SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 15
Market Fragmentation: What the Research Shows Sharon Brown-Hruska and Jerry Ellig Mercatus Center George Mason University http://www.mercatus.org/
Fragmentation or Competition? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Does fragmentation impair quote competition? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Benefits of competition (a.k.a. “fragmentation”) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
SEC’s 1997 Preferencing Study ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Suspicions… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
SEC proposals, August 2000 ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Payment for order flow: ,[object Object]
Does payment for order flow impair market efficiency? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
“ Best execution” is multi-faceted ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Payment for order flow and execution quality Faster Speed of execution Lower Other transaction costs Greater (NBBO) Price certainty Lower  (Likely offsets spread) Commissions Higher Spread
Payment for order flow segments the market ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Different effects on different traders ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Conclusions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
For more information… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

More Related Content

What's hot

M&A in banking series part 2
M&A in banking series part 2M&A in banking series part 2
M&A in banking series part 2
Gordon Low
 

What's hot (17)

Competition for-the-market
Competition for-the-marketCompetition for-the-market
Competition for-the-market
 
Scm t8
Scm t8Scm t8
Scm t8
 
Supply Chain Risk Management Step 1: Risk Identification
Supply Chain Risk Management Step 1: Risk Identification Supply Chain Risk Management Step 1: Risk Identification
Supply Chain Risk Management Step 1: Risk Identification
 
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...
 
Market analysis
Market analysisMarket analysis
Market analysis
 
Multi-sided markets – Filistrucchi – June 2017 OECD discussion
Multi-sided markets – Filistrucchi – June 2017 OECD discussionMulti-sided markets – Filistrucchi – June 2017 OECD discussion
Multi-sided markets – Filistrucchi – June 2017 OECD discussion
 
Multi-sided markets – Brekke – June 2017 OECD discussion
Multi-sided markets – Brekke – June 2017 OECD discussionMulti-sided markets – Brekke – June 2017 OECD discussion
Multi-sided markets – Brekke – June 2017 OECD discussion
 
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...
Economic Analysis in Merger Investigations – Break-out Session 2 – Quantitati...
 
Supply Chain Risk Management Step 2: Risk Impact Assessment
Supply Chain Risk Management Step 2: Risk Impact Assessment Supply Chain Risk Management Step 2: Risk Impact Assessment
Supply Chain Risk Management Step 2: Risk Impact Assessment
 
Multi-sided markets – Collyer – June 2017 OECD discussion
Multi-sided markets – Collyer – June 2017 OECD discussionMulti-sided markets – Collyer – June 2017 OECD discussion
Multi-sided markets – Collyer – June 2017 OECD discussion
 
Porter's 5 Forces Model
Porter's 5 Forces ModelPorter's 5 Forces Model
Porter's 5 Forces Model
 
Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – JENKINS – December 2021 OECD ...
Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – JENKINS – December 2021 OECD ...Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – JENKINS – December 2021 OECD ...
Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – JENKINS – December 2021 OECD ...
 
Pharmaceuticals – EU – November 2018 OECD discussion
Pharmaceuticals – EU – November 2018 OECD discussionPharmaceuticals – EU – November 2018 OECD discussion
Pharmaceuticals – EU – November 2018 OECD discussion
 
Environmental Considerations – INDERST – December 2021 OECD discussion
Environmental Considerations – INDERST – December 2021 OECD discussionEnvironmental Considerations – INDERST – December 2021 OECD discussion
Environmental Considerations – INDERST – December 2021 OECD discussion
 
M&A in banking series part 2
M&A in banking series part 2M&A in banking series part 2
M&A in banking series part 2
 
Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – Break-out Session 1 – Techniq...
Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – Break-out Session 1 – Techniq...Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – Break-out Session 1 – Techniq...
Economic analysis and evidence in abuse cases – Break-out Session 1 – Techniq...
 
Market Abusive Practices in the Electricity Sector
Market Abusive Practices in the Electricity SectorMarket Abusive Practices in the Electricity Sector
Market Abusive Practices in the Electricity Sector
 

Similar to Brown Hruska And Ellig Market Fragmentation Final Present To Sta 2000

GROUP 11 PRESENTATION 22 presented by group
GROUP 11 PRESENTATION 22 presented by groupGROUP 11 PRESENTATION 22 presented by group
GROUP 11 PRESENTATION 22 presented by group
Sumit717679
 
MKT_Broker_Analysis_Measuring_Execution_Quality_in_a_Fragmented_Market(US)_Ma...
MKT_Broker_Analysis_Measuring_Execution_Quality_in_a_Fragmented_Market(US)_Ma...MKT_Broker_Analysis_Measuring_Execution_Quality_in_a_Fragmented_Market(US)_Ma...
MKT_Broker_Analysis_Measuring_Execution_Quality_in_a_Fragmented_Market(US)_Ma...
Samuel Zou
 
Channel Concept
Channel ConceptChannel Concept
Channel Concept
Sj -
 
Chapter 10 price - the online value
Chapter 10   price - the online valueChapter 10   price - the online value
Chapter 10 price - the online value
Dr. Ankit Kesharwani
 

Similar to Brown Hruska And Ellig Market Fragmentation Final Present To Sta 2000 (20)

Spectrum Auction Recommendations for ICASA in South Africa
Spectrum Auction Recommendations for ICASA in South AfricaSpectrum Auction Recommendations for ICASA in South Africa
Spectrum Auction Recommendations for ICASA in South Africa
 
Spectrum Auctions for iWeek South Africa KB Enterprises
Spectrum Auctions for iWeek South Africa KB EnterprisesSpectrum Auctions for iWeek South Africa KB Enterprises
Spectrum Auctions for iWeek South Africa KB Enterprises
 
Equity Investments
Equity InvestmentsEquity Investments
Equity Investments
 
April_2013
April_2013April_2013
April_2013
 
GROUP 11 PRESENTATION 22 presented by group
GROUP 11 PRESENTATION 22 presented by groupGROUP 11 PRESENTATION 22 presented by group
GROUP 11 PRESENTATION 22 presented by group
 
PPP on Market Split.pptx
PPP on Market Split.pptxPPP on Market Split.pptx
PPP on Market Split.pptx
 
MKT_Broker_Analysis_Measuring_Execution_Quality_in_a_Fragmented_Market(US)_Ma...
MKT_Broker_Analysis_Measuring_Execution_Quality_in_a_Fragmented_Market(US)_Ma...MKT_Broker_Analysis_Measuring_Execution_Quality_in_a_Fragmented_Market(US)_Ma...
MKT_Broker_Analysis_Measuring_Execution_Quality_in_a_Fragmented_Market(US)_Ma...
 
Technical analysis, market efficiency, and behavioral finance
Technical analysis, market efficiency, and behavioral financeTechnical analysis, market efficiency, and behavioral finance
Technical analysis, market efficiency, and behavioral finance
 
342chapter18
342chapter18342chapter18
342chapter18
 
#CPAF15 WS2: Value Chain Integration (Monika Sopov, Joost Guijt, Centre for D...
#CPAF15 WS2: Value Chain Integration (Monika Sopov, Joost Guijt, Centre for D...#CPAF15 WS2: Value Chain Integration (Monika Sopov, Joost Guijt, Centre for D...
#CPAF15 WS2: Value Chain Integration (Monika Sopov, Joost Guijt, Centre for D...
 
Competition Management
Competition Management Competition Management
Competition Management
 
Volatility
VolatilityVolatility
Volatility
 
The common stock market ppt @ mba finance
The common stock market ppt @ mba financeThe common stock market ppt @ mba finance
The common stock market ppt @ mba finance
 
Marketing evaluation
Marketing evaluationMarketing evaluation
Marketing evaluation
 
Market Analysis
Market AnalysisMarket Analysis
Market Analysis
 
AAII Los Angeles September 2014
AAII Los Angeles September 2014AAII Los Angeles September 2014
AAII Los Angeles September 2014
 
Channel Concept
Channel ConceptChannel Concept
Channel Concept
 
M4P Presentation
M4P PresentationM4P Presentation
M4P Presentation
 
Chapter 10 price - the online value
Chapter 10   price - the online valueChapter 10   price - the online value
Chapter 10 price - the online value
 
Market structure
Market structureMarket structure
Market structure
 

More from Mercatus Center

More from Mercatus Center (20)

ACA Has Worsened Medicaid's Structural Problems
ACA Has Worsened Medicaid's Structural ProblemsACA Has Worsened Medicaid's Structural Problems
ACA Has Worsened Medicaid's Structural Problems
 
Evaluating a Sluggish Economy with Bruce Yandle
Evaluating a Sluggish Economy with Bruce YandleEvaluating a Sluggish Economy with Bruce Yandle
Evaluating a Sluggish Economy with Bruce Yandle
 
Affordable Care Act's 6 Year Anniversary
Affordable Care Act's 6 Year AnniversaryAffordable Care Act's 6 Year Anniversary
Affordable Care Act's 6 Year Anniversary
 
Capitol Hill Campis March 2016
Capitol Hill Campis March 2016Capitol Hill Campis March 2016
Capitol Hill Campis March 2016
 
Nominal GDP Targeting
Nominal GDP TargetingNominal GDP Targeting
Nominal GDP Targeting
 
Understanding the U.S. Health Care System
Understanding the U.S. Health Care SystemUnderstanding the U.S. Health Care System
Understanding the U.S. Health Care System
 
Wireless Spectrum in 2016: A Policy Update
Wireless Spectrum in 2016: A Policy UpdateWireless Spectrum in 2016: A Policy Update
Wireless Spectrum in 2016: A Policy Update
 
Buchanan Speaker Series: Education, Inequality, and Incentives
Buchanan Speaker Series: Education, Inequality, and IncentivesBuchanan Speaker Series: Education, Inequality, and Incentives
Buchanan Speaker Series: Education, Inequality, and Incentives
 
Modernizing Freight Rail Regulation: Recommendations from the TRB Study
Modernizing Freight Rail Regulation: Recommendations from the TRB StudyModernizing Freight Rail Regulation: Recommendations from the TRB Study
Modernizing Freight Rail Regulation: Recommendations from the TRB Study
 
Modernizing the SSDI Eligibility Criteria: Trends in Demographics and Labor M...
Modernizing the SSDI Eligibility Criteria: Trends in Demographics and Labor M...Modernizing the SSDI Eligibility Criteria: Trends in Demographics and Labor M...
Modernizing the SSDI Eligibility Criteria: Trends in Demographics and Labor M...
 
An Economic Situation Update with Bruce Yandle
An Economic Situation Update with Bruce YandleAn Economic Situation Update with Bruce Yandle
An Economic Situation Update with Bruce Yandle
 
How Can Policymakers and Regulators Better Engage the Internet of Things?
How Can Policymakers and Regulators Better Engage the Internet of Things? How Can Policymakers and Regulators Better Engage the Internet of Things?
How Can Policymakers and Regulators Better Engage the Internet of Things?
 
What Should We Do about Cyber Attacks?
What Should We Do about Cyber Attacks?What Should We Do about Cyber Attacks?
What Should We Do about Cyber Attacks?
 
Tools for Tracking the Economic Impact of Legislation
Tools for Tracking the Economic Impact of LegislationTools for Tracking the Economic Impact of Legislation
Tools for Tracking the Economic Impact of Legislation
 
The Sharing Economy: Perspectives on Policies in the New Economy
The Sharing Economy: Perspectives on Policies in the New EconomyThe Sharing Economy: Perspectives on Policies in the New Economy
The Sharing Economy: Perspectives on Policies in the New Economy
 
Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...
Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...
Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...
 
Bootleggers and Baptists in the Garden of Good and Evil: Understanding Americ...
Bootleggers and Baptists in the Garden of Good and Evil: Understanding Americ...Bootleggers and Baptists in the Garden of Good and Evil: Understanding Americ...
Bootleggers and Baptists in the Garden of Good and Evil: Understanding Americ...
 
Stephen C. Goss Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI Panel
Stephen C. Goss Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI PanelStephen C. Goss Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI Panel
Stephen C. Goss Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI Panel
 
David Stapleton Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI Panel
David Stapleton Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI PanelDavid Stapleton Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI Panel
David Stapleton Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI Panel
 
Jason J. Fichtner Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI Panel
Jason J. Fichtner Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI PanelJason J. Fichtner Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI Panel
Jason J. Fichtner Presentation for Mercatus Center SSDI Panel
 

Recently uploaded

Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service NoidaCall Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
dlhescort
 
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
amitlee9823
 
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Anamikakaur10
 
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
amitlee9823
 
Call Girls From Pari Chowk Greater Noida ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service I...
Call Girls From Pari Chowk Greater Noida ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service I...Call Girls From Pari Chowk Greater Noida ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service I...
Call Girls From Pari Chowk Greater Noida ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service I...
lizamodels9
 
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
daisycvs
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service NoidaCall Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
 
Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...
Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...
Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...
 
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
 
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
 
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with CultureOrganizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
 
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
 
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine ServiceCall Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
 
BAGALUR CALL GIRL IN 98274*61493 ❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRL
BAGALUR CALL GIRL IN 98274*61493 ❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRLBAGALUR CALL GIRL IN 98274*61493 ❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRL
BAGALUR CALL GIRL IN 98274*61493 ❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRL
 
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
 
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesMysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
 
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
 
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptxMonthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
 
Falcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to Prosperity
Falcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to ProsperityFalcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to Prosperity
Falcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to Prosperity
 
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdfDr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
 
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
 
Call Girls From Pari Chowk Greater Noida ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service I...
Call Girls From Pari Chowk Greater Noida ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service I...Call Girls From Pari Chowk Greater Noida ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service I...
Call Girls From Pari Chowk Greater Noida ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service I...
 
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
 
Eluru Call Girls Service ☎ ️93326-06886 ❤️‍🔥 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service
Eluru Call Girls Service ☎ ️93326-06886 ❤️‍🔥 Enjoy 24/7 Escort ServiceEluru Call Girls Service ☎ ️93326-06886 ❤️‍🔥 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service
Eluru Call Girls Service ☎ ️93326-06886 ❤️‍🔥 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service
 

Brown Hruska And Ellig Market Fragmentation Final Present To Sta 2000

  • 1. Market Fragmentation: What the Research Shows Sharon Brown-Hruska and Jerry Ellig Mercatus Center George Mason University http://www.mercatus.org/
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11. Payment for order flow and execution quality Faster Speed of execution Lower Other transaction costs Greater (NBBO) Price certainty Lower (Likely offsets spread) Commissions Higher Spread
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.