Watch full webinar here: https://bit.ly/43J5ft6 Can you follow agile methodologies in Denodo development? What are the activities of the different teams in a sprint? What are the best ways to manage your development, testing, and promotion? Join us for this session with Princess Jamelyn Ramos, Technical Consultant at Denodo, to get insights on how to plan and manage your sprint activities in Denodo development with recommended best practices. Watch On-Demand and Learn: - Sprint timeline and activities - Suggested automation for continuous integration - Promotion process and continuous delivery

1. Denodo TechTalks
Product Deep-Dive Series
A product deep-dive, webinar series covering
the critical capabilities of Denodo’s modern
data virtualization

2. Agile Development
Lifecycle and Best
Practices with Denodo
Princess Jamelyn Ramos
Technical Consultant | Denodo

3. AGENDA
1. Development Methodologies with Denodo Platform
2. Agile Project Development Timeline
3. Sprint Activities and Best Practices
4. Q&A

4. Development
Methodologies with the
Denodo Platform

5. 5
Development Methodologies
Any software development methodology can be implemented for Denodo Platform developments.
● Points to consider:
○ Impact of the Business Need
○ Customers’ Perception
○ Project Timeline
Traditional Methodologies Agile Methodologies
Waterfall Model Lean Software Development
Prototype Scrum
CMMI …
… …

6. Agile Development
Scrum

7. 7
Why Agile?
▪ Denodo works with data
▪ Whatever industry a company is from, their data is ingrained
everywhere and historically in the organization
▪ It’s never easy to find, define and finalise a data strategy, especially
for enterprise-wide initiatives
Agile gives the flexibility to implement your data services using
Denodo in a smaller scale at first, then eventually to enterprise-wide.

8. 8
Basic Project Timeline
Development
Development Team
Training
Gather Requirements Development & Testing
Development & Testing
Incorporate feedback from Sprint 1
…
Architecture
Architecture Team
Training
Design Solution
Architecture
Status Check Assessment
Revise architecture as appropriate
…
Business
Stakeholders
Business Need
Definition
Requirements for
Sprint 1
Requirements for Sprint 2
Validate Sprint 1
Requirements for Sprint 3
…
Operations
(Infrastructure)
Operations Team
Training
Install & Configure
Denodo Platform
Configuration Adjustment,
Monitoring
Status Check Assessment
Configuration Adjustment,
Monitoring
…
Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Week 5 Week 6
Sprint 1 Sprint 2
Week 7
Sprint 3
…
…. an iterative approach of continuous development and enhancement

9. Sprint Activities and Best
Practices

10. 10
Before You Start
Pre-Sprint Activities
Communication and preparation are required for all the
stakeholders.
● High-level business need has been defined
● Ranking of priorities (e.g. required, nice to have, …)
● Technical trainings and business workshops are done
○ Use case discovery
○ Functional workshops
○ Denodo trainings
● Solution architecture has been designed
● Redundant needs and reusable solutions have been identified
● Infrastructure and platform installations are ready
● Common definition of “DONE” for all the teams

11. 11
Basic Project Timeline
Sprint Timeline and Activities
Week 3
Development
Sprint 2: Development & Testing (and incorporate feedback)
Sprint 1
Demo
Sprint 2
Demo
Sprint 2
Req’ts
Sprint 3
Req’ts
Architecture
Sprint 2:
Architecture &
Requirements
Sprint 3:
…
Business
Stakeholders
Req’ts for
Sprint 2
Sprint 1
OK?
Sprint 1 Test
and Validation
Req’ts for
Sprint 3
Sprint 2
OK?
Operations
(Infrastructure)
Administration & Monitoring
Sprint 1
Deliverables
Administration & Monitoring
Sprint 2
Deliv.
Promotion
for validation
Week 4 Week 5 Week 6
Sprint 1 Sprint 2
User
Feedback
…
…
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Sprint 1: Development & Testing
Promotion
for validation

12. 12
Sprint Timeline and Activities
Development and Testing
Week 3
Development
Sprint 2: Development & Testing (and incorporate feedback)
Sprint 1
Demo
Sprint 2
Demo
Sprint 2
Req’ts
Sprint 3
Req’ts
Architecture
Sprint 2:
Architecture &
Requirements
Sprint 3:
…
Business
Stakeholders
Req’ts for
Sprint 2
Sprint 1
OK?
Sprint 1 Test
and Validation
Req’ts for
Sprint 3
Sprint 2
OK?
Operations
(Infrastructure)
Administration & Monitoring
Sprint 1
Deliverables
Administration & Monitoring
Sprint 2
Deliv.
Promotion
for validation
Week 4 Week 5 Week 6
Sprint 1 Sprint 2
User
Feedback
…
…
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Sprint 1: Development & Testing
Promotion
for validation

13. 13
Sprint Timeline and Activities
● Typical 2-week sprint will deliver 10+ data services
● Expected deliverables can be planned by balancing the ff. variables:
○ Time
○ Scope
○ Quality
● Actual deliverables in each sprint can still vary and will depend on number of
factors i.e.
○ Complexity of data sources
○ Complexity of infrastructure (e.g. security)
○ Complexity of modeling
○ Amount of reuse of existing virtual views
○ Experience of developers
○ Any rework from previous sprint
Development and Testing - Expected Deliverables
Sprint Deliverable
Variables
Quality
Scope
Time

14. 14
Best Practices
● Ideally all development artifacts should be saved in a Version Control System (VCS)
○ In simple scenarios, coordinated developers should be working on the same development server and sharing a
vdb
○ Developers should PUSH or Check In their changes to VCS from Denodo Designer Studio
● Denodo Testing Tool allows developers to create ‘unit-style’ and regression tests in created views
○ Tests execute queries against a view and compare results of each query against a set of expected results
○ Denodo Testing Tool is a script-driven, lightweight stand-alone testing application
● Tests can be automatically triggered using Jenkins as part of existing continuous integration (CI) processes like when
artifact is checked in to VCS
○ e.g. server-side hooks in Git
● Global elements (e.g. jar extensions, internalizations, etc.) should be done by administrators of the Denodo servers,
and not by developers
○ Avoids affecting other projects that also use the same global elements
Development and Testing - Continuous Integration and Automated Testing

15. 15
Continuous Integration - Sample Flow
Development and Testing - Continuous Integration and Automated Testing
project1_main
project1_dev
DEV SERVER
Testing Tool
Developers work on
shared vdb
1
Developers push
changes to git
through VDP
2
git notifies
Jenkins
Jenkins call VDP to pull
from git to master vdb
4
Jenkins runs
Denodo Testing
Tool tests for
validation. Notify
on error
5
3

16. 16
Setup
1. Download Denodo Testing Tool from DenodoConnects
2. Install a plugin on Jenkins which allows to send emails
3. Add a new “Freestyle project” in Jenkins
4. Configure the Batch section and add an execution
command to run the Denodo Testing Tool
5. Add a Post-build Action to send email notification in case
the tests failed
Development and Testing - Continuous Integration and Automated Testing
Continuous Integration - Jenkins Denodo Testing Tool

17. 19
Sprint Timeline and Activities
End of Sprint
Week 3
Development
Sprint 2: Development & Testing (and incorporate feedback)
Sprint 1
Demo
Sprint 2
Demo
Sprint 2
Req’ts
Sprint 3
Req’ts
Architecture
Sprint 2:
Architecture &
Requirements
Sprint 3:
…
Business
Stakeholders
Req’ts for
Sprint 2
Sprint 1
OK?
Sprint 1 Test
and Validation
Req’ts for
Sprint 3
Sprint 2
OK?
Operations
(Infrastructure)
Administration & Monitoring
Sprint 1
Deliverables
Administration & Monitoring
Sprint 2
Deliv.
Promotion
for validation
Week 4 Week 5 Week 6
Sprint 1 Sprint 2
User
Feedback
…
…
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Sprint 1: Development & Testing
Promotion
for validation

18. 20
Sprint Timeline and Activities
End of Sprint - Activities
For the Current Sprint …
● Sprint Review
○ Development team (Scrum team) presents and shows sprint deliverables to
Business Stakeholders
■ What worked, what didn’t and needs further effort
○ Business Stakeholders approve deliverables (or reject for rework)
■ Note: Approval can be partial i.e. approve only some deliverables
For the Next Sprint …
● Sprint Planning
○ Business Stakeholders present requirements for next sprint to Development
team
■ Development team get any clarifications necessary
○ Development and Architecture teams define architecture and deliverables for
next sprint

19. 21
Sprint Timeline and Activities
Promotion
Week 3
Development
Sprint 2: Development & Testing (and incorporate feedback)
Sprint 1
Demo
Sprint 2
Demo
Sprint 2
Req’ts
Sprint 3
Req’ts
Architecture
Sprint 2:
Architecture &
Requirements
Sprint 3:
…
Business
Stakeholders
Req’ts for
Sprint 2
Sprint 1
OK?
Sprint 1 Test
and Validation
Req’ts for
Sprint 3
Sprint 2
OK?
Operations
(Infrastructure)
Administration & Monitoring
Sprint 1
Deliverables
Administration & Monitoring
Sprint 2
Deliv.
Promotion
for validation
Week 4 Week 5 Week 6
Sprint 1 Sprint 2
User
Feedback
…
…
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Sprint 1: Development & Testing
Promotion
for validation

20. 22
Sprint Timeline and Activities
Promotion - Promotion Process
Deploy to Production
5. [Operations] If (2), (3) and (4)
pass and in accordance with
operational policies, deploy
artifacts to Production
environment
Deploy to Test Environment
1. [Development] Changes and
artifacts are checked in and
unit tested
2. [Operations] Build and
deploy sprint artifacts to Test
environment
Operational and Functional Tests
3. [Operations] Test deployment
from an operations perspective
e.g. stability, performance, etc.
4. [Business Stakeholders] Test
delivered artifacts (data services)
from a business functionality
perspective

21. 23
Best Practices
● Deployment to test environment can be automated using Solution Manager API or Denodo export and import scripts
● Testing by Operations team can also be automated using the Denodo Testing Tool
○ Ensure that there are no regressions after new deployment
● For High Availability (HA) and heavy queries, it is advised to do simulated performance and load testing which can be
automated using tools like K6, JMeter, etc.
○ In combination with the report generated by tools like JMeter, Denodo Diagnostic & Monitoring Tool is useful to
monitor the Denodo servers’ behavior during performance and load testing.
● Business Stakeholder testing is, more than likely, going to be manual testing using a client application of choice (e.g.
Tableau, Power BI, Excel, etc.)
● Final promotion to Production environment can also be automated using Solution Manager API or custom scripts.
Promotion - Continuous Deployment

22. 24
Continuous Integration & Continuous Deployment - Sample Flow
Promotion - Continuous Deployment
Solution
Manager
project1_main
project1_dev
DEV SERVER
Testing Tool
project1
TEST ENV
Developers work
on shared vdb
1
Developers
push changes
to git through
VDP
2
git notifies
Jenkins
Jenkins call VDP
to pull from git
to master vdb
4
Jenkins runs
Denodo
Testing Tool
tests for
validation.
Notify on
error
5
3
Jenkins creates a revision
from a full export of the
project1 vdb
7
Jenkins deploys the
project1 in a Test
Environment through
SM
8
Jenkins waits until a
certain number of
changesets have been
made, after certain
amount of time has
elapsed, etc.
6

23. 25
Sprint Timeline and Activities
Sprint Test and Validation
Week 3
Development
Sprint 2: Development & Testing (and incorporate feedback)
Sprint 1
Demo
Sprint 2
Demo
Sprint 2
Req’ts
Sprint 3
Req’ts
Architecture
Sprint 2:
Architecture &
Requirements
Sprint 3:
…
Business
Stakeholders
Req’ts for
Sprint 2
Sprint 1
OK?
Sprint 1 Test
and Validation
Req’ts for
Sprint 3
Sprint 2
OK?
Operations
(Infrastructure)
Administration & Monitoring
Sprint 1
Deliverables
Administration & Monitoring
Sprint 2
Deliv.
Promotion
for validation
Week 4 Week 5 Week 6
Sprint 1 Sprint 2
User
Feedback
…
…
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Ad-hoc Demo
and
Feedback Loop
Sprint 1: Development & Testing
Promotion
for validation

24. 26
Sprint Test and Validation
Sprint Timeline and Activities
● Business Stakeholders test previous sprint artifacts (data services) in the
test environment
○ If applicable, the business can test and validate the deliverables in the
middle of the sprint
○ It’s highly recommended to capture feedbacks as early as possible to
assess their impact on the current scope
● Validate that the data services work as expected and as defined
● Provide feedback to Development team if issues are discovered
● Agree, with the Development team, a timeline for correcting any defects
○ Note: The fix for an issue might not fall into the current sprint

25. CLOSING
REMARKS
▪ How Denodo works with different development methodologies and why we focus in
agile
▪ Different activities before, during, and after the sprint
▪ Best practices on how to manage your development and testing
▪ Best practices on how to manage your promotion process
▪ Different Denodo tools and features that you can leverage to have a continuous
integration (CI) and continuous deployment (CD) processes
Version Control Systems Integration — Virtual DataPort Administration Guide (denodo.com)
Denodo Testing Tool - User Manual
REST API — Solution Manager Administration Guide (denodo.com)

26. Q&A

27. Thanks!
www.denodo.com info@denodo.com
© Copyright Denodo Technologies. All rights reserved
Unless otherwise specified, no part of this PDF file may be reproduced or utilized in any for or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and
microfilm, without prior the written authorization from Denodo Technologies.