SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 10
Download to read offline
MULTIPLE STRATEGIES AND TECHNOLOGIES TO COMBAT

                              COUNTERFEIT DRUGS
                                                                  Authors: Sanjay Modi and Sanjeev Wadhwa




An anti-counterfeiting        The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has seen a rise of
strategy helps to             counterfeit drug cases since 2000 when there were only six. In 2006,
effectively detect            the number of cases rose dramatically to 54 (Bernstein, 2007). The
counterfeit products,         market for counterfeit drug is approximately $40 billion (WHO, 2006).
increase audit compliance,    According to the Center for Medicines in the Public Interest, counterfeit
and enhance supply chain      drug sales globally will reach $75 billion by 2010. This represents an
management capabilities.      increase of 90 percent from 2005 (WHO, 2006) and will represent 14
This strategy can identify    percent of the total drug market (Pitts, 2005). Furthermore, it is
the multiple best-fit         estimated that 10 percent of the global medicines are counterfeit.
solutions for meeting a       Approximately 60 percent of counterfeit drug cases occur in less-
company’s requirements        developed countries in which 25 percent of their drug supply is
via Radio Frequency           counterfeit (Morris, 2006). The largest producers of these drugs are
Identification Devices        Southeast Asia, Nigeria, Russia, Mexico, Brazil, and Latin America (U.S.
(RFID), ePedigrees, label     Immigration and Customs Enforcement, 2006).
security, dosage unit level
                              Counterfeit drugs are an increasing threat in the marketplace. These sub-
security, nanotechnology,
                              standard drugs affect human lives as the quality and/or type of drug is
and other capable
                              harmful to the patient. These products may not cure the targeted
solutions to combat
                              diseases and could possibly even kill patients. Also, they affect the
counterfeiting of drug
                              profits of the companies which manufacture the drugs. Pharmaceutical
products. One item alone
                              companies invest large amounts of resources to create drugs. They
will not protect the
                              spend up to 12 years and $1.2 billion on clinical development for drugs
companies from counter-
                              (Archarya, 2006). However, only 30 percent of drugs which are
feit drugs, but one with a
                              approved and marketed produce revenues that match or exceed initial
multi-level approach will
                              costs (DiMasi, 2002). Therefore, any counterfeit drugs sold as legitimate
lead to safeguarding the
                              drugs reduce the companies’ revenues and lead to lower profits.
supply chain, prevent
erosion of the brand          There are five different types of counterfeit mechanisms in which drugs
image, and increase           are manufactured or distributed without proper regulatory approval and
revenues. This will result    do not meet the determined standards of safety, quality, and efficacy
in decreasing the number      (WHO, 2007):
of counterfeit products in
                                • No active ingredient (43 percent)
the marketplace and
improving patient safety        • Low levels of active ingredient (21 percent)
and enhancing product           • Poor quality drugs (24 percent)
authenticity and                • Wrong ingredients (2 percent)
identification.                 • Wrong packaging or source (7 percent)
                              Counterfeiting can apply to both branded and generic products. In
                              wealthy developed countries, expensive drugs such as hormones,
                              steroids, and antihistamines are frequently counterfeited due to lifestyle
                              preferences. While in developing countries, those used to treat life-
                              threatening conditions such as malaria, TB, and HIV/AIDS are chosen to
                              be imitated due to their relatively high costs. As this trend continues,


                                | Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs |       1
other drugs such as anti-cancer and anti-virals might        Therefore, counterfeit drugs are passed as real drugs
be next on the list due to the high costs of these           due to the counterfeiters’ abilities to reproduce items.
drugs and the lucrative returns by the counterfeiters.

Sources of Counterfeit Medicines                                    C o u n terfeit    A u th en tic
Counterfeit drugs can be diverted and sold from                 1                                      1. Logo background
various channels within the drug distribution system            2        LO G O        LOG O              color
due to its complexity. There is no enforced                                                            2. Logo font not bolded
                                                                                                       3. Colored protective
government mandate to track the drugs efficiently               3        Logo           Logo              packaging on rim
                                                                                                          on top of bottle
within the system which allows for openings for                                                        4. Border type
counterfeiters throughout the system. Drugs can be                                                     5. Font size
                                                                4                                      6. Border size
diverted from their original purpose and sold outside                   D ru g         D ru g          7. Pill size and shape
the regulated distributed channels. For example, free           5       N am e                         8. Name of pill varies
                                                                                       N am e
samples to doctors may be sold illegally within the                     50m g
                                                                6                      50m g           Can you tell the difference
                                                                                                       if one of the above items
system. Patients may, in turn, sell their prescription                                                 were changed?
drugs for a profit. Also, drugs sold for lower prices in
various countries can be sold to other markets where            7
                                                                            D           P5
the price is higher. These drugs are not regulated              8
through safeguards as they are sold outside the
normal distribution channels                                  Figure 1: Difference between Counterfeit and
                                                              Authentic Drugs
The 1988 Prescription Drug Marketing Act (PDMA)
introduced a need for paper drug pedigree to track           As a result of illegal medical drugs within the system,
the drug from manufacturer to end user. However, it          the companies that manufacture and sell the
has yet to be fully implemented throughout the               authentic products incur large losses of revenue. This
industry and supply chain due to the high record-            decreases sales and profit margins due to other
keeping effort needed to maintain this type of               unauthenticated “substitute” products that people
system. Incomplete paper pedigrees lead to                   are buying in place of the authenticated drug
increasing the risk of counterfeit drugs in the              product. Large inventory losses and write-offs are
marketplace as the ingredients or products are not           placed on the balance sheets due to routing leakages
tracked within the supply chain. On the other hand,          and medicines which were not purchased legally. As
complete paper pedigrees help validate the                   noted earlier, these drugs threaten patient safety
authenticity of the drug but counterfeiters are finding      leading to possible deaths. There are audit and
ways around this paper-based process. For example,           regulatory compliance issues with counterfeit drugs
illegitimate secondary wholesalers can prepare fake          as they do not follow the regulated channels.
paper pedigree documents which pharmacies detect             Furthermore, the supply chain for the drugs is
as valid. An increasing trend is to use tools and            complicated due to higher inventory carryover
processes to copy drug labels and packages. This             leading to increased costs. The supply chain issues
makes it difficult to identify the real drug from the        push for an efficient and reliable tracking mechanism
fake copy due to the striking similarities between the       which has yet to be mandated by the industry or
two. Repackaging is another way to bring expired or          regulators due to high initial costs and lack of
compromised drugs into the distribution system and           industry standards.
mix them with genuine drugs. Finally, the lack of
tamper-evident packaging allows the original                 Anti-Counterfeit Strategies
packaging to be reused for unregulated drugs                 An anti-counterfeiting strategy helps to effectively
(HHS, 2004).                                                 detect counterfeit products, increase audit
                                                             compliance, and enhance supply chain management
The differences between counterfeit and authentic
                                                             capabilities. This strategy can identify the multiple
drugs can be difficult to detect unless one looks
                                                             best-fit solutions for meeting a company’s
closely at the bottle or packaging. These can be
                                                             requirements via Radio Frequency Identification
minor changes in the product container, label, or the
                                                             Devices (RFID), ePedigrees, label security, dosage
individual pill that can be hard to visually detect by
                                                             unit level security, nanotechnology, and other capable
the human eye. For example, a change in the type of
                                                             solutions to combat counterfeiting of drug products.
font, border type, or logo color is difficult to detect
                                                             One item alone will not protect the companies from
unless someone knows how they are packaged by the
                                                             counterfeit drugs, but one with a multi-level approach
manufacturer (Palmer, 2004; Genentech, 2001).



                          | Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs |                                       2
will lead to safeguarding the supply chain, prevent                                        training for the end-users. A study by A.T. Kearney
erosion of the brand image, and increase revenues.                                         believes implementation of a RFID system for a
This will result in decreasing the number of                                               manufacturer with $10 billion in prescription sales will
counterfeit products in the marketplace and                                                receive annual benefits of $20 – $55 million with the
improving patient safety and enhancing product                                             system excluding initial and recurring costs. A large
authenticity and identification. It also meets the                                         distributor with $40 billion in prescription product
necessary increased audit compliance by reducing                                           sales will have an annual benefit of $12 – $24 million
the supply chain issues such as time to account and                                        (Paddison, 2005).
inventory tracking. Therefore, this leads to an
                                                                                           In 2005, Pfizer announced it would use RFID tags on
increased bottom-line by effectively locating its
                                                                                           its Viagra® bottles which are sold in the United States.
products within the supply chain from manufacturer
                                                                                           GlaxoSmithKline took the initiative by planning to
to patients. This enables the drug manufacturer to
                                                                                           implement RFID tags on one of its anti-HIV drugs
capture higher revenues for legitimate drugs in the
                                                                                           within the next 18 months. Furthermore, Purdue
marketplace.
                                                                                           Pharma utilized RFID tags on Oxycotin® bottles to
RFID                                                                                       better track and authenticate the medications (FDA,
New trends in the industry are creating unique                                             2004). RFID tags can be embedded into the label of
opportunities within the anti-counterfeiting market.                                       the medicine bottle or within the blister pack to
The FDA has also recommended that pharmaceutical
companies start using RFID as a means of better
tracking drugs. These are radio transmitters that can                                              RFID

be attached to drug packages, medicine bottles, or                                                  XYZ
                                                                                                  Pharma




                                                                                                                                                                     RFID
active ingredient containers and scanned to emit an                                                                                D ru g
                                                                                                   RFID                            N am e
electronic product code. Individual packages of drugs                                                                              50m g
                                                                                                    XYZ
or their respective ingredients can be monitored                                                  Pharma
throughout the supply chain from manufacturers to
distributors and wholesalers to pharmacies (Wyatt,                                                A. Cartons of                B. RFID Tag              C. Blister Pack
                                                                                                      Drugs                   Medicine Bottle
2006). As a result of enhanced inventory
management practices, RFID can decrease revenue
losses as a result of stock-outs and drug expirations
and create cost savings of $2 billion worldwide
(Paddison, 2005).
One major obstacle for RFID tags is the costs
associated with the system. As RFID tags become
more of a commodity, the prices for tags and readers
will be significantly lower and lead to more cost
                                                                                                   1                                   2                         3
savings. Each passive tag costs $0.25 – $1.00 while                                              Scanner                           Computer                   Server
the each reader costs $500 – $3000. Furthermore,
there is the need for other resources such as                                              Figure 3: RFID Tags Embedded Within Cartons of Drugs,
computers, networks, databases, and additional                                             Medicine Bottle Labels or Blister Packs

                                                            Benefits and Costs (M = Millions)                                                      • Large Manufacturer
                                     Benefits                                                                     Costs                              — $10 billion in
Type                                              Total                                                Annual Ongoing           Total Costs
                  One-time       Annual          Benefits      Intangible Benefits   One-time                                                        prescription
                                                                                                    Initially   Long-term
                                                                                                                                                     product sales
Large                Not        $20 – $55       $20 – $55    1. Protect Overall      $15 – $20    $20 – $40     $8 – $16    $35 – $60 $23 – $36
Manufacturer      significant                                   Supply Chain                                                                       • Large Distributor —
$ 10 bilion in                                               2. Prevent Stolen
prescription                                                    and Lost Products                                                                    $40 billion in
product sales
                                                                                                                                                     prescription
Large               $2 – $4     $10 – $20       $12 – $24    3. Decrease Recovery    $9 – $20      $3 – $4      $3 – $4     $12 – $24 $12 – $24
Distributor
                                                                                                                                                     product sales
                                                                Costs of Lost or
$ 40 billion in                                                 Recalled Products                                                                 Source: Paddison, 2005
prescription                                                 4. Protect Brand
product sales                                                   Loyalty


Figure 2: Cost and Benefits for RFID Implementations




                                      | Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs |                                                                  3
prevent easy removal. This is very similar to airline        This will provide information on the “chain of
initiatives to utilize RFID tags rather than traditional     custody” of the drug and decrease counterfeit drugs
barcodes to track the baggage location in real-time.         in the supply chain. As the drug flows through the
The tags have a read rate of 99 percent, whereas bar         supply chain from manufacturer to wholesaler(s) to
codes have a read rate of 85-90 percent. This higher         pharmacy, each step is tracked via an Internet portal.
read rate leads to less manual sorting due to                In the ePedrigree system, the medical product’s
unreadable bar codes. This also decreases the time           information is verified and documented during each
and costs in getting the bags to the customers. The          step within a secure environment. Therefore, a
current cost for bag retrieval is estimated to be $2.5       product’s path is followed in real-time via the portal
billion a year by The International Air Transport            to ensure it is coming into the system from a valid
Association (Demerjian, 2005).                               source. A new data management infrastructure to
                                                             store and share the data has to be implemented
ePedigrees
                                                             within the company. A few vendors are already
Another development is the focus on ePedigrees to
                                                             providing services for the new system in order to
create a more efficient supply chain in a secure
                                                             easily transition into this environment.
environment. The PDMA states that pedigrees are
required for all non-Authorized Distributor of Record        The ePedigree shows detailed real-time information
wholesale distributions (SupplyScape, 2006). In              regarding the product and its distribution within the
2006, ePedigrees were implemented in only 200                supply chain. It provides general product information
                                                             along with a tracking number for easier identification.
                                                             As it travels from one location to another, it will
                               ePedigree System              provide the transaction details including names,
                                                             addresses, and drug license numbers. It will also have
                      Tracking Number                        the receiving person’s name and electronic signature.
                      Date                                   In addition, it will include details such as the
                                                             production number and expiration date so it can
   Manufacturer       Drug Information                       easily be traced back in the future for recalls or
                      Special Handling Information
                                                             quality checks (Bernstein, 2007).
                                          Wholesaler/
                       Manufacturer:
                                          Pharmacy           Overt Strategies
                       Name               Name               Pharmaceutical companies are experimenting with
                       Address             Address           overt strategies such as optically variable devices
                       Phone               Phone
                                                             (OVDs) that can help track/authenticate drugs. Some
                       Email               Email
    Wholesaler                                               companies are testing holograms, color-shifting inks
                       License No.         License No.
                                                             and watermarks that can help them authenticate
                       Electronic Signature/ID               medicine bottles and packages. Similar techniques
                       Name
                       Date and Time

                       Production Number
                       Expiration Date

     Pharmacy


Figure 4: ePedigree System Tracks Real-Time Drug
Information from Manufacturer to Pharmacy

million medicine bottles and blister packs. In
comparison, the number of prescriptions dispensed in
2006 was 3.7 billion (Lamb, 2007). As drug                          D ru g
                                                                                     Dr
shipments arrive within the various elements of the                 N am e              u
                                                                                    Na g               Logo
supply chain, ePedigrees are matched and signed to                  50m g          50 m e
                                                                                     m
                                                                                  Lo     g
confirm and validate the authenticity of the drugs.                  Logo           go
Software programs show the detailed information of
the validated drugs within the supply chain and their                                                   Logo
specific location at various time periods. ePedigree
will be utilized within all steps of the supply chain         Figure 5: Color Shifting Logo — Changing the Viewing
from manufacturer to retailer and customer.                   Angle Shifts the Color




                          | Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs |                       4
are currently utilized in safeguarding the U.S.                 the packaging. For the highest level of security, the
currency. The currency utilizes multiple safeguards             markers can be added to the individual pills in order
which makes it difficult, time-intensive, and costly for        to identify if the drug is counterfeit. The markers are
counterfeiters. It utilizes a dual color-shifting ink,          odorless, tasteless, and approved for human
watermark, security thread within the paper, and new            consumption. A quick test kit, similar to a pregnancy
symbols on the bill. In 2004, the pharmaceutical                test, can be performed in the field to determine the
companies started using color-shifting ink that                 authenticity. The pill is put into a special receptor-
changed color depending on the viewing angle so                 binding liquid, and a test strip is placed into the
counterfeits can be easily recognized by members                liquid. If the specified marker is in the pill, the strip
downstream within the supply (Palmer, 2004). Others             turns a specific color (Weinberg, 2007). Also, Kodak’s
are experimenting with using inks or dyes and some              Traceless® technology incorporates an odorless and
are already using tamper-resistant packaging tape on            colorless powder within the medicine packaging label
some of their products. Also, there is a change to              or within the drug ingredients. The package is read in
raised printing in which letters are raised above the           real-time with a patented handheld reader to
paper for easy inspection and detection for                     authenticate the drugs. For medicine packaging
counterfeits.                                                   labels, this method works with conventional printing
                                                                methods and can be utilized during the
Covert Strategies
                                                                manufacturing process (Kodak, 2007).
Companies are also shifting to covert strategies
which utilize special devices to authenticate the               Benefits
drugs. Authentix utilizes a new method incorporating            Pharmaceutical companies are more concerned about
nanotechnology markers (50 nM to 5000 nM in size)               brand image and reputation these days than ever
which are mixed into the drug packaging and                     before. This is one of the key reasons to protect the
individual pills. They can be specifically added to the         supply chain by utilizing the latest technologies.
inks, labels, and pill ingredients for easy detection.          Counterfeit drugs can lead to drug recall and liability
These markers have spectral properties that “light up”          suits which can cost the company millions and billions
when a light with a specific wavelength is placed on            of dollars. Fen-Phen was recalled in 1997 and led to
                                                                50,000 liability lawsuits. The total costs for the recall
A. Markers Emit Light at Specific Wavelength
                                                                and lawsuits were estimated at $14 billion (Gilchrist,
                                                                2005). In addition, brand loyalty is compromised as
                                                                consumers perceive additional risk when using a
                                                                company’s products. It might take several months or
                                                                years for a product to regain its market share
               D ru g
                                                                depending on the severity of the initial damage. This
               N am e                                           will result in lost sales and revenue along with the
               50m g
                                                                high costs of marketing and public relations to bring
                                                                the drug back to the market (Paddison, 2005).
                                                                An anti-counterfeiting strategy can better analyze
         Nanotechnology                 Specific Wavelength     how these methods benefit the client most effectively
            Markers                             Light           depending on business needs, requirements, desired
B. Receptor Binding Test                                        level of security, and geographic location. However,
                                                                for this strategy to work properly, a multi-step
   Pill with                                                    approach has to be implemented because an
   Marker                                3 Authentic            individual strategy alone has not worked in the past.
                1               2                               A multi-level strategy uses complementing
                                                                technologies that can provide the most protection for
                                                                a company’s brand and the highest level of security.
                                           Counterfeit          This will also result in additional costs as the
                                                                technologies become more sophisticated and the
             Add Pill to     Add Test
             Receptor          Strip                            quantity of products becomes marked or tagged. A
           Binding Liquid                                       basic foundation for protecting the Pharma Value
                                                                Chain focuses on tracking methods such as RFID and
Figure 6: Nanotechnology Markers Emit Light at Specific         ePedigrees. The next step is to protect the medicine
Wavelengths and Bind to Specific Receptor Binding Liquid
                                                                bottles and blister packs with overt technologies by
(Weinberg, 2007)



                             | Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs |                      5
Technologies                                                            Increased Layers of
                                                                                                              Protection
                                                                               3                                     Individual Pills
                                           Covert
                                                                                                                           Pill
                                                                        • Nano-
                                                                          Technology
                                                                        • Ink Markers +


                        Increasing Costs
                                                                          Patented Reader
                                                                                                                    Medicine Bottles
                                                                               3                                    Blister Packs
                                                                        • Color Shift Ink
                                                                        • Hologram
                                                                        • Watermarks

                                                                               3                                    Boxes         RFID
                                           Overt                                                                    and
                                                                   • RFID and ePedigree                                             XYZ
                                                                                                                                  Pharma
                                                                                                                    Pallets


                     Figure 7: Pharma Value Chain — Shifting Strategies and Technologies from
                     Overt to Covert Results in Increased level of Security at Higher Costs


increasing safeguards such as raised fonts, color-                                      All of these items will lead to better-guarded supply
shifting inks and logos, holograms, and watermarks                                      chain and costs savings. This will result in decreasing
so they can’t be reproduced by other sources. The                                       the number of counterfeit products in the
final step utilizes covert technologies to protect the                                  marketplace, improving patient safety, and enhancing
individual pills, medicine bottles, and blister packs by                                product authenticity. It also meets the necessary
incorporating nanotechnology markers and patented                                       increased audit and regulatory compliance by
ink markers and readers for authentication. By using                                    reducing the supply chain issues. Therefore, this
multiple safeguards into a specific product, it makes                                   complementing strategy based on client’s needs
it expensive and time-consuming for the                                                 leads to an increased bottom-line by effectively
counterfeiters. Furthermore, higher risk geographic                                     locating its products within the supply chain from
areas for counterfeit drugs require enhanced security                                   manufacturer to patient and reducing leakage during
levels and increased layers of protection in order to                                   the routing process. This enables the drug
protect the Pharma Value Chain.                                                         manufacturer to capture higher revenues for
                                                                                        legitimate drugs in the marketplace and protecting
                                                                                        the brand reputation.


                                                                                                         Increased Layers of
                                                           Technologies
                                                                                                              Protection

                                                               Nano-
                                                             Technology
                                                    Pill

                                                            Ink Markers+
                                                               Reader


                                                                                             Protect Supply             Maintain Brand
                             Increased Layers




                                                           Color Shift Ink                       Chain                   Reputation
                               of Protection




                                                            Holograms


                                                            Watermarks



                                                                 +
                                                                                            Increase Revenue           Enhance Patient
                                                RFID
                                                               RFID+                            and Profits            and Drug Safety
                                                  XYZ
                                                Pharma
                                                             ePedigrees


                       Figure 8: Implementation of Multiple Strategies for Protecting the Supply
                       Chain, Maintaining Brand Reputation, Increasing Revenue and Profits, and
                       Enhancing Patient and Drug Safety


                                                                                                                                              6
References                                                 McCarthy, Joe. 2006. “The Practicalities, Perils, and
Acharya, Satish. 2006. “The Productivity Tiger- Time and   Promise of RFID.” http://interrelativity.com/rfid/RFID-
Cost Benefits of Clinical Drug Development in India.”      Dorkbot-2006-03-01-final.pdf
Pharmalicensing.                                           Morris, Julian and Steven Philips. 2006. “Counterfeit
http://pharmalicensing.com/features/disp/1153412098_4      Medicines in Less Developed Countries.”
4bfac02291f1                                               www.fightingdiseases.org/pdf/IPN_Counterfeits.pdf
Bernstein, Illasa. 2007. “FDA’s Counterfeit Drug           Paddison, Chris. 2005. A.T. Kearney “Executive Agenda -
Initiative.”                                               Busting the Myths of Pharma RFID.”
http://www.unitdose.org/Bernstein.FDA.ppt#499,11,E-
Pedigree                                                   http://www.atkearney.com/shared_res/pdf/Busting_the_
                                                           Myths_of_Pharma_RFID.pdf
Credit Union National Association. 2007. “New Money’s
Coming.” http://googolplex.cuna.org/12433/privacy.html     Palmer, Gary. 2004. “For Pharmacists: Description and
                                                           Identification of Counterfeit Drugs.”
Dahold, Shabbir. 2007. “Safeguarding the drug supply       http://www.pfizer.com/pfizer/subsites/counterfeit_impor
chain with ePedigrees.”                                    tation/mn_pharmacist_viagra.jsp
http://www.bizjournals.com/masshightech/stories/2007/
05/21/focus2.html                                          Pitts, Peter. 2005. “21st Century Health Care Terrorism:
                                                           The Perils of International Drug Counterfeiting.”
DiMasi, J. Et al. 2002. “Returns on Research and           www.pacificresearch.org/pub/sab/health/2005/21st_Cen
Development for 1990s New Drug Introduction.”              tury_Counterfeiting_Report.pdf
Pharmacoeconomics 20: suppl.3, 11-29.
                                                           Roche. 2007. “Getting Prescription Tamiflu: Counterfeit
Demerjian, Dave. 2006. “Never Lose Luggage Again.”         Information."
http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2006/11      http://www.tamiflu.com/getting/counterfeit.aspx
/72181
                                                           Shepherd, Marv. 2004. “Counterfeit Drugs and the
FDA. 2005. “Radiofrequency Identification Technology:      Pharmacist’s Responsibility.”
Protecting the Drug Supply.”                               www.thecesolution.com/ce/lessons/AZ_Counterfeit_Dru
http://www.fda.gov/fdac/features/2005/205_rfid.html        gs_120104/images/AZ%20Counterfeit.pdf
FDA. 2004. “FDA Announces New Initiative to Protect        SupplyScape. 2006. “SupplyScape E-Pedigree.”
the U.S. Drug Supply Through the Use of                    http://www.supplyscape.com/documents/SupplyScape_
Radiofrequency Identification                              EPedigreeDatasheet.pdf
Technology”http://www.fda.gov/bbs/topics/news/2004/
NEW01133.html                                              U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. 2006. “ICE
                                                           Efforts to Combat Counterfeit Pharmaceuticals.”
Genentech. 2001. “Product Update- Nutorpin AQ.”            http://www.ice.gov/pi/news/factsheets/counterfeit_phar
http://www.gene.com/gene/products/information/oppor        ms.htm
tunistic/nutropin-aq/update.jsp
                                                           Weinberg, Cari. 2007. “Nanotechnology Fingerprints Can
Gilchrist, Sue and Macpherson, Helen. 2005. “Update on     Certify Authenticity.”
Recent Development in the Pharmaceutical Industry.”        http://www.aip.org/dbis/stories/2007/17021.html
http://www.freehills.com.au/publications/publications_52
20.asp                                                     WHO (World Health Organization). 2007. “Frequently
                                                           Asked Questions- What are the Different Types of
HHS Task Force On Drug Importation. 2004. “Report on       Counterfeit Drug Reported.”
Prescription Drug Importation.”
www.hhs.gov/importtaskforce/Report1220.pdf                 http://www.who.int/medicines/services/counterfeit/faqs/
                                                           15/en/index.html
Kelley, Brenda. 2004. “Securing the Drug Supply from
                                                           WHO (World Health Organization). 2006. “Fact Sheet
Counterfeiting Protects Brand Profits.”
                                                           No. 275-Counterfeit Medicines.”
www.supplyscape.com/.../Securing_Drug_Supply_from_
                                                           www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs275/en/
Counterfeiting_Protects_Brand_Profits_PMPS_Winter04.
pdf                                                        Yankus, Wyatt. 2006. “Counterfeit Drugs: Coming to a
Kodak. 2007. “Kodak Security Solutions Overview-           Pharmacy Near You.”
Traceless®.”                                               www.fip.org/files/fip/counterfeit/counterfeits0608-
http://www.graphics1.kodak.com/documents/Traceless%
                                                           ACSH.pdf
20Pharmaceutical%20Anticounterfeiting%20Presentatio
n.pdf
Lamb, Ed. 2007. “Top 200 Prescriptions of 2006.”
http://www.pharmacytimes.com/Article.cfm?Menu=1&ID=
4629


                                                                                                                     7
About CSC’s Life Sciences R&D Solutions                     Enterprise Technology Integration (ETI) — Our ETI
Our solutions span the entire range of drug                 Practice focuses on business systems strategy — we
development, from basic research at the cellular and        align the business system strategy to Business and
molecular levels to human clinical trials of potential      organizational strategies to ensure that technology is
medicines that prevent and cure disease. CSC’s Life         not implemented for the sake of technology; rather, it
Sciences R&D solutions encompass:                           serves the business strategy set for R&D. Our
                                                            solutions focus on:
Strategy and Process Innovation (SPI) — Our SPI
Practice links business and organizational strategies         • Enterprise Content Management — We provide
for R&D to deliver process innovation that                      solutions that help collaborate, control, and
dramatically increases throughput in clinical                   comply to 21 CFR Part 11 and global regulatory
development. Our proven solutions in this space                 bodies. Our expertise includes EDMS strategy,
include:                                                        migration, optimization, eBLA, eCTD, SPL, and
                                                                PIM. Our thought leadership in this space and our
  • Adaptive Clinical Trials — We provide consulting
                                                                14 years of expertise in this arena help our clients
    and industry expertise to reduce dead time
                                                                achieve superior results.
    between phases. We effectively leverage
    modeling and simulation to reduce number of               • Clinical Research Data Management — For
    patients in trials and help conduct in-silico trials,       structured data, our team provides drug
    where appropriate — resulting in cost take-out              development data management solutions that
    and shortened development cycles.                           are ICH, HL7, and CDISC compliant. These
                                                                systems provide a better way to manage data
  • Phase I Outsourcing — Through our division,
                                                                from labs, CRO’s, and imaging firms and enable
    Dynport Vaccine Corp. (DVC), we provide clients
                                                                our clients to achieve significant efficiency and
    the ability to outsource entire Phase I studies. We
                                                                productivity improvements for the R&D
    provide the program management, quantitative
                                                                organization.
    measures to reduce time and costs, and proven
    process that enables clients to conduct more
    trials effectively. We currently manage 11 such         For more information, visit www.csc.com/lifesciences.
    trials.
                                                            CSC
  • In-Licensing — We implement strategies and              Life Sciences Practice
    cutting-edge solutions to help pharmaceuticals          1160 West Swedesford Road, Suite 200
    and biotechs take full advantage of in-licensing        Berwyn, Pennsylvania 19312
    to augment their pipelines. Our structured              Unites States
    solutions ensure that no licensing opportunity is
    left unnoticed, and potential blockbuster
    opportunities are not given away to competition.
  • Bioinformatics Partnership — With the rise of
    commercial genomics, companies need to
    differentiate themselves from competition by
    efficiently managing biostatistics analytics and
    bioinformatics. CSC’s Life Sciences Practice
    serves as a strategic services partner to the client
    and provides standards driven bioinformatics
    solutions both through our U.S. and Indian
    operations and our strategic alliances with key
    partners.
  • Anti-counterfeiting Solutions — We leverage our
    expertise in defense, consumer products, and
    supply chain to deliver novel solutions for solving
    the expensive and ever-increasing drug
    counterfeiting issues. Our strategy and solutions
    go beyond the traditional RFID based solutions
    and provide quantifiable ROI.




                                                                                                                    8
About the Authors
Sanjay Modi
CSC Life Sciences
+1.973.243.0023
smodi@csc.com
Sanjay Modi works in CSC Life Sciences R&D
Solutions and is based in New York City. He holds a
MBA from The University of Maryland and a
Bachelor’s of Arts degree in Biology from The
University of Delaware.


Sanjeev Wadhwa
CSC Life Sciences
+1.973.243.0023
swadhwa@csc.com
Sanjeev Wadhwa is a partner and senior strategy
expert within CSC Life Sciences R&D Solutions.




                                                      9
CSC

266 Second Avenue
Waltham, Massachusetts 02451
United States
+1.800.272.0018

Worldwide CSC Headquarters

The Americas
3170 Fairview Park Drive
Falls Church, Virginia 22042
United States
+1.703.876.1000

Europe, Middle East, Africa
Royal Pavilion
Wellesley Road
Aldershot, Hampshire GU11 1PZ
United Kingdom
+44(0)1252.534000

Australia
26 Talavera Road
Macquarie Park, NSW 2113
Australia
+61(0)29034.3000

Asia
139 Cecil Street
#08-00 Cecil House
Singapore 069539
Republic of Singapore
+65.6221.9095



About CSC
The mission of CSC is to be a global leader in providing
technology enabled business solutions and services.

With the broadest range of capabilities, CSC offers clients
the solutions they need to manage complexity, focus on
core businesses, collaborate with partners and clients,
and improve operations.

CSC makes a special point of understanding its clients and
provides experts with real-world experience to work with
them. CSC is vendor-independent, delivering solutions that
best meet each client’s unique requirements.

For more than 45 years, clients in industries and governments
worldwide have trusted CSC with their business process and
information systems outsourcing, systems integration and
consulting needs.

The company trades on the New York Stock Exchange under
the symbol “CSC.”


Copyright © 2008 Computer Sciences Corporation. All rights reserved.
DS08_0528

More Related Content

What's hot

Counterfeit drugs: what a doctor should know
Counterfeit drugs: what a doctor should knowCounterfeit drugs: what a doctor should know
Counterfeit drugs: what a doctor should knowMark Davison
 
patent-access-drugs
patent-access-drugspatent-access-drugs
patent-access-drugsRakhi Gupta
 
Counterfeit drugs presentation to Pharmacy-3 students in South Dakota
Counterfeit drugs presentation to Pharmacy-3 students in South DakotaCounterfeit drugs presentation to Pharmacy-3 students in South Dakota
Counterfeit drugs presentation to Pharmacy-3 students in South DakotaThe Partnership For Safe Medicines
 
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other ProductsDetection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other ProductsNancy Sperling
 
FREE REPORT: PROGENICS PHARMACEUTICALS, INC
FREE REPORT: PROGENICS PHARMACEUTICALS, INCFREE REPORT: PROGENICS PHARMACEUTICALS, INC
FREE REPORT: PROGENICS PHARMACEUTICALS, INCBret Jensen
 
The Ones to Watch, Oct. - Dec. 2009 -- Pharma Matters Report
The Ones to Watch, Oct. - Dec. 2009 -- Pharma Matters ReportThe Ones to Watch, Oct. - Dec. 2009 -- Pharma Matters Report
The Ones to Watch, Oct. - Dec. 2009 -- Pharma Matters ReportThomson Reuters
 
Illicit Trade in Counterfeit Medicine by Kristina M. Lybecker, The Colorado C...
Illicit Trade in Counterfeit Medicine by Kristina M. Lybecker, The Colorado C...Illicit Trade in Counterfeit Medicine by Kristina M. Lybecker, The Colorado C...
Illicit Trade in Counterfeit Medicine by Kristina M. Lybecker, The Colorado C...OECD Governance
 
Follow on Biologics Market
Follow on Biologics MarketFollow on Biologics Market
Follow on Biologics MarketSanjay Modi
 
Counterfeits Kill
Counterfeits KillCounterfeits Kill
Counterfeits Killcmebahamas
 
False Advertising in the Drug and Food Industries
False Advertising in the Drug and Food Industries  False Advertising in the Drug and Food Industries
False Advertising in the Drug and Food Industries JoshuaRiger
 
C_R_COURSEWORK_AMBIKA_SHEVADE.docx (1)
C_R_COURSEWORK_AMBIKA_SHEVADE.docx (1)C_R_COURSEWORK_AMBIKA_SHEVADE.docx (1)
C_R_COURSEWORK_AMBIKA_SHEVADE.docx (1)Ambika Shevade
 

What's hot (19)

Counterfeit drugs: what a doctor should know
Counterfeit drugs: what a doctor should knowCounterfeit drugs: what a doctor should know
Counterfeit drugs: what a doctor should know
 
Session3
Session3Session3
Session3
 
Counterfeiting prescription drugs
Counterfeiting prescription drugsCounterfeiting prescription drugs
Counterfeiting prescription drugs
 
Counterfeit drugs 101 for Healthcare Providers
Counterfeit drugs 101 for Healthcare ProvidersCounterfeit drugs 101 for Healthcare Providers
Counterfeit drugs 101 for Healthcare Providers
 
patent-access-drugs
patent-access-drugspatent-access-drugs
patent-access-drugs
 
Counterfeit drugs presentation to Pharmacy-3 students in South Dakota
Counterfeit drugs presentation to Pharmacy-3 students in South DakotaCounterfeit drugs presentation to Pharmacy-3 students in South Dakota
Counterfeit drugs presentation to Pharmacy-3 students in South Dakota
 
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other ProductsDetection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
 
US Medical Research And Dvt
US Medical Research And DvtUS Medical Research And Dvt
US Medical Research And Dvt
 
Orphan drugs: why the hype?
Orphan drugs: why the hype?Orphan drugs: why the hype?
Orphan drugs: why the hype?
 
FREE REPORT: PROGENICS PHARMACEUTICALS, INC
FREE REPORT: PROGENICS PHARMACEUTICALS, INCFREE REPORT: PROGENICS PHARMACEUTICALS, INC
FREE REPORT: PROGENICS PHARMACEUTICALS, INC
 
Biodrug expanding
Biodrug expandingBiodrug expanding
Biodrug expanding
 
The Ones to Watch, Oct. - Dec. 2009 -- Pharma Matters Report
The Ones to Watch, Oct. - Dec. 2009 -- Pharma Matters ReportThe Ones to Watch, Oct. - Dec. 2009 -- Pharma Matters Report
The Ones to Watch, Oct. - Dec. 2009 -- Pharma Matters Report
 
Illicit Trade in Counterfeit Medicine by Kristina M. Lybecker, The Colorado C...
Illicit Trade in Counterfeit Medicine by Kristina M. Lybecker, The Colorado C...Illicit Trade in Counterfeit Medicine by Kristina M. Lybecker, The Colorado C...
Illicit Trade in Counterfeit Medicine by Kristina M. Lybecker, The Colorado C...
 
Follow on Biologics Market
Follow on Biologics MarketFollow on Biologics Market
Follow on Biologics Market
 
Counterfeits Kill
Counterfeits KillCounterfeits Kill
Counterfeits Kill
 
False Advertising in the Drug and Food Industries
False Advertising in the Drug and Food Industries  False Advertising in the Drug and Food Industries
False Advertising in the Drug and Food Industries
 
C_R_COURSEWORK_AMBIKA_SHEVADE.docx (1)
C_R_COURSEWORK_AMBIKA_SHEVADE.docx (1)C_R_COURSEWORK_AMBIKA_SHEVADE.docx (1)
C_R_COURSEWORK_AMBIKA_SHEVADE.docx (1)
 
Counterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 Overview
Counterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 OverviewCounterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 Overview
Counterfeit Drugs in America: 2017 Overview
 
What is an orphan drug?
What is an orphan drug?What is an orphan drug?
What is an orphan drug?
 

Viewers also liked

50 stunning mobile statistics - trends in gadgets and mobility
50 stunning mobile statistics - trends in gadgets and mobility50 stunning mobile statistics - trends in gadgets and mobility
50 stunning mobile statistics - trends in gadgets and mobilityAli Kafel
 
Sociale media voor sportverenigingen
Sociale media voor sportverenigingenSociale media voor sportverenigingen
Sociale media voor sportverenigingenHans Slender
 
Het sportpark van de toekomst
Het sportpark van de toekomstHet sportpark van de toekomst
Het sportpark van de toekomstHans Slender
 
The ADD Effect In Clinical Development
The ADD Effect In Clinical DevelopmentThe ADD Effect In Clinical Development
The ADD Effect In Clinical Developmentguest696d96
 
Economische en maatschappelijke impact sportevenementen
Economische en maatschappelijke impact sportevenementenEconomische en maatschappelijke impact sportevenementen
Economische en maatschappelijke impact sportevenementenHans Slender
 
DSO2014: Vitale sportvereniging of open sportclub?
DSO2014: Vitale sportvereniging of open sportclub?DSO2014: Vitale sportvereniging of open sportclub?
DSO2014: Vitale sportvereniging of open sportclub?Hans Slender
 
Moderne sportvereniging
Moderne sportverenigingModerne sportvereniging
Moderne sportverenigingHans Slender
 
Sociale media en sportevents
Sociale media en sporteventsSociale media en sportevents
Sociale media en sporteventsHans Slender
 
Economic and social value of local sport events
Economic and social value of local sport eventsEconomic and social value of local sport events
Economic and social value of local sport eventsHans Slender
 
NFV resiliency whitepaper - Ali Kafel, Stratus Technologies
NFV resiliency whitepaper - Ali Kafel, Stratus TechnologiesNFV resiliency whitepaper - Ali Kafel, Stratus Technologies
NFV resiliency whitepaper - Ali Kafel, Stratus TechnologiesAli Kafel
 
Stratus Fault-Tolerant Cloud Infrastructure Software for NFV using OpenStack
Stratus Fault-Tolerant Cloud Infrastructure Software for NFV using OpenStackStratus Fault-Tolerant Cloud Infrastructure Software for NFV using OpenStack
Stratus Fault-Tolerant Cloud Infrastructure Software for NFV using OpenStackAli Kafel
 
ETSI NFV#13 NFV resiliency presentation - ali kafel - stratus
ETSI NFV#13   NFV resiliency presentation - ali kafel - stratusETSI NFV#13   NFV resiliency presentation - ali kafel - stratus
ETSI NFV#13 NFV resiliency presentation - ali kafel - stratusAli Kafel
 
Red Hat NFV solution overview
Red Hat NFV solution overview   Red Hat NFV solution overview
Red Hat NFV solution overview Ali Kafel
 
Privatisering van sportaccommodaties
Privatisering van sportaccommodatiesPrivatisering van sportaccommodaties
Privatisering van sportaccommodatiesHans Slender
 
Maatschappelijke spin-off WK CP Voetbal
Maatschappelijke spin-off WK CP VoetbalMaatschappelijke spin-off WK CP Voetbal
Maatschappelijke spin-off WK CP VoetbalHans Slender
 

Viewers also liked (17)

50 stunning mobile statistics - trends in gadgets and mobility
50 stunning mobile statistics - trends in gadgets and mobility50 stunning mobile statistics - trends in gadgets and mobility
50 stunning mobile statistics - trends in gadgets and mobility
 
Sociale media voor sportverenigingen
Sociale media voor sportverenigingenSociale media voor sportverenigingen
Sociale media voor sportverenigingen
 
Minimalist Style
Minimalist StyleMinimalist Style
Minimalist Style
 
Het sportpark van de toekomst
Het sportpark van de toekomstHet sportpark van de toekomst
Het sportpark van de toekomst
 
The ADD Effect In Clinical Development
The ADD Effect In Clinical DevelopmentThe ADD Effect In Clinical Development
The ADD Effect In Clinical Development
 
Economische en maatschappelijke impact sportevenementen
Economische en maatschappelijke impact sportevenementenEconomische en maatschappelijke impact sportevenementen
Economische en maatschappelijke impact sportevenementen
 
DSO2014: Vitale sportvereniging of open sportclub?
DSO2014: Vitale sportvereniging of open sportclub?DSO2014: Vitale sportvereniging of open sportclub?
DSO2014: Vitale sportvereniging of open sportclub?
 
Moderne sportvereniging
Moderne sportverenigingModerne sportvereniging
Moderne sportvereniging
 
Iphone2
Iphone2Iphone2
Iphone2
 
Sociale media en sportevents
Sociale media en sporteventsSociale media en sportevents
Sociale media en sportevents
 
Economic and social value of local sport events
Economic and social value of local sport eventsEconomic and social value of local sport events
Economic and social value of local sport events
 
NFV resiliency whitepaper - Ali Kafel, Stratus Technologies
NFV resiliency whitepaper - Ali Kafel, Stratus TechnologiesNFV resiliency whitepaper - Ali Kafel, Stratus Technologies
NFV resiliency whitepaper - Ali Kafel, Stratus Technologies
 
Stratus Fault-Tolerant Cloud Infrastructure Software for NFV using OpenStack
Stratus Fault-Tolerant Cloud Infrastructure Software for NFV using OpenStackStratus Fault-Tolerant Cloud Infrastructure Software for NFV using OpenStack
Stratus Fault-Tolerant Cloud Infrastructure Software for NFV using OpenStack
 
ETSI NFV#13 NFV resiliency presentation - ali kafel - stratus
ETSI NFV#13   NFV resiliency presentation - ali kafel - stratusETSI NFV#13   NFV resiliency presentation - ali kafel - stratus
ETSI NFV#13 NFV resiliency presentation - ali kafel - stratus
 
Red Hat NFV solution overview
Red Hat NFV solution overview   Red Hat NFV solution overview
Red Hat NFV solution overview
 
Privatisering van sportaccommodaties
Privatisering van sportaccommodatiesPrivatisering van sportaccommodaties
Privatisering van sportaccommodaties
 
Maatschappelijke spin-off WK CP Voetbal
Maatschappelijke spin-off WK CP VoetbalMaatschappelijke spin-off WK CP Voetbal
Maatschappelijke spin-off WK CP Voetbal
 

Similar to Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs

Top Trends in Orphan Drugs
Top Trends in Orphan DrugsTop Trends in Orphan Drugs
Top Trends in Orphan DrugsBill Smith
 
" GENERIC MEDICINE''
" GENERIC MEDICINE''" GENERIC MEDICINE''
" GENERIC MEDICINE''Ajay Baykar
 
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other ProductsDetection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other ProductsNancy Sperling
 
Are there reasons for believing that the profitability of the industry might ...
Are there reasons for believing that the profitability of the industry might ...Are there reasons for believing that the profitability of the industry might ...
Are there reasons for believing that the profitability of the industry might ...Global Study Solutions - 9901366442
 
Is European market access becoming an incubator for rare disease development?...
Is European market access becoming an incubator for rare disease development?...Is European market access becoming an incubator for rare disease development?...
Is European market access becoming an incubator for rare disease development?...KateBenson18
 
Big pharma and modern medicine
Big pharma and modern medicineBig pharma and modern medicine
Big pharma and modern medicinesohrab642
 
Drug Bulletin of Nepal
Drug Bulletin of Nepal Drug Bulletin of Nepal
Drug Bulletin of Nepal Nabin Bist
 
Napm 2014 review
Napm 2014 reviewNapm 2014 review
Napm 2014 reviewnapmSA
 
The science of hope
The science of hopeThe science of hope
The science of hopeFreedom Monk
 
Indian pharma industry saurabh saxena
Indian pharma industry   saurabh saxenaIndian pharma industry   saurabh saxena
Indian pharma industry saurabh saxenanparulekar
 
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020Rajesh Sarma
 
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020KuicK Research
 
Tw 1108035 stof_clintrials_rev_v1
Tw 1108035 stof_clintrials_rev_v1Tw 1108035 stof_clintrials_rev_v1
Tw 1108035 stof_clintrials_rev_v1Helen Street
 
Generics and the Animal Health Industry
Generics and the Animal Health IndustryGenerics and the Animal Health Industry
Generics and the Animal Health IndustryAmanda Boddington
 
Market access conference NAPM
Market access conference NAPMMarket access conference NAPM
Market access conference NAPMnapmSA
 

Similar to Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs (20)

Top Trends in Orphan Drugs
Top Trends in Orphan DrugsTop Trends in Orphan Drugs
Top Trends in Orphan Drugs
 
" GENERIC MEDICINE''
" GENERIC MEDICINE''" GENERIC MEDICINE''
" GENERIC MEDICINE''
 
Final
FinalFinal
Final
 
Presentation
PresentationPresentation
Presentation
 
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other ProductsDetection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
Detection of Counterfeit Drugs and Other Products
 
Are there reasons for believing that the profitability of the industry might ...
Are there reasons for believing that the profitability of the industry might ...Are there reasons for believing that the profitability of the industry might ...
Are there reasons for believing that the profitability of the industry might ...
 
Is European market access becoming an incubator for rare disease development?...
Is European market access becoming an incubator for rare disease development?...Is European market access becoming an incubator for rare disease development?...
Is European market access becoming an incubator for rare disease development?...
 
Pharmaceutical Rfid Systems
Pharmaceutical Rfid SystemsPharmaceutical Rfid Systems
Pharmaceutical Rfid Systems
 
Pharmaceutical Rfid Systems
Pharmaceutical Rfid SystemsPharmaceutical Rfid Systems
Pharmaceutical Rfid Systems
 
Big pharma and modern medicine
Big pharma and modern medicineBig pharma and modern medicine
Big pharma and modern medicine
 
Drug Bulletin of Nepal
Drug Bulletin of Nepal Drug Bulletin of Nepal
Drug Bulletin of Nepal
 
Napm 2014 review
Napm 2014 reviewNapm 2014 review
Napm 2014 review
 
IJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdf
IJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdfIJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdf
IJPBA_2058_23_20230707_V1.pdf
 
The science of hope
The science of hopeThe science of hope
The science of hope
 
Indian pharma industry saurabh saxena
Indian pharma industry   saurabh saxenaIndian pharma industry   saurabh saxena
Indian pharma industry saurabh saxena
 
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020
 
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020
Global orphan drug market future outlook 2020
 
Tw 1108035 stof_clintrials_rev_v1
Tw 1108035 stof_clintrials_rev_v1Tw 1108035 stof_clintrials_rev_v1
Tw 1108035 stof_clintrials_rev_v1
 
Generics and the Animal Health Industry
Generics and the Animal Health IndustryGenerics and the Animal Health Industry
Generics and the Animal Health Industry
 
Market access conference NAPM
Market access conference NAPMMarket access conference NAPM
Market access conference NAPM
 

Recently uploaded

Call Girls Ooty Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ooty Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Ooty Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ooty Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Lucknow Call girls - 8800925952 - 24x7 service with hotel room
Lucknow Call girls - 8800925952 - 24x7 service with hotel roomLucknow Call girls - 8800925952 - 24x7 service with hotel room
Lucknow Call girls - 8800925952 - 24x7 service with hotel roomdiscovermytutordmt
 
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋TANUJA PANDEY
 
Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...Dipal Arora
 
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...indiancallgirl4rent
 
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...narwatsonia7
 
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...perfect solution
 
Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...
Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...
Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...Genuine Call Girls
 
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...Arohi Goyal
 
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟  9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟  9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...narwatsonia7
 
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Gwalior Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore EscortsCall Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escortsvidya singh
 
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...tanya dube
 
Call Girls Bangalore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Bangalore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Bangalore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Bangalore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Top Rated Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...
Top Rated  Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...Top Rated  Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...
Top Rated Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...chandars293
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Call Girls Ooty Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ooty Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Ooty Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ooty Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Lucknow Call girls - 8800925952 - 24x7 service with hotel room
Lucknow Call girls - 8800925952 - 24x7 service with hotel roomLucknow Call girls - 8800925952 - 24x7 service with hotel room
Lucknow Call girls - 8800925952 - 24x7 service with hotel room
 
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
 
Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
 
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...
 
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Ramamurthy Nagar ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
 
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...
 
Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...
Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...
Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...
 
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
 
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟  9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟  9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Ge...
 
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Gwalior Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore EscortsCall Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
 
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
 
Call Girls Bangalore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Bangalore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Bangalore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Bangalore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Top Rated Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...
Top Rated  Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...Top Rated  Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...
Top Rated Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...
 

Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs

  • 1. MULTIPLE STRATEGIES AND TECHNOLOGIES TO COMBAT COUNTERFEIT DRUGS Authors: Sanjay Modi and Sanjeev Wadhwa An anti-counterfeiting The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has seen a rise of strategy helps to counterfeit drug cases since 2000 when there were only six. In 2006, effectively detect the number of cases rose dramatically to 54 (Bernstein, 2007). The counterfeit products, market for counterfeit drug is approximately $40 billion (WHO, 2006). increase audit compliance, According to the Center for Medicines in the Public Interest, counterfeit and enhance supply chain drug sales globally will reach $75 billion by 2010. This represents an management capabilities. increase of 90 percent from 2005 (WHO, 2006) and will represent 14 This strategy can identify percent of the total drug market (Pitts, 2005). Furthermore, it is the multiple best-fit estimated that 10 percent of the global medicines are counterfeit. solutions for meeting a Approximately 60 percent of counterfeit drug cases occur in less- company’s requirements developed countries in which 25 percent of their drug supply is via Radio Frequency counterfeit (Morris, 2006). The largest producers of these drugs are Identification Devices Southeast Asia, Nigeria, Russia, Mexico, Brazil, and Latin America (U.S. (RFID), ePedigrees, label Immigration and Customs Enforcement, 2006). security, dosage unit level Counterfeit drugs are an increasing threat in the marketplace. These sub- security, nanotechnology, standard drugs affect human lives as the quality and/or type of drug is and other capable harmful to the patient. These products may not cure the targeted solutions to combat diseases and could possibly even kill patients. Also, they affect the counterfeiting of drug profits of the companies which manufacture the drugs. Pharmaceutical products. One item alone companies invest large amounts of resources to create drugs. They will not protect the spend up to 12 years and $1.2 billion on clinical development for drugs companies from counter- (Archarya, 2006). However, only 30 percent of drugs which are feit drugs, but one with a approved and marketed produce revenues that match or exceed initial multi-level approach will costs (DiMasi, 2002). Therefore, any counterfeit drugs sold as legitimate lead to safeguarding the drugs reduce the companies’ revenues and lead to lower profits. supply chain, prevent erosion of the brand There are five different types of counterfeit mechanisms in which drugs image, and increase are manufactured or distributed without proper regulatory approval and revenues. This will result do not meet the determined standards of safety, quality, and efficacy in decreasing the number (WHO, 2007): of counterfeit products in • No active ingredient (43 percent) the marketplace and improving patient safety • Low levels of active ingredient (21 percent) and enhancing product • Poor quality drugs (24 percent) authenticity and • Wrong ingredients (2 percent) identification. • Wrong packaging or source (7 percent) Counterfeiting can apply to both branded and generic products. In wealthy developed countries, expensive drugs such as hormones, steroids, and antihistamines are frequently counterfeited due to lifestyle preferences. While in developing countries, those used to treat life- threatening conditions such as malaria, TB, and HIV/AIDS are chosen to be imitated due to their relatively high costs. As this trend continues, | Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs | 1
  • 2. other drugs such as anti-cancer and anti-virals might Therefore, counterfeit drugs are passed as real drugs be next on the list due to the high costs of these due to the counterfeiters’ abilities to reproduce items. drugs and the lucrative returns by the counterfeiters. Sources of Counterfeit Medicines C o u n terfeit A u th en tic Counterfeit drugs can be diverted and sold from 1 1. Logo background various channels within the drug distribution system 2 LO G O LOG O color due to its complexity. There is no enforced 2. Logo font not bolded 3. Colored protective government mandate to track the drugs efficiently 3 Logo Logo packaging on rim on top of bottle within the system which allows for openings for 4. Border type counterfeiters throughout the system. Drugs can be 5. Font size 4 6. Border size diverted from their original purpose and sold outside D ru g D ru g 7. Pill size and shape the regulated distributed channels. For example, free 5 N am e 8. Name of pill varies N am e samples to doctors may be sold illegally within the 50m g 6 50m g Can you tell the difference if one of the above items system. Patients may, in turn, sell their prescription were changed? drugs for a profit. Also, drugs sold for lower prices in various countries can be sold to other markets where 7 D P5 the price is higher. These drugs are not regulated 8 through safeguards as they are sold outside the normal distribution channels Figure 1: Difference between Counterfeit and Authentic Drugs The 1988 Prescription Drug Marketing Act (PDMA) introduced a need for paper drug pedigree to track As a result of illegal medical drugs within the system, the drug from manufacturer to end user. However, it the companies that manufacture and sell the has yet to be fully implemented throughout the authentic products incur large losses of revenue. This industry and supply chain due to the high record- decreases sales and profit margins due to other keeping effort needed to maintain this type of unauthenticated “substitute” products that people system. Incomplete paper pedigrees lead to are buying in place of the authenticated drug increasing the risk of counterfeit drugs in the product. Large inventory losses and write-offs are marketplace as the ingredients or products are not placed on the balance sheets due to routing leakages tracked within the supply chain. On the other hand, and medicines which were not purchased legally. As complete paper pedigrees help validate the noted earlier, these drugs threaten patient safety authenticity of the drug but counterfeiters are finding leading to possible deaths. There are audit and ways around this paper-based process. For example, regulatory compliance issues with counterfeit drugs illegitimate secondary wholesalers can prepare fake as they do not follow the regulated channels. paper pedigree documents which pharmacies detect Furthermore, the supply chain for the drugs is as valid. An increasing trend is to use tools and complicated due to higher inventory carryover processes to copy drug labels and packages. This leading to increased costs. The supply chain issues makes it difficult to identify the real drug from the push for an efficient and reliable tracking mechanism fake copy due to the striking similarities between the which has yet to be mandated by the industry or two. Repackaging is another way to bring expired or regulators due to high initial costs and lack of compromised drugs into the distribution system and industry standards. mix them with genuine drugs. Finally, the lack of tamper-evident packaging allows the original Anti-Counterfeit Strategies packaging to be reused for unregulated drugs An anti-counterfeiting strategy helps to effectively (HHS, 2004). detect counterfeit products, increase audit compliance, and enhance supply chain management The differences between counterfeit and authentic capabilities. This strategy can identify the multiple drugs can be difficult to detect unless one looks best-fit solutions for meeting a company’s closely at the bottle or packaging. These can be requirements via Radio Frequency Identification minor changes in the product container, label, or the Devices (RFID), ePedigrees, label security, dosage individual pill that can be hard to visually detect by unit level security, nanotechnology, and other capable the human eye. For example, a change in the type of solutions to combat counterfeiting of drug products. font, border type, or logo color is difficult to detect One item alone will not protect the companies from unless someone knows how they are packaged by the counterfeit drugs, but one with a multi-level approach manufacturer (Palmer, 2004; Genentech, 2001). | Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs | 2
  • 3. will lead to safeguarding the supply chain, prevent training for the end-users. A study by A.T. Kearney erosion of the brand image, and increase revenues. believes implementation of a RFID system for a This will result in decreasing the number of manufacturer with $10 billion in prescription sales will counterfeit products in the marketplace and receive annual benefits of $20 – $55 million with the improving patient safety and enhancing product system excluding initial and recurring costs. A large authenticity and identification. It also meets the distributor with $40 billion in prescription product necessary increased audit compliance by reducing sales will have an annual benefit of $12 – $24 million the supply chain issues such as time to account and (Paddison, 2005). inventory tracking. Therefore, this leads to an In 2005, Pfizer announced it would use RFID tags on increased bottom-line by effectively locating its its Viagra® bottles which are sold in the United States. products within the supply chain from manufacturer GlaxoSmithKline took the initiative by planning to to patients. This enables the drug manufacturer to implement RFID tags on one of its anti-HIV drugs capture higher revenues for legitimate drugs in the within the next 18 months. Furthermore, Purdue marketplace. Pharma utilized RFID tags on Oxycotin® bottles to RFID better track and authenticate the medications (FDA, New trends in the industry are creating unique 2004). RFID tags can be embedded into the label of opportunities within the anti-counterfeiting market. the medicine bottle or within the blister pack to The FDA has also recommended that pharmaceutical companies start using RFID as a means of better tracking drugs. These are radio transmitters that can RFID be attached to drug packages, medicine bottles, or XYZ Pharma RFID active ingredient containers and scanned to emit an D ru g RFID N am e electronic product code. Individual packages of drugs 50m g XYZ or their respective ingredients can be monitored Pharma throughout the supply chain from manufacturers to distributors and wholesalers to pharmacies (Wyatt, A. Cartons of B. RFID Tag C. Blister Pack Drugs Medicine Bottle 2006). As a result of enhanced inventory management practices, RFID can decrease revenue losses as a result of stock-outs and drug expirations and create cost savings of $2 billion worldwide (Paddison, 2005). One major obstacle for RFID tags is the costs associated with the system. As RFID tags become more of a commodity, the prices for tags and readers will be significantly lower and lead to more cost 1 2 3 savings. Each passive tag costs $0.25 – $1.00 while Scanner Computer Server the each reader costs $500 – $3000. Furthermore, there is the need for other resources such as Figure 3: RFID Tags Embedded Within Cartons of Drugs, computers, networks, databases, and additional Medicine Bottle Labels or Blister Packs Benefits and Costs (M = Millions) • Large Manufacturer Benefits Costs — $10 billion in Type Total Annual Ongoing Total Costs One-time Annual Benefits Intangible Benefits One-time prescription Initially Long-term product sales Large Not $20 – $55 $20 – $55 1. Protect Overall $15 – $20 $20 – $40 $8 – $16 $35 – $60 $23 – $36 Manufacturer significant Supply Chain • Large Distributor — $ 10 bilion in 2. Prevent Stolen prescription and Lost Products $40 billion in product sales prescription Large $2 – $4 $10 – $20 $12 – $24 3. Decrease Recovery $9 – $20 $3 – $4 $3 – $4 $12 – $24 $12 – $24 Distributor product sales Costs of Lost or $ 40 billion in Recalled Products Source: Paddison, 2005 prescription 4. Protect Brand product sales Loyalty Figure 2: Cost and Benefits for RFID Implementations | Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs | 3
  • 4. prevent easy removal. This is very similar to airline This will provide information on the “chain of initiatives to utilize RFID tags rather than traditional custody” of the drug and decrease counterfeit drugs barcodes to track the baggage location in real-time. in the supply chain. As the drug flows through the The tags have a read rate of 99 percent, whereas bar supply chain from manufacturer to wholesaler(s) to codes have a read rate of 85-90 percent. This higher pharmacy, each step is tracked via an Internet portal. read rate leads to less manual sorting due to In the ePedrigree system, the medical product’s unreadable bar codes. This also decreases the time information is verified and documented during each and costs in getting the bags to the customers. The step within a secure environment. Therefore, a current cost for bag retrieval is estimated to be $2.5 product’s path is followed in real-time via the portal billion a year by The International Air Transport to ensure it is coming into the system from a valid Association (Demerjian, 2005). source. A new data management infrastructure to store and share the data has to be implemented ePedigrees within the company. A few vendors are already Another development is the focus on ePedigrees to providing services for the new system in order to create a more efficient supply chain in a secure easily transition into this environment. environment. The PDMA states that pedigrees are required for all non-Authorized Distributor of Record The ePedigree shows detailed real-time information wholesale distributions (SupplyScape, 2006). In regarding the product and its distribution within the 2006, ePedigrees were implemented in only 200 supply chain. It provides general product information along with a tracking number for easier identification. As it travels from one location to another, it will ePedigree System provide the transaction details including names, addresses, and drug license numbers. It will also have Tracking Number the receiving person’s name and electronic signature. Date In addition, it will include details such as the production number and expiration date so it can Manufacturer Drug Information easily be traced back in the future for recalls or Special Handling Information quality checks (Bernstein, 2007). Wholesaler/ Manufacturer: Pharmacy Overt Strategies Name Name Pharmaceutical companies are experimenting with Address Address overt strategies such as optically variable devices Phone Phone (OVDs) that can help track/authenticate drugs. Some Email Email Wholesaler companies are testing holograms, color-shifting inks License No. License No. and watermarks that can help them authenticate Electronic Signature/ID medicine bottles and packages. Similar techniques Name Date and Time Production Number Expiration Date Pharmacy Figure 4: ePedigree System Tracks Real-Time Drug Information from Manufacturer to Pharmacy million medicine bottles and blister packs. In comparison, the number of prescriptions dispensed in 2006 was 3.7 billion (Lamb, 2007). As drug D ru g Dr shipments arrive within the various elements of the N am e u Na g Logo supply chain, ePedigrees are matched and signed to 50m g 50 m e m Lo g confirm and validate the authenticity of the drugs. Logo go Software programs show the detailed information of the validated drugs within the supply chain and their Logo specific location at various time periods. ePedigree will be utilized within all steps of the supply chain Figure 5: Color Shifting Logo — Changing the Viewing from manufacturer to retailer and customer. Angle Shifts the Color | Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs | 4
  • 5. are currently utilized in safeguarding the U.S. the packaging. For the highest level of security, the currency. The currency utilizes multiple safeguards markers can be added to the individual pills in order which makes it difficult, time-intensive, and costly for to identify if the drug is counterfeit. The markers are counterfeiters. It utilizes a dual color-shifting ink, odorless, tasteless, and approved for human watermark, security thread within the paper, and new consumption. A quick test kit, similar to a pregnancy symbols on the bill. In 2004, the pharmaceutical test, can be performed in the field to determine the companies started using color-shifting ink that authenticity. The pill is put into a special receptor- changed color depending on the viewing angle so binding liquid, and a test strip is placed into the counterfeits can be easily recognized by members liquid. If the specified marker is in the pill, the strip downstream within the supply (Palmer, 2004). Others turns a specific color (Weinberg, 2007). Also, Kodak’s are experimenting with using inks or dyes and some Traceless® technology incorporates an odorless and are already using tamper-resistant packaging tape on colorless powder within the medicine packaging label some of their products. Also, there is a change to or within the drug ingredients. The package is read in raised printing in which letters are raised above the real-time with a patented handheld reader to paper for easy inspection and detection for authenticate the drugs. For medicine packaging counterfeits. labels, this method works with conventional printing methods and can be utilized during the Covert Strategies manufacturing process (Kodak, 2007). Companies are also shifting to covert strategies which utilize special devices to authenticate the Benefits drugs. Authentix utilizes a new method incorporating Pharmaceutical companies are more concerned about nanotechnology markers (50 nM to 5000 nM in size) brand image and reputation these days than ever which are mixed into the drug packaging and before. This is one of the key reasons to protect the individual pills. They can be specifically added to the supply chain by utilizing the latest technologies. inks, labels, and pill ingredients for easy detection. Counterfeit drugs can lead to drug recall and liability These markers have spectral properties that “light up” suits which can cost the company millions and billions when a light with a specific wavelength is placed on of dollars. Fen-Phen was recalled in 1997 and led to 50,000 liability lawsuits. The total costs for the recall A. Markers Emit Light at Specific Wavelength and lawsuits were estimated at $14 billion (Gilchrist, 2005). In addition, brand loyalty is compromised as consumers perceive additional risk when using a company’s products. It might take several months or years for a product to regain its market share D ru g depending on the severity of the initial damage. This N am e will result in lost sales and revenue along with the 50m g high costs of marketing and public relations to bring the drug back to the market (Paddison, 2005). An anti-counterfeiting strategy can better analyze Nanotechnology Specific Wavelength how these methods benefit the client most effectively Markers Light depending on business needs, requirements, desired B. Receptor Binding Test level of security, and geographic location. However, for this strategy to work properly, a multi-step Pill with approach has to be implemented because an Marker 3 Authentic individual strategy alone has not worked in the past. 1 2 A multi-level strategy uses complementing technologies that can provide the most protection for a company’s brand and the highest level of security. Counterfeit This will also result in additional costs as the technologies become more sophisticated and the Add Pill to Add Test Receptor Strip quantity of products becomes marked or tagged. A Binding Liquid basic foundation for protecting the Pharma Value Chain focuses on tracking methods such as RFID and Figure 6: Nanotechnology Markers Emit Light at Specific ePedigrees. The next step is to protect the medicine Wavelengths and Bind to Specific Receptor Binding Liquid bottles and blister packs with overt technologies by (Weinberg, 2007) | Multiple Strategies and Technologies to Combat Counterfeit Drugs | 5
  • 6. Technologies Increased Layers of Protection 3 Individual Pills Covert Pill • Nano- Technology • Ink Markers + Increasing Costs Patented Reader Medicine Bottles 3 Blister Packs • Color Shift Ink • Hologram • Watermarks 3 Boxes RFID Overt and • RFID and ePedigree XYZ Pharma Pallets Figure 7: Pharma Value Chain — Shifting Strategies and Technologies from Overt to Covert Results in Increased level of Security at Higher Costs increasing safeguards such as raised fonts, color- All of these items will lead to better-guarded supply shifting inks and logos, holograms, and watermarks chain and costs savings. This will result in decreasing so they can’t be reproduced by other sources. The the number of counterfeit products in the final step utilizes covert technologies to protect the marketplace, improving patient safety, and enhancing individual pills, medicine bottles, and blister packs by product authenticity. It also meets the necessary incorporating nanotechnology markers and patented increased audit and regulatory compliance by ink markers and readers for authentication. By using reducing the supply chain issues. Therefore, this multiple safeguards into a specific product, it makes complementing strategy based on client’s needs it expensive and time-consuming for the leads to an increased bottom-line by effectively counterfeiters. Furthermore, higher risk geographic locating its products within the supply chain from areas for counterfeit drugs require enhanced security manufacturer to patient and reducing leakage during levels and increased layers of protection in order to the routing process. This enables the drug protect the Pharma Value Chain. manufacturer to capture higher revenues for legitimate drugs in the marketplace and protecting the brand reputation. Increased Layers of Technologies Protection Nano- Technology Pill Ink Markers+ Reader Protect Supply Maintain Brand Increased Layers Color Shift Ink Chain Reputation of Protection Holograms Watermarks + Increase Revenue Enhance Patient RFID RFID+ and Profits and Drug Safety XYZ Pharma ePedigrees Figure 8: Implementation of Multiple Strategies for Protecting the Supply Chain, Maintaining Brand Reputation, Increasing Revenue and Profits, and Enhancing Patient and Drug Safety 6
  • 7. References McCarthy, Joe. 2006. “The Practicalities, Perils, and Acharya, Satish. 2006. “The Productivity Tiger- Time and Promise of RFID.” http://interrelativity.com/rfid/RFID- Cost Benefits of Clinical Drug Development in India.” Dorkbot-2006-03-01-final.pdf Pharmalicensing. Morris, Julian and Steven Philips. 2006. “Counterfeit http://pharmalicensing.com/features/disp/1153412098_4 Medicines in Less Developed Countries.” 4bfac02291f1 www.fightingdiseases.org/pdf/IPN_Counterfeits.pdf Bernstein, Illasa. 2007. “FDA’s Counterfeit Drug Paddison, Chris. 2005. A.T. Kearney “Executive Agenda - Initiative.” Busting the Myths of Pharma RFID.” http://www.unitdose.org/Bernstein.FDA.ppt#499,11,E- Pedigree http://www.atkearney.com/shared_res/pdf/Busting_the_ Myths_of_Pharma_RFID.pdf Credit Union National Association. 2007. “New Money’s Coming.” http://googolplex.cuna.org/12433/privacy.html Palmer, Gary. 2004. “For Pharmacists: Description and Identification of Counterfeit Drugs.” Dahold, Shabbir. 2007. “Safeguarding the drug supply http://www.pfizer.com/pfizer/subsites/counterfeit_impor chain with ePedigrees.” tation/mn_pharmacist_viagra.jsp http://www.bizjournals.com/masshightech/stories/2007/ 05/21/focus2.html Pitts, Peter. 2005. “21st Century Health Care Terrorism: The Perils of International Drug Counterfeiting.” DiMasi, J. Et al. 2002. “Returns on Research and www.pacificresearch.org/pub/sab/health/2005/21st_Cen Development for 1990s New Drug Introduction.” tury_Counterfeiting_Report.pdf Pharmacoeconomics 20: suppl.3, 11-29. Roche. 2007. “Getting Prescription Tamiflu: Counterfeit Demerjian, Dave. 2006. “Never Lose Luggage Again.” Information." http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2006/11 http://www.tamiflu.com/getting/counterfeit.aspx /72181 Shepherd, Marv. 2004. “Counterfeit Drugs and the FDA. 2005. “Radiofrequency Identification Technology: Pharmacist’s Responsibility.” Protecting the Drug Supply.” www.thecesolution.com/ce/lessons/AZ_Counterfeit_Dru http://www.fda.gov/fdac/features/2005/205_rfid.html gs_120104/images/AZ%20Counterfeit.pdf FDA. 2004. “FDA Announces New Initiative to Protect SupplyScape. 2006. “SupplyScape E-Pedigree.” the U.S. Drug Supply Through the Use of http://www.supplyscape.com/documents/SupplyScape_ Radiofrequency Identification EPedigreeDatasheet.pdf Technology”http://www.fda.gov/bbs/topics/news/2004/ NEW01133.html U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. 2006. “ICE Efforts to Combat Counterfeit Pharmaceuticals.” Genentech. 2001. “Product Update- Nutorpin AQ.” http://www.ice.gov/pi/news/factsheets/counterfeit_phar http://www.gene.com/gene/products/information/oppor ms.htm tunistic/nutropin-aq/update.jsp Weinberg, Cari. 2007. “Nanotechnology Fingerprints Can Gilchrist, Sue and Macpherson, Helen. 2005. “Update on Certify Authenticity.” Recent Development in the Pharmaceutical Industry.” http://www.aip.org/dbis/stories/2007/17021.html http://www.freehills.com.au/publications/publications_52 20.asp WHO (World Health Organization). 2007. “Frequently Asked Questions- What are the Different Types of HHS Task Force On Drug Importation. 2004. “Report on Counterfeit Drug Reported.” Prescription Drug Importation.” www.hhs.gov/importtaskforce/Report1220.pdf http://www.who.int/medicines/services/counterfeit/faqs/ 15/en/index.html Kelley, Brenda. 2004. “Securing the Drug Supply from WHO (World Health Organization). 2006. “Fact Sheet Counterfeiting Protects Brand Profits.” No. 275-Counterfeit Medicines.” www.supplyscape.com/.../Securing_Drug_Supply_from_ www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs275/en/ Counterfeiting_Protects_Brand_Profits_PMPS_Winter04. pdf Yankus, Wyatt. 2006. “Counterfeit Drugs: Coming to a Kodak. 2007. “Kodak Security Solutions Overview- Pharmacy Near You.” Traceless®.” www.fip.org/files/fip/counterfeit/counterfeits0608- http://www.graphics1.kodak.com/documents/Traceless% ACSH.pdf 20Pharmaceutical%20Anticounterfeiting%20Presentatio n.pdf Lamb, Ed. 2007. “Top 200 Prescriptions of 2006.” http://www.pharmacytimes.com/Article.cfm?Menu=1&ID= 4629 7
  • 8. About CSC’s Life Sciences R&D Solutions Enterprise Technology Integration (ETI) — Our ETI Our solutions span the entire range of drug Practice focuses on business systems strategy — we development, from basic research at the cellular and align the business system strategy to Business and molecular levels to human clinical trials of potential organizational strategies to ensure that technology is medicines that prevent and cure disease. CSC’s Life not implemented for the sake of technology; rather, it Sciences R&D solutions encompass: serves the business strategy set for R&D. Our solutions focus on: Strategy and Process Innovation (SPI) — Our SPI Practice links business and organizational strategies • Enterprise Content Management — We provide for R&D to deliver process innovation that solutions that help collaborate, control, and dramatically increases throughput in clinical comply to 21 CFR Part 11 and global regulatory development. Our proven solutions in this space bodies. Our expertise includes EDMS strategy, include: migration, optimization, eBLA, eCTD, SPL, and PIM. Our thought leadership in this space and our • Adaptive Clinical Trials — We provide consulting 14 years of expertise in this arena help our clients and industry expertise to reduce dead time achieve superior results. between phases. We effectively leverage modeling and simulation to reduce number of • Clinical Research Data Management — For patients in trials and help conduct in-silico trials, structured data, our team provides drug where appropriate — resulting in cost take-out development data management solutions that and shortened development cycles. are ICH, HL7, and CDISC compliant. These systems provide a better way to manage data • Phase I Outsourcing — Through our division, from labs, CRO’s, and imaging firms and enable Dynport Vaccine Corp. (DVC), we provide clients our clients to achieve significant efficiency and the ability to outsource entire Phase I studies. We productivity improvements for the R&D provide the program management, quantitative organization. measures to reduce time and costs, and proven process that enables clients to conduct more trials effectively. We currently manage 11 such For more information, visit www.csc.com/lifesciences. trials. CSC • In-Licensing — We implement strategies and Life Sciences Practice cutting-edge solutions to help pharmaceuticals 1160 West Swedesford Road, Suite 200 and biotechs take full advantage of in-licensing Berwyn, Pennsylvania 19312 to augment their pipelines. Our structured Unites States solutions ensure that no licensing opportunity is left unnoticed, and potential blockbuster opportunities are not given away to competition. • Bioinformatics Partnership — With the rise of commercial genomics, companies need to differentiate themselves from competition by efficiently managing biostatistics analytics and bioinformatics. CSC’s Life Sciences Practice serves as a strategic services partner to the client and provides standards driven bioinformatics solutions both through our U.S. and Indian operations and our strategic alliances with key partners. • Anti-counterfeiting Solutions — We leverage our expertise in defense, consumer products, and supply chain to deliver novel solutions for solving the expensive and ever-increasing drug counterfeiting issues. Our strategy and solutions go beyond the traditional RFID based solutions and provide quantifiable ROI. 8
  • 9. About the Authors Sanjay Modi CSC Life Sciences +1.973.243.0023 smodi@csc.com Sanjay Modi works in CSC Life Sciences R&D Solutions and is based in New York City. He holds a MBA from The University of Maryland and a Bachelor’s of Arts degree in Biology from The University of Delaware. Sanjeev Wadhwa CSC Life Sciences +1.973.243.0023 swadhwa@csc.com Sanjeev Wadhwa is a partner and senior strategy expert within CSC Life Sciences R&D Solutions. 9
  • 10. CSC 266 Second Avenue Waltham, Massachusetts 02451 United States +1.800.272.0018 Worldwide CSC Headquarters The Americas 3170 Fairview Park Drive Falls Church, Virginia 22042 United States +1.703.876.1000 Europe, Middle East, Africa Royal Pavilion Wellesley Road Aldershot, Hampshire GU11 1PZ United Kingdom +44(0)1252.534000 Australia 26 Talavera Road Macquarie Park, NSW 2113 Australia +61(0)29034.3000 Asia 139 Cecil Street #08-00 Cecil House Singapore 069539 Republic of Singapore +65.6221.9095 About CSC The mission of CSC is to be a global leader in providing technology enabled business solutions and services. With the broadest range of capabilities, CSC offers clients the solutions they need to manage complexity, focus on core businesses, collaborate with partners and clients, and improve operations. CSC makes a special point of understanding its clients and provides experts with real-world experience to work with them. CSC is vendor-independent, delivering solutions that best meet each client’s unique requirements. For more than 45 years, clients in industries and governments worldwide have trusted CSC with their business process and information systems outsourcing, systems integration and consulting needs. The company trades on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol “CSC.” Copyright © 2008 Computer Sciences Corporation. All rights reserved. DS08_0528