A quick guide to assessing your organization's position in the digital disruption journey. By Chris Bradley and Clayton OâToole, document from Mc-Kinsey
An Incumbents Guide to Digital Disruption Mc-Kinsey
1. An incumbentâs guide to
digital disruption
Incumbents neednât be victims of disruption if they recognize the
crucial thresholds in their life cycle, and act in time.
by Chris Bradley and Clayton OâToole
A decade ago, NorwegianmediagroupSchibstedmadeacourageous
decision:toofferclassifiedsâthemainrevenuesourceofitsnewspaper
businessesâonlineforfree.Thecompanyhadalreadymadesignificant
Internetinvestmentsbutrealizedthattoestablishapan-Europeandigital
strongholdithadtoraisethestakes.Duringapresentationtoaprospective
Frenchpartner,SchibstedexecutivespointedoutthatexistingEuropean
classifiedssiteshadlimitedtraffic.âThemarketisupforgrabs,âtheysaid,
âandweintendtogetit.â1 Today,morethan80percentoftheirearningscome
fromonlineclassifieds.2
Aboutthatsametime,theboardsofotherleadingnewspaperswerealso
weighingtheprospectofadigitalfuture.Nodoubt,likeSchibsted,theyeven
developedanddebatedhypotheticalscenariosinwhichInternetstart-ups
siphonedoffthelucrativeprintclassifiedadstheindustrycalleditsârivers
ofgold.âMaybethesescenariosappearedinsufficientlyalarmingâormaybe
theyweretoodangeroustoevenentertain.Butveryfewnewspapersfollowed
Schibstedâspath.
1
Raf Weverbergh, â8 lessons in how to disrupt yourself from Schibsted,â Whiteboard, whiteboardmag.com.
2
Annual report, Schibsted, 2015, schibsted.com.
May 2016
3. 3
WHERE YOU ARE AND WHAT YOU NEED
ItmayhelptoviewthesestagesonanS-curve(exhibit).Atfirst,young
companiesstrugglewithuncertaintybutareagileandwillingtoexperiment.
Atthistime,companiesprizelearningandoptionalityandworktoward
creatingvaluebasedontheexpectationoffutureearnings.Thenewmodel
thenneedstoreachsomecriticalmasstobecomeagoingconcern.Asthey
matureâthatis,becomeincumbentsâmind-setsandrealitieschange.The
establishedcompanieslockinroutinesandprocesses.Theyironoutand
standardizevariabilityamidgrowingorganizationalcomplexity.Inthe
questforefficiency,theyweedoutstrategicoptionsandrewardexecutives
forsteadyresults.Themeasureofsuccessisnowdeliveryofconsistent,
growingcashflowsinthehereandnow.Theoption-richexpectancy
offuturegainisreplacedbythetreadmillofcontinuallyescalating
performanceexpectations.
Exhibit
Incumbentâs
business
model
Disruption introduces an incumbent to a new journey.
QWeb 2016
Incumbent response
Exhibit 1 of 2
Disruption is âŠ
Incumbentâs move
Common barrier
Detectable Clear Inevitable New normal
Acuity Action Acceleration Adaptation
Myopia Avoidance
of pain
Inertia Fit
New business
model
Faint signals
with lots of
noise
Emergence
of a validated
model
Critical mass
of adoption
achieved
At scale and
mature
ProïŹt
Time
Decisive
impact
Negligible
impact