2. I. Introduction
II. Background of Analysis
III. Economic & Fiscal Impacts
IV. Benefits & Improvements
V. Case Studies
VI. Summary
VII. Questions
Agenda
3. About Camoin Associates
Founded in 1999 by Robert Camoin
Completed work in 32 states and counting
Employ 13 full-time staff
3
4. Background
Warren, Washington, and Saratoga
Comparison over time
Aug. 2015 – Jul. 2016
Aug. 2016 – Jul. 2017
Aug. 2017 – Jul. 2018
Focus on “Net New” Dollars
5. Total Arena Attendance
Attendance
150,000 150,000 151,371
176,114
208,332
-
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
Aug. 13 - Jul. 14 Aug. 14 - Jul. 15 Aug. 15 - Jul. 16 Aug. 16 - Jul. 17 Aug. 17 - Jul. 18
9. Quality of Place
Sense of Community
Healthy Business Environment
Historical Value
Downtown Revitalization
Gathering Place
Other Benefits
Photo: Mark Kurtz
10. Outdoor Video Board
9-Screen Video Board
6 LED Video Screens
Arena Lights
Updated Girders
Locker Room Renovations and Flooring
Wi Fi Installation
Audio System
Food & Beverage Upgrades
Building Equipment Upgrades
Private Luxury Suite
Improvements
11. Addition to Front of Arena
New Entrance & Meeting Space
More Food & Beverage Space
Renovations to Heritage Hall
Additional Locker Room Areas
Desired Additional Improvements
12.
13. It’s not uncommon that funding for sports arenas
and civic centers come from public subsidies
Sources
• Sports Stadiums + Public Subsidies.” University Of Michigan, www.umich.edu/~econdev/stadium_subsidy/.
• Fischenich, Mark. “Civic Center Subsidy Reaches $750,000.” Mankato Free Press, 6 Dec. 2015, www.mankatofreepress.com/news/civic-center-subsidy-reaches/article_a86814f0-9b7b-11e5-99cd-3f1876ef0670.html.
14. How? Why?
Cash payments
Tax abatements
PILOTS
Infrastructure
improvement
Operating cost
subsidies
Portion of bed tax
In-kind
Economic growth
Create jobs
Increase spending
More hotel stays and
meal purchases
Sense of community
Downtown
revitalization
Local support
15. Operated by City Center
Authority
Receive approximately
$1.2M from County bed
tax annually
Case Study: Saratoga City Center
16. Owned by Albany County
County funded TU Center
parking garage and the
arena, and recent $20
million renovation
Case Study: Times Union Center
17. Summary
Benefit Aug. 17 – Jul. 18
Sales $13,198,536
Jobs 155
Earnings $4,324,636
Tax Revenue $942,803
Attendance 208,332
- In addition to an increase in attendance, there has been a notable increase in economic impacts from visitors coming to the Arena.
The results of the original analysis of operations between August 2015 to July 2016 indicate that the Arena had a total economic impact of $10.6 million in sales, 131 jobs and over $3.6 million in earnings.
All sales, jobs, and earnings estimates increased over the following two years.
From August 2016 to July 2017, Arena operations supported 141 total jobs throughout the region, nearly $4 million in earnings and a total of $12.1 million in regional sales.
From August 2017 to July 2018, operations supported over $13 million in sales, 155 jobs and $4.3 million in earnings.
In addition to impacts already outlined, there have been one-time impacts on the regional economy through spending to upgrade and enhance the facility.
Specifically, the Coalition has received nearly $2.8 million in grant funding, of which nearly $1.7 was spent on contractors and laborers in the community to make physical improvements to the facility
Based only on net-new dollars, more people, more spending, etc. 155 jobs is mostly in the community and outside the Arena.
The County has a bed tax, which it distributes to itself, the City, the Authority and the Convention Bureau. Together, the Authority and the Bureau get $1.2m per year (it is a percentage, so changes every year) of the bed tax, 50% of which goes to operations and the balance to capital improvements