SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
From Adversity to Diversity – The role of assessments in the
transformation of South Africa.
This paper discusses the important role of assessments in the Transformation of South Africa.
The era of apartheid was characterised by a carefully socially engineered system masterminded
by Dry HF Verwoerd – a professor of psychology and sociology. The plan included the
education of black people to be “The hewers of wood” and the “drawers of water” i.e. people
educated to lowly positions. This had a dramatic effect on Education is South Africa and
resulted in a generation of people who were not able to fulfill their potential. When the dawn of
the new democratic South Africa came in 1994, it was essential that talented people of races
other than White could be identified. It was not possible to use results from educational systems
as they could not be regarded as a true reflection of ability. This is where psychological
assessment came into the picture. The new Employment Equity Act (South Africa’s Affirmative
Action Act” covered the issue of psychological testing. The first draft did not mention potential,
so a group of psychologist collaborated with the |Labour Dept. to include a clause of the
assessment of potential. Without this further discrimination may have continued because ability
assessment would favor the better educated white population.
The assessment of potential became a very important issue for the world of psychological
assessments. It resulted in several tests being developed which could measure potential and
not be influenced by education. Some of these have now been introduced into many others
countries in the world such as the UK, USA, and Australia.
Assessment of potential carried some clear guidelines on how this was to be done – it could not
be a verbal assessment because of language differences and thus non-verbal testing was
introduced. Several brilliant South African psychologists earned their doctorates working on
these tests.
Assessments in the process of recruitment and selection
1
Organisational Performance
P.O. Box 255
Morningside
Sandton
2057
Anne Newman
Counselling Psychologist
anne@icon.co.za
Cell: 082 570 6803
Ph: 011 463 6982
Fax: 011 706 6988 or 086 602 8350
We have very stringent regulations around psychological assessment in South Africa, and this
is appropriate given our history, and the need to establish fair working practices. Assessments
need to be conducted according to competencies profiled for particular job roles. These
competencies include both intellectual ability, potential for development and personal
characteristics.
Many organisations are opting for test batteries designed by psychologist to assist in their
selection of the best person for the job based on assessments as well as other selection
processes such as interviews.
It has become possible to offer these assessments and recommendations for employment.
There was some resistance to assessments when the Employment Equity Act was
promulgated, but now we understand that psychological testing plays a vital role in placing
competent people in key positions.
We have a very wide range of instinctual assessment tools such as the Cognitive process
Profile, The APIL B and TREAM series, the LPCAT, as well as assessment tools for personality
characteristics such as:
Occupational personally Profile
Occupational Personality Questionnaire
EQI 2
MBTI
As well as specific tests such as:
Thomas Kilman Conflict management
Work Related Risk Profile
Once a job has been profiled and key characteristics denied we can use psychological tests to
demine fit for a job.
Assessments to foster understanding and enhance the appreciation of
diversity
Another aspect of the transformation of South African was to learn to value our diversity and to
appreciate rather than denigrate our differences. Many programmes were developed to help
organisations with a cultural change process and a way in which people could learn to
understand each other better and work together more effectively.
Diversity does not only relate to gender and race although many organisations have focussed
mainly on these. The value of diversity becomes apparent when tames learn to work together
using the strengths of people and planning work according to particulate talents.
Diversity is also apparent in differences in attitudes, thinking skills, aspects of emotional
intelligence, The work of Hofstede has brought a great deal of insight into cultural differences in
2
various countries. His assessment of 6 dimensions of cultural difference has been used to
facilitate communication and working relationships amongst people in very many countries.
His dimensions are:
Power distance
Individualism vs collectivism
Masculinity vs femininity
Uncertainty avoidance
Long term orient orientation vs Short term orientation
Indulgence vs restraint
Organisations working internationally have used his work extensively to foster good
communication and mutual understanding to effect work alliances, trade agreements etc.
Another significant contribution to the debate on people and differences in the work of Gardner
on Multiple intelligences. He postulates that there are many types of intelligence not just the
concept of intellectual intelligence. He defines these as:
Musical- rhythmic
Visual- spatial
Verbal- linguistic
Logical – mathematical
Bodily - kinesthetic
Interpersonal
Intrapersonal
Naturalistic
Steven Stein also contributed with his book the EQ Edge and his journal article entitled “Why
Smart Leaders Fail”. His work, and that of many others, has further enlightened the work on the
qualities of leadership. This will be discussed further under the topic of Diversity and Top
Teams.
In South Africa we have great diversity in cultures and languages. Because we lived apart in
areas designated by colour, our only meeting with people from other races and cultures used to
be in the work place, unless they were people employed to work as housekeepers or graders.
Nowadays this has change but it is still true that for most of us we only really experience
diversity in the workplace.
Assessment to support Diversity in Top Team Management
McKinsey & Coo (Leadership Development Programme) defines the 3 dimensions of Top Teams as:
Alignment:
3
• Shared assumptions about business context, strategy and goals
• Shared beliefs about the Top Team
• Purpose, values governing behaviour, balance between individual and collective interests
Quality of Execution
• Effective team configuration in terms of structure and processes, mix and level of skills, focus of
time, incentives to work harder
• High quality interaction in terms of respect, understanding, trust. Open communication,
challenge, constructive conflict management and resolution
Ability to renew
• Sustainability which covers investment in team motivation and energy, balance of attention
across difficult horizons and successful planning
• Adaptability of the organisation and its context, openness to change, learning, effective internal
and external communication
Using this model one can plan a Top Team intervention and use assess characteristics to add to the
debate and to help Top Team member to understand and appreciate their strengths and areas of
development, and where particular would be best deployed to enhance team performance.
4

More Related Content

What's hot

Multicultural_guidance_and_counselling
Multicultural_guidance_and_counsellingMulticultural_guidance_and_counselling
Multicultural_guidance_and_counsellingMika Launikari [LION]
 
Gender diversity in workplace
Gender diversity in workplaceGender diversity in workplace
Gender diversity in workplaceShahriar Rawshon
 
Human Resource Development and capacity building for NGOs, NPOs, VOs
Human Resource Development and capacity building for NGOs, NPOs, VOsHuman Resource Development and capacity building for NGOs, NPOs, VOs
Human Resource Development and capacity building for NGOs, NPOs, VOsSrinivasan Rengasamy
 
Concept and role of culture in International human resource management
Concept and  role of culture in International human resource managementConcept and  role of culture in International human resource management
Concept and role of culture in International human resource managementSundar B N
 
Hofstede cultural dimensions
Hofstede cultural dimensionsHofstede cultural dimensions
Hofstede cultural dimensionsTrevor Davisson
 
The hofstede’s model (power distance and uncertainty
The hofstede’s model (power distance and uncertaintyThe hofstede’s model (power distance and uncertainty
The hofstede’s model (power distance and uncertaintyJessica Allison
 
Impact of LG Expatriate Managers_Facilitated Workshop Presentaion
Impact of LG Expatriate Managers_Facilitated Workshop PresentaionImpact of LG Expatriate Managers_Facilitated Workshop Presentaion
Impact of LG Expatriate Managers_Facilitated Workshop PresentaionSachin Mathews
 
Indian cultural dimensions
Indian cultural dimensionsIndian cultural dimensions
Indian cultural dimensionsPavel Kobychev
 
Visions On Governance Cpl
Visions On Governance CplVisions On Governance Cpl
Visions On Governance Cplsynergus
 
Workplace diversity management tookit and managers guide
Workplace diversity management tookit and managers guideWorkplace diversity management tookit and managers guide
Workplace diversity management tookit and managers guideInstansi
 
Nigeria Hofstede -olaolu onibonoje
Nigeria Hofstede -olaolu onibonojeNigeria Hofstede -olaolu onibonoje
Nigeria Hofstede -olaolu onibonojeOlaolu Onibonoje
 
An Overview - Diversity & Inclusion
An Overview - Diversity & InclusionAn Overview - Diversity & Inclusion
An Overview - Diversity & InclusionPartho Choudhury
 
Managing Diversity: A Comparison of two Indian Organizations
Managing Diversity: A Comparison of two Indian OrganizationsManaging Diversity: A Comparison of two Indian Organizations
Managing Diversity: A Comparison of two Indian OrganizationsNatasha Gupta
 
Module 2: Gender Strategy Development
Module 2: Gender Strategy DevelopmentModule 2: Gender Strategy Development
Module 2: Gender Strategy DevelopmentILRI
 

What's hot (20)

Organizing and managing across culture
Organizing and managing across cultureOrganizing and managing across culture
Organizing and managing across culture
 
Multicultural_guidance_and_counselling
Multicultural_guidance_and_counsellingMulticultural_guidance_and_counselling
Multicultural_guidance_and_counselling
 
Gender diversity in workplace
Gender diversity in workplaceGender diversity in workplace
Gender diversity in workplace
 
Human Resource Development and capacity building for NGOs, NPOs, VOs
Human Resource Development and capacity building for NGOs, NPOs, VOsHuman Resource Development and capacity building for NGOs, NPOs, VOs
Human Resource Development and capacity building for NGOs, NPOs, VOs
 
Concept and role of culture in International human resource management
Concept and  role of culture in International human resource managementConcept and  role of culture in International human resource management
Concept and role of culture in International human resource management
 
682 chapt611
682 chapt611682 chapt611
682 chapt611
 
Workforce diversity
Workforce diversityWorkforce diversity
Workforce diversity
 
Hofstede’s Newest Dimension: IVR
Hofstede’s Newest Dimension: IVRHofstede’s Newest Dimension: IVR
Hofstede’s Newest Dimension: IVR
 
Hofstede cultural dimensions
Hofstede cultural dimensionsHofstede cultural dimensions
Hofstede cultural dimensions
 
The hofstede’s model (power distance and uncertainty
The hofstede’s model (power distance and uncertaintyThe hofstede’s model (power distance and uncertainty
The hofstede’s model (power distance and uncertainty
 
Impact of LG Expatriate Managers_Facilitated Workshop Presentaion
Impact of LG Expatriate Managers_Facilitated Workshop PresentaionImpact of LG Expatriate Managers_Facilitated Workshop Presentaion
Impact of LG Expatriate Managers_Facilitated Workshop Presentaion
 
expat powerpoint
expat powerpointexpat powerpoint
expat powerpoint
 
Indian cultural dimensions
Indian cultural dimensionsIndian cultural dimensions
Indian cultural dimensions
 
Visions On Governance Cpl
Visions On Governance CplVisions On Governance Cpl
Visions On Governance Cpl
 
Workplace diversity management tookit and managers guide
Workplace diversity management tookit and managers guideWorkplace diversity management tookit and managers guide
Workplace diversity management tookit and managers guide
 
Nigeria Hofstede -olaolu onibonoje
Nigeria Hofstede -olaolu onibonojeNigeria Hofstede -olaolu onibonoje
Nigeria Hofstede -olaolu onibonoje
 
An Overview - Diversity & Inclusion
An Overview - Diversity & InclusionAn Overview - Diversity & Inclusion
An Overview - Diversity & Inclusion
 
Managing Diversity: A Comparison of two Indian Organizations
Managing Diversity: A Comparison of two Indian OrganizationsManaging Diversity: A Comparison of two Indian Organizations
Managing Diversity: A Comparison of two Indian Organizations
 
Chap2 culture
Chap2 cultureChap2 culture
Chap2 culture
 
Module 2: Gender Strategy Development
Module 2: Gender Strategy DevelopmentModule 2: Gender Strategy Development
Module 2: Gender Strategy Development
 

Similar to From Adversity to Diversity - the role of assessments in the transformation of South Africa.

Moving Beyond Mobility
Moving Beyond MobilityMoving Beyond Mobility
Moving Beyond MobilityLisa Ploeg
 
Human Resource Development In A Cultrually Diverse Environment
Human Resource Development In A Cultrually Diverse EnvironmentHuman Resource Development In A Cultrually Diverse Environment
Human Resource Development In A Cultrually Diverse EnvironmentAleeza Baig
 
Running head DIVERSITY PLAN .docx
Running head DIVERSITY PLAN                                      .docxRunning head DIVERSITY PLAN                                      .docx
Running head DIVERSITY PLAN .docxtodd271
 
New Equality And Diversity handout
New Equality And Diversity handoutNew Equality And Diversity handout
New Equality And Diversity handoutLaura Chapman
 
TelferSchool_WP-2014-01_Leck_Elliott_Bourgeois_Kemp
TelferSchool_WP-2014-01_Leck_Elliott_Bourgeois_KempTelferSchool_WP-2014-01_Leck_Elliott_Bourgeois_Kemp
TelferSchool_WP-2014-01_Leck_Elliott_Bourgeois_KempElliott Bourgeois
 
kier-diversity-research-report-2019.pdf
kier-diversity-research-report-2019.pdfkier-diversity-research-report-2019.pdf
kier-diversity-research-report-2019.pdfVanyaShukla4
 
Diversity management at Work Place
Diversity management at Work PlaceDiversity management at Work Place
Diversity management at Work PlaceHarshad Jain
 
Diversity Management The Challenges And Opportunities
Diversity Management   The Challenges And OpportunitiesDiversity Management   The Challenges And Opportunities
Diversity Management The Challenges And OpportunitiesShruti Bhatia
 
The Language of Diversity
The Language of DiversityThe Language of Diversity
The Language of DiversitySarah Jackson
 
TOPSpot-Diversity-August-28-2014
TOPSpot-Diversity-August-28-2014TOPSpot-Diversity-August-28-2014
TOPSpot-Diversity-August-28-2014Samantha Glave
 
Cur 518 wk 6 final slide share draft.
Cur 518 wk 6 final slide share draft.Cur 518 wk 6 final slide share draft.
Cur 518 wk 6 final slide share draft.Omegeia Banks-Ohara
 
How-to guide on attracting and recruiting diverse talent
How-to guide on attracting and recruiting diverse talentHow-to guide on attracting and recruiting diverse talent
How-to guide on attracting and recruiting diverse talentHarvey Nash Plc
 
Everyday_Inclusion_A4_FINAL_LOW_RES
Everyday_Inclusion_A4_FINAL_LOW_RESEveryday_Inclusion_A4_FINAL_LOW_RES
Everyday_Inclusion_A4_FINAL_LOW_RESRShort50
 
HOW TO INCORPORATE GENDER MAINSTREAMING AT THE WORKPLACE
HOW TO INCORPORATE GENDER  MAINSTREAMING  AT THE WORKPLACE HOW TO INCORPORATE GENDER  MAINSTREAMING  AT THE WORKPLACE
HOW TO INCORPORATE GENDER MAINSTREAMING AT THE WORKPLACE Abraham Ncunge
 
Unleashing the Power of Diversity and Inclusion: 11 Essential Chapters for Na...
Unleashing the Power of Diversity and Inclusion: 11 Essential Chapters for Na...Unleashing the Power of Diversity and Inclusion: 11 Essential Chapters for Na...
Unleashing the Power of Diversity and Inclusion: 11 Essential Chapters for Na...Enterprise Wired
 

Similar to From Adversity to Diversity - the role of assessments in the transformation of South Africa. (20)

Moving Beyond Mobility
Moving Beyond MobilityMoving Beyond Mobility
Moving Beyond Mobility
 
Report friday
Report friday Report friday
Report friday
 
Human Resource Development In A Cultrually Diverse Environment
Human Resource Development In A Cultrually Diverse EnvironmentHuman Resource Development In A Cultrually Diverse Environment
Human Resource Development In A Cultrually Diverse Environment
 
Running head DIVERSITY PLAN .docx
Running head DIVERSITY PLAN                                      .docxRunning head DIVERSITY PLAN                                      .docx
Running head DIVERSITY PLAN .docx
 
New Equality And Diversity handout
New Equality And Diversity handoutNew Equality And Diversity handout
New Equality And Diversity handout
 
Edd581 indv ar proprosal
Edd581 indv ar proprosalEdd581 indv ar proprosal
Edd581 indv ar proprosal
 
TelferSchool_WP-2014-01_Leck_Elliott_Bourgeois_Kemp
TelferSchool_WP-2014-01_Leck_Elliott_Bourgeois_KempTelferSchool_WP-2014-01_Leck_Elliott_Bourgeois_Kemp
TelferSchool_WP-2014-01_Leck_Elliott_Bourgeois_Kemp
 
kier-diversity-research-report-2019.pdf
kier-diversity-research-report-2019.pdfkier-diversity-research-report-2019.pdf
kier-diversity-research-report-2019.pdf
 
Diversity management at Work Place
Diversity management at Work PlaceDiversity management at Work Place
Diversity management at Work Place
 
Diversity Management The Challenges And Opportunities
Diversity Management   The Challenges And OpportunitiesDiversity Management   The Challenges And Opportunities
Diversity Management The Challenges And Opportunities
 
The Language of Diversity
The Language of DiversityThe Language of Diversity
The Language of Diversity
 
TOPSpot-Diversity-August-28-2014
TOPSpot-Diversity-August-28-2014TOPSpot-Diversity-August-28-2014
TOPSpot-Diversity-August-28-2014
 
Cur 518 wk 6 final slide share draft.
Cur 518 wk 6 final slide share draft.Cur 518 wk 6 final slide share draft.
Cur 518 wk 6 final slide share draft.
 
IAU_KU_2011_EEP Conclusion
IAU_KU_2011_EEP ConclusionIAU_KU_2011_EEP Conclusion
IAU_KU_2011_EEP Conclusion
 
PSYC704-Test-Essay
PSYC704-Test-EssayPSYC704-Test-Essay
PSYC704-Test-Essay
 
Key trends in shrm
Key trends in shrmKey trends in shrm
Key trends in shrm
 
How-to guide on attracting and recruiting diverse talent
How-to guide on attracting and recruiting diverse talentHow-to guide on attracting and recruiting diverse talent
How-to guide on attracting and recruiting diverse talent
 
Everyday_Inclusion_A4_FINAL_LOW_RES
Everyday_Inclusion_A4_FINAL_LOW_RESEveryday_Inclusion_A4_FINAL_LOW_RES
Everyday_Inclusion_A4_FINAL_LOW_RES
 
HOW TO INCORPORATE GENDER MAINSTREAMING AT THE WORKPLACE
HOW TO INCORPORATE GENDER  MAINSTREAMING  AT THE WORKPLACE HOW TO INCORPORATE GENDER  MAINSTREAMING  AT THE WORKPLACE
HOW TO INCORPORATE GENDER MAINSTREAMING AT THE WORKPLACE
 
Unleashing the Power of Diversity and Inclusion: 11 Essential Chapters for Na...
Unleashing the Power of Diversity and Inclusion: 11 Essential Chapters for Na...Unleashing the Power of Diversity and Inclusion: 11 Essential Chapters for Na...
Unleashing the Power of Diversity and Inclusion: 11 Essential Chapters for Na...
 

From Adversity to Diversity - the role of assessments in the transformation of South Africa.

  • 1. From Adversity to Diversity – The role of assessments in the transformation of South Africa. This paper discusses the important role of assessments in the Transformation of South Africa. The era of apartheid was characterised by a carefully socially engineered system masterminded by Dry HF Verwoerd – a professor of psychology and sociology. The plan included the education of black people to be “The hewers of wood” and the “drawers of water” i.e. people educated to lowly positions. This had a dramatic effect on Education is South Africa and resulted in a generation of people who were not able to fulfill their potential. When the dawn of the new democratic South Africa came in 1994, it was essential that talented people of races other than White could be identified. It was not possible to use results from educational systems as they could not be regarded as a true reflection of ability. This is where psychological assessment came into the picture. The new Employment Equity Act (South Africa’s Affirmative Action Act” covered the issue of psychological testing. The first draft did not mention potential, so a group of psychologist collaborated with the |Labour Dept. to include a clause of the assessment of potential. Without this further discrimination may have continued because ability assessment would favor the better educated white population. The assessment of potential became a very important issue for the world of psychological assessments. It resulted in several tests being developed which could measure potential and not be influenced by education. Some of these have now been introduced into many others countries in the world such as the UK, USA, and Australia. Assessment of potential carried some clear guidelines on how this was to be done – it could not be a verbal assessment because of language differences and thus non-verbal testing was introduced. Several brilliant South African psychologists earned their doctorates working on these tests. Assessments in the process of recruitment and selection 1 Organisational Performance P.O. Box 255 Morningside Sandton 2057 Anne Newman Counselling Psychologist anne@icon.co.za Cell: 082 570 6803 Ph: 011 463 6982 Fax: 011 706 6988 or 086 602 8350
  • 2. We have very stringent regulations around psychological assessment in South Africa, and this is appropriate given our history, and the need to establish fair working practices. Assessments need to be conducted according to competencies profiled for particular job roles. These competencies include both intellectual ability, potential for development and personal characteristics. Many organisations are opting for test batteries designed by psychologist to assist in their selection of the best person for the job based on assessments as well as other selection processes such as interviews. It has become possible to offer these assessments and recommendations for employment. There was some resistance to assessments when the Employment Equity Act was promulgated, but now we understand that psychological testing plays a vital role in placing competent people in key positions. We have a very wide range of instinctual assessment tools such as the Cognitive process Profile, The APIL B and TREAM series, the LPCAT, as well as assessment tools for personality characteristics such as: Occupational personally Profile Occupational Personality Questionnaire EQI 2 MBTI As well as specific tests such as: Thomas Kilman Conflict management Work Related Risk Profile Once a job has been profiled and key characteristics denied we can use psychological tests to demine fit for a job. Assessments to foster understanding and enhance the appreciation of diversity Another aspect of the transformation of South African was to learn to value our diversity and to appreciate rather than denigrate our differences. Many programmes were developed to help organisations with a cultural change process and a way in which people could learn to understand each other better and work together more effectively. Diversity does not only relate to gender and race although many organisations have focussed mainly on these. The value of diversity becomes apparent when tames learn to work together using the strengths of people and planning work according to particulate talents. Diversity is also apparent in differences in attitudes, thinking skills, aspects of emotional intelligence, The work of Hofstede has brought a great deal of insight into cultural differences in 2
  • 3. various countries. His assessment of 6 dimensions of cultural difference has been used to facilitate communication and working relationships amongst people in very many countries. His dimensions are: Power distance Individualism vs collectivism Masculinity vs femininity Uncertainty avoidance Long term orient orientation vs Short term orientation Indulgence vs restraint Organisations working internationally have used his work extensively to foster good communication and mutual understanding to effect work alliances, trade agreements etc. Another significant contribution to the debate on people and differences in the work of Gardner on Multiple intelligences. He postulates that there are many types of intelligence not just the concept of intellectual intelligence. He defines these as: Musical- rhythmic Visual- spatial Verbal- linguistic Logical – mathematical Bodily - kinesthetic Interpersonal Intrapersonal Naturalistic Steven Stein also contributed with his book the EQ Edge and his journal article entitled “Why Smart Leaders Fail”. His work, and that of many others, has further enlightened the work on the qualities of leadership. This will be discussed further under the topic of Diversity and Top Teams. In South Africa we have great diversity in cultures and languages. Because we lived apart in areas designated by colour, our only meeting with people from other races and cultures used to be in the work place, unless they were people employed to work as housekeepers or graders. Nowadays this has change but it is still true that for most of us we only really experience diversity in the workplace. Assessment to support Diversity in Top Team Management McKinsey & Coo (Leadership Development Programme) defines the 3 dimensions of Top Teams as: Alignment: 3
  • 4. • Shared assumptions about business context, strategy and goals • Shared beliefs about the Top Team • Purpose, values governing behaviour, balance between individual and collective interests Quality of Execution • Effective team configuration in terms of structure and processes, mix and level of skills, focus of time, incentives to work harder • High quality interaction in terms of respect, understanding, trust. Open communication, challenge, constructive conflict management and resolution Ability to renew • Sustainability which covers investment in team motivation and energy, balance of attention across difficult horizons and successful planning • Adaptability of the organisation and its context, openness to change, learning, effective internal and external communication Using this model one can plan a Top Team intervention and use assess characteristics to add to the debate and to help Top Team member to understand and appreciate their strengths and areas of development, and where particular would be best deployed to enhance team performance. 4