Managing Grid Constraints with Active Management Systems
1. Use Cases of Managing Grid
Constraints with Active Management
Systems
Chad Abbey
CEATI SGTF Meeting
October 2015
2. Contents
• Problem Description
• Changing Regulations and Technology Trends
• Active Network Management
• Use Cases
• North American Experiences
• Discussion
3. A (not so) Long Time Ago…
• Traditional planning rules
that define the “hosting
capacity” of a network
under N-1 criteria
• Challenge
– Can a new control approach
increase the amount of DG a
system can accommodate
– What planning tools are
required to support this new
way of doing things?
Substation
Generator
Generator
i v
Generator
i v
i vi v
4. New York State – Reforming the Energy Vision
• Comprehensive strategy to develop a cleaner and more
reliable, resilient and affordable energy system for all New
Yorkers
• Intended Policy outcomes:
– Customer knowledge, Market animation, System-wide efficiency,
Fuels and resource diversity, System reliability and resiliency, and
Carbon reduction.
• REV Demonstration projects
– Funding to demonstrate technology that further the vision
• NY Prize
– 40 M$ competition to help communities create microgrids
5. California
• Largest PV Solar industry in NA
– 9,977 MW of solar installed (4,316
MW in 2014)
– 2,182 solar companies
• Energy Storage Program
– PUC has mandated 1.3 GW by 2020
– 100 MW battery system in West LA
• Auto-DR
– Platform and program for automation
of DR at commercial facilities
• Distribution Resource Plans (DRP)
6. Ontario
• Leading Integration of Renewables and Smart Grid
Technologies in Canada
• OPA/IESO program
– Incentivized integration of energy storage for provision of
ancillary services
• OEB guidelines
– Recovery of costs through rates for demand response and
energy storage projects if their primary role is to defer CAPEX
7. Technology Alphabet Soup
• Distribution Management Systems
(DMS)
• Distributed Energy Resource
Management Systems (DERMS)
• Demand Response Management
Systems (DRMS)
• Microgrids
• Internet of Things (IoT)
• Systems of systems
• Fog Computing
9. Active Network Management
Substation
Generator
Generator
Generator
Generator
i v
Generator
i v
Historian
Real-Time Data
Manager (RTDM)
i vi v
OperationalServiceBus(OSB)
DNP3
IEC 61850
...
DNP3
REST
Historian
adapter
...
Generator outside
control of DERMS
DERMS enabled
generator
Real-Time Control
DERMS User Interface
10. Technology
ANM Platform Software Components
Application container to host autonomous ANM applications sharing a real time data manager
with sgs comms hub. Typically runs on commodity servers with hot failover redundancy (one as
Main and the other as Standby).
A modular, easy to integrate communications hub performing all data handling and processing
for sgs core via a range of standard industry protocols. Typically runs on commodity servers
(one as Main and the other as Standby)
A distributed software component located at each controlled device providing an interface to and
control of the grid edge device. Implements autonomous fail to safe mechanisms in the event of
non-compliance, loss of communications or abnormal operation.
ANM Software Applications using the Platform
Our ANM products use a combination of the ANM platform and software applications to deliver
specific functionality.
11. Integrated DERMS Platform
• Active network management:
automation layer that handles real-
time control of DER
• Analysis and Optimal
Scheduling: non-real time functions
that empower the operator and
enable a more holistic view of
operations
13. Use Case 1 – Thermal Constraint Management
Real-Time Data
Manager (RTDM)DNP3
IEC 61850
...
DNP3
REST
Historian
adapter
...
What-if Analysis
Substation
Generator
Generator
i v
Generator
i v
GIS
Historian
Generator
Generator
i vi v
OperationalServiceBus(OSB)
DERMS User Interface
Generator outside
control of DERMS
DERMS enabled
generator
Real-Time Control
Analysis and Scheduling
14. Orkney
Challenge
SSEPD seeking cost effective alternative to grid upgrades to
provide connections for renewable generators: network already at
‘full capacity’. Technical challenge is multiple thermal overloads
on various overhead and subsea cables.
Solution
Non-firm actively managed grid connections for distributed
generation using ANM 100 with an energy storage control
module.
Delivered Benefits
Operational since November 2009
Connected 24 MW of new renewable generation capacity to
33 kV grid previously considered to be full
103% of electricity demand met by renewables in 2013
Estimated saving of at least £30million
The Orkney Isles are located off the
north cost of Scotland and
interconnected to the main UK
transmission system.
Orkney Isles Background Information
• 70 islands with 20 inhabited
• ~1000 sq km and 21,000 inhabitants
• Winter peak demand of 31 MW
• Summer peak demand of 6 MW
• Installed background generation of 46 MW
• Annual average temperature 80C
• Industry mainly agricultural, fishing and tourism
15. NREL INTEGRATe Project
• Integrate Smart Campus as
part of IEEE 13 bus system
• Modified IEEE 13 bus
system to include
connection of secondary
network
• 3 DER embedded within
secondary network and
other simulated DER
15
16. Non-Wires Solutions
• Consolidated Edison
– Brooklyn Queens
Demand Response
(BQDM)
– Plymouth Street
• PowerStream
– DER options as
alternatives to capacity
– Ownership models
• Low Carbon London
– Proof of concept
17. Use Case 2 – Voltage Constraint Management
Substation
Generator
Generator
Generator
Generator
i v
Generator
i v
Historian
Real-Time Data
Manager (RTDM)
i vi v
OperationalServiceBus(OSB)
DNP3
IEC 61850
...
DNP3
REST
Historian
adapter
...
Generator outside
control of DERMS
DERMS enabled
generator
Real-Time Control
DERMS User Interface
18. • IUSA and SGS
partnering for NY “REV”
demo project
• Dynamic interconnect
option for large DG
using ANM platform
• Faster & cheaper than
traditional reinforcement
Targeted and value
driven smart grid
investments
Enables smart grid
“infrastructure as a
service” IUSA revenue
19. • Alternative grid
reinforcement
• Offers viable
interconnect solution for
otherwise uneconomic
DG interconnection
• Extendable and
scalable platform
Efficiently use existing
distribution assets
Supports data driven
distribution planning
Supports future “DER
markets” IUSA revenue
Valuing curtailed energy
DER-to-DER market
20. Use Case 3 – DER Aggregation and Scheduling
• Optimal
Scheduling based
on a holistic view
• Distribution
Marginal Prices
• Operator has
what-if analysis
tool
• Automation layer
ensures assets
are secure
Real-Time Data
Manager (RTDM)
OperationalServiceBus(OSB)
DNP3
IEC 61850
...
DNP3
REST
Historian
adapter
...
What-if Analysis
DER/Load
Forecasting
DER Scheduling
Pagg(πk)
Qagg(πk)
Aggregated
Generator
πk – economic signal generated within DER
Scheduling
DERMS User Interface
MDMS
GIS
Historian
EnterpriseServiceBus(ESB)
PV
Aggregator
Headend
ESS
Aggregator
Headend
SCADA/ADMS
Weather
Forecasts
Real-Time Control
Analysis and Scheduling
21. Discussion Questions
• Do you envisage integrating a DERMS system in the
near-future?
• If not, how do you plan on integrating DER?
• What are some of the characteristics of the ideal
operational tool that would help you integrate DER?
• Do you anticipate distribution operations (or even
microgrids) integrating with the ISO?
• What challenges do you have in terms of distribution
system planning?
22. Thoughts to leave you with…
• Regulatory model where revenues is dictated by performance
and not by how much capacity you build
• Is integrating DER equivalent to 200% of peak load possible?
• Other Critical National Infrastructure demand the best in real-
time control technologies, why should power systems be
different?
• Think of DERMS as a number of layers. The automation
layer—ANM—is the foundation
• Planners and operators need to be able to model the
behaviour of these systems.