Kevin Carter
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has announced its intent to adopt numeric nutrient criteria for Florida’s water bodies (lakes, streams, canals and estuaries). The criterion is
unprecedented in the nation and has drawn national attention to Florida’s water quality programs. The panel will discuss the
legal genesis of this proposed rule, including the most up to date developments in the state legislature and Congress; its technical
aspects, including the scientific basis for the rule; implementation and relief mechanisms; and the criteria’s impact on Florida’s current permitting programs, as well as its impact on a wide variety of stakeholders in Florida.
14. EPA Final Lakes Criteria November 2010 A B C D E F Long Term Average Lake Chlorophyll a f (μg/L) a Baseline Criteria b Modified Criteria (within these bounds) c Color and Alkalinity TP (mg/L) a TN (mg/L) a TP (mg/L) a TN (mg/L) a Colored Lakes > 40 PCU 20 0.050 1.27 0.050-0.16 1.27-2.23 Clear Lakes, Alkaline ≤ 40 PCU d and > 50 mg/L CaCO3 e 20 0.030 1.05 0.030-0.090 1.05-1.91 Clear Lakes, Acidic ≤ 40 PCU d and ≤ 50 mg/L CaCO3 e 6 0.010 0.51 0.010- 0.030 0.51-0.93
15. EPA Rivers and Streams Proposed and Final Criteria Rule has equations in place for downstream protection values for Lakes could potentially lower these criteria Nutrient Watershed Region EPA's Proposed and Final Instream Protection Value Criteria for Rivers and Streams TN (mg/L) Proposed TN (mg/L) FINAL TP (mg/L) Proposed TP (mg/L) FINAL Panhandle 0.824 N/A 0.043 N/A Panhandle West N/A 0.67 N/A 0.06 Panhandle East N/A 1.03 N/A 0.18 North Central 1.479 1.87 0.359 0.3 Bone Valley (now called West Central) 1.798 1.65 0.739 0.49 Peninsula (District waters) 1.205 1.54 0.107 0.12
16. From Presentation by Dr. Dana Thomas USEPA (February 15, 2011) http://www.tetratech-ffx.com/NOLAnutrient_workshop/presentations.htm
Editor's Notes
01/09/2011 K.Carter, SFWMD, Numeric Nutrient Criteria in Florida
The national nutrient strategy describes the approach we will follow in developing nutrient information and working with states and tribes to adopt nutrient criteria as part of their water quality standards. The strategy presents overenrichment assessment tools and recognizes current capabilities for conducting these assessments at the regional watershed and waterbody levels. The major focus of this strategy is the development of waterbody-type technical guidance and region-specific nutrient criteria . Once waterbody-type guidance and nutrient criteria are established, we will assist states and tribes in adopting numerical nutrient criteria into water quality standards 01/09/2011 K.Carter, SFWMD, Numeric Nutrient Criteria in Florida
Variability in the type, amount, and quality of data used for the rulemaking can be challenging 01/09/2011 K.Carter, SFWMD, Numeric Nutrient Criteria in Florida
Kevin Carter, SFWMD, presentation to BBRRCT
Kevin Carter, SFWMD, presentation to BBRRCT
, final May 2011? 01/09/2011 K.Carter, SFWMD, ABCs of Nutrient Regulation
01/09/2011 K.Carter, SFWMD, Numeric Nutrient Criteria in Florida
Mention Charlotte Harbor in Bone valley Workshop Agenda Item Number 9 2/24/2010