The application of ‘CPR-for-all’ is the ultimate evidence drift. A treatment that is completely appropriate for dropping dead whilst running a marathon has almost no place in acute healthcare facilities where chronic irreversible complex co-morbidities abound. 90% of doctors would not choose CPR for themselves, yet 100% are trained in how to administer it to patients. Defaulting to ‘CPR-for-all’ removes a patients’ ability to provide informed consent for assault whilst they die from another disease. Remember - 2 weeks in ICU can spare you 5 minutes of difficult conversation.
2. “First I will define what I conceive medicine to
be. In general terms, it is to do away with the
sufferings of the sick, to lessen the violence of
their diseases, and to refuse to treat those who
are overmastered by their disease, realising that
in such cases medicine is powerless.
#Hippocrat
400 BC
4. A Brief History of CPR
5 Cases
35yr old under GA
9yr old post GA
80yr old under GA
12yr old under GA
45yr old in ED
1960
And no brain.
5. Public Perception of CPR
100 in-patients aged ≥70 years were asked
“if you had a cardiac arrest, what would happen?”
‘MisconceptionsAmongElderlyPatients’,
Adamsetal2006
81% believed they had ≥50% chance of leaving hospital
with no disability
23% believed the chance of no disability was
≥90%
6. TV Shows Country
No. Episodes
Screened
No. Cardiac
Arrests
Witnessed
Outcome
Casualty,
Cardiac Arrest,
Medics
UK 64 52* 25% survival
Grey’s Anatomy,
House
US 91 46
69.6% ROSC,
71.9% survival to hospital
discharge
ER,
Chicago Hope,
Rescue 911
US 97 60
75% ROSC,
67% survival to hospital
discharge
Star Trek: TNG,
DS9 & Voyager
Outer
Space 526 96
13% ROSC,
9% long-term survival
*48% of patients <35 years old
I realise this is an impossible task. Giving a talk on DNR at a conference almost wholeheartedly dedicated to resuscitation is like talking about right heart failure at an orthopaedic conference.
Define resuscitation: is CPR.
JAMA July 1960
James Jude was the cardiac surgeon who first described closed chest massage. He died this year, aged 87. Ironically, he wasn’t for CPR
Evidence drift
‘Pneumonic plague’
Trauma predominates. None of these are ‘old age’. British TV series ‘Cardiac Arrest’ (the only show written by a junior doctor) showed people with cancer receiving CPR - with a 100% mortality rate
For those who say the public don’t believe everything they see on television, I have 2 words for you:
PRESIDENT TRUMP
CPR is the thing that doctor’s don’t want the most
This is the pinnacle of modern resuscitation
Mostly unchanged for 50 years
If you do this long enough, some idiot will come along & put you on ECMO
Interesting definition of ‘high’ - 28-39%. This is SURVIVAL, not ‘neurologically meaningful survival’
CPC 1 is lives independently, 2 is lives in sheltered accommodation, 5 is brain dead
100 Elderly patients undergo in-hospital CPR
‘Alive’ or ‘success’ of CPR is usually defined as ‘has a pulse’
This is not a very patient-centric definition
There is a similar Japanese study
Because..
- arrests are either predicted by preceding deterioration so early intervention prevents that person arresting (so CPR is not needed) or...
- it is recognised that the patient is dying and that this process is irreversible so management focus is shifted to palliative intent (so CPR is not used as an assault on a dying patient)
We should not be training 100% of all doctors to perform CPR
We should be training 100% of all doctors to talk to patients about not doing CPR
CPR should be like any other treatment that requires consent
‘Surprise’ question
CPR is evidence drift at its worst
It is an inappropriate treatment for dying
Many in-patients have been deteriorating for some time before they arrest
If you’ve deteriorated to the point that you need CPR, you are dying
Talk to your patients about what CPR means & the likely outcomes
Treat it like any other treatment that requires consent
Teach your colleagues how to talk to people about not doing CPR
I’m not talking about not doing CPR. I’m talking about not doing it as the default