SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
From Deficiency to Biliteracy: Meeting the Needs of Long Term English Language Learners Presenter: Nelson Flores CUNY Graduate Center  [email_address] Principal Investigator:  Kate Menken CUNY Graduate Center & Queens College [email_address] with Tatyana Kleyn—City University of New York Laura Ascenzi-Moreno, Nabin Chae,  Alexander Funk – CUNY Graduate Center AERA Conference 2010 Denver, CO
LTELLs by Grade in New York City, 2007-2008 Source: NYCDOE, 2008 Grade Number % of  ELLs 7 2,839 32.5 8 2,365 28.6 9 4,120 29.8 10 3,411 25.6 11 1,825 24.4 12 2,270 35.4
Overview of Phase I ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Findings of Phase I ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Programming Sequence Content-Area Courses Programming for Long-Term  English Language Learners Spanish Language & Literacy Development Advanced Placement Spanish Language Course Spanish as a Native Language  (4 semesters) Advanced Placement Spanish Literature Course ESL Course Sequence ESL for LTELLs  (4 semesters) Exit ELL Status Content Courses infused with explicit literacy strategies
Phase II Overview ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Overview of Phase II Student Participants  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Hybrid Language Use ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Preference for English in Academic Setting ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Resistance toward Academic Spanish ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
A Third Category of LTELLs ,[object Object],[object Object]
Effects of Subtractive Schooling ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Academic Performance School GPA School 1 64% School 2 71% Average GPA 67.5% R: How are you doing in school? Mina: Okay. R: You’re doing okay. What kind of grades do you get? M: Umm, I get 75 to 58.
Program Outcomes in English
Program Outcomes in Spanish
Implications for Educating LTELLs  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
A Final Reminder ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
For further information… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

More Related Content

What's hot

English as a_second_lang_supplemental_154_taag
English as a_second_lang_supplemental_154_taagEnglish as a_second_lang_supplemental_154_taag
English as a_second_lang_supplemental_154_taagHDMcWhorter
 
Core subjects 4_8_211
Core subjects 4_8_211Core subjects 4_8_211
Core subjects 4_8_211Megan Berger
 
TELPAS K-12-EPLS Connection 2015-2016.final
TELPAS K-12-EPLS Connection 2015-2016.finalTELPAS K-12-EPLS Connection 2015-2016.final
TELPAS K-12-EPLS Connection 2015-2016.finalHDMcWhorter
 
ELLiE: a longitudinal transnational study on early language learning
ELLiE: a longitudinal transnational study on early language learningELLiE: a longitudinal transnational study on early language learning
ELLiE: a longitudinal transnational study on early language learningETAI 2010
 
CLIL Potential for Primary ELT by Yuki Yamano
CLIL Potential for Primary ELT by Yuki YamanoCLIL Potential for Primary ELT by Yuki Yamano
CLIL Potential for Primary ELT by Yuki YamanoRichard Pinner
 
Does CLIL work for Japanese secondary school students?: Potential for the ‘we...
Does CLIL work for Japanese secondary school students?: Potential for the ‘we...Does CLIL work for Japanese secondary school students?: Potential for the ‘we...
Does CLIL work for Japanese secondary school students?: Potential for the ‘we...Richard Pinner
 
Making the ELPS-TELPAS Connection K-12
Making the ELPS-TELPAS Connection K-12Making the ELPS-TELPAS Connection K-12
Making the ELPS-TELPAS Connection K-12hzengin
 
Assessment of English Learners (ELs)
Assessment of English Learners (ELs)Assessment of English Learners (ELs)
Assessment of English Learners (ELs)Megan Berger
 
Dimensions of integrating language learning and disciplinary learning at tert...
Dimensions of integrating language learning and disciplinary learning at tert...Dimensions of integrating language learning and disciplinary learning at tert...
Dimensions of integrating language learning and disciplinary learning at tert...Richard Pinner
 
Classroom practices
Classroom practicesClassroom practices
Classroom practicesHDMcWhorter
 
English Learners (ELs) in School
English Learners (ELs)  in SchoolEnglish Learners (ELs)  in School
English Learners (ELs) in SchoolMegan Berger
 
TESOL Staff Development PowerPoint
TESOL Staff Development PowerPointTESOL Staff Development PowerPoint
TESOL Staff Development PowerPointgoodoogasteve
 

What's hot (19)

English as a_second_lang_supplemental_154_taag
English as a_second_lang_supplemental_154_taagEnglish as a_second_lang_supplemental_154_taag
English as a_second_lang_supplemental_154_taag
 
T7 Preparing Chinese Language Teachers for American Schools
T7 Preparing Chinese Language Teachers for American SchoolsT7 Preparing Chinese Language Teachers for American Schools
T7 Preparing Chinese Language Teachers for American Schools
 
Core subjects 4_8_211
Core subjects 4_8_211Core subjects 4_8_211
Core subjects 4_8_211
 
S. Gong, M. Met, S. Talbot: Utah's Chinese Immersion Program (Q1)
S. Gong, M. Met, S. Talbot: Utah's Chinese Immersion Program (Q1)S. Gong, M. Met, S. Talbot: Utah's Chinese Immersion Program (Q1)
S. Gong, M. Met, S. Talbot: Utah's Chinese Immersion Program (Q1)
 
TELPAS K-12-EPLS Connection 2015-2016.final
TELPAS K-12-EPLS Connection 2015-2016.finalTELPAS K-12-EPLS Connection 2015-2016.final
TELPAS K-12-EPLS Connection 2015-2016.final
 
Power point
Power pointPower point
Power point
 
ELLiE: a longitudinal transnational study on early language learning
ELLiE: a longitudinal transnational study on early language learningELLiE: a longitudinal transnational study on early language learning
ELLiE: a longitudinal transnational study on early language learning
 
CLIL Potential for Primary ELT by Yuki Yamano
CLIL Potential for Primary ELT by Yuki YamanoCLIL Potential for Primary ELT by Yuki Yamano
CLIL Potential for Primary ELT by Yuki Yamano
 
Does CLIL work for Japanese secondary school students?: Potential for the ‘we...
Does CLIL work for Japanese secondary school students?: Potential for the ‘we...Does CLIL work for Japanese secondary school students?: Potential for the ‘we...
Does CLIL work for Japanese secondary school students?: Potential for the ‘we...
 
Making the ELPS-TELPAS Connection K-12
Making the ELPS-TELPAS Connection K-12Making the ELPS-TELPAS Connection K-12
Making the ELPS-TELPAS Connection K-12
 
Assessment of English Learners (ELs)
Assessment of English Learners (ELs)Assessment of English Learners (ELs)
Assessment of English Learners (ELs)
 
Dimensions of integrating language learning and disciplinary learning at tert...
Dimensions of integrating language learning and disciplinary learning at tert...Dimensions of integrating language learning and disciplinary learning at tert...
Dimensions of integrating language learning and disciplinary learning at tert...
 
Teaching Resume v. 4.1
Teaching Resume v. 4.1Teaching Resume v. 4.1
Teaching Resume v. 4.1
 
Classroom practices
Classroom practicesClassroom practices
Classroom practices
 
Lesson 5
Lesson 5Lesson 5
Lesson 5
 
English Learners (ELs) in School
English Learners (ELs)  in SchoolEnglish Learners (ELs)  in School
English Learners (ELs) in School
 
Lesson 6
Lesson 6Lesson 6
Lesson 6
 
Unit 2 - Rubrics
Unit 2 - RubricsUnit 2 - Rubrics
Unit 2 - Rubrics
 
TESOL Staff Development PowerPoint
TESOL Staff Development PowerPointTESOL Staff Development PowerPoint
TESOL Staff Development PowerPoint
 

Similar to LTELL Presentation at AERA

Mythbusters of second language acquisition
Mythbusters of second language acquisition Mythbusters of second language acquisition
Mythbusters of second language acquisition Carla Huck
 
Bilingual Education.ppt
Bilingual Education.pptBilingual Education.ppt
Bilingual Education.pptlisalayla
 
2013 supporting the eal students in the mfl classroom
2013 supporting the eal students in the mfl classroom2013 supporting the eal students in the mfl classroom
2013 supporting the eal students in the mfl classroomIsabelle Jones
 
Session2 myths&reality immersion_for posting
Session2 myths&reality immersion_for postingSession2 myths&reality immersion_for posting
Session2 myths&reality immersion_for postingMike Yamakawa
 
ESL Activities and Mini-Books
ESL Activities and Mini-BooksESL Activities and Mini-Books
ESL Activities and Mini-BooksAdrienne Kirby
 
The Problems and Prospects of Teaching English Language In Secondary Schools -
 The Problems and Prospects of Teaching English Language In Secondary Schools -  The Problems and Prospects of Teaching English Language In Secondary Schools -
The Problems and Prospects of Teaching English Language In Secondary Schools - FernandoBorgeMafuca
 
local_media4775930823258548627.pdf
local_media4775930823258548627.pdflocal_media4775930823258548627.pdf
local_media4775930823258548627.pdfORENCIAHASPERVENICEM
 
Class 10 English Language Learners
Class 10   English Language LearnersClass 10   English Language Learners
Class 10 English Language Learnersrmcquirter
 
Class 11 ell 2018
Class 11   ell 2018Class 11   ell 2018
Class 11 ell 2018rmcquirter
 
Class 10 ell slides 2018
Class 10   ell slides 2018Class 10   ell slides 2018
Class 10 ell slides 2018rmcquirter
 
Week 6 class 1 - ell - ruth
Week 6   class 1 - ell - ruthWeek 6   class 1 - ell - ruth
Week 6 class 1 - ell - ruthrmcquirter
 
Ch 4 literacy original
Ch 4 literacy originalCh 4 literacy original
Ch 4 literacy originalEllie Gordy
 
Second language learning in the classroom
Second language learning in the classroomSecond language learning in the classroom
Second language learning in the classroomAhmad Murtaqi
 
Ell field study portfolio amy johnstone kennedy
Ell field study portfolio amy johnstone kennedyEll field study portfolio amy johnstone kennedy
Ell field study portfolio amy johnstone kennedyAmy Kennedy
 
1. teyl + eyl 2018 2019-sri sc
1. teyl + eyl 2018 2019-sri sc1. teyl + eyl 2018 2019-sri sc
1. teyl + eyl 2018 2019-sri scSri Cahyati
 
Language learner profile methodology final
Language learner profile methodology finalLanguage learner profile methodology final
Language learner profile methodology finalTanĭa Contreras Novoa
 

Similar to LTELL Presentation at AERA (20)

Mythbusters of second language acquisition
Mythbusters of second language acquisition Mythbusters of second language acquisition
Mythbusters of second language acquisition
 
Bilingual Education.ppt
Bilingual Education.pptBilingual Education.ppt
Bilingual Education.ppt
 
Protocolo gabriela buenfil
Protocolo gabriela buenfilProtocolo gabriela buenfil
Protocolo gabriela buenfil
 
Nyu Pte Overview Of Ells Oct2009
Nyu Pte Overview Of Ells Oct2009Nyu Pte Overview Of Ells Oct2009
Nyu Pte Overview Of Ells Oct2009
 
2013 supporting the eal students in the mfl classroom
2013 supporting the eal students in the mfl classroom2013 supporting the eal students in the mfl classroom
2013 supporting the eal students in the mfl classroom
 
Session2 myths&reality immersion_for posting
Session2 myths&reality immersion_for postingSession2 myths&reality immersion_for posting
Session2 myths&reality immersion_for posting
 
ESL Activities and Mini-Books
ESL Activities and Mini-BooksESL Activities and Mini-Books
ESL Activities and Mini-Books
 
The Problems and Prospects of Teaching English Language In Secondary Schools -
 The Problems and Prospects of Teaching English Language In Secondary Schools -  The Problems and Prospects of Teaching English Language In Secondary Schools -
The Problems and Prospects of Teaching English Language In Secondary Schools -
 
local_media4775930823258548627.pdf
local_media4775930823258548627.pdflocal_media4775930823258548627.pdf
local_media4775930823258548627.pdf
 
Njtesol07
Njtesol07Njtesol07
Njtesol07
 
Class 10 English Language Learners
Class 10   English Language LearnersClass 10   English Language Learners
Class 10 English Language Learners
 
Class 11 ell 2018
Class 11   ell 2018Class 11   ell 2018
Class 11 ell 2018
 
Class 10 ell slides 2018
Class 10   ell slides 2018Class 10   ell slides 2018
Class 10 ell slides 2018
 
Week 6 class 1 - ell - ruth
Week 6   class 1 - ell - ruthWeek 6   class 1 - ell - ruth
Week 6 class 1 - ell - ruth
 
Ch 4 literacy original
Ch 4 literacy originalCh 4 literacy original
Ch 4 literacy original
 
Second language learning in the classroom
Second language learning in the classroomSecond language learning in the classroom
Second language learning in the classroom
 
Ell field study portfolio amy johnstone kennedy
Ell field study portfolio amy johnstone kennedyEll field study portfolio amy johnstone kennedy
Ell field study portfolio amy johnstone kennedy
 
1. teyl + eyl 2018 2019-sri sc
1. teyl + eyl 2018 2019-sri sc1. teyl + eyl 2018 2019-sri sc
1. teyl + eyl 2018 2019-sri sc
 
Language learner profile methodology final
Language learner profile methodology finalLanguage learner profile methodology final
Language learner profile methodology final
 
Chapter1
Chapter1Chapter1
Chapter1
 

LTELL Presentation at AERA

  • 1. From Deficiency to Biliteracy: Meeting the Needs of Long Term English Language Learners Presenter: Nelson Flores CUNY Graduate Center [email_address] Principal Investigator: Kate Menken CUNY Graduate Center & Queens College [email_address] with Tatyana Kleyn—City University of New York Laura Ascenzi-Moreno, Nabin Chae, Alexander Funk – CUNY Graduate Center AERA Conference 2010 Denver, CO
  • 2. LTELLs by Grade in New York City, 2007-2008 Source: NYCDOE, 2008 Grade Number % of ELLs 7 2,839 32.5 8 2,365 28.6 9 4,120 29.8 10 3,411 25.6 11 1,825 24.4 12 2,270 35.4
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5. Programming Sequence Content-Area Courses Programming for Long-Term English Language Learners Spanish Language & Literacy Development Advanced Placement Spanish Language Course Spanish as a Native Language (4 semesters) Advanced Placement Spanish Literature Course ESL Course Sequence ESL for LTELLs (4 semesters) Exit ELL Status Content Courses infused with explicit literacy strategies
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13. Academic Performance School GPA School 1 64% School 2 71% Average GPA 67.5% R: How are you doing in school? Mina: Okay. R: You’re doing okay. What kind of grades do you get? M: Umm, I get 75 to 58.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.

Editor's Notes

  1. Limited literacy skills in English and their native language, in combination with strong oral skills for social purposes, are defining characteristics ALLD Pre-Test indicates that EBs read on average three grades below level in English and three and one-half grades below level in Spanish (though with a wide range, particularly in Spanish)
  2. This slide presents a visual model of the programmatic structure implemented at the two study sites. The program incorporates the previous points of a focus on literacy development in both English and Spanish language, academic literacy across content areas, and consistency in programming across the school. This visual model also presents the programming across time – students will take Spanish for 4 semesters eventually taking the Spanish regents – which underlines the program’s emphasis on academic language. These students will take an ESL course which is separate from the needs of newcomers – acknowledging their oral skills but weaknesses in literacy.
  3. The second phase of a 3 year study. The first phase included interviews with
  4. English ALLD Performance & Gain These scores are determined by ANOVA and measured by grade levels below. Both schools showed improvement in average grade level. School 3, the control school, showed a loss.
  5. Spanish ALLD Performance & Gains By the end of the study, students in School 1 performed significantly better. Student performance at school 2 remained relatively flat (did not experience language loss) School 3, the control school, experienced loss in performance.