SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 28
An introduction to HALT, HASS,
HASA, and CALT
Winson Mao
July 2, 2012
Page 2
Why accelerated life testing?
► Traditional testing methods are time consuming and
expensive.
► Manufacturers were not able to improve product
reliability dramatically with traditional testing
methods.
Page 3
Highly Accelerated Life Testing
HALT
Page 4
HALT — What is it?
Halt is a process to discover product design limitations
by subjecting products to step stresses.
• Halt is a design tool owned by engineering.
• To find product defects in design stage, not to pass
tests.
• To stimulate defects, not to simulate environmental
stresses.
Different
purpose
Different
Methods
Different
Equipment
Page 5
HALT — Equipment
Example: Qualmark Typhoon 2.5
Liquid nitrogen cooled
• Maximum thermal ramp rate: 200 °C/min
• Temperature range: -100°C to +200°C
Repetitive shock vibration
• Degrees of freedom: 6
• Acceleration: over 50G
Combined environment
Thermal and vibration
Page 6
HALT — Step stress approach model
Temperature step stress
Vibration step stress
Rapid thermal transitions
Combined environment
Page 7
HALT — How it works?
• Increase the stress, and repeat the process.
Page 8
HALT — Stress limits
Page 9
HALT — Why it works?
S-N Diagram (Aluminum 7075-T6)
(stress vs. number of cycles)
• 40KSI 2,000,000 cycles to failure
• 80KSI 2,000 cycles to failure
Number of cycles
Stress(KSI)
Page 10
HALT — Why it works?
20
15
10
5
100 200 300 400
TemperatureRateofChange°C/Min.
Number of Thermal Cycles
(18, 10)
(10, 55)
(5, 400)
Rate of change vs. number of cycles
18 °C/min 10 cycles
10 °C/min 55 cycles
5 °C/min 400 cycles
Page 11
HALT — Summary of results
Failure Percentage by Stress Type
Cold Step
Stress
14%
Combined
Environment
20%
Vibration Step
Stress
45%
Rapid Thermal
Transition
4%
Hot Step
Stress
17%
Page 12
HALT — Early fault detection is key
The cost of finding and fixing a product fault:
 $46 — during design phase
 $228 — before procurement
 $480 — before production
 $22,000 — before shipment
 $900,000 — on customer site
~ Hiroshi Hamada, Ricoh’s chairman
Page 13
HALT — BenefitsSpending
Time
MR
MR
MR — Manufacturing Release.
Page 14
Highly Accelerated Stress Screening
HASS
Page 15
HASS
A screening operation to detect weakness in
manufacturing.
• Equipment and parameters from HALT
• A mixed thermal cycle/vibration stress pattern
Page 16
HASS — Screen profile
For example
Page 17
HASS — General rules
• Screening of 100% of production
• Screening stress level — the 80/50 rule
80% of the temperature operating limits found in HALT.
50% of the vibration operating limits found in HALT.
• An effective yet safe screening profile
Effective: A singe application of the screen.
Safe: Remove less than 5% of the total life.
Page 18
Highly Accelerated Stress Auditing
HASA
Page 19
HASA
The same as HASS, only operated on an audit basis instead
of 100%.
Page 20
Calibrated Accelerated Life Testing
CALT
Page 21
CALT — What is it?
A test process that allows time compression in life testing
while retaining correlation in resulting life predictions.
Statistical model for CALT:
• Statistic distribution
The scatter in product life under a constant stress
• Relationship between life and stress
Page 22
CALT — Failure distribution
A mathematical model that describes the probability of failures
occurring over time.
Exponential distribution Normal distribution
Lognormal distribution Weibull distribution
Page 23
CALT — Weibull distribution
Weibull probability density
,)()(
1
et
tk
tf
k
k
k 


 0t
where k>0 is the shape parameter,
λ>0 is the scale parameter.
λ — the characteristic life (63.2%).
Page 24
CALT — Life and stress relationship
Usually the mean of the life distribution is expressed as a
function of the accelerating stress.
• Arrhenius relationship
es
B
CL 
where s is the stress, L is the mean of the life distribution, C, B, k, n are
unknown parameters.
• Inverse power model
s
n
k
L


1
s
BCL
1
lnln 
snkL lnlnln 
Page 25
CALT — Approach
Page 26
CALT — Complications
 Find the most suitable failure distribution model and
life—stress relationship
• Graphical data analysis
• Least squares analysis
• Maximum likelihood methods
 Competing failure modes
Page 27
References
 GMW8287 Highly Accelerated Life Testing, February
2002.
 GMW8758 Calibrated Accelerated Life Testing (CALT),
October 2004.
 W. Nelson, Accelerated Testing: Statistical Methods, Test
Plans, and Data Analysis, John Wiley & Sons, 2004.
 H. W. Mclean, Halt, Hass, and Hasa Explained, Revised
Edition, ASQ Quality Press, 2009.
Page 28
The End
Thank you!

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

CrystalBall in New Product Development
CrystalBall in New Product DevelopmentCrystalBall in New Product Development
CrystalBall in New Product DevelopmentRamon Balisnomo
 
Reliability estimation from accelerated degradation testing
Reliability estimation from accelerated degradation testingReliability estimation from accelerated degradation testing
Reliability estimation from accelerated degradation testingASQ Reliability Division
 
Ensuring reliability in lean new product development part2of2 24
Ensuring reliability in lean new product development part2of2 24Ensuring reliability in lean new product development part2of2 24
Ensuring reliability in lean new product development part2of2 24ASQ Reliability Division
 
Systematic Innovation An Introduction To Triz
Systematic Innovation    An Introduction To TrizSystematic Innovation    An Introduction To Triz
Systematic Innovation An Introduction To TrizRamon Balisnomo
 
Tolerance Stackups Using Oracle Crystal Ball
Tolerance Stackups Using Oracle Crystal BallTolerance Stackups Using Oracle Crystal Ball
Tolerance Stackups Using Oracle Crystal BallRamon Balisnomo
 
Tinker Tower DFSS Class Exercise
Tinker Tower DFSS Class ExerciseTinker Tower DFSS Class Exercise
Tinker Tower DFSS Class ExerciseRamon Balisnomo
 
ToleranceStackup
ToleranceStackupToleranceStackup
ToleranceStackupWinson Mao
 
Performing Tolerance Stack Ups Using Automated Excel Calculator By Arash Vakily
Performing Tolerance Stack Ups Using Automated Excel Calculator By Arash VakilyPerforming Tolerance Stack Ups Using Automated Excel Calculator By Arash Vakily
Performing Tolerance Stack Ups Using Automated Excel Calculator By Arash VakilyArash Vakily
 
Formula Fueler Design Of Experiments Class Exercise
Formula Fueler Design Of Experiments Class ExerciseFormula Fueler Design Of Experiments Class Exercise
Formula Fueler Design Of Experiments Class ExerciseRamon Balisnomo
 

Viewers also liked (13)

Highly accelerated stress screening
Highly accelerated stress screeningHighly accelerated stress screening
Highly accelerated stress screening
 
CrystalBall in New Product Development
CrystalBall in New Product DevelopmentCrystalBall in New Product Development
CrystalBall in New Product Development
 
Reliability estimation from accelerated degradation testing
Reliability estimation from accelerated degradation testingReliability estimation from accelerated degradation testing
Reliability estimation from accelerated degradation testing
 
Ensuring reliability in lean new product development part2of2 24
Ensuring reliability in lean new product development part2of2 24Ensuring reliability in lean new product development part2of2 24
Ensuring reliability in lean new product development part2of2 24
 
Qarajeet
QarajeetQarajeet
Qarajeet
 
Systematic Innovation An Introduction To Triz
Systematic Innovation    An Introduction To TrizSystematic Innovation    An Introduction To Triz
Systematic Innovation An Introduction To Triz
 
Tolerance analysis
Tolerance analysisTolerance analysis
Tolerance analysis
 
Tolerance Stackups Using Oracle Crystal Ball
Tolerance Stackups Using Oracle Crystal BallTolerance Stackups Using Oracle Crystal Ball
Tolerance Stackups Using Oracle Crystal Ball
 
Tinker Tower DFSS Class Exercise
Tinker Tower DFSS Class ExerciseTinker Tower DFSS Class Exercise
Tinker Tower DFSS Class Exercise
 
ToleranceStackup
ToleranceStackupToleranceStackup
ToleranceStackup
 
Performing Tolerance Stack Ups Using Automated Excel Calculator By Arash Vakily
Performing Tolerance Stack Ups Using Automated Excel Calculator By Arash VakilyPerforming Tolerance Stack Ups Using Automated Excel Calculator By Arash Vakily
Performing Tolerance Stack Ups Using Automated Excel Calculator By Arash Vakily
 
Formula Fueler Design Of Experiments Class Exercise
Formula Fueler Design Of Experiments Class ExerciseFormula Fueler Design Of Experiments Class Exercise
Formula Fueler Design Of Experiments Class Exercise
 
Example of DFSS Project
Example of DFSS ProjectExample of DFSS Project
Example of DFSS Project
 

Similar to ALT

Overview of halt a paradigm shift for rev3
Overview of halt a  paradigm shift for   rev3Overview of halt a  paradigm shift for   rev3
Overview of halt a paradigm shift for rev3Accendo Reliability
 
Applied Reliability Symposium 2009 M Turner
Applied Reliability Symposium 2009 M TurnerApplied Reliability Symposium 2009 M Turner
Applied Reliability Symposium 2009 M TurnerMark Turner CRP
 
Testing modules for potential-induced degradation – a status update of IEC 62804
Testing modules for potential-induced degradation – a status update of IEC 62804Testing modules for potential-induced degradation – a status update of IEC 62804
Testing modules for potential-induced degradation – a status update of IEC 62804Claudio Liciotti
 
Velocys ppt140813_ENFL-ACS_2014
Velocys ppt140813_ENFL-ACS_2014Velocys ppt140813_ENFL-ACS_2014
Velocys ppt140813_ENFL-ACS_2014John Glenning
 
PACCAR Investigation of Glass Fiber Reinforced Nylon 6/6 for Automotive Appli...
PACCAR Investigation of Glass Fiber Reinforced Nylon 6/6 for Automotive Appli...PACCAR Investigation of Glass Fiber Reinforced Nylon 6/6 for Automotive Appli...
PACCAR Investigation of Glass Fiber Reinforced Nylon 6/6 for Automotive Appli...Andrew Hollcraft
 
Major Challenges in HPHT Operations
Major Challenges in HPHT OperationsMajor Challenges in HPHT Operations
Major Challenges in HPHT OperationsHPHT Wells Summit
 
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...Society of Petroleum Engineers
 
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...Society of Petroleum Engineers
 
CFD Best Practices & Key Features
CFD Best Practices & Key FeaturesCFD Best Practices & Key Features
CFD Best Practices & Key FeaturesDesign World
 
Process simulation introduction 2018
Process simulation introduction 2018Process simulation introduction 2018
Process simulation introduction 2018DJHPIDesign
 
PPT ON TAGUCHI METHODS / TECHNIQUES - KAUSTUBH BABREKAR
PPT ON TAGUCHI METHODS / TECHNIQUES - KAUSTUBH BABREKARPPT ON TAGUCHI METHODS / TECHNIQUES - KAUSTUBH BABREKAR
PPT ON TAGUCHI METHODS / TECHNIQUES - KAUSTUBH BABREKARKaustubh Babrekar
 
Wireless Measurement and Control - AIChE New Orleans
Wireless Measurement and Control - AIChE New OrleansWireless Measurement and Control - AIChE New Orleans
Wireless Measurement and Control - AIChE New OrleansJim Cahill
 
Part 1 Biofluids Summary and CFD basics Pt 1(1).pdf
Part 1 Biofluids Summary and CFD basics Pt 1(1).pdfPart 1 Biofluids Summary and CFD basics Pt 1(1).pdf
Part 1 Biofluids Summary and CFD basics Pt 1(1).pdfSajawalNawaz5
 
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...KBC (A Yokogawa Company)
 
PID Tuning for Self Regulating Processes - Greg McMillan Deminar
PID Tuning for Self Regulating Processes - Greg McMillan DeminarPID Tuning for Self Regulating Processes - Greg McMillan Deminar
PID Tuning for Self Regulating Processes - Greg McMillan DeminarJim Cahill
 
Containment Filtered Venting - A new approach
Containment Filtered Venting - A new approachContainment Filtered Venting - A new approach
Containment Filtered Venting - A new approachAlexander Wolski
 

Similar to ALT (20)

Overview of halt a paradigm shift for rev3
Overview of halt a  paradigm shift for   rev3Overview of halt a  paradigm shift for   rev3
Overview of halt a paradigm shift for rev3
 
Applied Reliability Symposium 2009 M Turner
Applied Reliability Symposium 2009 M TurnerApplied Reliability Symposium 2009 M Turner
Applied Reliability Symposium 2009 M Turner
 
Testing modules for potential-induced degradation – a status update of IEC 62804
Testing modules for potential-induced degradation – a status update of IEC 62804Testing modules for potential-induced degradation – a status update of IEC 62804
Testing modules for potential-induced degradation – a status update of IEC 62804
 
Velocys ppt140813_ENFL-ACS_2014
Velocys ppt140813_ENFL-ACS_2014Velocys ppt140813_ENFL-ACS_2014
Velocys ppt140813_ENFL-ACS_2014
 
PACCAR Investigation of Glass Fiber Reinforced Nylon 6/6 for Automotive Appli...
PACCAR Investigation of Glass Fiber Reinforced Nylon 6/6 for Automotive Appli...PACCAR Investigation of Glass Fiber Reinforced Nylon 6/6 for Automotive Appli...
PACCAR Investigation of Glass Fiber Reinforced Nylon 6/6 for Automotive Appli...
 
Major Challenges in HPHT Operations
Major Challenges in HPHT OperationsMajor Challenges in HPHT Operations
Major Challenges in HPHT Operations
 
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...
 
annalee-1207
annalee-1207annalee-1207
annalee-1207
 
Automating Leak Testing
Automating Leak TestingAutomating Leak Testing
Automating Leak Testing
 
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...
Verifying Performance and Capability of New Technology for Surface and Subsur...
 
shock theory ppt.pptx
shock theory ppt.pptxshock theory ppt.pptx
shock theory ppt.pptx
 
CFD Best Practices & Key Features
CFD Best Practices & Key FeaturesCFD Best Practices & Key Features
CFD Best Practices & Key Features
 
Process simulation introduction 2018
Process simulation introduction 2018Process simulation introduction 2018
Process simulation introduction 2018
 
PPT ON TAGUCHI METHODS / TECHNIQUES - KAUSTUBH BABREKAR
PPT ON TAGUCHI METHODS / TECHNIQUES - KAUSTUBH BABREKARPPT ON TAGUCHI METHODS / TECHNIQUES - KAUSTUBH BABREKAR
PPT ON TAGUCHI METHODS / TECHNIQUES - KAUSTUBH BABREKAR
 
Wireless Measurement and Control - AIChE New Orleans
Wireless Measurement and Control - AIChE New OrleansWireless Measurement and Control - AIChE New Orleans
Wireless Measurement and Control - AIChE New Orleans
 
Part 1 Biofluids Summary and CFD basics Pt 1(1).pdf
Part 1 Biofluids Summary and CFD basics Pt 1(1).pdfPart 1 Biofluids Summary and CFD basics Pt 1(1).pdf
Part 1 Biofluids Summary and CFD basics Pt 1(1).pdf
 
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
 
PID Tuning for Self Regulating Processes - Greg McMillan Deminar
PID Tuning for Self Regulating Processes - Greg McMillan DeminarPID Tuning for Self Regulating Processes - Greg McMillan Deminar
PID Tuning for Self Regulating Processes - Greg McMillan Deminar
 
Containment Filtered Venting - A new approach
Containment Filtered Venting - A new approachContainment Filtered Venting - A new approach
Containment Filtered Venting - A new approach
 
03 adam hand
03 adam hand03 adam hand
03 adam hand
 

ALT

  • 1. An introduction to HALT, HASS, HASA, and CALT Winson Mao July 2, 2012
  • 2. Page 2 Why accelerated life testing? ► Traditional testing methods are time consuming and expensive. ► Manufacturers were not able to improve product reliability dramatically with traditional testing methods.
  • 3. Page 3 Highly Accelerated Life Testing HALT
  • 4. Page 4 HALT — What is it? Halt is a process to discover product design limitations by subjecting products to step stresses. • Halt is a design tool owned by engineering. • To find product defects in design stage, not to pass tests. • To stimulate defects, not to simulate environmental stresses. Different purpose Different Methods Different Equipment
  • 5. Page 5 HALT — Equipment Example: Qualmark Typhoon 2.5 Liquid nitrogen cooled • Maximum thermal ramp rate: 200 °C/min • Temperature range: -100°C to +200°C Repetitive shock vibration • Degrees of freedom: 6 • Acceleration: over 50G Combined environment Thermal and vibration
  • 6. Page 6 HALT — Step stress approach model Temperature step stress Vibration step stress Rapid thermal transitions Combined environment
  • 7. Page 7 HALT — How it works? • Increase the stress, and repeat the process.
  • 8. Page 8 HALT — Stress limits
  • 9. Page 9 HALT — Why it works? S-N Diagram (Aluminum 7075-T6) (stress vs. number of cycles) • 40KSI 2,000,000 cycles to failure • 80KSI 2,000 cycles to failure Number of cycles Stress(KSI)
  • 10. Page 10 HALT — Why it works? 20 15 10 5 100 200 300 400 TemperatureRateofChange°C/Min. Number of Thermal Cycles (18, 10) (10, 55) (5, 400) Rate of change vs. number of cycles 18 °C/min 10 cycles 10 °C/min 55 cycles 5 °C/min 400 cycles
  • 11. Page 11 HALT — Summary of results Failure Percentage by Stress Type Cold Step Stress 14% Combined Environment 20% Vibration Step Stress 45% Rapid Thermal Transition 4% Hot Step Stress 17%
  • 12. Page 12 HALT — Early fault detection is key The cost of finding and fixing a product fault:  $46 — during design phase  $228 — before procurement  $480 — before production  $22,000 — before shipment  $900,000 — on customer site ~ Hiroshi Hamada, Ricoh’s chairman
  • 13. Page 13 HALT — BenefitsSpending Time MR MR MR — Manufacturing Release.
  • 14. Page 14 Highly Accelerated Stress Screening HASS
  • 15. Page 15 HASS A screening operation to detect weakness in manufacturing. • Equipment and parameters from HALT • A mixed thermal cycle/vibration stress pattern
  • 16. Page 16 HASS — Screen profile For example
  • 17. Page 17 HASS — General rules • Screening of 100% of production • Screening stress level — the 80/50 rule 80% of the temperature operating limits found in HALT. 50% of the vibration operating limits found in HALT. • An effective yet safe screening profile Effective: A singe application of the screen. Safe: Remove less than 5% of the total life.
  • 18. Page 18 Highly Accelerated Stress Auditing HASA
  • 19. Page 19 HASA The same as HASS, only operated on an audit basis instead of 100%.
  • 20. Page 20 Calibrated Accelerated Life Testing CALT
  • 21. Page 21 CALT — What is it? A test process that allows time compression in life testing while retaining correlation in resulting life predictions. Statistical model for CALT: • Statistic distribution The scatter in product life under a constant stress • Relationship between life and stress
  • 22. Page 22 CALT — Failure distribution A mathematical model that describes the probability of failures occurring over time. Exponential distribution Normal distribution Lognormal distribution Weibull distribution
  • 23. Page 23 CALT — Weibull distribution Weibull probability density ,)()( 1 et tk tf k k k     0t where k>0 is the shape parameter, λ>0 is the scale parameter. λ — the characteristic life (63.2%).
  • 24. Page 24 CALT — Life and stress relationship Usually the mean of the life distribution is expressed as a function of the accelerating stress. • Arrhenius relationship es B CL  where s is the stress, L is the mean of the life distribution, C, B, k, n are unknown parameters. • Inverse power model s n k L   1 s BCL 1 lnln  snkL lnlnln 
  • 25. Page 25 CALT — Approach
  • 26. Page 26 CALT — Complications  Find the most suitable failure distribution model and life—stress relationship • Graphical data analysis • Least squares analysis • Maximum likelihood methods  Competing failure modes
  • 27. Page 27 References  GMW8287 Highly Accelerated Life Testing, February 2002.  GMW8758 Calibrated Accelerated Life Testing (CALT), October 2004.  W. Nelson, Accelerated Testing: Statistical Methods, Test Plans, and Data Analysis, John Wiley & Sons, 2004.  H. W. Mclean, Halt, Hass, and Hasa Explained, Revised Edition, ASQ Quality Press, 2009.