/a. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/460 806755?accountid=4870 Ray, G. (2011). Doing business in India: Opportunities and challenges. Journal of Marketing Development and Competitiveness, 5(4), 77-95. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/902 574950?accountid=4870 Russia and China: An old alliance hinges on energy. (2009, Sep 19). South Asian Media Net, pp. n/a. Retrieved from
  • 23. BRIC Case Analysis 23 http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/698 563701?accountid=48 RUSSIA: The rising star of the east. (2006). Marketing Week, (01419285), 30-30. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/228 167008?accountid=4870 Russia World Fact Book. (2012, Jan 9). Retrieved Feb 10, 2012, from Central Intelligence Agency: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world- factbook/geos/rs.html Russian Federation Profile. (2011, Nov 2). Retrieved Feb 11, 2012, from U.S. Department of State: http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/3183.htm Shappell, B. (2011). History ready to repeat? Business Credit, 113(6), 18-21. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/872 082924?accountid=4870 Smith, T. (2011). Brazil: More than just a resource play. Investment Week, , 56-56. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/905 164014?accountid=4870 Taking advantage of India's economic boom. (2010, Oct 31). The Financial Express, pp. n/a. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.saintleo.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/761 186267?accountid=4870
  • 24. BRIC Case Analysis 24 Williamson, J. (2006). The Rise of the Indian Economcy. American Diplomacy: Commentary and Analysis. Philadelphia: Foreign Policy Research Inst. .