We serve on FDI advisory, cross-border accounting, International tax planning, and Management consulting needs of our overseas clients all over the world.
3. Brief Facts of the Case
1.M/s G. K. Trading Company (“The Petitioner”) is
registered under U.P. GST Act 2017 w.e.f. 01
November 2017 for trade in Iron Bars and Rods and
Non-Alloy steel etc.
2.Respondent No. 5-Assistant Commissioner (S.I.B.),
UP, issued a summon to the petitioner under
Section 70 of UP GST Act requiring him to submit
details of purchases and sales, list of buyers and
sellers and certain other documents.
3.Later on, the Directorate General of Goods and
Services Tax Intelligence issued a summon to the
petitioner under section 70 and 174 of the CGST
Act, 2017 requiring the petitioner to appear in
4. Contention of Respondent
• The respondent contended that:
1.Section 6(2)(b) of U.P. GST Act, 2017 prohibits initiation
of a proceeding on the same set of facts. It does not
prohibit inquiry by the authorities under U.P. Act or under
Central Act.
2.Further, under Section 70 of CGST Act, the word “Inquiry”
has been used. Whereas, Section 6(2)(b) of UP GST Act
prohibits “Proceeding” and not “Inquiry”. In other words
“Inquiry” has not been prohibited under Section 6(2)(b) of
the U.P. GST. Act, 2017.
3.Jurisdiction of state authorities is limited to UP only.
Whereas, jurisdiction of centre authorities is expanded to
the whole India.
4.Further, state authorities have issued the notice on the
basis of facts that the Input Tax Credit has been illegally
taken by the petitioner on the basis of invoices of two
alleged dealers. However, no such fact is mentioned in the
summons issued by centre authorities. Therefore inquiry has
not been initiated on the same set of facts
5. Legal Extracts
• Provisions of UP GST and CGST is almost pari materia.
Relevant extract of UPGST Act and CGST Act is given below:
1.Section 6(2) of UP GST Act::
• Section 6 (2) Subject to the conditions specified in the
notification issued under sub-section (1),-
• ..
• (b) where a proper officer under the Central Goods and
Services Tax Act,2017 has initiated any proceedings on a
subject-matter, no proceedings shall be initiated by the
proper officer under this Act on the same subject- matter.
Chapter XIV (Inspection, Search, Seizure and arrest) Section
67. Power of inspection, search and seizure- (1) Where the
proper officer, not below the rank of Joint Commissioner,
has reasons to believe that––
• ,,,,:
