Gene therapy and gene editing techniques like CRISPR/Cas9 show promise for treating creatine transporter deficiency syndromes (CCDSs) but face challenges. Gene therapy using viruses to deliver replacement genes increased creatine uptake and weight gain in mice with CCDS, and small cognitive improvements, but the viruses don't target the brain well. CRISPR/Cas9 could repair mutated genes, but isn't precise and requires controlling when and where genes edit DNA. More research is needed to develop safe and effective methods to restore gene function in the brain and address current limitations before clinical use for CCDSs.
3. Conflicts of interest/disclosures
• I do not have any personal financial stake in any treatments
under development for CTD
• Sponsored research agreements (expired and ongoing):
4. Overview
• Gene therapy
• What is gene therapy?
• Are CCDSs good candidates for gene therapy?
• How is gene therapy performed?
• Gene replacement
• Gene repair
• What is standing in the way of gene therapy for CCDS?
5. What is gene therapy?
• Gene therapy is a way to use genes to combat disease by:
• Restoring gene expression
• Eliminating gene function
• Fixing gene mutations
8. Did you say virus? Is that safe?
Normal virus that makes you sick Virus used to deliver genes
Remove gene
that makes
more virus
No new viruses!
9. Are CCDSs a good candidate for gene
therapy?
• YES!
• They are caused by mutations in a
single gene
• They have a clear phenotype
• They can be identified using gene
sequencing
• Restoring CRT/SLC6A8 function in
human cells increases Cr uptake
• When Crt function is restored in mice,
they gain weight
• Suggests increase Cr uptake
• No changes in behavior
• Further testing needed
1W
2W
4W
8W
12W
14
16
18
20
22
Weight(g)
AAV9-hCrT
Control (KO)
KO
0
5000
10000
15000
Cr(mMol/mgprotein)
10. AAV treatment increases Cr
0
1
2
3
4
5
FoldChange
KO-hCRT
KO-CON
*
K
O
2W
4W
14W
W
T
0
5000
10000
15000
Cr(mMol/mgprotein)
AAV9-hCRT
Udobi, K.C. and Skelton M.R., unpublished
11. Small cognitive improvement in AAV
treatment
D
ay
1
D
ay
2
D
ay
3
D
ay
4
0
2
4
6
8
PathLength(m)
AAV9-hCrT
KO
AAV9-hCrT cKO
0
10
20
30
40
50
%DistanceinTargetQuadrant
*
AAV9-hCrT KO
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
DiscriminationIndex
D
ay
1
D
ay
2
D
ay
3
D
ay
4
0
2
4
6
8
10
PathLength(m)
AAV9-hCrT
KO
AAV9-hCrT cKO
0
10
20
30
40
%DistanceinTargetQuadrant
D
ay
1
D
ay
2
D
ay
3
0
20
40
60
80
Latency
AAV9-hCrT
KO
Udobi, K.C. and Skelton M.R., unpublished
13. What is Crispr?
• A protein (Cas9) “breaks” DNA
• Using a template from a healthy
donor, the cell repairs the “break”
and replaces the mutated DNA
with the healthy DNA
• Can be used to repair DNA or
introduce modifications
14. How would it be used to treat CCDS?
• In theory, it could be packaged into viral vectors directed to
repair AGAT, GAMT, or SLC6A8
• Must express guide-RNA and Cas9 enzyme
15. Limitations
• Crispr is not as precise as once thought
• Using Crispr/Cas9 to make genetically modified mice has run into
problems
• Would need to be directed to every cell
• Would need to be turned off after repair
16. Sounds great, what’s standing in the way?
• There’s still a lot we don’t know
• How long does it last?
• Can it be inherited?
• Will it interfere with the function of other genes?
• The virus doesn’t really get into the brain well
• For SMA1 patients it may be enough-uptake via motor neurons
• Cognitive delays are caused by loss in large, deep regions of the brain
• AAV9 is not effective in restoring expression at a high level
• We need to control when and where the gene is expressed
• Still more work required to understand when the gene turns on and off
• The delivery of a new gene is beneficial, but it would be better to mimic the
real-life expression of the gene