SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 24
Didactical engineering of museum exhibitions The case of a museum exhibit on animal adaptations to darkness
Background ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Design-based research ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],(Cobb et al., 2003)
Case Cave Expedition  (Experimentarium, Copenhagen)
Content Cave Expedition  (Experimentarium, Copenhagen)  Adaptations of the blind cave beetle to its environment of permanently dark caves
Project overview Design (exhibit engineering) Enactment  (visitors - exhibit) Analysis (synthesis of model) RQ:  Which factors, related to the scientific content or the exhibit objectives, affect the engineering of an exhibit? RQ:  Which relationships exist between the characteristics of exhibit engineering and those of visitors’ experiences? RQ:  Can re-engineering of an exhibit, based on empirical findings synthesised with education theory, engender visitor experiences that better reflect the stated objectives? (Design-based research collective, 2003)
Design Exhibition engineering ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],(Chevallard, 1985)
Source knowledge context Muscle cell Red blood cell Nerve  cell Transposition Teaching context Prototypical animal cell (c.f. Clément, 2007)
Museographic transposition ( adapted from Simonneaux & Jacobi, 1997 )
Content Adaptations of the blind cave beetle to its environment of permanently dark caves
 
Cave ( environment ) Abiotic factors Biotic factors Cave beetle (organism) Morphological adaptations Physiological adaptations Behavioural adaptations clawed feet reduced eyes tricho- bothria elongated antennae elongated legs CO 2 tolerance slow, methodical movement  reduced pigment reduced wings steno- hygrobia  chemo- reception tactile sense prey predators enclosed space saturated atmosphere high CO 2 uneven surfaces permanent darkness pools and drips vibration detection Scientific knowledge
 
Knowledge ecology of the Cave Expedition exhibit
Knowledge ecology  of the  Cave Expedition exhibit ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cave (environment) Abiotic factors Biotic factors Cave beetle (organism) Morphological adaptations Physiological adaptations Behavioural adaptations clawed feet reduced eyes tricho- bothria elongated antennae elongated legs CO 2 tolerance slow, methodical movement  reduced pigment reduced wings steno- hygrobia  chemo- reception tactile sense prey predators enclosed space saturated atmosphere high CO 2 uneven surfaces permanent darkness pools and drips vibration detection Cave beetle (visitor) Cave (exhibit) Abiotic factors darkness enclosed space uneven surfaces Biotic factors
“ These are the types of animals you’d find in caves. These are the animals that would prey on the beetles [in the wild]” (Exhibition engineer I, 2007)
Cave (environment) Abiotic factors Biotic factors Cave beetle (organism) Morphological adaptations Physiological adaptations Behavioural adaptations clawed feet reduced eyes tricho- bothria elongated antennae elongated legs CO 2 tolerance slow, methodical movement  reduced pigment reduced wings steno- hygrobia  chemo- reception tactile sense prey predators enclosed space saturated atmosphere high CO 2 uneven surfaces permanent darkness pools and drips vibration detection Cave beetle (visitor) Cave (exhibit) Abiotic factors darkness enclosed space uneven surfaces Biotic factors predators transient sightless- ness Behavioural adaptations slow methodical movement recruit tactile sense
Exhibition milieu Cave (environment) Abiotic factors Biotic factors Cave beetle (organism) Behavioural adaptations slow, methodical movement  tactile sense predators enclosed space uneven surfaces permanent darkness Cave beetle (visitor) Cave (exhibit) Abiotic factors darkness enclosed space uneven surfaces Biotic factors predators Behavioural adaptations slow methodical movement recruit tactile sense transient sightless- ness
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Design Exhibition engineering
Enactment The visitor and the exhibit ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What is it supposed to be, the exhibit you just visited? What makes it a cave, in your opinion? How did you find your way, inside? Exhibition milieu Cave (exhibit) Abiotic factors Biotic factors Cave beetle (visitor) Behavioural adaptations slow, methodical movement  tactile sense predators enclosed space uneven surfaces permanent darkness Cave (exhibit) transient sightless- ness Abiotic factors darkness enclosed space uneven surfaces recruit tactile sense Behavioural adaptations slow methodical movement transient sightless- ness
Analysis Synthesis of model ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Summary ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Taalmonument information booklet 2016
Taalmonument information booklet 2016Taalmonument information booklet 2016
Taalmonument information booklet 2016Isabeau Botha
 
Lost Childhoods C3 Meeting #2
Lost Childhoods C3 Meeting #2Lost Childhoods C3 Meeting #2
Lost Childhoods C3 Meeting #2Nina Simon
 
Museum of impact powerpoint pdf
Museum of impact powerpoint pdfMuseum of impact powerpoint pdf
Museum of impact powerpoint pdfurbanmomentum
 
Participatory Design Workshop for Museums
Participatory Design Workshop for MuseumsParticipatory Design Workshop for Museums
Participatory Design Workshop for MuseumsNina Simon
 
The Art of Relevance
The Art of RelevanceThe Art of Relevance
The Art of RelevanceNina Simon
 
Universal design for museum programs (GBMER workshop)
Universal design for museum programs (GBMER workshop)Universal design for museum programs (GBMER workshop)
Universal design for museum programs (GBMER workshop)astreichs
 
Writing Effective Interpretive Labels for Art Exhibitions: A Nuts and Bolts P...
Writing Effective Interpretive Labels for Art Exhibitions: A Nuts and Bolts P...Writing Effective Interpretive Labels for Art Exhibitions: A Nuts and Bolts P...
Writing Effective Interpretive Labels for Art Exhibitions: A Nuts and Bolts P...Stephanie Pau
 
Writing effective museum text
Writing effective museum textWriting effective museum text
Writing effective museum textHelen Adams
 
How To Use Open Content In An Interactive Museum Exhibit
How To Use Open Content  In An Interactive Museum ExhibitHow To Use Open Content  In An Interactive Museum Exhibit
How To Use Open Content In An Interactive Museum ExhibitKaren Drost
 
Museum Exhibit Development
Museum Exhibit DevelopmentMuseum Exhibit Development
Museum Exhibit DevelopmentTerry Gaouette
 

Viewers also liked (10)

Taalmonument information booklet 2016
Taalmonument information booklet 2016Taalmonument information booklet 2016
Taalmonument information booklet 2016
 
Lost Childhoods C3 Meeting #2
Lost Childhoods C3 Meeting #2Lost Childhoods C3 Meeting #2
Lost Childhoods C3 Meeting #2
 
Museum of impact powerpoint pdf
Museum of impact powerpoint pdfMuseum of impact powerpoint pdf
Museum of impact powerpoint pdf
 
Participatory Design Workshop for Museums
Participatory Design Workshop for MuseumsParticipatory Design Workshop for Museums
Participatory Design Workshop for Museums
 
The Art of Relevance
The Art of RelevanceThe Art of Relevance
The Art of Relevance
 
Universal design for museum programs (GBMER workshop)
Universal design for museum programs (GBMER workshop)Universal design for museum programs (GBMER workshop)
Universal design for museum programs (GBMER workshop)
 
Writing Effective Interpretive Labels for Art Exhibitions: A Nuts and Bolts P...
Writing Effective Interpretive Labels for Art Exhibitions: A Nuts and Bolts P...Writing Effective Interpretive Labels for Art Exhibitions: A Nuts and Bolts P...
Writing Effective Interpretive Labels for Art Exhibitions: A Nuts and Bolts P...
 
Writing effective museum text
Writing effective museum textWriting effective museum text
Writing effective museum text
 
How To Use Open Content In An Interactive Museum Exhibit
How To Use Open Content  In An Interactive Museum ExhibitHow To Use Open Content  In An Interactive Museum Exhibit
How To Use Open Content In An Interactive Museum Exhibit
 
Museum Exhibit Development
Museum Exhibit DevelopmentMuseum Exhibit Development
Museum Exhibit Development
 

Similar to A design-based research approach to museum exhibit engineering

Introducing the Museum
Introducing the MuseumIntroducing the Museum
Introducing the MuseumClive McGoun
 
MW2010: Matthias Krauss and Manfred Bogen, Conveying Culture Heritage and Leg...
MW2010: Matthias Krauss and Manfred Bogen, Conveying Culture Heritage and Leg...MW2010: Matthias Krauss and Manfred Bogen, Conveying Culture Heritage and Leg...
MW2010: Matthias Krauss and Manfred Bogen, Conveying Culture Heritage and Leg...museums and the web
 
Pedagogically Relevant Concepts in the Design of Hands-on Interactive Science...
Pedagogically Relevant Concepts in the Design of Hands-on Interactive Science...Pedagogically Relevant Concepts in the Design of Hands-on Interactive Science...
Pedagogically Relevant Concepts in the Design of Hands-on Interactive Science...Thomas Hillman
 
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdf
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdfApresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdf
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdfEdimarOliveiradaSilv1
 
Museum Making British University 2008
Museum Making British University 2008Museum Making British University 2008
Museum Making British University 2008Jean-Gabriel Leturcq
 
Museum-Making: Behind and Beyond Architecture
Museum-Making: Behind and Beyond ArchitectureMuseum-Making: Behind and Beyond Architecture
Museum-Making: Behind and Beyond ArchitectureJean-Gabriel Leturcq
 
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdf
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdfApresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdf
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdfEdimarOliveiradaSilv1
 
The Recurated Museum: III. Digital Collections, Exhibits, & Education
The Recurated Museum: III. Digital Collections, Exhibits, & EducationThe Recurated Museum: III. Digital Collections, Exhibits, & Education
The Recurated Museum: III. Digital Collections, Exhibits, & EducationChristopher Morse
 
Ecoacoustic Challenges: UKAN Soundscapes Workshop
Ecoacoustic Challenges: UKAN Soundscapes WorkshopEcoacoustic Challenges: UKAN Soundscapes Workshop
Ecoacoustic Challenges: UKAN Soundscapes WorkshopEdward Baker
 
TeZ - SPECTRAL SENSORIUM - ART/SCIENCE RESEARCH 2010-2015
TeZ - SPECTRAL SENSORIUM - ART/SCIENCE RESEARCH 2010-2015TeZ - SPECTRAL SENSORIUM - ART/SCIENCE RESEARCH 2010-2015
TeZ - SPECTRAL SENSORIUM - ART/SCIENCE RESEARCH 2010-2015TeZ Martinucci
 
Trading Zones And Disunity
Trading Zones And DisunityTrading Zones And Disunity
Trading Zones And Disunitylaughingbandit
 
The Value and Scale of the Experimental Archaeology Approach - The dialogue w...
The Value and Scale of the Experimental Archaeology Approach - The dialogue w...The Value and Scale of the Experimental Archaeology Approach - The dialogue w...
The Value and Scale of the Experimental Archaeology Approach - The dialogue w...EXARC
 
Standards, prototypes, and pilot projects - technology and flexibility in des...
Standards, prototypes, and pilot projects - technology and flexibility in des...Standards, prototypes, and pilot projects - technology and flexibility in des...
Standards, prototypes, and pilot projects - technology and flexibility in des...Alessandro Califano, PhD
 
Online assignment
Online assignment Online assignment
Online assignment 7736372218
 
Terre Haute Children's Museum Building & Exhibits
Terre Haute Children's Museum Building & ExhibitsTerre Haute Children's Museum Building & Exhibits
Terre Haute Children's Museum Building & ExhibitsLynn Hughes
 
Thcm Building&Exhibits
Thcm Building&ExhibitsThcm Building&Exhibits
Thcm Building&ExhibitsLynn Hughes
 
Annotating Archaeological Texts An Example Of Domain-Specific Annotation In ...
Annotating Archaeological Texts  An Example Of Domain-Specific Annotation In ...Annotating Archaeological Texts  An Example Of Domain-Specific Annotation In ...
Annotating Archaeological Texts An Example Of Domain-Specific Annotation In ...Yasmine Anino
 

Similar to A design-based research approach to museum exhibit engineering (20)

Introducing the Museum
Introducing the MuseumIntroducing the Museum
Introducing the Museum
 
MW2010: Matthias Krauss and Manfred Bogen, Conveying Culture Heritage and Leg...
MW2010: Matthias Krauss and Manfred Bogen, Conveying Culture Heritage and Leg...MW2010: Matthias Krauss and Manfred Bogen, Conveying Culture Heritage and Leg...
MW2010: Matthias Krauss and Manfred Bogen, Conveying Culture Heritage and Leg...
 
Pedagogically Relevant Concepts in the Design of Hands-on Interactive Science...
Pedagogically Relevant Concepts in the Design of Hands-on Interactive Science...Pedagogically Relevant Concepts in the Design of Hands-on Interactive Science...
Pedagogically Relevant Concepts in the Design of Hands-on Interactive Science...
 
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdf
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdfApresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdf
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdf
 
Museum Making British University 2008
Museum Making British University 2008Museum Making British University 2008
Museum Making British University 2008
 
Museum-Making: Behind and Beyond Architecture
Museum-Making: Behind and Beyond ArchitectureMuseum-Making: Behind and Beyond Architecture
Museum-Making: Behind and Beyond Architecture
 
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdf
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdfApresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdf
Apresentações em inglês (sem tradução).pdf
 
The Recurated Museum: III. Digital Collections, Exhibits, & Education
The Recurated Museum: III. Digital Collections, Exhibits, & EducationThe Recurated Museum: III. Digital Collections, Exhibits, & Education
The Recurated Museum: III. Digital Collections, Exhibits, & Education
 
Update on Nature on Screen work Sept 2011
Update on Nature on Screen work Sept 2011Update on Nature on Screen work Sept 2011
Update on Nature on Screen work Sept 2011
 
Ecoacoustic Challenges: UKAN Soundscapes Workshop
Ecoacoustic Challenges: UKAN Soundscapes WorkshopEcoacoustic Challenges: UKAN Soundscapes Workshop
Ecoacoustic Challenges: UKAN Soundscapes Workshop
 
TeZ - SPECTRAL SENSORIUM - ART/SCIENCE RESEARCH 2010-2015
TeZ - SPECTRAL SENSORIUM - ART/SCIENCE RESEARCH 2010-2015TeZ - SPECTRAL SENSORIUM - ART/SCIENCE RESEARCH 2010-2015
TeZ - SPECTRAL SENSORIUM - ART/SCIENCE RESEARCH 2010-2015
 
Trading Zones And Disunity
Trading Zones And DisunityTrading Zones And Disunity
Trading Zones And Disunity
 
The Value and Scale of the Experimental Archaeology Approach - The dialogue w...
The Value and Scale of the Experimental Archaeology Approach - The dialogue w...The Value and Scale of the Experimental Archaeology Approach - The dialogue w...
The Value and Scale of the Experimental Archaeology Approach - The dialogue w...
 
Experience planet earth
Experience planet earthExperience planet earth
Experience planet earth
 
Standards, prototypes, and pilot projects - technology and flexibility in des...
Standards, prototypes, and pilot projects - technology and flexibility in des...Standards, prototypes, and pilot projects - technology and flexibility in des...
Standards, prototypes, and pilot projects - technology and flexibility in des...
 
Tracing Ethnography
Tracing EthnographyTracing Ethnography
Tracing Ethnography
 
Online assignment
Online assignment Online assignment
Online assignment
 
Terre Haute Children's Museum Building & Exhibits
Terre Haute Children's Museum Building & ExhibitsTerre Haute Children's Museum Building & Exhibits
Terre Haute Children's Museum Building & Exhibits
 
Thcm Building&Exhibits
Thcm Building&ExhibitsThcm Building&Exhibits
Thcm Building&Exhibits
 
Annotating Archaeological Texts An Example Of Domain-Specific Annotation In ...
Annotating Archaeological Texts  An Example Of Domain-Specific Annotation In ...Annotating Archaeological Texts  An Example Of Domain-Specific Annotation In ...
Annotating Archaeological Texts An Example Of Domain-Specific Annotation In ...
 

A design-based research approach to museum exhibit engineering

  • 1. Didactical engineering of museum exhibitions The case of a museum exhibit on animal adaptations to darkness
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4. Case Cave Expedition (Experimentarium, Copenhagen)
  • 5. Content Cave Expedition (Experimentarium, Copenhagen) Adaptations of the blind cave beetle to its environment of permanently dark caves
  • 6. Project overview Design (exhibit engineering) Enactment (visitors - exhibit) Analysis (synthesis of model) RQ: Which factors, related to the scientific content or the exhibit objectives, affect the engineering of an exhibit? RQ: Which relationships exist between the characteristics of exhibit engineering and those of visitors’ experiences? RQ: Can re-engineering of an exhibit, based on empirical findings synthesised with education theory, engender visitor experiences that better reflect the stated objectives? (Design-based research collective, 2003)
  • 7.
  • 8. Source knowledge context Muscle cell Red blood cell Nerve cell Transposition Teaching context Prototypical animal cell (c.f. Clément, 2007)
  • 9. Museographic transposition ( adapted from Simonneaux & Jacobi, 1997 )
  • 10. Content Adaptations of the blind cave beetle to its environment of permanently dark caves
  • 11.  
  • 12. Cave ( environment ) Abiotic factors Biotic factors Cave beetle (organism) Morphological adaptations Physiological adaptations Behavioural adaptations clawed feet reduced eyes tricho- bothria elongated antennae elongated legs CO 2 tolerance slow, methodical movement reduced pigment reduced wings steno- hygrobia chemo- reception tactile sense prey predators enclosed space saturated atmosphere high CO 2 uneven surfaces permanent darkness pools and drips vibration detection Scientific knowledge
  • 13.  
  • 14. Knowledge ecology of the Cave Expedition exhibit
  • 15.
  • 16. Cave (environment) Abiotic factors Biotic factors Cave beetle (organism) Morphological adaptations Physiological adaptations Behavioural adaptations clawed feet reduced eyes tricho- bothria elongated antennae elongated legs CO 2 tolerance slow, methodical movement reduced pigment reduced wings steno- hygrobia chemo- reception tactile sense prey predators enclosed space saturated atmosphere high CO 2 uneven surfaces permanent darkness pools and drips vibration detection Cave beetle (visitor) Cave (exhibit) Abiotic factors darkness enclosed space uneven surfaces Biotic factors
  • 17. “ These are the types of animals you’d find in caves. These are the animals that would prey on the beetles [in the wild]” (Exhibition engineer I, 2007)
  • 18. Cave (environment) Abiotic factors Biotic factors Cave beetle (organism) Morphological adaptations Physiological adaptations Behavioural adaptations clawed feet reduced eyes tricho- bothria elongated antennae elongated legs CO 2 tolerance slow, methodical movement reduced pigment reduced wings steno- hygrobia chemo- reception tactile sense prey predators enclosed space saturated atmosphere high CO 2 uneven surfaces permanent darkness pools and drips vibration detection Cave beetle (visitor) Cave (exhibit) Abiotic factors darkness enclosed space uneven surfaces Biotic factors predators transient sightless- ness Behavioural adaptations slow methodical movement recruit tactile sense
  • 19. Exhibition milieu Cave (environment) Abiotic factors Biotic factors Cave beetle (organism) Behavioural adaptations slow, methodical movement tactile sense predators enclosed space uneven surfaces permanent darkness Cave beetle (visitor) Cave (exhibit) Abiotic factors darkness enclosed space uneven surfaces Biotic factors predators Behavioural adaptations slow methodical movement recruit tactile sense transient sightless- ness
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22. What is it supposed to be, the exhibit you just visited? What makes it a cave, in your opinion? How did you find your way, inside? Exhibition milieu Cave (exhibit) Abiotic factors Biotic factors Cave beetle (visitor) Behavioural adaptations slow, methodical movement tactile sense predators enclosed space uneven surfaces permanent darkness Cave (exhibit) transient sightless- ness Abiotic factors darkness enclosed space uneven surfaces recruit tactile sense Behavioural adaptations slow methodical movement transient sightless- ness
  • 23.
  • 24.