SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Review Form
Dear Reviewer,
Hope your valuable and eminent review helps to propel the quality of article.
TITLE: Water Requirement of Different Crops for Khurda District of Odisha, India
CATEGORY: Research Article
ARTICLE ID: ECAG-14-RA-018
Please indicate whether the following criteria are met Yes/No
The article title and abstract are appropriate yes
The purpose of the article and its significance is stated clearly yes
The study methods are sound and appropriate yes
The writing is clear and concise yes
The conclusions or summary are accurate and supported by the content yes
The article is of interest to members of the education research community yes
Please indicate any one of the following actions you recommend
Publish, no significant alterations suggested yes
Publish, but suggest changes to the article as specified in this review
Publish, but suggestions in this review must be addressed
Reject, but encourage author to try a major revision and a second peer review
Reject, do not encourage a rewrite
Review Comments & Suggestions
No comments

More Related Content

Similar to Review Form_ECAG-14-RA-018

Reviewer 1 ao_6073 (Dr Ali Olfati)
Reviewer 1 ao_6073 (Dr Ali Olfati)Reviewer 1 ao_6073 (Dr Ali Olfati)
Reviewer 1 ao_6073 (Dr Ali Olfati)Ali Olfati
 
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2 copy
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2   copyTata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2   copy
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2 copyFaisal Pak
 
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2Faisal Pak
 
What it needs to Write a Review Paper
What it needs to Write a Review PaperWhat it needs to Write a Review Paper
What it needs to Write a Review PaperMurugananth Gopal Raj
 
Sct book chapter review form (1)
Sct book chapter review form (1)Sct book chapter review form (1)
Sct book chapter review form (1)Hung Tran
 
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2 Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2 Faisal Pak
 
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2FaizalRisdianto1
 
EDCO 745Literature Review Final Grading Rubric CriteriaLeve
EDCO 745Literature Review Final Grading Rubric CriteriaLeveEDCO 745Literature Review Final Grading Rubric CriteriaLeve
EDCO 745Literature Review Final Grading Rubric CriteriaLeveEvonCanales257
 
Essential elements of a dissertation outline
Essential elements of a dissertation outlineEssential elements of a dissertation outline
Essential elements of a dissertation outlineEssayAcademy
 

Similar to Review Form_ECAG-14-RA-018 (10)

Review form cons rw-17-0047 by reviewer scientria ricerca
Review form cons rw-17-0047 by reviewer scientria ricercaReview form cons rw-17-0047 by reviewer scientria ricerca
Review form cons rw-17-0047 by reviewer scientria ricerca
 
Reviewer 1 ao_6073 (Dr Ali Olfati)
Reviewer 1 ao_6073 (Dr Ali Olfati)Reviewer 1 ao_6073 (Dr Ali Olfati)
Reviewer 1 ao_6073 (Dr Ali Olfati)
 
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2 copy
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2   copyTata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2   copy
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2 copy
 
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
 
What it needs to Write a Review Paper
What it needs to Write a Review PaperWhat it needs to Write a Review Paper
What it needs to Write a Review Paper
 
Sct book chapter review form (1)
Sct book chapter review form (1)Sct book chapter review form (1)
Sct book chapter review form (1)
 
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2 Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi  sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
 
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
Tata kelola jurnal menuju akreditasi sinta 2
 
EDCO 745Literature Review Final Grading Rubric CriteriaLeve
EDCO 745Literature Review Final Grading Rubric CriteriaLeveEDCO 745Literature Review Final Grading Rubric CriteriaLeve
EDCO 745Literature Review Final Grading Rubric CriteriaLeve
 
Essential elements of a dissertation outline
Essential elements of a dissertation outlineEssential elements of a dissertation outline
Essential elements of a dissertation outline
 

Review Form_ECAG-14-RA-018

  • 1. Review Form Dear Reviewer, Hope your valuable and eminent review helps to propel the quality of article. TITLE: Water Requirement of Different Crops for Khurda District of Odisha, India CATEGORY: Research Article ARTICLE ID: ECAG-14-RA-018 Please indicate whether the following criteria are met Yes/No The article title and abstract are appropriate yes The purpose of the article and its significance is stated clearly yes The study methods are sound and appropriate yes The writing is clear and concise yes The conclusions or summary are accurate and supported by the content yes The article is of interest to members of the education research community yes Please indicate any one of the following actions you recommend Publish, no significant alterations suggested yes Publish, but suggest changes to the article as specified in this review Publish, but suggestions in this review must be addressed Reject, but encourage author to try a major revision and a second peer review Reject, do not encourage a rewrite Review Comments & Suggestions No comments