This caselet enables an interesting discussion on portfolio risk which can be minimized using Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT). The degree and direction of correlation between asset returns have far-reaching effects on reduction of portfolio risk through diversification. The caselet through the dilemmas of the protagonist Payal Roy (Payal) presents a comprehensive analysis of risk and return associated with portfolio investments. The protagonist of the caselet, Payal was facing a dilemma when she resorted to forming an effective portfolio which could minimize the risk levels. Different statistical and financial tools such as standard deviation, R-squared and beta have been used in this caselet, to analyze the combination of stocks that can form an optimal portfolio based on Payal’s risk tolerance.