SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
Download to read offline
Valve Comparison
    Item            SMC Ball Valve          Stainless steel Valve             PVC Valve



   Types




   Major               S      M C              Stainless Steel,      Polyvinyl Chloride(PVC)
 Ingredients                                  Rubber or Teflon

Manufacturing    Heat Press Foaming        Casting Work, Cut-off      Casting Work, Cutting
  Process                                      Work, Finishing       Work, Injection Molding
                                                   Process
Manufacturing              Short                    Long                        Long
    Time
                (Simple Structure,         (Complicated              (Complicated Structure,
                Process Simplification)    Structure, Difficult to   Difficult to
                                           manufacture)              manufacture)
Watertightnes          Very High                   High                     Average
     s          Perfect watertight using   Watertight by a ball      Watertight by a ball
                an O-ring and 2            and O-ring on the         and O-ring on the
                Teflon Sheets              inside. But possible      inside
                                           to occur the problem
                                           due to the wear of
                                           the O-ring
Deformation                 No                       No                   Occurrence of
  by Heat                                                              deformation by heat
                (Almost no deformation                               (The valve is easily
                occurs due to the                                    deformed even at low
                material of the                                      heat due to the
                thermo-hardening resin                               properties of the
                - Excellent in heat                                  typical material of the
                resistance)                                          thermoplastic resin-
                                                                     remarkably low in heat
                                                                     resistance
 Harmful to     Same material as water     Harmless but              Highly harmful to
   human        tank and harmless to       potentially harmful       human body by a large
                human body                 depending on the          amount of hazardous
                                           material of internal      substances emitted
coating agent           from PVC itself.
Maintenance    Almost no maintenance      High maintenance        High maintenance cost
               required                   cost
               (No maintenance            (Steady maintenance     (Frequent replacement
               required as this is free   required due to the     required due to the
               from rust, scale, etc.)    rust etc. in the        deformation by heat in
                                          external valve)         summer and freeze
                                                                  and rupture in winter)




   Item             SMC Ball Valve         Acid-Resistant Valve         PVC Valve


Product Life       Semi-permanent          3~4 years (Frequent    1~2 years (Depending
                                                   rust)            on deformation by
                                                                           heat)
 Strengths       Excellent in corrosion
               resistance and strength
               as it is made of SMC
               material and no crack
               occurred due to the
               distinctive durableness
               unique to SMC material
                 In addition to the         No deformation due      Goon in chemical
               semi-permanent             to the high heat        resistance
               material life, it is       (Based on SUS316L)
               designed to allow the      (But, possible freeze
               replacement of the         and rupture in low
               wear part only easily.     temperature)
               Easy maintenance,
               repair, etc.
                 Good in chemical
               resistance and
               abrasion resistance. No
               freeze and rupture.
               Lower in price                                     Lower in price
               compared to stainless                              compared to stainless
               steel products (Refer                              steel products
               to the price list
               enclosed)
Low construction                                      Low construction cost
           cost as its weight is                                   as its weight is lighter
           lighter than metal                                      than metal products.
           products.
Weakness     Requires large direct    Deformation occurred           Low in heat and cold
           investment costs for       by high heat in case         resistance
           making molds as it is      of SUS304
           a molded product             Expensive and low            High in gas
                                      in corrosion                 permeability
                                      resistance
                                        Rust when left               Strength becomes
                                      unattended for a long        weak when exposed to
                                      time                         the nature
                                         Difficult to install or     High specific gravity
                                      replace due to the
                                      heavy weight of
                                      product
                                        No part level                Harmful to human
                                      replacement possible         body (use a plasticizer
                                      and it requires to           and stabilizer)
                                      replace the entire
                                      valve even when only
                                      a part is defective
                                                                     High maintenance
                                                                   costs due to short
                                                                   product life
기타사항       Excellent in acid          Decline of market            Degradation of
           resistance, chemical       share                        Competitiveness
           resistance, abrasion
                                         Caused by an                 Caused by the
           resistance, etc. and
                                      expensive product            occurrence of many
           applicable to broad
                                      price, management            problems, etc.
           and various fields such
                                      issues, etc.
           as water supplies,
           Purification plants,
           General chemistry
           companies, drug use
           pipelines, general
           industrial water,
           terminal disposal plants
           of sewage, general
           wastewater treatment
           facilities, general
seawater pipelines, etc.

More Related Content

What's hot

Plug & Abandonment
Plug & AbandonmentPlug & Abandonment
Plug & Abandonment
Statoil
 
Well Completion Design.pdf
Well Completion Design.pdfWell Completion Design.pdf
Well Completion Design.pdf
mmody4
 
Subsea well intervention: Learning from the past - planning for the future
Subsea well intervention: Learning from the past - planning for the futureSubsea well intervention: Learning from the past - planning for the future
Subsea well intervention: Learning from the past - planning for the future
Statoil
 
Feed Screw Manufacturing & Design For Injection / Extrusion / Blowmolding | G...
Feed Screw Manufacturing & Design For Injection / Extrusion / Blowmolding | G...Feed Screw Manufacturing & Design For Injection / Extrusion / Blowmolding | G...
Feed Screw Manufacturing & Design For Injection / Extrusion / Blowmolding | G...
Glycon Corp.
 
Casing Accessories , completion tools, liner hanger system
Casing Accessories , completion tools, liner hanger systemCasing Accessories , completion tools, liner hanger system
Casing Accessories , completion tools, liner hanger system
WellCare Oil Tools Private Limited, India.
 

What's hot (20)

Industrial Training on PLC SCADA HMI for fresher engineers
Industrial Training on PLC SCADA HMI for fresher engineersIndustrial Training on PLC SCADA HMI for fresher engineers
Industrial Training on PLC SCADA HMI for fresher engineers
 
pumps
pumpspumps
pumps
 
Hydraulic workover and snubbing solutions, رضا مصطفوی طباطبایی
Hydraulic workover and snubbing solutions, رضا مصطفوی طباطبایی Hydraulic workover and snubbing solutions, رضا مصطفوی طباطبایی
Hydraulic workover and snubbing solutions, رضا مصطفوی طباطبایی
 
Control Valves
Control ValvesControl Valves
Control Valves
 
Hydraulic Pump
Hydraulic PumpHydraulic Pump
Hydraulic Pump
 
Plug & Abandonment
Plug & AbandonmentPlug & Abandonment
Plug & Abandonment
 
S7 400 h
S7 400 hS7 400 h
S7 400 h
 
When is a SIL Rating of a Valve Required?
When is a SIL Rating of a Valve Required?When is a SIL Rating of a Valve Required?
When is a SIL Rating of a Valve Required?
 
Mechanical Seal for Pumps by Engr. Muhammad Shahbaz
Mechanical Seal for Pumps by Engr. Muhammad ShahbazMechanical Seal for Pumps by Engr. Muhammad Shahbaz
Mechanical Seal for Pumps by Engr. Muhammad Shahbaz
 
Cement& slurry design
Cement& slurry designCement& slurry design
Cement& slurry design
 
Api 671 4 th edition dresser rand ref x 46091 (3)
Api 671 4 th edition dresser rand ref x 46091 (3)Api 671 4 th edition dresser rand ref x 46091 (3)
Api 671 4 th edition dresser rand ref x 46091 (3)
 
Well Completion Design.pdf
Well Completion Design.pdfWell Completion Design.pdf
Well Completion Design.pdf
 
Valves and its types
Valves and its types Valves and its types
Valves and its types
 
Subsea well intervention: Learning from the past - planning for the future
Subsea well intervention: Learning from the past - planning for the futureSubsea well intervention: Learning from the past - planning for the future
Subsea well intervention: Learning from the past - planning for the future
 
Feed Screw Manufacturing & Design For Injection / Extrusion / Blowmolding | G...
Feed Screw Manufacturing & Design For Injection / Extrusion / Blowmolding | G...Feed Screw Manufacturing & Design For Injection / Extrusion / Blowmolding | G...
Feed Screw Manufacturing & Design For Injection / Extrusion / Blowmolding | G...
 
Basic hydraulic circuit
Basic hydraulic circuitBasic hydraulic circuit
Basic hydraulic circuit
 
Valves presentation
Valves presentationValves presentation
Valves presentation
 
Casing Accessories , completion tools, liner hanger system
Casing Accessories , completion tools, liner hanger systemCasing Accessories , completion tools, liner hanger system
Casing Accessories , completion tools, liner hanger system
 
pump calculation pdf .pdf
pump calculation pdf .pdfpump calculation pdf .pdf
pump calculation pdf .pdf
 
Offshore platform slot recovery process
Offshore platform slot recovery processOffshore platform slot recovery process
Offshore platform slot recovery process
 

Viewers also liked

VALVES AND THEIR TYPES
VALVES AND THEIR TYPESVALVES AND THEIR TYPES
VALVES AND THEIR TYPES
Madhur Mahajan
 
NEW Carten HiLife Series General Industry Brochure
NEW Carten HiLife Series General Industry BrochureNEW Carten HiLife Series General Industry Brochure
NEW Carten HiLife Series General Industry Brochure
Rebecca Caulfield
 
Valve types and selection
Valve types and selectionValve types and selection
Valve types and selection
Musa Sabri
 

Viewers also liked (15)

Valve Information
Valve InformationValve Information
Valve Information
 
VALVES AND THEIR TYPES
VALVES AND THEIR TYPESVALVES AND THEIR TYPES
VALVES AND THEIR TYPES
 
NEW Carten HiLife Series General Industry Brochure
NEW Carten HiLife Series General Industry BrochureNEW Carten HiLife Series General Industry Brochure
NEW Carten HiLife Series General Industry Brochure
 
Valve sizing reference
Valve sizing referenceValve sizing reference
Valve sizing reference
 
CV
CV CV
CV
 
Short Information Valve
Short Information ValveShort Information Valve
Short Information Valve
 
Válvulas de bola - Ball Valves
Válvulas de bola - Ball ValvesVálvulas de bola - Ball Valves
Válvulas de bola - Ball Valves
 
Continual improvement tools
Continual improvement toolsContinual improvement tools
Continual improvement tools
 
valve maintenance
valve maintenancevalve maintenance
valve maintenance
 
Classification of valves
Classification of valvesClassification of valves
Classification of valves
 
Valve Selection & Sizing
Valve Selection & SizingValve Selection & Sizing
Valve Selection & Sizing
 
Stainless Steel ball Valve manufacturer in Hebei
Stainless Steel ball Valve manufacturer in HebeiStainless Steel ball Valve manufacturer in Hebei
Stainless Steel ball Valve manufacturer in Hebei
 
Valves ppt
Valves pptValves ppt
Valves ppt
 
Valve types and selection
Valve types and selectionValve types and selection
Valve types and selection
 
Valves
Valves Valves
Valves
 

Similar to Valve Comparison Table

Toyo Riser Pipes Sea Grade
Toyo Riser Pipes Sea GradeToyo Riser Pipes Sea Grade
Toyo Riser Pipes Sea Grade
Azhar Qadri
 
Zeus impactand plastics
Zeus impactand plasticsZeus impactand plastics
Zeus impactand plastics
close2u23
 
120228 Composites EXPO 2012
120228 Composites EXPO 2012120228 Composites EXPO 2012
120228 Composites EXPO 2012
Toine Dinnissen
 
Borosilicate glass-tube
Borosilicate glass-tubeBorosilicate glass-tube
Borosilicate glass-tube
nobleglass
 

Similar to Valve Comparison Table (20)

Insta strip
Insta stripInsta strip
Insta strip
 
Insta strip
Insta stripInsta strip
Insta strip
 
Toyo Riser Pipes Sea Grade
Toyo Riser Pipes Sea GradeToyo Riser Pipes Sea Grade
Toyo Riser Pipes Sea Grade
 
General Requirement of Materials.pdf
General Requirement of Materials.pdfGeneral Requirement of Materials.pdf
General Requirement of Materials.pdf
 
Plastics
PlasticsPlastics
Plastics
 
NEWER ADVANCES IN IMPLANT MATERIALS.pptx
NEWER ADVANCES IN IMPLANT MATERIALS.pptxNEWER ADVANCES IN IMPLANT MATERIALS.pptx
NEWER ADVANCES IN IMPLANT MATERIALS.pptx
 
Refractories lesson introduction slidesh
Refractories lesson introduction slideshRefractories lesson introduction slidesh
Refractories lesson introduction slidesh
 
TALAT Lecture 2104.02: Case Study on Windows
TALAT Lecture 2104.02: Case Study on WindowsTALAT Lecture 2104.02: Case Study on Windows
TALAT Lecture 2104.02: Case Study on Windows
 
Polymeric Surge Arrester
Polymeric Surge ArresterPolymeric Surge Arrester
Polymeric Surge Arrester
 
A Designer's Introduction to the Development, Design and Application of Vinyl...
A Designer's Introduction to the Development, Design and Application of Vinyl...A Designer's Introduction to the Development, Design and Application of Vinyl...
A Designer's Introduction to the Development, Design and Application of Vinyl...
 
What is Corrosion in Reinforced Bars?
What is Corrosion in Reinforced Bars?What is Corrosion in Reinforced Bars?
What is Corrosion in Reinforced Bars?
 
Machinists Handbook
Machinists   HandbookMachinists   Handbook
Machinists Handbook
 
Sustainable Solutions for Thermal, Fire & Sound Control – Roxul
Sustainable Solutions for Thermal, Fire & Sound Control – RoxulSustainable Solutions for Thermal, Fire & Sound Control – Roxul
Sustainable Solutions for Thermal, Fire & Sound Control – Roxul
 
Use of Sheet Lead as the Protective Shielding
Use of Sheet Lead as the Protective ShieldingUse of Sheet Lead as the Protective Shielding
Use of Sheet Lead as the Protective Shielding
 
Zeus impactand plastics
Zeus impactand plasticsZeus impactand plastics
Zeus impactand plastics
 
Metallurgy--intro
Metallurgy--introMetallurgy--intro
Metallurgy--intro
 
porcelain and polymeric insulators Analysis
porcelain and polymeric insulators Analysisporcelain and polymeric insulators Analysis
porcelain and polymeric insulators Analysis
 
Canada Metal: Lead sheet metal for nuclear shielding, Construction
Canada Metal: Lead sheet metal for nuclear shielding, ConstructionCanada Metal: Lead sheet metal for nuclear shielding, Construction
Canada Metal: Lead sheet metal for nuclear shielding, Construction
 
120228 Composites EXPO 2012
120228 Composites EXPO 2012120228 Composites EXPO 2012
120228 Composites EXPO 2012
 
Borosilicate glass-tube
Borosilicate glass-tubeBorosilicate glass-tube
Borosilicate glass-tube
 

Valve Comparison Table

  • 1. Valve Comparison Item SMC Ball Valve Stainless steel Valve PVC Valve Types Major S M C Stainless Steel, Polyvinyl Chloride(PVC) Ingredients Rubber or Teflon Manufacturing Heat Press Foaming Casting Work, Cut-off Casting Work, Cutting Process Work, Finishing Work, Injection Molding Process Manufacturing Short Long Long Time (Simple Structure, (Complicated (Complicated Structure, Process Simplification) Structure, Difficult to Difficult to manufacture) manufacture) Watertightnes Very High High Average s Perfect watertight using Watertight by a ball Watertight by a ball an O-ring and 2 and O-ring on the and O-ring on the Teflon Sheets inside. But possible inside to occur the problem due to the wear of the O-ring Deformation No No Occurrence of by Heat deformation by heat (Almost no deformation (The valve is easily occurs due to the deformed even at low material of the heat due to the thermo-hardening resin properties of the - Excellent in heat typical material of the resistance) thermoplastic resin- remarkably low in heat resistance Harmful to Same material as water Harmless but Highly harmful to human tank and harmless to potentially harmful human body by a large human body depending on the amount of hazardous material of internal substances emitted
  • 2. coating agent from PVC itself. Maintenance Almost no maintenance High maintenance High maintenance cost required cost (No maintenance (Steady maintenance (Frequent replacement required as this is free required due to the required due to the from rust, scale, etc.) rust etc. in the deformation by heat in external valve) summer and freeze and rupture in winter) Item SMC Ball Valve Acid-Resistant Valve PVC Valve Product Life Semi-permanent 3~4 years (Frequent 1~2 years (Depending rust) on deformation by heat) Strengths Excellent in corrosion resistance and strength as it is made of SMC material and no crack occurred due to the distinctive durableness unique to SMC material In addition to the No deformation due Goon in chemical semi-permanent to the high heat resistance material life, it is (Based on SUS316L) designed to allow the (But, possible freeze replacement of the and rupture in low wear part only easily. temperature) Easy maintenance, repair, etc. Good in chemical resistance and abrasion resistance. No freeze and rupture. Lower in price Lower in price compared to stainless compared to stainless steel products (Refer steel products to the price list enclosed)
  • 3. Low construction Low construction cost cost as its weight is as its weight is lighter lighter than metal than metal products. products. Weakness Requires large direct Deformation occurred Low in heat and cold investment costs for by high heat in case resistance making molds as it is of SUS304 a molded product Expensive and low High in gas in corrosion permeability resistance Rust when left Strength becomes unattended for a long weak when exposed to time the nature Difficult to install or High specific gravity replace due to the heavy weight of product No part level Harmful to human replacement possible body (use a plasticizer and it requires to and stabilizer) replace the entire valve even when only a part is defective High maintenance costs due to short product life 기타사항 Excellent in acid Decline of market Degradation of resistance, chemical share Competitiveness resistance, abrasion Caused by an Caused by the resistance, etc. and expensive product occurrence of many applicable to broad price, management problems, etc. and various fields such issues, etc. as water supplies, Purification plants, General chemistry companies, drug use pipelines, general industrial water, terminal disposal plants of sewage, general wastewater treatment facilities, general