SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
Are Forest Restoration
Investments Benefiting Local
Communities Most in Need?
A new program seeks to create jobs and improve
rural economies through investments in
restoration, but the results have been mixed.
Chelsea P. McIver
FERRY COUNTY IS FIRST in the rankings of Washington
counties with the highest unemployment rates. In fact, all
three counties in northeastern Washington register in the
top ten and all have unemployment rates above 9%. Clear-
ly this forest-dependent region could benefit from eco-
nomic development. Federal investments in restoration
have been steadily increasing and a new program called
the Collaborative Forest Landscape Restoration Program
(CFLRP) aims to bolster this trend while creating economic
opportunities for local residents.
UNEMPLOYMENT RANKINGS, DEC. 2015
1Counties in northeast WA are struggling
to recover jobs and income lost during
the Recession
2 Economic impacts tend to occur where workers live (place of residence and/or
business), rather than where they work
Most of the economic impacts of resto-
ration are lost due to leakage out of the
local tri-county economy.
As much as 86% of contract dollars flowed to business, workers and
communities out of state.
3 Programs such as stewardship contracting have been shown to keep more dollars in the
local economy, but other efforts targeting economically-disadvantaged counties have
been less effective.
Restoration activities packaged into a stewardship con-
tract increased the share of dollars staying in the local
economy by 19%.
Contracts set-aside for businesses from economically-disad-
vantaged counties through the HUB Zone program have had
weak effect in local economy (% Local, CFLRP vs. non-CFLRP).
4 Harvesting timber benefits counties where
trees are cut AND processed
100 percent of timber harvested was processed by local
mills, generating multiple benefits
project area
mills
processing
timber
5 For more information on this and similar
projects, contact:
Chelsea P. McIver
Bureau of Business and Economic Research
University of Montana
chelsea.mciver@business.umt.edu
(406) 243-5614
Or visit:
www.bber.umt.edu/FIR
Non-CFLRP CFLRP
% Local, CFLRP vs. non-CFLRP % Local, CFLRP vs. non-CFLRP

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (10)

Miss gabriela’s day
Miss gabriela’s dayMiss gabriela’s day
Miss gabriela’s day
 
Maatam aursahaba
Maatam aursahabaMaatam aursahaba
Maatam aursahaba
 
Ejercicio 2
Ejercicio 2Ejercicio 2
Ejercicio 2
 
Resolucion de problemas proyecto final
Resolucion de problemas proyecto finalResolucion de problemas proyecto final
Resolucion de problemas proyecto final
 
Gen epio immem_griffiths
Gen epio immem_griffithsGen epio immem_griffiths
Gen epio immem_griffiths
 
Materiales para crear arte
Materiales para crear arteMateriales para crear arte
Materiales para crear arte
 
Design portfolio
Design portfolio Design portfolio
Design portfolio
 
La Musica <3
La Musica <3La Musica <3
La Musica <3
 
F excel
F excelF excel
F excel
 
Types of paragraphs adriana y shanith
Types of paragraphs adriana y shanithTypes of paragraphs adriana y shanith
Types of paragraphs adriana y shanith
 

Similar to Are Forest Restoration Investments Benefiting Local Communities Most in Need?

McIver et al-Rural Connections-Fall16
McIver et al-Rural Connections-Fall16McIver et al-Rural Connections-Fall16
McIver et al-Rural Connections-Fall16
Chelsea McIver
 
RuralUrbanConnections_FINAL_-7
RuralUrbanConnections_FINAL_-7RuralUrbanConnections_FINAL_-7
RuralUrbanConnections_FINAL_-7
Erin Meyers
 
Spring2015_Newsletter
Spring2015_NewsletterSpring2015_Newsletter
Spring2015_Newsletter
Kerin Boti
 
TRF Economic Strategy 1a
TRF Economic Strategy 1aTRF Economic Strategy 1a
TRF Economic Strategy 1a
Edwin Dale Hahn
 
AgLandPreservation
AgLandPreservationAgLandPreservation
AgLandPreservation
Jaclyn Evans
 
Kern tax budget hearing comments 110815
Kern tax budget hearing comments 110815Kern tax budget hearing comments 110815
Kern tax budget hearing comments 110815
KernTax
 
Alliance August 2010 Forum.ppt
Alliance August 2010 Forum.pptAlliance August 2010 Forum.ppt
Alliance August 2010 Forum.ppt
mikehuggins
 

Similar to Are Forest Restoration Investments Benefiting Local Communities Most in Need? (20)

McIver et al-Rural Connections-Fall16
McIver et al-Rural Connections-Fall16McIver et al-Rural Connections-Fall16
McIver et al-Rural Connections-Fall16
 
CEDS Executive summary
CEDS Executive summaryCEDS Executive summary
CEDS Executive summary
 
Farmlandpreservation2011
Farmlandpreservation2011Farmlandpreservation2011
Farmlandpreservation2011
 
policy options.pdf
policy options.pdfpolicy options.pdf
policy options.pdf
 
RuralUrbanConnections_FINAL_-7
RuralUrbanConnections_FINAL_-7RuralUrbanConnections_FINAL_-7
RuralUrbanConnections_FINAL_-7
 
LUVRules Social Purpose Grant
LUVRules Social Purpose GrantLUVRules Social Purpose Grant
LUVRules Social Purpose Grant
 
Spring2015_Newsletter
Spring2015_NewsletterSpring2015_Newsletter
Spring2015_Newsletter
 
Franklin county economic development aug. 22, 2013
Franklin county economic development   aug. 22, 2013Franklin county economic development   aug. 22, 2013
Franklin county economic development aug. 22, 2013
 
TRF Economic Strategy 1a
TRF Economic Strategy 1aTRF Economic Strategy 1a
TRF Economic Strategy 1a
 
CTA case studies on the status of extension and advisory: Papua New Guinea
CTA case studies on the status of extension and advisory: Papua New GuineaCTA case studies on the status of extension and advisory: Papua New Guinea
CTA case studies on the status of extension and advisory: Papua New Guinea
 
Hisa Essay
Hisa EssayHisa Essay
Hisa Essay
 
AGA Article 6 -2013
AGA Article 6 -2013AGA Article 6 -2013
AGA Article 6 -2013
 
ARRA Overview
ARRA OverviewARRA Overview
ARRA Overview
 
AgLandPreservation
AgLandPreservationAgLandPreservation
AgLandPreservation
 
ARRA Overview Illinois Workforce Partnership Regional Meetings
ARRA Overview Illinois Workforce Partnership Regional MeetingsARRA Overview Illinois Workforce Partnership Regional Meetings
ARRA Overview Illinois Workforce Partnership Regional Meetings
 
Kern tax budget hearing comments 110815
Kern tax budget hearing comments 110815Kern tax budget hearing comments 110815
Kern tax budget hearing comments 110815
 
Alliance August 2010 Forum.ppt
Alliance August 2010 Forum.pptAlliance August 2010 Forum.ppt
Alliance August 2010 Forum.ppt
 
Case study of extension and advisory services in papua new guinea
Case study of extension and advisory services in papua new guineaCase study of extension and advisory services in papua new guinea
Case study of extension and advisory services in papua new guinea
 
Miner Cash Flow Project Presentation
Miner Cash Flow Project PresentationMiner Cash Flow Project Presentation
Miner Cash Flow Project Presentation
 
Power point slide presentation of the final projectobjectivedi
Power point slide presentation of the final projectobjectivediPower point slide presentation of the final projectobjectivedi
Power point slide presentation of the final projectobjectivedi
 

Recently uploaded

Tech Framework Integrated Workspace Management System
Tech Framework Integrated Workspace Management SystemTech Framework Integrated Workspace Management System
Tech Framework Integrated Workspace Management System
Sushant Joshi
 
"NEON LIGHT CITY" AR PC game from M.A.D tronics Studios
"NEON LIGHT CITY" AR PC game from M.A.D tronics Studios"NEON LIGHT CITY" AR PC game from M.A.D tronics Studios
"NEON LIGHT CITY" AR PC game from M.A.D tronics Studios
tess51
 

Recently uploaded (9)

AI Data Engineering for SMEs - some tricks and tools
AI Data Engineering for SMEs - some tricks and toolsAI Data Engineering for SMEs - some tricks and tools
AI Data Engineering for SMEs - some tricks and tools
 
PEARL KITCHEN SINKS(R.A ENGINEERING INDUSTRIES
PEARL KITCHEN SINKS(R.A ENGINEERING INDUSTRIESPEARL KITCHEN SINKS(R.A ENGINEERING INDUSTRIES
PEARL KITCHEN SINKS(R.A ENGINEERING INDUSTRIES
 
Dropbox DBX Q1 2020 Investor Presentation.pdf
Dropbox DBX Q1 2020 Investor Presentation.pdfDropbox DBX Q1 2020 Investor Presentation.pdf
Dropbox DBX Q1 2020 Investor Presentation.pdf
 
Tech Framework Integrated Workspace Management System
Tech Framework Integrated Workspace Management SystemTech Framework Integrated Workspace Management System
Tech Framework Integrated Workspace Management System
 
Financial management icar entrepreneurship development
Financial management icar entrepreneurship developmentFinancial management icar entrepreneurship development
Financial management icar entrepreneurship development
 
EXPERIENCE THE FUTURE OF WORK FOR FUTURE OF BUSINESSES
EXPERIENCE  THE FUTURE OF WORK FOR FUTURE OF BUSINESSESEXPERIENCE  THE FUTURE OF WORK FOR FUTURE OF BUSINESSES
EXPERIENCE THE FUTURE OF WORK FOR FUTURE OF BUSINESSES
 
CARA BINA PENDAPATAN PASIF HARIAN RM9000 BERMODALKAN RM30 DI TDC
CARA BINA PENDAPATAN PASIF HARIAN RM9000 BERMODALKAN RM30 DI TDCCARA BINA PENDAPATAN PASIF HARIAN RM9000 BERMODALKAN RM30 DI TDC
CARA BINA PENDAPATAN PASIF HARIAN RM9000 BERMODALKAN RM30 DI TDC
 
MARKETING PLAN RESMI TDC IMUNO INDONESIA 2024
MARKETING PLAN RESMI TDC IMUNO INDONESIA 2024MARKETING PLAN RESMI TDC IMUNO INDONESIA 2024
MARKETING PLAN RESMI TDC IMUNO INDONESIA 2024
 
"NEON LIGHT CITY" AR PC game from M.A.D tronics Studios
"NEON LIGHT CITY" AR PC game from M.A.D tronics Studios"NEON LIGHT CITY" AR PC game from M.A.D tronics Studios
"NEON LIGHT CITY" AR PC game from M.A.D tronics Studios
 

Are Forest Restoration Investments Benefiting Local Communities Most in Need?

  • 1. Are Forest Restoration Investments Benefiting Local Communities Most in Need? A new program seeks to create jobs and improve rural economies through investments in restoration, but the results have been mixed. Chelsea P. McIver FERRY COUNTY IS FIRST in the rankings of Washington counties with the highest unemployment rates. In fact, all three counties in northeastern Washington register in the top ten and all have unemployment rates above 9%. Clear- ly this forest-dependent region could benefit from eco- nomic development. Federal investments in restoration have been steadily increasing and a new program called the Collaborative Forest Landscape Restoration Program (CFLRP) aims to bolster this trend while creating economic opportunities for local residents. UNEMPLOYMENT RANKINGS, DEC. 2015 1Counties in northeast WA are struggling to recover jobs and income lost during the Recession 2 Economic impacts tend to occur where workers live (place of residence and/or business), rather than where they work Most of the economic impacts of resto- ration are lost due to leakage out of the local tri-county economy. As much as 86% of contract dollars flowed to business, workers and communities out of state. 3 Programs such as stewardship contracting have been shown to keep more dollars in the local economy, but other efforts targeting economically-disadvantaged counties have been less effective. Restoration activities packaged into a stewardship con- tract increased the share of dollars staying in the local economy by 19%. Contracts set-aside for businesses from economically-disad- vantaged counties through the HUB Zone program have had weak effect in local economy (% Local, CFLRP vs. non-CFLRP). 4 Harvesting timber benefits counties where trees are cut AND processed 100 percent of timber harvested was processed by local mills, generating multiple benefits project area mills processing timber 5 For more information on this and similar projects, contact: Chelsea P. McIver Bureau of Business and Economic Research University of Montana chelsea.mciver@business.umt.edu (406) 243-5614 Or visit: www.bber.umt.edu/FIR Non-CFLRP CFLRP % Local, CFLRP vs. non-CFLRP % Local, CFLRP vs. non-CFLRP