SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 38
Download to read offline
Differences between
Q335 and Current
Design
Hussein Mohamed
April 2015
hmohamed@nycsca.org
Contents
• LED Lighting
• D75 Lighting
• Theatrical
Lighting
• Control Systems
• Switches
• Automatic shades
• 2014 NYCECC
Objectives
1. How are we doing? What NGL tells us about the
performance and quality of SCA Luminaires
2. Toward better educational environment for Autistic
Classroom
3. Design code compliant 2014 New York State and
NYC Energy Codes Energy Code
4. Design code compliant Lighting Control relay panel
solutions for automatic sweep off controls.
Lights
Lights - Classroom
• Current Design • Q335
Fluorescent
-Louver lens
-59W
-Not Dimmable
-70 Up/30 Down
-$50/ft
LED
-Flat frosted lens
-30W
-Dimmable
-70 Up/30 Down
-$67/ft
Lights – Classroom
(Example)
• Current Design • Q335
Lights – D75 Classroom
• Current Design • Q335
LED
-Completely indirect (100% up light)
-45W
-Dimmable
-Soft Light (30K)
-Wide Distribution (no hot spots above the
fixture)
-Flicker Free
Regular Classroom
Lights - Corridor
• Current Design • Q335
Fluorescent
-Flat lens
-2’x4’
-59W
-$120
LED
-Arc curved lens
-2’x2’
-40.4W
-$200
Lights – Corridor
(Example)
• Current Design • Q335
Lights - Offices
• Current Design • Q335
Fluorescent
-Parabolic Louvers
-2’x4’
-64W – 96W
-$160/ea
LED
-Flat lens with trim/Convex wings &
articulated center spine
-2’x4’ & 2’x2’
-38W – 75W
-$200/ea-$240/ea
Lights – Offices
(Example)
• Current Design • Q335
Lights - Gymatorium
• Current Design • Q335
HID or Fluorescent
-Open glass reflector
-30 Lumens per Watt (HID)
-45 Lumens per Watt (Fluorescent)
-Not Dimmable
-Long turn-on time
LED
-Drop lens with glare control
-90 Lumens per Watt
-Dimmable
-Instantaneous Turn-On
- Optional Occupancy Sensor (2014 NYCECC)
Lights – Gymnatorium
(Example)
• Q335• Current Design
Lights - Toilets
• Current Design • Q335
Fluorescent
-Prismatic lens
-2’x2’
-64W
-$127/ea.
LED
-Frosted lens
-2’x2’/1’x4’
-30W/4 ft.
-$150/ea.
Lights – Storage/Mechanical
• Current Design • Q335
Fluorescent
-Exposed lamps & reflector
-1’x4’
-64W
-$90/ea.
LED
-Reflective/refractive optics
-1’x4’
-50W
-$150/ea.
Lights - Stairs
• Current Design • Q335
Fluorescent
-Flat lens
-2’x4’
-64W
-$120
LED
-Wall mounted
-6”x3’
-Occupancy + RF
-40.4W
-$200
- 2014 NYCECC
LPD = 45109/83373
=0.54 w/ft²
Lights - LPD
Lights – Theatrical Spotlights
• Current Design • Q335
Tungsten
-Adjustable lens beam and spot
-585W – 10,000 Lumens
-Needs different “gels” to add different
colors
-Dimmable via line voltage dimming
-$300
LED
-Adjustable lens beam and spot
-150W – 8,000 Lumens
-Individually programmable with multiple
colors
-Dimmable via low voltage dimming
-$1000
Lights – Theatrical Border Lights
• Current Design • Q335
Incandescent
-Fixed lens
-75W per lamp x 4 lamps
-Needs different “gels” to add different colors
-Dimmable via line voltage dimming
-$300/4 lamps fixture
LED
-Adjustable lens beam and spot
-150W
-Individually programmable with multiple colors
-Dimmable via low voltage dimming
-$1000
-Reduced number of fixtures
Control
Systems
Switch
General
Outlets
IWB Quad
Master Control
PNL
Room Controller
Teacher
Quad
Control System – Classroom
• Current Design
-2 momentary switches
-2 power packs
-one or more vacancy sensor
-lamp “a” and lamp “b”
controlled separately
-no daylight harvesting
- No dimming
-$500
• Poor light quality (over/under-lit areas)!
o Overlighting wastes money!
o Underlighting compromises safety!
• No dimming – creates jarring shifts in light levels!
• Circuit-level controls not granular enough for
savings or performance requirements!
Toilets Mech./Storage Corridor
Recep. Panel Lighting Panel
CR-1 CR-2
IWBGENERAL V4000
O.S.SPACE
1 2
3
Control System – Classroom
• Q335
• Automatic assessment of ambient light!
• Gradual (imperceptible) adjustment!
• No jarring shifts in light levels!
• Consistent light levels across facility!
• No under-lit/over-lit areas!
-one dimming switches
-one controller for two or four
classrooms
-one or more vacancy sensor
-entire fixture work as one unit
-daylight harvesting
-smooth dimming
-$500
Ceiling Motion Sensor + Power Pack + Manual on Switch
• Manual On – Auto Off
• Manual off switch
4 Walls 1 Door up to 900 sq ft
Occupancy Sensor Switch – Line Voltage
• Manual On – Auto Off
• Manual off switch
4 Walls 1 Door up to 3 Light fixtures
Areas controlled by an occupant-
sensing device (O.S.Space)
1. Three rows of fixtures
2. Dimming switching
3. Vacancy sensing
4. Day light harvesting
5. Automatic Shade
D75 Classroom
Control System - Relay Panel
• Current Design • Q335
36 Circuit Relay Panel
-One relay per each circuit in the lighting
panel
-$1500
24 Circuit Relay Panel
-Selected circuits from the lighting panel.
-Selected circuits from the receptacle panel.
-$1000
Control System - Theatrical Panel
• Current Design • Q335
24 Circuit Dimmer Panel
-Contains dimmer and relay circuits
-DMX cable connect from panel to each
fixture
-$24000
12 Circuit Relay Panel
-Contains only relay circuits
-DMX or 0-10V cable connect from panel to
each fixture.
-$3000
Switches
• Current Design • Q335
Two Gang Low Voltage Switch
-on/off
-two per classroom
-Each switch controls one lamp in row of
fixtures
-Switches communicate with local sensors
in room
-$150
One Gang Low Voltage Dimmer Switch
-on/off, up/down and preset
-one per classroom
-Switch controls dimming of all fixtures in room
with a preset level set in the middle
-Switch communicates with local control panel
connected to local sensors in room.
-$175
Automatic Shades
C402.3.1
Building Envelope Requirements
C402.3.1 Maximum area.
The vertical fenestration area (not including opaque doors
and opaque spandrel panels) shall not exceed 30 percent of
the gross above-grade wall area.
C402.3.1.1 Increased vertical fenestration area with
daylighting controls.
In Climate Zones 1 through 6, a maximum of 40 percent
of the gross above-grade wall area shall be permitted to be
vertical fenestration, provided:
1. No less than 50 percent of the conditioned floor area is
within a daylight zone;
2. Automatic daylighting controls are
installed in daylight zones; and
3. Visible transmittance (VT) of vertical fenestration is
greater than or equal to 1.1 times solar heat gain coefficient
(SHGC).
< 30% Glazing
IECC 2012 – C402.3.1
◘ Prescriptive:
30% Max OR
40% Max when
▫ >50% Conditioned floor
area in daylight zone
▫ Automatic daylighting
control installed
▫ Certain VT requirements
Section 8.4.2
Power - Automatic Receptacle Control
IECC 2012
◘ No requirements
STD. 90.1 – 8.4.2
◘ Mandatory:
50% in offices (private and
open) and computer
classrooms
New York State & NYC
PRECRIPTIVE rather than
mandatory
Section 8.4.2 Power stipulates automatic control
of 50% of receptacles installed in private offices,
open offices and computer classrooms, including
receptacles installed in modular partitions.
50% Switched Load
C405.2.2.1
Automatic time switch control devices.
• Automatic time switch controls shall be installed to control lighting in
all areas of the building. ( Except where you have Occ
Sensors )
Many walls
Many doors
Up to 5000 sq ft per zone
C405.2.2.3
Daylight zone control.
• Switched separately from non-daylit zones
• Up to 2500 sq ft per zone
• Manual controls are acceptable
C405.2.2.3.1 Manual daylighting controls.
Manual controls shall be installed in daylight zones unless automatic controls are
installed in accordance with C405.2.2.3.2 Automatic daylighting controls.
(C405.2.2.3.2 Continuous dimming or multilevel switching)
505.2.2.1
Light Reduction Controls
IECC 2012
◘ Three Categories:
1. Dimming device controlled
space (reduced illumination
by at least 50%)
2. Occupant- sensing devise
controlled space.
3. Automatic time switch
controlled space
(corridor/lobbies, storerooms
and restrooms)
>50% Reduced illumination
1
2
3
Differences between Q335 and Current Design

More Related Content

Similar to Differences between Q335 and Current Design

A case study of intelligent buildings
A case study of intelligent buildingsA case study of intelligent buildings
A case study of intelligent buildingsRajat Nainwal
 
AC Powered Driver Topologies
AC Powered Driver Topologies AC Powered Driver Topologies
AC Powered Driver Topologies ON Semiconductor
 
Museums to Net Zero Buildings - Lessons Learned with LED Lighting
 Museums to Net Zero Buildings - Lessons Learned with LED Lighting  Museums to Net Zero Buildings - Lessons Learned with LED Lighting
Museums to Net Zero Buildings - Lessons Learned with LED Lighting Cindy Foster-Warthen
 
Using multiple Feature Models to specify configuration options for Electrical...
Using multiple Feature Models to specify configuration options for Electrical...Using multiple Feature Models to specify configuration options for Electrical...
Using multiple Feature Models to specify configuration options for Electrical...Jaime Chavarriaga
 
Session 6 - LEDucation 8 - Controls Presentation - Flicker Buzz & Color
Session 6  - LEDucation 8 - Controls Presentation - Flicker Buzz & ColorSession 6  - LEDucation 8 - Controls Presentation - Flicker Buzz & Color
Session 6 - LEDucation 8 - Controls Presentation - Flicker Buzz & ColorCindy Foster-Warthen
 
General specifications for energy efficient led based
General specifications for energy efficient led basedGeneral specifications for energy efficient led based
General specifications for energy efficient led basedHeikham Anandkumar Singh
 
Jamel gantt depth knowledge of lighting
Jamel gantt depth knowledge of lightingJamel gantt depth knowledge of lighting
Jamel gantt depth knowledge of lightingJamel Gantt
 
Intelligent Street light monitoring system
Intelligent Street light monitoring systemIntelligent Street light monitoring system
Intelligent Street light monitoring systemvikas mantri
 
California Title 24 in the LED Era - Presented by Jim Benya, Benya Burnett Co...
California Title 24 in the LED Era - Presented by Jim Benya, Benya Burnett Co...California Title 24 in the LED Era - Presented by Jim Benya, Benya Burnett Co...
California Title 24 in the LED Era - Presented by Jim Benya, Benya Burnett Co...Cindy Foster-Warthen
 
Led placement guidelines for Membrane Switches
Led placement guidelines for Membrane SwitchesLed placement guidelines for Membrane Switches
Led placement guidelines for Membrane SwitchesPhil Heft
 
Automatic room temperature control
Automatic room temperature controlAutomatic room temperature control
Automatic room temperature controldebabratrath
 
H07 Power Load Survey
H07 Power Load SurveyH07 Power Load Survey
H07 Power Load Surveyphase3-120A
 
Telehousenorth2presentationford sd2015
Telehousenorth2presentationford sd2015Telehousenorth2presentationford sd2015
Telehousenorth2presentationford sd2015Telehouse
 

Similar to Differences between Q335 and Current Design (20)

A case study of intelligent buildings
A case study of intelligent buildingsA case study of intelligent buildings
A case study of intelligent buildings
 
AC Powered Driver Topologies
AC Powered Driver Topologies AC Powered Driver Topologies
AC Powered Driver Topologies
 
Museums to Net Zero Buildings - Lessons Learned with LED Lighting
 Museums to Net Zero Buildings - Lessons Learned with LED Lighting  Museums to Net Zero Buildings - Lessons Learned with LED Lighting
Museums to Net Zero Buildings - Lessons Learned with LED Lighting
 
Using multiple Feature Models to specify configuration options for Electrical...
Using multiple Feature Models to specify configuration options for Electrical...Using multiple Feature Models to specify configuration options for Electrical...
Using multiple Feature Models to specify configuration options for Electrical...
 
Session 6 - LEDucation 8 - Controls Presentation - Flicker Buzz & Color
Session 6  - LEDucation 8 - Controls Presentation - Flicker Buzz & ColorSession 6  - LEDucation 8 - Controls Presentation - Flicker Buzz & Color
Session 6 - LEDucation 8 - Controls Presentation - Flicker Buzz & Color
 
Iil complete catalog
Iil complete catalogIil complete catalog
Iil complete catalog
 
AUTOMATIC SMART ENERGY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
AUTOMATIC SMART ENERGY MANAGEMENT SYSTEMAUTOMATIC SMART ENERGY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
AUTOMATIC SMART ENERGY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
 
www.innovativeinductionlighting.com
www.innovativeinductionlighting.comwww.innovativeinductionlighting.com
www.innovativeinductionlighting.com
 
General specifications for energy efficient led based
General specifications for energy efficient led basedGeneral specifications for energy efficient led based
General specifications for energy efficient led based
 
Jamel gantt depth knowledge of lighting
Jamel gantt depth knowledge of lightingJamel gantt depth knowledge of lighting
Jamel gantt depth knowledge of lighting
 
Intelligent Street light monitoring system
Intelligent Street light monitoring systemIntelligent Street light monitoring system
Intelligent Street light monitoring system
 
Critical power: Transfer switches and switchgear
Critical power: Transfer switches and switchgearCritical power: Transfer switches and switchgear
Critical power: Transfer switches and switchgear
 
California Title 24 in the LED Era - Presented by Jim Benya, Benya Burnett Co...
California Title 24 in the LED Era - Presented by Jim Benya, Benya Burnett Co...California Title 24 in the LED Era - Presented by Jim Benya, Benya Burnett Co...
California Title 24 in the LED Era - Presented by Jim Benya, Benya Burnett Co...
 
Led placement guidelines for Membrane Switches
Led placement guidelines for Membrane SwitchesLed placement guidelines for Membrane Switches
Led placement guidelines for Membrane Switches
 
Group project progree
Group project progreeGroup project progree
Group project progree
 
Automatic room temperature control
Automatic room temperature controlAutomatic room temperature control
Automatic room temperature control
 
00001036 h
00001036 h00001036 h
00001036 h
 
H07 Power Load Survey
H07 Power Load SurveyH07 Power Load Survey
H07 Power Load Survey
 
Title 24
Title 24Title 24
Title 24
 
Telehousenorth2presentationford sd2015
Telehousenorth2presentationford sd2015Telehousenorth2presentationford sd2015
Telehousenorth2presentationford sd2015
 

Differences between Q335 and Current Design

  • 1. Differences between Q335 and Current Design Hussein Mohamed April 2015 hmohamed@nycsca.org
  • 2. Contents • LED Lighting • D75 Lighting • Theatrical Lighting • Control Systems • Switches • Automatic shades • 2014 NYCECC
  • 3. Objectives 1. How are we doing? What NGL tells us about the performance and quality of SCA Luminaires 2. Toward better educational environment for Autistic Classroom 3. Design code compliant 2014 New York State and NYC Energy Codes Energy Code 4. Design code compliant Lighting Control relay panel solutions for automatic sweep off controls.
  • 5. Lights - Classroom • Current Design • Q335 Fluorescent -Louver lens -59W -Not Dimmable -70 Up/30 Down -$50/ft LED -Flat frosted lens -30W -Dimmable -70 Up/30 Down -$67/ft
  • 6. Lights – Classroom (Example) • Current Design • Q335
  • 7. Lights – D75 Classroom • Current Design • Q335 LED -Completely indirect (100% up light) -45W -Dimmable -Soft Light (30K) -Wide Distribution (no hot spots above the fixture) -Flicker Free Regular Classroom
  • 8. Lights - Corridor • Current Design • Q335 Fluorescent -Flat lens -2’x4’ -59W -$120 LED -Arc curved lens -2’x2’ -40.4W -$200
  • 9. Lights – Corridor (Example) • Current Design • Q335
  • 10. Lights - Offices • Current Design • Q335 Fluorescent -Parabolic Louvers -2’x4’ -64W – 96W -$160/ea LED -Flat lens with trim/Convex wings & articulated center spine -2’x4’ & 2’x2’ -38W – 75W -$200/ea-$240/ea
  • 11. Lights – Offices (Example) • Current Design • Q335
  • 12. Lights - Gymatorium • Current Design • Q335 HID or Fluorescent -Open glass reflector -30 Lumens per Watt (HID) -45 Lumens per Watt (Fluorescent) -Not Dimmable -Long turn-on time LED -Drop lens with glare control -90 Lumens per Watt -Dimmable -Instantaneous Turn-On - Optional Occupancy Sensor (2014 NYCECC)
  • 13. Lights – Gymnatorium (Example) • Q335• Current Design
  • 14. Lights - Toilets • Current Design • Q335 Fluorescent -Prismatic lens -2’x2’ -64W -$127/ea. LED -Frosted lens -2’x2’/1’x4’ -30W/4 ft. -$150/ea.
  • 15. Lights – Storage/Mechanical • Current Design • Q335 Fluorescent -Exposed lamps & reflector -1’x4’ -64W -$90/ea. LED -Reflective/refractive optics -1’x4’ -50W -$150/ea.
  • 16. Lights - Stairs • Current Design • Q335 Fluorescent -Flat lens -2’x4’ -64W -$120 LED -Wall mounted -6”x3’ -Occupancy + RF -40.4W -$200 - 2014 NYCECC
  • 17. LPD = 45109/83373 =0.54 w/ft² Lights - LPD
  • 18. Lights – Theatrical Spotlights • Current Design • Q335 Tungsten -Adjustable lens beam and spot -585W – 10,000 Lumens -Needs different “gels” to add different colors -Dimmable via line voltage dimming -$300 LED -Adjustable lens beam and spot -150W – 8,000 Lumens -Individually programmable with multiple colors -Dimmable via low voltage dimming -$1000
  • 19. Lights – Theatrical Border Lights • Current Design • Q335 Incandescent -Fixed lens -75W per lamp x 4 lamps -Needs different “gels” to add different colors -Dimmable via line voltage dimming -$300/4 lamps fixture LED -Adjustable lens beam and spot -150W -Individually programmable with multiple colors -Dimmable via low voltage dimming -$1000 -Reduced number of fixtures
  • 20.
  • 22. Control System – Classroom • Current Design -2 momentary switches -2 power packs -one or more vacancy sensor -lamp “a” and lamp “b” controlled separately -no daylight harvesting - No dimming -$500 • Poor light quality (over/under-lit areas)! o Overlighting wastes money! o Underlighting compromises safety! • No dimming – creates jarring shifts in light levels! • Circuit-level controls not granular enough for savings or performance requirements!
  • 23. Toilets Mech./Storage Corridor Recep. Panel Lighting Panel CR-1 CR-2 IWBGENERAL V4000 O.S.SPACE 1 2 3
  • 24. Control System – Classroom • Q335 • Automatic assessment of ambient light! • Gradual (imperceptible) adjustment! • No jarring shifts in light levels! • Consistent light levels across facility! • No under-lit/over-lit areas! -one dimming switches -one controller for two or four classrooms -one or more vacancy sensor -entire fixture work as one unit -daylight harvesting -smooth dimming -$500
  • 25. Ceiling Motion Sensor + Power Pack + Manual on Switch • Manual On – Auto Off • Manual off switch 4 Walls 1 Door up to 900 sq ft Occupancy Sensor Switch – Line Voltage • Manual On – Auto Off • Manual off switch 4 Walls 1 Door up to 3 Light fixtures Areas controlled by an occupant- sensing device (O.S.Space)
  • 26. 1. Three rows of fixtures 2. Dimming switching 3. Vacancy sensing 4. Day light harvesting 5. Automatic Shade D75 Classroom
  • 27. Control System - Relay Panel • Current Design • Q335 36 Circuit Relay Panel -One relay per each circuit in the lighting panel -$1500 24 Circuit Relay Panel -Selected circuits from the lighting panel. -Selected circuits from the receptacle panel. -$1000
  • 28.
  • 29. Control System - Theatrical Panel • Current Design • Q335 24 Circuit Dimmer Panel -Contains dimmer and relay circuits -DMX cable connect from panel to each fixture -$24000 12 Circuit Relay Panel -Contains only relay circuits -DMX or 0-10V cable connect from panel to each fixture. -$3000
  • 30.
  • 31. Switches • Current Design • Q335 Two Gang Low Voltage Switch -on/off -two per classroom -Each switch controls one lamp in row of fixtures -Switches communicate with local sensors in room -$150 One Gang Low Voltage Dimmer Switch -on/off, up/down and preset -one per classroom -Switch controls dimming of all fixtures in room with a preset level set in the middle -Switch communicates with local control panel connected to local sensors in room. -$175
  • 33. C402.3.1 Building Envelope Requirements C402.3.1 Maximum area. The vertical fenestration area (not including opaque doors and opaque spandrel panels) shall not exceed 30 percent of the gross above-grade wall area. C402.3.1.1 Increased vertical fenestration area with daylighting controls. In Climate Zones 1 through 6, a maximum of 40 percent of the gross above-grade wall area shall be permitted to be vertical fenestration, provided: 1. No less than 50 percent of the conditioned floor area is within a daylight zone; 2. Automatic daylighting controls are installed in daylight zones; and 3. Visible transmittance (VT) of vertical fenestration is greater than or equal to 1.1 times solar heat gain coefficient (SHGC). < 30% Glazing IECC 2012 – C402.3.1 ◘ Prescriptive: 30% Max OR 40% Max when ▫ >50% Conditioned floor area in daylight zone ▫ Automatic daylighting control installed ▫ Certain VT requirements
  • 34. Section 8.4.2 Power - Automatic Receptacle Control IECC 2012 ◘ No requirements STD. 90.1 – 8.4.2 ◘ Mandatory: 50% in offices (private and open) and computer classrooms New York State & NYC PRECRIPTIVE rather than mandatory Section 8.4.2 Power stipulates automatic control of 50% of receptacles installed in private offices, open offices and computer classrooms, including receptacles installed in modular partitions. 50% Switched Load
  • 35. C405.2.2.1 Automatic time switch control devices. • Automatic time switch controls shall be installed to control lighting in all areas of the building. ( Except where you have Occ Sensors ) Many walls Many doors Up to 5000 sq ft per zone
  • 36. C405.2.2.3 Daylight zone control. • Switched separately from non-daylit zones • Up to 2500 sq ft per zone • Manual controls are acceptable C405.2.2.3.1 Manual daylighting controls. Manual controls shall be installed in daylight zones unless automatic controls are installed in accordance with C405.2.2.3.2 Automatic daylighting controls. (C405.2.2.3.2 Continuous dimming or multilevel switching)
  • 37. 505.2.2.1 Light Reduction Controls IECC 2012 ◘ Three Categories: 1. Dimming device controlled space (reduced illumination by at least 50%) 2. Occupant- sensing devise controlled space. 3. Automatic time switch controlled space (corridor/lobbies, storerooms and restrooms) >50% Reduced illumination 1 2 3